You are on page 1of 76

Leon National High School

SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL


F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

PRODUCTION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF HYBRID BRIQUETTES

FROM WASTE PAPER AND BANANA PEELS UNDER A LOW-PRESSURE

DENSIFICATION TECHNIQUE

A Senior High School Research


Presented to the Faculty of
Leon National High School – Senior High School
F. Cabarles, St., Leon, Iloilo

In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Subject
Research Capstone
Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics Strand

by
Cabaluna, Lincoln Rhyme Capatayan

Cabarles, Roj Christian Hada

Cajayon, Joshua Osano

Capayan, Quinjie Benedict Espinosa

Morales, Riona Lee Cabaluna

July 2023
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Approval Sheet

In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Subject
Research Capstone
Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics Strand

by
Cabaluna, Lincoln Rhyme Capatayan

Cabarles, Roj Christian Hada

Cajayon, Joshua Osano

Capayan, Quinjie Benedict Espinosa

Morales, Riona Lee Cabaluna

Approved:

JOSHUA MONTEFRIO, Adviser

PAUL ANBEN CAELIAN, Subject Group Head (STEM)

JOSE ROLANDO RAFAEL C. CABANIG, Ph.D.

School Principal II
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Acknowledgement

The researchers would like to extent their profound and genuine gratitude
to the following persons who have shared their knowledge, assistance, time, and
resources for the completion of the study:

The researcher's parents, Mr. and Mrs. Conrado C. Cabaluna Jr., Mr. and
Mrs. Romeo C. Cabarles, Mr. and Mrs. Adolfo Cajayon, Mr. and Mrs. Quirico
Capayan Jr., and Mrs. Rosalie Morales;

Mr. Joshua C. Montefrio, for acting as our adviser and sharing his time,
intelligent advises, suggestions, recommendations, and keeping us on the right
track until the study is completed;

To our classmates, for acting as our defense panels and for sharing their
time to edit our study;

Faculty of Leon National High School, Leon Public Market Vendors, and
the Department of Agriculture, for providing the necessary materials and
equipment for the study;

And above all, to the all-powerful God almighty, who gave us wisdom,
strength and perseverance to complete the study.

The Researchers
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Cabaluna, Lincoln Rhyme C., Cabarles, Roj Christian H., Cajayon, Joshua O.,
Capayan, Quinjie Benedict E., Morales, Riona Lee C. “Production and
Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes from Waste Paper and Banana Peels
under a Low-pressure Densification Technique”. An unpublished Grade 12
Capstone Research, Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics
Strand, Leon National High School, Leon, Iloilo. July 2023.

Abstract
This study was undertaken to investigate the physical, mechanical and thermal

properties of hybrid briquettes produced from Waste Paper(WP) and Banana

Peels(BP) under a low-pressure densification technique. The materials were

combined into varying ratios of WP to BP (75:25, 50:50, 25:75). The mixtures

were compressed using an improvised compressor machine, utilizing a car jack

built into a wooden frame and PVC tube pipes as a cylindrical molder. The

physical property was determined in terms of its moisture content, density and

water resistance, mechanical property was determined using the drop test

method, while the thermal property was obtained by its burning efficiency.

Results showed that for physical properties, there was no significant difference

between treatment in terms of moisture content and water resistance since p-

value=0.066>α=0.05. Meanwhile, results showed a significant difference

between treatments in terms of the density since p-value=0.035<α=0.05 with

treatment having the highest density (4.9). For mechanical property, the results
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

showed no significant difference between treatments in terms of the shatter

index since p-value=0.211>α=0.05. For thermal property, there was a significant

difference between treatments in terms of its burning efficiency since p-

value=0.018<α=0.05 with treatment 25BP:75WP having the shortest time it took

to combust and the longest time it lasted.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Table of Contents

Chapter Page

1 INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY

Background of the Study and Conceptual Framework 1

Statement of the Problem 8

Hypothesis 9

Significance of the Study 10

Definition of Terms 11

Scope and Limitation 13

2 REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

Briquettes 15

Combustion Characteristics of Briquettes 17

Hybrid Briquettes 18

Banana Waste Briquettes 20

Charcoal Briquettes 21

Waste Paper 22

Banana Peels 23

Sawdust 25

3 METHODOLOGY

Research Design 35
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Materials and Equipments 35

Procedures 38

Treatments 39

Data Collection 40

Data Analysis 43

4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Descriptive Data Analysis 44

Inferential Data Analysis 53

5 SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Summary 54

Conclusions 54

Recommendations 55

References 57

Appendices
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

List of Tables

Tables Page

1 Materials and Equipment 35

2 Material Composition of Banana Peels and Waste Paper 39

3 Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes in its Physical Properties 44

4 Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes in its Mechanical Properties 45

5 Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes in its Thermal Property 46

6 Physical Properties of Hybrid Briquettes based on different 47

mixture of Waste Paper and Banana Peel ratio

7 Mechanical Properties of Hybrid Briquettes based on different 49

mixture of Waste Paper and Banana Peel ratio

8 Thermal Property of Hybrid Briquettes based on different 50

mixture of Waste Paper and Banana Peel ratio

9 Significant Difference in the Physical, Mechanical, and 51

Thermal Properties of Hybrid Briquettes


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

List of Appendices

Appendix

A Letter to the Facilitator of LGU Department of Health-Leon

B Letter to the Statistician

C Pictures taken during the conduction of the study


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Production and Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes from Waste Paper and

Banana Peels under a Low-Pressure Densification Technique

Chapter 1

Introduction to the Study

Chapter One is divided into six parts: Background of the Study and

Conceptual Framework, Statement of the Problem, Hypothesis/es, Significance of

the Study, Definition of Terms, Scope and Limitation of the Study.

Part One, Background of the Study and Conceptual Framework of

the study, presents the prologue of the study and provides an overview and the

need of the tests and experiments. It also explains the key concepts and the

variables included in the study.

Part Two, Statement of the problem, describes the purpose for

conducting the study and its specific objectives.

Part Three, Hypothesis/es, presents the specific questions, which

the study sought to answer and the hypothesis advanced.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

1
Part Four, Significance of the Study, discusses the benefits that

might be derived from the results and who will profit from them.

Part Five, Definition of Terms, gives both the actual meaning and

operational definition with some terms used in the study.

Part Six, Scope and Limitation of the Study, specifies the bounds

and limitations of the study.

Background of the Study

The potential of biomass energy, in particular wood fuels, as an

alternative for energy sources based on fossil fuels is currently attracting

attention on a global scale. Wood fuels, according to the Food and Agriculture

Organization (2004), are "any type of biofuel derived directly or indirectly from

trees and shrubs grown on forest and non-forest land." Charcoal and fuelwood

from trees serve as more than just 14% of the total primary energy used

worldwide (FAO 1996). The Department of Energy (DOE) emphasized that the

country's energy mix was and would remain dependent on indigenous energy,

especially wood fuels. In its 2005 Update of the Philippine Energy Plan, according

to the Household Energy Consumption Survey (HCES) conducted in the


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

2
Philippines in 1989, 1995, and 2004, an average of 35% of all households

utilized charcoal. Charcoal contributes only 2.2% or roughly 5.5 Million Barrels of

Fuel Oil Equivalent (MMBFOE) of the Philippine energy demand on a national

scale which translates to more than a billion kilograms of charcoal consumed

every year (DOE 2004).

In one of the towns in the city of Iloilo, many domestic sectors mainly

use lump charcoals as a primary fuel source. For instance, a famous eatery in the

municipality of Leon, Iloilo, Lola Ritas’, uses charcoal to cook most of their dishes

as it is faster. Hardwood lump charcoal is produced by cooking natural

hardwood, tree branches, and twigs in a low oxygen environment. Because the

hardwood retains its inherent structure and properties of a tree after being

burned and transformed, it is also referred to as lump charcoal. Due to the

region’s abundant nature, charcoal production has become common to the

natives. They cut down trees to produce charcoals and use them mainly for

cooking, resulting in various environmental issues such as soil erosion, flooding,

and air pollution.

These environmental issues led to the characterization of alternative fuel

sources like briquettes. Biomass briquettes are typically made of green waste

and other organic materials. They are frequently used as a fuel for electricity

generation, heating, and cooking. Briquettes have a low sulfur content, good
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

3
boiler efficiency, and practical thermal value, in addition to having a higher bulky

and specific density. Various organic components, such as rice husk, bagasse,

pulverized nut shells, municipal solid waste, and agricultural waste, are present

in these compressed compounds. Briquettes’ composition varies on the

availability of raw materials in each region. In order to make the raw materials

burn longer and facilitate transportation, they are gathered and crushed into

briquettes. It is also inexpensive, biodegradable, and environmentally beneficial.

The product is used in a variety of industries, including the chemical industry,

food industry, pharmaceutical business, etc. The demand for briquettes may rise

as a result of the growing need for resources to produce power while reducing

environmental pollution. Additionally, it offers an eco-friendly option and is cost-

effective. When compared to commercial fuel sources like coal, firewood, and

charcoal, these advantages also make it a preferable option (Fortune Business

Insights, 2022). However, due to various variables including high moisture

content, inconsistent shapes and sizes, and low bulk density, biomass is

particularly challenging to handle, transport, store, and use in its natural form

(Karunanithy et al., 2012). Which is why many researchers continued to find

ways on how to make briquettes more efficient for use and transport. Hybridized

briquettes which are a mix of different variables that according to some studies,
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

4
are more efficient. These hybrid briquettes are made of different organic biomass

and wastes which are abundant in several countries.

Many developing nations produce large amounts of wastes which they

utilize inefficiently, severely polluting the environment. Paper is one of the

examples. Waste Paper contributes to 19% of the total municipal solid waste in

the Philippines (Environmental Studies Institute, 2013). Recycling paper is

viewed as advantageous from an economic and waste management perspective.

Papers converted to pulp is a good substitute of starch as binders. Because of

the proteinaceous components they contain, papers are cellulosic in nature and

have strong adhesive properties making it a good binding material for briquettes.

Another waste produced in the locality are banana peels. Large amounts

of wastes are produced during the banana cultivation process. The most

important wastes are the leaves, stalks, and pseudostems because they are

produced in higher quantities and take up more space. The number of waste

leaves represents almost 100,000 tons of unrecovered garbage in Western

Visayas, where annual banana production is considerable (Nathoa et al., 2014).

Only a tiny percentage of banana peels are reutilized as a biomass material,

while the remainder becomes rotten trash. As a consequence, farmers and

vendors often face several challenges in disposing of the waste. Banana peel has

a high carbohydrate content, which makes it suitable as a source of bioenergy


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

5
(Nathoa et al., 2014). This quality signifies its potential use for domestic and

industrial heating applications as a fuel source.

The qualities found in banana peels and waste paper show that they are

compatible with the quality attributes of densified products, which improved

when various biomass ingredients were combined, according to earlier studies.

This study assumes that mixing waste paper and banana peels will

produce high-quality hybrid briquettes that will both increase sustainability and

make waste management more efficient. As a result, banana peel will be used to

make hybrid briquettes utilizing a low-pressure method and wastepaper pulp as

a binder. The purpose of the study is to evaluate the briquettes' suitability as a

potential alternative energy source for domestic cooking applications in terms of

their physical, mechanical, and thermal qualities.

Conceptual Framework

In this study, the researchers attempted to produce and characterize

hybrid briquettes as an alternative fuel source to mitigate charcoal usage which

causes several environmental issues like soil erosion, air pollution, deforestation,
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

6
and etc. Hence, the researchers thought of finding organic wastes that can be a

good variable for hybrid briquettes.

As biomass briquettes are more ecofriendly, they are also more

sustainable and cost-effective when compared to lump charcoals. However, as

time passes, more and more research are being done to continuously enhance

biomass briquettes, which are now combined with various materials like wastes

and organic mases, also known as hybrid briquettes. They are found to be more

sustainable and effective compared to biomass briquettes, according to recent

studies. Materials like waste paper, banana peels, and coconut husks are found

to be good constituents of hybrid briquettes. Papers converted to pulp is a good

substitute of starch as binders. Papers are cellulosic by nature and have high

adhesive qualities due to the proteinaceous components they contain, making

them an excellent binding medium for briquettes. Also, the process of growing

bananas results in significant waste production. As a consequence, farmers and

vendors often face several challenges in disposing of the waste. Banana peel has

a high carbohydrate content, which makes it suitable as a source of bioenergy

(Nathoa et al., 2014).

This study produced hybrid briquettes from waste paper and banana peels

using low pressure densification technique. Low density biomass leftovers

present management, storage, transportation, and combustion process


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

7
problems. The technology of densification and briquetting is crucial in reducing

the issue of large storage capacity and simple transportation. The best method

for using agricultural waste as a solid biomass fuel is to make briquettes.

Densification Briquette technology is the term used to describe the compaction of

biomass. It is also known as the process of compacting particles (biomass

residues) with the aid of varying pressure levels to create solid biomass fuel.

these variables each have the quality to produce a more solid, more efficient,

and more sustainable hybrid briquettes.

The research framework showed how the mixture of briquette will directly

affect the production and characterization of hybrid briquette made from banana

peels and waste paper in terms of its physical, mechanical, and thermal

properties.
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

8
Research Paradigm

Independent Dependent
Vriab;es Vria

Briquette Mixtures Briquette Properties

 25:75 ● Physical
 50:50 Moisture Content
 75:25
Density
Water Resistance
● Mechanical
Shatter Index
● Thermal
Burning Efficiency

Statement of the Problem

Generally, this study aimed to produce and characterize hybrid briquettes

made from waste paper and banana peels under low pressure densification

technique.

Specifically, this study sought answers to the following questions:

1. What are the properties of hybrid briquettes in terms of the following:

a.) Physical

b.) Mechanical
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

9
c.) Thermal

2. What are the properties of hybrid briquettes based on different mixtures

of waste paper and banana peel ratio: 25:75, 50:50, 75:25?

3. Is there a significant difference in the physical properties of hybrid

briquettes with different banana peel to waste paper ratio?

4. Is there a significant difference in the mechanical properties of hybrid

briquettes with different banana peel to waste paper ratio?

5. Is there a significant difference in the thermal properties of hybrid

briquettes with different banana peel to waste paper ratio?

Hypothesis

There was no significant difference in the production and characterization

of hybrid briquettes from waste paper and banana peels in terms of its physical,

mechanical, and thermal properties with different mixtures of banana peel to

waste paper ratio.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

10
Significance of the Study

The significance of this study is in the creation of briquettes with

equitable physical, mechanical, and thermal properties using previously unutilized

banana peels combined with paper. Rural areas in underdeveloped nations like

the Philippines may gain significantly from this in terms of the environment and

socioeconomic development.

The sole purpose of this study is to produce and characterize hybrid

briquettes as an alternative fuel source. This research may offer empirical

significance to the different sectors namely;

Municipal Environment and Natural Resources Office. This can help to

inform and give them ideas about alternative fuel sources that can support to the

implementation of new laws and policies that can help mitigate environmental

issues like illegal logging and deforestation.

Schools and teachers. This can help them to educate their students about

alternative fuel sources and inform them that papers in schools can be used to

make alternative fuel sources like briquettes.

Banana cue vendors. This can help in the disposal of banana peels and

give them knowledge about the other uses of banana peels.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

11
Society, this will help them have a more sustainable and cost-effective

alternative fuel source.

Future researchers. This may serve as a reference to gain more

information about hybrid briquettes.

Definition of Terms

For purposes of clarity and precision, important terms in this study were

given conceptual and operational definitions.

Banana Peel—the skin of a banana (especially when it is stripped off or

discarded), (Vocabulary, 2022).

In this study, it is an ingredient used in making a briquette, as an

alternative for fuels.

Briquette--a block of compressed coal dust, charcoal, or sawdust and

woodchips, used for fueling and kindling (Free Dictionary, 2022).

In this study, it refers to a small compressed charcoal-like mainly

composed of banana peels and used papers using low pressure densification

technique.
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

12
Densification--an increase in the density of something (Vocabulary, 2022).

In this study, it refers to the technique used in making the briquette

wherein low-pressure densification is used.

Low Pressure—physical pressure that is lower than a standard or average

pressure (Oxford, 2022).

In this study, it refers to the pressure applied to the briquette.

Waste Paper—paper discarded as used, superfluous, or not fit for use

(Merriam-Webster, 2022).

In this study, it refers to the used papers that are meant to be disposed,

recycled and used as one of the main ingredients in making a hybrid briquette.

Moisture Content—is simply how much water is in a product (IFT,2009).

In this study, it refers to the parameter for evaluating changes that may

occur in the physical conditions of briquettes during storage and transport.

Density—the degree of compactness of a substance (Oxford,2023).

In this study, it refers to parameter for the briquetting process.

Water Resistance—does not allow water to pass through easily, or is not

easily damaged by water (Collins,2023).


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

13
In this study, it refers to the rate at which briquettes can withstand

degeneration in high humidity or water exposure.

Shatter Index—is the degree of shatter of a standard sand specimen at

dropping from a certain height (Nakayama,2007).

In this study, it refers to the direct means of gauging the strength of

briquettes for the purpose of handling transportation and storage.

Scope and Limitation

This study aims to produce and characterize hybrid briquettes from waste

paper and banana peel using a low-pressure densification technique. This study

was limited to the characterization and production of hybrid briquettes to assess

if it could serve as a potential alternative energy source for domestic

applications.

The waste papers utilized were bond papers (modules) gathered in Leon

National High School. While the banana peels were gathered from Leon Public

Market banana cue vendors.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

14
Low pressure densification technique was used as a method of

characterizing the hybrid briquettes. There were five properties to be tested and

each had three replicates during the procedures.

A total of 54 hybrid briquettes were made and treatments of different

mixtures of banana peels and waste paper were distributed in the following

ratios: Treatment A - 75:25, Treatment B - 50:50, and Treatment C - 25:75. The

data gathered for moisture content, density, water resistance, shatter index, and

burning efficiency were tabulated and statistically analysed using Kruskal Wallis

Test.
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Chapter 2

Review of Related Literature

Chapter Two presents literature such as: Briquettes, Waste Paper, Banana

Peel, and Related Studies.

Part One, Briquettes, presents the overview, common briquette mixtures,

and briquette technologies.

Part Two, Waste Paper, refers to the characteristics of waste paper that

will be used in production of briquette.

Part Three, Banana Peels, refers to the characteristics of banana peels

that makes a suitable variable for the production of hybrid briquettes.

Part Four, Related Studies, present studies and researches related to our

study.

Briquettes

A briquette is solid fuel made from a combustible material, such as paper,

compressed into a block or any convenient shape (Speight, 2013). It is a cost-

effective alternative to coal and charcoal in a developed world, where fuel is not
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

15
as readily accessible (Gupta, 2020). The high energy potential of biomass used in

briquetting coupled with their easy attainability and lower cost promote briquette

as a substitute for fuels (Haykiri-Acma and Yaman, 2010).

It is generally known worldwide that fossil fuels are both vulnerable and

insufficient in the short and long terms respectively, thus initiating the search for

energy resources that are renewable and sustainable in order to meet a

considerable part of the energy demand in the future. Biomass resources have

gained attention due to their capability to be converted into multiple fuels, and

are also CO2- neutral and are, therefore, environmentally friendly (Chen et al.,

2015).

Nigeria, a country with a high agricultural activity, reintegrated waste,

which were to be disposed indiscriminately, to contribute to solving the energy

problem in the country through briquetting (Agbo and Ugwu, 2013). Their study

produced briquettes out of empty fruit branches of oil palm using starch and

asphalt as binders separately. The briquettes made with starch had a higher

calorific, higher burning rate, and higher heat output while also producing less

smoke and igniting in a shorter amount as compared to the briquettes with

asphalt as binders.
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

16
The binder types, amount of binder agent and water addition, have

significant effects on the thermal behavior and combustion of the briquettes

(Altun, et al., 2003).

Romallosa's (2017) study made use of a hydraulic jack to compress and

produce a cylindrical briquette with a hole at the center using biomass and urban

waste. The results of her study suggest that the technology used in briquetting

yielded suggestive effects in the production quality of briquettes.

Urgel (2014) in her study entitled Production of Homemade Biomass

Briquettes from Dried Syzygium samarangense (Makopa) Leaves, she explained

how briquettes were produced from dried Syzygium samarangense leaves using

paper as binder. She compared the briquettes based on their physival and

chemical properties. The briquettes with 37.5% biomass yielded the longest

burning time and longest ignition time. While those with 0% biomass yielded the

shortest burning time and the shortest ignition time. The briquette with 0%

biomass proved to be the strongest among the three. The briquettes with 50%

and 37.5% biomass did not break under about 2100 grams but only bent. The

outcome of the study shows the potential of using dried Syzygium samarangense

leaves as a source of making biomass briquettes.

In the study of Zhang, Everette, and Tynerr (2013), they converted

peanut shells, an abundant agricultural waste from the country of Gambia, into
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

17
fuel briquette. By consulting the local connections, the students developed a

series of pressing devices and processes for the purpose. Then they compared

the strength, burning rate and duration of burning of the briquettes, as well the

challenges to obtain binder and process the material. They ended up settling to

an easy to follow recipe and a very simple device to press the loose shells to

briquettes.

Combustion Characteristics of Briquettes

Briquetting is a process of compressing loose biomass residues into a

high-densified solid block that can be used as a fuel. Briquette from agricultural

waste (biomass) contributes to the energy mix. The briquette fuels are

advantageous to handle, have ease of transport, and improve heating value than

other types of biomass fuel. (Berhe, Zergaw 2022)

In the study of Berhe and Zergaw (2022) entitled Combustion

Characteristics of Briquette Fuel Produced from Biomass Residues and Binding

Materials, they demonstrated that briquettes produced from biomass residues

and binding materials showed varied results in terms of proximate and ultimate

analysis of briquettes. The mean ignition time of briquettes produced from

biomass wastes and binders was significantly varied (p<0.05). The longest
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

18
ignition time (71.07 ± 8.24 seconds) was observed in sawdust briquettes

followed by coffee pulp briquettes (68.58 ± 7.26 seconds) whereas the shortest

ignition time was scored in khat waste briquettes (65.03 ± 7.12 seconds) .

Generally, the ignition time of sawdust briquette is higher by 8.5% than the

ignition time in khat waste briquette. The lowest ignition time of khat waste

briquette might be accredited due to relatively low particle size, low porosity, and

high bonding force of briquette.

From the observed results, they concluded that sawdust residue with

binding material of paper pulp briquette was considered as high-quality and

durable solid fuel briquettes. The addition of pulp paper as a binder increases

fixed carbon content and calorific value of briquettes produced from selected

residues. In general, the production of briquette from these residues and binding

material helps to reduce the burden on forests and provide renewable, clean,

and sustainable energy and a substitute for fuelwood and charcoal.

Hybrid Briquettes

Base on the study of Patrick Imoisili et al. (2017) production of

sawdust/sorghum dust hybrid briquette from biomass is also possible.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

19
Experimental tests carried out show that sawdust and sorghum dust, which are

normally produced in large quantities without control, can be transformed into

good quality materials. High-grade solid fuel briquettes with excellent quality,

preservability and durability. Both domestic and industrial energy production for

energy generation. Briquettes have proper handling, transportation and storage

characteristics.

In addition, briquettes have a relatively high calorific value, making them

an attractive choice as an energy source. In particular, OPTB briquettes have

shown the best quality, but can burn and leave a significant amount of ash. The

relatively low ash content of the corn cob added to OPTB addresses this

shortcoming, making hybrid briquettes an advantageous option. The critical

qualities of hybrid briquettes have supported and justified the use of oil palm

trunk bark, which had not previously been used in briquette production. Further

research is recommended, including an optimized process varying raw material

properties (particle size and moisture content) and compaction conditions

(pressure and temperature). The study also recommends further evaluation of

the thermal properties of briquettes and their performance in cooking

applications. The use of these materials as alternative energy sources is desirable

as it not only addresses waste disposal and energy scarcity issues, but also

reduces indoor air pollution. Extracting useful energy from maize cob and OPTB
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

20
mixtures has the potential to bring significant environmental and socioeconomic

benefits to rural communities in developing countries, including Nigeria (Kpalo,

et al., 2020).

Banana Waste Briquettes

Banana peel is another type of agricultural, waste which originates from

industrial banana production. Banana is one of the most popular tropical fruits

consumed worldwide. In Thailand, 200 tons of banana peel is produced daily and

the amount is constantly increasing. A small fraction of the peel is used for

animal feed and the remainder becomes rotted garbage. Banana peel is

carbohydrate rich and could, potentially, be converted into bioenergy (Nathoa et

al., 2014). Banana waste contains 14% lignin, 14.8% hemicellulose and 13.2%

cellulose (Anwar et al., 2014). It has the potential for industrial charcoal

production for domestic use.

In the study of Mopoung and Udeye (2016) entitled Characterization and

Evaluation of Charcoal Briquettes Using Banana Peel and Banana Bunch Waste

for Household Heating they determined that combustion efficiencies of banana

peel charcoal briquettes and banana bunch charcoal briquettes were 9.10 and

8.38%, respectively. The time used to reach to maximum temperature during


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

21
banana bunch charcoal briquette combustion (36 min) is shorter than for banana

peel charcoal briquette combustion (48 min). The maximum burning times of 114

and 92 minutes were observed for banana peel and banana bunch charcoal

briquettes, respectively. The results can be considered a contribution to the

development of more eco-friendly, sustainable and renewable utilization of

banana waste.

Charcoal Briquettes

Charcoal and firewood are among the primary cooking fuels used in many

developing countries, even though they both pose a number of environmental,

social and economic challenges. Including the ecological impacts of indoor air

pollution produced by cooking with solid fuels (Gladstone et al., 2014). Charcoal

is an impure form of graphitic carbon obtained as a residue when carbonaceous

material is partially burned with limited access of air. This process rapidly

decomposes organic material through anaerobic heating by smoldering

agricultural waste (i.e., covering burning biomass with soil) in pits or trenches

(Claxton, 2014).
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

22
Charcoals have been also transformed into briquettes for ease of handling

and to reduce the dust problem and increase the energy density (Sjlie, 2012).

Briquette charcoal is a solid fuel from organic matter containing carbon, which

has a high calorific value and can be lit for a long time (Nuriana et al., 2014).

There are clear advantages of charcoal briquettes that include price, burn time,

environmental sustainability and potential for product standardization

(Mwampamba et al., 2013).

Waste Paper

Based on a study by Grigorion (2003), approximately 25 to 40% of the

municipal solid waste each year worldwide consists of paper and paper products.

Since recycling waste paper is an expensive practice, and as waste paper tends

to reduce the quality of paper produced (Groom et al., 1994), it makes an

optimal material to be used.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

23
Banana Peel

One such example of a biomass resource is banana peel. Banana peels

have a relatively high calorific value (between 15.00 MJ/Kg, a higher heating

value of 16.15 MJ/Kg and a lower heating value of 14.80 MJ/Kg) which makes it

a suitable fuel source (Kabenge et al., 2018).

According to Ahmad, Sazali, and Kamarolzaman (2017), there are many

materials that can be used to make briquettes. As for the banana waste, the

results showed that the briquettes were successfully produced according to the

desired shape and dimensions of the square mold. Banana peels appear to

facilitate manufacturing operations as they act as excellent binders and

substrates. Mixing banana peel with banana pseudostems and leaves improved

the efficiency of briquette production compared to single type waste briquettes

alone.

Pyrolysis analysis of briquettes showed that three stages of decomposition

occurred. removal of water and moisture, removal of volatiles, or removal of

cellulose and lignin from bananas, and the third stage is loss of remaining water

and chemicals. Banana waste and in-product parts. A high HHV value of 12-22

MJ/kg suggests good combustibility of the briquettes. The thermochemical

aspects of the samples are comparable to other banana materials or biomass

currently used for heating or combustion purposes, indicating that banana waste
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

24
may be an effective material for energy generation. Compressing banana peel

and molasses, which are by-products from the banana industry, into briquettes

using the medium-pressure briquette method.

Strong briquette density is affected by briquette pressure and binder ratio.

A high rate of increase was found. The density gradually decreased when the

molding pressure exceeded 7 MPa. Also, a decrease in the rate of density

increase has been reported for briquettes with slow binders. The relationship

between briquette density and briquette pressure Binder ratio was also

developed and verified. The average compressive strength of briquettes was

above 700kPa.

For raw banana peel, the maximum mass loss rate was 586 K. A fast-

burning section and a slow-burning section of banana peel cross-sections were

separated at a temperature of approximately 673 K. This material was slightly

higher than some agricultural residues. (Wilaipon, et al., 2007).


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

25
Sawdust

In Odusote's et al., (2016) study, sawdust was utilized to increase the

density and mass of briquette; however, a higher ratio of sawdust in the mixture

resulted in a decreased compressive strength in the briquette.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Chapter 3

Methodology

Chapter Three includes six parts: Purpose of the Study and

Research Design, Treatments, Materials, Data Collection and Data Analysis.

Part One, Research Design, presents on how the study were

conducted.

Part Two, Materials, describes the materials used and the

procedures.

Part Three, Treatments, presents the varying ratios of the materials used.

Part Four, Data Collection, presents procedures or steps in gathering the

data needed for the study.

Part Five, Data Analysis, describes the method used to analyze and

interpret the gathered data in the study.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

35
Research Design

This study utilized a quantitative experimental research design. According

to Creswell (2013), this design is a systematic and scientific approach to research

in which the researchers manipulate one or more variables and control and

measure any change in other variables. Hence, it measures the causal

relationship between the independent (densification of banana peels and waste

paper) and dependent (hybrid briquette) variables of the study. In this light, this

design was used because the researchers wanted to know if the briquette in

terms of physical, mechanical and thermal properties can serve as a potential

alternative energy source for domestic cooking applications.

Materials and Equipment

Table 1. Materials and Equipment used in the Production and Characterization

of Hybrid Briquettes

Material Quantity Purpose

-used as a variable in
Waste Paper 2 sacks the production of hybrid

briquettes

-used as a variable in
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

36
Banana Peels 4 sacks the production of hybrid

briquettes

-served as binder for


Sawdust ½ sack hybrid briquettes

-used to soak the waste

paper

-used to soak hybrid


Water
briquettes; to measure

the water resistance of

hybrid briquettes

-used as container to

soak waste paper

-used as container to
Basin 2pc
soak hybrid briquettes;

to measure the water

resistance of hybrid

briquettes

-used to mold the hybrid


Molder 1pc briquettes
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

37
-used as the equipment

to utilize the low


Hydraulic Jack 1pc densification technique

and form hybrid

briquettes

-used to measure weight

of hybrid briquettes; to
Weighing Scale 1pc be used to assess

properties of hybrid

briquettes

-used to hold the hybrid

briquettes; to be used in
Clay stove 1pc assessing the burning

efficiency of hybrid

briquettes

-used to measure
Ruler 1pc volume of hybrid

briquettes; to assess the

density of hybrid
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

38
briquettes

Procedures

Waste papers were collected from local schools in Leon, Iloilo, while the

banana peels were obtained from the local banana cue vendors in Leon Public

Market. Sawdust were obtained from nearby millworks and cabinet shops. The

banana peels were dried under heat for at least five days and were cut or

shredded into tiny pieces. We calculated the initial moisture content of banana

peels. All moisture contents presented in this paper are on a % wet basis. Both

materials were later cut/shred into small pieces. The waste papers were soaked

in water for 2 days and ground to form pulp in accordance with the procedure

described by Roy et al. The briquettes were formed using a cylindrical mold

(measurements of mold is not yet final). Three briquettes were produced from

each sample and their initial densities were measured immediately after ejection

from the mold. The resultant briquettes were placed on a flat surface and left to

air dry in a closed room with adequate air ventilation for 30 days or dried using a

dryer for 2-3 days before testing the properties. This were all executed in a
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

39
makeshift workroom in one of the researcher’s residences in Barangay Talacuan

Leon, Iloilo.

Treatments

A total of three different samples will be prepared in varying ratios of banana

peels (BP) to waste papers (WP) (100:0, 50:50, 0:100), and each sample was

mixed with sawdust to thicken the mixture (roughly 5–10% by weight of sample

mix).

Table 2. Material Composition of Banana Peels and Waste Paper

Sample Number Sample Name Banana Peels Waste Paper


1 MIX 1 25 75
2 MIX 2 50 50
3 MIX 3 75 25
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

40
Data Collection

The materials were collected in nearby premises. The banana peels were

collected from banana queue vendors in Leon, Iloilo, and the waste paper were

collected from local schools in Leon.

Generally, this study aimed to characterize the hybrid briquettes in six

categories (moisture content, density, water resistance, shatter index,

compressive strength, and calorific value) to assess if it could serve as a

potential alternative energy source for domestic cooking applications.

1.Moisture Content

Moisture content was determined by sun-dried methods. Each briquette

was weighed before sun-dried for 5 days. The loss in mass, expressed as a

percentage of final sun-dried mass was taken as the moisture content of the

briquettes. The moisture content was calculated by equation

W 1−W 2
MC= x 100
W2

where MC = moisture content, W1 = wet weight, W2 = weight after

drying.
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

41
2.Density

The density of briquettes was determined by measuring the diameter,

height and central whole diameter at different points using a Vernier caliper,

while the mass was measured with a digital weighing balance (Model AND GF

3000). The density of briquettes was determined 30 days after the briquetting

process. The density will be calculated by:

m
ρ=
v

where ρ = Density, m = mass of biomass briquette, V = volume of

biomass briquette.

3.Water Resistance

The water resistance test was carried out in accordance with the

procedure described in Davies and Davies,. A digital weighing balance (Model

AND GF 3000) will be used to measure the initial weight of each sample

briquette and then dunked in water for 2 min. A stopwatch will be used to time

the process. The briquette’s weights will be measured again and the relative

change in weight will be recorded. Percentage water absorbed was calculated

using the following equation


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

42
W 2−W 1
% absorbed by briquette= x 100
W1

where W2 = final weight of briquette after immersion and W1 = initial

weight of briquette before immersion.

Water resistance (%) = 100% - % water absorbed by briquette.

4.Shatter Index

The procedure involved weighing and recording the initial mass of the

briquette, followed by subjecting the sample to a gravitation fall from a constant

2-m height. The drop is repeated three times and each time the sample was

passed through a sieve (2.36 mm), while the mass of the briquette retained on

the sieve was recorded. The shatter index of each briquette was calculated by

the equation:

Bz
K= ×100
B

where K = shatter index, Bz = weight of briquette after shattering, B =

weight of briquette before shattering.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

43
5.Burning Efficiency
In burning efficiency test, a total of 9 set ups were done. Set-up 1-3 utilized

the 75:25 hybrid briquette, set-up 4-6 utilized the 50:50 and set-up 7-9 for the

25:75. 3 Briquettes were put over the clay stove in each set-up and lighted for

fire. The time was recorded for how long it took to burn and how long it lasted.

Data Analysis

Samples of briquettes were selected using simple random sampling

method in each of the five categories and their properties (density, moisture

content, water resistance, compression strength, shatter index and calorific

value) were tested and replicated four times. The test data obtained were

subjected to Kruskal Wallis Test and Fisher’s Least Significance Difference (LSD)

test to determine the significant differences between the various treatments of

the briquettes. All significance tests in this study were conducted with p < 0.05

(density less than 0.05).


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Chapter 4

Results and Discussion

Chapter Four presents the Descriptive Data Analysis and Inferential Data

Analysis.

Part One, Descriptive Data Analysis, presents the results of the study with

the use of frequency and percentage.

Part Two, Inferential Data Analysis, test if there is/are significant

difference/s in the test variable.

Descriptive Data Analysis

SOP 1. What are the properties of hybrid briquettes in terms of the following: a.)

Physical, b.) Mechanical, c.) Thermal.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

44
Table 3. Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes in its Physical Properties

Descriptive Statistics
Std.
N Minimum Maximum Mean
Deviation
Moisture
9 105.050 152.940 125.55378 16.686453
Content
Density 9 3.20 5.20 4.1444 .67289
Water
9 94.30 165.25 130.7489 24.92735
Resistance
Valid N
9
(listwise)

The results in Table 3 showed the mean of all the physical properties of

the hybrid briquettes. A total of 9 briquettes were tested for each property,

having 3 for each mixture. According to Huang J. (2014), briquettes' moisture

content should be between 10% - 18% because briquettes with moisture

content below 10% or above 18% are inconsistent and prone to breaking. The

briquettes' mean moisture content of 12.5% indicates that they have a high

moisture content, which makes them less consistent and more likely to break.

High moisture content can harm briquettes and equipment, but can improve

compression strength and shatter index. It can also cause poor combustion

properties, including low heat output, low temperature, and long fuel residence,

leading to fume emissions and explosion risks (Tumuluru et al., 2011). According
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

45
to Bello, R S (2020), in order to produce efficient briquettes its density must

range from 490-820kg/m3. The lower moisture briquettes have high resistance

to water, high impact resistance and excellent storability. Density had a mean of

4.14 which means the briquettes had high density. Recent studies have reported

that the higher the density in briquettes, the higher the energy/volume ratio.

The burning time may be longer, however, other combustion properties of such

briquettes may be negatively affected (Kers et al., 2010. Water resistance had a

mean of 130.75 which meant the briquettes had high water resistance. Water

resistance is an important characteristic for briquettes, as it affects their

durability and performance. While there is no universally defined ideal water

resistance range for briquettes, a range of 88% to 92% is often considered

desirable (source). In comparison with this data, the briquettes produced by the

researchers demonstrate varying degrees of water resistance in the lower range:

exhibiting a maximum of 6% to a minimum of -65.25%.).


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

46
Table 4. Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes in its Mechanical Properties

Descriptive Statistics
Std.
N Minimum Maximum Mean
Deviation
Shatter
9 95.95 100.00 98.0889 1.46999
Index
Valid N
9
(listwise)

Table 4, given the mechanical property in terms of the shatter index. The

shatter index had a mean of 98.09 meaning it has a high resistance to shattering

and will be easy for transport. According to Borowski et al., the shatter index of

briquettes should be at least 90%. In a previous study, a minimum value of 50%

was considered an acceptable shatter index for fuel briquettes developed for

industrial and domestic applications.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

47
Table 5. Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes in its Thermal Property

Descriptive Statistics
Std.
N Minimum Maximum Mean
Deviation
Burning Efficiency -
How long it took to 9 10 15 11.67 2.500
combust (min)
Burning Efficiency -
How long it lasted 9 30 60 45.00 12.990
(min)
Valid N (listwise) 9

Table 5 showed the thermal property of the hybrid briquettes in terms of

it burning efficiency, how long it took to combust and how long it lasted.

According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the

average burning efficiency of charcoal is estimated to be around 80%. This

means that approximately 80% of the energy stored in charcoal is converted into

heat during the burning process. Burning efficiency in terms of how long it took

to combust had a mean of 11.67 meaning when compared to charcoal, it is as

efficient. Burning efficiency in terms of how long it lasted had a mean of 45.00

meaning when compared to charcoal, it also proves to be as efficient.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

48

SOP 2. What are the properties of hybrid briquettes based on different mixtures

of waste paper and banana peel ratio: 25:75, 50:50, 75:25?

Table 6. Physical Properties of Hybrid Briquettes based on different mixture of


Waste Paper and Banana Peel ratio.

Physical
Treatments Moisture Water Density
Content Resistance
75BP:25 Mean 114.38133 144.5433 4.0000
WP N 3 3 3
Std. 8.393373 9.21152 .30000
Deviation
50BP:50 Mean 144.25333 147.0333 3.5333
WP N 3 3 3
Std. 9.994500 17.87068 .28868
Deviation
25BP:75 Mean 118.02667 100.6700 4.9000
WP N 3 3 3
Std. 12.111178 6.40021 .43589
Deviation
Total Mean 125.55378 130.7489 4.1444
N 9 9 9
Std. 16.686453 24.92735 .67289
Deviation
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

49
Table 6 showed that the physical properties of the hybrid briquettes were

tested based on different banana peel to waste paper ratio. In terms of

moisture content, mixture 50BP:50WP had the highest mean of 144.25333,

meaning it had the highest moisture content and the mixture 75BP:25WP had

the lowest moisture content since banana peels are not that absorbent to water.

In terms of the water resistance, mixture 50BP:50WP had the highest mean of

147.0333, meaning it had the highest resistance to water and mixture

25BP:75WP had the lowest resistance to water. Based on the results given by

Table 4, the treatment 25BP:75WP with mean of 4.900 g/cm3 is the only data

that is efficient based on density and mixture 50BP:50WP with mean of 3.53

and 75BP:25WP with mean of 4.00 isn’t as efficient according to the data given

by Bello.

Table 7. Mechanical Properties of Hybrid Briquettes based on different mixture


of Waste Paper and Banana Peel ratio.

Mechanical
Shatter Index
Std.
Treatments Mean N
Deviation
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

50
75BP:25WP 97.2333 3 .51733
50BP:50WP 97.6900 3 2.08430
25BP:75WP 99.3433 3 .57830
Total 98.0889 9 1.46999
Table 7 showed that the mechanical properties of hybrid briquettes were

tested in terms of its shatter index. In the context of briquetting the term

“shatter index” refers to the briquettes resistance to shattering under pressure. A

higher shatter index indicates better durability and strength of briquette. The

result indicated that the mechanical properties of the hybrid briquettes increases

as the percentage of waste paper in the mixture increases. The mixture

25BP75WP has the highest mean among 3 mixtures, suggesting that the 25BP-

75WP is more durable and less likely to break apart when subjected to pressure

or impact.

Table 8. Thermal Property of Hybrid Briquettes based on different mixture of


Waste Paper and Banana Peel ratio.

Thermal
Burning Burning
Efficiency - How Efficiency -
Treatments
long it took to How long it
combust (min) lasted (min)
Mean 15.00 30.00
75BP:25WP N 3 3
Std. Deviation .000 .000
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

51
Mean 10.00 45.00
50BP:50WP N 3 3
Std. Deviation .000 .000
Mean 10.00 60.00
25BP:75WP N 3 3
Std. Deviation .000 .000
Mean 11.67 45.00
Total N 9 9
Std. Deviation 2.500 12.990

Table 8 showed that the thermal properties of hybrid briquettes were

tested in terms of its burning efficiency. Burning efficiency refers to the

briquettes efficiency when it comes to burning. Common wood charcoal starts to

ignite at 5 mins and last for 45 mins. The mixture 50BP:50WP with mean of 5.00

on how long it took to burn and mean of 45 mins on how long it lasts, and

mixture 25BP:75WP with mean of 5.00 on how long it took to burn and mean of

60 mins on how long it lasts, making it more efficient compared to common

wood charcoals. The results indicated that the higher the percentage of waste

paper the less time it takes to burn and the more time it lasts making it efficient

for fuel applications.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

52
SOP 3. Is there a significant difference in the physical, mechanical, and thermal

properties of hybrid briquettes with different banana peel to waste paper ratio?

Table 9. Significant Difference in the Physical Properties of Hybrid Briquettes

Test Statisticsa,b
Physical Mechanical Thermal
Burning Efficiency
How How
Moisture Water Shatter
Density long it long it
Content Resistance Index
took to lasted
combust
Chi- 8.000 8.000
5.42 6.713 5.422 3.115
Square
df 2 2 2 2 2 2
Asymp. .018 .018
.066 .035 .066 .211
Sig.
a. Kruskal Wallis Test
b. Grouping Variable: Treatments
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

53
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

54
Table 9 showed the significant difference in the Physical, Mechanical, and

Thermal Properties of Hybrid Briquettes. As shown in Table 7, there is no

significant difference (p-value=0.066>α=0.05) in the moisture content and water

resistance of hybrid briquettes, meaning their values are the same. The moisture

content of briquettes is high making it consistent and the briquette doesn’t tend

to fall into pieces (Renewable Energy World, 2014). The water resistance of

briquettes is low meaning the briquettes are prone to water just like common

wood charcoal. There is a significant difference in the (p-value=0.035<α=0.05)

in the density of hybrid briquettes, meaning their values is different. The mixture

25BP:75WP has the highest value of density among the mixtures indicating that

this mixture has high resistance to high impact and excellent storability and

mixture 75BP:25WP has the lowest value of density indicating that it is more

prone to impact and can have problems during transport. There is no significant

difference in the shatter index of briquettes, meaning their values are the same.

The shatter index of briquettes is high it is highly resistant to shattering and will

be easy for transport. There is a significant difference in the burning efficiency

(how long it took to burn) of hybrid briquettes, meaning their values isn’t the

same. The mixture 25BP:75WP has the lowest mean indicating that it is efficient

for cooking applications and is comparable to common wood charcoal, while the

mixture 75BP:25WP has the highest mean indicating that it takes longer to ignite
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

55
and isn’t efficient as common wood charcoal. There is a significant difference in

the burning efficiency (how long it lasted) of hybrid briquettes. The mixture

25BP:75WP has the highest mean indicating that it last longer and efficient

similarly to common wood charcoal, while the mixture 75BP:25WP has the lowest

mean indicating that it burns fast and isn’t efficient as fuel source.

Inferential Data Analysis

Kruskal Wallis Test showed that there was no significant difference in the

production and characterization of hybrid briquettes with different banana peels

to waste paper ratio in its physical property in terms of its moisture content and

water resistance, meanwhile, there was a significant difference in terms of its

density. In mechanical property, the results showed no significant difference in

terms of its shatter index. In thermal property, the results showed a significant

difference in terms of its burning efficiency (how long it took to combust and

how long it lasted) based on different waste paper to banana peels ratio.
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

56
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

Chapter 5

Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations

Chapter Five includes the Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations

of the study.

Part One, Summary, itemizes the answers to specific questions.

Part Two, Conclusions, presents the general concept or result of the

study.

Part Three, Recommendations, enumerates the things to be done for

future improvement of the study.

Summary

This study about the production and characterization of hybrid briquettes from

waste paper and banana peels under a low-pressure densification technique was

conducted to produce alternative hybrid briquettes that have higher handling and

transportation characteristics made from organic materials. This study sought to

answer the following questions: 1). What are the properties of hybrid briquettes

in terms of the following: a.) Physical, b.) Mechanical, c.) Thermal. 2). What are
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

54
the properties of hybrid briquettes based on different mixtures of waste paper

and banana peel ratio: 25:75, 50:50, 75:25? 3). Is there a significant difference

in the physical, mechanical, and thermal properties of hybrid briquettes with

different banana peel to waste paper ratio? Results showed no significant

difference in terms of the hybrid briquettes’ physical (moisture content and water

resistance) and mechanical (shatter index) properties. Meanwhile, results

showed a significant difference in terms of the hybrid briquettes’ physical

(density) and thermal (burning efficiency) properties.

Conclusions

The results of the experiment indicate the following conclusions: All the

hybrid briquettes exhibit a notable level of density, indicating an increased

capacity for energy. The hybrid briquettes all displayed a high moisture content

level and a low water resistance. Among the various mixtures tested, the results

demonstrate that the 25BP:75WP briquette ratio is the most favorable,

showcasing superior physics, mechanical, and thermal characteristics. The

50BP:50WP exhibited the poorest qualities in the test. Based on the findings, it

can be inferred that increasing the ratio of WP in the mixtures also increases its
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

55
density. The value of density was shown to be inversely proportional to the

moisture content. A similar trend was found in both relationships of density with

water resistance and burning efficiency. Overall, the hybrid briquettes possess

low handling and transportation characteristics but have suitable thermal

properties for cooking and heating applications.

Recommendations

This study solely focuses on the characterization of hybrid briquettes from

waste paper and banana peels. As such, it aims to serve as a premise for further

study on the potential of briquettes as a fuel source alternative. To further this

research, the researchers recommend a study on the quality assessment of

hybrid briquettes and their economic impact when compared to traditional

methods, as well as the characterization and analyses of combustion and

emission of different biomass blends or mixtures. The study also recommends a

further assessment of the thermal property of the hybrid briquettes, as well as

their performance in cooking applications. The use of these materials as

alternative sources of energy is desirable because it tackle problems of waste

disposal, energy shortages as well as mitigate against indoor air pollution. The

production and characterization of hybrid briquettes from waste paper and


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

56
banana peels could bring significant environmental and socio-economic benefits

to rural communities of developing countries, including Philippines. The

researchers also recommend further studies on different briquette production

technologies and integration into the current renewable energy systems. The

results of further research can inform and encourage different sectors on the use

of briquettes for a sustainable future.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

57
References

de Oliveira Maia, B. G., Souza, O., Marangoni, C., Hotza, D., de Oliveira, A. P. N.,

& Sellin, N. (2014). Production and characterization of fuel briquettes

from ... - researchgate. research gate.

https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Bianca-Goulart-De-Oliveira-Maia/

publication/

286446712_Production_and_Characterization_of_Fuel_Briquettes_from_Ban

ana_Leaves_Waste/links/56698d7808aea0892c49a687/Production-and-

Characterization-of-Fuel-Briquettes-from-Banana-Leaves-Waste.pdf

Parayno, P. P., & Busmente, M. G. M. (2013). Study report - WADEF.wadef.com.

http://www.wadef.com/projects/isteac/StudyReport__Paper_Recycling_Res

earch_Philippines.Work_Results.pdf

(PDF) production and characterization of fuel briquettes from banana ... (n.d.-a).

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/286446712_Production_and_Char

acterization_of_Fuel_Briquettes_from_Banana_Leaves_Waste

The World’s Fastest Dictionary | Vocabulary.com. (n.d.). Www.vocabulary.com.

https://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/banana%20peel
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

58
Densification - Definition, Meaning & Synonyms. (n.d.). Vocabulary.com.

Retrieved October 25, 2022, from

https://www.vocabulary.com/dictionary/densification

briquette. (n.d.). The Free Dictionary. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from

https://www.thefreedictionary.com/briquette

Definition of WASTEPAPER. (n.d.). Www.merriam-Webster.com.

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/wastepaper

Mitchual, S.J.; Frimpong-Mensah, K.; Darkwa, N.A. Relationship between

Physico-Mechanical Properties, Compacting Pressure and Mixing Proportion of

Briquettes Produced from Maize Cobs and Sawdust. J. Sustain. Bioenergy Syst.

2014, 4, 50–60. [CrossRef]

Roy, R.; Kundu, K.; Kar, S.; Dahake, V.R.; Rajan, P. Production and evaluation of

briquettes made from dry leaves, wheat straw, saw dust using paper pulp and

cow dung as binder. Res. Front. 2015, 3, 51–58.

ASTM D3174-12. Standard Test Method for Ash in the Analysis Sample of Coal

and Coke from Coal; ASTM International: West Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2012.

ASTM D3176-15. Standard Practice for Ultimate Analysis of Coal and Coke; ASTM

International: West Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2015.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

59
ASTM D2444-16. Standard Test Methods for Direct Moisture Content

Measurement of Wood and Wood-Based Materials; ASTM International: West

Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2016.

ASTM D2395-17. Standard Test Methods for Density and Specific Gravity

(Relative Density) of Wood and Wood-Based Materials; ASTM International: West

Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2017.

Davies, R.M.; Davies, O.A. Physical and combustion characteristics of briquettes

made from water hyacinth and phytoplankton scum as binder. J. Combust. 2013,

2013, 549894. [CrossRef]

ASTM D440-86. Standard Test Method of Drop Shatter Test for Coal; ASTM

International: West Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2002.

Antwi-Boasiako, C.; Acheampong, B.B. Strength properties and calorific values

of sawdust-briquettes as wood-residue energy generation source from tropical

hardwoods of different densities. Biomass Bioenergy 2016, 85, 144–152.

[CrossRef]

ASTM D2166-85. Standard Test Method of Compressive Strength of Wood; ASTM

International: West Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2008.

ASTM D5865-13. Standard Test Method for Gross Calorific Value of Coal and

Coke; ASTM International: West Conshohocken, PA, USA, 2013.


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

60

Appendices
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

61
Appendix A

June 22, 2023


MARIANE C. CADURNIGARA
Research Statistician
Leon, Iloilo

Ma’am:
The undersigned, Roj Christian H. Cabarles, a student of Leon National
High School under the Academic Track Science, Technology, Engineering, and
Mathematics, is conducting a research study entitle “ Production and
Characterization of Hybrid Briquettes from Waste Paper and Banana Peels under
a Low-pressure Densification Technique in Partial Fulfillment of the requirements
in Capstone Research.
In this regard, the undersigned respectfully requests your kind permission
to be the Research Statistician. Approval to this request will greatly contribute to
the completion of this study.
Thank you very much and Godbless!

Respectfully Yours,
Roj Christian H. Cabarles
Researcher
Noted:

JOSHUA C. MONTEFRIO
Research Teacher
Confirmed:
MARIANE C. CADURNIGARA
Research Statistician
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

62

Appendix B

Documentation

Figure 1. Collection of Banana Peels Figure 2. Sun drying of Banana Peels

Figure 3. Collection of Waste Paper Figure 4. Soaking the Waste Paper

for two day


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

63

Figure 7. Pulverizing the Banana Figure 8. Turning the Waste Paper

Peels into pulps

Hybrid Briquette Making Process of Banana Peels and Waste Paper


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

64
Figure 9. Mixing the Banana Peels

and Waste Paper in ratios BP:WP

respectively (75:25, 50:50, 25:75)

Figure 10. Placing the mixture in the

moulder

Figure 13. Cutting the briquettes into

a height of 1.5 inches

Figure 12. Removing the formed


Figure 11. Compressing the mixture
briquette from the moulder
inside
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

65

Figure 14. Drying the Briquettes into

a food dehydrator

Characterization of the Hybrid Briquettes

Moisture Content

Figure 17. Measuring the weight and

height of the briquettes

Figure 15. Measuring the weight of

briquettes before drying and its

weight after drying

Density

Figure 16. Solving the moisture

content of hybrid briquettes


Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

66

Figure 21. The briquettes was

dropped in a height of 2 meters

Figure 18. Solving for the density of

hybrid briquettes

Water Resistance

Figure 20. Submerging the briquette

Figure 19. Measuring the dry weight in water and solve for its water

of briquettes resistance

Shatter Index
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

67

Figure 22. This was repeated 3 times

briquettes was sieved (2.36mm)

each time it was dropped

Burning Efficiency

Figure 23. How long it took to ignite


Figure 24. How long it lasted
Leon National High School
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
F. Cabarles St., Leon, Iloilo

68

You might also like