Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Textbook Animation A World History Volume Ii The Birth of A Style The Three Markets 1St Edition Giannalberto Bendazzi Ebook All Chapter PDF
Textbook Animation A World History Volume Ii The Birth of A Style The Three Markets 1St Edition Giannalberto Bendazzi Ebook All Chapter PDF
https://textbookfull.com/product/twice-the-first-quirino-
cristiani-and-the-animated-feature-film-1st-edition-giannalberto-
bendazzi/
https://textbookfull.com/product/a-history-of-wine-in-
europe-19th-to-20th-centuries-volume-ii-markets-trade-and-
regulation-of-quality-silvia-a-conca-messina/
https://textbookfull.com/product/sapiens-a-graphic-history-the-
birth-of-humankind-2020th-edition-david-vandermeulen/
https://textbookfull.com/product/a-history-of-science-in-society-
volume-ii-from-the-scientific-revolution-to-the-present-andrew-
ede/
Gardner s Art Through the Ages A Global History Volume
II Fred S. Kleiner
https://textbookfull.com/product/gardner-s-art-through-the-ages-
a-global-history-volume-ii-fred-s-kleiner/
https://textbookfull.com/product/sapiens-a-graphic-history-the-
birth-of-humankind-vol-1-yuval-noah-harari/
https://textbookfull.com/product/aloha-rodeo-three-hawaiian-
cowboys-the-world-s-greatest-rodeo-and-a-hidden-history-of-the-
american-west-first-edition-david-wolman/
https://textbookfull.com/product/world-history-volume-ii-
since-1500-william-j-duiker-jackson-j-spielvogel/
https://textbookfull.com/product/a-people-s-history-of-the-world-
chris-harman/
ANIMATION: A WORLD
HISTORY, VOLUME II
A continuation of 1994’s groundbreaking Cartoons, Giannalberto Bendazzi’s Animation: A World History is the largest, deep-
est, most comprehensive text of its kind, based on the idea that animation is an art form that deserves its own place in
scholarship. Bendazzi delves beyond just Disney, offering readers glimpses into the animation of Russia, Africa, Latin
America, and other often-neglected areas and introducing over fifty previously undiscovered artists. Full of firsthand,
never-before-investigated, and elsewhere unavailable information, Animation: A World History encompasses the history of
animation production on every continent over the span of three centuries.
Features include:
• Over 200 high-quality head shots and film stills to add visual reference to your research
• Detailed information on hundreds of never-before-researched animators and films
• Coverage of animation from more than ninety countries and every major region of the world
• Chronological and geographical organization for quick access to the information you’re looking for
Volume II delves into the decades following the Golden Age, an uncertain time when television series were overshadowing
feature films, art was heavily influenced by the Cold War, and new technologies began to emerge that threatened the tradi-
tional methods of animation. Take part in the turmoil of the 1950s through the 1990s as American animation began to lose
its momentum and the advent of television created a global interest in the art form. With a wealth of new research, hundreds
of photographs and film stills, and an easy-to-navigate organization, this book is essential reading for all serious students of
animation history.
A former professor at the Nanyang Technological University of Singapore and the Università degli Studi of Milan,
Italian-born Giannalberto Bendazzi has been thoroughly investigating the history of animation for more than forty
years. A founding member of the Society for Animation Studies, he authored or edited various classics in a number of
languages, and has lectured extensively on every continent.
‘Giannalberto Bendazzi is a highly gifted historian, scholar, observer, teacher, and most of all, lover of animation in all
of its many forms. His painstaking and detailed research, as well as his social and cultural observations about the various
times during which many animated pieces were produced, give his writing an authenticity rarely seen in other books on
the subject. I cannot think of anything better than to curl up with one of his books and have him tell me the world history
of the animation medium I love.’
Eric Goldberg, Animator and Director,
Walt Disney Animation Studios
‘Giannalberto Bendazzi’s book gives us the complete overview of how the art of animation developed around the world
in the last one hundred years. It is a book global in scope for an art form now global in appeal and being created around
the world. This work is an essential addition to the library of any serious scholar of cinema.’
Tom Sito, Chair of Animation,
University of Southern California
‘A staple of any animation library, this encyclopedic book covers the far reaches of production worldwide, throughout
history. It is an incredible resource from one of the animation world’s leading scholars.’
Maureen Furniss, Director of the Program in
Experimental Animation at CalArts
‘Giannalberto Bendazzi is one of the world’s finest historians and scholars of the art of animation. We are indeed fortu-
nate that his thorough research, cogent perceptions, and eloquent writing is now in this ... acclaimed masterly tome on
world animation.’
John Canemaker, Oscar winning independent Animator,
Animation Historian, Author, and Professor
‘I feel that one looks into Giannalberto Bendazzi’s exhaustive book as one does into a mirror – it is the whole history of the
animated film and all its creators... In taking up such a grand endeavor, Bendazzi has shown a determination, a predispo-
sition, and above all, a talent comparable to that of the finest filmmakers... With this talent Giannalberto Bendazzi gives
meaning to our work. To our creativity and volition, to both the ability to withstand hard work and the temperamental
nature of a creative spirit, to study, to our artistic caprices, to accuracy, and to our eccentricities, creative perfection and
human imperfection, expectations and improvisations, passions and doubts, successes and failures...This is a book that has
long been anticipated by professionals and enthusiasts of animation from all over the world.’
Jerzy Kucia, Director, Poland
‘I am extremely proud that Giannalberto Bendazzi, at the beginning of my career, was my first official biographer. And I
like to believe that I was the flame that led him to become one of the world’s top experts in the field of animation.’
Bruno Bozzetto, Director, Italy
‘I don’t know any historian of animation more reliable than Giannalberto Bendazzi.’
Yamamura Koji, Director, Japan
‘I have been anxiously waiting for this sum total on animation...Giannalberto Bendazzi monitored, saw, and noted every-
thing and met everyone in the world of my beloved profession – and for so long, way before it was fashionable. Wherever
I went – to both festivals and meetings throughout continents - he was there. Welcome to the monumental book that takes
into account a great art and the whole planet.’
Michel Ocelot, Director, France
ANIMATION: A WORLD
HISTORY
Volume II: The Birth of a Style—
The Three Markets
Giannalberto Bendazzi
CRC Press
Taylor & Francis Group
6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300
Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742
CRC Press is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
3 Eastern Europe 57 changes within the market (in the field of tel-
evision or advertising) and within technology
Poland57
(e.g. computers), it is substantially uniform, as
Czechoslovakia and Puppets 57
it obeys the political and economic division of
Hermína Týrlová 59
the world into two major areas: one influenced
Karel Zeman60
by the liberal United States and one influenced
Jiří Trnka62
by the communist Soviet Union. This period is
The Music of the Puppets 67
called ‘The Three Markets (1960–1991)’.
Hungary68
Yugoslavia: The First Stage 8 The Three Markets (1960–1991) 99
of the Zagreb School 68 Global Stability 99
Croatia68 It Seemed Such an Easy Game 99
Bulgaria71 Animation Forks100
Romania71
More About It 1 71 9 America 102
More About It 2 74 On the Big Screen – Shorts 102
4 Soviet Union 76 On the Big Screen – Feature Films 103
Stephen Bosustow 104
Russia76 A Cat in the Heavy Traffic 105
Ivan Ivanov-Vano 79 Ray Harryhausen 106
Lithuania83 On the Small Screen 107
Georgia83 Weston Woods, from Book
5 Asia 85 to Film109
Independent Filmmakers 110
Japan85
Ernest Pintoff 111
Toei Doga’s Start-Up 85
Jane Aaron112
Praiseworthy People 87
John Canemaker 113
Mori Yasuji 87
George Griffin 114
Otogi Pro88
Those Talented Inventive
Experiments88
People117
China89
John and Faith Hubley 118
6 Latin America 91 Will Vinton 120
Fine Artists for Animation 123
Mexico91
Jules Engel123
Venezuela91
Robert Breer128
Brazil92
John Whitney 129
Argentina92
James Whitney 130
7 Africa 94 Lawrence Jordan 132
South African Republic 94 People Not to Overlook 133
Stan Van der Beek 134
The Fifth Period Canada136
The National Film Board
The Fifth Period begins with the blooming of Goes to Heaven 136
the television series and auteur animation and Pierre Hébert 138
ends with the conclusion of the Cold War. Vancouver & Co.140
Although it is varied and subjected to strong Caroline Leaf 142
Contents vii
The Fourth Period is short and runs from 1951 (the date of projection of the UPA short Gerald McBoing Boing) to 1960, the
date of the first international animation film festival (Annecy, France). It is characterized by indecision. Disney and his
imitators lost momentum, the UPA proposed a new style, the television age began and an original animation output was
born in Europe. We’ll christen it ‘The Birth of a Style (1951–1960)’.
This page intentionally left blank
1
AMERICA
After the Long Telegram Former US enemies such as Japan, Germany and Italy
were hurriedly backed up and pushed to recovery and
On 2 September 1945, Japan signed the official surren- reconstruction (although not rearmed), in order to serve as
der to the United States and the Second World War was anti-communist allies.
over. Almost immediately (although both the USA and the In February 1945, at the Yalta conference, Winston
USSR heavily demobilized), the Cold War started. Churchill had snarled: ‘While there is life in my body,
In February 1946, the US State Department carefully no transfer of British sovereignty will be permitted’.1 Six
read the ‘long telegram’ of the American chargé d’affaires months later, on 26 July 1945, the electorate voted him
in Moscow, George F. Kennan. The Soviets, Kennan said, out of his Prime Minister’s chair. His Labour Party succes-
were aiming at eroding the capitalist nations and imposing sor, Clement Attlee, did all he could to decolonize. India
their ideological rule on the world, and they were doing so in became independent in 1947, and India was the hub
order to justify their internal power in the face of their popu- around which the British Empire revolved. In a couple of
lation’s sacrifices. On 12 March 1947, President Harry Tru- decades, most of the former colonies became independent
man addressed a speech to the Congress, declaring that the states.
USA, as the leader of the Free World, would support every- Not the British colonies only. The Netherlands tried to
where democracy against communism (Truman Doctrine). resist, but had to let her own empire go. France resisted
In 1948, Czechoslovakia fell last into the group of the strongly and fought in Indochina and northern Africa, but
‘satellite’ European states of the Soviet Union, along with was defeated. By the early 1960s, residual colonies were
Poland, Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria, Albania, Yugoslavia small and few, with the exception of some Portuguese ter-
and the eastern section of Germany. The continent was polit- ritories that would become independent ten years later.
ically split into two different areas, separated by the so-called On 5 March 1953, Joseph Stalin suddenly died in Mos-
Iron Curtain. In 1949, the communist People’s Republic of cow. Most of his compatriots both worshipped him and
China was proclaimed, under Mao Zedong’s leadership. were terror-stricken by him, so his demise left in the Soviet
In the same year, the Soviet Union showed that it, too, Union an immense empty space, which lasted for three
was equipped with atomic bombs. This meant that the years, until the very different figure of Nikita Khrushchev
Cold War could not become a hot one, but at the high took over.
price of the end of humankind. The two superpowers On 18–24 April 1955, about twenty-five representatives
would always carefully handle any regional crisis (the main of newly independent states from Asia and Africa gath-
ones being the Korean War, 1950–53, the Cuban Missile ered in Bandung, Indonesia. Indonesia’s Sukarno, China’s
Crisis of 1962 and the Vietnam War, which involved the Zhou Enlai, India’s Nehru, Egypt’s Nasser, Cambodia’s
US in the 1960s and early 1970s) in order to avoid the trig- Sihanouk, Ghana’s Nkrumah and Cyprus archbishop
gering of an atomic confrontation. Makarios were among the participants.
1
Entry in Admiral William D. Leahy’s diary, quoted in Terry H. Anderson, The United States, Great Britain and the Cold War 1944–1947,
Columbia and London: University of Missouri Press, 1981.
4 Chapter 1: After the Long Telegram
The policy and myth of the Third World2 were actu- 1951, Julian Beck and Judith Malina founded the Living
ally born there, along with the practice of nonalignment. Theatre. In 1952, Ernest Hemingway published The Old
Young, tolerant, pacific, purged of the White nations’ vice, Man and the Sea and John Steinbeck East of Eden, architect
the Third World countries shone. The Third Worldism Le Corbusier completed in Marseilles the building of the
pleased the young intellectuals of various nations just as, Cité Radieuse. On 5 January 1953, in Paris, Samuel Beck-
in the nineteenth century, the proletariat had been seen as ett’s Waiting for Godot premiered; in the same year sculptor
the example of moral excellence. Henry Moore created King and Queen, Jacques Tati directed
Actual events would prove less romantic. Many out of Les vacances de M. Hulot and Mizoguchi Kenji Ugetsu Mono-
those young nations became dictatorships, and the Third gatari (Ugetsu); and James D. Watson and Francis H. Crick
World as a whole played an ambiguous and complex inter- discovered the double helix of DNA. In 1954, Ilya Ehren-
national role of stratagems, alliances/reversals of alliances burg published The Thaw. In 1955, J.R.R. Tolkien com-
with the Superpowers. Often it was the battlefield in case pleted the publication of The Lord of the Rings, Vladimir
of tiny, hot ‘wars by proxy’ that the Cold War allowed Nabokov Lolita (in Paris), Claude Lévi-Strauss Sad Tropics,
itself. Satyajit Ray directed Aparajito (The Unvanquished). In
1956, John Osborne published Look Back in Anger, Allen
Ginsberg Howl and Other Poems, Tanizaki Junichiro The Key;
Culture the Free Cinema movement was born in London, Ingmar
Bergman directed The Seventh Seal and Ichikawa Kon The
World War II shocked the world culture no less than the Burma Harp. In 1957, Boris Pasternak published (in Italy)
world politics and the world economy. In Western Europe Doctor Zhivago, Jack Kerouac On the Road, Vance Packard
the main problem, for some decades, was ‘should an The Hidden Persuaders and the Nouvelle Vague took shape in
intellectual be committed?’ ‘Committed’ meant ‘work- Paris. In 1959, Raymond Queneau published Zazie in the
ing within the actual political situation’ and forgetting the Metro, Eugène Ionesco Rhinoceros; Charles P. Snow gave the
ivory tower. In most cases it meant to be a leftist, which controversial lecture The Two Cultures; Frank Lloyd Wright
meant to be a full-fledged communist or (in political jar- built the Guggenheim Museum in New York; Alain Res-
gon) a ‘fellow traveller’ or a ‘useful idiot’. Mountains of nais directed Hiroshima mon amour and Federico Fellini La
pages and billions of neurons were spent on this theme dolce vita. In 1960, the New American Cinema was born
and this practice, on the ground that communism was the and American Pop Art took shape.
only real alternative to Fascism/Nazism. For the United States, and for the many nations that
Actually, writers, artists, musicians and philosophers imitated her, a novel of 1951 was indelible: J. D. Salinger’s
didn’t produce anything meant to be stable. They were The Catcher in the Rye. It told, with adolescent language,
rebellious and uncertain. adolescent alienation, confusion, rebellion. Independently
In 1945, Jean-Paul Sartre founded in Paris the journal from its literary value, it depicted the themes and the times
Les Temps modernes, starting to build his role as Europe’s cul- of a whole generation that was supposed to be happy, and
tural and political leading opinion maker, and Jean Dubuf- became synonymous with it.
fet opened his first one-man exhibition. In 1946, 1948,
1949, 1951 and 1958, William Carlos Williams published
the five volumes of Paterson. In 1946, Jackson Pollock aban-
doned the brush and inaugurated the technique of squeez-
Almighty and Suspicious
ing, pouring, dribbling paint on canvas that would lead to The fifteen years from 1945 to 1960 were a contradictory
the Action Painting. In 1947, Albert Camus’s The Plague, time for the United States. Victory in the war, together with
Thomas Mann’s Doctor Faustus, Anna Frank’s Diary and an extraordinary economic expansion and the simultane-
Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire were published. ous collapse of the traditional world powers (UK, France,
In 1949, Jorge Luis Borges published The Aleph, George The Netherlands, Japan), gave the US a position of planet
Orwell 1984, Arthur Miller Death of a Salesman, Konrad leadership. To the rest of the world, America presented a
Lorenz King Solomon’s Ring and Margaret Mead Male and picture of prosperity, generosity and optimism – an image
Female. In 1950, Kurosawa Akira directed Rashomon. In reinforced by American financial aid, particularly to Europe.
2
The First World being the capitalist West, and the Second the totalitarian, communist East.
Chapter 1: After the Long Telegram 5
Such splendour, however, was not faultless. The Cold and painter Jackson Pollock were all heralds of a marginal
War against the Soviet Union hid psychological disquiet world and the bearers of stylistically overflowing, rebellious
and phobia, which materialized in the ‘McCarthyist’ per- ideas. Initially, what they all wanted was to detach them-
secution of the Left. Cinema replaced the portrayal of the selves from the mainstream of American culture; inevi-
bold American – naïve, perhaps, but always inexhaustible – tably, they were absorbed and embraced by the market
with new characters and new actors (from Montgomery (especially Pollock and his colleagues of Action Painting).
Clift to Marlon Brando, James Dean and Anthony Per- Hollywood animation shared the fate of the film indus-
kins) who expressed anxiety, uneasiness and neurosis. Juve- try in general; as its most frail branch, it was the first to dry
nile crime increased, and the large American middle class out. Animated shorts, which had always been regarded as
gradually became aware of its sociocultural fragmentation. fillers, were eliminated without being really missed as costs
Beatnik communities arose to propose an autonomous rose. Studios shrank and gradually closed. Very few young
counterculture. The consumer age broke out with the pop- artists joined studio staffs. Disney was the first to reduce
ularization of television and modified decades-old patterns the production of shorts, concentrating on feature films
of thought and behaviour. and, later on, other projects such as live-action features
It was precisely television that helped precipitate the cri- for children, documentaries on the wonders of nature and
sis of cinema. Starting in 1946, the sale of television sets the very successful amusement parks. In the meanwhile,
increased dramatically; shortly afterward, the networks avant-garde groups collected the spiritual inheritance of
began broadcasting in colour. This new kind of home Mary Ellen Bute and Oskar Fischinger and gave rise to
entertainment kept huge numbers of spectators away from new, rich productions of abstract animation, which per-
the theatres. Then, in 1948, with a decision which ended fectly complemented the stylistic and linguistic research of
years of litigation, the Supreme Court upheld the ruling in off-Hollywood filmmakers.
the United States vs. Paramount et al. trial, involving all major Traditional, round-shaped drawings (‘O-style’) could no
California movie companies, pursuant to the antitrust law. longer compare with the drawings of comic-strip artists,
From that time on, the three components of production, fashionable cartoonists and advertisers. American anima-
distribution and exhibition were to be separated. The ver- tion was born from popular comics and their inevitably
dict terminated the companies’ monopoly over the audi- poor drawings had flourished in the caricature/children’s
ence and ended the lifestyle and work methods that had book style of Walt Disney; now, for the first time, it would
characterized the entertainment field. In short, it marked join the group of the major commercial arts. Animators
the end of legendary Hollywood. found themselves looking with awe at the style of artists,
Comedy evolved. Deprived of artists such as Capra, such as the New Yorker cartoonists James Thurber and Saul
Lubitsch and Stevens, it survived through the work of Steinberg, and at the subversive humour of the corrosive
craftspeople and through the caustic films of Billy Wilder. New York magazine, Mad. For the first time, American
In the late 1950s, causticity became a rule outside cin- animation would follow the national and international
ema, with the ‘sick comedians’ – educated entertainers, trend, and would even contribute to set it. This was a
well versed in quick political gags and dirty words, who vital boost, if also a temporary one: after some years, that
addressed students and intellectuals in the thousands of approach, too, would fall irremediably out of fashion. In
night clubs which spread like mushrooms after the war. other words, for animation this was a time of indecision,
Their favourite topic: the American malaise. The group, incertitude and even opacity in the USA and the rest of
which included Lenny Bruce, Mort Sahl and Dick Greg- the world as well.
ory, exerted its influence for years, spawning artists such as
Woody Allen. In contrast, the old slapstick comedy, with
its absurd pyrotechnics, was dismissed as being definitively
naïve, as the inheritance of a ‘childish’ age; Jerry Lewis
Gerald McBoing Boing
and Bob Hope, who partially hearken back to it, became Released on 25 January 1951 and winner of the first UPA
isolated phenomena. Academy Award on 29 March 1951, Gerald McBoing Boing
In music, alongside the concert-hall experiments of the was the epitome of the stylistic gospel that would change
likes of John Cage, bebop reigned; a form of jazz born in again, and forever, the accepted approach to animated
the black ghetto, it was, by its own definition, the expres- films.
sion of an ‘alternative’ culture. Artists such as jazz musician Cahiers du cinéma commented from Paris: ‘The work of
Charlie Parker, writer Jack Kerouac, poet Allen Ginsberg Mr Bosustow and Mr Cannon contains such a blasting
6 Chapter 1: After the Long Telegram
charge that we can’t but compare it to the one that long ago physician are. Bobe Cannon had fluidity as an animator
exploded the silent cinema and gave birth to the sound film’.3 and conveyed it into his directorial style. His metamorpho-
Based on a story by Dr Seuss,4 written by Bill Scott and ses are an example: he loved to keep the character on the
Phil Eastman and directed by Bobe Cannon, Gerald McBo- screen, while dissolving the background in such a way that
ing Boing tells the story of a child who can’t speak words, the story continues without edges and interruptions, flow-
but speaks in sound effects instead. Rejected by the school, ing delicately ahead.
spurned by other children and even rebuffed by his father, Limited animation and two-dimensional design would
Gerald runs away from home and sets about becoming a become, in the following decade(s), the young frontier of
tramp; but just as he’s trying to catch a departing train, quality animation all over the world.
a radio producer hires him. In a very happy ending, he
becomes famous coast-to-coast as a one-man sound-effects
department.
Although strictly traditional in its values, the scenario
UPA
itself has something new: no gags. Gerald McBoing Boing is In 1943, Stephen Bosustow,5 David Hilberman,6 and Zach-
a little moral play about a handicapped person who can, ary ‘Zack’ Schwartz,7 three former employees of Disney,
nonetheless, climb the ladder of success. Funny, of course, formed Industrial Film and Poster Service. One year later, the
but not in the traditional, slapstick way. United Auto Workers hired them to make a film to endorse
Second: the drawings. Sharp, angular outlines around Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s reelection: Hell Bent for Election.
the distinctly bidimensional characters and objects: an ‘I’ The short was designed by Zachary Schwartz and directed –
style instead of the volumetric ‘O’ style championed by for one single dollar – by moonlighting Charles M. (Chuck)
Disney. Jones. Another film for the United Auto Workers, Brotherhood
Third: the colours. Casually thrown within the outline of Man (1946), was directed by Robert Cannon.
of an armchair or of a carpet, just to suggest that that On 1 May 1944, the company’s name was changed to
piece of furniture is red or brown. United Film Productions and, on 31 December 1945, to
Fourth: the music. Gail Kubik (1914–1984) was not a United Productions of America (UPA). In July 1946, Hil-
popular-song strummer, but an important American com- berman and Schwartz withdrew from the enterprise, and
poser, who would win the 1952 Pulitzer Prize for Music, Stephen Bosustow remained as the only executive producer.8
and who produced an innovative score. Bosustow9 had a complex, contradictory personality.
Fifth, and most important: the limited animation. In Born in Canada, he moved to California years before his
one of the first frames we see Gerald’s mother embroider- debut at MGM in 1931. A good scriptwriter, he worked
ing; her arm, only, is in motion. The doctor comes to visit for Ub Iwerks and for Walter Lantz before joining Dis-
the child; he’s a very dignified, stiff-necked gentleman, and ney in 1934. Once at Disney, he collaborated on a Mickey
only his legs are in motion – a very mechanical motion. Mouse series and on films such as Snow White, Bambi and
Disney’s full animation, personality animation and plau- Fantasia. He was dismissed on 20 May 1941, eight days
sible impossible are gone. Instead, a bold, simple concise- before the Disney strike, along with twenty other employ-
ness has told us a lot about who the housewife and the ees.10 As the leader of UPA, he demonstrated respect for
3
Francois Chalais, ‘Le fil à couper Disney’, Cahiers du cinéma, No. 6, Octobre–Novembre 1951, Paris.
4
Pseudonym of children’s writer and cartoonist Theodor Seuss Geisel (1904–1991).
5
Born in Victoria, British Columbia, Canada, on 6 November 1911, he died in Los Angeles, California, on 4 July 1981.
6
Born in Cleveland, Ohio, on 18 December 1911, he died in Palo Alto, California, on 5 July 2007.
7
Born in New York on 6 March 1913, he died in Tel Aviv, Israel, on 12 January 2003.
8
Hilberman and Schwartz moved to New York and founded the Tempo Animation Studio to produce commercials. Both leftists, they
were suspected during the most brutal period of the United States’s witch hunt. In 1947, during a hearing of the HUAC (House Un-
American Activities Committee), Walt Disney himself openly accused Hilberman of being a communist. In 1953, ‘the FBI announced
there would be an investigation, and Tempo’s clients soon broke off all contact. The FBI never followed through, but Tempo closed
its doors, laying off 150 artists (Tom Sito, Drawing the Line [Lexington, Kentucky: University Press of Kentucky, 2006]). Zack Schwartz
devoted himself to teaching; Dave Hilberman freelanced in Europe and then back home in the States, eventually becoming a university
professor, too.
9
The name, which suggests Slavic roots, is actually from Cornwall.
10
He would be among the strike leaders.
Chapter 1: After the Long Telegram 7
the talent and culture of his collaborators,11 great energy, The innovative research that would characterize the
and, above all, a vision: not to make money, but to make years to come was largely due to a newly hired staff of
quality films. At times, he was naïve and tactless. Basically scene designers and layout experts (John Hubley, Paul
a shy man, he often blamed himself retrospectively for Julian [by birth name Paul Hull Husted, Terre Haute,
making wrong decisions and for having been weak. With Indiana, 25 June 1914–Van Nuys, California, 5 Septem-
uncommon modesty, he also downplayed his artistic tal- ber 1995], Jules Engel, Bill Hurtz [1919–2000] and Herb
ent. He did not teach anything to his filmmakers, he said, Klynn [1917–99]), directors (John Hubley again, Bobe
but left them free to express their intellectual needs; he Cannon, Pete Burness) and screenwriters (Phil Eastman,
dismantled the assembly-line system and supported the 1909–86; Bill Scott, 1920–85).
forming of small, spontaneous teams of animators.12 This The fortunes of the newly founded company turned for
is the appreciation of Adam Abraham, the UPA historian: the better when Columbia, which was now ready to ter-
‘The most complaisant of managers, Bosustow gave his minate its contract with Screen Gems, agreed to become
employees extraordinary freedom as he presided over that a distributor for UPA shorts. Robin Hoodlum (1948) and The
rare anomaly: a for-profit company dedicated to Art’.13 Magic Fluke (1949) still featured the same characters (the
11
Just an example: although, according to the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences’ regulations, the Oscar for the animated
short subject was presented to the producer, Bosustow let the winning shorts’ directors go to the ceremony and collect the statuette.
12
Personal communications from Stephen Bosustow to the author (1973).
13
Adam Abraham, When Magoo Flew: The Rise and Fall of Animation Studio UPA, Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 2012, Intro-
duction, p. x.
8 Chapter 1: After the Long Telegram
14
However, he did receive an honorary diploma from USC many years later because of the two Oscars he won for Mr. Magoo animated
short subjects.
15
Bruce Burness, Pete Burness’s son, wrote: ‘In many conversations with my father it was clear that he felt Trouble Indemnity was the best
film of his entire career; but he was thrilled that Bobe got the Academy Award. My father held Bobe Cannon in the highest regard. The
Cannon family and the Burness family got together socially many times over the years at either our house or the Cannon Ranch’ (e-mail
message to author, 26 February 2010).
Chapter 1: After the Long Telegram 9
16
Pete Burness’s son Bruce wrote: ‘My father really struggled with the idea of doing a feature-length Mr. Magoo. As the film progressed he
became more and more distressed by what he felt was the overcommercialization of Mr. Magoo. Directing and nurturing this Mr. Magoo
character had been the pinnacle of his career. My father had agonized over how to develop and present Mr. Magoo’s identity since the
day he arrived at UPA. He could not bear what he felt was the complete corruption of Mr. Magoo’s identity’ (e-mail message to author,
26 February 2010).
17
In the filmographies he’s variously credited as ‘Robert’, ‘Bob’ or ‘Bobe’. Friends also called him ‘Bobo’.
18
Gerald McBoing Boing’s Symphony (1953) was the simple story of Gerald asked to substitute for a whole orchestra, with a seemingly disas-
trous result but an eventual success (some scenes of Gerald wandering in the middle of a transparent, anonymous crowd set a fashion).
How Now McBoing Boing (1954) was meant to put an end to the saga: Gerald’s parents take him to the greatest specialist in the world, and
he eventually discovers the boy just has an upside-down larynx (some scenes of people running as if they had wheels instead of legs set
a fashion). The fourth, tacked-on instalment, Gerald McBoing! Boing! on Planet Moo (1956), brought the kid into space, with the result of
convincing aliens that on planet Earth people didn’t speak words, but went ‘boing, boing’ instead (and here the only interesting point is
the original graphics).
10 Chapter 1: After the Long Telegram
John Hubley
The real directing star at UPA was not self-effacing Bobe
Theory from Practice
Cannon, but dashing, outgoing John Hubley. This great In July 1946, John Hubley and Zachary Schwartz
filmmaker had joined Disney’s in 1935 at twenty-one, had published an interesting – as much as unnoticed –
participated until the 1941 strike, and had left in 1941 essay: ‘Animation Learns a New Language’ (Hol-
for Screen Gems, where he had been promoted from lay- lywood Quarterly, Vol. 1, No. 4).20 After both having
out man to director. In 1942 he joined the army and was substantially worked on animated army educa-
assigned to the Army Air Force First Motion Picture Unit; tional films, they wanted to share the lesson they
then, in 1944, was back to civilian duties and was hired had drawn.
by Bosustow. He directed three Fox and Crow films (Robin They wrote:
Hoodlum, 1948; The Magic Fluke, 1949; Punchy de Leon, 1950)
and the already mentioned, and fundamental, Ragtime Six months before America entered World War
Bear. II, the animated motion picture industry of Hol-
Rooty-Toot-Toot (1951) is a funny, rhythmic, ironic ver- lywood was engaged in the production of the
sion of the traditional ballad of Frankie and Johnny. The following films: 1 feature-length cartoon about
title comes from the fifth stanza of the ballad, where a deer; 16 short subjects about a duck; 12 short
it has mere onomatopœic value. Betrayed by Johnny, subjects about rabbits; 7 short subjects of a cat
Frankie kills him. She is acquitted but, after the trial, chasing a mouse; 5 short subjects with pigs; 3
she kills her lawyer, again out of jealousy. No subject short subjects with a demented woodpecker;
for children at all; the ballad, moreover, belongs to the 10 short subjects with assorted animals; 1 short
adult-only rhymes most suitable for a tavern or brothel. technical subject on the process of flush riveting.
Brilliant and disenchanted, the short musical confirmed Since that time, the lone educational short,
the innovative UPA use of drawings and colours. The dubbed by the industry a ‘nuts and bolts’ film,
drawings are purposely flat, two-dimensional, with has been augmented by hundreds of thousands
oblong or angular shapes, and the limited animation of feet of animated educational film. Because of
contrasts with the continuum mobile of the style which was wartime necessity, pigs and bunnies have collid-
considered ‘classical’ at that time. Strongly antirealistic ed with nuts and bolts. [. . .] Many professional
backgrounds are here often limited to a few sketches studios producing educational films of infinitely
or to large areas of solid colour. Everything is clearly, varied subjects soon discovered that, within the
deliberately dominated by a visual culture influenced by medium of film, animation provided the only
Matisse, Picasso and Klee: no longer animated comic means of portraying many complex aspects of
drawings or films with drawn actors. These were the a complex society. Through animated drawings
works of cultivated art directors who gave drawing and artists were able to visualize areas of life and
painting a major role. thought which photography was incapable of
It is said that Warner Bros. director Friz Freleng once showing.
declared: ‘When I die, I don’t want to go to Paradise. [. . .] We must [therefore] examine the basic
I want to go to UPA’. But even UPA was this side of Para- difference between animation and photographed
dise, and the witch hunt was scaring the hell out of the action. [. . .] A drawing’s range of expression, its
United States. John Hubley refused to cooperate with area of vision, is wider than that of the photo-
investigators looking for supposed communists, and pres- graph, since the camera records but a particular
sure was placed on UPA. On 31 May 1952, John Hubley aspect of reality in a single perspective from a
was forced to leave.19
19
Sadly, he was not the only one. The victory over UPA, the leftist, heavily unionized studio, was a triumph for McCarthyites. For
deeper insight, see Karl Cohen, Forbidden Animation – Censored Cartoons and Blacklisted Animators in America, Jefferson, NC, and London:
McFarland, 1997.
20
Now published by the University of California Press, Stable URL; http://www.jstor.org/stable/1209495.
Chapter 1: After the Long Telegram 11
21
The real name of this quick-witted (and underestimated) screenwriter and gagman was Thornton Garfield (1911–1988). Animation
director Bob Kurtz wrote: ‘About my mentor and writing partner T. Hee [. . .] His closest friend throughout his career was Marc Davis
and he didn’t know Tee’s abandoned given last name. Tee’s name reflected his gentle spirit and his view of life. I don’t know if Tee hated
Garfield as much as it didn’t fit him. T. Hee fit him well’. (E-mailed letter to the author, 3 February 2009)
22
José Cuauhtémoc ‘Bill’ Meléndez was born in Hermosillo, Sonora State, Mexico, on 15 November 1916, and was brought up in Ari-
zona and California. He joined Disney in 1938, Leon Schlesinger/Warner Bros. in 1941 and UPA in 1949. He established Bill Meléndez
Productions in 1964, becoming famous with his cinematic renditions of Charles M. Schulz’s Peanuts and Jim Davis’s Garfield the Cat.
He died in Santa Monica on 2 September 2008.
23
Saperstein (1918–1998) produced dozens of hurried TV Mr. Magoo cartoons, plus the TV series The Famous Adventures of Mr. Magoo,
in which the character starred in adaptations of classics from world literature. Abe Levitow (1922–1975) directed both the series and the
feature-length theatrical film Gay Purr-ee (1962), which unsuccessfully aimed at catching the attention of the cultivated audience.
12 Chapter 1: Walt Disney
It is necessary here to discredit an endlessly repeated rather forgotten feature The Reluctant Dragon (1941) and its
legend: that limited animation was adopted in order to segment Baby Weems, which actually is nothing else than a
save money. It wasn’t. Most of the UPA shorts were over filmed storyboard. Toot, Whistle, Plunk and Boom (directed by
budget – money was never a priority for Stephen Bosus- Ward Kimball and Charles A. Nichols in 1954) looked just
tow, who cared for quality – and in 1960 the studio was like a UPA production and, despite initial scepticism, was
heavily indebted to Columbia. UPA limited animation awarded an Oscar.24
should better be called stylized animation, necessary to The late 1940s/early 1950s were difficult years for
match stylized drawings. Disney animation. Mary Browne Robinson Blair (1911–
Not everybody properly used the recipe. Some applied it 1978), an exquisite watercolourist from Oklahoma, was
to old slapstick comedy, hoping to reduce work, but missed the one who didn’t let its artistic look lose its shine. She set
the implications of stylized animation. Others heavily her mark into such films as Saludos Amigos, The Three Cabal-
applied it to TV series, where actually work and money leros, Make Mine Music and Melody Time, and then Cinderella
had to be saved, and rejected criticism on the ground that and Alice in Wonderland up to Peter Pan, with her bidimen-
the highly praised UPA films had used it, too. In UPA’s sional, modernist, faux-naïf ‘inspirational paintings’ based
productions, on the contrary, precise correlations existed on sharp chromatic contrasts. Mary Blair took her leave
between humour, drawings and animation. The conse- of Mickey Mouse’s father in 1953, but was called back ten
quences of this style must be considered over an extended years later to create It’s a Small World, an ‘attraction’ for
period of time. When Bobe Cannon let colour overlap the the 1964 New York’s World Fair that was later moved to
contours of his characters and considered both lines and Disneyland in California.
colours as one plastic whole obeying pictorial rather than Walt Disney was not actually a conservative, as far as art
narrative laws, he claimed his right to a specific language. was concerned, and even enrolled undisciplined surrealist
In other words, and on a minor scale, he did what Jackson painter Salvador Dalí to make a short for him.25 Neverthe-
Pollock had initiated some time before in paintings with less, theatrical animation – especially theatrical animated
his ‘unfinished’, incidental style. shorts – weren’t his cup of tea anymore, and the anima-
Without exaggeration, it can be inferred that the very tion department of the company gradually grew smaller
idea of animation as an art form, in the United States and smaller.
as well as in other countries, became commonplace with Out of the animated feature films produced in the
UPA. Entertainment animation left the exclusive realm of 1950s, none was bad, but none was really good, either.
comedy and became the foundation for graphic and picto- They were formulaic. Cinderella (1950, directed by Clyde
rial research as well as for diverse styles, themes and ‘gen- Geronimi and Wilfred Jackson) still had some Snow White
res’. In short, it became a medium for the greatest freedom charm and some charming characters and villains. Sleep-
of expression. ing Beauty (1959, supervising director Clyde Geronimi) is
It should be added that the audiences did not always rather original in its look, as artist and illustrator Eyvind
adapt to the new language. Those who loved tradition Earle (1916–2000) was given – or took – the full respon-
criticized stylization as poor drawing, and segmented ani- sibility for colours and design. Its shining and flat chro-
mation as a sign of incompetence. Full animation was later matism reminds us of the illuminated manuscripts of the
re-evaluated, and today, the two schools still vie for the Middle Age in which the story is set.
favour of the public.
Warner Bros.
Walt Disney Warner Bros. lost one of its best directors in 1946, when
As strange as it may seem, the roots of the UPA approach Bob Clampett left to work at Screen Gems and, subse-
sink into the Disney production: it’s sufficient to watch the quently, to devote himself to hand-animated puppets for
24
Contrary to expectations, evidence exists that both Walt and Roy Disney admired UPA’s output.
25
Dalí worked more devotedly than anybody would have expected for eight months, between 1945 and 1946, along with writer and layout
man John Hench (1908–2004). Due to economic difficulties, the production was discontinued. A short by the title of Destino was released
in 2003, under the auspices of Roy Edward Disney. It was produced by Baker Bloodworth and directed by Frenchman Dominique Mon-
féry, on the basis of the original storyboards and paintings.
Chapter 1: Warner Bros. 13
26
Robert was the best known of the three McKimson brothers who worked in the same time in Hollywood animation. Thomas McKim-
son (1907–1998) was hired at Disney’s in 1928, then worked for Harman and Ising, later for Bob Clampett and eventually for his brother
Robert and for Art Davis. In 1947, he left animation to join the comic-book industry. Charles McKimson (1914–1999) started his career
in Tex Avery’s team in 1937, was drafted during the Second World War and in 1946, upon his return, entered his brother Robert’s unit.
In 1954, he too left animation for comics.
27
According to some sources, the nickname derived from a comics character, which Freleng closely looked like: fictional congressman
Frizby, who appeared in a column of the Los Angeles Examiner newspaper.
28
Tweety Pie (1947), Speedy Gonzales (1955), Birds Anonymous (1957), and Knighty Knight Bugs (1958).
14 Chapter 1: Warner Bros.
29
Charles Solomon, The History of Animation – Enchanted Drawings, New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1989, p. 149.
30
Steve Schneider, That’s All Folks!, New York: Henry Holt & Co., 1988, p. 42.
31
Mike Barrier, Hollywood Cartoons – American Animation in Its Golden Age, New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999, p. 472.
32
In order to enjoy these early 3D films, spectators must wear plastic glasses with one red lens and one green lens.
33
By Silvano Ghiringhelli.
34
Chuck Jones, Chuck Amuck – The Life and Times of an Animated Cartoonist, New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1989, p. 97.
Chapter 1: Warner Bros. 15
Figure 1.2 Chuck Jones. Image Courtesy of the Chuck Jones Museum.
His most intriguing creation of this period is he had to animate graphics and numbers, which
the Minah Bird, who appears for the first time in helped develop his ability to give life to inanimate
The Little Lion Hunter (1939). This uncanny animal objects or even to abstractions.
periodically materializes in the midst of the action, The Dover Boys (1942), a spoof of turn-of-the-
walking to the syncopated pace of Mendelssohn’s century dime novels, makes revolutionary use of
Fingal’s Cave, disrupting the cartoon’s world as well both animation and design. The characters move
as its form, with the invulnerability and indifference from one rigid pose to another with only a few
of a supernatural creature. drawings in between. Animator Bobe Cannon
From 1942 on, Chuck Jones experimented with used in some scenes the technique of smear ani-
unrealistic, stylized backgrounds, influenced by mation: rapid movement between two extremes
modern art. He accelerated the timing of his films, portrayed in only one or two smeared drawings.
using a much more subtle editing. He tried unu- The Dover Boys has been acknowledged as a pre-
sual expressive camera angles. In Conrad the Sailor cursor of the UPA style because of its stylized
(1942) he says he used graphic matches theorized backgrounds and aggressively streamlined ani-
by Eisenstein: ‘first we’d show a gun pointing up in mation. It was also crucial in the development of
the air, then, in the next shot, there’d be a cloud in Jones’s style because of its use of character poses.
exactly the same shape’.35 At the Warner’s animation department, the pro-
The cartoons of this period are innovative and duction of a cartoon was the result of a collabora-
full of stimulating ideas. But they are often plagued tive effort and could take more than a year. The
by unresolved aesthetical contradictions as well. director’s involvement in each stage of the produc-
During the Second World War, Jones directed tion varied greatly. But the best directors all knew
some educational black-and-white cartoons for what was important to them in order to keep con-
the army featuring Private Snafu. In these shorts, trol of the final result.
35
Greg Ford and Richard Thompson, ‘Chuck Jones: Interview’, Film Comment, January–February 1975, p. 27–28.
16 Chapter 1: Warner Bros.
The actual animation of the characters was His cartoons are beautifully drawn. Jones was
carried out through three stages. The director the best draughtsman of the great Warner direc-
drew ‘character layouts’ that indicated the main tors. He worked with the same team of very tal-
movements of a character for each scene. Based ented animators for almost all his career, even after
on them, the animator drew the ‘extremes’ that he left Warner’s. And they knew how to best serve
precisely define the key stages of every single his intentions.
movement. Finally, the assistant animator and/or From 1952 on, background artist Maurice Noble
inbetweener provided the drawings needed to ani- gave a decisive contribution to the visual aspect of
mate the character from one extreme to the other. the cartoons. With his help, Jones carried on his
Typically, twelve drawings were needed for every experiments with sceneries, using distorted per-
second of film. spective, abstract geometrical settings (Duck Amuck
Jones was more or less involved in every stage [1953], Duck Dodgers in the 24 1/2 Century [1953]) or
of the production. But his main means of control unnatural colours (What’s Opera, Doc? [1957]).
over his cartoons were the character layouts. He Jones’s mise-en-scène is very refined. He is
always drew more than his colleagues. For his first more aware of camera placement than any other
cartoons, he was drawing so many that not much Warner cartoon director after Tashlin. If needed,
was left to do for the animators. He learned pro- he uses the most unusual angles: in Bear Feet (1949),
gressively to focus on a limited number of strong, after Junior has inadvertently propelled Pa into
expressive poses. space, there is an extreme low-angle shot from the
After The Dover Boys, the poses became the struc- ground as we see Pa flying above the treetops and
turing elements around which everything in Jones’s Junior running after him. His editing can also be
cartoons takes its place. They dictate the timing of quite creative: in Dripalong Daffy (1951), the final
the scenes, the editing and the choice of angles. But duel between Daffy and Nasty Canasta is intro-
they are not merely a formal device. They allow duced by a sequence of shots reminiscent of High
him to tell a tale through the character’s facial Noon, with a shot from under Daffy’s arched legs
expressions and body postures, to reveal the charac- and a tilted camera angle of Canasta.
ter’s psychology with great subtlety and to dispense Avery’s lesson was not lost on him. The slowness
many comical touches. of Jones’s first years gave way to a refined, complex
So the centrality of the poses reflects Jones’s timing in which extreme quickness cohabits with
main concern in filmmaking: the personalities of pauses of great effect, as in the Road Runner and
his characters. The psychological interplay between Coyote series.
the characters is more relevant in his cartoons than His art of timing is perhaps best shown in an
situations or gags. opera parody he directed in 1950, The Rabbit of
Under Jones’s guidance, the studio’s main stars, Seville. The canonical Elmer Fudd–Bugs Bunny
Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck, acquired richer per- chase lands on the Hollywood Bowl during a per-
sonalities and became much more coherent from formance of Rossini’s The Barber of Seville. In 1946,
film to film. He also created many new unforgetta- Jones had written an article on music and anima-
ble characters. The most notable were Wile E. Coy- tion in which he praised Friz Freleng’s Rhapsody in
ote, the Road Runner, Pepe le Pew and the Three Rivets with these words: ‘The music was not used
Bears. as a background, but as the dictating factor in the
In the second half of the 1940s, his learning actions of the characters’.36 The Rabbit of Seville fol-
years were through, and Jones emerged as the most lows the same principle with great ingenuity.
intellectual and artistically ambitious Hollywood Jones inherited a vast repertoire of gags from
cartoon director of his era. For more than a decade, the silent comedians. In The Rabbit of Seville there
he would create a number of great works showing are two borrowings from Chaplin’s The Great Dicta-
full mastery of the different aspects of his art. tor: the barbershop scene and the barber chair gag.
36
Chuck Jones, ‘Music and the Animated Cartoon’, Hollywood Quarterly, July 1946.
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
ordre, et les membres n'avaient que le titre de
Clari, au lieu que les sénateurs de Rome étaient Soz. l. 2, c. 3. et
appelés Clarissimi. Thémistius va jusqu'à dire que, 32, l. 4, c. 22, l.
vingt-cinq ans après Constantin, ce sénat avait 7, c. 9.
encore si peu de considération, que l'ambition d'y
parvenir était taxée de folie; et du temps de Zos. l. 2, c. 32.
Théodose Ier, il avoue que ces sénateurs, qu'on
appelait Pères Conscripts, étaient fort au-dessous Anony. Vales.
de ce titre. Ce n'est pas que les empereurs
n'eussent tâché de donner à leur sénat tout l'éclat
qu'ils pouvaient lui communiquer; mais ce ne fut Themist. Or. 3,
jamais qu'une lumière réfléchie: celui de Rome p. 48, et 14, p.
brillait de son propre fonds, et par l'antiquité de sa 183.
noblesse. Cette distinction primordiale, entre les
deux sénats, se maintint dans l'opinion publique, Conc. Constant.
malgré tous les efforts de la puissance souveraine can. 3.
pour la faire disparaître. Ajoutez que les
empereurs firent tout pour relever le nouveau Godef. ad Cod.
sénat, excepté la seule chose qui peut vraiment Th. lib. 14. tit.
illustrer une compagnie politique; ils ne lui 13.
donnèrent aucune part dans le gouvernement, et
ne le respectèrent pas assez pour le rendre Vales. ad Amm.
respectable à leurs sujets. Constantin fit une l. 26, c. 6.
espèce de partage entre Rome et Constantinople:
il déclara celle-ci capitale de toute l'étendue
comprise du Septentrion au Midi, entre le Danube Le Quien, Or.
Christ. t. 1, p.
et les extrémités de l'Égypte, et d'Occident en 66.
Orient, entre le golfe Adriatique et les frontières de
la Perse. Il y mit le siége du préfet du prétoire
d'Orient, et la détacha de la province d'Europe[57], Till. art. 67.
et de la métropole d'Héraclée, pour la juridiction
civile et ecclésiastique. Mais son église ne fut érigée en patriarchat
qu'au concile de Chalcédoine en 451; ce qui fut jusqu'au
commencement du treizième siècle un sujet de contestation entre
cette église et celle de Rome. Constance établit ensuite un préfet de
la ville; et la coutume s'introduisit que des deux consuls l'un résidât à
Rome, l'autre à Constantinople.
[57] L'une des divisions administratives de la Thrace.—S.-M.
Le fondateur voulut encore que sa ville partageât
l'empire des sciences. Il y institua des écoles vi. Autres
célèbres, dont les professeurs jouissaient de établissements.
grands priviléges. Elles subsistèrent jusqu'à Léon
l'Isaurien. La bibliothèque commencée par Cod. Th. l. 13, t.
Constance, augmentée et placée dans un bel 3.
édifice par Julien, mise par Valens sous la garde
de sept antiquaires, montait à cent vingt mille
Hist. Misc. l. 21,
volumes quand elle fut brûlée sous Basilisque. apud Murat. t. 1,
Zénon la rétablit, et elle était déja fort nombreuse, p. 151.
lorsque ce même Léon, destructeur barbare de
toute science, comme il eût voulu l'être de toute
orthodoxie, la fit brûler avec le chef et les douze Zonar. l. 14, t. 2,
p. 52.
savants associés qui en avaient la direction.
Constantin s'était contenté de fournir les églises de
Constantinople d'exemplaires de l'Écriture sainte. Euseb. vit.
Eusèbe nous donne la lettre par laquelle ce prince Const. l. 4, c.
le prie de faire copier sur du parchemin bien 36, 37.
préparé, par les plus habiles écrivains, cinquante
de ces exemplaires, et de les lui envoyer dans Just. nov. 43 et
deux chariots, sous la conduite d'un diacre de 59.
Césarée. Il chargea en même temps le receveur
général de la province de faire les avances Leon, nov. 12.
nécessaires. Ses ordres furent promptement
exécutés, et l'empereur accoutumé à donner à ses
peuples la subsistance corporelle, distribua aux Ducange,
églises avec encore plus de joie cette divine Const. Christ. l.
2, c. 9, p. 150 et
nourriture. Sa prévoyance s'étendit jusque sur les 151.
morts. Pour leur procurer gratuitement la
sépulture, il fit don à l'église de Constantinople de
neuf cent cinquante boutiques exemptes de toute Till. art. 65.
imposition. Le loyer, dont cette exemption
augmentait la valeur, était employé à gager un pareil nombre de
personnes destinées au soin des funérailles dont ils faisaient tous
les frais. On les appelait Decani, Lecticarii, Copiatæ. Ils étaient au
rang des clercs. L'empereur Anastase en augmenta le nombre
jusqu'à onze cents. Cette institution paraîtra peut-être de peu de
conséquence, mais elle épargnait aux pauvres un surcroît de
larmes; et la sépulture de ceux qui mouraient dans l'indigence,
n'était plus pour leurs enfants un second dommage.
C'est au temps de la fondation de Constantinople,
qu'on doit, ce me semble, rapporter le nouvel ordre vii. Nouvel ordre
établi dans l'empire. Hadrien avait introduit des politique.
changements dans les emplois, tant civils que
militaires: il avait réglé les offices de la maison des Vict. epit. in
princes. Dioclétien et Constantin y firent encore Hadriano, p.
quelques innovations. Les détails ont échappé à 204.
l'histoire: ces objets ne lui appartiennent en effet,
qu'autant qu'ils intéressent l'administration publique. Ce sont aussi
les seuls auxquels nous allons nous arrêter.
Jusqu'à l'abdication de Dioclétien, l'empire n'avait
formé qu'un corps indivisible. Le partage qui se fit viii. Nouvelle
alors entre les deux empereurs et les deux Césars, division de
le sépara en quatre départements, dont chacun l'empire.
avait son préfet du prétoire et ses officiers.
Constantin et Licinius étant restés seuls Euseb. hist.
souverains, ce vaste empire ne fut plus divisé eccl. l. 8, c. 13.
qu'en deux parties: Constantin réunit à sa
domination ce qu'avait d'abord possédé Sévère, et ensuite Maxence;
Licinius joignit à l'héritage de Galérius tout l'Orient, après la défaite
et la mort de Maximin. La première guerre contre Licinius fit acquérir
à Constantin la plus grande partie de ce que son rival possédait en
Europe; et par la seconde il devint seul maître de tout l'empire. Le
titre de capitale donné à Constantinople, sans être ôté à la ville de
Rome, produisit la nouvelle division d'empire d'Orient et d'empire
d'Occident: c'était à peu près le même partage que celui des états
de Constantin et de Licinius, avant la bataille de Cibalis.
Constantin sentit bien que, pour faire obéir ces
deux grands corps, et les rendre, pour ainsi dire, ix. Quatre
plus flexibles, il était nécessaire de les subdiviser préfets du
encore. L'exemple de Dioclétien lui avait appris à prétoire établis.
ne pas se donner des collègues ou des
subalternes qui fussent eux-mêmes souverains. Il
se réserva la souveraineté toute entière, et se Zos. l. 2, c. 33.
contenta de créer quatre préfets du prétoire, au
lieu des deux qui avaient servi de lieutenants aux De la Barre,
empereurs, depuis que la puissance avait été Mém. de l'Αcad.
réunie entre les mains de Constantin et de des Inscrip. t. 8,
Licinius. Ces quatre préfets avaient à peu près le p. 450.
même district qu'avaient eu les deux empereurs et
les deux Césars, selon la division de Dioclétien.
Giannone, Hist.
Ces districts étaient ceux d'Orient, d'Illyrie, d'Italie de Naples, l. 2,
et des Gaules. Ils se subdivisaient en plusieurs c. 1.
parties principales qu'on appelait diocèses, dont
chacun comprenait plusieurs provinces. L'Orient renfermait cinq
diocèses: l'Orient propre, l'Égypte, l'Asie, le Pont, la Thrace. L'Illyrie
n'en contenait que deux: la Macédoine et la Dacie. Sous le nom de
Macédoine était comprise toute la Grèce. Ces deux préfectures
formaient l'empire d'Orient. Celui d'Occident contenait les deux
autres. L'Italie comprenait trois diocèses: l'Italie propre, l'Illyrie
occidentale, et l'Afrique. Les Gaules en avaient le même nombre:
savoir, la Gaule proprement dite, la Bretagne, et l'Espagne à laquelle
était jointe la Mauritanie Tingitane. Chacun de ces diocèses était
gouverné par un vicaire du préfet, auquel les gouverneurs immédiats
des provinces étaient subordonnés. Le diocèse d'Italie avait seul
deux vicaires, dont l'un résidait à Rome, l'autre à Milan. Le rang des
gouverneurs variait aussi bien que leur nom, selon les divers ordres
de dignité qu'il avait plu à l'empereur d'établir entre les provinces.
Les plus considérables de celles-ci donnaient à leurs gouverneurs le
titre de consulaires; à la tête de celles du second rang étaient les
correcteurs; les présidents gouvernaient celles du dernier ordre.
[Constantin fit aussi quelques changements dans
la division et la circonscription des provinces de [Malal. l. 13,
l'empire. La Commagène qui séparait la Syrie de part. 2, p. 3 et 5.
l'Osrhoène, et qui avait formé autrefois un état
particulier, fut séparée de la Syrie, avec quelques Amm. l. 14, c. 8.
autres portions de territoire, et elle fut érigée en
province. L'Euphrate qui la bornait à l'Orient dans toute sa longueur,
lui fit donner le nom d'Euphratèse; elle fut aussi appelée
Césareuphratense, et la ville d'Hiérapolis, célèbre
par ses superstitions et par le culte qu'elle rendait Reland.
à la grande déesse des Syriens, sur lequel nous Palæstin. l. 1, c.
avons un traité curieux de Lucien, devint la 34.]
métropole de ce nouveau gouvernement. La
troisième Palestine, ou la Palestine salutaire, formée de l'ancienne
Idumée et des portions de l'Arabie qui s'étendent entre l'Égypte et la
Syrie, ainsi que la Phrygie salutaire, furent aussi des provinces de la
création du même empereur]—S. M.
Les préfets du prétoire qui n'étaient dans leur
institution que les capitaines de la garde du prince, x. Des maîtres
étaient devenus très-puissants dès le règne de de la milice.
Tibère. C'étaient eux qui levaient, payaient,
punissaient les soldats; ils recueillaient les impôts Zos. l. 2, c. 32,
par leurs officiers; ils avaient le maniement de la et 33.
caisse militaire, et l'inspection générale de la
discipline des armées. Les troupes leur étaient
Notit. Imp.
dévouées, parce qu'ils les tenaient sous leur main.
Constantin leur laissa la supériorité sur les autres
magistrats; mais il les désarma; il en fit des Till. art. 83.
officiers purement civils, de judicature et de
finance. Il leur ôta l'autorité directe sur les gens de guerre, qu'ils
continuèrent pourtant de payer. Pour remplir toutes les fonctions qui
concernent le maintien de la discipline, il créa deux maîtres de la
milice, l'un pour la cavalerie, l'autre pour l'infanterie. Ces deux
emplois se réunirent dans la même personne sous les enfants de
Constantin; mais le nombre des maîtres de la milice s'accrut ensuite;
on en trouve jusqu'à huit dans la notice de l'empire, faite du temps
de Théodose le Jeune. Ils n'avaient au-dessus d'eux dans l'ordre
des dignités, que les consuls, les patrices, les préfets du prétoire et
les deux préfets de Rome et de Constantinople. Zosime accuse
Constantin d'avoir affaibli la discipline, en séparant l'emploi de payer
les troupes du droit de les punir: ces deux fonctions réunies
auparavant dans le préfet du prétoire, contenaient les soldats dans
le devoir, en leur faisant appréhender le retranchement de leur
solde. Un autre inconvénient, selon lui, qui me paraît plus réel, c'est
que ces nouveaux officiers, et plus encore leurs subalternes,
dévoraient par de nouveaux droits la substance du soldat.
Pour rabaisser d'un degré les préfets du prétoire,
et diminuer d'autant leur puissance et leur fierté, xi. Patrices.
l'empereur institua une nouvelle dignité qu'il éleva
au-dessus d'eux: c'était celle des patrices. Ce Zos. l. 2, c. 40.
n'était qu'un honneur sans fonction. Le patrice
cédait le rang aux consuls; mais il conservait
ordinairement ce titre pendant toute sa vie. Il God. ad Cod.
pouvait y en avoir plusieurs: Aspar, sous Théodose Th. t. 2, p. 75.
le Jeune, est appelé le premier des patrices.
Sous les empereurs précédents, le nom de duc Ducange,
Gloss. Lat.
qui, dans l'origine, signifiait un chef, un conducteur, Patricius.
avait été particulièrement appliqué aux
commandants des troupes distribuées sur les
frontières, pour les défendre contre les incursions xii. Des ducs et
des Barbares. Ces troupes, placées de distance des comtes.
en distance dans des camps retranchés et dans
des forts, formaient comme une barrière autour de Zos. l. 2, c. 33.
l'empire. Zosime loue Dioclétien d'avoir fortifié
cette barrière, et reproche à Constantin de l'avoir
Aurel. Vict.
dégarnie, en retirant une grande partie des soldats Proc. Ædif. l. 4,
dans des villes qui n'avaient pas besoin de c. 7.
garnison: ce qui causa, dit-il, plusieurs maux en
même temps; l'entrée fut ouverte aux Barbares; les
Amm. l. 27, c. 5.
soldats par leurs rapines et leur insolence vexèrent
les villes jusqu'à en faire déserter plusieurs, et les
villes par leurs délices et leurs débauches Euseb. vit.
énervèrent les soldats. Mais d'autres auteurs, Const. l. 4, c. 1.
même païens, louent ce prince d'avoir multiplié les
forts des frontières; et l'histoire en nomme entre Pancirol. in
autres un des plus considérables, qu'elle appelle notit. or. c. 4,
Daphné de Constantin, qu'Ammien Marcellin place 36, 139.
au-delà, Procope en-deçà du Danube dans la
seconde Mésie[58]. Les ducs, dont nous parlons, God. ad Cod.
veillaient chacun à la défense d'une frontière. Th. t. 2, p. 101.
C'était une dignité supérieure à celle de tribun; ils
étaient perpétuels; et afin de les attacher au Till. art. 84.
département qu'ils défendaient, on leur assignait
aussi-bien qu'à leurs soldats les terres limitrophes des Barbares,
avec les esclaves et les bestiaux nécessaires pour les mettre en
valeur. Ils les possédaient en toute franchise, avec droit de les faire
passer à leurs héritiers, à condition que ceux-ci porteraient les
armes. Ces terres s'appelaient bénéfices; et c'est, selon un grand
nombre d'auteurs, le plus ancien modèle des fiefs. Quelques-uns de
ces commandants de frontière furent honorés par Constantin du titre
de comte, plus relevé alors que celui de duc. Les comtes étaient
d'ancienne institution: dès le temps d'Auguste on voit des sénateurs
choisis par le prince pour l'accompagner dans ses voyages, et pour
lui servir de conseil. Ils furent ensuite distingués en trois ordres,
selon le plus ou le moins d'accès qu'ils avaient auprès du prince: on
les appelait comites Augusti; ce qui ne désignait qu'un emploi. On en
fit ensuite une dignité. Ce titre fut donné aux principaux officiers du
palais, au gouverneur du diocèse d'Orient, et à plusieurs de ceux qui
commandaient les armées dans les provinces.
[58] Des médailles avec la légende CONSTANTIANA. DAFNE. furent frappées en
mémoire de la fondation de cette forteresse. La Notice de l'empire fait mention de
corps de troupes soumises au maître de la milice de Thrace, nommée Balistarii
Dafnenses et Constantini Dafnenses. Ils étaient sans doute chargés de la défense
de la même place. Elle fut probablement construite après les victoires remportées
par Constantin sur les Goths. Voyez ci-après, § 16.—S.-M.
La qualité de noble était depuis près d'un siècle
attachée à la personne des Césars. Celle de xiii.
nobilissime était née quelque temps avant Multiplication
Constantin: il la donna à ses deux frères Julius des titres.
Constance et Hanniballianus, avec la robe
d'écarlate brodée d'or. Ce nom fut ensuite affecté Pancirol. not.
aux fils des empereurs, qui n'avaient pas encore Or. c. 2.
celui de César. Ce fut vers ce temps-là qu'on vit se
multiplier les titres fastueux, qui s'attachèrent aux divers grades de
dignité, de commandement, de magistrature. Les noms d'illustres,
de considérables (spectabiles), de clarissimes, de perfectissimes, de
distingués (egregii), eurent entre eux une gradation marquée. C'était
une grande affaire de les bien ranger dans sa tête, et une faute
impardonnable de les confondre. Le style se hérissa d'épithètes
enflées, et se chargea d'une politesse exagérée. On convint de
s'humilier et de s'enorgueillir tour à tour en donnant et recevant les
noms de sublimité, d'excellence, de magnificence, de grandeur,
d'éminence, de révérence, et de quantité d'autres dont le rapport
était toujours frivole et souvent ridicule. Le mérite baissa en même
proportion que haussèrent les titres.
Quoique toute cette vanité eût commencé avant
Constantin, et qu'elle se soit augmentée après lui, xiv. Luxe de
il mérite qu'on lui en attribue une partie. Fondateur Constantin.
de Constantinople, il en pouvait être le législateur:
c'était l'occasion la plus favorable de réformer les Jul. in Cæs. p.
mœurs, et de les ramener à l'ancienne sévérité. Au 318 et 336 ed.
lieu d'orner ses sénateurs et ses magistrats de tant Spanh.
de pompe extérieure, il eût pu les décorer de
vertus en resserrant les nœuds de la discipline. Sa Vict. epit. p.
ville n'eût rien perdu de son éclat; elle aurait gagné 224.
du côté de la solide et véritable grandeur: Rome et
tout l'empire auraient profité de cet exemple. Mais
Constantin aimait l'appareil; et les reproches que Cedren. t. 1, p.
lui fait Julien quoique envenimés par la haine, ne 295.
paraissent pourtant pas destitués de fondement. Il
multiplia sur l'habit impérial les perles, dont Ducange, de
Dioclétien avait introduit l'usage; il affectait de numm. inf. ævi,
porter toujours le diadème, dont il fit une espèce c. 17.
de casque ou de couronne fermée et semée de
pierreries. Il donna cours au luxe en enrichissant La Bléterie, note
trop certains particuliers, dont la fortune excita une sur les Césars
dangereuse émulation de faste et d'opulence. de Julien, p.
Cependant, quoiqu'il ne fût pas ennemi des plaisirs 212 et 213.
honnêtes, il n'en fut rien moins que l'esclave, tel
que Julien le représente. Il s'occupa toute sa vie des affaires de l'état
et peut-être un peu trop de celles de l'église. Il composait lui-même
ses lois et ses dépêches; il donnait de fréquentes audiences, et
recevait avec affabilité tous ceux qui s'adressaient à lui; et s'il porta
trop loin la magnificence des fêtes et la pompe de sa cour, c'était un
délassement qu'on peut pardonner à ses travaux et à ses victoires.
Après avoir rassemblé sous un seul aspect ce qui
regarde la fondation de Constantinople et les xv. Suite de
principaux changements que cet établissement l'histoire de
produisit dans l'ordre politique, nous allons Constantin.
reprendre la suite des faits. L'année 331, sous le
consulat de Bassus et d'Ablabius, fut employée à Idat. chron. Zos.
faire des lois et à régler plusieurs affaires de l. 2, c. 31.
l'église, dont nous parlerons ailleurs. Dès l'année
suivante 332, Pacatianus et Hilarianus étant An. 331.
consuls, l'empereur reprit les armes, d'abord pour
défendre les Sarmates, et ensuite pour les punir.
Zosime avance que depuis que Constantinople fut An 332.
bâtie, le bonheur de Constantin l'abandonna, et
qu'il ne fit plus la guerre que pour y recevoir des affronts. Il raconte
qu'un parti de cinq cents cavaliers Taïfales s'étant jeté sur les terres
de l'empire, Constantin n'osa en venir aux mains avec eux; mais
qu'ayant perdu la plus grande partie de son armée (il ne dit pas
comment), effrayé des ravages de ces Barbares, qui venaient
l'insulter jusqu'aux portes de son camp, il se crut trop heureux de se
sauver par la fuite. Ce récit ne s'accorde ni avec le caractère de
Constantin, ni avec tous les autres témoignages de l'histoire, qui
nous montre ce prince toujours victorieux.
Il le fut encore deux fois cette année. Les
Sarmates attaqués par les Goths implorèrent le xvi. Guerre
secours des Romains. Le prince leva une grande contre les
armée pour les défendre, et renouvela à cette Goths.
occasion la loi qui obligeait les fils des soldats
vétérans, au-dessus de l'âge de seize ans, à porter Idat. chron.
les armes, s'ils voulaient profiter des priviléges Anony. Vales.
accordés à leurs pères. Il s'avança lui-même
jusqu'à Marcianopolis dans la basse Mésie, et fit Euseb. vit.
passer le Danube à son fils Constantin à la tête de Const., l. 4, c. 5.
ses troupes. Le jeune César remporta le 20 avril
une glorieuse victoire[59]. Près de cent mille
Socr. l. 1, c. 18.
ennemis périrent dans cette guerre par le fer, par
la faim et par le froid[60]. Les Goths furent réduits à Soz. l. 1, c. 8.
donner des ôtages, entre lesquels était le fils de
leur roi Ariaric. Cette défaite les tint en respect
pendant le reste de la vie de Constantin et sous le Themist. or. 15,
p. 191.
règne de son fils Constance. La pension annuelle
que les princes précédents s'étaient engagés à
leur payer, au grand déshonneur de l'empire, fut Cod. Th. lib. 7,
abolie; les Goths s'obligèrent même à fournir aux t. 22. leg. 4 et
Romains quarante mille hommes, qui étaient ibi Godef.
entretenus sous le titre d'alliés[61]. La religion
chrétienne s'étendit chez eux, et avec elle [Julian, or. 1, p.
l'humanité et la douceur des mœurs. Comme la 9, ed. Spanh.
nation était partagée en un grand nombre de
peuples, tous n'eurent pas le même sort. Aurel. Vict. de
Constantin sut gagner, par des négociations et des Cæs. p. 177.
ambassades, ceux qu'il n'avait pas réduits par les
armes. Il se fit aimer de ces anciens ennemis de Eutr. l. 10.]
l'empire, et porta peut-être un peu trop loin la
facilité à leur égard, en élevant les plus distingués aux honneurs et
aux dignités. Il fit même ériger une statue dans Constantinople à un
de leurs rois, père d'Athanaric, pour retenir ce prince barbare dans
les intérêts des Romains.
[59] Gibbon, rapporte (t. iii. p. 448) que Constantin fut vaincu par les Goths dans
une première bataille. Aucun auteur ancien ne fait mention d'un tel événement.
C'est sans aucun doute une erreur de Gibbon.—S.-M.
[60] Il existe des médailles frappées à l'occasion des succès que Constantin obtint
dans cette guerre. Elles portent la légende VICTORIA GOTHICA. Voyez Eckhel,
Doct. num. vet., t. viii, p. 90.—S.-M.
[61] Selon Jornandès (de reb. Get. c. 21), ce sont les rois des Goths, Araric et
Aoric, qui fournirent à Constantin un corps de quarante mille auxiliaires.—S.-M.
—[Pendant que Constantin et son fils combattaient
les Goths dans la Thrace et sur les bords du [Constant.
Danube, une diversion s'était opérée sur un autre Porphyr. de
point en faveur des Romains. L'empereur se adm. imp. c.
53.]
rappelant des relations d'amitié qui avaient existé
autrefois entre son père Constance et les Chersonites[62], peuple
grec qui avait conservé une existence indépendante au milieu des
Barbares de la Tauride, il eut l'idée de s'adresser à leur république
pour en obtenir des secours. La situation de leur pays était tout-à-fait
avantageuse pour attaquer les Goths, sur leur propre territoire. La
proposition de Constantin fut bien accueillie par Diogène, fils de
Diogène, qui était à cette époque chef et stéphanéphore[63] de
Cherson[64]. Un armement fut préparé; on envoya aussitôt des chars
de guerre et des arbalétriers[65] sur les bords du Danube, où les
Goths furent défaits par les Chersonites. Constantin, touché du
service que ces Grecs lui avaient rendu, manda après la guerre
leurs chefs dans la ville impériale, où il les combla d'honneurs et de
distinctions flatteuses. Il ne borna pas là sa reconnaissance; des
distributions de vivres et de matériaux, pour la construction de
machines de guerre, furent faites aux Chersonites, qui obtinrent en
outre pour leurs bâtiments de commerce, et pour tous les particuliers
de leur nation, des immunités et de grands priviléges dans toutes les
parties de l'empire.]—S.-M.
[62] La ville de Cherson nommée d'abord Chersonesus, avait été fondée par une
colonie venue d'Héraclée en Bithynie, dont elle avait aussi porté le nom. Long-
temps indépendante et riche par son commerce, elle fut obligée, pour échapper à
la domination des Scythes, de se mettre, environ un siècle avant notre ère, sous la
protection du célèbre Mithridate Eupator, roi de Pont, qui prit le titre de Prostate de
cette ville (Strab., l. 7, p. 308). Elle fut ensuite soumise aux rois du Bosphore; et
plus tard, au premier siècle de notre ère, elle avait recouvré sa liberté, par
l'intervention des Romains (Plin., IV, c. 12).—S.-M.
[63] Στεφανηφοροῦντος και πρωτέυοντος τος τῆς Χερσωνιτών Διογένους του
Διογένους. Presque toutes les colonies grecques répandues dans la Chersonèse
taurique et sur les côtes de la mer Noire, étaient d'origine ionienne et pour la
plupart venues de Milet. Le premier magistrat de cette ville avait le titre de
Stéphanéphore, ou Porte-Couronne, ce qui se pratiquait aussi dans d'autres cités
ioniennes. On ne doit donc pas être surpris de voir désigné de la même façon le
suprême magistrat d'une république, qui, quoique d'origine dorienne, étant
environnée partout de républiques ioniennes, a pu imiter leurs usages.—S.-M.
[64] Gibbon (t. iii, p. 449) a confondu les habitants de la ville de Cherson, l'antique
Chersonesus, avec les peuples de la Chersonèse taurique. S'il avait lu avec plus
d'attention le chapitre de Constantin Porphyrogénète, d'où ce récit est tiré, il y
aurait vu que cet auteur distingue bien la république de Cherson, du reste de la
presqu'île Taurique, possédée alors par les rois du Bosphore cimmérien, et que la
ville de Cherson fournit seule des secours aux Romains. L'historien anglais se
trompe encore en disant que le stéphanéphore des Chersonites était un magistrat
perpétuel, tandis qu'il est si facile de reconnaître, par la grande quantité des
stéphanéphores de Cherson mentionnés par Constantin Porphyrogénète, que ces
magistrats étaient annuels, comme presque tous ceux qui gouvernaient les
républiques grecques.—S.-M.
[65] Τὰ πολεμικὰ άρματα καὶ τὰς χειροβολίσρας. On entend par ce dernier mot des
balistes qui se manœuvraient avec la main, par conséquent une espèce
d'arbalète.—S.-M.