Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3, July 1989
Ec=b4Ea
-+
J
Ea
Eb=b5 Ea
by Barnes and Barthold for meeting the future demand of
electric energy [l]. Subsequently, several papers appeared
on the feasibility of high phase order transmission [2-8]. Fig. 1: A set of balanced six e.m.f's
Willems analysed the behaviour of interconnected three
phase and poly-phase power systems [ 9 1.
Tiwari e t al Under the transformation T [ 12 1, the sequence
1 1
[ 10 and Chen e t al [ 11 have extended the method components of V,I and E are given by,
1
of modelling three phase systems t o multi-phase systems. v = T-lV, i = T- I and e = T-lE.
Although economic considerations will ultimately
override all other consideration for or against the conver- Equation (2.1) transforms t o
sion of existing three phase systems into six or higher e = Z i + v
phase systems, the various aspects of high phase order
systems must be throughly investigated. in particular, the
subject of fault analysis assumes considerable importance
from the operational point of view. This aspect has been
reported in a piecemeal way in the literature. Bhatt e t ai
1:
1 o . . . o
0 . . . . 0
Authorized licensed use limited to: DELHI TECHNICAL UNIV. Downloaded on September 8, 2009 at 03:45 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
161 I
p"i 2
where,
A = I
l l . . .
:]
It Is possible t o choose a in such a way that the sum of
ail elements of any of i t s rows Is 1. That is,
Authorized licensed use limited to: DELHI TECHNICAL UNIV. Downloaded on September 8, 2009 at 03:45 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1612
Example: z -z z -z
For a fault involving shorting of terminals (a,e,f) V = a Te- % T L e + O T L T - l a Te
in one bunch and of terminals (b,d) in another bunch and
terminal c isolated, the matrices a and B would be given
A 6
by Since Le = 0, TLT-l = T a n d c a ij =1
J =1
we have
Aa = A and ATe = 0
This gives,
V = aTe= aE
with this method of choosing a and we always have or.
an = a , n an integer
a @ =Ba = =Da = a D
where 6,1 is a delta function and j = 0, 1 . A where D1 is a diagonal matrix having 1's a t those places
which correspond t o the grounded terminals.
8. Post phase-fault terminal voltages
The sequence components Of the terminal
"Itages As an example, the matrices a ' , B', a , B , p , U'
and D1 for the fault shown in Fig. 3 would be
are given by,
v = e - Z c I 0 0 0 0
Substituting for I from Eq. (7.2) we get,
z -z
v = e-(U+ L1T-l (U- a )Te (8.1)
The actual post-fault terminal voltages are then given by,
z -z
V = Tv = Te - T(U+.L)T-(lU- a )Te (8.2)
or,
Authorized licensed use limited to: DELHI TECHNICAL UNIV. Downloaded on September 8, 2009 at 03:45 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1613
=I:
0 0 0
and finally,
U
112
112
i":":!
0
0 :
I
D ~ o o o o o o
112
112
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
C
0
0
0
0
;
0
0
,U" 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
-
10.
T-l
Ground faults
T-l
i = 7 (U-a )Te +-;(U+ D,A)-
1
Dla Te
1 = -
a =U, and
T - l (U+ 2 D A)-lDITe
(10.1)
(9.16)
1 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0
F==q
f
z 6 1
11. Interpretation of Equation (9.16)
(i) The first term in this equation is the same as the
Fig. 3: A typical siinuitaneous RHS of Eq. (7.2). This shows that one component of the
ground and phase fault current following a simultaneous ground and phase fault
The sequence current vector (1) for a simultaneous ground is equal t o the current following a phase fault alone.
and phase fault would be given by Eq. (5.4) after replacing (11) An examination of Eq. (10.1) reveals that the multi-
U by a ' and f3 by f3' in It. Therefore, plier Te Is the pre-ground-fault voltage a t the terminals
of the generator. Also, Eq. (8.5) shows that the post phase-
(U- CL +U )Te=z [{(U+ f3 - U'- a + )+~ a ( U - a + U )A 1 T
6
11 (9.7) fault terminal voltage a t the generator terminals is a Te.
The second term in Eq. (9.16) is, therefore, the current
where, following a ground fault a t the terminals of a generator
generating an unbalanced set of e.m.f.'s a Te. This is
a = (zo -z)/z nothing but a confirmation of the superposition principle.
Finally, from Eq. (9.16), the expression for the
Equation (9.7) simplifies t o
individual seauence currents following a simultaneous
-
I = T-1 ( u + M ~ t ) - ~ ( U - a + D ~ a ) T e
(9.8)
ground and phase fault on a six phase generator may be
Z written as
where, 6 6
M = (D-DID-U+D1 + %
6 D 1 A) (9.9) 1 [4 1 bkj ark)b7-' ]I +
r=l k=l
It Is straight forward t o show that for integral values
of n,
T-l
i =- U-M(U+M)-l a ] (U- a +D1 a )Te (9.12)
Z j = 0,1...5.
which further simplifies t o
Where A = 6z+(zo-z) trace D1, and D1 = diag (d,) m=1,6.
T-l T-l
i =- (U-a)Te+- (U+M)-lD1 a T e (9.13) This is the most general equation for the sequence curr-
ents following any complicated simultaneous ground and
phase fault on the terminals of a six phase generator. This
Also,
equation can easily be programmed on a digital computer
(u+M) = ( D - D ~ + D+ %D,A) for the study of any fault. The simulation of this equation
1 6
on a network analyser can be done once the sequence
= ( D ~ +~ D ~ A ) currents obtained froin the equation are written in the
format
where, el
(io i1 i2 ig i4 i,)=(a 0 1 a2 a3 a4 a5 )- z+z' (1 1.2)
Df= (D-DID+D1) is a non-singular diagonal matrix.
with 1 as the second element of the r o w . vector. An
Therefore, exarnination of (a ,a
manner in which' .&qu&ce
...
a and z') atonce indlcates
networks must be connected
the
Authorized licensed use limited to: DELHI TECHNICAL UNIV. Downloaded on September 8, 2009 at 03:45 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
i/
1614
k
= 0 0
0
0
112
112
0
112
0
0
1
0
0
(if = ( 0, 1 , 0, 0, 0, -1
112
0
112
0
)z+z
I!
112
el
‘D’=o
( 1 3.3)
Substituting j=O, 1...5, respectively in Eq. (11.11, we get, The connection of sequence networks is shown in Fig. 6.
(io,i 1 ,i2,i3,i4,i5)
(z+z0) e,
3-
(3z+5z ) z(z+3z0) (13.1)
z+ -
( 3Z+5Z0)
113 113 0
The sequence networks must be connected as shown 113 113 0
in Fig. 4 to satisfy the above equation. a = 0 0 113 113 113 0 , D~ = 0
0 0 113 113 113 0
0 0 113 113 113 0
113 113 0 0 0 113
Authorized licensed use limited to: DELHI TECHNICAL UNIV. Downloaded on September 8, 2009 at 03:45 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1615
+n#/nF
112
0
0
112
0
0
112
0
0
0
0
112
13z+2z0 z(2z+zo)
z+ (13.7)
112 112 , D,
~
a = 0 0 0 0 = 0 13z+2z
112 0 0 112 0 ' 0
0 0 112 0 112 0
0 112 0 0 0 112 The connection of sequence networks is shown in Fig. 10.
r-1
el
(i)t = ( 0, I , 0, 215, 0, -115 ) ;+z/5 (1 3.5)
1:3 -
el Fig. 10: (a-g), (b-c-e-f) fault
1
1 :2 f 112 0 0 112 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0
Fig. 8: (a-d), (b-f), (c-e) fault 0 112 0 0 0 112 000000
IV: faults of type c
a = 0
112
0
0
0
0
112
0
112
0
112
0
:
112 0
000000
000000
000000
(i)(a-g), (b-f) fault .o 112 0 0 0 112 000000
( i f = ( 0, 1, 0, 215, 0, -115 ) e
z+z/5
1
( 1 3.8)
14. CONCLUSIONS
Although the variety of faults on a six phase system
C z (11z+3zo)
1 Is considerably more complex than in a three phase
system, their analysis can be done by a single equation
z+ (1 3.6) presented here. For a given fault involving both phase and
9Z+Zo ground faults only two matrices a and D1 need be written.
These matrices may be called 'phase fault coefficient
The connection of sequence networks is shown in Fig. 9. matrix' and 'ground fault coefficient matrix', respectively.
The sequence currents when written in the format
suggested here indicate the method of connecting sequence
networks for the simulation of the given fault. The method
1given In the paper can be applied to a general n-phase
system.
15. Future work
e A systematic study of fault analysis on 6 phase
1 power systems has been undertaken a t the department of
Electrical Engineering, Govt. Engineering College, Jabaipur,
India. The next step In this direction would be the analysts
of:
Fig. 9: (a-g), (b-f) fault (i) Transient currents following a complicated fault
(ii)
t
CL = 1 ;F ;F
(a-g), (b-c-e-f) fault
0
0
32
0
114
114
0
114
114
0
-(2Z+Z ) 3Z
32
0
:F
114
114
0
114
114
,D :::
000000
1
1 0 0 0 0 0
(ii)
(ill)
(iv)
16.
1.
sequential faults
faults through impedances
propagation of switching surges on a SIX phase trans-
mission line etc.
References
Authorized licensed use limited to: DELHI TECHNICAL UNIV. Downloaded on September 8, 2009 at 03:45 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1616
3. S.S. Vankata, 'Feasibility Studies of Higher Order 15. S.P. Nanda, S.N. Tiwari, L.P. Singh, 'Fault Analysis
Phase Electrical Transmission System (Phase ti)', Final of Six Phase Systems', Electric Power Systems Research
Report t o Allegheny Power System, Greensburg, Pennsyl- Journal, Vol 4, No. 3, July 1981, pp. 201,
vania, 1977-78. 16. J.L. Willems, 'The Fault Analysis and Component
4. S.S. Venkata, 'Feasibility Studies of Higher Order Schemes for Polyphase Power Systems' Electrical Power
Phase Electrical Transmission System (Phase Ill), Final and Energy Systems, Vol. 2, 1980, pp 43-46.
Report t o Allegheny Power System, Greensburg, Pennsyl-
vania, 1978-79.
5. W.C. Guvker, W.H. Booth, M.A. Jansen, S.S. Venkata, Dr. B.K. Bhat was born in Bandi-
E.K. Stanek, N.R. .Bhatt,'138 Six-phase Transmission System pur, Kashmir, India in 1937. He
Feasibility' Proceedings of the 1978 American Power graduated with B.Sc. Electrical
Conference, Chicago Illinois, April 25, 1978, pp. 1293-1305. Engineering from University of
.. Agra India in 1958. He went t o
6. W.C. Guyker, W.H. Booth, S.S. Venkata,'l38-KV, Six- @-'
phase, Power Transmlssion Feaslbl1ity:An overview', pres- Canada in 1965 where he took
ented a t the Pennsylvania Electric Association's Planning M.A.Sc. and D.Sc. degrees i n 1966
Committee Meeting, Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, May 1- and 1970 from the Universities
I
Authorized licensed use limited to: DELHI TECHNICAL UNIV. Downloaded on September 8, 2009 at 03:45 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.