Professional Documents
Culture Documents
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
karsresIr
nig
karfVaybgM
edayelak
eG> EGl nig cy hIl
www.gillministries.com
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
GMBIGkniBn
elakeG>EGl nigcy hIl KWCaGkmancMeNHevahaCaGnrCati CaGkniBn RBmTaMgCaGkbeRgnRBHKm<Ir.
enAkgebskkmkargarCasavkrbs;Kat; elakeG>EGl )aneFVIdMeNIreTACaeRcInRbeTsnCnCatinana Cag50CnCati
elIBiPBelak eday)anGFib,ayeTAkan;hVgmnusSrab;ryBan;nak; nigmanmnusSCaeRcInrab;lannak; )ansab;tamviT
nigTsSnatam TUrTsSn_pgEdr .
BYkeKmanesovePAemeronCaeRcIn EdlmanCagBIrlank,al )andak;lk;enAshrdGaemrik . BYkeK)an
sresresovePACaeRcIn Edl)anbkERbCaeRcInPasa nigRtv)aneKykeTAeRbIenAsalaRBHKm<Ir RBmTaMgfak;sika
salaenACuMvijBiPBelak .
CIvitEdlmankarpas;ERbeBjeedayGMNac
Edl)anmkBIesckIBitedaysarRBHbnlnRBH
)anpHecj
eLIgeTAdl;CIvitGkdTeTot tamrykarGFib,ay karbeRgn karsresrdmanTwkdmrbs;BYkeK RBmTaMgkarpSay tamvIedGU
nigtam rykarsab;GUDIy:Urbs;BYkeK .
sirIldKYr[RBWRBcnRBHvtmanrbs;RBH KWRtv)anTTYlkarBiesaFn_enAkgkarsresIr nigkarfVaybgM enAkg
kmviFIsikasalaepSg eBlEdlGkeCOTaMgLay)anRsavRCavrkeXIjnUvrebob EdleFVI[BYkeK)ankayCaGkfVay bgMRBH
edayesckIBit nigedayGs;BIcit . manmnusSCaeRcIn)anRsavRCavrkeXIjnUvxatnCyCmHfI nigKYr[ PJak;epIl RBmTaMgman
PaBkahan tamrykarbeRgnrbs;BYkeK GMBIsiTiGMNacrbs;GkeCO .
rIGkRsIhIl)anbNHbNaldl;GkeCOCaeRcIn
CaCMhaneq<aHeTAkan;kargarCaGFiFmCati
EdlRBHRTg;
)anRbTandl;BYkeKedaypal;xnmak; edayGMNacnkareR)as[Carbs;RBH EdlhUrtamrydrbs;BYkeK . man
mnusSCaeRcIn)aneron edIm,I[)anTTYlnUvkarGsartamrebobGFiFmCati EdlBYkeK)anbgrtKaeTAdl;GkdT eTot
tamryGMeNayTan TaMg9nRBHviBaaNbrisuTkgkarrs;enA nigkarbMeBjkargarrbs;BYkeK .
TaMgelakeG>EGl nigGkRsIcy )ansikSa ehIyTTYl)annUvkRmitfak;m:asrneTvviTa . rIelakeG>EGl
kcg;)anTTYltMENgbNitEpkTsSnviCa enAkgkRmitfak;eTvviTa EdlecjBIsklviTalyTsSnRKIsanpgEdr .
kickargarrbs;eK )antaMgmUldanRKwHenAelIRBHbnlRBH KW)antaMgelIRBHeysUv edIm,I[manesckICMenOrwgmaM RBm TaMg)anbeRgn
edaynUvGMNacecsanRBHviBaaNbrisuT .
kargarrbs;eK KWCakarbgajbMPWmkBIesckIRsLaj;dGs;BIcitnRBHdCaRBHvrbita . karGFib,ay nigkar beRgn
rbs;BYkeK KW)anRbRBwteTAedayGMNacnkarcak;eRbgtaMg EdlmanTIsmal; karGsar nigkareR)as[Ca KWCakarGsar
EdlmanrlkrMeBIk eRkamGMNacRBHecsarbs;RBH .
TIsmal;drs;revIk Edlrab;bBalnUvsMeNIcbrisuT karyMenAcMeBaHRBHPkrbs;RBHGmas; RBmTaMgkarsEmg
nUvkarRBWRBcnsirIlrbs;RBH nigGMNacEdlRtv)anTTYlkarBiesaFn_tammnusSCaeRcIn Edl)ancUlrYmRbCuMrbs;BYk eK .
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
RBHbnleTAkan;RKbeRgn nigsisS
enAkgkarsikSaeneron karsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM enaHBYkGkeCOnwgrukrk[eXIj nUvesckIGMNr KWCa
clnaenAkgRBHvtmannRBH nigkgkarrMedaHviBaaNrbs;BYkeK enAkgRKb;TaMGMNacecsa karRss;Rsay KWCakar
cglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgdx<g;xs; nigkarfVaybgMRbkbedaykarCitsiT cMeBaHRBH karTaMgenHKWmanenAkgRBH Km<Ir .
edaynUvesckIBitEdl)anebIksEmgenAkgesovePAenH BYkGkeCOnwg)anRtLb;mkCaGkfVaybgMdl;RBHCa RbcaMf .
karTmHcUleTAkgviBaaNdeBjedayGMNacecsa
enaHnwgekIteLIgenAkgCIvitmnusSTaMgGs;
Edlnwg
{Rbjab;cUleTARBH} edaymanesckIseRmccitfI edIm,IrMedaHrUbkay RBlwg nigviBaaNrbs;BYkeK[mankar BiesaFn_RKb;TaMgGs;
EdlCakarebIksEmgnUvGMNacecsaTaMgenH [CaCIvitsikSaEdlmankarpas;br)an .
vaCakarsMxan;cMeBaHeBlevlaenaH KWRtv)aneKcMNay minEmnRtwmEtCakarsikSanUvesckIBitTaMg enHenaHeT
KWCakarGnuvtn_ nigCakarBiesaFn_nUvRKb;karTaMgGs; EdlCakarebIksEmgenAkgemeronTaMgenH enAeBlEdlkarTaMg enHekIteLIg
KWCaRBHvtman nigsirIlrbs;RBHdelIslub EdlnwgRtv)anebIksEmg .
eyIgmansMNUmBrmuneBlbeRgnemeronenH sUm[elakGkGanesovePATaMgLay nigsab;tamkaEstefb
TaMgLayEdlmanbBaIraynamdUcCa sMNUmBrnkarGan nigkarsab; CaedIm . elakGkGacTTYlkarRCtRCab eTA
elIesckIBitnRBHbnlrbs;RBH KWCakarykcitTukdak;tamryemeron karsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM edayxng
pal;eRcInb:uNa enaHesckIBitnwgeFVIclnaecjBIKMnit nigviBaaNrbs;elakGkeRcInb:ueNaHEdr . bnab;BIenaHmk
esovePAenHnwgpl;nUvkarsegbdl;elakGk edIm,I[)aneRbIR)as dUcCaelakGkEck[nUvesckITukcitTaMgenHeTAdl;
GkdTeTotEdr .
karebIksEmgBICIvitEdlmanlkNCabuKl KWCatRmvkarnesckIbeRgndCak;lak;bMput . GkniBn)an
lubecjnUvkarTaMgenH ecjBIkickargarTaMgenH edIm,I[RKbeRgnpl;[nUvkarebIksEmg BIkar BiesaFn_rbs;xnpal;
eTAdl;sisSTaMgLayNa EdlmanlTPaBGacTTYl)an . vanwgEtgEtRtv)aneKcgcaMfa RBHviBaaNbrisuT EdlRTg;
)anyagmkedIm,IbeRgneyIgnUvRKb;karTaMgGs; . ehIyenAeBlEdleyIgkMBugeFVI beBlEdleyIgkMBugbeRgn enaH
eyIgEtgEtRtv)anpl;[nUvGMNac RBmTaMgRtv)an RbTan[edaynUvRBHviBaa brisuT .
karsikSaenHKWCakarRbesIrbMput sRmab;karsikSaCalkNbuKl bCakarsikSatamRkm salaRBHKm<Ir
salaeronfGaTit RBmTaMgRkmsikSatampH .
KWCakarsMxan; TaMgRKTaMgsisS EdlRtvEtmanesovePAemeron[)anRKb;d kgeBlEdlkMBugsikSa . esov
ePAemeronl eyIgRtvEtsresrkt;RtacuH KUsbnat;xageRkamBaksMxan; BinitBicarNanUvRKb;TaMg BaknImYy
RBmTaMgecHsegbGtbTpgEdr . eyIg)anTuk[mancenaHsRmab;elakGkkt;Rta nigeFVIesckIsegb . rebobrbb
Rtv)aneKerobcMTukCamun edaymanRbBnxeyag GacemIl)anrhsTan;cit sRmab;[elakGkemIlsareLIgvij nig
CYy[elakGk)anrkeXIjenAkEngdEdlmgeTot)an . manrebobrbbBiess EdleFVI[manlTPaBsRmab; mak;
BYkeK)ansikSaEtmgb:ueNaH tamrysmarenH edIm,IbeRgnnUvmatikaenH eTAdl;GkdTeTot .
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
elaksavkb:ul )ansresreTAkan;elakFIm:Ueffa
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
matika
emeronTI 1
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM -----------------------------------------------------------------------17
emeronTI 2
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM -------------------------------------------------------------------- 29
emeronTI 3
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg --------------------------------------------------------43
emeronTI 4
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH ------------------------------------------------------------- 55
emeronTI 5
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir ----------------------------------------------------- 69
emeronTI 6
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg -------------------------------------------------- 81
emeronTI 7
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM -------------------------------------------------------93
emeronTI 8
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay -------------------------------------------------- 103
emeronTI 9
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg ------------------------------------------------------------------ 117
emeronTI 10
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr ------------------------------------------------------------------ 131
emeronTI 11
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg ------------------------------------------------------147
emeronTI 12
GMBIkarrs;enACasg ------------------------------------------------------------------------- 163
emeronTI 13
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM -----------------------------------------------------175
emeronTI 14
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM----------------------------------------------------189
emeronTI 15
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM --------------------------------------------------------------205
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
esckIepIm
sUm,IEtenAeBlEdlelakeGIr:undCasg
)ancUleTAkgerag]e)asfrbs;elakm:UesRbcaMfkeday
ehIyeRkaymkk)ancUleTAkgRBHviharrbs;escsaLm:Un rIsmysBVfenH eyIgCaGkeCO KWCaBYksg
kRtvEtcUleTAkgRBHvtmanrbs;RTg;CaRbcaMfpgEdr .
eragg]e)asfrbs;elakm:Ues )anekIteLIgdl;TVarEdl)anGnuBaat[cUleTAxagkgTIlan . BYk
GkeCOTaMgGs;GaccUleTA)anRtwmTIlanxageRkA . rIBYksg )ancUleTAeFVIskmPaBedayqgkat;tam TIlan
edIm,IeTAbMeBjkargarfVaydl;RBHGmas; enAkgTIbrisuT . kgmYyqaMmg semcsgGaccUleTA kgTIbrisuTbMput
EdlmanhwbnesckIsBaarbs;RBH .
TIbrisuTbMputKWCasMeNAmnusSEdlenAEpndI EdlesInwgblgEdlenAsansYK KWCabnb;rbs;RBH .
hwbEdlmanKRmbRKbedaymanTIsenaseR)as KWCaTIkEngenAEpndI KWCaRbePTnblgrbs;RBH . edIm,I
[)ancUleTAkgTIbrisuTbMput KWRtvEt[)anenAkgRBHvtmannRBHy:agsiTsalsin .
kgmYyrMeBcEd;lRBHeysUvRTg;)ansuKtenAelIeQIqag enaHvaMgnnEdl)aMgxNCakNalrvag mnusS
nigRBH KW)anrEhkdac;ecjCaGFiFmCati cab;BIelIrhUteRkam . mnusSminRtvkardac;ecjBIRBH
edaysarGMeBI)abyUrGEgVgeLIy . GMeBI)abrbs;mnusSRtvEt)anTTYlnUvkarGt;eTas[ . \LvenH mnusSRbs-RsI
GaccUleTAkgRBHvtmannRBHedayGg;GacehIy .
sUm,IEtmankareCOneTAmuxkgkarcUleTAxagkg edayBYksgEdlenAkgRBHKm<IrsBaacas;k eday
kmankareCOneTAmuxkgkarcUleTAxagkgenAsmysBVfenHEdr
KWeyIgCaBYkGkeCOCasg
Edl
)ancUlmkkgRBHvtmannRBHGgCaRbcaMf kgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgMpgEdr . eyIgRtvEtcUl
eTAkgCaRbcaMfedaypal;xn enAeBlsresIrtemIgenaHEdr . eyIgRtvEtcUleTAedayrYmKa CamYynwg
rUbkayTaMgmUl KWkgeBleyIgcUleTAedayrYmKaenaHg . edIm,IcUleTAtamkartRmv[mannUvskmPaB sab;bgab;
cMeBaHEpkrbs;eyIg . RBHRTg;seRmcRBHTyfa eyIgcUleTAkgRBHvtmannRBH enaHeyIgRtv
Etcab;yknUvkarpgepImedIm,IeFVIkary:agdUecaH .
TImYy eyIgRtvTTYlnUvkarbeRgnedayescdavID edIm,I
cUrnaMKacUltamTVarRTg; edayeBalBakGrRBHKuN ehIycUleTAkgTIlanRTg; edaybTsresIr
cUrGrRBHKuNdl;RTg; ehIysresIrRBHnamRTg;cuH TMnukdMekIg 1004 .
9
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
11
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
12
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
emeronTI 1
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
esckIepIm
manclnamYydfI Rss;nRBHviBaaNbrisuT EdleFVI[
mankarBiesaFn_enACuMvijBiPBelak . m:ageTot kargarfVaybgM
enAkgBYkCMnuMCaeRcIn KWhak;dUcCamankaresaHkeRkaH nigmankar
esakseRggeTAvij . ceRmgtamTMenomTmab; KW)anpusecjBI
kgcitmkRtwmEtBak;kNalb:ueNaH EdlCaceRmgdkRsg;ecjBI
TMnuktemIgcas;mkenaH . enAsmysBVfenH KWminEdlRtv)an
eKEsVgrkeXIjBYkGkeCOEdlenAkg BYkCMnuMCaeRcIn [)anman
CMhrkgkareRcgsresIr karTHdsresIr edaydrbs;BYkeK RBm
TaMgkarsresIrtemIgenAcMeBaHRBHPknRBHGmas;eLIy . man
karBiesaFn_CaeRcIncMeBaHGtnynkarfVaybgMdBit enaHKWCakar
EdlBYkeK)anlutCgg;cuH ehIyelIkdeLIgsresIrdl;RBH TaMg
Rsk;TwkEPkecjBIEPkrbs;BYkeK edIm,IkuM[TTYlkar)at;bg;nUvRBH
vtmannRBH enAeBlEdlBYkeKkMBugEteRcgsresIrtemIgdl;RBH
edIm,I[kar fVaybgMdl;RTg;enaHmankmaMgkan;EtxaMgkaeLIg .
RKb;RbePT]bkrN_ePgTaMgGs; KWRtvEtRbKl;[eTABYkCMnuM
vij. enAkgRBHviharKWminRtv)anRbKuMbTceRmgdyUrGEgVgeLIy
KWBYkRkmceRmg bBYkGkceRmgmankarRbkbTak;TgCamYynwg
RBH edaymanryeBlxIb:ueNaH. pyeTAvij BYkGkeCOTaMgLay
KWmankarBiesaFn_ kgkarcak;eRbgtaMgrbs;RBH tammeFa)ayfI
Cab;Canic .
13
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
Cajwkjab; sirIlrbs;pgRBHEtgcak;bMeBjmkdl;sal
RbCuM KWCaGMeNaecsarbs;RTg;)anbk;e)akqgkat;RBHvihar eday
manCakarrlkrMeBIkeLIg . dUcCaenAkgfnkarqgRBHvihar KWva
manlTPaBcMeBaH karQrenAelIbegalBBknsirIlrbs;RTg;
dUecaHEdr .
RBHKm<Ir1BgSavtarkSRt 810/11 Ecgfa luHBYksg
)anecjBITIbrisuTmkvij enaHBBkkmkeBjkgRBHviharnRBH
eyhUv:a l;em:H)anCaBYksgQreFVIkargarBuM)an edayeRBaHBBk
enaH d,itsirIlnRBHeyhUv:a)anenAeBjkgRBHviharnRBHGg
ehIy .
kartaMgBiBNrbs;escdavID
escdavIDKWCamYyGg Edl)anecHBIrebobfVaynUvkarsresIr
dl;RBH . cUreyIgRkeLkemIleTABakesaknkartaMgBiBN Edl
manBak;kNal KWCaGVIEdlRBHviBaaNbrisuTRTg; )ankMBugEteFVIenA
smysBVfenH kgkarEknUvkarfVaybgMdBitdl;BYkCMnuMrbs;RTg;.
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1501-6 Ecgfa cUrsresIrdl;RBH
eyhUv:a cUrsresIrdl;RBH enAkgTIbrisuTrbs;RTg; cUrsresIrdl;
RTg; enAcenaHGakas CaTIsMEdgRBHecsaRTg; cUrsresIrdl;RTg;
edayeRBaHkar\TibTirbs;RTg; cUrsresIrdl;RTg; [smnwgsNan
dFMRbesIrrbs;RTg; cUrsresIrRTg;edayERt cUrsresIrdl;RTg;
edayedjBiN nigcab;sug cUrsresIrdl;RTg;edayvayRkab;
ehIyelatkeBag cUrsresIrRTg;edayRbdab;manExS ehIynigxy
cUrsresIrdl;RTg;edayvayQwg[BrgM cUrsresIrRTg;edayvay
QwgBsUrrMBg KYr[CIvitTaMgLayEdlmandegIm )ansresIrdl;
RBHeyhUv:a cUrsrsIrdl;RBHeyhUv:acuH .
14
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
eyIgral;KaKYrKb,IsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGmas;
niymny
karsresIrtemIg
karfVaybgM
karfVaybgMKWCaTRmg;dx<s;bMputnkarsresIrtemIg. cMeBaH
RKb;TaMgdMeNIrnRBHBrdGsarEdlhYsBIKMnit EdleyIg)anKit
enaH KWeyIgkMBugEtcglbgajnUvkarekatsresIr nigkarelIk
temIgrbs;eyIgdl;RBH sRmab;PaBCabuKl buKliklkNrbs;
RTg; Edl)ankMNt;edaymanPaBRKb;lkN_ .
eyIgral;KakMBugEtbMeBjkargarfVayRBH sRmab;Gs;Gk
EdlRTg;)antaMgeLIg KWminRtwEtsRmab;GVIEdlRTg;)aneFVIsRmab;
eyIgrYcehIyenaHeLIy .
kareRbbeFobBIkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
karsresIrtemIg
karsresIrtemIgKWCa
karniyaynUvBaksmIleTAkan;RBH
karcglbgajBIkarekatsresIrsRmab;>>>
kareBalBaksresIr
karelIksresIr
karsEmgnUvesckIsresIr
15
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
karsresIredayTHd
karEfgnUvBaksresIr
karsresIrtemIgKWCakarniyay bCakareRcgGMBIRBHfa
RTg;KWCa RBHdGsar KWsRmab;GVIEdlRTg;)aneFVIsRmab;eyIg
ral;KaenaHg .
karfVaybgM
karsresIrtemIgdx<s;bMput
karfVaybgMKWCa
karcglbgajnUvkarfVaybgMedaylutCgg;eKarB
karmanviBaaNekatxac
karRkabcuHy:agTabbMputenAkgkarfVaybgM
kareKarBdmantm
karfVayRKb;karTaMgGs;eTARBH
karfVaybgMKWCakarniyay bCakareRcgfVayeTAkan;RBH .
elakGk)anqgputnUvcMNucnkarKitGMBIerOgr:av EdlRTg;)aneFVI
seRmc RBmTaMg)ancUleTAkgkarfVaybgM KWcMeBaHGs;GkEdl
RTg;)aneRCIserIsTuk.
karfVaybgMKWCaTRmg;nkarsresIrtemIgdx<s;bMput .
TImYyKWCa
karsEmgGakb,kiriyaGs;BIcit
kartaMgciteKarBdmaMmYncMeBaHRBHGaTikr
karcab;epImnUvkarCBawgKitenAkgcitdGs;BIcit
karCBawgKitdmanCeRmAeRCAcMeBaHPaBdFM]tm nigPaB
mantmrbs;RBH .
16
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
bnab;mkvanwgmankarbgrmkedaykgnKMnit
nig
GarmN_ . karfVaybgMminGacRtv)aneK {begIteLIg} )anenaH
eLIy KWvaRtvEt)an eKbBalvaeTAdl;Epkxagkgvij .
CaTIbBab; vaCakarcak;ecjnRBlwg edaykarcglbgajd
manCeRmAeRCAnkareKarBy:agRCaleRCA karekatxacxaMg kar
Gsar nigkareKarBCaedIm .
etIkarfVaybgMKWCaGVI?
muneBlEdleyIgGaccUleTAkgkarfVaybgM enaHKWCakar
caM)ac; [yl;nUvGVICakarfVaybgMenaH .
edaynUvRBHviBaaN
eyIgGacfVaynUvkarfVaybgMdBitdl;RBH EdlecjBIviBaaN
rbs;eyIgral;Ka .
RBHKm<Iry:Uhan 1424 Ecgfa GkNaEdlminRsLaj;
enaHminkan;tamBakeT BakEdlGkral;KaB enaHminEmnCa
Bak KWCaRBHbnlrbs;RBHvrbita EdlRTg;cat;[mkeTetI .
karfVaybgMedayviBaaN KWRtvEtfVaybgMedayGs;BIcit
rbs;eyIg karfVaybgMedayviBaaN kmannyfa CakarfVaybgM
EdlecjBIcitrbs;eyIg edaynUvGMNacecsanRBHviBaaNbrisuT
EdlRKb;TaMgGs;KWsitenA Epkxagkg esIrEtRKb;kEngdUcKa
EdlRBHKm<Ir)anehAfa Cacit bCa viBaaNrbs;eyIg .
edayesckIBit
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
eyIgminGacfVaybgMRBH)an tamEpkxagsac;Qamrbs;
eyIgenaH)aneLIy KWvaCakarsMxan;edIm,Ismat nUvRKb;TaMgKMnit
xagsac;QamTaMgGs;rbs;eyIg RBmTaMgesckIGaRkk; edIm,I[
viBaaNrbs;eyIg GacfVaybgMRBHedaynUvRBHviBaaNrbs;RTg;
)an .
RBHKm<IrkUl:Us 35 Ecgfa dUecHcUrsMLab;nisSysac;
Qamrbs;Gkral;Ka EdlenAEpndIenHecj KWCakarshaysn;
esakeRKak sMerIbsMral b:gR)afaGaRkk; nigesckIelaP Edlrab;
TukdUcCakarfVaybgMrUbRBH .
RBHKm<IrkUl:Us 316/17 Ecgfa cUr[RBHbnlnRBH
RKIs )ansNitenAkgGkral;KaCabribUr edayR)aCJaRKb;y:ag TaMg
beRgnehIyTUnanKa edaynUvTMnukdMekIg TMnukbrisuT nigcMerog
xagviBaaN TaMgeRcgkgcitfVayRBH edayRBHKuN ehIykg
RKb;karTaMgGs; eTaHebIkarGVIEdlGkral;KanwgeFVI edayBaksMdI
bkiriyakedaycUreFVITaMgGs; edayRBHnamnRBHGmas;eysUv
TaMgGrRBHKuNdl;RBHdCaRBHvrbita edaysarRTg;pg .
eyIgRtvEtsmatedayxng nigfVaybgMRBHEdlecjBIcit
dbrisuTenaH. sac;QamminGacfVaybgMRBH)aneLIy . RbsinebI
18
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
eyIg)anTuMlmehIy enaHRKb;TaMgGs;Edlmin)aneFVIsRmab;RBH
enaHnwgmin)anbnSl;TukeLIy EtviBaaNrbs;eyIgnwgfVaybgM
edaynUvRBHviBaaNnRBHvij .
elakGR)ahaMKWCaKMrUTImYyrbs;eyIg
elakGR)ahaM)anfVaybgM
tamxeyagenAkgRBHKm<IrCadMbUgcMeBaHfVaybgM KWCakar
tPab;CamYynwgelakGR)ahaM .
RBHKm<Irelakub,ti 225 Ecgfa rYcR)ab;eTA)avfa cUrg
enATIenHsinemIllapg GjnwgeTAeNaHfVaybgMCamYynwgkUn
Gj rYcswmmkgvij .
RkwtvinyEdl)anebIksEmgelIkTImYy
maneKalkarN_nkarbkRsayRBHKm<Ir EdlRtv)anTTYl
karRtas;ehAfaCa {RkwtvinyEdl)anebIksEmgelIkTImYy} .
RBHKm<IrenaH)anEcgfa karebIksEmgtamRBHKm<IrCaTImYy n
RbFanbTCaeRcIn Edl)anRbTan[nUvkarbBaak;bgajy:agc,as;
mYynGtny nigesckIsMxan;rbs;va enATIkEngdTeTot Edl
)anekIteLIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir .
karCYbRbTHCaelIkTImYynBak {fVaybgM} KWRtv)aneKrk
eXIj enAeBlEdlelakGR)ahaMkMBugEt)anniyayCamYynwg
mnusSkemaH Edl)anelIktmdl;elakGsak nigdl;Kat; [eFVI
dMeNIreTAkan;PMm:Ura (Moriah) .
PaBFn;FrnkarfVaybgM KWRtv)anbgajtamkarebIksEmg
TImYyenH .
19
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
elakGR)ahaM)ansab;bgb;
karTTYlxusRtvrbs;elakGR)ahaM cMeBaHkartaMgsBaarbs;
RBH KWmanEtkarsab;bgab;EtmYyKt; .
KanmeFa)aysRmab;eyIgcMeBaHkarKitBIGVI eRkABIkarsab;
bgab;tamRBHraCbBatienH EdlCakarTamTarrbs;elakGR)ahaM
enaHeLIy . elakGsakKWCakUnnesckIsna . Kat;KWCaGkRtv
)anseRmctamesckIsBaa EdlRBHRTg;)aneFVICamYynwgelak
GR)ahaM .
yBabUCadman\TiBl
20
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
karfVaybgMdBitmannyfa mankarcuHcUlRKb;lkNTaMg
Gs; eTAdl;RBH .
skmPaBnkarsab;bgab; nigesckICMenO
skmPaBnkarfVaybgM KWCaskmPaBnkarsab;bgab; nig
esckICMenO . elakGR)ahaM KWBitR)akdNas; minEdlmankar
PaMgPat;cMeBaH karfVaybgMenHeLIy .
enAfTIbIndMeNIrrbs;Kat; edIm,InaMykelakGsakeTAfVay
CadgVay enaHelakGR)ahaM)anmanRbsasn_fa {eyIgnwgRtLb;
mkGkvij} .
skmPaBnkarsab;bgab; )anvilRtLb;mkskmPaBn
esckICMenOvij .
karcuHcUlTaMgRsugxagEpkrUbkay
esckIsab;rbs;elakGsak KWmannyfa CaesckIsab;RKb;
Ebby:ag EdlelakGR)ahaM)anrs;enAsRmab;RKb;karTaMgGs;
enaH . RKb;TaMgesckIsna enAkgkartaMgsBaa KWCamUldanRKwH
eTAelIkMeNItkUnRbsrbs;Kat;enaHg . RKb;y:agEdlKat;)aneCO
KWCakarrYmbBalCa mYynwgelakGsakenaHg . vaCaskmPaB
mYy EdlsrubmknUvkarcuH cUlcMeBaHRBHenaHg .
edaysarEtkarsab;bgab;rbs;elakGR)ahaM kgkarfVay
bgM enaHRBHRTg;)anKg;enAkgkarsresItemItgenaH RBmTaM)annaM
mknUvGMeNayTanBiessnesckICMenO Edl)anbgM[elak
GR)ahaMebCJafanwgfVayelakGsakTukCayBabUCa .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 223 Ecgfa b:uEn RBHEdl)antaMg
eLIg kgTMnuksresIrrbs;GRsaEGleGIy RTg;brisuT .
21
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
elakGR)ahaM)annaMkUnRbsrbs;Kat; ecjeTAkan;TIfVay
yBabUCa ehIykarenH)anRtLb;eTACaKMrUnkarfVayyBabUCa pac;
RBat;eTAvij . eRkaymkeyIgeXIjfa RBHdCaRBHvrbitaRTg;)an
bBandgVayyBabUCa KWCaRBHraCbuRtarbs;RTg;RBHnamRBHeysUv
RKIsmk . manRBwtikarN_mYydmankmaMg manlTPaB EdlRBH
eysUvRTg;)anRtvTTYlkareFVICayBabUCa CMnYs[elakGsak
EdlelakGR)ahaM)anbBaneTA[eFVICayBabUCaenaH .
eyIgRtvEtcuHcUlRKb;karTaMgGs; nUvkarseRmccitCa
lkNbuKl karelaPln;xaMg RBmTaMgdak;Epnkar cUleTAdl;TI
fVaybgMdBitvij .
kRmnkarsresIrtemIg
cMeBaHescsUl
karmanbBaaedayBYkviBaaNGaRkk;
karsresIr nigkarfVaybgM
karRbKMtnICakarnaMmknUvkarrMedaH
kMLgeBlEdlviBaaNGaRkk;)anmksNitelIescsUl enaH
davID)anykBiNrbs;Kat;mkelgfVay . bnab;mk escsUlk)an
TTYlkarFUres,IyeLIgvij KWRTg;manGarmN_leLIgvij ehIy
viBaaNGaRkk;enaH k)ancakecjBIRTg;eTA .
lRbesIrmannyfa eBareBjedayCMnaj . GkRbKMbTePg
nigGkceRmg KYrKb,IRtv)anTTYlnUvCMnajenH . GkbeRmIrbs;
escsUl )andwgnUvkarEsVgrkGkCMnajRbKMbTePg BIeRBaHBYkeK
Fab;)aneXIjnUvGMNacnkarRbKMbTePg edaymankarcak;eRbg
taMgCamun . davIDkRtv)anTTYlkareRCIserIsmkeFVIkarenaH .
sMNYrrMBksareLIgvij
1> cUrsresrBIniymny bkaryl;dwgBIkarsresIrtemIgrbs;elakGk .
2>
cUrsresrBIniymny bkaryl;dwgBIkarfVaybgMrbs;elakGk .
3>
23
emeronTI 2
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
karfVaybgMenAkgerag]e)asf
eKalkarN_dTeTotnkarbkRsayRBHKm<IrKWCa {c,ab;
Edl)ansresrTukCaeRcIn} . eKalkarN_enHEcgfa cMnYnnkar
sl;cenaHEdl)anRbTan[ nUvRbFanbTdBiessmYy EdlbBaak;
bgajBIsarsMxan;rbs;va .
enACMBUkTI51kgRBHKm<IrsBaacas; KWRtv)aneKe)aHbg;erag
]e)asf KWCakarbgajnUvnUvsarsMxan;rbs;BYkva cMeBaHeyIg .
karrMBkBIerag]e)asf nigBIRBHviharenAkgRBHKm<IrsBaacas;
manerag]e)asf nigRBHviharCaeRcIn Edl)anebIksEmg
enAkgRBHKm<IrsBaacas; . cab;taMgBIeBlEdlmankEngxVHxat
TaMgenH EdlBYkbNaCn)anCYbCamYynwgRBHenaH KWCakEngEdl
BYkeK)ancUleTAkgRBHvtmannRBHGg KWvaCakarsMxan;EdleyIg
mankaryl;dwgcMeBaHBYkeK nigkarepSgKarvagBYkeK .
erag]e)asfrbs;elakm:Ues
KMrU bbg;GaKarsRmab;erag]e)asfrbs;elakm:Ues KWRtv)an
RbTan[nUvkarlmitdBitR)akdedayRBHRTg;)aneFVITkmk . erag
]e)asfmannyfa tg; ehIymanRbeyaCn_ enAeBlEdlkUnecA
GuIRsaEGl )apas;brTIkEngqgkat;valrehasan .
erag]e)asfrbs;elakm:Ues KWCakEngfVaybgMenAkgRKa
sBaacas; . vaCakEngtaMgenAbeNaHGasnrbs;hwbnesckI
sBaa . enATIenaHehIy EdlmanRBHvtmannRBHKg;enA RBmTaMg
24
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
edaysarEtescdavIDCaGkeFVIsgam enaHRBHRTg;min)an
GnuBaat[RTg;sagsg;RBHvihareLIy . RBHRTg;)anRbTannUv
KeRmagEpnkar sRmab;sagsg;RBHvihardl;RTg; ehIyescdavID
)anRbmUlsmarmkBIRKb;kEng edIm,ITuksRmab;karsagsg;RBH
viharenaH .
rIhwbnesckIsBaaRtvdak;TukenAkgerag]e)asfrbs;es
cdavID Edlbnab;eRkaymkkRtv)annaMvilRtLb;eTAvij edayBYk
PIlIsIn eTAdak;enAmuxRBHviharrbs;escsaLm:Un Edl)ansag
sg;rYcehIyenaH .
eKAlbMNgCacm,gnerag]e)asfrbs;escdavID KWRtvEt
ebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgMRBH tammeFa)ayEdlRtvRbmUlpMmk
EtmYykEng .
rIerag]e)asfrbs;escdavID KWRtv)aneKemIleXIjtam
{bgc} cUleTAxagkg kgkarfVaybgMenARKasBaafI . bgcKWRtv
)aneFVIeLIgedayRbePTnRtsal bCaerag]e)asfenARKasBaa
cas; b:uEnenAxagkgKWRtv)aneKeFVIrYcral;ehIy edayEbbepSgKa
enaHg . rIBYksg)ancUleTAxagkgtamTVaredayGrRBHKuN
RBmTaMgcUl eTAdl;TIlannkarsresIr BIeRBaHhwbEdlmanRBH
vtmannRBH KWeBjeTAedaylMG . KanTIbrisuTbMputNa Edl
)aMgedayvagnneToteT KWmanEtyBabUCaEdlRtvykcUleTAfVay
Etb:ueNaH KWCayBabUCankarsresIrenaHg .
25
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
RBHviharrbs;escehr:Ut
RBHviharenHKWRtv)anTTYlkarsagsg;eLIg enARbEhlqaM
520 mun K>s> ehIykminEmnCaTIkEngEdlrugerOg dUcCaRBH
viharrbs;escsaLm:UnenaHeT KWmanTMhMFMCagmuneTAeTot . va
mankarxVHxateRKgsgarwm EdlmanenAkgRBHviharrbs;esc
saLm:UneTAeTot . rIhwbnesckIsBaaKWmankar)at;Gs;ehIy.
enAeBlEdlescehr:UD)anRKb;RKgelIsasn_yUda RTg;)an
sagsg;eLIgvijnUvRBHviharrbs;sUr:U)abil . escehr:UDmin)an
sagsg;eLIg edaymancitcg;fVaybgMenaHeT . RTg;RKan;Et)an
sagsg;eLIg edIm,IsEmgnUvesckIemaTnPaB KWRTg;)ansagsg;
eLIgnUvsMNg;GaKarCaeRcIn enAkgrCkalrbs;RTg;Etb:ueNaH .
RBHviharrbs;sUr:U)abil KWCaFmtab:ueNaH minEmnCarbs;Edl
manriTiGMNacRKb;RKan; sRmab;CakarsBVRBHTyrbs;RTg;enaH
eLIy . karEdlekIteLIgBitR)akd KWCaRBHviharrbs;escehr:UD
EdlRBHeysUvRTg;)anyagmk nigRTg;yagvilRtLb;eTAvij .
Rkmrbs;BYksgTaMgGs;enaH KWsuTEtCamuxgar ehIyKWEdlRBH
eysUvRTg;)anpab;tusRmab;dUrluyrbs;BYksgTaMgenaH .
RBHKm<Irm:afay 2112/13 Ecgfa RBHeysUv RTg;
yagcUleTAkgRBHvihar kbeNjGs;TaMgGkEdllk;dUrkgRBH
viharecj RTg;pab;tunBYkGkdUrR)ak; nigeCIgm:arbs;BYkGklk;
RBab ehIyRTg;manbnleTAeKfa manesckIEcgTukmkdUecH
dMNak;GjRtvehAfa CaTIsMrab;GFisan EtGkral;Ka)anyk
eFVICaeragecarvij .
27
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
enAeBlEdlRBHeysUvRTg;)ansuKtenAelIeQIqag vaMgnn
Edl)aMgenACakNalrvagTIbrisuT nigTIbrisuTbMput vaMgnnenaH
mankRmasRkasNas; KWRbEhlCa 7>2 sgIEm:Rt = 6 GuIg
eNaH KWekIteLIgBIPHGFiFmCati cab;BIelIdl;eRkam .
tamryRbvtisasnBUCBgSrbs;sasn_yUda KWmanEt
semcsgeT EdlGacecjcUlBITIbrisuTeTATIbrisuTbMput)an . TI
brisuTbMputKWCakEng Edl)anEfrkSahwbnesckIsBaaenAxagkg
enaH . KWCakEngEdlmanRBHvtmannRBHKg;enA . rMEhkvaMgnn
cab;BIelIcuHeTAeRkam KWCakarRbkasR)ab;fa kardac;ecjBIRBH
rbs;mnusSRtv)anpSHpSaeLIgvijehIy . mnusSCati\LvenHKW
manksiTikgkarcUlmkrkRBHvtmannRBHvijehIy
RBHeysUvRTg;)anEfgTMnayfa KanfRttelIfNanRBH
viharenH EdlminRtvbMpajenaHeLIy edayCnCatir:Um enAkgqaMTI
70 mun K>s> KWTaMgRBHvihar nigbrievnnRBHviharRtv)aneqH
excxI ehIyenAeBlEdlkMBugEteqHenaH mask)anrlay nighUr
cUleTAkgbMENkfenaHeTA . edIm,IeFVIkarykmasmk[)anvij
Tal;EtbMEbkfenaH dUcCaRBHeysUvRTg;)anEfgTMnayTukmk .
RBHKm<Irm:afay 242 Ecgfa EtRTg;manbnleTAeKfa
Gkral;KaeXIjvtTaMgenHbeT R)ab;Gkral;KaCaR)akdfa enATI
enHnwgKanfenARttelIf EdlminRtvTMlak;cuHenaHeT .
karedIrtamhwb
hwb)anenAkgerag]e)asfrbs;elakm:Ues rhUtdl;smy
rbs;elakeGlI . bnab;mk hwbenaHkRtv)aneKlYcykeTA KWCa
lTplnkarCMnuMCRmHdl;RkmRKsarrbs;elakeGlI .
RBHKm<Ir1saMyUEGl 230-35 Ecgfa ehtuenaH RBH
eyhUv:a CaRBHnsasn__GRsaEGl RTg;manbnlfa Gj)ansna
28
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
enaHkeXIjRBHdakun)andYlpab;muxdl;dI enACMeBaHhwbnRBH
eyhUv:a rYceKelIkRBHdakun eTAdak;enAkEngedImvij luHdl;f
EskeTot kaleKeRkakBIRBlwm enaHkeXIjRBHdakun)andYlpab;
muxdl;dI enACMeBaHhwbnRBHeyhUv:aeTotehIyk,al nigdTaMg
2nRBHdakun k)ak;dac; enAelIRkbTVar sl;enAEttYRBHdakun
bu:eNaH .
RBHhsnRBHeyhUv:a ksgt;elIBYkRkgGasdUDy:agFn;
RTg;bMpajeK ehIyvayeKedayeraKbsdUg)at enARkgGasdUD
nigRsukCMuvijTaMgGs; kalBYkGasdUDeXIjfa ekItmany:agdUecaH
enaHeKCMnMuKafa minRtv[hwbnRBHrbs;sasn__GRsaEGl enA
CamYynwgeyIgeToteLIy d,itRBHhsnRTg;sgt;elIeyIgral;Ka
Fn;Nas; ehIyelIRBHdakunCaRBHneyIgEdr .
hwbRtv)anbBanmkkan;RkgeyrUsaLimvij
edaysarEtkarCMnuMCRmHrbs;RBH enaHBYkPIlIsInk)anehA
rkBYksgrbs;eKTaMgGs; ehIysYrBYkeKBIrebobeFVIdUcemc [hwb
enaHGacbBanRtLb;eTAvij)an . BYkeKk)anTwmreTHnwgeKajI
mYyKU EdlenACab;bMe)AedaHkUnenAeLIy edIm,IdwkykhwbenaH
edayeKajIEdlbMe)AedaHkUnTaMgBIrenaHeTA . eRkABIenHeTot
eKajITaMgBIrenaHk)aneFVIdMeNIr eq<aHtRmg;eTAkan;TwkdIGuIRsaEGl
eTA .
RBHRTg;)anGnuBaat[BYkPIlIsIn dwkykhwbnwgreTHenaH
eTA . mincaM)ac;manmnusSNaedIm,IdwknaMhwbenaHykeTAeLIy .
b:uEn sUmemIl[eXIjnUvGVIEdl)anekIteLIg KWenAeBlEdlRbCa
rasrbs;RBH)anBayameFVIkardUcEdl)aneFVIenHcuH .
RBHKm<Ir1saMyUEGl 67/8 Ecgfa dUecH cUreFVIreTH1fI
ehIyykeKajI2EdlbMe)AkUn \tEdlmanGkNayknwmmkTwm
30
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
escdavID)ancgbrhwbBIKay:at;-y:arIm eTAkan;PMsuIy:Un
ehIykmankarRBmandxaMgmYy enAkgkarxMRbwgERbgbrTIkEng
hwbCaelIkTImYy .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 137/8/10 Ecgfa eKkykhwbn
RBHdak;elIreTHfI naMecjBIpHGbn:adab;mk manGusa nigGhy:UrCa
Gkbr davID nigBYkGRsaEGlTaMgGs;Ka eKkRbKMePgenAcMeBaH
RBHGs;BIkMLaMg RBmTaMgeRcgcMerogpg edaysug BiN Rkab;
Qwg nigERt>>> dUecH RBHeyhUv:aRTg;manesckIeRkaFnwgGusa k
RbharKat;bg; edayeRBaHKat;)anlUkdeTABal;hwbKat; ksab;
enATIenaHcMeBaHRBHeTA .
mankarsab;bgab;cMeBaHnItiRkmrbs;RBH EdlRtvEt)aneK
dwg nigRtveK)anykmkGnuvt . escdavIDKWCaGkTTYlxusRtv
KWRKan;EteyIgRtvEteFVI[)ansmrmenaHg {KWCac,ab;RBHvihar}
EdlRtveFVItam .
karsresIrtemIgKWminGaclak;nUvkarsab;bgab;eLIy
escdavID nigmnusSrbs;RTg; )aneRbIreTHedIm,IbrTIkEng
rbs;hwbenH)an KWTal;EtBYksgelvIb:ueNaH EdlGacEsghwb
CamYynwgeQIEsg . RBHvtmannRBH minGacRtv)andwknaMeday
reTHeLIy . KWRtvEt)andwknaMedaykar]TisfVay faetIRtveRCIs
erIsykmnusSRbePTNaenaHvij .
31
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
]e)asfrbs;elakm:Ues b:uEnsRmab;karesssl;nGayukal
rbs;davID ehIyrhUtdl;RBHviharrbs;escsaLm:UnRtv)anTTYl
karsagsg;ehIy eTIbGacRtv)anykhwbEdlmanRBHvtmann
RBH mkdak;enAkgerag]e)asfrbs;escdavID)an .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 161/4-9/31/34 Ecgfa eKnaMyk
hwbnRBHmk dak;enAkNalRtsal EdldavID)andMeLIgTuk
sMrab; rYckfVaydgVaydut nigdgVayemRtI enAcMeBaHRBH>>> RTg;k
dMrUvBYkelvIxH [eFVIkargarenAcMeBaHhwbnRBHeyhUv:a edIm,Inwg
rMBk GrRBHKuN ehIynigsresIrdl;RBHeyhUv:a CaRBHnsasn_
GRsaEGl KWeGsaPCaem ehIybnab;mkmansakarI yIEGl
esmIr:am:Ut eyhEGl m:aFiFa eGlab ebNay:aGUbiD-eGdMm
nigyIEGl suTEtkan;BiNnigsug ehIyeGsaPCaGkvayQwg[B
rgM ebNay:a nigy:ahaesol CaBYksg kpMERtCanic enAcMeBaH
hwbnesckIsBaapgRBH enAfenaHg davID)anbgab;mundMbUg [
mankarGrRBHKuNdl;RBHeyhUv:a edaysareGsaP nigBYkbgbn
elakfa cUrGrRBHKuNdl;RBHeyhUv:a cUrGMBavnavdl;RBHnamRTg;
cuH cUrsMEdgBIGs;TaMgkarnRTg; enAkNalRKb;TaMgsasn_ cUr
eRcgfVayRTg; cUreRcgsresIrdl;RTg;cuH cUrnwkfgBIGs;TaMgkar
Gsarrbs;RTg;>>> cUr[pemXmanesckIGMNr ehIy[EpndI)an
eRttGreLIg [)anEfgenARKb;;TaMgsasn_fa RBHeyhUv:aRTg;
esayraC>>> cUrGrRBHKuNdl;RBHeyhUv:a d,itRTg;l BIeRBaH
esckIsb,rsnRTg;enAGs;kl,Canic .
eRKgePgsRmab;karfVaybgM
man]bkrN_ePgCaeRcInEdl)anRtveKeRbI enAkgkarfVay
bgM enAkgerag]e)asfrbs;escdavID .
33
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
edaysarEthwbnesckIsBaa )anRtvTTYlkarGnuBaat[
)anemIleXIj Gs;ryeBl40qaM enaHerag]e)asfrbs;escdavID
KWRtv)anCaKMrUdl;BYkCMnuM [)ancUlrYbrYmKa RBmTaMg)aneFVIeday
pal;xnmak;EfmeTotpg kgkarfVaybgMRBH .
RBHKm<Irkickar 1516/17 Ecgfa eRkayenaH Gjnwg
RtLb;mk elIkTIlMenArbs;hgdavID EdlrlMenaHeLIg Gjnwg
sg;Rtg;kEng)ak;Ebk ehIydMeLIg[Rtg;eLIgvij edIm,I[sMNl;
mnusS )ansVHEsVgrkRBHGmas; RBmTaMgsasn_dTTaMgb:unan
Edl)anehAtameQaHGjenaHpg enHehIyCaRBHbnlnRBH
Gmas; CaRBHEdleFVIkarTaMgenaH .
elaksavky:akubk)ansabsg;emIlnUvBakTMnay Edl
eharaeGm:us)anEfgTMnayenAkgRBHRBHKm<IrenHdUecHfa
nAfenaHGjnwgelIkTIlMenArbs;davIDeLIgvij KWCaTIEdl
RtvrlM ehIynwgbiTcenaH)ak;Ebk[Cit GjnwgelIkTIxUcbg;eLIg
ehIysg;eLIg[dUcCakalBIedIm edIm,I[eK)aneFVICamas; elI
35
KMrUrbs;RBHsRmab;karfVaybgM
3>
36
emeronTI 3
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
RBHbnlrbs;RBHKWeBjeTAedayesckIbeRgnrbs;RBH dl;
RbCarasrbs;RTg; [)anRtLb;eTACaGksresIrtemIg nigCaGk
fVaybgMdl;RBHGg . vaCakarsMxan;cMeBaHkarcMNayeBlGanBI
RBHbnl edIm,I[eyIgral;Ka)andwgfa
ehtuGVI)anCaeyIgral;KaKYrKb,IsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGg
etIGkNaKYrKb,IsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGg
etIenAeBlNaEdleyIgKYrKb,IsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGg
etITIkEngNaEdleyIgKYrKb,IsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGg
ehtuGVI)anCaeyIgral;KaKYrKb,IsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGmas;
BIeRBaHRTg;KWCa
mankitiyssRmab;karGrRBHKuN
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1071/2/8 Ecgfa sUmGrRBHKuN
dl;RBHeyhUv:a d,itRTg;l esckIsb,rsnRTg;sitesrenACanic
KYr[BYkGkEdlRBHeyhUv:a)aneR)aselaH )anfadUecHEdr KWGs;
GkEdlRTg;)anelaH [rYcBIkNab;dnBYkxaMgsRtvenaH>>>
sUm[mnusSTaMgLaysresIrdl;RBHeyhUv:a edayeRBaHesckI
sb,rsrbs;RTg; ehIyedayeRBaHGs;TaMgkarGsar EdlRTg;)an
eR)asdl;mnusSCati .
37
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
mankitiyssRmab;karsresIrtemIg
RTg;FM]tm
kar\TibTirbs;RTg;
RTg;)aneRCIserIseyIg
sUmfVaysirIldl;RBH
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
sMEdgesckIsegaHrbs;RBH dl;GkNaEdlerobpvrbs;xn[
Rtg; .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 6930 Ecgfa TUlbgMnwgeRcgTMnuk
sresIr dl;RBHnamrbs;RBH ehIynwgelIkdMekIgRTg;edayGr
RBHKuN .
karbBaa[sresItemIg
tamryescdavID
tamryelaksavkb:ul
tamryelaksavky:Uhan
BIeRBaHKWCakarl
39
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
BIeRBaHCaTIKab;RBHhbTy
BIeRBaHCakarlRss;Rtkal
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
41
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
dl;RBHeyhUv:acuH ehIykMu[ePcbNaRBHKuNNamYyrbs;RTg;
eLIy .
RKb;TaMgGs;EdlmandegIm
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1506 Ecgfa KYr[CIvitTaMgLay
EdlmandegIm )ansresIrdl;RBHeyhUv:a cUrsrsIrdl;RBHeyhUv:a
cuH .
RKb;mnusSTaMgGs;
BYkGksucrit
43
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
BYkGkbrisuTrbs;RBH
BYkGkEdlRtv)aneR)aselaH
Gs;GkEdlekatxacdl;RBHGmas;
BYkGkbeRmIRBH
44
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
Gs;TaMgeTvtarbs;RTg;
FmCatiTaMgGs;
TaMgescTaMgRbCaras
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
eBlEdleyIgenAmanCIvitrs;
enAEtsresItemIgdl;RTg;Canic
enAeBlEdlGs;kmaMg
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 4211 Ecgfa RBlwgGjeGIy
ehtuGVI)anCagRtvbegancuH ehIymanesckIrsab;rsl;enAkg
xndUecH cUrsgwwmdl;RBHcuH d,itGjnwg)ansresIrdl;RTg;eTot
EdlRTg;CaesckICMnYy ehIyCaRBHnGj .
sresItemIgCanic
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
enAkgcMeNamRbCaCatiTaMgLay
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 579 Ecgfa RBHGmas;eGIy
TUlbgMnwgRbTUlddl;RTg;enA kNalBYkCn TUlbgMnwgeRcg
sresIrRTg; enAkNalBYksasn_dT .
enAkgTIlanrbs;RBHGg
enAkgcMeNammnusSCaeRcIn
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 10930 Ecgfa mat;TUlbgMnwgGr
RBHKuNdl; RBHeyhUv:ay:agRkElg eGI TUlbgMnwgsresIrdl;
RTg; enAkNalCnTaMgLay .
47
esckiIbeRgnrbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
sMNYrrMBksareLIgvij
1> cUrpl;[nUvehtuplbIy:ag EdleyIgral;KaKYrKb,IsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGmas; .
2>
etIenAeBlNaEdlRtvEtsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGmas;? cUr[nUv]TahrN_mYyEdldkRsg;ecjBI
RBHKm<Ir ehIymYyeTotEdldkRsg;ecjBIkardkBiesaFn_pal;rbs;elakGk .
3>
48
emeronTI 4
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
karsresIrtemIgKW)anRbdUceTAnwgrgVg;TwkePg
rgVg;nClviTa
mankEngCaeRcInenAkgRBHKm<Ir EdlniyayBIkarsresIr
temIg KW)anRbdUceTAnwgrgVg;TwkePg . rgVg;enHKWKanTIbBab;eT
KWenAEtmanCabn EdlhUrecjeTABImak;eTAmak;eTot .
TwkenAelIEpndIenHnwgRtvhYteTAvij
KWCaTRmg;BBkEdlmanenAkgGakas
TwkePgenaHnwgvilRtLb;mkEpndIvij
rgVg;nkarsresIrtemIg
karsresIrtemIgKWRtvEtKanTIbBab;eLIy . eyIgral;Ka
fVaykarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH enaHnwgnaMmknUv
RBHBr
CyCmH
karlUtlas;
RBHKm<IreGm:us 58 Ecgfa cUrEsVgrkRBHEdlRTg;)an
begItpaykUnman; nigpaynayRBan keFVI[mb;nesckIsab;ERb
eTACaRBlwmRsag ehIy[fRtLb;eTACayb;vij RBmTaMgehATwk
smuRTmk rYccak;eTAelIEpndI RBHnamRTg; KWRBHeyhUv:a .
RBHKm<IreGm:us 96 Ecgfa RBHEdl)ansagGs;TaMg
sandx<s;rbs;RTg; enAelIsansYK ehIytaMgCIvitTaMgLay [enA
EpndI kEtgEtbgab;TwksmuRT[eLIgeTAelI rYccak;mkelIEpndI
vij RTg;RBHnamCa RBHeyhUv:a .
49
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
RBHRTg;)ancak;ecjmknUvRBHBr
karsresIrtemIgsemAeTAxagelI
rIRBHBrvijRtv)anTmak;cuHmk
RKan;EtRBHRTg;)anRtas;ehATwkEdl)anbgteTA enaHTwk
ePgkFak;cuHmkPam rIRTg;Edl)anehAeyIgral;Kamk [
sresIrtemIgdl;RTg; enaHKWedIm,I[RTg;)ancak;ecjnUvRBHBrrbs;
RTg;mkeyIgral;KaenaHg .
RBHKm<Iry:Ub 3627/28 Ecgfa KWRTg;EdlCk;TwkenAelI
[ERbCacMhay rYcTMlak;CaePgvij CaTwkEdlBBkcak;cuHmk
[Fak;CabribUr eRsacRsb;elImnusSelak .
RBHKm<IreGsay 458 Ecgfa pemXeGIy cUrRsk;Twk
BIelImk ehIy[BBkcak;esckIsucritcuH mk cUr[EpndIhaeLIg
[)anbegItplCaesckIsegaH ehIy[esckIsucritBnkeLIg
CamYyKa Gj KWeyhUv:a Gj)anbegItesckIenaHeLIg .
enAeBlEdleyIgral;KafVaykarsresIreTARBH enaHRTg;)an
bgVilRBHBr[Fak;cuHmk dUcCaTwkePgEdl)anvilmkeyigvij
dUecaHEdr .
RBHKm<IrsuPasit 1125 Ecgfa mnusSEdlmancitsTa
nwg)anbribUr ehIyGkNaEdleRsacTwkdl;eK enaHnwg)aneK
eRsacTwkdl;xnEdr .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 675/6 Ecgfa RBHGgeGIy sUm[
CnTaMgLaysresrdl;RTg; [CnTaMgGs;sresIrdl;RTg;cuH enaH
nwgbegItpleLIg ehIyRBHdCaRBHneyIg RTg;nwgRbTanBrmk
eyIg .
50
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
RBHRTg;)anbNal[RBHBr edIm,IcRmaj;[cUleTAkgTwk
ePg EdlRtvEtTmak;mkelIEpndICabnbnab; .
TRmg;TwkePgEdlmanhYskMNt;enAtamdgswg enaHkRtv
Fak;mksmuRT ehIyEdlva)anecjmkBITINa enaHkvaFak;eTA
vij Edlva)anmkenaHEdr ehIycMeBaHrebobrbbTaMgGs; kvanwg
cab;epImsarCafIeLigvijEdr .
plkRmEdl)anmkBIkarsresIrtemIg
RtvTuk[RBHRTg;beBajskmPaB
RBHKm<Irkickar 1625/26 Ecgfa luHeBlRbEhlCa
kNalGRFaRt b:ul nigsLas kMBugEtGFisan ehIyeRcg
sresIrdl;RBH BYkGkeTasksab;Edr enaHRsab;EtekItman
keRkIkdICaxaMg dl;em:H)anCarBaydl;eCIgCBaaMgKukpg ehIyTVar
TaMgb:unanrebIkecjPam exaHkrehIbecjTaMgGs;eTA .
EpndInaMmknUvkarrIkceRmIn
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 675/6 Ecgfa RBHGgeGIy sUm[
CnTaMgLaysresrdl;RTg; [CnTaMgGs;sresIrdl;RTg;cuH enaH
nwgbegItpleLIg ehIyRBHdCaRBHneyIg RTg;nwgRbTanBrmk
eyIg .
CyCmHk)anmkEdr
RBHKm<Ir2r)akSRt 2021/22 Ecgfa rYckalRTg;)an
BieRKaHnwgbNaCnehIy enaHRTg;kdMrUv[manBYkGk EdlRtv
eRcgfVayRBHeyhUv:a ehIyeBalsresIr edayeskBak;Ca
Rbdab;brisuT kgkalEdleKnaMmuxBYkTBecjeTA edayeBalfa
cUrGrRBHKuNdl;RBHeyhUv:acuH d,itesckIsb,rsRTg;enACab;Gs;
kl,Canic dUecH kaleKcab;taMgeRcg ehIysresIreLIg enaHRBH
52
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
naMmknUvesckIsuxsan
RBHKm<IreGsay 6018 Ecgfa enAkgRsukgnwgmin
EdlBniyayBIesckIRceLateTot bBIkarrwbCan; bBIkarbMpaj
enAkgRBMEdngeLIy KWgnwgehAkMEpggfa esckIsegaH
ehIyTVargfa esckIsresIr .
bMpas;bMERbeyIgral;Ka
eyIgral;KanwgRtv)anbMpas;bMERb[cUleTAkgsirIldUcKa
dUcCaRBH EdleyIgral;KafVaybgMenaH .
RBHKm<Ir2kUrinfUs 311/18 Ecgfa d,itebIsinCaesckI
enaH EdlkMBugEtsUn)at;eTA )anmkedaysarsirIl enaHesckI
EdlCab;enA R)akdCamansirIlelIseTAeTot>>> ehIyeyIgral;Ka
TaMgGs; EdlkMBugEtrMBwgemIlsirIlRBHGmas; TaMgmuxTeT dUcCa
qHemIlRTg;kgkBak; eyIgkMBugEtpas;ERbeTA [dUcCarUbqHenaH
g BIsirIleTAdl;sirIl KWedaysarRBHGmas;dCaRBHviBaaN .
RBHKm<Ir1y:Uhan 31/2 Ecgfa emIl esckIRsLaj;
y:agNah EdlRBHvrbita)anpl;mkeyIgral;Ka [eyIg)anehA
faCakUnrbs;RBHdUecH KWedayehtuenaH)anCaelakiyminsal;
eyIgeT BIeRBaHminsal;RTg;Edr BYksnPaeGIy \LvenH eyIgral;
KaCakUnRBHehIy EtEdleyIgral;Kanwg)aneTACay:agNaeTot
enaHminTan;sMEdgmkenAeLIy b:uEn eyIgdwgfakalNaRTg;elc
53
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
RTg;bBaa[eyIgmanesckIGMNr
eyIgral;KaRtv)anTTYlbBaa [manesckIGMNrenAcMeBaH
RBHGmas; .
RBHKm<IrecaTiykfa 127/11/12 Ecgfa ehIyenA
TIenaH Rtv[gral;KabriePaKenAcMeBaHRBHeyhUv:a CaRBHng
ehIygnigBYkRKsarg RtvGrsb,ayeLIg edayeRBaHRKb;TaMg
rbs;EdldglUkeTAcab;yk BIrbs;TaMgbu:nanEdlRBHeyhUv:a
CaRBHng )anRbTanBrdl;gehIy>>> enaHRtvnaMykGs;TaMg
dgVay EdlGjbgab;g eTAfVayenAkEngNaEdlRBHeyhUv:a Ca
RBHng RTg;nwgerIssMrab;taMgRBHnamRTg;cuH KWGs;TaMgdgVaydut
yBabUCa dgVay1PaKkg10 dgVayelIkcuHeLIg ehIyRKb;TaMg
pleRCIserIs Edlg)anbn;fVayRBHeyhUv:apg Rtv[gral;Ka
Grsb,ayeLIg enAcMeBaHRBHeyhUv:a CaRBHng RBmTaMgkUn
RbskUnRsIg nig)avRbs)avRsIg ehIynigBYkelvIEdlenAkg
TIRkggpg d,itBYkelvIKancMENk KanmrdkenACamYynwgg
eT .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 1610 Ecgfa cUrmancitrIkray
edaynUvRBHnambrisuTrbs;RTg; cUr[Gs;GkEdlEsVgrkRBH
eyhUv:a mancitGrsb,ayeLIg .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 331 Ecgfa BYkGksucriteGIy
cUrmancitrIkraykgRBHeyhUv:acuH d,itesckIsresIrenaH sMNMdl;
mnusSeTogRtg; .
RBHKm<IrlUka 146/47 Ecgfa rYcm:araniyayeLIgfa
RBlwgelIkdMekIgRBHGmas; viBaaNkrIkraynwgRBHdCaRBHGg
segaHn .
55
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
bnab;BIRKab;BUCEdlRtv)aneRBaHcuH
esckIGMNrGrsb,ayKW)anmkBIkarebIksEmg nigkar
CBawgKitBIRBHbnlrbs;RBH .
RBHKm<Ireyerma 1516 Ecgfa TUlbgM)aneXIjRBH
bnlRTg; TUlbgM)anTTYlTanelbcUlGs;ehIy RBHbnlrbs;
RTg;CaesckIGMNr ehIyCaTIrIkraydl;citTUlbgM d,itRBHeyhUv:a
CaRBHnBYkBlbrivareGIy TUlbgM)anehAtamRBHnamRTg; .
eyIgRtvEt {ecjeTAedaymanesckIGMNr} KWbnab;BIRKab;
BUCnRBHbnlrbs;RBH EdlRtv)aneRBaHcUlmkkgciteyIg .
RBHKm<IreGsay 5510-12 Ecgfa BIeRBaHEdlePg
nighimFak;cuHmkBIelIemX \tvilRtLb;eTAelIvij KWmkeRsacdI
eFVI[ekItecjCaBnkeLIg ehIyk[BUCBeRgaHdl;GkEdleRBaH
nigGahardl;GkEdlbriePaKCay:agNa enaHBakGj Edlecj
BImat;GjeTA kminEdlvilmkGjvij eday\tekItply:ag
dUecaHEdr KWnwgeFVIsMerctamesckIb:gR)afaenAkgcitGj ehIynwg
cMerInekIneLIg kgkarGVIEdlGjcat;eTAeFVIenaH d,itgral;Kanwg
ecjeTAedayGMNr ehIyeKnwgnaMgecjeTAedaysuxsan Gs;
TaMgPMFM nigPMtUcTaMgbu:nannwgFayecjCacMerogenAmuxg ehIy
RKb;TaMgedImeQIenARBnwgTHdpg .
bBab;sataMgedaymanesckIGMNr
etIsataMgBayameFVIdUcemcxH bnab;BIRBHbnlEdl)an
eRBaHcUleTAkgcitrbs;eyIgehIy? KWvamky:agRbjab;Rbjal;
56
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
RKab;BUCnRBHbnlrbs;RTg; )anenAkgeyIgKWenAeBlEdl
esckIGMNrrbs;RTg; )aneFVIkarenAkgeyIg .
RBHKm<Iry:Uhan 1510/11 Ecgfa ebIGkral;Ka kan;
tambBati enaHnwgenACab;kgesckIRsLaj;rbs; dUcCa)an
kan;tambBatinRBHvrbita ehIykenACab;kgesckIRsLaj;
rbs;RTg;Edr )anniyayesckITaMgenH R)ab;dl;Gkral;Ka edIm,I
[esckIGMNrrbs; )anenACab;kgGkral;Ka ehIy[esckI
GMNrrbs;Gkral;Ka)aneBareBjpg .
tamrykarsab;bgb;dl;RBHbnlrbs;RBH enaHesckI
GMNrrbs;RTg; nwgeFVIkarenAkgeyIg . esckIGMNrrbs;RTg;KWmin
57
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
esckIGMNrnaMmknUvkmaMg
eBlEdleyIgGrsb,ay nigsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGmas;
enaHeyIgTTYl)annUvkmaMgrbs;RTg; .
RBHKm<Irenehma 810x Ecgfa >>>kuM[mancitRByeLIy
BIeRBaHesckIGMNrrbs;RBHeyhUv:aCakMLaMgnGkral;Ka .
esckIGMNrQHelIviBaaNGaRkk;
karGrsb,ayKWCakUnesarEdleFVImanCyCmH {elIviBaaN
GaRkk;} KWCaGarkSsataMg .
enAeBlEdleyIgGrsb,ay RBmTaMg)anEfrkSanUvRKab;BUC
nRBHbnlrbs;RTg; enaHeyIgral;KamankmaMg nigmanCyCmH
enAkgCIvitCaRKIsanrbs;eyIg .
RBHKm<Ir1y:Uhan 213/14 Ecgfa Bukral;KaeGIy
sresrepJImkGkral;Ka BIeRBaH)ansal;RBH EdlRTg;Kg;enAtaMgBI
edImerogmk kMeLaHral;KaeGIy sresrepJImkGkral;Ka BIeRBaH
)anQHemkMNacehIy ekgral;KaeGIy )ansresrepJImkGk
ral;Ka BIeRBaH)ansal;RBHvrbita Bukral;KaeGIy )ansresr
epJImkGkral;Ka BIeRBaH)ansal;RBHEdlKg;enAtaMgBIedImerogmk
kMeLaHral;KaeGIy )ansresrepJImkGkral;Ka BIeRBaHman
kMLaMg ehIyRBHbnlksitenAkgGkral;Ka Gkral;Ka)anQH
emkMNacehIy .
esckIGMNrnaMmknUvkarEkCafIeLIgvij
RbsinebIsataMg)anlYcnUvesckIGMNrrbs;eyIg ehIyeyIg
)an)at;bg;nUvRKab;BUCnRBHbnl enaHesckIl nigCyCmHrbs;
eyIg eyIgnwgGacTTYl)anBIBYkvamkvijCaminxan .
59
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
enAeBlEdleyIgbeBajsemgedayesckIGMNr ehIy)an
fVaydgVaynkarsresIr enAkgdMNak;nRBHGmas; enaHkarCab;
eTasrbs;eyIg nwgRtv)anvilRtLb;mkeyIgvij ehIysataMgk
RtvEtvilRtLb;fyeRkayBIkarlYcenaHvijCak;CaminxanEdr .
RBHKm<Ireyerma 339-11 Ecgfa TIRkgenHnwg)an
sMrab;CaehtunaM[Grsb,aydl;Gj sMrab;CaesckIsresIr nig
esckIlpg enAcMeBaHGs;TaMgnKrenAEpndI CaBYkGkEdlnwgB
niyayBIGs;TaMgkarl EdlGjeR)asdl;eK rYceKnwgekatxac
ehIyPyjr edayeRBaHRKb;TaMgesckIlnwgesckIsuxTaMgb:unan
EdlGjpl;dl;eK>>> RBHeyhUv:a RTg;manbnldUecHfa enATIenH
Edlgral;Kafa CaTIxUcbg;\tmanmnusS bstVNaenAeTot KWenA
kgTIRkgnRsukyUdaTaMgb:unan ehIyenAGs;pvrbs;RkgeyrUsaLim Edlecalsat;enH \tmanGkNaGaRsyenA bmnusS b
stVNaeLIy enaHnwgmanBsMelgmnusSmgeTot CasMelgGr
sb,ay nigsMelgrIkray KWsMelgrbs;bIRbBnefagfI nigsMelg
BYkGkEdleBalfa cUrelIksresIrRBHeyhUv:anBYkBlbrivar d,it
RBHeyhUv:aRTg;l BIeRBaHesckIsb,rsrbs;RTg;sitesrenAGs;
kl, ehIysMeLgrbs;BYkEdlnaMykdgVayGrRBHKuNcUlkgRBH
viharnRBHeyhUv:aEdr d,itGjnwgeFVI[BYkGkRsukenH EdlenACa
eQIy)anvilmkvij dUckalBIedIm enHehIyCaRBHbnlnRBH
eyhUv:a .
RtvEtGFisantamkarGFisanTaMg7cMNuc
enAeBlEdleyIgmanesckIGMNr enaHeyIgGacsmtdl;
ecar sataMg [vabg;sgeyIgvij tamkarGFIsanTaMg7cMNuc
Edlva)anlYcykeTAenaH .
60
karsresIrtemIgnaMmknUvRBHBrrbs;RBH
cUreFVIbBaIBIplkRmTaMgBIrnkarsresIrtemIg .
3>
61
emeronTI 5
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgEdl)anbkERbenARKasBaacas;
cMnYnBakCaPasaeheRBIr EdlEbkepSgBIKa enAKWRtv
)aneKeRbI edIm,IBNnaBIkarsresIrtemIgenARKasBaacas; . kar
sikSanUvBakTaMgenHKW)anebIksEmg [mankaryl;dwg)anc,as;
las; nUvGtnynkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH enAsmysBVfenH .
BakCaPasaeheRBIrsRmab;karsresIrtemIg KW)anbBaak;
bgajnUvskmPaBnkarrMeCIbrMCYlCaeRcIn .
haLal
BakhaLal {Halal" KWCaBakEdlRtv)aneKeRbICajwk
jab;bMput KWRtv)aneKbkERbCaBaksresIrtemIg . BakenHRtv
)aneKeRbIcMnYn160dg enAkgRBHKm<IrsBaacas; .
BakenHmannyfa karsresIrtemIgrbs;RTg;)anmkBIRTg;
edayviBaaN nigesckIBit .
edIm,IeFVIkarbgaj
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 2222 Ecgfa TUlbgMnwgRbkas
R)ab;BIRBHnamRTg; dl;BYkbgbn TUlbgMnwgsresIrdMekIgRTg; enA
kNalBYkCMnMu .
manGMnYt
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 10218 Ecgfa esckIenHnwg)ankt;
TuksMrab;dMNmnusSCan;eRkay [bNamnusSEdlnwgekIteLIg
)ansresIrdMekIgdl;RBHeyhUv:a .
62
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
kareFVIBiFIbuN
karsresIrtemIgedayhYsehtuGMBI
fVaysirIl
caMgCHrsI
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
64
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
karERskedaysemgERt
karfVaysirIledaynUvCyCmH
hSam:ar
hSam:armannyfa
edj belgePgedayRbdab;manExS
RBmTaMgmankaryl;dwgedaykareRcgsresIrtemIg
edaybnrtambTePg
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
y:adasmannyfa
karfVaykarln;tYedayGrRBHKuN
RBH .
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
karlutCgg;cuHedaymankareKarBbUCa
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
68
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
karsresIrtemIgdl;RBH KWminEmnCakareFVIlMhat;Epkxag
GarmN_enaHeT KWCakareFVIskmPaBxagviBaaNvij .
karsresIrtemIgdBitR)akd enaHnwgnaMmknUvkarrMedaHxag
GarmN_ .
GarmN_KWminEmnCakarcaM)ac; dl;rUbkay bxagEpksac;
QamenaHeT .
RBHRTg;)anRbTandl;eyIgnUvGarmN_ ehIyGarmN_TaMg
enaH KWRtvEt)aneKeRbIedIm,IfVaysirIldl;RTg; . GarmN_KWrYm
bBalTaMgkareFVIBiFI karniyaysresIrdelIslub nigkarfVaynUv
karbBaak;bgajedayERskCasERmkxaMgfVayRBHCaedIm .
karFanar:ab;rg
karsresIrtemIgKYrKb,IRtv)aneKeFVI edayGakb,kiriya Ca
karFanar:ab;rg . karFanar:ab;rgmannyfa esaHcMeBaH nigsresIr
dl;GkNamak; edaymankarsmrm .
skmPaBnkarsresIrtemIg minKYrKb,IFab;Rtv)aneK
GnuBaat edIm,I[manPaBnfyTaMgxagkg nigxageRkAxNsIma
nkarcak;eRbgtaMg RBmTaMgkarhUrmknRBHviBaaNbrisuT enAkg
karRbCuMdBiessenaH .
karsresIrtemIgRBH KWKankMNt;RBMEdnnUvGtnynesckI
GMNrGrsb,ayrbs;eyIgenaHeT KWRtv)anpl;[CakarbBaak;
bgajnUvkarFanar:ab;rg nigGrRBHKuNdl;RBHEtb:ueNaH .
esckIbBab;
eyIgGacKUsbBaak;nUvesckIbBab;xH EdldkRsg;ecjBI
BakCaPasaeheRBIr .
69
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
RBHRTg;CaviBaaN ehIyeyIgral;KaRtvEtfVabgMRTg;eday
viBaaN nigesckIBitEdr .
karsresIrtemIgKWGacRtv)aneKsresIredayGarmN_ bu:En
eyIgRtvEtcaMyam RbqaMgTas;nwgkarsresIrtemIgedayFmta
EdlmanesckIGMNrEtRtwmrUbkay KWmin)anTTYlnUvkarRbTanmk
xagvIBaaNenaHecj .
RBHKm<Iry:Uhan 423/24 Ecgfa EtnwgmaneBlevla
mk kenA\LvenHehIy enaHBYkGkEdlfVaybgMedayBitRtg; eK
nwgfVaybgMRBHvrbitaedayviBaaN nigesckIBit BIeRBaHRBHvrbita
RTg;rkBYkGky:agenaH [)anfVaybgMRTg; RBHRTg;CaviBaaN
ehIyGkNaEdlfVaybgMRTg; enaHRtvEtfVaybgM edayviBaaN
nigesckIBitEdr .
BakEdl)anbkERbmkfakarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgMenAkgRBHKm<IrsBaafI
manBakCaKasaRkikCaeRcIn EdlRtv)aneKeRbIcMeBaHkar
BNnanUvkarsresIrtemIg enAkgRBHKm<IrsBaafI . karsikSa
cMeBaHBakTaMgenH nwrMedaHeyIgral;Ka[manskmPaBbEnm nig
mankarbBaak;bgajbEnm enAkgkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBHrbs;
eyIg .
GayeNGU Aineo
dgVay bBiFInkarsresIrtemIg
karbeBajsemgkgkarGrRBHKuN
70
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
karsresIredayTHdsaTr
karelIktemIgcMeBaH
GWLCIGU E ulogeo
karebIkmat;BiBNnasresIr
duksa D oxa
karfVaysirIl
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
RbsKueNGU P roskuneo
karlutCgg;cuH
RBHbnlniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir
edayg edaymanBaknigkarpl;[nUvceRmgenAkgeBlevla
edayRBHviBaaNbrisuT} .
sMNYrrMBksareLIgvij
1>
2>
3>
etIBakCaPasaeheRBIrmannydUcemc EdlRtv)aneKeRbIsRmab;BakfVaybgMRBH?
4>
cUr[GtnynUvBakCaPasaRkikBIry:ag EdlRtv)aneKbkERbfaCaBakfVaybgM .
73
emeronTI 6
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
eyIgral;KaRtv)anbegIteLIgmk KWsRmab;karsresIr
temIg nigkarfVaybgM . bMNgcitdFMbMputnCIvitrbs;eyIg KWRtv
EtsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgMdl;RBH . ehtuplEdleyIgrs;enA
KWRtvEtfVaybgMdl;RTg;enaHg . elaksavky:UhanR)ab;eyIgfa
RBHRTg;kMBugEtEsVgrkkUnRbs-RsI[fVaybgMdl;RTg;
RBHKm<Iry:Uhan 423 Ecgfa EtnwgmaneBlevlamk
kenA\LvenHehIy enaHBYkGkEdlfVaybgMedayBitRtg; eKnwg
fVaybgMRBHvrbitaedayviBaaN nigesckIBit BIeRBaHRBHvrbita
RTg;rkBYkGky:agenaH [)anfVaybgMRTg; .
RBHRTg;Grsb,ayCamYynwgkareRcg
RBHRTg;Grsb,ayeday)anBeyIgeRcgceRmg
RBHKm<Irespana 317 Ecgfa RBHeyhUv:a dCaRBHng
RTg;Kg;enAkNalg RTg;CaRBHdman\TibTi edIm,ICYysegaH
RTg;nwgmanesckIrIkrayGrsb,aycMeBaHg RTg;nwgsMrakkg
esckIRsLaj;rbs;RTg; knwgGrsb,aynwgg edaysMeLg
eRcg .
BakCaPasaeheRBIr)aneRbIBNna nUvskmPaBrbs;RBH
edaykarGrsb,ay KWmannyfa {elateLIgelatcuH bgVilCuMvij
EdlbeBajnUvesckIrMePIbedayGrsb,ayRkElg} .
eyIgGacTUlsYrfa {ehtuGVI)anCaRBHRTg;)aneFVI[mankar
rMePIbcitdl;eyIg EdlRTg;kMBugEtGrsb,ay elateLIgelatcuH
EdlbeBajnUvesckIrMePIbedayGrsb,ayRkElgy:agdUecH?}
74
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
BYkeTvtacm,aMg .
mhaeTvtakaRBIEy:l KWCaGkdwknaMBYkeTvta EpknaMsar .
mhaeTvtalUsuIhVW KWCaGkdwknaMBYkeTvta EdlRtv)an
begItmkCaBiesssRamb;sresIrtemIg nigfVaybgM
KWCaGkcaMyamdl;blgnRBH .
mhaeTvtalUsuIhVW
KWCaeTvtaecrUbnEdlTTYlkarcak;eRbgtaMg
RBHRTg;)anbegIteTvtalUsuIhVW [eFVICaeTvtaecrUbncaMyam
karBardl;blgnRBH .
RBHKm<IreGesKal 2814 Ecgfa gCaecrUbnEdl)an
cak;eRbgtaMgeLIgCaGkRKb)aMg KWGj)antaMggeLIg [g)an
enAelIPMbrisuTrbs;RBH gk)anedIreTAmkenAkNalfPWcaMg .
eTvtaecrUbnKWCaGkRKb)aMgenATIsenaseR)as enABIelI
hwbnesckIsBaa edaymansabTaMgsgxag ehIylUsuIhVWk)an
CaGkyamblgnRBHenAbnab;enaH {KWCaeTvtaecrUbnEdl)an
TTYlkarcak;eRbgtaMg[eFVICaGkRKb)aMg} .
75
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
GtnyneQaH
Rtv)anbegItmksRmab;karRbKMbTePg
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
lUsuIhVWkCaGkEdlmankartak;Etgsmitsmag edayman
karrMelcedayt,gCaeRcIn KWenAeBlKat;)aneFVIclna nigdkdegIm
enaHkKanTIbBab;eLIy KWEtgEtmankarpas;brnUvTsSnIyPaBn
sirIledaynUvBnW nigmansemgenAnKrsansYK .
cUrcgcaMfa RbePTn]bkrN_TaMgbIenH KWCavg;ePg Edl
manxl;semg nigExSKWRtv)anebIksEmgmk .
karRKb)aMgblgnRBH edayeTvtaEdl)anTTYlnUvkar
cak;eRbgtaMg Edl)anelceLIg edaymankarRKb)aMgdl;kar
sresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM .
lUsuIhVWRtvEt)anTTYlkarGnuBaat [)aneFVICaeTvtadFM
sem,Im KWKat;)aneTACavg;ePg nigCaGkceRmgkgkarsresIr
temIg nigfVaybgMCabnenAmuxblg .
RBHKm<Iry:Ub 387 Ecgfa kgkalEdlpayRBwk)an
eRcgCamYyKa ehIyGs;TaMgkUnRBH)anERskGrsaTr .
lUsuIhVWRtv)anTukkEng[enATMen
karFak;cuHrbs;lUsuIhVWBIsansYK KW)anTuknUvTIcMhmYy .
enAeBlEdllUsuIhVW)aneFVIkatTas;TTwgRbqaNgnwgRBH ehIyk
Rtv)anbeNjecjBIsansYK {KWBIPaBCaeTvtarbs;Kat;} mk enaH
EpkTIbIEdlCataraRbcaMf eTvta enAnKrsansYK Edl)anTas;
TTwg enaHRtv)anTukkEngKat;enA .
RBHKm<IreGsay 1412 Ecgfa taraRbcaMf Capay
RBwkeGIy ng)anFak;cuHmkBIelIemXehIy gEdl)anepkGs;
TaMgnKr[rab g)anRtvkab;rMlMdl;dIEdrh+ .
RBHKm<IreGesKal 2815/16 Ecgfa cab;taMgBIfEdl
gekItmkenaH g)anRKb;lkN_kgRKb;TaMgpvrbs;g drabdl;
77
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
evlaEdleXIjmanesckITucenAkgg d,itedaysarkarCYjERbd
bribUrrbs;g enaHeK)anbMeBjgedayesckIRceLat ehIyg
)aneFVI)ab ehtuenaHGj)ane)aHecalgecjBIPMnRBH TukdUcCa
rbs;Gab; neTAvij ecrUbnEdlRKb)aMgeGIy Gj)anbMpajg
ecjBIkNalfPWcaMgenaHeTA .
RBHKm<IrvivrN 127-9 Ecgfa enaHmancM)aMgenAelI
emX KWmIEkl nigBYkeTvtarbs;elakc,aMgnwgnaK ehIynaK nig
eTvtavakc,aMgnwgelakEdr Etmin)anQHeT kmineXIjmankEng
Na[va enAelIemXeTotpg enaHnaKFMRtve)aHTMlak;eTA KWCaBs;
BIburaN EdleQaHehAfaGarkS ehIysataMgpg Edl)annaM
elakiyTaMgmUl[vegVgecj vaRtve)aHTMlak;eTAEpndIvij RBm
TaMgBYkeTvtarbs;vapg .
RBHKm<IrvivrN 124k Ecgfa knyvakTajpayenAelI
emX 1PaKkg3 RKvat;ecaleTAEpndI>>> .
PaBTeTKWRtv)anekIteLIgkgeBlrMeBc enAnKrsansYK
KWedaysarlUsuIhVW nigBYkeTvtarbs;vaRtv)anbeNjecj .
RBHRTg;)anbMeBjenAkEngTeT
RBHRTg;)anmanEpnkaredIm,IbMeBj enAkEngcenaHEdl
)ancakecjeTA edallUsuIhVW nigBYkeTvtarbs;va RBHRTg;)an
begItmnusSmk edIm,Ikan;kab;nUvGMNacRKb;RKgelIEpndI KW[RKb;
RKgelIlUsuIhVW sataMg RBmTaMgBYkeTvtarbs;va BYkviBaaN
GaRkk; . mnuSRtvEtsEmgbMPWnUvkarbraCyrbs;sataMg enAelI
EpndIenH . RBHRTg;)anbegItmnusSmk [mancMENkbnab;
BIRBHGg nigesayraCCamYynwgRTg; enAelIblgrbs;RTg; .
PaBTeT\LvenHKWRtv)anbMeBj edayBYkCMnuMrbs;RTg; .
78
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
muneBlnkarFak;cuHrbs;va lUsuIhVWKWCaRbFaelIRkmdUrtnI
enaH enAnKrsansYK .
RBHKm<IreGesKal 2813x Ecgfa >>>Rkab; nigxy
rbs;g enaH)aneRtmTuksMrab;gtaMgBIfEdlgekItmk .
GMeNayTanxagEpkdUrtnIrbs;va KWRtvEt)aneKeRbIenA
kgkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH b:uEnenAeBlEdlva)anFak;cuHmk enaH
GMeNayTanenHk)anRtLb;mkCaxUcGs;eTA .
]bkrN_ePgRtv)anbegIteLIg
]bkrN_ePgRtv)anbegIteLIgedayelakkaGn KWTaMg
]bkrN_ePg TaMg]bkrN_eFVIsgam .
RBHKm<Irelakub,ti 421/22k Ecgfa bnKat;eQaH
yU)al CaBuknBYkGkelgsugnigxy nagsLakbegIt)an
TU)al-kaGn CaembeRgnBYkCaglgin nigCagEdk>>> .
79
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
karbMPan;]bkrN_ePg
kUneKamas
rUbeFVIBImas
sataMgKWCaGkniBnedaybMPan; nigCaGkbMPan;nUvdUrtnI
KWCaTIsmal;dGaRkk;bMputrbs;va .
RBHKm<Ir1kUrinfUs 1433k Ecgfa d,itRBHRTg;minEmn
CaRBHnesckIvwkvreT KWRTg;CaRBHnesckIsuxsanvij>>> .
enAeBlEdlBYkkUnecAGuIRsaEGl )aneFVIrUbkUneKa nigfVay
bgMdl;rUbenaH enaHelakm:Ues)anBedaymansemgbMPan; dxaMgka
EdlKat;minGacemIleXIj EtmgnUvsBaasmal;enaHeLIy .
RBHKm<IrnikmnM 3217/18 Ecgfa kalyU:esV)anBsUr
sMeLgrbs;bNaCnTaMgLayEdleKnaMKaERskdUecaH enaHkCMrab
mU:esfa manBsUrcM)aMgenATIdMeLIgRtsalehIy EtmU:eseqIyfa
tamEdlGjB enaHminEmnCasUrsMErknBYkEdlQH bBYkcaj;eT
KWCasUrsMeLgnmnusSEdleRcgvijeTetI .
escenbUeksar)aneRbIRbePT]bkrN_dUrtnI edIm,InaMKaeFVI
karfVaybgMdl;rUbEdleFVIBImas EdlRTg;)ansagsg;eLIgenaH .
RBHKm<IrdanIEy:l 35/7 Ecgfa evlaNaEdlGkral;Ka
BsUrERt xy sug cabIu BiN nigbuI ehIydnIRKb;ya:g enaHRtv
RkabfVaybgMdl;rUbmas EdlRBHkruNaRTg;)antaMgeLIgeTA>>>
dUecH enAevlaenaH kalCnTaMgLay)anBsUrERt xy sug cabuI
BiN nigdnIRKb;ya:gehIy enaHCnTaMgLay RBmTaMgsasn_dT
nwgmnusSRKb;Pasapg kRkabfVaybgMdl;rUbmas Edlesc
enbUeksa)antaMgTukenaH .
80
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
sUm[bMNgRBHhbTyRTg;)anseRmcenAEpndIdUcCaenAsansYKEdr
RBHeysUvRTg;)anbeRgndl;BYksisSrbs;RTg; [ecH
GFisanfa sUm[bMNgRBHhbTyRTg;)anseRmc enAEpndIdUcCa
enAsansYKEdr . etIbMNgRBHhbTyrbs;RBHenAsansYK enaH
y:agdUcemc? etIbMNgRBHhbTyrbs;RBH)anseRmcy:agdUcemc
xHenATIenaH?
elaksavky:Uhank)anpl;[ nUvkarCak;EsgdFMGsar
cMeBaHGVIEdl)anekIteLIg enAsansYKsmysBVfenH ehIy
cMeBaHGVIEdl)anekIteLIgenAeBlGnaKtxagmux . karCak;Esgd
eRcInelIslb;enH KW)anrYmbBalTaMgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVay
bgMpgEdr .
karsresIrtemIgenAEtbn
BYkeTvta)ancab;epImbnpl;[ nUvkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH
RBHKm<IrvivrN 48-11 Ecgfa tYmanCIvitTaMg4enaH
mansab6RKb;rUb kmanEPkeBjxnenACMuvij ehIyTaMgxagkgEdr
kecHEteBalBak\tQb;QrTaMgyb;TaMgf fa brisuT brisuT
brisuT KWRBHGmas; CaRBHdmanRBHecsabMput EdlRTg;Kg;enAtaMg
EtBIedIm kenA\LvenH ehIyRtvyagmkeTot kalNatYmanCIvit
TaMg4enaH)anfVaysirIl l,IRBHnam nigBakGrRBHKuN dl;RBH
GgEdlKg;elIblg CaRBHdmanRBHCnrs;Gs;kl,Canic erograb
drabeTArYcehIy enaHBYkcas;TMuTaMg24nak; kTMlak;xnRkabcuH
enAcMeBaHRBHGgEdlKg;elIblg TaMgfVaybgMdl;RBHdmanRBHCn
rs;Gs;kl,Canic erograbteTAenaH ehIykdak;mkudxncuHfVay
enAmuxblg edayTUlfa RBHGmas; CaRBHneyIgral;KaeGIy
RTg;KYrnwgTTYlsirIl kitinam nigRBHecsa d,itRTg;)anbegItrbs;
81
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
manBBYkeTvtarab;rylan RBmTaMgsaRBHhsTaMgLay
)anfVaybgM nigsresIrtemIgdl;RBH .
RBHKm<IrvivrN 511-13 Ecgfa enaHeXIj ehIykB
sMeLgeTvtaCaeRcInenACMuvijblg RBmTaMgtYmanCIvit nigBYkcas;
TuMpg cMnYnneTvtaenaH manTaMgmWunTaMgEsn ehIyTaMgBan;rab;Ca
Ban; RKb;KakbnWsMeLgfa kUnecomEdleK)ansMLab; enaHKYrnwg
)anRBHecsa RTBsm,ti R)aCJa \TibTi kitinam sirIlnigRBHBr
enaHkBRKb;TaMgGs;EdlmanCIvit enAsansYK enAEpndI enA
eRkamdI ehIyenAkgsmuRT nigRKb;TaMgGs;EdlenAsanTaMgenaH
niyayfa sUmfVayRBHBr kitinam sirIl nigRBHecsa
dl;RBHGgEdlKg;elIblg ehIydl;kUnecom enAGs;kl,Canic
erograbteTA .
RBHeysUv)anGFisanfa {sUm[RBHhbTyRTg;)ansMerc
enAEpndI dUcenAsansYKEdr} .
srubkarfVaybgM
mankarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM enAEtbnkgnKrsan
sYKenAsmysBVfenH . karfVaybgMedayBYkeTvtaTaMgsl;Esn
nigkarfVaybgMedayBhuKuNnmnusSBIRKb;Catisasn_ CnCati nig
RKb;Pasa .
RBHKm<IrvivrN 79/10 Ecgfa eRkayenaHmk RkeLk
eTAeXIjmnusS1hVgy:agFM EdlKanGkNaGacnwgrab;)aneLIy
eKmkBIRKb;TaMgsasn_ RKb;TaMgBUCmnusS RKb;TaMgRKsar ehIy
82
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
84
eKalbMNgdGs;kl,rbs;RBHsRmab;karsresIrtemIg
sMNYrrMBksareLIgvij
1>
2>
3>
etIGkNaEdlRtv)anbegIteLIg
edIm,I[)andwknaMkarfVaybgMenAnKrsansYK? cUrBnl;tam cemIyrbs;elakGk .
etIGkNaEdlRtv)anbMeBj
CMnYs[GkdwknaMfVaybgM? cUreFVIkarBnl; .
enAkEngcenaHTeT
etIRKb;TaMg]bkrN_ePgTaMgGs;suTEt)anebIksEmgmke
dayRBHb? etIelakGkGacR)ab;BIPaB epSgKaenaH)anedayrebobNa?
85
emeronTI 7
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
]bkrN_ePg bdUrtnI
]bkrN_ePg KWRtv)aneKeRbICajwkjab; edIm,IbBaak;
bgajBIkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM .
edayescdavID
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1503-5 Ecgfa cUrsresIrRTg;
edayERt cUrsresIrdl;RTg;edayedjBiN nigcab;sug cUrsresIr
dl;RTg;edayvayRkab; ehIyelatkeBag cUrsresIrRTg;eday
Rbdab;manExS ehIynigxy cUrsresIrdl;RTg;edayvayQwg[B
rgM cUrsresIrRTg;edayvayQwgBsUrrMBg .
BYkRkmdUrtnIEdlRtvEtfVaynUvkarsresIrtemIgtamry
]bkrN_ePg enaHBYkeKRtvEtEsVgrknUvkardRbesIr edaykareFVI
y:agdUecaH .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 333 Ecgfa cUreRcgTMnukfIfVay
RTg; ehIyelgePg[BrgM edaybuinRbsb; .
karenHKWGacCaCMnajxagEpkviBaaN ehIybnab;mkeTIb
Gacrk)annUvkarbuinRbsBVxagrUbkayEdlRbesIrCageTAeTot .
cMeBaHCMnajKW minEmnsMedAeTAelIEtkarelgeRKgePgb:ueNaHeT
KWCakaryl;dwg nigCakarcglbgaj nUvkarhUrmk nigkaresay
nUvGarmN_rbs;RBHviBaaNEfmeTotpg .
CMnajnkarelgePgdbuinRbsBVrbs;escdavID cMeBaHkar
edjBin EdlGacbeNjviBaaNGaRkk;ecjBIescsUl nig)annaM
mknUvkarRss;Rsay RBmTaMg)anTTYlnUvkareR)as[Ca .
86
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
enAkgnKrsansYK
RBHKm<IrvivrN 142 Ecgfa rYcBsMeLgmkBIelIemX
dUcCasUrTwkeRcIn ehIydUcprlan;y:agxaMg rIsMeLgEdlBenaH
kdUcCasUrsBrbs;BYkdnIEdlkMBugEtcab;sug .
RBHviBaaNbrisuT)aneFVIkartamrydUrtnI
karbeBajedaykarcak;eRbgtaMg
RBHviBaaNbrisuT)aneRbIR)as;nUveRKg]bkrN_ePg edIm,I
fVaysirIldl;RBH nigsRmab;karsagdl;BYkbNaCn . dUrtnIKW
GacCYybegIt[manbriyakas sRmab;GMeNayTanCaPasadT
karbkERbPasadT karGFib,ay kareR)as[Ca BaksmIn
cMeNHecHsat; nigBaksmInR)aCJa GMeNayTannesckICMenO
nigGMeNayTannkarbTi)armICaedIm .
RBHKm<Ir2BgSavtarkSRt 315 Ecgfa Et\LvenH sUm
naMGkePgmak;mkTUlbgM rYckalGkenaHkMBugEtelgePg enaH
RBHhsnRBHeyhUv:a kmkelIeGlIes .
87
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
karcglbgajdl;kareR)aselaH
edaykarCab;eTas
edaymanesrIPaB
enAeBlEdlBYkGuIRsaEGlsitenAkgkarCab;eTas Rkm
ePgrbs;BYkeKk)anRtvQb;pak .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1371-4 Ecgfa eyIg)anGgycuH
enAmat;TenRsuk)abLn eGI eyIg)anyM edaynwkrBJkdl;Rkg
sy:Un eyIg)anBak;Brsugrbs;eyIgenAedImcak nakNalRsuk
enaH d,itenATIenaHBYkGkEdlnaMeyIgeTACaeQIy eKbgM[eyIg
eRcgbT KWBYkGkEdlbMpajeyIg eK[eyIgelg [eK)anGr
sb,ay edayBakfa cUreRcgbT1rbs;Rkgsy:Unmk [eyIg
sab;emIl EteyIgnwgeRcgbTnRBHeyhUv:a enAkgRbeTsdT
dUcemc)an .
enAeBlEdlkarCab;eTasrbs;BYkeK Rtv)anbBab;ehIy
70qaMeRkaymk BYkeKk)aneFVIdMeNIrvilRtLb;mkkan;pHsEm,g
xnvij edaymanesckIGMNrGrsb,ay TaMgeRcg nigERskCy
eXasedaykgrMBgeLIg .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1261/2 Ecgfa kalRBHeyhUv:a
RTg;)annaMBYkeQIymkRkgsy:Unvij enaHeyIgral;Ka)an dUcCa
mnusSEdlyl;sbieT RKaenaH mat;eyIg)aneBledaykaresIc
sb,ay ehIyGNatkeBjedaybTcMerog enaHenARKb;TaMgsasn_
maneKfa RBHeyhUv:aRTg;)aneFVIkary:agFMsMrab;BYkenaHBit .
88
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
]bkrN_ePgenAkgkarsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgMenAkgRBHKm<IrsBaacas;
karsresrEcgCadMbUg
RBHKm<Irelakub,ti 421 Ecgfa bnKat;eQaHyU)al Ca
BuknBYkGkelgsugnigxy .
GMBIeQaHy:a)al Yabal b y:a)al JubalCaPasa
eheRBIr mannyfa hUrmkedaymank,ndEgry:agGFwkGFm
dUcCaExSTwkhUr .
cMeBaHelakm:Ues
cMeBaHelakm:Ues nigBYkkUnecAGuIRsaEGl)aneRcgfVay
dl;RBHeyhUv:a .
RBHKm<IrnikmnM 151/2 Ecgfa rYcBIenaHmk mU:es nigBYk
kUnecAGRsaEGl knaMKaeRcgTMnukenHfVayRBHeyhUv:afa nwg
eRcgfVayRBHeyhUv:a d,itRTg;manCyCMnHy:ag]tm RTg;)anpl
TaMgesH TaMgGkCiHeTAkgsmuRT RBHeyhUv:aRTg;CakMLaMgn
ehIyCaTMnukEdleRcgpg RTg;)anCYysegaH ehIyCaRBHn
nwgelIksresIrdl;RTg; KWCaRBHnBuknwgdMekIgRTg; .
cMeBaHnagm:aram
nagm:aram nigBYkRsITaMgGs;)anCaGkTTYlxusRtv xag
EpkceRmgfVaydl;RBHeyhUv:aEdlnagm:aram)aneRcg .
RBHKm<IrnikmnM 1520/21 Ecgfa eharam:aram Cabg
RsIrbs;eGIru:n nagkykRkab;mkenAd ehIybNasITaMgGs;Ka k
eTAtamTaMgbnrRkab;ehIyelatkeBagkBaat;pg m:aramnagk
TTYlBakeqIynwgeKfa cUreRcgfVayRBHeyhUv:a d,itRTg;manCy
CMnHy:ag]tm RTg;)anplTaMgesHTaMgGkCiHeTAkgsmuRT .
89
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
BYkrasGuIRsaEGl
BYkrasGuIRsaEGl)aneFVIBiFIeRcgceRmg .
RBHKm<IrCnKNna 2117 Ecgfa rYcBYkGRsaEGleKk
eRcgTMnukenHfa [puseLIg GNgeGIy cUreRcgsresIrGNg
enHcuH .
eharaRsIedbUr:a nigelak)ar:ak
eharaRsIedbUr:a nigelak)ar:ak)anR)arBBiFICyCmHrbs;
BYkeK edayeRcgceRmg .
RBHKm<IrBYkecAhVay 51-3 Ecgfa enAfenaH edbUr:a
nig)ar:ak CakUnGbeNamkeRcogfa cUrRkabfVaybgMdl;RBH
eyhUv:a d,itBYkGknaMmux)antaMgxnnaMBYkGRsaEGl ehIybNa
Cn)anRbKl;xnedaysRKBIcit BYkesceGIy cUrsab; BYkemRtt
RtaeGIy cUrepgRtecoksab;cuH nwgeRcogfVayRBHeyhUv:a
nwgeRcogsresIr dl;RBHeyhUv:a CaRBHnsasn_GRsaEGl .
RkmsIsasn_GuIRsaEGl
RkmsIsasn_GuIRsaEGl )anR)arBBiFICyCmHrbs;esc
davIDelIykkUlIy:at .
RBHKm<Ir1saMyUEGl 186/7 Ecgfa RKakalEdleK
RtLb;vilmk KWenAevlaEdldavIDmkBIsMLab;sasn_PIlIsInmak;
enaHvijehIy enaHBYkRsITaMgLay knaMKaecjBITIRkgrbs;sasn__
GRsaEGlTaMgb:unan mkTTYlescsUledayGMNrRBmTaMgeRcg
nigelatkeBag ehIybnrRkab; nigRbdab;ePgepSg kMBugEdleK
elgePg enaHkeRcgeqIyqgKaeTAvijeTAmk edayBakfa sUl
RTg;)ansMLab;TaMgBan; ehIydavIDTaMgmuWn .
90
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
cMeBaHescdavID
rIescdavIDvij KW)anenAEtbneRcgsresIrtemIgdl;RBH
eyhUv:aCab;Canic .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 717 Ecgfa nwgsresIrdl;RBH
eyhUv:a tamesckIsucritRTg; ehIynwgeRcgdMekIgfVayRBHnam
RBHeyhUv:a dx<s;bMput .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 136 Ecgfa TUlbgMnwgeRcgfVay
RBHeyhUv:a d,itRTg;)aneR)askarlCabribUrdl;TUlbgMehIy .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 2113 Ecgfa RBHeyhUv:aeGIy
sUm[RTg;)anefIgeLIgeday\TibTirbs;RTg; enaHeyIgnwgeRcg
sresIrBIRBHecsanRTg; .
cMeBaHBYksg
manBYkelvIdCasgcMnYnCa4000nak; )aneRcgsresIr
temIgdl;RBHGmas; CamYynwg]bkrN_ePg .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 1516 Ecgfa davIDkR)ab;[emBYk
elvIdMrUv[BYkcMerogCabgbneK kan;Rbdab;ePg KWBiN sug nig
Qwgelg[BsUrRklYc ehIyeLIgsMeLgeRcgedayGMNr .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 235 Ecgfa man4Ban;nak;CaGkqaM
TVar4Ban;nak;eTot CaGkeRcgsresIrdl;RBHeyhUv:a edayRbdab;
ePg EdldavID)aneFVIsMrab;kareRcgsresIr .
RBHKm<Ir2r)akSRt 3021 Ecgfa BYkkUnecAGRsaEGl
Edl)anmkRkgeyrUsaLim eKeFVIbuNnMbug\tdMEbenaHGs;7f
edayesckIrIkrayCaxaMg ehIyBYkelvInwgBYksg keRcgsresIr
91
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
fVayRBHeyhUv:aral;f pSMedayePgmansUry:agxaMgfVayRBH
eyhUv:a .
]bkrN_ePgkgkarsresIr nigfVaybgMenAkgRBHKm<IrsBaafI
BYksisS
RBHeysUv nigBYksisSRTg;)aneRcgTMnuk1CamYyKa .
RBHKm<Irm:afay 2630 Ecgfa rYckal)aneRcgTMnuk
mYyehIy enaHknaMKaecjeTAPMedImGUlIv .
TMnuktemIgKWCaceRmgsresIrtemIgdl;RBH .
elaksavkb:ul
elaksavkb:ul)anbeRgnBYkCMnuM edaykareRcgceRmg
Edlmankarcak;eRbgtaMg .
RBHKm<Ir1kUrinfUs 1415 Ecgfa dUecH RtveFVIdUcemc
RtvGFisan edaynUvviBaaN ehIyRtvGFisanedaynUvR)aCJapg
nwgeRcgedayviBaaN ehIynwgeRcgedayR)aCJaEdr .
RBHKm<IreGePsUr 519/20 Ecgfa ehIyniyayKaeTA
vijeTAmk edaybTTMnukdMekIg TMnukbrisuT nigcMerogxagviBaaN
TaMgeRcg ehIysresIrdl;RBHGmas;edaycit TaMgGrRBHKuNdl;
RBHdCaRBHvrbitaCadrab kgRKb;karTaMgGs; edaynUvRBHnamRBH
eysUvRKIs .
RBHKm<IrkUl:Us 316 Ecgfa cUr[RBHbnlnRBHRKIs
)ansNitenAkgGkral;KaCabribUr edayR)aCJaRKb;y:ag TaMg
beRgnehIyTUnanKa edaynUvTMnukdMekIg TMnukbrisuT nigcMerog
xagviBaaN TaMgeRcgkgcitfVayRBH edayRBHKuN .
TMnuktemIg
TMnuktemIg KWCaceRmgnkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH .
92
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
ceRmgxagviBaaN
ceRmgxagviBaaN KWCaceRmgEdl)anRbTan[ mkBI
RBHviBaaNbrisuT ehIyEdl)aneRcgecjeTAedayg KWCaRBH
viBaaNRTg;)anRbTan[ TaMgBaksmI nigTaMgmanBkCYnlEfm
eTotpg .
bTceRmgTaMgGs;enaH KWGacmanCaceRmgCaPasarbs;
mnusS bCaPasadTEdlKanGkNadwg)an .
CavtbMNgdsMxan;
vtbMNgCacm,genAkgceRmg KWRtvEtCakarsresIr nig
karelIktemIgdl;RBH . KWminEmnCakareRcgedayxwtxMRbwgERbg
bedayeRcgsRmab;karCb;elogenaHeLIy . ceRmgTaMgenaHKW
minEmnCakarecjmkBImnusSenaHeLIy KWecjmkBIRBHsRmab;eFVI
[RBHRTg;sBVRBHhbTyEtb:ueNaH .
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 212 Ecgfa RTg;manbnlfa TUlbgM
nwgRbkasR)ab;BIRBHnamRTg; dl;BYkbgbn TUlbgMnwgeRcg
sresIrBIRTg; enAkNalBYkCMnuM .
karbBaak;bgajBIkarsresIrtemIgxagviBaaN
karsresIrtemIgRBHedaysemg
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 169 Ecgfa cUreRcgfVayRTg; cUr
eRcgsresIrdl;RTg;cuH cUrnwkfgBIGs;TaMgkarGsarrbs;RTg; .
eFVIkarTmab;edIm,IniyayCECkCamYynwgRBH
cUrsresIrBIkarGsarrbs;RTg;
cUrcab;epImniyayBIkarsresIrtemIgRBHBImYyfeTA1f
cUrsresIrtemIgdl;RBHedaykarniyay nigkarsresIr
93
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
cUrTmab;xnkgkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH
maneBlsRmab;bnWsemg nigmaneBlsRmab;ERskeha .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 471 Ecgfa mal CnTaMgLayeGIy
cUrTHdTaMgGs;KacuH cUrERskeharfVayRBH edaysMeLgCaCy
CMnH .
RBHKm<IreGsay 126 Ecgfa BYkGkenARkgsyU:n
eGIy cUrbnWsMeLgeLIg ehIyERskehaedayGMNrcuH d,itRBHd
brisuTnsasn_GRsaEGl RTg;FMRbesIrenAkNalgral;Ka .
RBHKm<Ir1saMyUEGl 45 Ecgfa kalhwbnesckIsBaa
rbs;RBHeyhUv:a )anmkdl;kgTIe)aHTBehIy enaHRsab;EtBYk
GRsaEGlTaMgGs;Ka eKERskeLIgCaxaMg dl;em:H)anCaBxrxar
enAEpndI .
94
karRbKMbTePgKWCakarebIksEmgnUvkarfVaybgM
EdlniyayBI]bkrN_ePg
2>
cUrpl;[nUvKMrUBIkgRBHKm<Ir
EdlniyayBIkarrMedaHedaykarRbKMbTePg KWCakarcak;eRbgtaMg[eFVI karGFib,ay .
3>
cUrpl;[nUvKMrUBIkarRbKMbTePg
EdlRtv)aneKeRbIkgkarsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgMenAkgRBHKm<Ir sBaacas; .
4>
cUrpl;[nUvKMrUBIkarRbKMbTePg
EdlRtv)aneKeRbIkgkarsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgMenAkgRBHKm<Ir sBaafI .
95
emeronTI 8
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
kMNt;cMNaM ceRmgTaMgLay KYrKb,IRtv)aneKeRCIserIsCamundMbUg cMeBaHkarcab;epImemeronenH Edlnwg
)anCakarxqtxMRbwgERbg kgkarbeBajskmPaB EdlebIkbgajBIkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkaymak; KWEdlBYk
eK)ansikSarYcmkehIy . bnab;BIkarbBaak;bgajxagrUbkay EdlRtv)aneKTTYlkarsikSarYcmkehIy enaHcUr
cMNayeBlevla edIm,IeFVIkarBiesaFn_nUvkarbBaak;bgajCaBiessenaH enAkgeBlevlankarsresIrtemIgdman
kRmitx<s; benAkgkarfVaybgMEdlsitenAkgcit . vaCakareFVI[ql;faetIRBHvtmannRBH nwgcUlmkKg;kgcitrbs;
eyIgedayviFINa enAeBlEdleyIgmankarBiesaFn_ nUvkarcglbgajBIkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgMenAkgRBH
Km<IrenaHg .
karcglbgajBIkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
edaykarQr
karQrKwCasBaankareKarB .
RBHKm<Ir2r)akSRt 2019 Ecgfa BYkelvI xagBYkkUn
ecAekhat; nigBYkkUnecAkUereKQreLIg sresIrdl;RBHeyhUv:a Ca
RBHnsasn_GRsaEGl edaysMeLgy:agxaMgRkElg .
RBHKm<IrvivrN 79/10 Ecgfa eRkayenaHmk RkeLk
eTAeXIjmnusS1hVgy:agFM EdlKanGkNaGacnwgrab;)aneLIy
eKmkBIRKb;TaMgsasn_ RKb;TaMgBUCmnusS RKb;TaMgRKsar ehIy
RKb;TaMgPasa kQrenAmuxblg nigkUnecom TaMgBak;GavsEvg
ehIykan;FagcakenAd eKbnWsMeLgfa esckIsegaHeRscnUvRBH
neyIgral;Ka EdlKg;elIblg ehIyeRscnwgkUnecompg .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 338 Ecgfa cUr[RKb;EpndIxac
cMeBaHRBHeyhUv:a ehIy[RKb;mnusSenAelakiyekatERkgdl;RTg;
cuH .
96
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
karedIrdEgr
karTHdrbs;elakGk KWCakarcglbgajcMeBaHPaB
sb,ayrIkray GMNrGr nigkarkPaB .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 471 Ecgfa mal CnTaMgLayeGIy
cUrTHdTaMgGs;KacuH cUrERskeharfVayRBH edaysMeLgCaCy
CMnH .
RBHKm<IreGsay 5512 Ecgfa d,itgral;Kanwgecj
eTAedayGMNr ehIyeKnwgnaMgecjeTAedaysuxsan Gs;TaMg
PMFM nigPMtUcTaMgbu:nannwgFayecjCacMerogenAmuxg ehIyRKb;
TaMgedImeQIenARBnwgTHdpg .
karedIrdEgrKWCakarcglbgaj nUvCyCmHxagEpkrUb
kay . karedIrdEgrenACuMvijTIRkgeyrIxUr KWCakarbgab;bBaa Edl
naMmknUvCyCmH)aneBjelj .
RBHKm<Iry:UesV 62-5 Ecgfa RBHeyhUv:aRTg;manbnl
nwgyU:esVfa emIl Gj)anRbKl;RkgeyrIxUr RBmTaMgesceK nig
BYkmnusSxaMgBUEksat;CMnajTaMgbu:nan mkkgkNab;dgehIy
dUecHRtv[gral;Ka CaBYkfwkc,aMg edIrCMuvijTIRkgGs;6f kg1
f1CMu Rtv[mansg7rUb kan;ERtEsgecomedIrnaMmuxhwb rYcdl;
fTI7 enaHRtv[edIrBTTIRkgGs;7CMuEfmeTot ehIyBYksgRtv
pMERteLIg kalNaeKpMEsgecom mansMeLgy:agEvg Bdl;g
97
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
98
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
edaykaresIcsb,ay
mankarcglbgajmYysIBIGMNrenAkgRBHGmas; Edl
manEtpvmYyenHeT edIm,IbBaak;bgajfa vaKWCakarekIteLIgtam
rysMeNIc . kareR)as[Ca nigkarrMedaHdFM]tm KWEtgEtmkenA
kMLgeBlnkaresIcdbrisuT enAcMeBaHRBHGmas; . sMeNIcdBit
R)akd KWCakarebIksEmgnUvesckIGMNrEpkxagkg .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1262 Ecgfa RKaenaH mat;eyIg)an
eBledaykaresIcsb,ay ehIyGNatkeBjedaybTcMerog
enaHenARKb;TaMgsasn_maneKfa RBHeyhUv:aRTg;)aneFVIkary:agFM
sMrab;BYkenaHBit .
RBHKm<Iry:Ub 820/21 Ecgfa emIl RBHRTg;minEdllH
bg;mnusSRKb;lkN_ bTb;Tl;mnusSEdlRbRBwtGaRkk;eLIy dl;
cugbMput RTg;nwg[mat;Gk)aneBjedayesckIsMeNIc ehIy[
bbUrmat;Gk)anERskeLIg edayGMNrvij .
karcglbgajBIkarfVaybgMxagEpkrUbkay
karelIkdRbTUleLIg
enAkgtMbn;EpkxagrUbkay KWCakarelIkdelakGkeLIg
EdlCaTIsmal;nkarcuHcUl . enAkgkarfVaybgM vaCaTIsmal;
nkarfVayyBabUCa nigkarcuHcUl .
RBHKm<Irr:Um 121 Ecgfa dUecH bgbneGIy TUnanGk
ral;KaedayesckIemtakruNanRBH [)anfVayrUbkayTukCayBa
bUCars; ehIybrisuT EdlKab;RBHhbTydl;RBH CakareKarBn
Gkral;KaEdlmanTMng .
99
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
100
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
karsb;sat;
kardYlRkabcuHeTAelIkRmal KWCakarbBaak;bgajBIkar
eKarB nigkarfVaybgMdmanCeRmAeRCAbMput cMeBaHkarFanar:ab;rg
deBjelj enaHKWCakarbnabxndBitR)akdenaHg .
RBHKm<Ir1BgSavtarkSRt 1839 Ecgfa kalBYkCnTaMg
Lay)aneXIj enaHeKkRkabpab;muxeBalfa RBHeyhUv:aRTg;Ca
RBH RBHeyhUv:aRTg;CaRBHBitehIy .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 2920 Ecgfa davIDRTg;manbnl
dl;BYkCMnuMTaMgGs;Kafa cUrGkral;KabgMTUldl;RBHeyhUv:a CaRBH
nGkral;KacuH dUecHBYkCMnuMTaMgGs;ksUm[RBHeyhUv:a CaRBHn
BYkByuekaeK)anRBHBr rYceKnk,alfVaybgMdl;RBHeyhUv:a nig
escpg .
karsb;sat;KWGacCakarcgl bgajcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
enaHg .
101
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
Canickal karRsk;TwkEPkKWEtgEtRtv)anTTYlxusRtv
cMeBaHkarBiesaFn_ nUvesckIRsLaj; nigesckIemtakruNa y:ag
xaMgkarbs;RBH .
RBHKm<Irkickar 2036/37 Ecgfa luH)anniyayesckI
TaMgenaHrYcehIy enaHb:ulklutCggGFisanCamYynwgeKTaMgGs;
Ka ehIyRKb;KakyMCaeRcIn rYceKbkKat;efIbedayfitfm .
karsresIrtemIgEdlbnrtamedaykarRsk;TwkEPk KWCa
karcglbgaj nUvkardwgKuN nigkareKarB EdleFVI[mankarrMePIb
xaMg . CaerOy BYkeKEtgnaMmknUvkarbeBajGarmN_dmanCeRmA
eRCA nigkareR)as[CaEpkxagkg .
RBHKm<IrlUka 737/38 Ecgfa ehIyemIl enARkgenaH
mansImak;Edlman)abnag)andwgfa RTg;Kg;enAtukgpHGkparIs
enaHkykdbfEkvdak;eRbgRkGUbmk nagQrBIxageRkayeTob
RBH)aTRTg;TaMgyM cab;taMgsMrk;TwkEPk TTwkRBH)aTRTg; rYcyk
sk;k,alnagCUt kefIIbRBH)aT edayRsLaj; ehIyykeRbg
RkGUblabpg .
CaerOy karRsk;TwkEPkKWCakarplitnUvesckIGMNr nig
CyCmHdFM]tm .
102
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
karelatraMKWCakarebIksEmgdx<s;bMput . vatRmv[eRbI
R)as; nUvrUbkayTaMgmUl tamlMdab;nkarbBaak;BIesckIGMNr BI
karsresIr nigfVaybgMenAcMeBaHRBHeyhUv:a .
BakCaPasaeheRBIr nigPasaRkikKWRtv)aneKbkERbfa
{karelatraM} mannyfa {karelat karelatkeBag karelIkeCIg
eLIg bkarelat} . cMeBaHBakdTeTot BakxHKWCaeFVIeTAeday
g RBmTaMgkareFVIedaymincaM)ac;eronsURttamEbbFmCatienaH
eLIy .
RBHKm<Irkickar 38 Ecgfa Kat;ksHQreLIgedIreTAmk
ehIycUleTAkgRBHviharCamYynwgGkTaMg2enaH TaMgedIr TaMg
elat TaMgsresIrdl;RBHpg .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1493 Ecgfa KYr[eKsresIrRBH
namRTg; edayelatkeBag KYr[eKeRcgsresIrRTg; edayRkab;
nigsug .
103
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
KMrUnkarelatraMenAkgRBHKm<IrsBaacas;
enAkgBiFIbuN
BYkkUnecAGuIRsaEGl)anelatraMenAkgBiFI nkarsegaH
nigkareR)aselaH KWenAeBlEdlBYkeKRtv)anrMedaHecjBICnCati
eGsIB .
RBHKm<IrnikmnM 1520 Ecgfa eharam:aram CabgRsI
rbs;eGIru:n nagkykRkab;mkenAd ehIybNasITaMgGs;Ka k
eTAtamTaMgbnrRkab; ehIyelatkeBagkBaat;pg .
BYkeKmanesckIGMNrGrsb,ay KWenAeBlEdlhwbn
esckIsBaaRtv)anerobcMeLIgvij .
RBHKm<Ir2saMyUEGl 614 Ecgfa davIDkelatkeBaag
Gs;BIkMLaMgRTg;enAcMeBaHRBHeyhUv:a RTg;Bak;eGpUDeFVIBIsMBt;xt
eTs .
karraMedaynUvviBaaN
tamktbuKl bCaRkm
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
karelatraMedaynUvviBaaN KWminEmnCakarelatraMeday
mansmaCikEdlmanePTpyKaenaHeT .
nagm:aram nigBYksITaMgGs;)anelatraM
karelatraMTaMgcas;TaMgekg
KankarkMNt;Gayu
kareRcg nigkarelatraM
kareRcg nigkarelatraM KWEtgEteTAedayTnwmnwgKa .
RBHKm<Ir1saMyUEGl 295 Ecgfa etIenHminEmndavIDeT
bGI CaGkEdleK)aneRcgeqIyKaBIdMeNIrvakgr)aMeKfa sUl)an
sMLab;TaMgBan; EtdavIDTaMgmuWn .
eBlevlaEdlRtvelatraM
maneBlevlaRtwmRtv EdlRtvelatraM .
RBHKm<Irsasa 34 Ecgfa maneBlyM nigeBlesIc man
eBlsMrab;esayesak nigeBlsMrab;elatkeBag .
karelatraMenAcMeBaHRBHGmas;
karcglbgajBIkarsresIrtemIgenH KWCakarsab;bgab;nUv
RBHbnlrbs;RBHEdl)anebIksEmgehIy EdleyIgral;KaRtvEt
sresIrtemIgdl;RTg; edaykarelatraMenaH . KWCaskmPaB Edl
CabMNgcitrbs;eyIg sUm,IEteyIgmanGarmN_faeqatlg; eday
kareFVIy:agdUecaH enaHKWedaysarEteyIgsab;bgab;dl;RBH ehIy
105
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
)anrYmshkarN_CamYynwgGkeCOdTeTot enAeBlEdlBYkeK)an
elatraMenAcMeBaHRBHGmas; .
karelatraMedayRBHviBaaN
karelatraMedaynUvviBaaN KWenAeBlEdlrUbkayTaMgmUl
rbs;eyIg )aneRkamkardwknaMeBjelj rbs;RBHviBaaNbrisuT .
BYkGkeCOenAkgkMLgeBlenH KWRtv)an {)at;bg;} xagviBaaN
ehIykRtv)anRsUbTajykeTA nUvGMNacRBHecsarbs;RTg; Edl
BYkeK)anRbgRbytedayxngpal; bkedayGkdTepSgeTot
pgEdr . vanwgEtgEt)ansitenAkgeBldRKb;lkN_rbs;RBH
dUecHKWminEmnCakarEdleFVI[xUcecjBIesckIGMNrenaHeT KWeFVI[
)anlm [suIsgVak;RKb;RKan; nig[hUreTA edaymanclnarbs;
RBHenAkgeBlPamenaH .
karEkCafIeLIgvijEdl)anTayTukmk
karEkCafIeLIgvijcMeBaHkarelatraM KWCakarEdl)anTay
Tukmk .
RBHKm<Ireyerma 314/13 Ecgfa RBmcarInsasn_
GRsaEGleGIy Gjnwgsg;geLIgvij enaHgnwg)antaMgenA g
nwg)antak;EtgedayRkab;CafIeTot RBmTaMgecjeTA elatkeBag
CamYynwgBYkGkEdlelgsb,ay>>> RKaenaH nagRkmMunwgmancit
rIkraykgkarelatkeBag RBmTaMgBYkkMeLaH nigBYkcas;TaMg
Gs;Kapg d,itGjnwgbMERbesckIesakesArbs;eK eTACaesckI
GMNrvij ehIykMsanciteK RBmTaMg[eKrIkrayecjBIesckITuk
RByrbs;eK .
RbsinebIeyIgral;KaCarasGuIRsaEGlxagviBaaN GBawg
karenHKWsRmab;eyIral;KaenAsmysBVfenHehIy .
106
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
karRBman
karRbytcMeBaHkarelatraMxagrUbkay
karelatraMnragkayEdlCaEpkCaFmCati kRtv)anrab;
bBalCamYynwgkarRtLb;mkRbRBwtkarEbbGaRkk;eLIgvijpgEdr
dUcCakarfVaybgMrUbRBH karkMpit nigkarRbRBwttampvelakiyCa
edIm . sataMgmankarEkgbnM sRmab;karRKb;Ebby:ag . kar
EkgbnM KWCakareFVI[)andUcsuTsat dUcCarbs;edImsuTGBawg .
minEmnsRmab;EtkarbgajenaHeT
eKalbMNgnkarelatraMsresIrtemIgdl;RBH KWminFab;
Edl)anRtveKtaMgciteFVIsRmab; {bgaj} bsRmab;karsEmg Edl
RtvEtKUsbBaak;BIkarRbgRbytrbs;mnusS cMeBaHGkelatraMenaH
eLIy . CMnYs[nUvkarenH karelatraMKWRtvEtCakarTTYlxusRtv
nigCakartaMgcit nUvkarcglbgajBIkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBHxag
EpkrUbkay EdlCakarcUlrYmCamYynwgBYkbgbnEdlCaGkeCO
TaMgGs; .
vaRtvEt)anCacMENkBiess TaMgburs TaMgsI TaMgekg
TaMgcas; .
RBHKm<Ireyerma 3113k Ecgfa RKaenaH nagRkmMunwg
mancitrIkraykgkarelatkeBag RBmTaMgBYkkMeLaH nigBYk
cas;TaMgGs;Kapg>>> .
BYkGkeCOTaMgLay minRtvbBab;nUvkarsresIrtemIg nig
RtLb;mkCa {GkRsavRCav} b[)anRtLb;mkCaGkbMEbkecj
edaymeFa)ayNamYy EdlmkBIkarsresIrtemIgy:agxaMgka
kMLgeBln {karelatraMxagviBaaN} bCa {karelatraMenAcMeBaH
RBHGmas;} enaHeLIy . minRtv)anTTYlkarGnuBaat[)anRtLb;
107
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
cMeBaHBYkGkeCO edIm,IbdiesFnUvkarcUlmkkgkarelatraM
sresIrtemIg enAcMeBaHRBHGmas; KWenAeBlEdlRBHviBaaNbrisuT
kMBugEteFVIclna edaynUvmeFa)ay EdlsitenAkgskmPaBTas;
TTwgenAcMeBaHRBH . edIm,I[mankardwgxnedayxng RBmTaMg
mankarekatxac cMeBaHkar)at;bg;nUvkarecHeKarBxngrbs;buKl
Namak; EdlGacmankarRBycit bkmankarrMgab; nUvkarbgrmk
nRBHviBaaNbrisuT .
kardGsarbMputxH KWCa {karvayTmHyk)an} Edl)an
ekIteLIg KWCaclnanRBHviBaaNbrisuT Edl)anyagmkrUbkay
rbs;BYkGkeCO KWenAeBlEdlmak;)ansab;xagGataniym nig
eFVIclnaedaykarsab;bgab;dl;RBHviBaaNbrisuT KWeK)aneFVIkar
EdlescdavID)aneFVIEdr {karelatraMenAcMeBaHRBHGmas; eday
maneBjnUvRKb;TaMgbTietCrbs;pgRTg;}.
108
karcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIgxagEpkrUbkay
sMNYrrMBksareLIgvij
1>
cUr[eQaHbIy:agCakarcglbgaj nUvkarsresIrtemIg
EdlRtv)aneKbkERbfa Ca\riyabfnkar Fanar:ab;rg nigkareKarB .
2>
3>
enAkgkarbEnmcMeBaHerag]e)asfrbs;escdavID
etIkarcglbgajnUvkarfVaybgM KWCaTMnay cMeBaHkarEkBYkCMnuMsarCafIeLIgvijb?
etIkarcglbgajnUvkarsresIrtemIg
xagEpkrUbkayenaHy:agdUcemcEdr
EdlelakGkman
GarmN_minsuxRsYlesIrEtRKb;eBlCamYyGkepSg? etIRBHbnlrbs;RBHEcgmkdUcemcEdr GMBI
cMNucBiessenaH? etIelakGkmanbMNgnwgsresIrtemIgdl;RBH edaymeFa)aydUecH)anbeT
RbsinebIRTg;sBVRBHhbTy[elakGkeFVIy:agdUecaH?
109
emeronTI 9
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
karKanlTPaBedIm,IcUleTAsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgM KWCa
]bsK EdlmanbBaaCamUldanrvagRBH nigeyIg . vaCakarsMxan;
EdlGkeCOmak; mankarEsVgrkRBHGg rhUtdl;BYkeKdwgnUvGVI
EdlCabBaarbs;BYkeK bkCabBaaEdlman ehIyBYkeKenAEtTak;
TgCamYynwgbBaaenaH . dUcKaEdr ]bsKEdlenAEtmanenAkg
eyIg KWCakarraraMgenAcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGmas; KWva
GacTuk[eyIgenAsresIrtemIg EtKancemIykgkarGFisan bk
min)anTTYlnUvkareR)as[CaCaedIm .
karGt;eTasEtgEtRtv)anRbTan[
{min)ancakecjeTANaeT}
{EsnGam:asNas; manGarmN_fa dwgxnBIPaBGata
niym}
eTaHCay:agNakeday karsresIrtemIg KWCaRBHraCbBati
mkBIRBH ehIyKankMNt;nUvkarGt;eTasEdr
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1506 Ecgfa KYr[CIvitTaMgLay
EdlmandegIm )ansresIrdl;RBHeyhUv:a cUrsrsIrdl;RBHeyhUv:a
cuH .
]bkKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIgEdleyIgRtvTak;TgCamYyRBH
KWCaGMeBI)ab
GMeBI)abKWCakarbMEbknUvkarRbkbTak;Tg nigkarR)aRsy
Tak;TgCamYynwgRBH . GMeBI)abraraMgeyIgBIRBHvtmanrbs;RBH .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 6618 Ecgfa ebIRbsinCaeXIj
manesckITucritenAkgcit enaHRBHGmas;RTg;minRBmsab;eT .
110
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
karpnaeTasKWRtv)andak;mkelIeyIgedaysataMg minEmn
mkBIRBHeLIy .
eyIg)anTUlsUmdl;RBHmg edIm,I[RTg;)anGt;eTas)ab
[eyIg enaHeyIgRtvEtGt;eTas)ab[xneyIgEdr . karpnaeTas
KWCalTplEdlmanenAkg
karTTYlsal;nUvPaBKantm dUecHeyIg)anlMeGogeTArk
{karnk,alrbs;eyIg} cUleTAkgRBHvtmannRBH .
kardwgxnBIPaBKantmrbs;eyIg EdleyIg)anbMePcnUv
esckIemtakruNa nigRBHKuNrbs;RBH . eyIg)anRtLb;Ca
GkdwgxnBIGataniym CMnYs[kardwgxnEdlmkBIRBH .
dMeNaHRsay
111
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
cUredaHKMnitGataniym ehIydak;karTaMgenaHfVaydl;RBH
eysUv .
eBlevlaEdleyIgRtvbEnm KWCakarKitdl;RBHeysUv KW
eyIgRtvseRmccitsresIrtemIgdl;RTg;bEnmeTot .
PaBelakiyniymkMBugEtmanenAkgcit nigKMnitrbs;eyIg
)andak;eTAelIkargarrbs;elakiyenH .
karseRmccit {kareKarBxng} b {suPavFm} bEnmelI
karbMeBjkargarfVayRBH enAkgkarfVaybgM .
dMeNaHRsay
RBHKm<Ir1eBRts 57 Ecgfa ehIycUreprRKb;TaMgesckI
TukRByrbs;Gkral;KaeTAelIRTg; d,itRTg;EtgykRBHTyTukdak;
nwgGkral;Ka .
RBHKm<IrPIlIB 48 Ecgfa mYyeTot bgbneGIy esckI
NaEdlBit esckINaEdlKYrrab;Gan esckINaEdlsucrit esckI
NaEdlbrisuT esckINaEdlKYrRsLaj; esckINaEdlman
eQaHl ebImansKuNNa bCaesckIsresIrNa enaHcUrBicarNaBI
esckITaMgenaHcuH .
112
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
karxVHPaBkk;ekA bkarRBegIykenIycMeBaHRBHGmas; KW
EtgEtbgak;mnusSmak; BIkarcUleTAkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkar
fVaybgM .
RBHKm<IrvivrN 24 Ecgfa EtGjRbkan;esckIenHnwg
g KWfa g)ane)aHbg;ecalesckIRsLaj;edImecj .
dMeNaHRsay
cUreFVIkarseRmccitvilEbrmkrkRBH edaykarERbcity:ag
eBjelj ehIybnab;mk eFVIskmPaBedaykarsab;bgab; ehIy
cab;epImsresIrtemIgdl;RTg; .
RBHKm<Irm:aLaKI 37k Ecgfa gral;Ka)ane)aHbg;
ecalesckIbBatrbs;Gj cab;taMgBIRKaBYkByuekaerogmk \t
kan;tameLIy RBHeyhUv:anBYkBlbrivarRTg;bgab;fa cUrvilmk
GjvijcuH enaHGjnwgRtLb;mkgEdr>>> .
karbHe)ar
karbHe)arcMeBaHRBH cMeBaHBukmay bcMeBaHsiTiGMNac
EdlRBHRTg;)aneRCIserIsenAkgBYkCMnuM KWCa]bsKdcm,g cMeBaH
karsresIrtemIg .
113
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
manmnusSCaeRcInnaMmknUvbBaarbs;BYkeK cUleTAkgBYk
CMnuM ehIybgbBaaenaHCamYyBYkeK . vaCakarsMxan;EdleyIg Rbg
eRbberobcMnUvcitrbs;eyIg edIm,IsresIrtemIgdl;RBH muneBl
EdleyIgcUlmkdl; .
RBHKm<Ir2kUrinfUs 48/9 Ecgfa EdleyIgRtveKsgt;
sginRKb;CMBUk EtminTlpveLIy manesckIvilvl; EtminTl
114
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
116
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
kareRkmRkMcit
KMnitxusqgcMeBaHRBHvrbita
Hindrances to Praise
edIm,I[eyIgral;Ka)anRtLb;eTACaGkmanCyCmH cMeBaH
viBaaNnkareRkmRkMcit KWedaysarEtRBwtikarN_rbs;eyIg Rtv
bBab;bgrnUvkarsresIrtemIg EdlmanenAkgCIvitrbs;eyIg .
RBHKm<Ir1eBRts 412/13 Ecgfa BYkRbs enaHk
RtvenACamYynwgRbBnedayR)aCJaEdr dUcnwgeRKgPaCnEdl
exSayCag KWCamnusSRsI RBmTaMgrab;Gannag TukdUcCaGkRKg
RBHKuNnCIvit TukCamrdkCamYyKa edIm,IkMu[manGVIbgak;dl;
esckIGFisanrbs;Gkral;KaeLIy .
dMeNaHRsay
KWCadgVaynkarsresIr EdleyIgral;KaRtvEtcab;epIm
edaymanesckIGMNrGrsb,ay . KWCaskmPaBnkarsab;bgab;
dl;RBH EdleyIgral;KaRtvEteskBak;nUvsemkbMBak; nkar
sresIrtemIgrbs;eyIg .
RBHKm<IreGsay 613 Ecgfa nwgEck[dl;BYkGkEdl
esayesakenARkgsy:Un)anPYglMGCMnYsEpH ehIyeRbgnesckI
GMNrCMnYsesckIesakesA RBmTaMgGavBak;nesckIsresIrCMnYs
TukFn;EdlRKbsgt; edIm,I[eK)anehAfa CaedImeQInesckI
sucrit KWCaedImEdlRBHeyhUv:a)andaM manRbeyaCn_[RTg;)an
efIgeLIg .
manmnusSCaeRcIn)anTTYlGarmN_ CaGviCmangMBIRBH .
BYkeKmanGarmN_fa RBHRTg;EtgEtCMnuMCRmHdl;BYkeKCanic . rI
GkdTeTotTTYlGarmN_fa RBHRTg;minsBVRBHhbTycg;[
mnusSmanesckIGMNredayxnKat; bedayxnnagenaHvij .
117
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
dMeNayRsay
cemIyKWRtvEtTTYlnUvkRm {dRtwmRtv} KWCaKMnitrbs;RBH
EdlRTg;)ancMNayeBlevla enAkgRBHbnlrbs;RTg; .
RBHKm<Iry:Uhan 316 Ecgfa d,itRBHRTg;RsLaj;
mnusSelak dl;em:H)anCaRTg;RbTanRBHraCbuRtaRTg;Et1 edIm,I[
GkNaEdleCOdl;RBHraCbuRtaenaH minRtvvinaseLIy KW[man
CIvitGs;kl,Canicvij .
RBHKm<Irr:Um 831/32/38/39 Ecgfa dUecH eyIgnwg
EfgR)ab;BIesckITaMgenHfadUcemc ebIsinCaRBHkan;xageyIg etI
GkNaGacTas;nwgeyIg)an RBHGgEdlmin)ansMcTuknUvRBH
raCbuRtaRTg;begIt KW)anbBanRTg;eTACMnYseyIgral;Ka enaHetI
manTMngGVI [RTg;minRbTanRKb;TaMgGs;mkeyIg CamYynwgRBH
raCbuRtaRTg;enaHpg>>> d,iteCOCak;faeTaHsab;brs; BYkeTvta
bGMNacGVIkarGVIenACan;enH beTAmux b\TibTiGVI TImankMBs; TICMerA
brbs;GVIEdlekItmkeTotkI enaHBMuGacnwgBRgat;eyIg ecjBI
esckIRsLaj;rbs;RBH EdlenAkgRBHRKIseysUv CaRBHGmas;
neyIgral;KaeTA)aneLIy .
c,ab;RbBNIy_rbs;sasna
118
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
cemIyKWRtvEtmankarRbgRbyt nUvesckIraykarN_ BI
RbBNIy_rbs;eyIg eTAcMeBaHRBHbnlrbs;RBH RBmTaMgGnuBaat
[RBHviBaaNbrisuTbgajeyIgnUvpvdRtwmRtvpgEdr .
esckIGMnYt
esckIGMnYtKWRtv)aneKxVl;xVaykRmitx<s; edaymanrUbPaB
CaGataniymrbs;eyIg cMeBaHcMNgcg;)anEtlEdleKKiteTAdl;
enaH . esckIGMnYtKW)andak;mnusSeTAkgGataniym KWeKcg;Ggy
enAelIblgCMnYsRBH . karseRmccitrbs;BYkeK KWcg;sresIr
temIgdl;mnusS EdlpyBIdgVaynkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH .
RBHeysUvRTg;)anBNnaBIBYkGkdewknaMsasna Edlman
esckIGMnYt enAkgeBlrbs;RTg; .
RBHKm<Irm:afay 231/2/5-7 Ecgfa RKaenaH RBH
eysUvRTg;manbnlnwghVgmnusS ehIynigBYksisSRTg;fa BYk
GacarnigBYkparIs eK)antaMgxneK GgyenATIbeRgnrbs;elak
m:Ues>>> RKb;TaMgkarEdleKeFVITaMgb:unan enaHsuTEteFVI[EtmnusS
emIleXIjeT KWeKeFVIsakFMkt;Rkitviny nigrMeyalGaveK[
Evg eKKab;citnwgkEngelx1kgkarsuIelog nigkEngEdlmuxeK
kgsalaRbCMu RBmTaMgKab;cit[mnusS KMnab;xnenATIpSar ehIy
[eKehAxnfa elakRKpg .
dMeNaHRsay
cMeBaHdMeNaHRsay KWRtvEteFVIkarbnabxnedayxnelak
Gkpal; .
RBHKm<Irm:afay 2311/12 Ecgfa EtGkNaEdlFM
CageKkgBYkGkral;Ka enaHRtveFVICaGkbMerIdl;Gkral;Kavij Gk
119
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
karekatxaccMeBaHGVI EdlmnusSdTeTotKitdl;eyIgfa
CaGkCab;cMNg nigCaGkEdlbiTRBHviBaaNbrisuT BIskmPaB
dwknaM nigBIGtcritrbs;eyIg . karekatxacdl;mnusS KWCa
lTplEdleFVI[mankarRBy)arm nigkarfb;)arm RBmTaMgcab;
ykRbRsIEPkrbs;eyIgecjBIRBHGmas; EdlRTg;CamYyGgEdl
eyIgRtvEtmkrkRTg;enaHg .
karekatxaccMeBaHRbePTxH EdlpynwgesckICMenO .
RBHKm<IrsuPasit 2925 Ecgfa karEdlxaccMeBaH
mnusS enaHnaM[Cab;Gnak; EtGkNaEdlTukcitdl;RBHeyhUv:aBit
enaHnwg)ansuxvij .
RBHKm<IrsuPasit 910 Ecgfa esckIekatxacdl;RBH
eyhUv:aCaedImcmnR)aCJa ehIykarEdlsal;dl; RBHdbrisuT
enaHKWCaeyabl; .
dMeNaHRsay
enAeBlEdleyIgdak;RBH dmaneBjedayesckIsucrit
sniPaBenAkgCIvitrbs;eyIg KWenAeBlEdleyIgcab;epImsal;RTg;
120
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
faRTg;CanrNa enaHesckIPyxaccMeBaHGkdTeTotnwgRtvvinas
)at;eTA .
karraraMgrbs;satMag
PaBlg;exA
enAkgtMbn;CaeRcIn KWCakarsMxan;sRmab;karsresIrtemIg
nigkarfVaybgM enAkgCIvitrbs;BYkGkeCO Edl)anTTYlkar)at;
bg;eTAenaH .
dMeNaHRsay
dMeNaHRsaycMeBaHkarenH KWCakarsikSaBIGVIEdlRBHRTg;
sresrEcgTukenAelIRbFanbTenH .
RBHKm<IrhUes 46 Ecgfa rasGj eKRtvbMpajeTA
edayxVHxatdMriH dUecH edayeRBaHgminRBmTTYldMriH )anCaGjk
nwge)aHbg;ecalg min[eFVICasgdl;GjeTotEdr ehIyeday
121
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
Hindrances to Praise
ehtuEdlg)anePcc,ab;rbs;RBHng enaHGjknwgePckUnecA
rbs;gdUcKa .
kareFVIskmPaB minEmnCakarRbtikmeT
manmnusSCaeRcIn)aneFVIkarRbtikm enAkgmeFa)ayCa
GviCman cMeBaHGs;GkEdl)ansitenA {kgsac;Qam} KIWkMLg
eBlsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgMenaHg . BYkGkeCOxHkman
Rbtikm nigmankarsitenA {karedaHxnecj} edaykarhYscitdl;
GkdTeTot . karenHKW)ankayCa]bsKmYy cMeBaHlTPaBkg
karcUleTAedayesrIkgRKb;kar EdlcglbgajBIkarsresIr
temIg nigkarfVaybgMenAkgRBHKm<Ir .
dMeNaHRsay
CMnYs[karRbtikmdl;GkdTeTot enaHeyIgRtvkareFVI
skmPaBtamRBHbnlrbs;RBH . eyIgRtvkarTTYlxusRtv Edl
maneBjedayqnsab;bgb; dl;karebIksEmgnRBHbnlrbs;
pgRBH . eyIgral;KaKWCakUnrbs;RTg; eyIgKYrKb,IsEmgbgaj
edayesrI KWRtvEtsresIrtemIgy:agGs;BIcitrbs;eyIg ehIynig
fVaybgMdl;RTg;CaerogrhUtteTA .
kareFVIRbtikmKWRtvEt)aneKkMNt;RBMEdn nigKaMRTnUvbnk
cMeBaHRbBNIy_sasna nigmankarPyxaccMeBaHmnusS . kareFVI
skmPaBKWRtvEt)aneFVIedayesrI edIm,IeFVIclna nigbgrmkeday
nUvRBHviBaaNnRBH .
RBHeysUvRTg;)anyagmk edIm,IedaHeyIg[manesrI
RBHKm<Iry:Uhan 832 Ecgfa Gkral;Kanwgsal;esckI
Bit ehIyesckIBit enaHnwgeR)as[Gkral;Ka)anrYc .
122
]bsKcMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg
karbUksrub
Hindrances to Praise
karKanlTPaBsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgMKWCakarbgajnUv
mUldanbBaa EdlCaesckIRtvkar edIm,I[)anRbkbTak;TgsarCa
fIeLIgvijCamYynwgRBH . cUrEsVgrkRBH rhUtdl;elakGkdwgnUv
bBaa ehIybnab;mk cUreFVIkarTak;Tg[mankitiyseLIgvij .
RbsinebIelakGkenAEtminGaccUleTAkgkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH
cUrseRmccitBYkCMnuMcas;TuM nigEsVgrkCMnYyBIKat; bBInagenaH .
sMNYrrMbksareLIgvij
1 cUrdak;eQaHnUv]bsKmYy cMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg ehIyedaHRsaynUvbBaaEdl)anrkeXIj enAkg
RBHbnlnRBHenaH .
123
emeronTI 10
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
karepSgKarvagkarsresIrtemIg nigyBabUCankarsresIr
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 1315 Ecgfa dUecH Rtv[eyIgral;Ka
fVayBaksresIr edaysarRTg;TukCaeRKgbUCadl;RBHCanic KWCa
plnbbUrmat; EdlEfgR)ab;BIRBHnamRTg; .
mankarepSgKarvagkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH nigyBabUCa
nkarsresIr .
karsresIrtemIg
karsresIrtemIgKWhUrmky:aggayRsYl enAeBlEdleyIg
enAkg {karRbkbTak;TgdRtwmRtv} CamYynwgRBH . vaCakarhUr
mkedayg enAeBlEdleyIgKitdl;RKb;karTaMgGs; EdlRTg;
)aneFVIsRmab;eyIgral;KaehIy .
yBabUCankarsresIr
yBabUCankarsresIr KW)anfVayeTAdl;RBH enAeBlEdl
karTaMgLayhak;bIdUcCaminTan;)anmandMeNIrkarRtwmRtvl .
karenaHKWy:agdUecH
karsresIrEdl)anfVayedaykarbBaWcitxn KWcMeBaHkar
TaMgLayCameFa)ay EdlkMBugEtdMeNIrkareTA
karsresIrEdl)anfVayedayesckICMenOnigkarsab;bgab;
karsresIrEdl)anfVayedaysarGs;GkEdlRBHKg;enA
124
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
yBabUCankarsresIr
enAEtbn
yBabUCankarsresIr KWCakarsresIrtemIgCabn .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 341 Ecgfa nwgelIksresIrdl;
RBHeyhUv:aRKb;eBlevla esckIsresIrBIRTg;nwgenAkgmat;
Canic .
karsab;B
yBabUCankarsresIr KWCakarsresIrtemIgEdlGacsab;
B)an . maneBlCaeRcIn EdlescdavIDmanbnlfa karsresIr
temIgrbs;RTg; KWenAEtbnkgmat;rbs;TUlbgMCanic .
elaksavkb:ulnigsuILaseFVICaKMrU
elaksavkb:ulnigsuILas enAkgKuk )ansresIrtemIgdl;
RBH edaynUvceRmg nigkarGsarEdl)anCab;tam .
RBHKm<Irkickar 1622-26 Ecgfa hVgmnusSkelIkKa
Tas;nwgb:ul ehIynwgsLasEdr rYcemnKr)al)anknak;EhkGav
eKecj ehIybgab;[vaynwgrMBat; eRkayEdlvaymansamCa
eRcInehIy enaHkykeTAdak;Kuk bgab;emPUXMu [rkSaedayRbyt
RbEyg emPUXMuTTYlbgab;y:agdUecaHehIy knaMykeKeTAdak;kg
KukeRCA RBmTaMgdak;exaHPab;enAeCIgpg luHeBlRbEhlCa
kNalGRFaRt b:ul nigsLas kMBugEtGFisan ehIyeRcg
sresIrdl;RBH BYkGkeTasksab;Edr enaHRsab;EtekItman
keRkIkdICaxaMg dl;em:H)anCarBaydl;eCIgCBaaMgKukpg ehIyTVar
TaMgb:unanrebIkecjPam exaHkrehIbecjTaMgGs;eTA .
125
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
CalkNrUbkay
CalkNxagviBaaN
CalTpl
BYkeK)anTTYlnUvkarRbyuTRbqaMg nigkarebotebon .
semkbMBak;rbs;eKRtv)anedaHecj . BYkeK)anTTYlnUvPaBlVIg
CUrct; nigRtv)ancab;cgnaMcUleTAkgKukeRCA KWCaGkCab;eTas
]RkiddFn;FrbMput nigRtv)aneKdak;exaHmin[erIrYceLIy kminGac
TaMgeFVIclna)anpg .
BYkeKkMBugEtGFisan nigeRcgceRmgTMnuktemIg .
etIBYkeK)anGFisany:agdUecHfa {RBHeGIy ehtuGVI)an
CaRTg;GnuBaat[karenHekIteLIgy:agdUecH} b?
eyIgral;KakMBugEtbeRmIRTg;eTetI .
eyIgral;Ka)anenAkEngEdlRTg;)anbBanmkeTetI
eyIgral;Ka)andwgfa BYkeKminRtv)ancat;mkeT
BYkeK)aneRcgsresIrtemIg ehIyBYkGkCab;KukdTeTot
k)anBBYkeKeRcgEdr .
BYkeKrTvrYcBIcMNg nigRtv)anedaH[manesrIPaBeLIgvij
rInayemPUXuM nig {GkpH} rbs;Kat;TaMgGs; )anTTYlnUv
esckIsegaH .
RKb;KaenAkgKuk)anBBIRBHeysUv .
BYkGkeCOdTeTotenATIRkgPIlIBk)anTTYlnUvkarkmSan
citpgEdr .
126
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
escy:UsapatkCaKMrUmak;eTotEdr
escy:Usapat)anedIrtamRBHraCbBatirbs;RBH nig)an
TTYlnUvkarBiesaFn_nCyCmHdGsar . namrbs;RTg; KWeyhUs
mannyfa {RBHeyhUv:aRKb;RKg} .
karbeRgnBYkbNaCnBIRBHbnl
karGFisanenAeBlmanbBaa
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
RBHRTg;)aneqIytb
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
TaMgGs;Ka)anfVaybgM
karEtgtaMgBYkGkceRmg
CyCmH
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
lkNxagrUbkay
lkNxagviBaaN
CalTpl
CMhanedIm,ITTYlnUvCyCmH
BYkeKEbrCakMBugEteBIbRbyuTKaeTAvijeTAmk edayman
hVgmnusSCaeRcIn mkBIbICnCati .
BYkeK)andwgnUvRBHbnlrbs;RBH Edl)anEcgmk . BYkeK
)ancab;epImfVaynUvkarsresIr KWminEmnedayenAbnab;BIkar
braCyrbs;xaMgsRtvb:ueNaHeT KWenAeBlEdlxaMgsRtv)ancuH
cUlcMeBaHBYkeK ehIyRKb;y:agTaMgGs; khak;dUcCaKanesckI
sgwmenaHpgEdr . BYkeK)anfVaynUvdgVaykarsresIr .
lTplKWCaCyCmHeBjelj enAeBlEdlxaMgsRtvrbs;
BYkeK Rtv)ansmab;KaeTAvijeTAmk ehIyBYkeKk)anTTYlnUvrbwb
dFMeFgbMput .
tamryescy:Usapat eyIgrkeXIjnUvCMhannCyCmH
TaMg5y:agdUcxageRkamenH
dwgnUvRBHbnlRBH
EsVgrkRBHvtmannRBH
130
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
sab;BmkBIRBH
eCOelIRBHbnlnigsab;bgab;RBH
eFVIskmPaBedayesckICMenO
sgamenAkgkarsresIrtemIg
sresIrtemIgdl;RBHenAcMeBaHCyCmH Edl)anebIk
sEmgehIy .
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
paldl;bNaCnTaMgLay RbeyaCn_nwgdak;Rcvak;dl;BYkesceK
nigexaHEdkdl;BYkGkmanRtkUlx<s;rbs;eKEdr edIm,InwgsMerckar
vinicydl;eK dUcCa)ankt;TukehIy karenHCakitiysdl;BYkGk
EdlbrisuTrbs;RTg; cUrsresIrdl;RBHeyhUv:acuH .
enAkgsgamxagviBaaN enaHeyIgminRtwmEt)anTTYl
nUvCyCmH KWedaysardavEdlmanmuxBIrdmutRsYc nRBHbnl
rbs;RBH KWCaRBHbnlEdlRtv)anniyayecjmkBImat;rbs;eyIg
b:uEnCyCmHfFM]tm enaHkRtv)anQHedaysarviBaaN EdlCa
karsresIrtemIgrbs;RBHedayceRmgenaHg .
RBHKm<IreGsay 3031/32 Ecgfa d,itedaysarRBH
sUresognRBHeyhUv:a enaHsasn_GasesrnwgRsyutcit RTg;nwg
vayeKedaydMbgrbs;RTg; ehIyRKb;rydMbgEdlRBHeyhUv:a
)andMrUv[RtvvayeK enaHnwgBsUrRkab;nigsugRbKMeLIgCadrab
kgRKb;TaMgeBltKaenaH RTg;nwgc,aMgnwgeK edayRBHBahuelIk
sMerc .
karsresIrtemIgeday]bkrN_ePg KWmanEpkmYydsMxan;
edaymanCyCmHenARKb;smrPUmixagviBaaN .
karfVaybgM karGFib,ay nigkareFVIsgam
RBHKm<IrvivrN 196-8 Ecgfa enaHBsUrdUcCasMeLg
nmnusS1hVgy:agFM dUcsUrTwkeRcIn ehIydUcsUrprlan;y:ag
xaMgfa haellUy:a d,itRBHGmas;dCaRBH EdlmanRBHecsabMput
RTg;esayraCeLIgehIy cUr[eyIgGrsb,ay ehIyrIkrayeLIg
TaMgfVaysirIldl;RTg;cuH d,it)andl;eBlerobvivahmglnkUn
ecomehIy PriyaRTg;)anerobxnCaeRsc RTg;RbTan[nag)an
132
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
karfVaybgM
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
karGFib,ay
kareFVIsgam
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
eXareXArbs;esckIxJal;nRBHdmanRBHecsabMput RTg;manRBH
namkt;enARBHBs ehIyenARBHrURTg;fa escelIGs;TaMgesc
CaRBHGmas;elIGs;TaMgRBHGmas; .
yBabUCankarsresIr KW)anRbTan[tamryRBHeysUv
yBabUCankarsresIr GacRtv)anRbTanmkRtwmEttam
ryRBHeysUvETb:ueNaH .
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 1315 Ecgfa dUecH Rtv[eyIgral;Ka
fVayBaksresIr edaysarRTg;TukCaeRKgbUCadl;RBHCanic KWCa
plnbbUrmat; EdlEfgR)ab;BIRBHnamRTg; .
vaCakarfVaynUvkarGrRBHKuN edaynUvRBHnamRTg;sRmab;
dl;Gs;GkEdlRTg; Kg;enACamYy nigGVIEdlRTg;)aneFVIrYcehIy .
RBHKm<IreGePsUr 520 Ecgfa TaMgGrRBHKuNdl;RBHd
CaRBHvrbitaCadrab kgRKb;karTaMgGs; edaynUvRBHnamRBH
eysUvRKIs .
vaCakarfVaynUvkarGrRBHKuN edaynUvRBwtikarN_TaMgGs;
minEmnedayRKan;EtCakarEdleyIg )aneFVIkarRbwkSadlenaHeT .
RBHKm<Ir1EfsSaLnic 516-18 Ecgfa cUrGrsb,ay
Canic cUrGFisan\tQb;Qr cUrGrRBHKuNkgRKb;karTaMgGs;
BIeRBaHRBHRTg;sBVRBHhbTy[Gkral;KaeFVIy:agdUecaH edaynUv
RBHRKIseysUv .
eyIgGaceFVIkarenH)an enAeBlEdleyIgRbtibti)aneBj
elj KWCareobEdlRBHRTg;)anbgVilRKb;karTaMgGs; [eFVIkarrYm
Ka sRmab;CaesckIlenAkgCIvitrbs;eyIgral;Ka .
135
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
cUrcgcaMBIkarseRmccitrbs;elakGk
cUrbnnUvTmab;kgkarsresIrtemIgrbs;elakGk
cUrcgcaMfa karsresIrtemIgenAkgeBldlM)ak enaHRBH
RTg;nwgeFVIkar[)anCaRbeyaCn_dl;elakGk .
cUrsresIrtemIgenAkgeBldlM)ak enaHnwgnaMmknUvsirIl
fVaydl;RBHdCaRBHvrbita .
eBlEdleyIgminTTYlGarmN_ kgkarsresIrtemIgdl;
RBH enaHKWCaeBlEdleyIgRtvkarsresIrtemIgdl;RTg; [esIrEt
RKb;eBlTaMgGs;vij . enAeBlEdleyIgbeBajskmPaB kgkar
136
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
sab;bgab;dl;RBHbnlrbs;RBH nigcab;epImsresIrtemIgdl;RTg;
enaHeyIgRtvEtfVaydgVaynkarsresIrdBitdl;RBH ehIyEdl
Kab;dl;RBHhbTynRTg; .
karcab;epImedayesckICMenO
meFa)ayEdlelakGkcab;epIm KWRtvfVaydgVaynkar
sresIr edaynUvesckICMenO . karsresIrtemIgdl;RTg;sRmab;kar
EdlRTg;)anKg;enA nigsRmab;GVIEdlRTg;)aneFVIrYcmkehIy .
bnab;mk cUrfVaydgVaynkarGrRBHKuNdl;RBHsRmab;sankarN_
TaMgLay EdlsUm,IEtelakGkminyl;keday .
cUrsresIrtemIgdl;RTg; sRmab;kareFVIpvnkarrMedaH sUm,I
EtelakGkminGacemIleXIjpvecjBIbBaaenaHkeday . cUr
sresIrtemIgdl;RBHsRmab;karEdlRTg;)anKg;enA nigrMedaHcit
KMnitelakGk[)anmkRTg; RBmTaMgesckIsnatamryRBH
bnlrbs;RTg; .
m:ageTot elakGk)ancab;epImfVaydgVaynkarsresIr
ehIyenAEtbnteTAeTot . cUrRbkasxaMgBIRBHbnlrbs;RBH
EdlesckIRbkasenaH[)anCaCyCmH nigCakarrMedaH .
TImYy elakGknwg)anCadgVaynkarsresIredaykarsab;
bgab; . edaykareFVIy:agdUecH enaHelakGknwgrkSacitKMnitrbs;
elakGkeTAelIRTg; ehIynwgminsitenAelIRBwtikarN_enaHeLIy .
enAeBlEdlelakGk rkSanUvkareRbbeFobBIGMNacecsa nig
sirIlrbs;RTg; eTAnwgRBwtikarN_rbs;elakGk enaHelakGknwg
eXIjnUvrebobdtUcmYy EdlvaBitR)akdCamanEmn .
enAeBlEdlelakGkbMeBj dl;KMnitrbs;elakGkCamYy
nwgRBHbnlrbs;RBH ehIypg;citeTAelIGMNacecsa nigesckI
.
137
karfVayyBabUCankarsresIr
TIsmal;nwgcUleTARTg;
karelatraMenAcMeBaHRTg;
fVaysirIldl;RTg; nigbTietCedaynUvRBHnamRTg;
ehIyRTg;nwgerobpvnesckIsegaH nigrMedaHelakGk
sMNYrrMBksareLIgvij
1 etIkarepSgKarvagkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH nigkafVaydgVaynkarsresIr enaHy:agdUcemcxH?
emeronTI 11
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
esckIepIm
kargarCadMbUgrbs;BYkCMnuMedIm KWkMBugEtbMeBjkargarfVay
dl;RBHGmas; .
RBHKm<Irkickar 31-3 Ecgfa rIkgBYkCMnuMenARkg
Gan;TIy:Uk enaHmanRKGFib,ay nigRKbeRgnxH>>> kMBugEdlGk
TaMgenaHeFVIkargarfVayRBHGmas;TaMgtm enaHRBHviBaaNbrisuT
manbnlR)ab;fa cUrEjk)aNa)as nigsulecj[ sMrab;kargar
EdlehAeK[eFVI dUecH eRkayEdl)antm ehIyGFisan RBm
TaMgdak;delIGkTaMg2 enaHkebIk[eKeTA .
enAeBlEdlBYkCMnuM)ancab;epIm erobcMkargarCadMbUg enaH
BYkeKk)anrGilPat;dYlpgEdr rIkarbMeBjkargardTeTot KW)an
kayeTACakarcaM)ac;kan;EteRcIneLIg . BYkCMnuMRtvkarkarbMeBj
kargardl;GkEdlmanCmW dl;BYkGkEdlmankarrgTukedayBYk
viBaaNGaRkk; dl;BYkGkRk nigdl;BYkGkEdlmancitesaHkeRkaH
CaedIm . karRbwkSakargarKW)ancab;epImTak;TgCamYynwgbBaan
karrMCYlkgcit bBaaGaBah_BiBah_ eTAdl;Gs;GkEdlRsvwgxYb
nigejneRKgejn RkmyuvCnEdlmankarbHe)ar nigekgEdl
RtvBntecj . kareFVIbBaIKWmanCabnCab;Canic . karlHElg
karkMpit kargubgulkgkamKuN CmWpvePTKW)ancab;epImratt,at
dl;BYkCMnuM .
139
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
etIvaGacecHEtekItmaneLIgb enAeBlEdlrUbkayrbs;
RBHRKIs)anvilRtLb;mkkarbMeBjkargarCaTUeTA kgkarsresIr
temIg nigkarfVaybgM RKb;TaMgkarbMeBjkargardTeTotTaMgGs;
enH nwgkaymkCamankarcaM)ac; kan;EttictYceTAb? maneBlCa
eRcInEdlBYkRkmnimYy cUleTAkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVay
bgMdBit ehIykmanmnusSCaeRcIn)ancab;epImeFVIkareR)as[Ca
xagGarmN_ xagrUbkay ehIysUm,IEtenAeBlEdlBYkeK )an
cUlmkRBHvtmannRBH enaHkRtv)anTTYlnUvkarrMedaHpgEdr .
karbMeBjkargarCasg
sUm,IEtRBHeysUvRTg;kCasemcsgneyIgpgEdr KWEdl
eyIg)anEckcaynUvPaBCasemcsgrbs;RTg;enaHg . GkeCO
RKb;rUbKWCasgenAcMeBaH .
RBHKm<IrvivrN 16 Ecgfa RBmTaMgtaMgeyIgral;KaeLIg
CanKr ehIyCaBYksgfVayRBHdCaRBHvrbita enaHsUm[RTg;)an
sirIl nigRBHecsaenAGs;kl,CanicerograbteTA GaEm:n .
PaBCasemcsgrbs;eyIgKWRtv)anebIksEmgtamrebob
elakmuilKIsSaEdk . vaRtv)anebIksEmgeRkaymkeTot tam
rykargarCasgrbs;escdavID . PaBCasgTaMgBIrenH KWRtv
)anseRmcenAkgkargarCasgrbs;RBHeysUv . RBHeysUvKWCa
semcsgdGs;kl, ehIyeyIgral;KaRtvEtGnuvtenAkgPaBCa
sgEdlenABIeRKamRTg; btamryRTg; .
vaCakarcaM)ac; edIm,IsikSaBImuxgarnPaBCasg enAkg
RBHKm<IrsBaacas; edIm,I[eyIgGacTTYlnUvkarebIksEmg nUvmux
garrbs;eyIg)anc,as;las; KWCasgdUcCaeyIg)anfVaynUvdgVay
nkarsresIrCabneTAeTot .
140
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
PaBCasemcsg
elakmuilKIsSaEdk
RBHKm<Irelakub,ti 1418 Ecgfa ehIymuilKIsSaEdkCa
escRkgsaLim knaMyknMbug nigRsaTMMBaMg)ayCUrmk BIeRBaHRTg;
Casgrbs;RBHdx<s;bMput .
elakmuilKIsSaEdkKWCasemcsg nRksaLim bcb,n
KWCaRkgeyrUsaLim . elakGR)ahaM)anfVay1PaKkg10 eTA
dl;mak;enH EdleQaHKat;mannyfa {escnesckIsucrit} .
pyBIPaBCasgrbs;elakeGIr:un KWcMeBaHelakmuilKIsSaEdk Kan
RtkUl KantMNvgSeT . Kat;KWCasemcsgEdl)anTTYlkar
eRCIserIsedayRBHpal; minEmntamryRkwtvinyeT .
enAkgRBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg eyIgrkeXIjBakTMnayGMBIRBH
eysUvfaCasgtamrebobelakmuilKIsSaEdk .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1104 Ecgfa RBHeyhUv:aRTg;)an
s,fehIy fagCasgenAGs;kl,Canic tamrbobelak
miulKIsSaEdk RTg;nwgminERbRBHhbTyeLIy .
GkniBnRBHKm<IreheRBIrkebIksEmg BIkargarCasgrbs;
RBHeysUv KWCasemcsgEdlKg;enACasgGs;kl,Canic tam
rebobelakmuilKIsSaEdk .
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 71-3/17 Ecgfa rIelakmuilKIsSaEdk escRkgsaLim Casgrbs;RBHdx<s;bMputenH EdleTAcYb
nwgelakGR)ahaM kgkalEdlRtLb;BIvaybMpajBYkescvij k
)anRbTanBrdl;elak ehIyelakGR)ahaM )anyk1PaKkg10
BIrbs;TaMgGs;CUnelak namescenaH edImdMbUgRsayfa escn
esckIsucritrYcmkCaescRkgsaLim KWfa CaescnesckIsux
.
141
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
142
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
PaBCasgdbrisuT KWCaelakeGIr:un
elakeGIr:unKWRtv)anEtgtaMgeLIg CasemcsgelIkTImYy
ehIyBYkkUnrbs;Kat; kRtv)anEtgtaMgeFVICasgEdr . PaBCa
sgrbs;elakeGIr:un KWRtv)anseRmcEtgtaMgeLIgedayemelI
vgSRtkUl KWCaBUCrbs;elvI .
RBHKm<IrelvIviny 2117/21 Ecgfa [R)ab;dl;eGIru:n
fa ebImanGkNakgBYkkUnecAg enAGs;TaMgdMNterogeTAEdl
viklvikar enaHminRtvcUlmkfVayRBHesayrbs;RBHnxneLIy .
kartRmv[)anRKb;lkN_
GkNaEdlviklvikarkgBUCeGIru:ndCasg enaHminRtvcUl
mkfVaydgVaydutnRBHeyhUv:aeT GkenaHviklvikarehIy dUecH
minRtvcUleTAfVayRBHesayrbs;RBHnxneLIy .
enAeBlEdlBYksgkMBugEtfVaydgVay enaHBYkeKeFVICarUb
PaBenAelIEpndI bCaRbePTmYy rbs;RBHeysUvEtb:ueNaH .
RBHeysUvRTg;RKb;lkN_ ehIyRTg;kEtgEteFVIRKb;rUbTaMgGs; )an
RKb;lkN_Edr dUecHKanGkNamYyEdlmankarxVHcenaH GaceFVI
seRmc)antamrUbPaBenaHeLIy .
sBVfenH BYkGkeCORtv)anRKb;lkN_enAkgRTg; .
GMBIsemkbMBak;
semkbMBak;rbs;BYksg KWCakarsmal;BImnusSdT
eTotTaMgGs; enAeBlEdlBYkeKmin)anbMeBjkargarenaH . RBH
RTg;)anRbTannUvGtnynesckIbeRgn
GMBIGVIEdlBYkeKRtvEteskBak; enARKb;eBlTaMgGs; . Qut
semkbMBak;nImYy
KWeTAtamRbePTnkarTak;Tgrbs;eyIgCamYynwgRBH .
143
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
semkbMBak;enAeBlbMeBjkargar KWmanbYnRbePT
exaEvgxteTs Linen
kMNat;mYyduMeFVIBIeramecom edayKanefr
exaRTnab;manbYnBN
kMNat;xteTs LinensRmab;TTUr
144
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
karBiBNNaBImuxgarCasg
ePIgRtveqHCanic
BYksgKWRtvEtdutePIg[eqH enAelIGasnadgVayCanic .
RBHKm<IrelvIviny 69/13 Ecgfa cUrbgab;dl;eGIru:nnig
BYkkUnelakfa enHCarebobdgVaydut KWdgVayenHRtvEtenAelIeCIg
RkannGasnaeBj1yb;Tal;RBwk ehIyePIgEdlenAelIGasna
kRtvEteqHenACanicEdr>>> RtvEtmanePIgeqHenACanicelIGasna
minRtv[rlt;eLIy .
elaksavkb:ul)anbeRgndl;elakFIm:Uef[ePIgenAEteqH
kgKat;Cab;Canic .
RBHKm<Ir2FIm:Uef 16 Ecgfa edayehtuenaH)anCarMBk
dl;Gk [das;etOnGMeNayTanrbs;RBH EdlenAkgGkeday
dak;delI .
enAkgnKrsansYK )anniyayBIRsIRBhcarIy_TaMg10nak;
enaHRBHeysUvRTg;)anTUnandl;eyIgral;Ka cMeBaHkarcaM)ac;[rkSa
ePIg[enAEteqH enAkgCIvitrbs;eyIgCab;Canic .
kare)assmatEpH
BYksgRtvEte)assmatEpH BIelIGasnaecj .
RBHKm<IrelvIviny 610/11 Ecgfa sgRtv[Bak;Gav
xteTs ehIyeskexaxteTs eTAekIbEpHEdlePIg)aneqHdgVay
enAelIGasna ehIydak;enAEk,rGasnasin rYcedaHsMelokbMBak;
enaHecj eskBak;bnas;eTot ykEpHecjeTAeRkATIdMeLIg
Rtsalcak;enAkEngsat .
ePIgminGacnwgenAEteqHbneTAeTot)aneLIy RbsinebIeK
Tuk[EpHenAkan;EteRcIneLIgenAelIGasna . eyIgGackaymkCa
145
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
enamored
cUrfVayyBabUCa
BYksgKWmanEtmak;eTEdlGacfVayyBabUCa)an .
RBHKm<IrnikmnM 2938/39/42 Ecgfa rIdgVayEdl
RtvfVayenAelIGasnaral;EtfCanic enaHKWkUnecom2Gayu1xYb
kUnecom1RtvfVaykgeBlRBwk ehIy1eTotkgeBllac>>> enH
ehIyCadgVaydutCanic EdlkUnecAgteTAmux RtvfVayenAmat;
TVarRtsalCMnMuenAcMeBaHRBHeyhUv:a CakEngEdlGjnwgmkCYbnwg
gral;Ka edIm,InwgniyayCamYynwgg .
eyIgral;KaRtv)anTTYlbBati[fVaydgVaynkarsresIr
enaH .
karRbTanRBHBr
BYksgKWRtvEtsUmRBHRbTanBrdl;BYkbNaCn .
RBHKm<IrelvIviny 922 Ecgfa enaHeGIru:nkelIkd[Br
dl;BYkbNaCn rYccuHmkBIkarfVaydgVayelaH)ab dgVaydutnig
dgVayemRtI .
146
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
149
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
karsmat
RkmRKsarrbs;elaky:akub
BYkbNaCn
150
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
151
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
muxgarnBYksgrbs;eyIgKWCakarsresIrtemIg
153
emeronTI 12
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
GkeCOKWCasgEdlbMeBjkargarcMeBaHRBHGmas; eday
karsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM enaHeyIgRtvdwgfa karRtas;ehA
rbs;eyIg karedIrrbs;eyIg semkbMBak;rbs;eyIg nigdgVayrbs;
eyIg .
RBHKm<Ir1eBRts 25/9 Ecgfa enaHGkral;Kak)ansag
eLIg dUcCafrs;Edr [)aneFVICapHxagviBaaN CaBYksgbrisuT
sMrab;nwgfVayeRKgbUCaxagRBlwgviBaaNEdlRBHRTg;sBVRBHhb
TyTTYl edayRBHeysUvRKIs>>> EtGkral;KaCaBUCeRCIserIs Ca
BYksghg Casasn_brisuT CarasdCaekrGakrnRBH edIm,I[
Gkral;Ka)ansMEdgecj [eXIjGs;TaMglkNrbs;RBH Edl
RTg;)anehAGkral;KaecjBIesckIggwt mkkgBnWGsarrbs;
RTg; .
kareRCIserIssRmab;PaBCasg
\LvenHRBHeysUvRTg;Casemcsgrbs;eyIg .
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 715-17 Ecgfa esckIenHkrwgrwtEt
c,as;CageTAeTot edaymansg1epSgeTotekIteLIg TamEbb
elakmiulKIsSaEdk sgenaHmin)antaMgeLIgtamRkitviny Edl
manesckIbBatixagsac;QameT KWtamRBHecsarbs;CIvitdminecH
sUneLIyenaHvij d,itmanesckIbnal;BIRTg;fa gCasgenA
Gs;kl,Canic tamrebobelakmiulKIsSaEdk .
154
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
Living as Priests
karseRmcRBHTyrbs;RBH sRmab;BYkkUnecAGuIRsaEGl
KWEdlBYkeKRtvEtenAkgnKrrbs;BYksg .
RBHKm<IrnikmnM 196k Ecgfa gral;Kanwg)aneFVICanKr
dl;GjEdlsuTEtCasg ehIyCasasn_brisuT[GjEdr>>> .
karseRmcRBHTyrbs;RBH KWminmankarpas;breLIy .
GkeCORKb;rUb KWCasg . cab;taMgBIeyIgral;Ka)an {enAkgRBH
RKIs} mk enaHeyIg)anEckcaynUvPaBCasgrbs;RTg; .
RBHKm<IrvivrN 16 Ecgfa RBmTaMgtaMgeyIgral;KaeLIg
CanKr ehIyCaBYksgfVayRBHdCaRBHvrbita enaHsUm[RTg;)an
sirIl nigRBHecsaenAGs;kl,CanicerograbteTA GaEm:n .
karedIredaymantmcMeBaHkarRtas;ehArbs;eyIg
elaksavkb:ul)anCRmj [eyIgrs;enACaCIvitEdlman
tmcMeBaHkarRtas;ehArbs;eyIg .
RBHKm<IreGePsUr 41 Ecgfa dUecH CaGkCab;Kukkg
RBHGmas; TUnanGkral;Kafa cUr[Gkral;KaedIrEbbKYrnwg
kargar EdlRTg;)anehAmkeFVIcuH .
CarasbrisuT
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 1214 Ecgfa cUredjtamesckIemRtI
cMeBaHmnusSTaMgGs;cuH ehIy[)anEjkCabrisuTEdr ebIGkNa
KanesckIbrisuT enaHminEdleXIjRBHGmas;eLIy .
155
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
Living as Priests
kartRmv[mansRmab;karfVaybgM KWminmankarpas;br
eLIy . RKan;EtRBHRTg;)antRmv [mankargarrbs;BYksgdBit
R)akd enaHRTg;k)antRmv[manBYkeK KWCaeyIgral;Ka .
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 1022 Ecgfa enaHRtv[eyIgcUleTA
CitTaMgmancitesaHRtg; nigcitdwgBitR)adk ehIyesckICMenO
RBmTaMgmanciteR)aHEjkCasat rYcBIbBaacitEdlesAhgpg
ehIy)anlagrUbkaynwgTwkdsatEdr .
tamryRBHelahitrbs;RBHeysUv enaHeyIgral;KaGac
cUleTARBHvtmanrbs;RTg; edaymanesckIeCOCak;enaHg .
citrYmmkEtmYy
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 8611 Ecgfa RBHeyhUv:aeGIy
sUmbeRgnTUlbgM[sal;pvnRTg; TUlbgMnwgedIrkgesckIBit
rbs;RTg; sUmbMRBmcitTUlbgMmk [ekatxacdl;RBHnamRTg; .
{citrbs;TUlbgM)anrYmmkEtmYy edayekatxacdl;RBH
namRTg;} KWmannyfa karnaMmknUvRKb;TaMgKMnit [)anrYmmkEt
mYykgkarfVaybgM . vaCakarRbmafdl;RBH cMeBaHkarfVaybgM
156
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
Living as Priests
viBaaNEdlexcxaM
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 5117 Ecgfa dgVayEdlKYrfVay
dl;RBH enaHKWCaviBaaNexcxaM RBHGgeGIy RTg;minemIlgay
cMeBaHcitexcxaM ehIyTn;TabeLIy .
157
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
Living as Priests
viBaaNEdlexcxaM KWCakarmYyEdl)aneronsURtrYcmk
ehIy BIkardak;Biny nigkarsab;bgab; RBmTaMg)anfVaynUvPaB
CaRBHGmas;rbs;RBHeysUv .
kareKarBhYsehtucMeBaHRBH
karEjkxnecjBIelakiy
RBHKm<IrkUl:Us 113 Ecgfa RTg;)aneR)as[eyIgrYcBI
GMNacnesckIggwt ehIypas;eyIgmkkgnKrrbs;RBHraCbuRta
snPanRTg; .
semkbMBak;dl;PaBCasgrbs;eyIg
kaeskBak;nUvesckIsegaH
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 1214 Ecgfa cUredjtamesckIemRtI
cMeBaHmnusSTaMgGs;cuH ehIy[)anEjkCabrisuTEdr ebIGkNa
KanesckIbrisuT enaHminEdleXIjRBHGmas;eLIy .
semkbMBak;nkarsresIr
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
Living as Priests
vaCakarsMxan;Ed;leyIg)aneskBak; nUvsemkbMBak;n
karsresIrrbs;eyIg . karsMxan;dFMeFg KWRtv)anRbTanmkenA
kgRBHbnl eTAdl;karsMxan;nsemkbMBak;rbs;BYksg enAkg
RBHKm<IrsBaacas; . eyIgKWCaGkeCOCasgxagviBaaN ehIy
semkbMBak;rbs;eyIg kxagviBaaNEdr .
semkbMBak;xteTsKWtMNag[esckIsucrit
159
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
PaBCamas;rbs;eyIg
cMeBaHxneyIgpal;
dgVaynkarsresIr
Living as Priests
eyIgRtvEtcUlRBHvtmanrbs;RTg;edaykarfVaydgVay.
RBHKm<IrsuPasit 39/10 Ecgfa cUrfVaykitinamdl;RBH
eyhUv:a edayRTBsm,ti ehIynigpldMbUg BIesckIcMerInrbs;g
TaMgGM)alm:ancuH y:agenaH Gs;TaMgCRgkgnwg)aneBjbribUr
Gs;TaMgFugg nwg)anTwkTMBaMg)ayCUrhUrehorpg .
eyIgRtvEtnaMyknUvdgVay edayxneyIgpal; .
RBHKm<Irr:Um 121 Ecgfa dUecH bgbneGIy TUnanGk
ral;KaedayesckIemtakruNanRBH [)anfVayrUbkayTukCayBa
bUCars; ehIybrisuT EdlKab;RBHhbTydl;RBH CakareKarBn
Gkral;Ka EdlmanTMng .
RBHKm<Ir1EfsSaLnic 523 Ecgfa sUm[RBHnesckI
suxsan EjkGkral;KaecjCabrisuTsBVRKb; ehIy[TaMgRBlwg
nigviBaaN ehIyrUbkayTaMgmUl)anbMrugTuk\tesAhg drabdl;
RBHeysUvRKIs CaRBHGmas;neyIgRTg;yagmk .
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 1315/16 Ecgfa dUecH Rtv[eyIg
ral;KafVayBaksresIr edaysarRTg;TukCaeRKgbUCadl;RBH
Canic KWCaplnbbUrmat; EdlEfgR)ab;BIRBHnamRTg; kMu[ePcnwg
eFVIKuN ehIyEckcayeLIy d,itRBHRTg;sBVRBHhbTynwgeRKg
bUCay:agenaH .
Bakfa {yBabUCa} sacrifice KWbBaak;fa karsresIr
temIgminEmngayRsYl bRsNukCanicenaHeT . ehIyvakRtvEt
)aneKfVayCabneTACanicenaHEdr .
160
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
Living as Priests
karrs;enACasg bkarKaMRTTmab;cas;
Caerogral;f eyIgRtv)anRbQmmuxCamYynwgkarseRmc
cit . etIeyIgrs;enACasg beyIgRtvKaMRTcMeBaHTmab;cas;rbs;
eyIg pvEdlRtveFVICaFmtarbs;eyIg?
RBHKm<Ir1eBRts 25 Ecgfa enaHGkral;Kak)ansag
eLIg dUcCafrs;Edr [)aneFVICapHxagviBaaN CaBYksgbrisuT
sMrab;nwgfVayeRKgbUCaxagRBlwgviBaaNEdlRBHRTg;sBVRBHhb
TyTTYl edayRBHeysUvRKIs .
cUleTAenAeBlBYksg)ancUl
elakeGIr:undCasg )ancUleTAkgerag]e)asfrbs;elak
m:UesCaRbcaMf eRkaymkeTot kcUleTAkgRBHviharrbs;esc
saLm:Un .
enAsmysBVfenH eyIgkRtvEtcUlmkRBHvtman rbs;
RTg;CaRbcaMfEdr .
erag]e)asfrbs;elakm:Ues manTVarrbgEd;l[ebIk[cUl
eTATIlan . BYksg)ancUleTAtampvenH edIm,I {bMeBjkargar
fVayRBHeyhUv:a} enAkgTIbrisuT . kgmYyqaM semcsg)an
cUleTAkgTIbrisuTbMput EdlmanhwbnesckIsBaaenAkgenaH .
TIbrisuTKWCatMNag[sansYKEdlenAelIEpndI KWCabnb;
EdlmanblgnRBH . rIhwbnesckIsBaa Edl)anRKbTI
senaseR)as KWCaRbePTnblgnRBH . edIm,I[)anenAkgTI
brisuT KWRtvEt)anenAkgRBHvtmannRBH .
enAeBlEdlRBHeysUvRTg;)ansuKtenAelIeQIqag enaH
vaMgnn Edl)aMgTIbrisuT nigTIbrisuTbMput krEhkBuHCaBIrcab;BIelI
cuHmkeRkam . mnusSCatiKWminRtv)anenAdac;ecjBIRBHGs;ry
161
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
RtvcUleTAtamTVar
TIlan
Living as Priests
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
TIbrisuT
Living as Priests
163
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
TIbrisuTbMput
Living as Priests
enAeBlenaH kmanTwkEPkhUrFak;mktamEpnf<al;rbs;
eyIgral;Ka . CYnkal RKb;karTaMgGs;EdleyIgGaceFVI KWRtvEt
bBab;karRbKMbTePg kareRcgceRmg nigkarEdlmanTaMb:unan
enaH[enAesm enAcMeBaHRBHvtmandbrisuTnRBH . eyIgkRtv
EtmankarRbytRbEygcMeBaHGs;GkEdlenACuMvijeyIgpgEdr .
niyayrYm KWeyIgRtvRbytRbEygsRmab;RBH . eyIgkMBugQr
kMBuglutCgg;cuH CYnkal sUm,IEtmankardundabenAkgRBHvtman
nRTg; enaHk)at;Gs;Edr edaysaresckIRsLaj;rbs;pgRTg; .
ebIKankEngsukenAenHeT EdleyIg)anqgputeTAk\t
RbeyaCn_Edr sUm,IEtsemcsgCMnan;edIm Edl)anFab;ecjcUl
BITIbrisuT etATIbrisuTbMputkeday kminGacdMeNIrkareTA)anl
eLIy .
eyIgmanKMrUnkarEdlKYr[RBWRBcmYyrbs;RBH enAeBl
EdlhwbnesckIsBaa Rtv)annaMcUleTAkgRBHviharrbs;esc
saLm:Un
RBHKm<Ir1BgSavtarkSRt 810/11 Ecgfa luHBYksg
)anecjBITIbrisuTmkvij enaHBBkkmkeBjkgRBHviharnRBH
eyhUv:a l;em:H)anCaBYksgQreFVIkargarBuM)an edayeRBaHBBk
enaH d,itsirIlnRBHeyhUv:a)anenAeBjkgRBHviharnRBHGg
ehIy .
bCakarRbkan;xab;tamTmab;cas;
manmnusSCaeRcInEdlenAkgBYkCMnuM BIsmycas;KMrwlrbs;
eK KWmankareRcgy:agTn;Pn; nigy:agRsgUtRsgat; EdlRsg;
ecjBIesovePATMnuktemIg KWEdlmanGarmN_eqatlg; enAkgkar
164
GMBIkarrs;enACasg
Living as Priests
ebIksEmgnUvkarsresIrtemIgrbs;BYkeKenaH . manmnusSCaeRcIn
manGarmN_fa vaminGac {CakarsageLIg} )aneT cMerBaHkarebIk
sEmgkgkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBHenaH . escdavID)ansresrfa
BYkGksucriteGIy cUrmancitrIkraykgRBHeyhUv:acuH
d,itesckIsresIrenaH sMNMdl;mnusSeTogRtg; TMnukdMekIg
331.
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1471 Ecgfa cUrsresIrdl;RBH
eyhUv:a d,itkarEdleRcgsresIr dl;RBHneyIg enaHCakar
sMNMehIy kBieraHpg esckIsresIrCakarKYrKb,I .
eyIgRtvEteRCIserIsnUvkarsab;bgab;dl;RBH . eyIgRtv
EtQanmYyCMhan KWCakarkmSancit dl;GkCMnan;cas;rbs;eyIg
RBmTaMgcUleTA[)aneBjeljTaMgRsug eTAkgkarebIksEmgn
karsreIrtemIgenAkgRBHKm<Ir edIm,ITTYlBIRKb;karTaMgGs;EdlRBH
RTg;)aneFVIsRmab;eyIg .
RBHRTg;manehtuplsRmab;esckIbeRgndl;eyIg [man
esckIGMNrGrsb,ay [)anTHd ERskehar nigelatraMpgEdr.
karsresIrtemIgrbs;eyIgral;Ka KWkMBugEt)anseRmcenAkgRTg;
ehIyeyIgRtvkarkarRbTanBrenaH . plkRmKWsRmab;eyIgral;
Ka
sMNYrrMBksareLIgvij
1 cMeBaHBYksg EdlenAkgRBHKm<IrsBaacas; )aneskBak;nUvsemkbMBak; EdlBitR)akd . cUrBNnaBI
{semkbMBak;} nPaBCasgenAkgRBHKm<IrsBaafI .
2 etIGVIeTACakarfVaytgVay EdleyIgRtvEtfVayeTAdl;RBH?
3 cUrBNnanUvkareCOneTAmuxnkarcUleTARBHvtmannRBH EdleyIgRtvEtbBaak;bgaj enAkg
karsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgMenaH?
165
emeronTI 13
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
karfVaybgMedayviBaaN
RBHeysUvRTg;manbnlfa
RBHRTg;CaviBaaN ehIyGkNaEdlfVaybgMRTg; enaHRtv
EtfVaybgMedayviBaaN nigesckIBitEdr y:Uhan 424.
eyIgGacsresIrtemIgdl;RBH edayGs;BIcit Gs;BIRBlwg
nigGs;kmaMgrbs;eyIg . b:En eyIgGacfVaybgMRTg; edayviBaaN
Etb:ueNaH .
dUcCasemcsgenAfnkarlageTasrbs;xn EdleyIg
emIleXI)aMgnvaMgnnenAxagkg . enHKWCakardKYr[RBWRBc enA
kgeBlmYyrMeBcenaH . RbsinebIsemcsg)anman)abenAkg
CIvitrbs;Kat; enaHKat;RtvEtdwgfa Kat;nwgRtvsab;enAcMeBaHRBH
vtmandbrisuTnRBH . cMeBaHerOgr:avEdleyIg)anTTYlenAkg
TIlan enaHnwgminRtv)anTTYlkarGnuBaat [enA)anyUrGEgVg enA
kgCIvitrbs;eyIgenaHeT . vanwgRtv)anCaf EdlelakGan:anas
nignagsaPIr:a )ankuhk;RBHviBaaNbrisuT enAkgRBHKm<Irkickar
CMBUkTI5enaHg .
edIm,IfVaybgMedayesckIBit enaHmannyfa {Kankarlak;
kM)aMg} NamYyeLIy . eyIgQrenATIPW KWCaTIebIkcMhenAcMBaH
RTg; edayKankarlak;kM)aMgNamYyeLIy . dUcCasemcsgBI
CMnan;cas; eyIgRtvEtRbgeRbberobcMedayxng cMeBaHkarcUl
mkkugRBHvtmannRTg; . RKb;GMeBI)abTaMgGs; KWRtvEt)anTTYl
nUvkarGt;eTas[ nig)anTTYlnUvkarsmat edayRBHelahitrbs;
RBHeysUv .
166
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
karbEgbgg;nwcUleTAkgRBHvtmanrbs;RTg;
enAeBlEdleyIgcUleTAkgRBHvtmanrbs;RTg; enaHcit
rbs;eyIgkMBugEtniyayCamYynwgescdavIDfa {TUlbgMcg;EsVgrk
RBHPkRTg;} . etIeyIg)anEsVgrkRBHhsrbs;RBHedayjwkjab;
rebobNah+ KWCakarseRmccittamEpksac;Qamrbs;eyIg Rtv
)anseRmc .
maneBlCaeRcIn EdleyIg)ancUlmkRBHvtmanRbkb
edaykarRBWRBcrbs;pgRTg; KWkMLgeBlnkarfVaybgMCarYm .
karTTYlGarmN_nkarcak;eRbgtaMgdKYr[RBWRBcrbs;RBH kman
GkxH)ancakecjBIkarenH CalkNTYlEtmak;g ehIyk)an
vilEbreTArkkarenA {xageRkATIlan} edIm,Ipl;[nUvkarniyay
PasadTecjmk TaMgmankarbkERb bCakarTayTMnayCaedIm .
kgeBlPamenaH karcak;eRbgtaMgdxaMgka)anecjmk ehIyBYk
bNaCnk)ansUm[GgyenA ehIyeyIgral;Kak)anseRmcciteFVI
tam {kmviFIEdlmanenaH} .
RBHvrbitaneyIgEdlKg;enAsansYK kminTuk[eyIgenA
EtgEdr . etIRTg;)anTuk[eyIgenA nigcMNayeBlCamYynwg
RTg;yUrb:uNaeTAh+
eyIgRtvkareronsURtBIkarbgg;caMnUvRBHvtmanrbs;RTg; .
karGnuelamtamrUbPaBrbs;RTg;
enAkgTIlan KWenAeBlEdleyIgkMBugEtelatraM enAcMeBaH
RBHGmas;dmanRKb;TaMgbTiGMNacrbs;eyIg KWCakarrkeXIjGVI
mYydsMxan; cUlmkkgviBaaN . XaMgpkTmab;sasna RBmTaMg
karRBegIykenIyxagviBaaN Rtv)anTmak;chugs;ehIy . kmic
168
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
enAeBlEdleyIg)ansikSaenAkgemeronTI1 enAeBldMbUg
.
169
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
ehtuGVI)anCamanPMm:UrIy:a
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
171
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
etIvaRKan;EtCakarekIteLIgRBmKacMeBaHdavIDb enAeBl
EdlKat;)anXValstVenaH KW)ancMNayeBlCaeRcInem:agkgkar
sresIrtemIgRBHenATIval enAegefhimenaH? betIKat;)anebIk
TVarsansYK KWenAeBlKat;)anfVaybgMdl;RBHbeT?
172
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
Gs;rykalCaeRcInqaMeRkaymk KWenAryeBlkMeNIt
rbs;RBHeysUv enaHBYkeTvta)anelcmkBYkGkKgVal nig)an
eRcgceRmgdUecHfa
sYsIdl;RBHenAsandx<s;bMput ehIyesckIsuxsanenAEpn
dI enAkNalmnusS EdlCaTIKab;RBHhbTydl;RTg; lUka
214 .
karsresIrtemIgKWCakarebIks,vaMgnn
vaMgnnnesckIggwt
lUsuIehVIrKWCaecrUbnEdl)anTTYlkarcak;eRbgtaMg [RKb
)aMg . FmCatirbs;Kat; KWCaGkRKb)aMg . b:uEn \LvenHKWCMnYs[
GkRKb)aMgnUvblgnnKrsansYK edaymankarsresIrtemIg nig
karfVaybgM enaHKat;)anCaGkmkRKb)aMgenAEpndI edays,
vaMgnnnesckIggwtvij .
RBHKm<IreGsay 602 Ecgfa d,itemIl esckIggwtnwg
RKbelIEpndI ehIyesckIsUnsugnwgRKbelIGs;TaMgCnCati Et
RBHeyhUv:aRTg;nwgrHeLIgPWdl;g ehIyeKnwgeXIjsirIlnRTg;
sitelIg .
sataMg)antaMgxnCaRBHgGmas; EdlRKb;RKgelITwkdIn
esckIggwt .
RBHKm<IreGePsUr 612 Ecgfa d,iteyIgral;KaminEmn
tyuTnwgsac;QameT KWnwgBYkRKb;RKg BYkmanGMNac nigBYkmas;
nesckIggwtenAelakiyenHvij ehIyTas;nwgGMNacGaRkk;xag
viBaaN enAsandx<s;Edr .
173
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
eKalbMNgrbs;s,vaMgnnnesckIggwt KWRtvEteFVI[
mnusSCatiTaMgGs;ggwt KWvabiT)aMgmin[)anTTYlnUvsirIlrbs;RBH
EfmeTotpg .
RBHKm<Ir2kUrinfUs 43/4 Ecgfa ebIsinNaCadMNwgl
rbs;eyIgRtvRKb)aMg enaHKWRtvRKb)aMgcMeBaHEtBYkGk Edl
kMBugvinaseT CaBYkGkEdlRBHrbs;elakiyenH )anbgab;dl;
KMnitBYkeKEdlmineCO ERkgrsIBnWndMNwgl EdlsMEdgBIsirIln
RBHRKIsdCarUbGgRBH )anPWmkdl;eK .
sgamEdlmaneBjedayGMNac
erOgr:avEdlmaneBjedayGMNac KWenAeBlEdleyIg)an
ksagGasnankarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgMenaHg . {p
xageRkAnkarRKb)aMg} rbs;s,vaMgnnnesckIggwt KWRtv)an
bgrTwkEPkedayEpk nigRtv)anbMePcbMpajehIy . karRKb;
RKgnesckIggwt KWRtv)anTTYlkarbraCyehIy .
RBHKm<IreGsay 257 Ecgfa enAelIPMenH RTg;nwg
bMpajs,Edl)aMgmuxRKb;TaMgsasn_ RBmTaMgKMrbEdlRKbelICn
CatiTaMgb:unanpg .
enAeBlEdleyIg)anebIknKrsansYK tamrykarsresIr
temIg nigkarfVaybgM KWBYkeTvtaGacelceLIg RBHGgRTg;pal;
k)anyagmk ehIyRBHvtmanrbs;RTg; kRtv)anKg;enApgEdr .
KMrUrbs;eharadanIEy:l
enAkgRBHKm<IrdanIEy:lCMBUkTI10 KWeTvtaEdlCaGknaM
saredayRbjab; enaHk)anTTYlkarxusRtvcMeBaHBakrbs;ehara
danIEy:l kRtv)anbBab;f[enARTwg Gs;ryeBl21f eday
sarRBHGgmas;nnKreBIrsuI .
174
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
175
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
eyIgbMeBjtamtYnaTIerogxnenAkgRBHGmas; ehIycab;epIm
sresIrtemIg nigfVaybgMdl;RTg; enaHeyIgnwgvayTmHcUl)an
dl;tMbn;xagviBaaNCaminxan .
kareFVIsgamtamrykarsresIrtemIg
xaMgsRtvrbs;eyIg EdlCaGkFab;)ansresIrtemIgmg
enAkgnKrsansYK enaHminGacQrenAkgkarbeBajsemgnkar
sresIrtemIgenaH)aneToteLIy . GkEdlRtv)anbBaneday
Rbjab;Rbjal; edayRBHeyhUv:a enaHKWCaeTvtacm,aMg nwgcaMBYn
sak;vaybeNjviBaaNGaRkk;TaMgenaH . enAkgkarRcbUkRcbl;
enaHBYkvanwgrujRcanKaeTAvijeTAmk ehIyBYkvanwgRtvTTYlkar
braCy enAeBlEdlBYkeyIgcab;epImsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGmas;
enaH .
manmnusSCaeRcIn KWenAeBlEdlBYkeK)aneronsURt Edl
eyIg)anenATIeFVIsgamCamYynwgBYkxaMgsRtvenaH KWRtvcMNay
eBlCaeRcIn kgkarERskeTAkan;GarkS nigBYkviBaaNGaRkk;rbs;
va . BYkeKKW)anpg;citeTABYkxaMgsRtv .
mankEngsRmab;eFVIsgamxagbTePg enAsmysBVf
enH . vaKYrKb,I)anrMBkeyIgcMeBaHCyCmHrbs;eyIg edayman
siTiGMNacelIxaMgsRtv ehIynigrMBkdl;vapdwgfa vaFab;)anTTYl
nUvkarbraCyrYcehIy
kaeFVIsgamEdlmaneCaKCy KWminEmnCakarERskCy
eXaseTAelIxaMgsRtvenaHeT . KWvaCakarsresIrtemIgEdl)an
taMgenAehIyb:ueNaH . vaCakarpg;citeTAelIPaBdGsarnRBH
rbs;eyIgvij .
177
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
178
CyCmHtamrykarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
179
emeronTI 14
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
eyIgRtvEtedIrtamKeRmagEpnkar nigKMrUnkarbMbYsrbs;
RBH sRmab;kardwknaMxagviBaaNenAkgBYkCMnuM RbsinebIeyIg)an
eKarBtamkarcak;eRbgtaMgrbs;RBH cMeBaHkargarsresIrtemIg nig
kargarfVaybgM .
RKKgVal nigBYkcas;TuMEdlRtvbMeBjkargardTeTot
PaBCaGkdwknaMxagviBaaN
RKKgVal nigBYkcas;TuMEdlkMBugEtbMeBjkargardTeTot
rbs;BYkCMnuM RtvEtpl;[PaBCaGkdwknaM siTiGMNacxagviBaaN
TaMgedaypal; nigTukCaKMrUsRmab;karbMeBjkargarkgkarsresIr
temIg nigkarfVaybgEdlmanRbsiTiPaB enAkgBYkCMnuM .
RBHKm<Ir1eBRts 52/3 Ecgfa cUrXValhVgecomrbs;
RBH EdlenACamYynwgGkral;KacuH TaMgRKb;RKg edaysRKBIcit
minEmnedaybgMeT kminEmnedaycg;)ankMrEdr KWedayKab;cit
vij minEmnEbbdUcCamanGMNacelIrbs;RTBeT KWedIm,I[)aneFVI
CaKMrUdl;hVgecomvijb:ueNaH .
karcUlrYmeFVIskmPaB
vaCakarlenAeBlEdlRKKgVal nigBYkcas;TuMEdlbMeBj
kargardTeTot )ancUlrYmy:agskmenAkgkarsresIrtemIg nig
fVaybgMTaMgGs;Ka cab;BIeBlPamenaHmk [kargar)ancab;epIm
eTAedayrlUn . edaykareFVIy:agdUecaH enaHBYkeKnwg)ankayCa
KMrU nigCakarelIkTwkcitdl;GkcUlrYmenAkgRBHviharenaH .
180
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
RKKgVal nigBYkGkeFVIkardTeTotkRtvkareBlevladUecH
Edr KWedIm,IeFVIkarRbgeRbberobcMy:agc,as;las; enAkgcitrbs;
BYkeK sRmab;karcak;eRbgtaMg edIm,I[)anbeBajsRmab;eFVI
kargardl;BYkbNaCn .
RBHKm<Irkickar 62 Ecgfa BYksavk12nak;kehAsisS
TaMgGs;mkniyayfa minKYrKb,I[eyIgTukRBHbnlecal edIm,I
nwgeTAbMerItueT .
karemIleXIjnUvkarbgrmknRBHviBaaN
vakCakarsMxan;pgEdr sRmab;Gs;GkEdlbMeBjkargar
TaMg5y:ag edIm,IeCosvagnUvkarbMEbkecjdTeTot ehIycMeBaH
karpl;[k)aneBjeljedayxneKpgEdr cMeBaHkaremIleXIjnUv
karbgrmk nigkaeFVIclnarbs;RBHviBaaNbrisuT sRmab;GkcUl
rYmeFVIkargarenaH .
181
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
karEtgtaMgBYkGkdwknaMfVaybgM
182
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
GkdwknaMRkmceRmg
GkdwknaMRkmceRmg kRtv)anTTYlkarEtgtaMgpgEdr .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 1522 Ecgfa ehIyekNana Caem
BYkelvIelakRttelIkarcMerog KWelakEdlbgat;karenaH BIeRBaH
elakCaGkRbsb; .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 1527 Ecgfa davIDRTg;RBHBs
sMBt;xteTsy:agm:d RBmTaMgBYkelvIEdlEsghwb BYkcMerog nig
ekNana CaemelIBYkcMerogpg ehIydavIDkBak;eGpUDeFVIBIsMBt;xt
eTsEdr .
BYkGkkan;eRKgePg
BYkGkkan;eRKgePgkRt)amTTYlkarEtgtaMg sRmab;
kargarpgEdr .
RBHKm<Ir1r)akSRt 256/7 Ecgfa GkTaMgenaHsuTEt
enAkgbgab;rbs;Buk sMrab;karcMerogkgRBHviharnRBHeyhUv:a
edayelgQwg BiN nigsug edIm,IeFVIkargarrbs;RBHviharnRBH
eGsaPeyDUfin nigehm:an elakenAkgbgab;rbs;esc GkTaMg
enaH nigbgbneKEdl)anhat;eRcgfVayRBHeyhUv:a KWGs;Edl
Rbsb; enaHmancMnYn288nak; .
BYkGkdwknaMk)anTTYlnUvkarhVwkhat;nUvGMeNayTanrbs;BYkeK
kardak;muxgarCaBYkRKGFib,ay
CaerOy Gs;GkEdlRBHRTg;)aneRCIserIs CaGkdwknaM
fVaybgM enaHnwg)anbMeBjkargartam {GMeNayTan} CaRK
GFib,aypgEdr . rIBYkGkelgePgkeRbIedaykarbeBaj BIRBH
viBaaNCaRKGFib,ay eTAkgskmPaBenaHEdr .
183
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
GkfVaybgM
kareBjvyxagRBlwgviBaaN
Rtas;ehAmkBIRBHviBaaNbrisuT EdlRtvEt)anTTYlnUvesckI
sgwm nigkarduHdal)an .
RBHKm<Ir1y:Uhan 220/27 Ecgfa rIGkral;Ka )an
RBHdbrisuTcak;lab[ehIykecHRKb;TaMgGs;pg>>> rIdMeNIrEdl
RTg;cak;lab[ enaHkenACab;nwgGkral;KaBit ehIyGkral;Kamin
Rtvkar [GkNabeRgnBIkarGVIeT b:uEn dUcCadMeNIrcak;labenaH
)anbeRgnBIRKb;karTaMgGs; ehIyminEmnCaesckIkMPUteT KWCa
esckIBitvij enaHRtv[Gkral;KaenACab;kgRTg;cuH tamEdl
dMeNIrenaH)anbeRgnmk .
GkdwknaMsresIrtemIg enaHminGacdwknaMmnusSenAkEng
EdlBYkeKmin)anrs;enAenaHeLIy . karsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgM
dxaMgka enaHRtvEtCaEpkmYyRbcaMf kgkardwknaMCalkN
buKl nigCaRkmBicarNaeBlfVaybgM .
RBHKm<Iry:Uhan 423/24 Ecgfa EtnwgmaneBlevla
mk kenA\LvenHehIy enaHBYkGkEdlfVaybgMedayBitRtg; eK
nwgfVaybgMRBHvrbitaedayviBaaN nigesckIBit BIeRBaHRBHvrbita
RTg;rkBYkGky:agenaH [)anfVaybgMRTg; RBHRTg;CaviBaaN
ehIyGkNaEdlfVaybgMRTg; enaHRtvEtfVaybgM edayviBaaN
nigesckIBitEdr .
edIm,I[)aneTACaGkdwknaMenAkgrUbkayrbs;RBHRKIs enaH
buKlmak;RtvEt)anCaGkeCOmanlkNeBjvyehIy . KMnit
R)aCJarbs;Kat; brbs;nag RtvEtmankarBiesaFn_ nigmanCMnaj
185
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
GkdwknaMRtvmanlTPaB
karyl;dwgedayviBaaN
edaykareKarBRbNibtn_
CaGkdwknaMxagviBaaN nwgelIkTwkcitdl;rUbkayEdl)ancUlrYm
TaMgGs;enaH .
RBHKm<IreGePsUr 412/13 Ecgfa RbeyaCn_nwgnaM[
BYkbrisuT)anRKb;lkN_eLIg sMrab;eFVIkarCMnYy ehIynigsag
rUbkayRBHRKIseLIg Tal;EteyIgral;Ka)anrYbrYm xagesckI
CMenOrYcCaeRsc ehIy)ansal;RBHraCbuRtanRBH dUcKaTaMgGs;
KWdl;)aneBjCamnusS ehIydl;xatkMBs;nesckIeBareBjpg
RBHRKIs .
BYkeKRtvEtCaGkmanlTPaBeFVI[smehtupl nigdwknaM
BYkbNaCn)an .
RBHKm<Ir1kUrinfUs 111 Ecgfa cUrRtab;tam dUcCa
)anRtab;tamRBHRKIsEdr .
BYkeKRtvEt)anCaGkyl;dwgxagviBaaN edIm,IeFVItamkar
cak;eRbgtaMg nigkardwknaMedayRBHviBaaNbrisuT )anCaGkvagv
nigyl;dwgcMeBaHrebob EdlGkbeRmIRBHRtvEtTTYlxusRtv .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 7872 Ecgfa dUecH elakkeFVICaGk
KgValXValeK edayciteTogRtg; RBmTaMgnaMpveKedayfVIdd
CMnaj .
BYkeKRtvEtTTYlsarPaB nigcuHcUlcMeBaHRKKgVay nigBYk
GkdwknaMxagviBaaNdTeTot enAkgBYkCMnuM .
RBHKm<Ir1eBRts 55 Ecgfa Gkral;KaEdlenAekg
enaHRtvcuHcUlnwgBYkcas;TuMEdr ehIyRtv[RKb;KamancitsuPaB
186
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
dl;KaeTAvijeTAmk BIeRBaHRBHRTg;EtgttaMgnwgmnusSGYtGag Et
pl;RBHKuNdl;BYkrabsavij .
GkdwknaMfVaybgM KWRtvEtCaGkEdlmanGtcritbgaj
Pstag KWCaGs;Edlrs;enACakCn nigCaGksucrit KWCaGkEdl
ecHTTYleTas . GkbeRmIRBHEdlecHbnabxn enaHskmPaB
rbs;Kat; nwgEtgEtmankarRbgRbytcMeBaHkarRtas;ehArbs;RBH
ehIykminEdlEsVgrknUvkarnaMmknUvsirIl sRmab;EtxngenaH
eLIy .
RBHKm<Ir1eBRts 56 Ecgfa dUecH cUr[Gkral;Kabnab
xn enAeRkamRBHhsdBUEkrbs;RBHcuH edIm,I[RTg;)andMekIgGk
ral;KaeLIg enAevlakMNt; .
karcuHcUl nigkareBjedayesckIesaHRtg;
RtvEt)aneBjedayesckIesaHRtg; nigeTgTat;eBlevla
edaykarseRmcnUvkarTTYlxusRtv EdlRBHRTg;)anRbTan[enH.
RBHKm<Ir1kUrinfUs 42 Ecgfa rIGkr:ab;rg Rtv[eK)an
esaHRtg; .
Gkkan;eRKgePg
kareRCIserIsGkCMnajxageRKgePg
CaerOy BYkRbKMbTePgKWRtv)anTTYlkarRtas;ehAeday
RBH edIm,Ielgtam]bkrN_ePgdBitR)akd KWCaEpkmYynRkm
fVaybgM EdlRtv)anRbTanBr[manlTPaBCaGFiFmCati edIm,I
GacelgnUv]bkrN_ePgenaH . eTaHCay:agNakeday karenHKW
minEmnCakarbRgm[tUc cMeBaHkarTTYlxusRtvrbs;GkNamak;
enaHeT KWedIm,IhVwkhVWn nigedIm,Ihat;sm[maneBjedayesckI
187
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
189
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
RkmGkdwknaMenAkgRBHvihar
karTTYlxusRtv nigPaBCacm,grbs;GkeCORKb;rUb RtvEt
cUleTAkgkargarsresIrtemIg nigkargarfVaybgMy:agxab;xnCaTI
bMput .
RBHKm<IreheRBIr 212 Ecgfa RTg;manbnlfa TUlbgM
nwgRbkasR)ab;BIRBHnamRTg; dl;BYkbgbn TUlbgMnwgeRcg
sresIrBIRTg; enAkNalBYkCMnuM .
karRbgeRbberobcM
karKitTukCamun
RKb;KaKWRtvEtmankarRbgeRbberobcMcitrbs;Kat; ehIy
[manGakb,kiriya kgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM KWRtv[
mkdl;RBHviharmuneK bmunBYkbgbnGkeCOTaMgGs; .
cMeBaHGtcritEdlmankarKitTukCamun nigkareCOCak; enaH
KYrKb,Imandl;eyIgmak; enAkgkargarsresIrtemIg nigkargar
fVaybgM .
karmkTan;eBl
karmkTan;eBl KWCakarbgajnUvvtman nigesckIRsLaj;
rbs;eyIgcMeBaHRBH . eyIgminKYrKb,IeFVI[)at;bg;karmkelOn[
Tan;eBlenaHeLIy KWEdleyIgnwg)ancMNayeBlenAkgRBH
vtmanrbs;RTg;enaHg .
enAeBlEdlmankareCOneTAmux KWCa {karcUlmkkg} BI
TVarrbg mkdl;TIlan TaMgenAxageRkATIlan nigxagkgTIlan
enaHeyIgRtvEt)anenABIxageRkay KWminEmnCakarBiesaFn_y:ag
eBjelj kgkarfVaybgMdBitenaHeLIy y:agehacNas;keyIg
)ancab;ykeBlBImYyCMhaneTAmYyCMhaneTot enAkkarcUleTA
190
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
kgRBHvtmanrbs;RTg;pgEdr . eyIgKYrKb,IerobcMKeRmagcUlmk
[)anmuneK nig)anerobcMviBaaNrbs;eyIg RBmTaMg)anTTYlnUv
karesmsat; nigeRtmbMeBjkargarrYcCaeRsccUleTAcMeBaHRBH
Gmas; enAkgkarBiesaFn_deBjeljbMput RBmTaMg)anTTYlnUv
karBiesaFn_cMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgMenaH .
manmnusSCaeRcIn)anrkeXIj nUvtmdGsarbMputenAkg
eBlnkargarsresIrtemIg nigkargarfVaybgM .
edaykarfVaycitTaMgRsugrbs;eyIg
kareFVItamGkdwknaMfVaybgM
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
192
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
cUreFVI[)anCaGkyl;dwg BIRBHviBaaNbrisuTcuH . Ca
erOy RTg;seRmcRBHTynwgRbTan {ceRmgxagviBaaN} dl;
rUbkaypgEdr . RbsinebIRBHRTg;sBVRBHhbTybMeBjRBHraCkic
tammeFa)ayenH KWqgtamryeyIg EdleyIg)anTTYlnUvsiTI
GMNacNamYy EdlGac)anCatRmvkaredayPaBCaGkdwknaM enA
cMeBaHkarRbTanBrenaH .
vaGacCakarcab;epImniyayPasadT ehIybnab;mk k
mankarpas;brclnacUleTAkgkaryl;dwgrbs;elakGk . vaGac
)anRtLb;mkCaGkecHGFib,ay . RBHRTg;nwgRbTannUvBaksmI
RBmTaMgBakCYn . ceRmgsresIrtemIgfI KWEtgEt)anRbTan[
dl;rUbkayrbs;RBHRKIs enAkMLgeBlTaMgenaH .
RBHKm<IreGePsUr 519 Ecgfa ehIyniyayKaeTAvijeTA
mk edaybTTMnukdMekIg TMnukbrisuT nigcMerogxagviBaaN TaMg
eRcg ehIysresIrdl;RBHGmas;edaycit .
193
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
PaBCaGkdwknaMkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM
195
emeronTI 15
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
karRbgeRbberobcM
kargarfVaybgMEdlmaneBjeCaKCy nigeBjedaykar
cak;eRbgtaMg KWminEmnRtwmEtCakarekIteLIgenaHeT . vaCakar
cMNayem:ageBlnkarRbgeRbberobcMGFisan muneBlkargar
)ancab;epIm .
kargardRbesIrCacm,g nwminEmnCakarcaM)ac;[)anCaKMrU
sRmab;karGVI EdlnwgekIteLIgdl;GkdTeTotenaHeT . RBHRTg;
dCaRBHnkarERbRbl . cUrGFisan nigTTYlkardwknaMrbs;RTg;
sRmab;kargarbeRmIBiessmYy . cUrGnuBaat[RBHviBaaNbrisuT
nigkaryl;dwgBIkarcak;eRbgtaMgrbs;RTg; .
RBHKm<IrbrieTv 322/23 Ecgfa KWnwkBIesckIenHfa
kMuEtmanesckIsb,rsrbs;RBHeyhUv:a enaHeyIg)ansUn)at;Gs;
rlIgeTAehIy esckIemtakruNarbs;RTg; enaHminecHputeLIy
esckITaMgenaH ecHEtfIeLIgral;EtRBwkCanic esckIesaHRtg;rbs;
RTg;FMNas; .
enAkgkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgMxH esIrEtRKb;eBl
TaMgGs; nwgRtv)aneKcMNaykgkarsresIrtemIgdl;RBH Edlman
eBjedayesckIGMNrGrsb,ay . enAkgkardTeTot kargar
beRmInwgpas;bry:agqab;rhsbEnmeTot cUleTAkgeBlnkar
fVaybgMdmanPaBxaMgka .
kareRCIserIsceRmg
eBlEdlmanRbsiTiPaB enaHvaCakarsMxan;edIm,IrkeXIj
nUvRbFanbTnkarsEmgRBHbnl EdlRtv)aneKerobcMKeRmag
196
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
ceRmgEdl)aneRtmtammeFa)ayrebobenH KWEdl
ceRmgTaMgenaH nw)anCaKMrUn {karcUleTAkg} Cabnbnab;
ceRmgnkarGrRBHKuN nigceRmgkarsresIrtemIg
EdlnwgTajnaM[kan;EtmankRmitx<s;eLIg cMeBaHkar
cUlrYm TaMgEpkrUbkay TaMgEpkxagkarbeBajsemg
ceRmgEdlnwgbeBaj nUvkarcak;eRbgtaMgrbs;RBH
ehIymnusSknwgcUlkRmitnkarsresIrtemIg kan;Et
x<s;eLIg
ceRmgnkarfVaybgMcugeRkay EdlnwgbMpas;bERbdl;
BYkGkeCO [kan;EtcUleTACitRBHvtmannRBH .
197
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
ceRmgKYrKb,IRtv)anerobCaRkm tammeFa)ayEdlBYk
GkfVaybgMminRtv)anpas;breTAxagmuxxageRkay rvagceRmg
fVaybgM nigceRmgsresIrtemIgenaHeLIy KWRtv[mankareCOn
eTAmux edayminmankarrMCYy sUm,IEtkarbgrmknkarfVaybgM
enaHkmankRmitkan;Etx<s;eLIgpgEdr .
cUreFVIkareRCIserIsy:agRbgRbyt nUvKnwHTaMgLay enA
kgceRmgEdlnwgRtveRcg nigRkmEdlRtveRcgrYmKa[)anBit
R)akdc,as;las; eTAtamcMNgeCIgbTceRmgenaH .
vaCakarlcMeBaHkarpl;nUv]bkrN_ePg nigRbdab;bBaaMg
rUbPaBenAxagelI RbsinebIGk)aneRbItambBaIEdlbgajnUvbT
ceRmgtamlMdab;lMeday enaHBYkGkeRcgkRtvEteFVItambBaI
ceRmgenaHEdr . elakGkGaceFVIkarpl;[nUveRKg]bkrN_ePg
bkbgajnUvTIkEngceRmgEdlenAkEngNa KWeFVIeTAtamGkcg
RkgnUvbTePgsRmab;fVaybgMenaH . cUreFVIkarpl;[nUveRKg
]bkrN_ePg edayeFVIkarsRmlePgEdlmanExS sRmab;kar
pas;brkUnesarePg edIm,I[karRbKMbTePgGacbnbgrnUvceRmg
nImYy)anl .
RbsinebImanceRmgfIEdlRtvykmkeRcg RtverobcMkar
bBaaMg[)anlebIsinCamanRbdab;bBaaMg EdlRtvykmkeRbI .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 333 Ecgfa cUreRcgTMnukfIfVay
RTg; ehIyelgePg[BrgM edaybuinRbsb; .
Rbdab;bBaaMgRtvEtmankBak;Rss;PWfa ehIyRtvEt)an
erobcMtamlMdab;lMeday EdlBYkeKnwgRteRbIR)as;vaenaH .
198
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
ceRmgnwgRtvEt)anhUrmk BImYybTeTAmYybTeTot
edayKankarrGak;rGYleLIy edIm,I[Gac)anCakarR)akdRbCa KW
[mankarbgrmknRBHviBaaN .
karerobcMedayviBaaN
GkdwknaMlnwgminEdlcUlmkkargarbeRmIeday {RtCak;}
enaHeLIy . karRbgeRbberobcM KWrab;bBalTaMgeBlevladeRcIn
EdlRtvcMNaykgkarGFisan nigkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVay
bgM CalkNeTal edIm,I[)anyl;lkNnRBHviBaaN sRmab;
kargarbeRmImuneBlGgRbCuM)ancab;epIm . bnab;mk Kat;nwgman
lTPaBcab;epImRkmbnrtambTceRmgCadMbUg {GkenAtamtMbn;
pal;} . Caerogral;naTInkargarbeRmI EdlRtvEtmanGkdwknaM
edIm,IeFVIclnacUleTAkgkarbgrmknRBHviBaaNbrisuT KWCaeBl
EdlRtvsresIrtemIg nigfVaybgMdl;RBHdBitR)akd .
karerobcMxagEpkrUbkay
199
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
RkmdwknaMfVaybgM
GkceRmg nig]bkrN_ePg
kareRCIserIsEdleBjedaykarGFisan KWCasmaCik
nImYynRkmfVaybgM . cUreFVIkarkarBardl;RkmGkdak;Biny nig
RkmGkmanPaBRsLaj;desaHxagviBaaN b:uEn Rtv[twgrwg
cMeBaHGs;GkEdlmankarTak;TgnwgGMeBI)ab bcgsm<nCamYynwg
bBaaEdlGacekItmaneLIg .
cUrsEmgnUvPaBCaGkdwknaMxagviBaaN EdlmankRmit
x<s; karelIkTwkcit nigkarrIkceRmInxagCMnaj tammuxsBaa
nImYy . cUrdak;[mansg;dax<s;delIslb; nigbgajnUvkar
sresIrcMeBaHkarnImYysRmab;Epkrbs;Kat; brbs;nag. cUrtRmv
[manPaBesaHRtg; karebCJa nigbRgmviBaaNmkEtmYy .
RkmfVaybgMKYrKb,IGFisanrYmKa muneBlcab;epImkargar
fVaybgM .
karGnuvtn_nUvesckIbeRgn
fVaysirIldl;RBH
cUrkuMeFVIkarGUsTajnUvkarRbgRbyt cMeBaHxngenaH
eLIy . BYkGkeCO KWRtvEtmankaremIleXIjRBHeysUv nigfVay
bgMRTg; RBmTaMgdl;RBHvrbitapg .
RBHKm<Irm:afay 178 Ecgfa kaleK)anegIbeLIg enaH
min)aneXIjGkNaesaH eXIjEtRBHeysUvEtb:ueNaH .
cUreFVICaGkyl;dwg
vaCakarsMxan;EdlGkdwknaMmankaryl;dwg cMeBaHRKb;TaMg
Gs; EdlkMBugEteFVIdMeNIrkMLgeBleFVIkargarbeRmI
dl;RBH nigkardwknaMedayRBHviBaaNbrisuT
200
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
kar)anCaGkKYr[eCOCak;
cMeBaHshdwknaMnkargarfVaybgM
cMeBaHeRKg]bkrN_ePg
BYkcas;TuMEdlmanR)aCJa nigmanPaBCaGkdwknaM
cMeBaHGkdwknaMRBHviharTaMgmUl
kardwknaMBYkeK[cUleTAkg
BYkbNaCnRtvEt)anTTYlkarGnuBaat BIkEngEdlBYkeK
cUleTAkgRBHvtmanrbs;RBH . elakGkminGacdwknaMBYkeKecj
BIkEngEdlelakGkenAenaHeT CMnYs[karenH elakGkRtvEt
manCMnajkgkardwknaMBYkeKRKb;karTaMgGs;EdlenAxagkgKWCarUb
kayEtmYy ecjBIkEngEdlBYkeKenAenaH [)ancUleTAkgkEng
EdlmankarshkarN_KaedaynUvRBHviBaaNenaHg .
cUrEsVgrk edIm,IeFVIkaredayRbjab;Rbjal; kgkarTak;Tg
CamYyBYkGkdwknaMRBHvihar RtvCYyksagnUvkareCOCak;cMeBaHBYk
bNaCn edaymanPaBCaGkdwknaMrbs;elakGk ehIybnab;mk
Rbjab;Rbjal;eFVIkarbMpas;bMERbBYkeK [Gac)ancUleTAkgkar
sresIrtemIgenaH .
201
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
sab;bgab;dl;RBHvij . cMeBaHBYkGkdTeTotKWGacenAeRkamkar
benasBIxaMgsRtv benAeRkambnknkarxVl;xVayvij . manGk
dTeTotEdlGacenAeRkamkarpnaeTasBIxaMgsRtv bkenAeRkam
bnknkarEfrkSaenaH KWRKan;EtmindwgBIrebobRtveFVIEtb:ueNaH .
elakGkCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM KWminRtv)aneTACaGkEdl
minRtv)ancUleTAxagkgenaHeLIy . etIsirIlnwgRtveTACay:ag
Navij enAeBlEdlmnusSTaMgGs;mancitrYmmkEtmYy edIm,IcUl
eTAxagkg)anenaH . eTaHCay:agNakeday kmanGkxHEdl
eyIgRtvEtkuMeGIeBIdwgcMeBaHGs;Gk Edlnwgminkan;xab;nUvkarRbg
RbytdeBjeljbMput eTAelIrUbkayrbs;BYkGkeCO Edl)an
shkarN_KaenaH . CYnkal PaBCalkNbuKTaMgenH GacRtv
)aneKTak;TgedaymanlkNCakCn enAeBlcugeRkay nig
TTYlnUvkarbeRgn bCakartaMgBiBN EdlmankarcUlrYmeday
kRmitx<s; .
cUrkan;xab;nUvkarebIkEPk
enAeBlEdlelakGkbiTEPk enaHelakGkkMBugEtbiT
mnusSEdlelakGkRtvEtdwknaMcUleTAkgkarfVaybgMenaHehIy .
GkdwknaMRtvEt)anCaGkEdlmansm,CBa cMeBaHGVIEdl)anekIt
eLIg nigTIkEngNaEdlmnusSxagviBaaN KWCaGkmankargar
sresIrtemIgkMBugEtmankarrIkceRmIn .
GkdwknaMKWminRtvCaGkEdlkaymkCaGk {)at;bg;xag
viBaaN} y:agdUecaH EdlKat; bnag)an)at;bg;nUvkarTak;TgCamYy
nwgkardwknaMrbs;Kat; brbs;nagenaHeLIy . eBlevlaKWRtv)an
{Rsay} ehIy sRmab;GkdwknaMEdlenAkgeBlevlafVaybgMpal;
203
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
kMLgeBlsresIrtemIg nigGFisanKWminEmnCaeBlevla
edIm,IbBab; nigedIm,I {Eckcay} enaHeLIy . kartaMgBiBNxI KW
CYnkal BitCa)anCYyenAkgkarnaMmnusS[cUleTAkgkarsresIr
temIgdmankRmitx<s; . kuMbBab;nUvkarbgrmknkargarbeRmI bk
CakareRbIeBlevlaBIdMbUg edaykarniyayBIsac;erOgTaMgLay
EdlnwgminnaM[mankarbgak;nUvclnarbs;RBHviBaabrisuT enAkg
karsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgMenaH)aneLIy .
karTak;TgeTAnwgkMhus
cUrcgcaMfa eyIgTaMgGs;KaKWCa {GkeronsURt} ehIykar
eFVIxusKWCaEpkmYynkar)anmkBIkareronsURtenaH . kuMdak;xng
[enAeRkamkarebenasenaH[esaH . cUr[mankarEpmElmbMput
CamYynwgmnusS RbsinebIelakGkmankMhuscMeBaHRBH ehIyeFVI
karpas;brcMeBaHkMhusqgenaH tamkardwknaMrbs;RBH .
CYnkalbnab;BIkargarbeRmIenaHRtv)anbBab; cUrcMNay
eBlevlaTUeTARBHedayeTalEtmak;g GMBIkMhusqgenaH . TUl
dl;RTg;BIkEngEdlelakGkmanGarmN_fa )aneFVIxusenaH . cUr
TUlsUmdl;RTg;BIGVIEdlenAxagkgcit edIm,I[mankaryl;dwg
204
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
vaCakarlcMeBaHGkdas;etOneRkInrMBk edIm,IeRcgfVayeTA
RBHGmas; . BYkeKminKYrKb,IeRcgedaysarEtCaTmab;enaHeLIy
bkCaGkEdlRKan;EteFVIkareRcgenaHeLIy . KWBYkeKKYrKb,I
eRcgsresIrtemIgdl;RBHGmas; nigcUleTAkgRBHvtmanrbs;
RTg;y:ageBjelj kgkarfVaybgMdBit .
cUrcab;epImedaykarGrRBHKuN
muneBlEdleyIgsresIrtemIgdl;RBHy:ageBjelj enaH
TImYyeyIgRtvEtcUleTAkgTIsresIrtemIgenaH .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 1004 Ecgfa cUrnaMKacUltamTVar
RTg; edayeBalBakGrRBHKuN ehIycUleTAkgTIlanRTg; eday
bTsresIr cUrGrRBHKuNdl;RTg; ehIysresIrRBHnamRTg;cuH .
205
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
cUreFVIclnakgkarsresIrtemIg
cUrbgrcUleTAkgkarfVaybgM
cUreFVItamkarcak;eRbgtaMg
maneBlevlaCaeRcIn EdleK)ancMNaykMLgeBlsresIr
temIg nigfVaybgMenAkg {TIlan} enaH . KWenATIehIy Edlmak;
RtvEt)anTTYlnUvkarbeBajnUvsemg nigkarcglbgajxag
EpkrUbkay kan;EtlRbesIreLIg cMeBaHkarsresIrtemIg nigkar
fVaybgMdl;RBH sRmab;RKb;TaMgRBHBrdGsarrbs;pgRTg; .
cUr[)anyl;dwgcMeBaHRBHviBaaNbrisuT enAkgeBlrbs;
RTg;cuH ehIycab;epImeFVIclna[mnusS)ancUleTAkgesckIBit
kan;EtmanCeRmAeRCA nigcUlrYmfVaybgMRBHsRmab;Gs;Gk Edl
RTg;Kg;CamYy .
cUrTukbMNgEpnkarrbs;elakGkenAmagsin TRmaMEt
elakGk)ancMNayeBl[)aneRcIn kgkarRbgeRbberobcM .
elakGkGacpaknUvceRmgxH enAeBlEdlmankarbEgbgg; [
)aneBlyUrsRmab;kardTeTotEdlRtveFVI .
enAeBlEdlmankarcak;eRbgtaMg nRBHviBaabrisuTdeBj
kmaMg cUrcab;epImcUlmk edaykuMeFVIkarRbjab;Rbjal;eBk cMeBaH
ceRmgCabnbnab;enaH . karbEgbgg;enATIenaHGs;ryeBlyUr
KWCakarTTYlcak;eRbgtaMg EdlkMBugEtmankarlUtlas;enAkg
RbBlPaB . karsEmgCabneTot nUvceRmgenaHrhUtdl;RBH
viBaaNRTg;)anbMeBj nUvkargarEdlRTg;kMBugEteFVIkarenaH KWCa
karnaMmknUvPaBCabgbn cUleTAkgkarsresIrtemIgkan;Etx<s;
eLIg bkarcUleTAkan;EtCitenAkgRBHvtmanrbs;RTg; kgkarfVay
bgMenaH .
206
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
GMeNayTannkarbeBajsemg
cUreFVIkarelIkTwkcitedaykg [mankarbgrmkeday
esrI cMeBaHkarGnuvtn_ nUvGMeNayTannkarbeBajsemgrbs;RBH
viBaaNbrisuT ecjBIcMeNamGkdwknaMRBHvihar . Canickal KWRtv
bgg;caMnUvTIkEngdsmrm EdlnwgfVayeBlevlasRmab;RBHRTg;
)anmanbnleTAkan;RbCarasrbs;RTg; tamryGMeNayTann
karniyayPasadT nigkarbkERbPasadT bktamrykar
GFib,ayCaedIm .
RBHKm<Ir1kUrinfUs 127-10 Ecgfa ehIyRTg;RbTan[
RBHviBaaNsMEdgmkkgRKb;Ka edIm,I[)anekItpl d,itRTg;RbTan
[mak;manBaksMdInR)aCJavagv edaysarRBHviBaaN [mak;
eTotmanBaksMdIncMeNHecHsat; tamRBHviBaaNdEdl ehIy[
mak;epSgeTotmanesckICMenO edaynUvRBHviBaaNdEdl [mYy
eTot)anGs;TaMgGMeNayTan nigGaceR)as[Ca edaynUvRBH
viBaaNdEdl [mYyeTot)ansMEdgkarbTi)armI nig[mYyeTot
ecHGFib,ay [mYyeTotsegtsal;Gs;TaMgviBaaN [mYyeTot
ecHniyayPasadTepSg ehIy[mYyeTotecHbkERbPasa
dT .
CYnkal GacmanBaksmInkardas;etOneRkInrMBk tam
ryRBHKm<Ir btamryceRmgxagviBaaN .
RBHKm<IrTMnukdMekIg 403 Ecgfa RTg;)anbNal[man
TMnukfIenAkgmat; KWCaesckIsresIrdl;RBHneyIg mnusSCa
eRcInnwgeXIj RBmTaMgmanesckIekatxac ehIynwgTukcitdl;RBH
eyhUv:apg .
207
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
GkdwknaMfVaybgM KWRtvEtrkSaTuknUvsiTiGMNacxag
viBaaN enAelIRKb;TaMgkargarbeRmITaMgGs; . enAkgRkmmnusS
CabgbndFM EdlRtv)aneKseRmccitelIkdrbs;Kat; brbs;nag
eLIg [)ancUlmkCamak;kgBYkcas;TuM sRmab;TTYlsal;enA
cMeBaHmuxGMeNayCaGksEmgRBHbnl .
karsEmgRBHbnlGacCatRmvkar cMeBaHkarpl;[nUvkar
eRbIRbBnsemg bkgkarbeBajsemglmnwgGacB)an edayRkm
GkdwknaMRBHviharTaMgmUl .
sRmab;karsag
erOgr:avTaMgGs; KYrKb,IRtv)aneFVIseRmc sRmab;karsag
EdlmanlkNeBjvy . RKb;karebIksEmgxagviBaaN KWCa
karRtvc,ab; nigCakarsmrm b:uEn RKb;karTaMgGs;EdlRtv)aneFVI
rYcehIy enaHKYrKb,I)aneFVIsRmab;CakarksagrYmKaTaMgGs;vij .
RBHKm<Ir1kUrinfUs 1426 Ecgfa dUecH eFVIdUcemc
bgbneGIy kalNaGkral;KaRbCMu enaHRKb;KamanTMnukdMekIg man
esckIbeRgn manesckIebIksMEdg manniyayPasadT man
esckIbkERbEdr Rtv[eFVIkarTaMgGs;sMrab;nwgsagciteLIg .
cUreCosvagnUvkarPan;RcLM
RBHRTg;minEmnCaGkniBnedaymankarPan;RcLMeT .
RBHKm<Ir1kUrinfUs 1433k Ecgfa d,itRBHRTg;minEmn
CaRBHnesckIvwkvreT KWRTg;CaRBHnesckIsuxsanvij>>> .
RbsinebIkargarbeRmIcab;epImedaymankarPan;RcLM enaH
cUreFVIkarpas;br nignaMRtLb;ecjmkBIkarPan;RcLMenaHmkvij .
RbsinebICakarcaM)ac; cUrTukarenaHsin ehIyeFVIkarBll;BIGVI Edl
kMBugEtmankarekIteLIg dUecH KWCakareFVI[)anc,as;las;nUv
208
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
enaHkarfVaybgMdBit nwg)ancab;epImbgrmknUvrgVas;cMeBaHRBHkEt
lRbesIreLIgCalMdab;Edr .
GMBIeBlevla
karrab;bBal
cMeBaHGkdwknaMfVaybgM KWRtvEtmanPaBRbytRbEyg
cMeBaHkarsak;enAkgeBl EdlmankareRCIserIsedayelakRK
KgVal bBYkcas;TuM . RbsinebIclnanRBHviBaaNkMBugEtdwknaM
cUleTAkgryeBlnkarsresIrtemIg nigkarfVaybgM KWRtvEt
TTYly:agmankarRbgRbyt edIm,IbBaak;BIkarenaH cMeBaHxag
viBaaN nigsiTiGMNacrbs;elakGk [)aneFVIy:agdUecaHeday
eTalEtmak;g BIelakRKKgVal bBIcas;TuMEdlmanPaBCaGkdwk
naMxagviBaaN cMeBaHkarRbCuMmuneBlkareFVIbneTAeTot .
cUr[mankaryl;dwgcMeBaHRBHviBaaNbrisuT edaykarrab;
bBalnUvkargarsresIrtemIg nigkargarfVaybgM edaykarcak
ecjy:agsuPaB EdlGkfVaybgMmak; enAkgRBHvtmannRBH .
karmaneBjedayCMnajdwknaMenAkgRBHvihar qgtamryTVarrbg
edaymankarGrRBHKuN nigcUleTAkgTIlandRbesIr KWCakar
BiesaFn_nkarsresIrtemIg ehIybnab;mk manclnasuPaBdl;
BYkeK [)ancUleTAkgPaBKYr[Pyxac nigRBHvtmandCitsiTn
RBHenAkgkarfVaybgMGs;BIcitdBitR)akd EdlelakGk)annaM[
BYkeKcUleTAkgkarekokkitrbs;RTg; .
cUreFVIkarRbgRbyt kuMeFVIkarqaeqAbgak;nUvGVIEdl)anekIt
eLIg cMeBaHkarrs;enA nigviBaaNrbs;BYkGkeCO kMLgeBlRbjab;
dBiessenaH cUrGnuBaat[mak; EdlCaGkfVaybgM[)ankan;Cit
210
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
211
karbMeBjkargarCaGkdwknaMfVaybgM
212