Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Edited by
Ayman S. El-Baz
University of Louisville, Louisville, KY, United States; University of Louisville
at Alamein International University (UofL-AIU)
Jasjit S. Suri
ATHEROPOINT, Roseville, CA, United States
Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier
125 London Wall, London EC2Y 5AS, United Kingdom
525 B Street, Suite 1650, San Diego, CA 92101, United States
50 Hampshire Street, 5th Floor, Cambridge, MA 02139, United States
The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, United Kingdom
Copyright © 2023 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical,
including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the
publisher. Details on how to seek permission, further information about the Publisher’s permissions policies and our
arrangements with organizations such as the Copyright Clearance Center and the Copyright Licensing Agency, can be found
at our website: www.elsevier.com/permissions.
This book and the individual contributions contained in it are protected under copyright by the Publisher (other than as may
be noted herein).
MATLABs is a trademark of The MathWorks, Inc. and is used with permission. The MathWorks does not warrant the
accuracy of the text or exercises in this book. This book’s use or discussion of MATLABs software or related products
does not constitute endorsement or sponsorship by The MathWorks of a particular pedagogical approach or particular
use of the MATLABs software.
Notices
Knowledge and best practice in this field are constantly changing. As new research and experience broaden our
understanding, changes in research methods, professional practices, or medical treatment may become necessary.
Practitioners and researchers must always rely on their own experience and knowledge in evaluating and using any
information, methods, compounds, or experiments described herein. In using such information or methods they should be
mindful of their own safety and the safety of others, including parties for whom they have a professional responsibility.
To the fullest extent of the law, neither the Publisher nor the authors, contributors, or editors, assume any liability for any
injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or
operation of any methods, products, instructions, or ideas contained in the material herein.
ISBN: 978-0-12-824421-0
With love and affection to my mother and father, whose loving spirit sustains me still
Ayman El-Baz
vii
viii Contents
10.2.2 Face stimuli 220 12.3.1 Commonly used datasets for machine
10.2.3 Gaze-following stimuli 224 learning-based behavioral assessment of
10.3 Action behavior phenotype 228 autism spectrum disorder 258
10.3.1 Dataset and analysis 228 12.3.2 Dimensionality reduction 258
10.3.2 Methods and results 228 12.3.3 Commonly used dimensionality reduction
10.4 Drawing behavior phenotype 231 techniques 258
10.4.1 Dataset 231 12.3.4 Classification algorithms 259
10.4.2 Analysis 231 12.3.5 Model selection 260
10.4.3 Results and discussion 233 12.3.6 Confusion matrix 264
10.5 Discussion and conclusion 233 12.4 Conclusion 265
References 235 References 266
xiii
xiv List of contributors
xvii
This page intentionally left blank
Acknowledgments
The completion of this book could not have like to express their deep appreciation and
been possible without the participation and indebtedness particularly to Dr. Ali H.
assistance of so many people whose names Mahmoud and Ahmed Sharafeldeen for their
may not all be enumerated. Their contributions endless support.
are sincerely appreciated and gratefully Ayman S. El-Baz
acknowledged. However, the editors would Jasjit S. Suri
xix
This page intentionally left blank
P A R T 1
1
Remote telehealth assessments for autism
spectrum disorder
Angela V. Dahiya1, Jennifer R. Bertollo1, Christina G. McDonnell2
and Angela Scarpa1
1
Department of Psychology, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, United States 2Department of Psychology,
University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY, United States
1
Given recent literature and self-advocacy efforts voicing opposition to person-first language, the current chapter
frequently utilizes identity-first language instead, including using the term “autistic” rather than “individuals with ASD”
[83,84]. However, we recognize that this may not be the preference of every person in the autism community at this time.
years of age, but the median age of first diagno- policy mandates [12]. One common route of uni-
sis in the United States is 4 years and 3 months versal screening is to have primary care physi-
[4]. In addition to racial, ethnic, and sex and cians or staff administer an evidence-based
gender disparities in the timeliness of autism screening measure such as the Modified
identification (see [5], for review), children in Checklist for Autism in ToddlersRevised with
remote or rural communities, and those below Follow-up (discussed in more detail later in this
the poverty line, are diagnosed significantly chapter) during child well visits, in order to
later than those in urban or more affluent com- increase the chances of flagging children with
munities [6,7]. Barriers such as geographic isola- developmental, social, or communication con-
tion, financial instability, lack of local resources, cerns who may otherwise go unnoticed until
and more recently, the COVID-19 pandemic beginning preschool or Kindergarten. Once a
that requires physical distancing, are challenges screening instrument or qualified professional
that many remote communities continue to face (e.g., pediatrician) identifies characteristics sug-
[8,9]. Even poor urban communities face a simi- gesting increased likelihood of being on the
lar lack of ASD provider availability compared autism spectrum, the child is then referred for a
to wealthier communities [10], and all indivi- comprehensive diagnostic assessment.
duals may face uncontrollable circumstances Currently, standard face-to-face ASD diag-
that create access barriers regardless of locale nostic assessments consist of several hours of
(e.g., natural disasters, snowstorms, illness). As testing, including a developmental history
such, remote assessment opportunities for ASD interview with one or more caregivers (e.g.,
diagnosis widen our capacity to reach as many Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised, ADI-R;
people as possible when they are unable to [13]) and an observational behavioral assess-
come to a clinic in person or simply do not have ment with the individual suspected to meet cri-
access to experts in their community. teria for a diagnosis of ASD (e.g., Autism
Diagnostic Observation Schedule, 2nd Edition,
ADOS-2; [14]). At present, many experts con-
sider these two measures to comprise the
1.1.1 In-person standardized assessments
“gold standard” protocol for an ASD evalua-
for autism spectrum disorder tion and thus they are both widely used instru-
Prior to formal diagnostic assessment for ASD, ments. The ADI-R gathers necessary medical
screening methods are intended to “catch” char- and developmental information, while evaluat-
acteristics of ASD early in development and sub- ing social communication (e.g., stereotyped
sequently refer a child for a thorough diagnostic utterances, little use of nonverbal communica-
assessment if autistic features are present. The tion), reciprocal interaction and peer relation-
American Academy of Pediatrics recommends ships (e.g., limited response to others, lack of
universal autism screening for all children reciprocal conversation abilities), and RRBs
throughout infancy and toddlerhood; specifically, (e.g., presence of preoccupations, complex
they recommend all children be screened for body mannerisms, sensory interests). The
broad behavioral and developmental concerns at ADOS-2 uses specific interaction tasks to
9, 18, and 30 months, and specifically for ASD prompt for the aforementioned social commu-
using a standardized screening tool at 18- and nication differences and RRBs, which a trained
24-month well visits [11]. However, adoption of clinician facilitates, observes, and codes. In
these recommendations has been inconsistent, as addition to the ADI-R and the ADOS-2, an
not all governing organizations put forward the assessment battery often includes measures of
same screening recommendations and resulting cognitive and language abilities to further
Although the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted important to consider how such technologies can
in an unprecedented need to utilize remote assess- be leveraged to improve access to screening and
ment measures, many other circumstances can assessment practices. We now review the existing
create barriers to receiving in-person services for evidence for the use of telehealth-based technol-
families outside of the context of the current pan- ogy for facilitating autism diagnostic assessments,
demic. For example, individuals or families living including (1) live videoconferencing, (2) asyn-
in rural areas or who are otherwise geographically chronous video observations (i.e., nonlive obser-
isolated from major medical centers may not have vations of current behavior via video), (3)
the ability to travel to a clinic during normal busi- retrospective video analysis (i.e., nonlive observa-
ness hours without requesting a full day or more tion of past behavior), (4) mobile and web appli-
off from work, a loss of pay that may not be cations, and (5) online websites.
affordable to many. Rural areas also see a stark
paucity of resources and providers broadly, but
particularly those knowledgeable in ASD [9]. 1.2 Telehealth assessments
These barriers together result in a later average
age of diagnosis in rural areas compared to urban Several forms of technology can be used to
or suburban regions [26], which in turn lead to aid in the diagnostic assessment of ASD. Certain
delays in receiving desired supports and/or ser- aspects of in-person ASD assessment, such as
vices that support independence and quality of parent or caregiver interviews, can be translated
life for autistic individuals [6,7]. Additionally, most easily to remote conduct, as having a con-
caregivers may avoid scheduling services for versation by phone or video is nearly identical
themselves or their children if they have other to having the same conversation in-person.
children at home and cannot afford or find child- Further, it has been demonstrated that phone-
care, as there may not be room or resources for based screening methods for this population
those children at a typical provider’s office. can help categorize individuals who may be at
Further, several of these barriers such as low an increased likelihood of having developmen-
socioeconomic status, unmet childcare needs, and tal delays [28,29], prior to a more comprehen-
difficulty navigating service systems dispropor- sive diagnostic assessment. Additionally, more
tionately affect racial-ethnic minority families and peripheral aspects of comprehensive ASD
their children, who are significantly less likely assessments, such as cognitive and academic
than their white counterparts to have their autistic achievement testing via telehealth, have been
characteristics documented in a formal diagnosis demonstrated to be a valid means of assessing
[27]. In sum, the need to understand and utilize cognitive function without major shifts in scores
the most accessible methods of service delivery is during COVID-19 [30], although these measures
of the utmost importance well beyond this current are still understudied in minority populations to
time of crisis, and novel methods of assessment ensure their equitable use [21]. However, other
delivery are necessary in order to increase core aspects of the standard in-person assess-
equitable service access. ment of ASD, particularly the observation of
Remote telehealth assessment is one such solu- children or adults presenting with autistic fea-
tion that may help to expedite ASD screening tures, require more careful consideration and
and diagnosis in rural communities, where study through remote platforms. For example,
delays are too often the norm, but also in any because ASD is characterized by social and com-
under-resourced communities or otherwise hard- munication differences, individuals may have
to-reach and isolated populations [10]. In an seemingly improved communication abilities if
increasingly technologically driven world, it is observed with familiar family or caregivers in
suggesting that outcomes could be highly incon- screening to differentiate possible ASD-specific
sistent due to both the limited length of a submit- from non-ASD concerns [47].
ted video and the number of features that a rater Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Italian
is aiming to analyze during that short period of Ministry of Health’s “Early Bird Diagnostic
time. Protocol for Autism Spectrum Disorder” proj-
Chambers et al. [44] also explored the use of ect was underway to determine the best
video observations and diagnostic coding in a screening and diagnostic procedures by age for
nonEnglish speaking South African population those with suspected ASD. In response to the
with administration being conducted in their COVID-19 pandemic, Conti et al. [48] transi-
native language of isiZulu. These videos were tioned the study to enroll toddlers in their
collected by speech-language pathologists among remote surveillance protocol (RSP). Although
children at increased likelihood of an ASD diag- still under study to better understand the util-
nosis from 12 to 48 months of age in a natural ity of this protocol for detection and timely ini-
home environment, in addition to administering tiation of supports and services, the authors
other questionnaires including the Early describe their RSP procedures in their recent
Screening for Autism and Communication Disorder publication. The RSP begins with a brief
(ESAC; [85]) the Communication and Symbolic parent-child play interaction, which is video
Behavior Scales-Developmental Profile Behavior recorded and then discussed among the clini-
Sample (CSBS; [45]) and the Systematic cal team according to the items on the Toddler
Observation of Red Flags of ASD [46]. In terms of Module of the ADOS-2. Parents then partici-
the implementation of this observation, both the pate in three online interviews to assess their
United States and South African teams estab- child’s history and autistic traits, adaptive
lished 100% agreement among participants, skills, and social and emotional functioning.
improving the accessibility and adaptability of After all of this information is collected, the
this video-based method in a different language team makes a decision about whether to pro-
and/or country. vide feedback online to the parents about
Although video observations can be used diag- developmental concerns, or whether a “live”
nostically to assess for ASD, it is also feasible to face-to-face visit is necessary to complete the
observe videos as a screening tool. Considering evaluation before providing a diagnosis.
the importance of adapting these assessment
methods to diverse populations, the study con-
ducted by [86] is important to highlight, as this
1.2.3 Asynchronous video analysis:
research team applied the video observation
method to a sample of families of various socio-
retrospective
economic status and backgrounds. Children with Another form of technology that has long
suspected ASD or language delay (LD) were com- been used for identifying signs of ASD is anal-
pared to non-ASD or non-LD groups, and they ysis of prior video recordings. Frequently, ret-
were recorded during an ADOS-2 administration. rospective video analysis examines whether
Several standard autistic behaviors were specifi- children who are later diagnosed with ASD
cally coded: social skills, vocal sounds or expres- can be differentiated from other children in
sive language, play behaviors, and response to their early years of life. Much of the earliest lit-
name. Although the sensitivity rate for detecting erature on technological ASD identification uti-
ASD was relatively low (61%), the specificity of lizes family home videos to investigate signs of
ruling-out ASD was promising (82%). This find- ASD. The evidence gleaned from retrospective
ing suggests that this method can be effective for video analysis studies clearly establishes that
multiple choice questions to gather information delays after one trial. After three trials, autistic
from caregivers on social skills, communica- children and typically developing children’s
tion, and RRBs. This study found that this performance were significantly different.
mobile method had a sensitivity of 89.9% and However, 10 trials were necessary before autis-
specificity of 79.7% for future diagnosis of tic children and those with another develop-
ASD. Similarly, Maleka et al. [62] investigated mental delay could be differentiated, and they
a mobile application in South Africa, in which remained significantly different through 20
the mobile version of the Parents Evaluation of trials. While not a diagnostic tool in and of
Developmental Status (PEDS) tool had high itself, this application is a promising remotely
agreement with a pen-and-paper version when administered and parent-facilitated tool that
completed by community health workers. can aid in ASD screening and in providing
Finally, [87] created an online version of the more nuanced metrics of social and communi-
aforementioned model by [63]; the INvesT cation skills.
model in which researchers categorized the More recently, Egger et al. [64] examined a
likelihood of autism in 12- to 36-month-old smartphone application known as the ResearchKit
children based on caregiver reports of specific (https://www.researchandcare.org) to collect
developmental concerns. This tool was able to data on child emotions and ASD-related beha-
provide data on the likelihood of developmen- viors in a natural environment via the Autism &
tal delays, noting several children who Beyond study (https://autismandbeyond.research-
achieved high scores on the measure, which kit.duke.edu/study). This study allowed the app
accurately aligned with their diagnosis from an to be used with families at their home, specifically
in-person assessment. with children from 12 to 72 months of age. Not
An additional app has been piloted in chil- only does this app utilize a user-friendly platform,
dren 18 to 48 months of age, not to assess ASD but it also improves access to care for caregivers
more broadly, but specifically to measure a and children who face barriers to receiving
child’s response to their name, a skill that is ASD-specific assessment services. Further, the
often disrupted in young autistic children [88]. process of using the app includes clear steps to
In this study, parents would say their child’s provide consent, complete brief questionnaires,
name, video record their child’s response from and record their child as they interact with the sti-
their smartphone, and also indicate whether muli presented to them on the app. The involve-
they thought their child responded. The pur- ment of caregivers and other family members is
pose of developing this app was to address important, as the app is primarily collecting data
shortcomings of current ASD assessment mea- in the child’s natural home environment with
sures that either rely on parent/caregiver observations recorded via the app on the care-
report or require clinicians to make gross deci- giver’s personal device. Data collection for this
sions about a child’s response to name (i.e., study is now completed and analysis is underway
determining whether the child looks in in hopes that this will prove to be a feasible tool.
response to their name overall, when only We have previously discussed using video
given one or very few trials to observe this observations as a method of assessing the pres-
behavior), thereby under-appreciating the vari- ence of ASD, followed with a manual coding of
ability in children’s behavioral responses. To these videos. The ResearchKit app expands on
this end, Thomas and colleagues found no sig- this method by creating a tool developed for an
nificant differences in clinician-coded response iPad or tablet (with video recording capabilities)
to name between children with and without using an online version of the Modified Checklist
diagnoses of ASD or non-ASD developmental for Autism in Toddlers Revised with Follow-up
with neuroplasticity in the social brain [81]. As such, we urge future research to continue to
Other psychophyisological indices (i.e., heart evaluate the psychometric properties of these
rate variabililty) may offer similar uses as emerging methods, including establishing reli-
potential biomarkers and should continue to ability and validity of these methods using
be studied for their potential benefits in large and diverse sample sizes. Considering
screening and diagnosis [82]. the striking lack of research on the application
Although these technology-based tools have of these tools for older children, adolescents,
not been tested remotely, this research can and adults, research should specifically focus
point to potential methods of screening and on the validation of these tools across the
identification that may work in conjunction lifespan and in different demographics.
with clinical judgment skills to accurately Additionally, it is critical that future research
inform diagnostic decisions. continues to obtain key stakeholder feedback
on the use of these tools and methods, includ-
ing whether caregivers, families, and autistic
individuals themselves find this technology
1.3 Implications
easy to use and comfortable. Lastly, future
research needs to assess both the replicability
The current chapter provides a number of
of these results and the real-world utility of the
promising options for technology-based or
summarized technologies. For example, studies
telehealth remote assessments for ASD.
on the dissemination and implementation of
There are five broad types of technology that
these evaluation tools by community provi-
have been applied to the diagnosis of ASD,
ders, including the development of training
including (1) live video-conferencing, (2)
protocols for providers, would be particularly
asynchronous (nonlive) video analysis of
useful to ensure that they can be implemented
current behavior, (3) retrospective video
with fidelity and coded reliably outside of
analysis, (4) mobile and web applications,
structured research settings. In doing so, it will
and (5) online websites. With further
be vital to identify barriers to their use by com-
research to support the validity of these
munity providers and in underserved settings,
methods, these approaches have the exciting
and to adjust protocols and recommendations
potential to expand the reach of autism diag-
accordingly.
nostic services and thereby potentially
Ultimately, the long-term goal of this research
improve the recognition of autism in under-
area is to improve the reach of autism services
served communities and during the COVID-
through the application of novel technological
19 pandemic. As further advances are made
approaches like those reviewed in the current
in this field, researchers will be able to
chapter. The use of these technological
develop novel tools that can facilitate a
approaches has the potential to reduce clinician
streamlined screening and diagnostic assess-
bias and burden, decrease wait times, and over-
ment process.
come geographical barriers to accessing services,
thereby reducing inequities in the diagnostic pro-
cess. Thus, this research has important potential
1.3.1 Future directions for advancing basic scientific understanding of
First and foremost, the current state of the autism assessment, as well as mobilizing clinical
literature reveals promising but incomplete services and reducing diagnostic disparities for
findings regarding the validity and utility of families that heretofore remain underserved with
tele-assessment tools that span development. respect to autism needs.
References ,http://www.apa.org.ezproxy.lib.vt.edu/monitor/
2020/07/autism-screening..
[1] American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and [13] C. Lord, M. Rutter, A. Le Couteur, Autism diagnostic
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5s), interview-revised: a revised version of a diagnostic
American Psychiatric Pub, Washington, D.C, 2013. interview for caregivers of individuals with possible
[2] L. Zwaigenbaum, M.L. Bauman, R. Choueiri, C. Kasari, pervasive developmental disorders, Journal of Autism
A. Carter, D. Granpeesheh, et al., Early intervention for and Developmental Disorders 24 (5) (1994) 659685.
children with autism spectrum disorder under 3 years of [14] Lord, C., Rutter, M., DiLavore, P., Risi, S., Gotham, K.,
age: recommendations for practice and research, & Bishop, S. Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule,
Pediatrics 136 (Suppl 1) (2015) S60S81. Available from: Second ed., Western Psychological Corporation, Los
https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2014-3667E. Angeles, CA, 2012.
[3] L.R. Robinson, J.R. Holbrook, R.H. Bitsko, S.A. [15] M. Huerta, C. Lord, Diagnostic evaluation of autism
Hartwig, J.W. Kaminski, R.M. Ghandour, et al., spectrum disorders, Pediatric Clinics of North
Differences in health care, family, and community fac- America 59 (1) (2012) 103.
tors associated with mental, behavioral, and develop- [16] C.E. Rice, K.V. Naarden Braun, M.D. KoganCenters
mental disorders among children aged 28 years in for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), Screening
rural and urban areasUnited States, 20112012, for developmental delays among young
MMWR Surveillance Summaries 66 (8) (2017) 1. childrenNational Survey of Children’s Health,
[4] M.J. Maenner, K.A. Shaw, J. Baio, Prevalence of autism United States, 2007, MMWR Suppl 63 (2) (2014)
spectrum disorder among children aged 8 yearsaut- 2735.
ism and developmental disabilities monitoring net- [17] Campbell, J.M., & Scarpa, A. Psychotherapy for indivi-
work, 11 sites, United States, 2016, MMWR duals with developmental disabilities. In J.
Surveillance Summaries 69 (4) (2020) 1. Zimmerman, J. Barnett, L. Campbell (Eds.), Bringing
[5] K.P. Nowell, C.M. Brewton, E. Allain, S.S. Mire, The Psychotherapy to the Underserved, Oxford University
influence of demographic factors on the identification of Press, New York, 2020, pp. 281299.
autism spectrum disorder: a review and call for research, [18] Corona, L., Hine, J., Nicholson, A., Stone, C., Swanson,
Review Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders A., Wade, J. et al. TELE-ASD-PEDS: A Telemedicine-
2 (3) (2015) 300309. Based ASD Evaluation Tool for Toddlers and Young
[6] L. Antezana, A. Scarpa, A. Valdespino, J. Albright, J.A. Children. Vanderbilt University Medical Center, 2020.
Richey, Rural trends in diagnosis and services for autism [19] M.J. Sanchez, J.N. Constantino, Expediting clinician
spectrum disorder, Frontiers in Psychology 8 (2017) 590. assessment in the diagnosis of autism spectrum disor-
[7] R.A. Rhoades, A. Scarpa, B. Salley, The importance of der, Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology 62
physician knowledge of autism spectrum disorder: results (7) (2020) 806812.
of a parent survey, BMC Pediatrics 7 (1) (2007) 110. [20] J. Ashburner, S. Vickerstaff, J. Beetge, J. Copley,
[8] Y.M. Janvier, J.F. Harris, C.N. Coffield, B. Louis, M. Remote vs face-to-face delivery of early intervention
Xie, Z. Cidav, et al., Screening for autism spectrum programs for children with autism spectrum disor-
disorder in underserved communities: early childcare ders: perceptions of rural families and service provi-
providers as reporters, Autism 20 (3) (2016) 364373. ders, Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders 23
[9] A. Scarpa, L.S. Jensen, D. Gracanin, S.L. Ramey, A.V. (2016) 114.
Dahiya, L.M. Ingram, et al., Access to autism spectrum [21] R.L. Farmer, R.J. McGill, S.C. Dombrowski, M.B.
disorder services for rural Appalachian citizens, McClain, B. Harris, A.B. Lockwood, et al., Teleassessment
Journal of Appalachian Health 2 (1) (2020) 2540. with children and adolescents during the coronavirus
[10] A. Drahota, R. Sadler, C. Hippensteel, B. Ingersoll, L. (COVID- 19) pandemic and beyond: practice and policy
Bishop, Service deserts and service oases: Utilizing implications, Professional Psychology: Research and
geographic information systems to evaluate service Practice 51 (5) (2020) 477487. Available from: https://
availability for individuals with autism spectrum dis- doi.org/10.1037/pro0000349.
order, Autism 24 (8) (2020) 20082020. [22] J.H. Wright, R. Caudill, Remote treatment delivery in
[11] S.M. Myers, C.P. Johnson, Management of children response to the COVID-19 pandemic, Psychotherapy
with autism spectrum disorders, Pediatrics 120 (5) and Psychosomatics 89 (3) (2020) 1.
(2007) 11621182. Available from: https://doi.org/ [23] E. Gordon-Lipkin, J. Foster, G. Peacock, Whittling
10.1542/peds.2007-2362. down the wait time: exploring models to minimize the
[12] American Psychological Association. (2020). A push delay from initial concern to diagnosis and treatment
for universal screening. Monitor on Psychology, 51(5). of autism spectrum disorder, Pediatric Clinics of
North America 63 (5) (2016) 851859. Available from: functional extension of a digital tool for rapid assess-
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pcl.2016.06.007. ment of risk for autism spectrum disorders in toddlers
[24] H.M. Geurts, M.D. Jansen, A retrospective chart study: based on pilot test and interview data, International
the pathway to a diagnosis for adults referred for ASD Conference on Human-Computer Interaction,
assessment, Autism 16 (3) (2012) 299305. Available Springer, Cham, 2019, pp. 1322.
from: https://doi.org/10.1177/1362361311421775. [35] M. Alfuraydan, J. Croxall, L. Hurt, M. Kerr, S. Brophy,
[25] A. Estes, J. Munson, S.J. Rogers, J. Greenson, J. Winter, Use of telehealth for facilitating the diagnostic assess-
G. Dawson, Long-term outcomes of early intervention in ment of autism spectrum disorder (ASD): a scoping
6-year-old children with autism spectrum disorder, review, PloS One 15 (7) (2020) e0236415.
Journal of the American Academy of Child and [36] B. Parmanto, G. Pramana, D.X. Yu, A.D. Fairman, B.E.
Adolescent Psychiatry 54 (7) (2015) 580587. Available Dicianno, M.P. McCue, iMHere: A novel mHealth sys-
from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaac.2015.04.005. tem for supporting self-care in management of com-
[26] D.S. Mandell, M.M. Novak, C.D. Zubritsky, Factors plex and chronic conditions, JMIR mHealth and
associated with age of diagnosis among children with uHealth 1 (2) (2013) e10.
autism spectrum disorders, Pediatrics 116 (6) (2005) [37] J.L. Schutte, M.P. McCue, B. Parmanto, J. McGonigle, B.
14801486. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1542/ Handen, A. Lewis, et al., Usability and reliability of a
peds.2005-0185. remotely administered adult autism assessment, the
[27] D.S. Mandell, L.D. Wiggins, L.A. Carpenter, J. Daniels, autism diagnostic observation schedule (ADOS) module
C. DiGuiseppi, M.S. Durkin, et al., Racial/ethnic dis- 4, Telemedicine and e-Health 21 (3) (2015) 176184.
parities in the identification of children with autism [38] C. Lord, A. Holbrook, D. Dow, K. Byrne, R.
spectrum disorders, American Journal of Public Grzadzinski, K. Sterrett, et al., Brief Observation of
Health 99 (3) (2009) 493498. Available from: https:// Symptoms of Autism, Western Psychological Services,
doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2007.131243. Torrance, CA, 2020.
[28] S.L. Bishop, C. Farmer, V. Bal, E.B. Robinson, A.J. [39] S.H. Kim, C. Lord, Combining information from mul-
Willsey, D.M. Werling, et al., Identification of develop- tiple sources for the diagnosis of autism spectrum dis-
mental and behavioral markers associated with genetic orders for toddlers and young preschoolers from 12 to
abnormalities in autism spectrum disorder, American 47 months of age, Journal of Child Psychology and
Journal of Psychiatry 174 (6) (2017) 576585. Psychiatry 53 (2) (2012) 143151.
[29] B.B. Nelson, L.R. Thompson, P. Herrera, C. Biely, D.A. [40] S. Risi, C. Lord, K. Gotham, C. Corsello, C. Chrysler,
Zarate, I. Aceves, et al., Telephone-based developmental P. Szatmari, et al., Combining information from multi-
screening and care coordination through 2-1-1: a random- ple sources in the diagnosis of autism spectrum disor-
ized trial, Pediatrics 143 (4) (2019) e20181064. Available ders, Journal of the American Academy of Child &
from: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2018-1064. Adolescent Psychiatry 45 (9) (2006) 10941103.
[30] Raiford, S.E., Breaux, K., Chen, S., & Matta, T. "COVID [41] C.J. Smith, A. Rozga, N. Matthews, R. Oberleitner, N.
Slide" not evident in individually administered clinical Nazneen, G. Abowd, Investigating the accuracy of a
test scores obtained from a large, referred sample, novel telehealth diagnostic approach for autism spectrum
NCS Pearson, 2021. disorder, Psychological Assessment 29 (3) (2017) 245.
[31] A.V. Dahiya, E. DeLucia, C.G. McDonnell, A. Scarpa, [42] Q. Tariq, J. Daniels, J.N. Schwartz, P. Washington, H.
A systematic review of technological approaches for Kalantarian, D.P. Wall, Mobile detection of autism
autism spectrum disorder assessment in children: through machine learning on home video: a develop-
implications for the COVID-19 pandemic, Research in ment and prospective validation study, PLoS
Developmental Disabilities 109 (2021) 103852. Medicine 15 (11) (2018) e1002705.
[32] A.V. Dahiya, C. McDonnell, E. DeLucia, A. Scarpa, A [43] Q. Tariq, S.L. Fleming, J.N. Schwartz, K. Dunlap, C.
systematic review of remote telehealth assessments for Corbin, P. Washington, et al., Detecting developmen-
early signs of autism spectrum disorder: video and tal delay and autism through machine learning mod-
mobile applications, Practice Innovations 5 (2) (2020) 150. els using home videos of bangladeshi children:
[33] L.L. Corona, A.S. Weitlauf, J. Hine, A. Berman, A. development and validation study, Journal of Medical
Miceli, A. Nicholson, et al., Parent perceptions of Internet Research 21 (4) (2019) e13822.
caregiver-mediated telemedicine tools for assessing [44] N.J. Chambers, A.M. Wetherby, S.T. Stronach, N.
autism risk in toddlers, Journal of Autism and Njongwe, S. Kauchali, R.R. Grinker, Early detection of
Developmental Disorders 51 (2020) 476486. autism spectrum disorder in young isiZulu-speaking
[34] D. Adiani, M. Schmidt, J. Wade, A.R. Swanson, A. children in South Africa, Autism 21 (5) (2017)
Weitlauf, Z. Warren, et al., Usability enhancement and 518526.
captures atypical attention in toddlers with autism, insights from behavioral and electrophysiological
Autism 23 (3) (2019) 619628. studies, Developmental Neuropsychology 27 (3) (2005)
[68] J. Barbaro, M. Yaari, Study protocol for an evaluation of 403424.
ASDetect-a Mobile application for the early detection of [80] S.J. Webb, E.J. Jones, K. Merkle, M. Murias, J.
autism, BMC Pediatrics 20 (1) (2020) 21. Available from: Greenson, T. Richards, et al., Response to familiar
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12887-019-1888-6. faces, newly familiar faces, and novel faces as assessed
[69] J. Barbaro, C. Dissanayake, Prospective identification of by ERPs is intact in adults with autism spectrum dis-
autism spectrum disorders in infancy and toddlerhood orders, International Journal of Psychophysiology 77
using developmental surveillance: the social attention (2) (2010) 106117.
and communication study, Journal of Developmental & [81] S. Bölte, A. Ciaramidaro, S. Schlitt, D. Hainz, D.
Behavioral Pediatrics 31 (5) (2010) 376385. Kliemann, A. Beyer, et al., Training-induced plasticity
[70] J. Barbaro, C. Dissanayake, Early markers of autism of the social brain in autism spectrum disorder, The
spectrum disorders in infants and toddlers prospec- British Journal of Psychiatry 207 (2) (2015) 149157.
tively identified in the social attention and communi- [82] M.A. Patriquin, E. Hartwig, B.H. Friedman, S.W. Porges,
cation study, Autism 17 (1) (2013) 6486. A. Scarpa, Autonomic response in autism spectrum dis-
[71] A. Ben-Sasson, D.L. Robins, E. Yom-Tov, Risk assess- order: relationship to social and cognitive functioning,
ment for parents who suspect their child has autism Biological Psychology 145 (2019) 185197. Available
spectrum disorder: machine learning approach, Journal from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biopsycho.2019.05.004.
of Medical Internet Research 20 (4) (2018) e134. [83] P. Bradshaw, C. Pickett, M.L. van Driel, K. Brooker, A.
Available from: https://doi.org/10.2196/jmir.9496. Urbanowicz, “Autisitc” or “with autism” Why the
[72] L.E. Achenie, A. Scarpa, R.S. Factor, T. Wang, D.L. way general practitioners view and talk about autism
Robins, D.S. McCrickard, A machine learning strategy for matters, Australian Journal of General Practice 50 (3)
autism screening in toddlers, Journal of Developmental (2021) 104108. Available from: https://doi.org/
and Behavioral Pediatrics 40 (5) (2019) 369. 10.31128/AJGP-11-20-5721.
[73] A.M. Gadomski, M.R. Riley, M. Scribani, N. Tallman, [84] L. Kenny, C. Hattersley, B. Molins, C. Buckley, C.
Impact of “Learn the signs. Act early.” Materials on Povey, E. Pellicano, Which terms should be used to
parental engagement and doctor interaction regarding describe autism? Perspectives from the UK autism
child development, Journal of Developmental & community, . Autism 20 (4) (2016) 442462. Available
Behavioral Pediatrics 39 (9) (2018) 693700. from: https://doi.org/10.1177/1362361315588200.
[74] L.G. Klinger, G. Dawson, K. Barnes, M. Crisler, [85] A. Wetherby, C. Lord, J. Woods, W. Guthrie, K. Pierce,
Autism spectrum disorder, in: E.J. Mash, R.A. Barkley S. Shumway, et al., The Early Screening for Autism
(Eds.), Child Psychopathology, Guilford Publications, and Communication Disorders (ESAC): Preliminary
New York, 2014. field-testing of an autism-specific screening tool for
[75] T.W. Frazier, E.W. Kiingemler, M. Beukemann, L. children 12 to 36 months of age. Paper presented at
Speer, L. Markowitz, S. Parikh, et al., Development of the International Meeting for Autism Research
an objective autism risk index using remote eye track- (IMFAR), (2009) Chicago, IL, USA.
ing, Journal of American Academic Child and [86] T.P. Gabrielsen, M. Farley, L. Speer, M. Villalobos, C.
Adolescent Psychiatry 55 (2015) 301309. Available N. Baker, J. Miller, Identifying autism in a brief obser-
from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaac.2016.01.011. vation, Pediatrics 135 (2) (2015) e330e338. Available
[76] M. Gluckman, S.P. Johnson, Attentional capture by from: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2014-1428.
social stimuli in young infants, Frontiers in [87] R. Obeid, L. Beekman, N. Roizen, A. Ciccia, E.J. Short,
Psychology 4 (2013) 17. Available from: https://doi. Using telehealth to address disparities in cognitive,
org/10.3389/fpsyg.2013.00527. language, and emotion regulation problems in young
[77] W. Jones, A. Klin, Attention to eyes is present but in children: a case illustration using the INvesT model,
decline in 26-month-old infants later diagnosed with Birth Defects Research 111 (2019) 11541164.
autism, Nature 504 (7480) (2013) 427431. [88] R.P. Thomas, W. Guthrie, L.A. Wang, J. Miller, W.
[78] S.J. Webb, G. Dawson, R. Bernier, H. Panagiotides, Struebing, J. Pennington, et al., Diminished rate of
ERP evidence of atypical face processing in young response to name in Autism spectrum disorder: using
children with autism, Journal of Autism and a smartphone application to provide a quantitative
Developmental Disorders 36 (7) (2006) 881. measure of behavior. Oral presentation presented at
[79] G. Dawson, S.J. Webb, J. McPartland, Understanding the International Society for Autism Research (INSAR)
the nature of face processing impairment in autism: annual meeting, (2018) Rotterdam, Netherlands.
2
Maternal immune dysregulation and
autism spectrum disorder
Alexandra Ramirez-Celis, Danielle (Hyun Jung) Kim and
Judy Van de Water
Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Rheumatology, Allergy, and Clinical Immunology,
University of California, Davis, CA, United States
developing baby. Several groups have reported the resulting immune response by targeting
that both skewed cytokine profiles and the pres- various types of immune cells and tissues [11].
ence of maternal autoantibodies that react to pro- Ultimately, they are the master regulators of
teins in the developing brain during pregnancy the immune system, and some classes of cyto-
have a strong association with ASD risk [13,14]. kines include interleukins (IL), chemokines,
These findings are strongly supported by animal lymphokines, hematopoietins, interferons, as
models (reviewed in [1316]). In this chapter, we well as other families such as platelet-derived
review experimental and epidemiological studies growth factor (PDGF), transforming growth
that support the role of maternal immune dysregu- factor (GF), and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)
lation as a risk factor for an ASD outcome. In the families, all of which are produced throughout
first section, the implication of cytokines as media- the body [17]. The cytokines produced by these
tors of ASD is discussed, and in the second part, cells generally act locally, where the cells or
the pathogenic role of maternal antibrain autoanti- tissues that produce them can act back upon
bodies and the potential for their application as themselves (autocrine), adjacent cells (para-
biomarkers of ASD risk are discussed (Fig. 2.1). crine), or can affect cells at a distance (endo-
crine) [18]. Thus, whether the cytokines are
2.2 Cytokines and chemokines acting directly or indirectly, they induce a
(overview) cascade of other signaling pathways to
induce cell differentiation and proliferation,
Cytokines are small cell-signaling proteins or they further up- or down-regulate the
that modulate cellcell communication and immune response.
FIGURE 2.1 Summary of genetic and environmental factors that can impact brain development and are associated
with ASD risk. Autism etiology is a combination of genetic predisposition due to different genetic mutations and exposure
to environmental insults during gestation and the perinatal period that include: pollution, medications, and toxins. Also,
maternal immune dysregulation/ activation, autoimmunity, infection, gut dysbiosis, and gonadal hormones can impact
neurodevelopment and are risk factors for autism.
activity is dependent on the cytokine/chemokine circuits in the brain, leading to changes in motor
environment that works in a paracrine fashion activity and speech as well as other neuropatholo-
with adjacent cells. For example, microglia enter a gies associated with neuropsychiatric and neuro-
pro-inflammatory state during neuroinflammation developmental disorders [26,29].
and then gradually switch their state into an anti- In vitro studies have shown that the cytokines
inflammatory one. This is induced by the cytokine TNF-α and IL-1 can increase the expression and
environment with help from adjacent cells to initi- the activity of serotonin transport in a dose- and
ate the repair process [23]. For example, astrocytes time-dependent manner [30,31], which is relevant
are activated by certain cytokines and chemo- because of their role in mood regulation. In rodent
kines, and they secrete growth factors to coordi- hippocampal cultures and slices, TNF-α produced
nate neuronglia communication and support by astrocytes enhanced synaptic efficacy by
neuroprotection [24]. Myelination via oligoden- increasing the number of AMPA receptors [26].
drocytes depends on cytokine signals for differen- The correlation between TNF-α and AMPA
tiation and proliferation [25]. Therefore, although receptor number was demonstrated when AMPA
not limited to microglia, changes in brain cell expression and synaptic strength were reduced
function due to alterations in the cytokine/chemo- upon blocking TNF-α signaling via the TNF solu-
kine environment can be detrimental to brain ble receptors [32]. TNF-α can also increase neural
development and contribute to neuropathology stem cell proliferation without affecting differenti-
and changes in brain function. ation [26]. IL-1 production is associated with
Immune responses and interactions between stress and cognition, and impaired production of
cells in the CNS frequently involve neurotransmit- IL-1 can lead to deficits in memory [33]. The effect
ters such as glutamate and monoamines, and hor- of IL-1 on memory appears to be coupled with
mones such as glucocorticoids, prostaglandins, reduced corticosterone secretion [34], and the pro-
and neutrophins [26,27]. Neurotransmitters not duction of IL-1 can regulate neuronal-derived fac-
only influence the state of neurons, but also influ- tors such as GABA, CD200, and fractalkine [27].
ence the production of inflammation-related IGF-1 and other trophic factors are induced upon
molecules induced by the activation of monoam- activation of endothelial cells via IL-1 [27].
inergic receptors expressed by microglia and
astrocytes [27]. Immune cells in the periphery can 2.2.2.2 Immune mediators and brain
express receptors for neuropeptides and hor- development
mones, as well as receptors for serotonin and In the fetal brain, various developmental
dopamine [27,28]. Neurotransmitters are impor- events occur throughout gestation. Neural
tant in remodeling neural circuits, which is essen- stem cells proliferate and differentiate during
tial for neurogenesis and memory consolidation embryogenesis into mature neurons and other
[26]. In some cases, injury, infection, or chronic nervous system tissues, leading to the forma-
stress can elicit a robust immune response, caus- tion of the CNS. Axonal growth occurs when
ing morphological and physiological changes in axons navigate the embryonic brain and find
brain cells to secrete high amounts of cytokines, their appropriate synaptic partners to form
chemokines, and prostaglandins [26]. Thus, dis- neural interconnectivity [35]. The assembly of
ruption of the immune-dependent homeostasis neuronal circuits along with spatial formation
might result in detrimental effects on neural plas- also takes place during this time [36].
ticity, neurogenesis, and memory. In particular, Synaptogenesis is the process in which neuro-
neuronal hyper-excitability, adrenocortical stimu- transmitters are released to establish pre- and
lation, reduction of neurotrophins, and other post-synaptic terminals to form neural circuits
plasticity-related molecules can accelerate neural and ultimately complex neural networks [37].
"Hän hourailee."
"Ei, viime yönä ensi kerran, mutta nyt paljon kamalammin kuin
silloin."
"Kuinka on, veli, onko sinusta tullut käytöllinen mies?" kysyi sairas
äkisti ja katsoi minuun niin selvästi ja ajattelevasti, että minä
tahtomattani säpsähdin ja yritin vastaamaan hänelle, mutta hän
jatkoi heti: "Minä, ystäväni, en ole tullut käytölliseksi mieheksi…
Minkäpä sille voi? Minä olen syntynyt haaveksijaksi…
Haaveksiminen, mielikuvitus… Mitä on mielikuvitus? Sohakevitsin
talonpoika [eräs henkilö Gogolin romaanissa: 'Kuolleet sielut'], se on
mielikuvitus… Voi voi!"
Me istuuduimme.
"Entä vanhempanne?"
"Äitini on kuollut, mutta isäni elää yhä vielä Pietarissa. Veljelläni on
paikka virastossa, ja Vanja asuu heidän tykönänsä."
"Ja puolisonne?"
"Eikö ole reipas pikku tyttö minulla?" jatkoi Sofia Nikolajevna. "Hän
ei pelkää mitään, ja hyvin sukkela hän on lukemaan, saatan minä
sanoa hänen kiitokseksensa."
"Mitä, lapseni?"
"Ei, ei mitään, minä sanon sitte perästä päin."
"Hän on kuollut."
"Olenko minä nähnyt häntä, äiti?" kysyi pikku tyttö hiljaa kuiskaten.
"Ei, et ole, Lydia. Ah, mikä vahinko", kertoi Sofia Nikolajevna vielä
kerran.
"Niin, sellainen hän oli", lausuin viimeksi, "se mies, joka nyt on
mennyt pois ilman kiitosta, huomiota ja ihmisten hyväksymistä! Ja
ehkäpä ei maksa vaivaakaan valitella tuota puutetta. Sillä mitäpä
merkitsee ihmisten kiitos? Mutta minusta tuntuu tuskalliselta, jopa
loukkaavaltakin, että sellaisen miehen, jolla on sydän niin täynnä
rakkautta ja hellyyttä, piti kuolla, saamatta kertaakaan maistaa
vastarakkauden autuutta, voimatta herättää hellää myötätuntoisuutta
yhdenkään naisen sydämmessä, joka olisi ollut kyllin arvokas
hänelle. Olkoonpa niinkin, että mies sellainen, kuin me muut, ei
myöskään saa maistaa tätä autuutta, hän ei sitä ansaitsekaan, mutta
Pasinkov! Ja enkö minä ole elämässäni tavannut monta sataa
miestä, joita ei käy millään tavalla verrata häneen, mutta joita
kuitenkin nuoret, jalot naiset ovat rakastaneet! Täytyykö viimeinkin
uskoa, että muutamia vikoja, esimerkiksi itserakkautta tai
kevytmielisyyttä, täytyy välttämättä olla miehessä, ennenkuin nainen
voi kiinnittää sydämmensä häneen? Taikka pelkääkö rakkaus
täydellisyyttä, minä tarkoitan: inhimillistä, täällä maan päällä
mahdollista täydellisyyttä, katsooko se sitä vieraaksi ja
vaaralliseksi?"
"Sentähden, että minä sen tiedän, että minä tiedän sen ihan
varmaan."
Sofia Nikolajevna aikoi sanoa jotakin, mutta pysyi vaiti. Hän näytti
taistelevan sisällistä taistelua itsensä kanssa.
"Hän juuri."
"Ei, ei mitään."
"Vai niin, no, sitte ei ole muuta tällä kertaa; saat mennä nyt."
"Mikä tyttö?"
"Kyllä hän piti hänestä aina. Ja tyttö, niin, kun hän sai tietää, että
herra oli kuollut, oli hän joutua surusta aivan mielettömäksi. Muuten
ei ole mitään sanottavaa hänestä. Hyvä ja kelpo tyttö hän on."
"On."
"Sen hän kirjoitti minulle", sanoi hän "kun hän vielä oli
Novgorodissa ja ryhtyi opettamaan minua lukemaan ja kirjoittamaan.
Katsokaa toisiakin kirjeitä. On siellä niitä Siperiastakin. Olkaa hyvä ja
lukekaa ne."
Minä luin kaikki kirjeet. Ne olivat kaikki kirjoitetut hyvin
ystävällisesti, jopa hellästikin. Ensimmäisessä Siperiasta lähetetyssä
kirjeessä nimitti Pasinkov Mariaa paraaksi ystäväkseen, lupasi
lähettää hänelle rahaa Siperian matkaa varten ja lopussa olivat
seuraavat rivit:
"Kyliä näen, että hän oli hyvin rakastunut teihin", sanoin minä
antaessani tytölle kirjeet takaisin.
"Niin, kyllä hän piti paljon minusta", vastasi Maria kainosti ja kätki
kirjeet huolellisesti taskuunsa, kyynelien sill'aikaa hiljaa juostessa
pitkin hänen poskiansa. "Minä luotin aina häneen. Jos Jumala olisi
antanut hänen elää, hän ei suinkaan olisi hyljännyt minua. Antakoon
Jumala hänelle ijankaikkisen autuuden taivaan valtakunnassa."
Maria huokasi.