Professional Documents
Culture Documents
All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means,
including photocopying, recording or by any information retrieval and storage system without permission of the author. Likenesses of
characters to anyone living or dead is strictly a coincidence.
ISBN- 9798201977252
Contact Information:
sandrasookoo@yahoo.com
newindependencebooks@gmail.com
Visit me at www.sandrasookoo.com
Publishing History:
First Digital Edition, 2022
Contents
Dear Readers,
Dedication
Acknowledgement
Blurb
Chapter One
Chapter Two
Chapter Three
Chapter Four
Chapter Five
Chapter Six
Chapter Seven
Chapter Eight
Chapter Nine
Chapter Ten
Chapter Eleven
Chapter Twelve
Chapter Thirteen
Chapter Fourteen
Chapter Fifteen
Chapter Sixteen
Epilogue
Regency-era romances by Sandra Sookoo
Author Bio
Stay in Touch
Dear Readers,
Ever since I began my writing career back in 2008, crafting Christmas romances has been a fun little
hobby. Now, readers love my holiday romances so much they expect at least two every year. I’m
happy to provide them and more than one close friend/reader has dubbed me the “Queen of Christmas
romances.” I don’t know if that’s true, but I certainly love them. My favorite trope for these is the
second chance romance, which is what The Most Wonderful Earl of Year is.
I hope you enjoy this couple. They were interesting to write and very entertaining. Also, it wouldn’t
be a Christmas romance if I didn’t throw in a couple of tear-jerking scenes.
Happy reading!
Sandra
Dedication
To Jeff Salter. Thanks for the support over the years and for enjoying my stories. Best wishes in your
future endeavors.
Acknowledgement
It's always fun to "poll the audience" when writing a book to get a general feel of what readers like and to also make them a part of the
book's creation.
Thanks to the following friends on Facebook for answering the question of what a man would leave a woman at the altar:
Belinda Wiley Wilson
Ilene Bieleski
Sandie Liu Morehead
Donna Antonio
Jeff Salter
Debbie Kummoung
Kelly Price
Penny Elliott
Sandra F. Schehl
Amelia Hester
Donna Acosta
Tiffany Tinney Dwibhashyam
Gloria E. Trinidad-Tellez
Melanie Bryson Purcell
Robyn Porter
Eliza Lloyd
Dawn Roberto
Jen Bergmann
Gina Griffin Johnson
Sharon Villone Doucett
Kat Tolle
Mari Peterson
Patricia Way
AnnMarie Spiby
Cindy Bartolotta
Melissa MacKinnon
Carrie Burke
Jena Lang
Paula Shene
Meghan Lyndsey Ann Edwards
Roslynn Ernst
Lynne Connolly
Angie Eads
Linda J. Rahrig Burkhalter
Tana Hillman
Margaret Murray-Evans
Deanna Dent
Marina Bauman Leonard
Michelle Fidler
Roni Denholtz
Lori Cooper Lewis
Christie Kelley
And thank you to the following Facebook friends for spit balling fun Christmas activities:
Alison Pridie
Jessica Downing
Rachel E. Moniz
Morgan James
Jennifer Morin
Dorothy Callahan
Meghan Lyndsey Ann Edwards
Donna Antonio
Diana Lloyd
Marina Bauman Leonard
Marilyn Parry
Melanie Bryson Purcell
Judy Johnsen
Blurb
Love at Christmastide is wonderful… if the couple in question believes in the magic.
Alistair Forsythe, the 12th Earl of Reardon, is the most sought-after man in the ton this Christmastide season. Handsome, of good
character, and possessing a large fortune, he finally intends to do his duty to his title after being in India for years. In the market for a
wife, he can now easily have his pick of any woman, yet none of them have snared his interest—not since Carole—but she is beyond his
reach.
Miss Carole Hazelton doesn’t give two farthings about a man’s position within the ton or his looks. In fact, she’s not thought about the
beau monde since that horribly embarrassing day five years ago when Alistair left her standing alone at the altar. Now making her living
as a governess, she’s both dismayed and furious to discover the neighbor who’s returned to the townhouse next door is the man who’d
jilted her—Alistair.
As that old scandal recirculates, it throws their reputations into question. To repair the damage, the earl and Carole must practice
forgiveness. While she’s not quick to forget, he’s not above employing charm and mistletoe to his advantage or drawing on their past
romance, but when the feelings they both thought long dead come rushing back, that love just might ruin them both… or provide a second
chance they never knew they needed.
Chapter One
Present day
“Reardon?” The sound of fingers being snapped in front of his face wrenched him out of his
thoughts. Alistair blinked at his friend, who’d obviously returned from his errand. A bottle of brandy
was in one hand while a plate full of sweet edibles was in the other. “Woolgathering?”
“Perhaps. Mostly thinking about the day I left Carole at the altar without a word.” It had been
tantamount to an unforgivable sin and beyond the manners of a gentleman, but looking back, he
wouldn’t have changed a thing.
Not even for their reputations.
“Ah yes and created the scandal of the Season that year.” Jonathan pressed the brandy bottle
into his hand. “Here. Drink. I’ll procure glasses.” After leaving the plate of sweets on the small
ivory-inlaid table between their two chairs, he went to the sideboard. “Thank goodness society
doesn’t judge men by the same yardstick they do women.”
“Indeed.” Though heat went up the back of his neck all the same. Society favored men, and
titled men all the more, while they stacked every minute scandal upon women’s heads like burning
coals. “It is my fondest hope our paths don’t cross.”
When he’d arrived in Bombay all those years ago, the reunion between him and his father had
been awkward at best. Knowing there had been a secret in the family of such magnitude didn’t lend
itself well to congenial celebration. Of course, he’d questioned his father about the existence of an
older twin. He and his brother had apparently been parted when they were but a year old, and since
the bulk of their lives since birth had been spent on their father’s country estate, the rumors and gossip
was kept between the servants. If anyone else had known there’d been two sons of the Earl of
Reardon, it was hushed up quickly out of necessity and apparent embarrassment on his father’s part.
Not that such a conversation was any better when Alistair had arrived in India, for his father
had been beaten within an inch of his life from what he could only assume were the people who’d
kidnapped said brother. His father remained tight-lipped about that too.
Damn the man’s pride.
But the reasons for any of it were never discussed, and even now Alistair wasn’t certain what
had caused the rift between his parents after that day or why his father had been all too distant in
being a true father to him or what had happened to land his father into the sick bed.
“Here.” Jonathan shoved a cut crystal glass into his free hand. “Pour,” he ordered as he
dropped into the chair beside him. “You look like you need the fortification.”
Alistair blew out a breath. “Perhaps I do. I am feeling uneasy being back in London after all
this time.” He uncorked the bottle with his teeth, and then after spitting out the cork, he poured a
measure of the amber liquid into his glass. After doing the same with his friend’s matching glass, he
rested the bottle on the table. “Here’s to a better future.”
“So says the man who made a fortune and then some while we were gone,” Jonathan grumbled
and followed it up with a hearty sip of brandy.
He snorted. “As if you didn’t do the same.” They had both been lucky. Exporting tea and
various spices on a smaller scale than the enormous shipping outfits owned by the Crown, they had
been able to undercut their competitors and gain customers hand over fist.
Would my father have been proud had he liked me better than my twin?
There was no way to know. When Alistair had gone to India, he’d been immediately caught up
in his father’s work to retrieve his brother—who he was never able to meet—for by the time he and
the viscount had finally ferreted out the names and locations of the kidnappers—most of whom had
either left the area or had died—when his search party arrived, it was to find his brother not only
dead, but had apparently been that way for more than a few years. The only thing left had been a
desiccated corpse in a cave in the hills. Jewelry, various travel papers, and clothing on the bones all
pointed to a correct identification.
Once he came back to the fort where his father had been staying, Alistair had been forced to
tell him the unsavory news. Not only had he been paying blackmail coin, but the victim had perished
before the earl had set out for India.
After that, his father had taken a marked turn for the worse. In a matter of days, it seemed as if
the man had given up his will to live. Had the death of his firstborn son meant so much even though
he’d not seen the child since the first year of his life? Did it not matter about the other twin—him?
Those suppositions had caused more friction between Alistair and his father, and two days later,
leaving more questions than answers, his father had died, giving him the title he had always thought
would eventually be his anyway.
Now chance and fate had aligned, but it wasn’t the joyful occasion he’d once thought it might
be. Five years ago, he’d lost both his father and a brother that he’d never known existed. It still
haunted him to this day.
Thanks to Jonathan’s steadying presence, he remained in Bombay to settle his father’s estate
there, then they found the life so pleasing they’d made a living for years and filled both their coffers.
During that time, he’d been forced to forget about Carole and the romance they’d once had, for she
was better off without him, and the scandal connected to his family name, especially since it remained
shrouded in secrets.
She deserved better five years ago. That hadn’t changed.
“What the hell, Reardon?” The viscount poked him in the shoulder. “You once more popped
back into your thoughts while I am trying to tell you which women are the choicest morsels of the
holiday social scene.”
Right. The reason he had returned to London. He needed to start his life over yet again. With a
sigh, Alistair nodded. Tossing back the remainder of the brandy in his glass, he lifted an eyebrow. “I
suppose you have listed them into categories?”
“Of course I have.” Mischief twinkled in his eyes. “Looks. Worth. Connections. And how
well she kisses.”
“I see.” Damn, but one of the things he had adored about Carole was how she’d kissed him.
Almost as if each meeting of their lips had been a sacred covenant. But those days had passed. “How
long is your list?”
Jonathan shrugged. “Five ladies. Two of whom are society’s darlings this year.”
“Ugh.” At seven and thirty, he surely wasn’t in the mood to court a debutante. “I would rather
not align myself with a young lady just making her Come Out.”
“Then we shall concentrate on the other three.” His friend poured another measure of brandy
into his glass and then did the same for Alistair. “And whichever of the ladies you don’t pick, I shall
choose one for myself.”
“May fate grant us good fortune.” He put his drink aloft in silent salute. “I would like to hope
this Christmastide will usher in the lives we are finally mature enough to have.”
“Here, here!” Jonathan took a sip. “And here’s to firmly keeping the past in the past. I’m sure
Carole has moved on from you and is quite content in her life.”
“Here, here.” Though he echoed his friend’s sentiments, the unease of earlier hadn’t
dissipated. Knowing Carole was next door would make him self-conscious and forever remind him of
his greatest embarrassment.
Please let us not see each other in passing. Some wounds don’t need reexamined.
Chapter Two
Present day
A strangle of giggles erupted from the corridor beyond and pulled her from her tortured
thoughts, belonging to the seven-year-old twins who were her charges. A boy and a girl—William
and Mary—they were a handful as soon as they woke in the morning, named after their father and
mother respectively and not the historical figures. No doubt they were on their way to luncheon—
albeit late—but she wouldn’t begrudge them the time. They were children, after all, and if their
mother wished to be in their company even though it upset the schedule Carole had laid down for
them, who was she to complain?
Constantly she had to remind herself she was merely the help—not exactly part of the servants
but not good enough to mingle with the Quality—and her opinions should be kept to herself.
As she continued to watch the ever-changing traffic on the streets below, her thoughts once
more turned inward.
Following the death of her father and once the family had emerged from their year of
mourning, the Hazelton’s required an income to keep the house running and to pay the handful of
servants still employed. Carole took a position of governess which let her remain in Kent to be near
her mother and sister, but as time went on, the two children grew and no longer needed her care.
Facing another financial crisis—and since her sister might still have a chance to make a good match if
they were very careful—once more it was up to Carole to save them.
She’d applied for another position, and this one was in London with Lord Collingsworth, and
that had proved to be a turning point in her life. Since the old scandal surrounding her name had been
five years before, she’d felt confident enough it had blown over and everyone had forgotten her in the
face of other more scandalous on-dits. To her delight, the viscount and viscountess had found her
acceptable in face, form, and abilities, and they had offered her the position on the spot.
Every day she woke, Carole would always remain grateful to them for giving her a chance. As
long as she didn’t flaunt herself in society, no one would have cause to remember what had happened
five years ago. Everything would be fine. She would have her position and the comfort of watching
her charges grow into functioning—and hopefully kind—members of society. The best she could hope
for personally was to get on with a decent gentleman, perhaps a military man or a merchant, and have
a modest life. If she were truly fortunate, she might have children of her own. As of yet, none of that
had happened, for being a governess meant she wasn’t able to circulate through society as she used to,
but that was to be expected for someone in her reduced circumstance.
Not that it was a terrible life. She enjoyed the work, and she’d become invested in her
charges’ growth and upbringing. It was interesting to fill in at various dinners the viscountess threw if
numbers needed to be made up.
Above and beyond all of that, her heart was still broken. It didn’t matter that so much time had
passed between now and when her engagement had fallen apart, she suspected those feelings would
never quite fade. Never would she fully trust another man again, and that made for a future which
would stretch endlessly before her, filled with staying on the fringes of someone else’s life.
Drat Alistair’s eyes.
Worrying and letting bitterness fester in her soul wouldn’t solve any immediate problems, so
she turned away from the window with a sigh and then grabbed up a gray pelisse. Not the most
cheerful of colors, but there was no longer enough coin to purchase fripperies that weren’t
serviceable and suitable for the position of governess. She shoved her arms through the sleeves and
frowned at her equally unappealing navy day dress.
Had she married that scoundrel, she would have been dressed in the first stare of fashion and
elegance as befitting the next countess of Reardon. Instead, she was forced to mend her own clothing
and find ways to not only make them last but also look as fetching as she could without people
thinking she was putting on airs.
And thus, recalling why her name might sound familiar.
Perhaps spending some time in the garden before her assigned trip to Hyde Park with the
children would help to clear her mind. With a sense of boredom mixed with ennui, she donned a
bonnet of brown silk and trimmed with black velvet ribbon and a few pheasant feathers. Once, she’d
had smart, pretty little bonnets, but unfortunately, she’d been forced to sell them years ago. A yank at
the ribbons beneath her chin made an efficient bow.
No sense in worrying about that now.
She snagged a pair of brown kid gloves from the vanity along with her reticule that matched
the boring pelisse, and then Carole quietly exited her room. Since the schoolroom and nursery suite
took up all the space on the third floor, she’d been given one of the guest rooms on the second. Both
she and the viscountess thought it good enough, for the children were old enough that they wouldn’t
have dire emergencies in the night, and if they were frightened, they could always come down a level
and wake Carole.
As of yet, such a situation hadn’t made itself known, for William and Mary were quite self-
sufficient… and mischievous.
She deliberately avoided the morning room where luncheon was being served. No sense in
having her limited free time taken away when there wasn’t a need. On the ground floor, she took a
short cut through Lord Collinsworth’s library, went straight to the double French-paned doors, and
then slipped outside into the small stretch of garden separated from the neighbor’s house by a four-
foot stone wall.
As of yet, there had been no snow in the London area, but there was a decided chill in the air.
It reminded her of the years she’d spent in Kent, but being so close to the sea, the chances of having
snow in the winter was slim. Perhaps there would be some this winter in London, but probably not
for Christmastide.
As she paced about the abbreviated walkway that wound through a handful of ornamental fruit
trees toward the row of low hedges at the back wall, Carole filled her lungs with the relatively clean
air. At times, when the weather was fair, she would retreat here with a book of poetry and sit for a
couple of hours by herself. At others, she would escape to the green space behind the Hanover Square
area to walk and let her thoughts run wild.
Still, though, the worries mounted and worried her, and in those moments, the incredible
loneliness snuck in to bedevil her. Then she remembered to remain grateful she held a respectable
position and hadn’t needed to rely on making a livelihood on her back like so many women were
forced to. Additionally, her employers were lovely people, and most days, so were their children.
Next door, the soft woof of a dog filtered to her ears. Carole frowned. When had the neighbor
returned? The townhouse had sat empty for as long as she’d held the governess position here, and
from what the housekeeper had told her, no one had been in residence for a few years.
“I mean it, Fitzroy, do your business. I have an appointment yet this afternoon.”
Immediately, upon hearing the masculine voice, her heart dropped into the pit of her stomach.
Surely not… She crept toward that side of the wall separating this garden from his.
Then he spoke again. “Good boy. Now, back inside with you. Go find Mother, and no
complaints this time. I do not have the time or wherewithal to play nursemaid to you.” A hint of
annoyance wove through that baritone, and this time there was no mistaking to whom the voice
belonged to.
Her gasp must have been all too audible, for he turned about, and then the man’s eyes widened
with the same horrendous shock that currently battered her insides. It was true and not just a trick of
her ears. “Alistair.” How was this possible?
“Carole?” He moved closer to the wall, and she couldn’t help but look him over.
In the five years since they’d been apart, he had matured. His dark brown hair, combed into a
popular style was now sprinkled with threads of silver, especially at the temples. A frown tugged at
the corners of his mouth that was as sensual looking as it had ever been. As she crept even closer to
the wall, he followed her movements with eyes that were still as rich as brandy and his shoulders as
wide as she remembered, covered now by a black greatcoat. A top hat was clutched in one gloved
hand and drat the wall that prevented her from seeing the rest of his body.
“You are the neighbor who has been absent?” It was much too difficult to wrap her mind about
the possibility, so she’d been forced to utter it. Yet she couldn’t deny the evidence of her own eyes: he
was even more handsome than he’d been when she’d last seen him—the day before they were
supposed to have been wed.
Drat his rotted soul.
“I am.” From his expression, it seemed he couldn’t believe it either.
“But…” She shook her head. “That cannot be correct.”
“If that is so, then I am currently living in a house not mine, and also, if said accusation is true,
then someone should really tell my mother. She won’t be best pleased.” Those lips she’d once kissed
with abandon, curved downward in a fierce frown. “And knowing none of that is certainly not true,
this is surely my townhouse, so please move past your shock.”
The nerve of the man! Using all the willpower she possessed, Carole refrained from stamping
her foot as she wished. “Can you blame me? I haven’t seen you for five years!” Her voice rose an
octave on the exclamation.
“That was in the past.” He glanced about. Fearful someone would overhear?
Well, too bad. “And now, here you are, as big as you please, without apparent regret or the
good sense to offer up an apology, thinking to order me about as if we were strangers.” She propped
her hands upon her hips and glared at him. This time she lowered her voice. It wouldn’t do to have
everyone on the street bear witness to what was surely going to be a lovely row. “Perhaps you had
best explain to me what the devil you are doing here, looking at me as if I’m the one affronting you,
for after you do, I intend to give you the dressing down you so richly deserve. And do remember, Mr.
Forsythe, I have had five years to think of exactly what to say if I ever had the ill-fortune of seeing
you again.”
For she wouldn’t be trifled with. Since she’d locked her heart behind a cage, she was a
woman immune to charm and love. At least now her rage would be assuaged.
Chapter Three
At least he had the answer to one question. Apparently, Carole—Miss Hazelton, he should
really call her—did remember, and no, she hadn’t managed to get move past it.
Alistair eyed her warily. “Actually, it is Lord Reardon now.” When he’d responded to her
initial greeting minutes before, it had been a touch cooler than he’d intended. Mostly out of shock, but
more because he hadn’t been ready for the rush of emotion that had crashed over him. He might have
told Jonathan he was completely immune to her, but that obviously wasn’t true.
“I beg your pardon?” Confusion reflected in her blue eyes that used to remind him of the
sapphire on his mother’s favorite tiara.
“I am not a mister. Haven’t been for nearly five years. My father died, leaving me the earldom
and the title.” It was the best explanation he could—and would—give.
“Oh, you can understand my confusion. When one is absent from someone’s life, one tends to
not think of them any longer.” Sarcasm fairly dripped from her voice. Standing as she was with her
hands propped on her hips, he couldn’t help but study her.
Her chestnut hair beneath the unassuming bonnet was just as he remembered it. The equally
plain clothing did absolutely nothing for her frame, which was a shame because when he’d known
her, she wore gowns of sumptuous fabrics and rich hues, but it was the high color in her cheeks and
the daggers she shot at him from those eyes that would stay with him for much longer than the attire.
Then she narrowed her eyes. “You do not seem as surprised to see me as I am to see you. Why
is that, I wonder?”
“I, uh…” He tugged at the knot of his cravat. Under no circumstances could he let her see he
still held her in high regard, for she would make jest of that, perhaps use it against him. “Jonathan, or
rather Viscount Frawley, informed me yesterday you were here. He must have seen you on the street,
but in any event, he told me, so I had some time to digest that fact.”
“Ah.” She didn’t seem relieved or delighted. In fact, she continued to regard him as if she
hated the very sight of him. “How fortunate for you.”
Somewhat relieved she didn’t demand an explanation for the events of that day years ago, he
didn’t offer one either. No sense in ripping a scab off an old wound. There was a low-grade anger to
her now that he didn’t wish to stir further. Yet he had questions and was curious as to how she’d
passed those years. What happened to the sweet, docile, biddable miss he used to know and would
have married? This woman with a tart mouth had a backbone seemingly made of steel, and it was both
impressive and attractive. Another round of feeling for her welled in his chest. It was as if the five
years since he’d left had never happened. What would she do if he were to come through that curved
wooden garden gate that separated the properties and then catch her up in an embrace? Would she
receive him with gladness, or would she slap his face?
“Yes, I suppose I have been fortunate in many aspects of my life since… Well, you know.”
Now he realized why her entire attitude had become prickly. He’d ruined her, destroyed her
reputation that day. Perhaps if the same had happened to him, he wouldn’t be best pleased to see him
either.
One of her thinly feathered eyebrows lifted. “The day you decided I wasn’t worth your time
and left me at the altar?”
That wasn’t exactly true, but he couldn’t clear the misconception unless he wished to open the
whole, ugly mess of the scandal that had rocked his family. Which he didn’t want to do. At least not
now.
“Yes.” What else could he say?
“Well, bully for you.”
The vernacular took him by surprise, and though his lips twitched, he tamped down on the
urge to grin lest she assumed he made jest of her. Obviously, she must have picked up the word from
one of her charges. The best course of action was to steer her away from asking about his life. “When
did you return to London, Miss Hazelton?” Would she mind he didn’t use her Christian name? Under
the circumstances, he didn’t feel comfortable to claim that right, especially since he didn’t deserve it.
“Ah, so then we’re to conduct ourselves in this manner. Like strangers?” Was that for her
benefit or his? Carole might have been civil and cordial, but her attitude was quite cool. It drove a
shard of hurt into his heart, but then, he could only blame himself. She stared at him as if she wished
to pin him to a board like he was a bug. “I arrived six months ago when Lord Collingsworth decided
his manor house needed too much refurbishment to make summer living relaxing.”
He shifted his weight. Right. Why couldn’t he remember the name of his damned neighbor?
Probably because everything he’d ever known had flown out of his mind the second he’d laid eyes on
her again. Then he frowned. It was all too odd, and vastly unsatisfying, to converse with her when
there was a stone wall between them. “I have only just returned to Town this week.”
Something flickered in her eyes, but it was gone before he could properly read it.
When Carole said nothing else, not even to ask after his health, he sighed. “Where have you
been in the interim?” Perhaps if he could ascertain how she’d passed her days, he could better talk
with her. “I assumed your father would have rented out a townhouse every year.”
For a few seconds, her mouth pinched into a tight line. “About two weeks following our
broken engagement, my family and I went back to Hazelton Park in Kent. I have been there ever since,
with the exception of needing to come to London.”
They could have been acquaintances passing each other in a corridor at a society function for
all the warmth that wasn’t between them. “I see.” Though, he rather didn’t. What he wanted to ask her
was if she’d thought of him over the years, but he was too much of a coward to voice the inquiry.
Instead, he rushed on with the first question that popped into his mind. “How does your family fare?”
“Oh… you… jackanapes!” It wasn’t a compliment. If possible, even more anger had gathered
in her eyes, and if a storm at sea were personified, Carole Hazelton was exactly that. “My father is
dead. Three months after our broken engagement. Thanks to you.” So much animosity roiled in her
voice, he unconsciously took a step backward even though the wall separated them.
What was this, then? No matter that he still had feelings—residual or not—for the woman,
when she was basically accusing him of killing her father, that’s where he drew the line. “How the
devil could I have been responsible? I wasn’t even there!”
“That is the whole issue, you thick-skulled lout!” Carole crossed her arms at her chest. “You
never showed at the church that day, and the shame killed my poor papa.” Sadness jumped into her
eyes. “Because you didn’t keep your promise, my father is dead. I don’t know if I can ever forgive
you for that.”
Confusion ran rampant through his mind. “Which are you more upset about: my jilting you or
your father dying?” The words were out of his mouth before he could recall them.
How much more of a bacon-brained idiot can you be, Reardon?
She fairly vibrated with fury. Twin spots of color blazed on her cheeks, made even more
prominent due to the fact that the blood had drained from her face. “How can you be so cruel?” The
words were soft, but emotion trembled in the tones.
And damn if he still didn’t know to what she referred. That only deepened the mystery
surrounding her, but one thing he could say with certainty. He both wanted to be her comfort and
simultaneously run as far away from her as he could. “I’m afraid you will need to be more specific.”
If she thought she could rake him across the coals, he was under no obligation to stand there and take
it without making it just as uncomfortable for her.
It didn’t matter it wasn’t the gentlemanly thing to do. All of that flew out the window when
she’d more or less accused him of murdering her father.
“Argh!”
Thank goodness the wall was between them, for he felt it deep down into his soul that she
would have slapped him. He held up a hand, palm outward. “I do not wish to fight with you.”
“That is readily obvious,” she snapped with the fire still dancing in her eyes. “You never did
fight for what you wanted, did you?”
Did that mean she took exception to him choosing a family crisis over her? When she hadn’t
known about the scandal to begin with? Bloody hell. Never before had he realized what a woman
scorned looked like, but he refused—flat out refused—to enter into the conversation or put forth the
explanation she hungered for. He needed a clear head and to organize his thoughts before he’d do that.
“Enough. Can we not call a truce?”
Carole stood there doing nothing except blinking at him, and even that held a furious edge, but
it was somehow appealing. When his gaze dropped to her mouth, she thinned those lips into a flat
line. “No.”
“Fine.” Alistair heaved out a sigh. He was going to be hopelessly late for the meeting with his
man-of-affairs. “Why are you a governess for Lord Collingsworth?” Perhaps if they started off with
small, easy to answer questions, her anger would fade.
“Why do you think?” Hurt clouded her eyes. Vulnerability lay stamped across her face. She
looked so fragile, and a tad lost that his heart squeezed. The delicate tendons in her throat worked
over the collar of her pelisse. He wanted to protect her from every bad thing in the world, even if one
of those things was apparently him. “When you jilted me, everything changed.”
“But I—”
“No.” Carole shook her head. “My entire life was upended. It never went back to what it was
on that morning.”
“Did you marry?” What a nodcock question, Reardon! If she had, she would not have needed
to take a position.
“I did not. The rumors surrounding your defection saw to that.” The infinite sadness in her
eyes warred with annoyance. “I am not the same woman I was when you knew me. I am a governess
now and would appreciate it if you would simply leave me alone.”
How could he do that when his entire being screamed at him to make things right with her?
Five years had gone by in seemingly the blink of an eye, and now that he was here with her once
more, he wished to start over again, to discover if she might be able to love him anew.
Apparently, he hadn’t banished those old feelings as well as he’d thought.
But none of that would be accomplished while she continued to present the front of a hellcat.
“Carole, please, if we could—”
The remainder of his words were lost as the back door flew open and two tow-haired
children spilled out into the garden. Perhaps around seven years old, the boy looked the perfect image
of a country gentleman in tan breeches, brown boots, and even a brown tweed waistcoat, while the
girl was more demure in a pale blue dress with plenty of frills and a matching pelisse and bonnet.
“Miss Hazelton, Mama says the carriage is out front and ready for our trip to Hyde Park.” The
boy bounced his curious gaze between Alistair and her then ended up frowning. “Are we still going?”
“Of course we are.” In that moment, Carole transformed from a woman scorned and a
veritable storm to a nurturing ideal of what he thought his wife might be. “I was merely chatting with
our neighbor, who has finally come home from…” A trace of confusion went through her expression
as she connected her gaze back to his. “I apologize. I have no idea where you have been.”
That was the crux of the matter, indeed.
The longer Alistair peered at the twins, the more his mind was hurtled back to Bombay and
the horrible time he’d been obligated to suffer through that had prevented the life he’d wanted once
upon a time. All these years later, he couldn’t believe he’d been a twin, and no one had told him
throughout the whole of his existence. As he stared at the boy, both twins stared back at him, as
curious as he was.
“Hey, mate, Miss Hazelton is waiting on an answer,” the boy reminded him with an intense
look about him.
“Right.” Alistair shook his head in order to clear it. “I was in India, actually.” Never had he
despised that decision more than he did right now. He’d missed out on so much of Carole’s life,
hadn’t been able to enjoy her company as he’d originally assumed. And for what? Both his father and
the brother he’d never known about were dead. “There was a matter of some urgency that demanded
my attention.”
Once again, Carole’s gaze was upon him, and it was filled with sad speculation. “In any
event, Lord Reardon is now in residence, and I should think you will treat him with the respect he
deserves in his station, William,” she gently admonished as she ruffled a hand through the boy’s hair.
A pang of jealousy went through Alistair’s chest. What he wouldn’t give for her to lay a hand
—even a finger—on him again, merely so he could feel that connection. He focused on the children.
“It’s a pleasure to meet you.”
Both of them peered at him with matching hazel eyes. The boy nodded. “I have never met an
earl before. Is it difficult, Your Lordship?”
That largely depended on the day. He shrugged. “At times. You may call me Alistair.”
Carole snorted. “No, he may not.” She shook her head for emphasis, and with a hard glance,
said to the boy, “He is Lord Reardon, and I don’t want you to bother him.”
The boy—William—scowled. “What if I see him over the garden gate? Should I ignore him?
That isn’t good manners, and you are forever telling Mary and me we should be on our best
behavior.”
Alistair bit the inside of his cheek to keep from grinning. These children would prove a
handful if they hadn’t already.
A hint of a blush filled Carole’s cheeks. “Of course you should behave, but his proper form of
address is Lord Reardon.”
For the first time, the girl spoke. She waved shyly to him. “Hello, Lord Reardon. I am Miss
Mary Fairfax.” As she crept closer to the wall, she flashed him a smile that would undoubtedly win
half a dozen hearts when she was older. “I think it’s lovely you live next door. That house has been
sad and empty for too long.”
He gave her a grin. If he and Carole had been married as planned, would they have had a
child, perhaps two, by this point? “Actually, my mother and her dog have been in residence during my
absence. Have you not seen her?” It was entirely possible the two hadn’t crossed paths, for his
mother wasn’t one to socialize overly much, and the child wouldn’t have gone out without
supervision.
The child’s eyes were round, but her smile widened. “I have seen the dog. May I meet him
sometime? Mama won’t let us have a dog, so I am stuck with him.” She hooked a thumb over her
shoulder to indicate her brother. “And Miss Hazelton. She is a lovely governess, but she is sad all the
time.”
“I am sorry to hear that.” Did that mean Carole still thought about him? Wished things had
been different? Perhaps this was his way into spending a few more minutes with her. “Of course you
can meet the dog, but make certain you gain permission from Miss Hazelton first.”
Carole’s eyes narrowed, but she didn’t look at him. Instead, she shepherded the children
toward the door. “Go inside and wait for me in the entry hall. I shall be only a moment. Then we’re
off for our nature walk.”
Glad to once more be in her company alone, Alistair came closer to the wall. He laid a
gloved hand atop it. “You and I need to talk privately. Might you set aside some time in your schedule
to do so?” It felt all too awkward conversing as if they were strangers while ignoring the history
between them, but perhaps that was what their relationship amounted to now.
“We were done talking the day you left, Alistair.” The fury had returned to her voice with such
force that the tones shook from it even as she kept her pitch low. “You never even wrote to me!” Her
chin trembled before she got hold of her emotions. “Do you know how much a letter from you would
have been welcomed? When I needed words of comfort and reassurance from you, I had nothing
except silence. It was a smack in the face after everything else.”
Heat crept up the back of his neck. That was a fair point. He could have written, could have
explained in letters why he’d done the egregious thing that he had. But in that, he was also a coward,
so he’d let the matter drop. “I apologize for my appalling lack of manners. Everything happened so
quickly. I didn’t think about it…” His words trailed off. That wasn’t exactly true. There had been so
much thought put into that decision, and ultimately, he hadn’t wished to hurt her with the onslaught of
gossip that would eventually befall his family name if word of the missing twin got out, hadn’t wanted
to give her a life that had been based in a lie. “I thought about you, many times, until I… didn’t.”
Well, damn. He didn’t know when it had happened, but eventually, he truly did cease to think
about Carole and the world he’d left behind. Once his father had died, too many responsibilities had
filled his moments, and when he wasn’t working toward a fortune, he’d taken refuge in sleep, for at
least then the memories would cease to haunt him.
Mostly.
“I see.” Pain reflected in her impossibly blue eyes. “I need to go. Please, if you have a shred
of decency left in your body, leave me alone.”
“But I thought—”
“No.” She shook her head. “You have your life; I have mine. This is how it must be. Good
day, Lord Reardon.”
Then she vanished inside the house and closed the door firmly behind her. Alistair stood
looking at the spot she’d vacated for long moments after. There was much he needed to think about,
for his feelings hadn’t been left strictly to the past. The question now remained: did he want a
renewal of what they had, or should he start again from the beginning?
That was if Carole would give him the chance.
Chapter Four