Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- 9
2003 .
454/97 2/1/
1 7
8 9 10
/
2001 2002 ..
. //.
1
1 35697 2/21 2
2 ... //// 35695 11/21 5
// 543(3)
/ 543 /////. 63
3 39722 23/2001 7
4 33075 19/21 9
///- -
. 214/74
5 38161 19/21 11
///
23/2
6 / 44594 /- - 15/21 13
()
( )
7 46382 / ( ) 28/21 16
... 82 192 194
8 44031 / / 30/2001 19
... 32 33 63 25
9 42703 22/21 22
/
59(1) 543(2) (3)57 (2) /
26
10 36320 / / / 18/21 27
///. 1195
i
11 35003 9/21 29
(BooK value) / ( )
( market value)
12 36645 11/21 31
- /
///. 114 1149(1)
13 37297 / 2/21 35
///. 1261(2) 1386 1409
14 37298 / 2/21 38
38228 7/21 40
15 ( )
16 36638 21/21 42
///. 1179 ( )
17 36013 / 21/2001 45
///. 3059/1/, 3088/1/, 3110//
18 39940 / / 27/21 49
///. 114 1149
19 38169 12/21 51
/
///// 33(2)
20 39539 3/21 53
///. 114 1149(1) (2) ( )
. 7/1986 2(5) 21 22 24 23
... - 4 (8)
. 455/1997
21 ///. 1723 38666 56
9/21
/
58
22 /////. 2143 34544 11/21 59
/
23 33201 61
27/21
///. 266- 289(2069(1))
24 () / 31721 / / 25/21 63
///. 2125 2124 /
ii
25 31171 27/21 65
/
.6/89 6 58
. 368/95 2(28)
... - 26(1)
///. 1193(1) (2) 2027 2035 2054 2118
26 35034 / / 6/21 68
27 () 34314 / 11/21 71
( )
/
///. 212
28 31704 29/21 74
29 38457 2/21 77
///. 2089
79
30 35657 / 6/21 80
/
. 361/95 41(1) ()
///. 996(1)
31 / 36338 / 25/21 83
. 361/95 5(1) 39 /
32 34440 / 6/21 85
33 / 33841 6/2001 87
. 361/95 41(1)() ( )
34 33368 9/21 89
/
.27/88 . 343/94 2(9) 26(1)
35 . / 34788 2/21 92
(2 )
36 31906 4/21 94
37 47/67 37281 8 16/2001 98
/ ( )
.47/67
. 11/87
iii
38 / 37339 / 28/21 101
... - 37 25/88 (4)
39 37016 3/21 104
. 377/96 142(1) ()
40 39085 3/21 106
/
. 368/96 . 6/89 8(2) .4/1996 ( )
41 38745 / ( 1/21 108
)
42 / 36677 / / 3/21 111
43 37866 19/21 113
44 / / / 41608 22/21 115
/
117
45 42139 3/21 118
46 42309 3/21 120
674(1) (2)
122
iv
52 33470 / 2/21 136
53 34945 / 2/21 138
. 542
54 31264 / 5/21 140
145 2 29 //
55 1161 34586 28/2001 143
///. 1161 /
. 124 ( )
56 43315 18/21 146
. 717
/////. 284 285
148
57 -(-) 42253 8/21 149
///. 1791 1771(1) 1790 2090-2123
. 41/96 7
152
58 / / 21214 4/21 153
/ //
.377/96 139/1///,154/1/ 153 14 ( )
59 . 345/95 35391 25/21 155
. 345/95 7(3) 52(1) 56 /
2
///. 224()
60 37375 11/21 158
. 199/92 8(1) ...
61 37050 3/21 160
/ - /
... 13 (1)
62 - 38237 21/21 163
( )
63 / 37184 9/2001 166
( )
v
64 37163 23/21 170
///. 1688(2) 3167(1) 1688(2) 3168 /
65 38794 24/21 173
///. 3318 3324 3325 3346 1731
/////. 315 319 35 357
66 39529 / 11/21 176
/
( )
67 1 25 40752 / ( 28/2001 179
. 177/1945 2() )
68 40133 2/2001 181
//
... - 96(3) /
. 33/85 5(2)()
. 109/96
184
// 185
- 41385 ( )
69
3/22
. 377/96 26 28 3
42361 / 187
70 ..
5/22
. 377/96 43(3)
42818 . / 189
71 10/22
377/96 27
41767 190
72
.377/96 27(1)() 8/22
42923 192
73
.377/96 14(1)() / 22/22
... - 42(1)()
5 44410 / 195
74 // 01/2002
. 494/98 2()
47807 198
75 06/2002
. 377/96 95/2/,97,96 /
( )
vi
45889 2/22 201
76
47806 203
77 / 2/22
. 377/96
47469 205
78 15/22
. 377/96 1 ( )
///. 1853 47784 208
79 2/22
. 377/96 164(3)
///. 1853 1852
3 49057 211
80 //
5/22
. 377/96 3 28(2)
46276 213
81 11/2002
. 494/98 2/2() () ( )
42985 215
82
( ) 25/22
49958 217
//
83 . 377/96 27(1)() 12/22
40529 / 219
84
. 377/96 11 1/22
48648 222
10(1)()
85 24/2002
. 377/96 10(1)()
( )
() 47825 (.) 224
86
25/22
( )
47535 226
87 2/22
. 377/96
49750 2/1 228
88 3/22
. 377/96 134(2) 27(1)()
vii
49797 // 230
-
89 3/22
. 377/96 27(2)
/
50009 232
90 ()
6/22
. 377/96 27(1)()
50205 234
91 2/22
/ 48476 / 236
()
92 12/22
. 515/99 78 (1) 87
49273 238
93 27/22
. 377/96 11 (2)
//
50148 240
( )
94 4/22
/////. 378
49931 242
95 21/22
. 377/96 43/3/
50838 244
96 12/22
. 377/96 28 ( )
45746 246
///
97
6/22
. 377/96 27(3)
44405 248
//
98
19/22
. 377/96 36 37 38
53064 250
99 17/22
. 377/96 43(3)
50182 252
100
13/22
viii
44218 254
101
. 377/96 9 ( 13/22
)
46363 .. 257
102 . 377/96 124,105 19/2002
. 377/96 50923 260
103 19/2002
. 377/96
. 377/96 3/3/ //
51912 263
104 /
7/22
. 377/96 163(2)
- 55189 266
105
3/22
43(3)
53358 268
106
18/22
. 377/96 27(3)
43160 270
. 377/96 9,10 ( )
107 22/2002
52459 / 272
108
16/22
. 377/96 77(5) 24(2)
45170 274
() /
109 8/22
. 377/96 13(1) /
276
-
/ 43424 277
110 1/22
/////. 39 (1),40(2) / /
43410 280
111
30/22
/////. 69(2)
47551 282
112
6/22
ix
40229 / 284
/
113 15/22
/////. 358 /
/////. 41 358 ( )
/ 43731 ... 286
114
8/22
/////. 7() 78 69 72
/////. 28 39581 288
115
25/22
/////. 280 69(2) 70(), 71(2)
() 45984 / 290
116
26/22
/////. 223/2/,234
47252 / 292
117 / 26/22
/////. 241 248
(Review of judgement) 43821 / 295
( /
118 5/2002
)
/////. 6(1)(),()
/ 42871 07 32 301
119 / 12/2002
/////. 6(3)(4) /
/////. 421 37214 304
120 /////. 418 421 (
25/22
)
/ 44634 / 306
121
22/22
/ 45371 - / 308
122 //////. 280 8/22
( )
/////. 216 36776 // 310
123 /////. 216(3)
7/22
/ / 44545 312
/ /
124 7/22
-
/////. 341 342 343
44883 314
125 . 97/9 8/22
. 216/92 2
/////. 394 - 449
x
/////. 43 39799 / 317
126 21/22
43845 320
//
127 2/22
/
/////. 28 / / 44931 / 323
128 2/22
///. 208 209 320 (1) ,348(1)
/ 48237 / 325
129 6/22
/////. 480
/ - 50022 5 // 327
130 29/22
/////. 97 95(3)
45038 / 329
131 ( ) 23/2002
/
/ /////. 481 43005 331
( )
132 19/22
/////. 481 . 452(1)
/////. 6 / 45839 / / 333
133
/////. 6 ( ) 5/22
/ - 39853 335
134 /////. 256 345 327 ( 21/22
)
41526 . 338
135 2/22
... - 8(3), . 25/88 1
//
/ 52752 ( ) 340
136 ( 16/22
/////. 277 )
/ 45247 17/22 343
137
49857 / 346
138
/ / 3/22
/////. 5
- 48632 348
139 14/22
/////. 235(2) 83
xi
49660 350
140 / ( )
22/22
/////5 223 234 137 249 256
/////. 5(1) 52525 / 352
141
29/22
/////. 5
/ / 43331 354
142
/ () 19/22
/////. 341(1)
( 36730 356
)
. 377/96 138 147 164(1)
143 3/22
/////. 9 23 (1) () 231 (1)() 278(3)
///. 1851 () 1852(1)
. 454/97 2(4)
/ / 50376 / 361
/ / / 7/08
12/22
/
144
/////. 105(1) 78
xii
1
negligent homicide
power of cassation bench
//. 35697
2 21 ..
- -
- -
1384 3 2 ..
29 2
..
28 1998 ..
1996 .. ...
539/1//
543/2/
494 2 2,
/ /
35
35
29 1998 4
2
543/3/
691
59 543/3/
59
/
543 3
1. 1384 3 2 ..
543/3/
2. 14498 23 1999 ..
3. 543 3
4.
2 21 ..
4
//. 35695
11 2001 .
- -
- -
15071
14 2000 . 63
1996 ...
543 3
63
63
1949 .
2000/ /
63 1
5
...
?
?
...
-
- 1949 .
-
543 3
63 1
1949
63 1
/
1. / 15071 14 2000 .
2. 2077 12 2000 .
3.
11 2001 .
6
leave of appeal
//.39722
23 2001 .U.
:- wMn` SNS
eTT<
uL<
MT<
}]:- - k`vDM
L c[< <d@ uSnU SM" NUK? 26 k 2000 .U. u} cu` u?~ k[ c=J
Sc[ ~U uK?KG<u }c< ` =h`M k[w< o u03/07/2000 .U. ` uc<
` u? }kv @U u< v UM u04/07/2000 .U. uT[T> u? u<M K/u?~
TSM M?KG<&G< = } ` u?~ LM p }cu ` Mv dJ `
}K< vKG<u =M SM ` KU }wKA w }cu uSJ<
}SMg? u29/07/2000 .U. K=MM T>v< ` }cu Mv SJ< vSK}<U uSS] u
04/07/2000 .U. k[w< TSM eI}~ =`U }SMg? < 29/07/2000 .U. TSM
w KpL /u?~ uSL< SK<u >? uvu< dSM Lvw TKU @ <
uJ U >?< MuM }wKG< ' eKJU Sc[ I eI} eK}Sw [UM T>M
<::
7
Su< S[ }K< SM" u} `/u? (u/S/l. 21282) uM }f pU 26
k 2000 .U. uK?Ku u13 S < e^ =k }[u <& uK?Ku }[u ` }ga
vKu ="H@K ` Kc< ` u? o p`x u` IU o< Su= 03/2000
.U. }kv K?K< }u u%EL KT>kK< k TKU Su= 04/2000 .U uT[T> u<M K`
u?~ uL< TSM u< L v T>M Mv =c< q }LK p } }vKu
p }cu Sw Mv dJ kU wKA uK?Ku }c< ` vKu ="H@K
SM }c< w T>SK}< M w <& IU eI} SJ< M TKU pU 20 k
2000 .U. uK< KA <d@ cu Sw =LK Su= 29 k 2000 .U. u}
TSM ` Kc< ` u? sM:: ` u?~U T>= 03/2000 .U. Mw c SM"U
T>= 15/2000 .U. p_< uT 'T>= 22 k 2000 .U. K` u?~ [c <:: v
p_< SM" < L< u T[T> u? J J Su< S[ LM:: L c\
Hq /e/e/I/l 187 (1) (2) c[< c^` ` uT` SM" ` u}c u 15 k <e v
T>M LdkU }wKA v >? MuM }vK v Tek o<U u^c<
}S < }wKA u/S/c/e/I/l 191 (3) Sc[ pL /u?~ M}kuK< <& ` c< }
/u? KpL /u?~ M KA }L< u/S/l 21282 u15/09/2000 .U. }< v Sg
wu? T>SK}< SM" Su= 29 k 2000 .U. v KTK T>M dk =
uSS] Su= 4 k 2000 .U. u} TSM v Tp[w T>M p< }Mw
=c< Ku G<@ M}KU:: SM" v Tp[w T>M u04/07 /2000 .U. `
Kc< ` u? c=SK}< ` Mv upLL< Te}LK ` H> `c< vKu
=K LSK}< o }c< w T>SK w KA e}LK <& e` ` u?~ I
eI} uSS< U V SM" ue` J I ` =K }SMf u29/07/2000 .U.
u} TSM <:: unL SM" u}LKu ` ` H> L v Tp[w
T>M uI< }kS< >? w dM Su= 04/2000 .U. K` u?~ sM ' ` u?~U
SL Ku Mv uM Mw SL < ` p dM k[ <' eKJU Su= 29
k 2000 .U. < wu? KG<K} >? k[u o kU wKA }S< Td[ L~ KTv[p
}kSu < }wKA S}`U KSS] >? v o k[u }` Sc }u= K<U
' =U u%EL u\ S SM" u e` u? J uT[T> u? u<M /u?~ [< u\
SLL SM" uI< Sc[ v KTp[w S~ T>d J< ' uSJ<U ^M
pL /u? M KA I G<@ uT>v dw SM" pU 26 k 2000 .U. K}LKu
p <d@ v Tp[w T>M K< u29/07/2000 .U. SK} IU SM" v
>?< =M [< u^c< < uTK o< u/S/e/e/I/l. 191 (3) Sc[ <p T[<
Sc[ I eI} }Su <d@ J }M& eKJU T>}K< <d@ c}M::
8
abuse of power
Criminal Liability of judges judges
//. 33075
19 2001 .
- // -
- ///- - -
// . 214/74 23/1///
17/1/ /
/ //
/// /
200( )
/////
/
200( )
26 99 .
. 214/74
-
//
-
9
//
//
-
// . 214/74
2
/
-
// . 214/74
///
/. 10588 14/07/99 . // /. 12083 13 1999 .
// //. 195/2////1/
10
unlawful enforcement of right
//. 38161
19 2001 .
- -
- /// -
/
26 2000 .
/
/
1990 . 21 1997 .
.... 32/1/ 436/1//
/
/
/
/
800.00 / /
/ /
26 2000 .
17
2001 .
11
?
/ ....
32/1/ 436/1/
/
/ ... 436//
... 436//
/
1
... 23/2/
/ ... 23/2/
436//
12
corruption
injunction of property
principle of proportionality
//. 44594
15 21 .
- /- / - /
- /4 / -
- -
- - 434/97
23
/ /
//
/ /
. 434/97 9
/ /
/
//
/
/ // /
/
13
/
/ 22/7/2001 /
/
// /
///
- - /
/ /
/ /
? ?
/
//
/ /
/
/
/ /
/ / /
/
? ?
/
/
(good will)
/
/
/
14
1. / .4180 8/2001 /
12 2001 .
2. / //. 64231 3 2001 .
15
//. 46382
28 21 ..
- 1. /
2.
3. / /
4.
- -
/
32/1// 692/1/ 16 21 .. 445
15/16
/ 134/1/
/
/
/
/ 3
82/1//
16
6 //
192
/ /
/
192
194
192
/
1
/ 82
194
/
1. / ///7933 21/8/21 ..
/ .. 45568 9/9/21 ..
6 //
2 // 192
197/1/
17
2. / .
3. 85 2 /
/
4. /
18
//. 4431
3 21 ..
- / / -
- -
32/1/ 63/2/
24 1998 /
///// 141
/
24 21 ..
1 21 ..
33
25 ?
19
111
141 149
/
/ 24 1998
/
32
()
32/1// 63
33 33
33
8
25 1
33
33
20
1.
2.
3.
4.
21
//. 42703
22 21 .
- -
- / / -
1/8/2000 .
1996 . 543(3) 8 2000 .
3-42631 .
50- 60 .
/ 5060
.
543(3)
10,000( )
22
/
5,000 ( ) 14 2001
.
543(3)
? ?
543(3)
? ?
/
/
50 60 .
/
543(3)
57
57(2)
59
59(1) -
23
()
()
Article 59
50 - 60 .
59(1)
// 50-60 .
/
50 60 .
/
50 .
24
50 .
?
? ?
?
(accident)
(negligent
act)
/
(accident)
(negligent criminal offence) /
/ /
1. / 10769 18 2001 .
/ . 71726 26 2001 .
/ 70164 2001 .
2. 543(3)
3.
25
26
//. 3632
18 21 .
- / / -
- / -
/ 4
/
/ /
/
/
/////. 33/2/
///. 1195
27
/ /
///. 1195
1. / /. 21523 11 2 ..
2.
/////.
343 /
3.
28
//. 353
9 21 .
- -
- / / 4 / -
/
/
8 544
5 ..
41,078.77 ( ) /
/ /
/ /
/
/
/
29
/
/
/book value/
/market value/ /
/
1. / /. 24/6/98 / /
/. 9775 28/7/98 / /. 445 4/9/98
/ /. 416 7/4/2
2. /////.
343/1/ /
3. /
30
// 36645
11 2001 .
- -
- / -
////// /
270
26/10/94
/ /
/ ?
/
// /
/
/
/ /
31
/ /
///1149/1/
///.1140
/Form/
////1808(2)
/ ?
/
/ /
32
/
1140 1149
1
1204 1
1204 2
1206
2879
33
215 1
34
//. 37297
2 21 .
- - /
- / -
7
864
/ /
/ /
97/9
//
/
/
16349.50 / / 8174.75/
/
/
/ /////. 337
/
/ 1 2 .. /
/
/
97/9
/ 97/9
35
8 2 ..
/
3 2 ..
///. 1259-1277
///. 126/1/
/Book value/
/Market value/
///. 1261/2/
6
///. 1386-149
/
36
1. / /. 11851 17 2 ..
/ /. 6273 3 2 /////. 348/1/
2. 2 864
3.
4.
5.
37
//. 37298
2 2001 .
- /
21938 17
2000 . 60274 27 2000 .
10 2000 .
02 964
28,092/ /
8 2000 .
38
1261/1/
1.
2. 02 964
3.
4.
2 2001 .
::
39
//. 38228
7 21 .
- - /
- 1.
/
2. /
/ //
/ /
////
45.00 /
/
/ / /
//. 1195 /
/ / /
/ /
//. 1195 /
/
//. 1149/1/
40
//. 114
//. 1195 /ownership/
//. 114 1195
/ //. 1195
/
/
41
//. 36638
21 2001 .
- -
- 1. -
2. / -
/
11 15
. 433 40,000( )
6 1976 19 11 1995 .
40,000 ( )
/ ///.
2443 ///. 2436
1845
40,000 ( )
/ ///. 1179/1/
///. 1179/1/
40,000 ( )
/ /
42
///. 1140
6 1976 .
/ /. 2443
////. 348/1/
/ ///
////. 337
17 2000 . / ///
19
40,000 ( ) 1975
40,000 (
) //// 19
///. 1979/1/2/
40,000
( ) /
/////. 348/1/ /// /////. 337
/ /
1179/1/2/
19
() ()
/
/ ()
19
()
///
43
3. 40,000 ( )
4.
44
//. 3613
21 21 ..
- / - / -
- / -
/ / 4 151
/
/
/. 97/9
45
/. 97/9 98/9
/
/
2/21
/
?
//
/
///. 359/1/ /2/
///. 359
1.
2.
3
/right of Preference/
3 3
/right of persuit/
///. 359/2/
///.
384/1/ /2/
46
3
///. 359/1/ /right of
preference/
///. 1988/1/
// 359/1/
///. 388/1/
///.
311//
/ /
/
/
/ /
/
/
47
1. / / /. 1772 3/1/2 /
/. 14659 19/5/2 ..
2. 4 151
3.
48
//. 3994
27 21 .
- / -
- / -
15 1998 ..
11/12 1638
/
/
9 2 .. 2 // /
-
///. 1149
3
21 .. /
49
/Possessory action/ ///. 1149/1/
///. 114 1149
///. 114 1149
/
1/ / //. -395 27
2 .. / /. 5585 25 2 ..
/ /. 6753 25 2 ..
/////. 348/1/
2/
3/
50
// 38169
12 2001 .
- - ..
- / -
/
17 24 360 / 1973
1990
30 1994 54 14,193.76(
) 150,628.55 (
) 164,817.41 (
)
()
///// 33(2)(3) /
/
/
/// 33(2)(3)
/////. 33(2)(3)
51
/
////. 348(1)
29/9/2000 /
()
()
/
(
)
/
/////.33(2)
52
//. 39539
30 2001 .
- - /
- -
26 6000( )
/
/
1000.00( )
/ /
/ /
/
/ 23 2000 . 4// /
-
-
24 2001 . 4//
35 - 40/4/
/
53
/ 07 2001 . 2//
/
1991 . 1991 .
/
7/1986 2/5/
2/5//
21 22
23 24
/
/
1991 .
/
- 40/8/ 455/1997
///. 1149/1/2/
///. 1140 1149
7/1986
/
54
7/1986
24
/ ///. 1140
1149 7/1986 2/5/212223
24
1. / /. 319/92 08 1996 .
/. 01595 17 1999 . /. 05481 28
2000 . /////. 348/1/
2.
3.
4.
/
::
55
//. 38666
9 21 ..
- - /
- / - /
///
/
35259
97/9 98/9 216/92
/
//////428/2/
/
/
////1723/1/
//////428/1/
// /
/ //////337
56
97/9 98/90 216/92
/
//////444
/
//////421 455
/
////1723/1/
97/9 98/9
////1723
/
/ /
1. / .. 5134 24/6/2 .. //
.. 2488 8/9/2 .. //////348/1/
2. 35259 .
3. /
4.
57
58
//. 34544
11 2001 .
- - -
- / -
/
... 48755 07 2000 .
/
///. 2143
30,000.00 ( )
/
/ /////. 348/1/
59
/
?
/
/
/
///. 2143
/
::
60
//. 3321
27 21 .
- - /
- -
18 27
33
6375. /
/ 26
1997 . / /
/
/ / /
/
15/1/2 .
/
11 2 .
/
/ /
1 2 .
61
?
///. 266 - 289
///. 269/1/
/
/
/////. 329/1/
///.269/1/
/
1/ / /. 57875 6 1999 .
/ /. 51136 27 1999 /////. 348/1/
2/
3/ 7968.75 / /
4/
5/ /
62
//. 31721
25 21 ..
- / / -
- / -
// /// /
/
35( )
//
/ / 78(
) //
//
6 1999 ..
?
4 // .
2125
13
1 / / 4 2125 . 2124
2125
63
2125//
/ /
/
4
/
1. /// /
// /. GM181/98 28
98 .. /. 09/99 13 1999 .. /////. 348/1
2.
64
//. 31171
27 21 ..
- -
- / - /
5 1997 ..
5,000.00 / /
/
/
27/7/97
.. /
5,000.00 / /
/ /
/
/
3 1999 ..
65
1 2 ..
6 2 ..
1,.00 / /
/
6/1989 6 58
368/1995
2/28/
6/89 6/5/ 58/1// 6/5/
58/1//
/
/// - 26/1/
///. 1193/1/
///. 1193/2/
/proof of ownership/
66
/ /
/
///. 1193 /1/ /2/
/// 1193 . 6/1989 6/5/ 58/1//
368/1995 2/28/
-
///. 227 235 254
///. 2118
1. / /. 32974 8 1998 ..
/ /. 26383 19 1999 ..
/////. 348/1/
2. / /. 2282 7 1997 ..
/////. 348/1/
3.
5,000.00 / /
4.
5. /
67
//. 3534
6 21 .
- / -
- / -
/
28 1998 .
1,. / /
27 1998 .
/
8. / /
/
/ 8
2 .
/
25 2 .
3 2 .
68
?
/
/
/ /
///. 291
/actual damage/
/future damage/ ///. 29/1/ 292
/General utility/ /specific utility/
///. 291 292
/material
damage/
///. 212
69
/
///.
29291292 212
1/ / /. 33351 3 1999 .
/ /. 57181 16 2 . /////. 348/1/
2/
(Negative impact)
///. 212
3/ / /////.
343/1/
4/
// /
5/
70
//. 34314
11 21 ..
- / -
- 1. -
2. / -
3. -
4. -
5. -
6. -
3 // 14 1995 .. 1
6
1
// 14.00 / /
2 1996 ..
/ /
/
2 1998 ..
/
71
/
/ /
/
12 2 .. /
/ /
4 /
2 6
23 2 ..
/
/
3 2 ..
2 1998 .. /
/
/
/
/
1,.00 / / 6//
72
? /
///. 212 /
1. / /. 33149 29 1999 ..
/ /. 49878 8 2 ..
/////. 348/1/
2.
3.
4.
5. 25,.00 /
/
6.
7. /
73
//. 3174
29 21 .
- -
- - /
2 1999 .
1 1999 . ///. 24665
21 1997 .
3-5884 9
1996 . 1
36.83
1 / / 9 1996 . 16 1997 .
68,000 / /
23/2/1998 . 4 1998 .
6/1989 6 19
1
/
/ /. 1735 2 1998 .
11/6/96 . 21 1997 .
25,000 / / 36,111.11 /
/
74
/ ///. 24665 1/1999 .
6/89 6 58
/
/ /////. 348/1/
/ 2
1999 .
1/352/21/18/123 18/8/1996 .
/ 6/89 6 58
11 21 .
/ /
6/89 6/5/ 58/1//61 78
/
19
1
6/89
/.4/64/64/5/15 9/1996 .3/64-16/6
28/1997 . 4/ 64-6/3 27/1997 ./
6/1989
6/1989
75
///.
228231/1/
2/ .. 1735 2 1998 .
/////. 348/1/
3/
36,111.11 / /
4/
76
// 38457
2 2001 .
- - /
- -
//
/
/
9 2000 .
///. 2089(1)
// 2089(1)
13
/
// 2081(1)
2089
77
/
78
79
//. 35657
06 2001 .
- / -
- -
/
/
/
/ /
/
/ 361/95 41(1)()
/
/
12 2000 . /
/
/
/
?
28
2000 . /
/
80
28 2000 .
361/95 39 /
/ 41 /
41(1)()
/
/
///.996/1/
/
/
/
1. / /. 678/99 08 1999 .
/. 04083 12 1999 .
/. 04951 16 2000 .
/////. 348/1/
2. / 361/95 41(1())
3.
/
4.
5. /
1. 361/1995 41 1()
81
996/1/
2
361/1995 41/1/
996 1
2.
-
-
948/1/
-
948 2
-
947
850
3.
361/1995
361/1995 41/1//
361/95 41/1/ 996/1/
82
//. 36338
25 2001 .
- / -
- / -
/
/
/ /
/ /
/
/
5 2000 .
/
/
/
?
/ -
-
//// .9/1/ - /
// .231 /
.9/2/
/ - ?
83
/
. 361/95 39
/ - 50/1/
5000( ) -
/ -
/ / -
1. / / /. 02188
3 1998 . / /.
02897 25 2000 . //// . 348/1/
2. / /
3.
84
//. 3444
6 21 .
- / - /
26 1999 . 1957 .
/ 29 1986 .
1 1986 .
/ 14
1999 . /
/
/ /
/
15 2 . /
/
/
1 2 .
/
/
85
3 2 .
/ 1957 . 1/11/86 .
/
/
18419 4 1998 .
---
---
2/
3/
4/ /
86
//. 33841
6 2001 .
- -
- 1. -
2. / -
3. / -
4.
5. -
6. -
01973
10 1998 .
03392 13 2000 .
9 2000 .
47/1967
004 668/669
4 28 /
4 28
/ 47/67 004
47/1967
004
87
- 004
004
47/1967
? 47/1967
?
361/1995
41
41(1)()
-
361/1995 41 (1) ()
47/1967
-
-
1. / 0455 5
1997 . 01973 10
1998 . 03392 13
2000 . -
2.
3.
4.
5.
6 2001 .
88
// 33368
9 2001 .
/ 1949
. // . 386 642
/
(6)
/
/ /
30 99 .
/ -
/ ? /
() ? / ?
?
/
/ ()
/ () ()
89
/ /
.27/1988 25
/ /
2627 28 1949 . /
.296 .331
/ 26
/
/ 28
/
26/1/
// .296 .331
.386 . 642
(2)(3) (4)
/ /1/
/2/
/1/
/
( )
26 (2)
.27/88 () .343/95
2 /
26
.343/95 2(9)
26(2)
/ .27/88
/
()
.343/95 2(9)
26/1/ //
()
/ /
90
1. / .014/99 18 99 .
//// . 195/2/ // /2/
2. /
91
//. 34788
2 2001 .
- -
/ ( ) -
5
() ()
/
////. 33(2)
/ /
92
/
/ / /
...
...
/ /////. 337
-
25/88
36/95
41/1/ /
1 2000
/ ?
. 24/1/ /
()
/
/ /
1. .. / /. 2633/91 22 1997 .
/ /. 02703 30 1999 .
. 05360 4/4/2000 .
2. // /
3.
93
//. 3196
4 21 ..
- - /
- -
/ /
3 53 849 1957
.. 47/67
/
/
1959 ..
47/67
47/67
/////. 358
/ 47/67
47/67
/
/
/
94
/
/
/
/Justicable/
/
/
///. 1195
/
/ /
/Jusciable matter/
/ /
/
/////. 358
/
/
1. /. 1998 19 1999 ..
/. 682 3/3/97 ..
/////. 348/1/
2.
/ /
95
/Justicable matter/
3. /
3 53
5 1981 ..
26 1973 .. 5 1981 ..
47/1967
/Justicable/
1168 1
1168 1
96
97
//. 37281
16 2001 .
- -
- 1. 08 / -
2. -
3. / -
07 2000 .
/////. 336/2000 21/2000 .
()
()
1998 . 100( )
500( )
//.02127/98 18 1999 .
. 110/1987
// 08/1999 .
/ ///. 14649
15 2000 . /////. 348/1/ /
/ // / 336/2000
. /////. 337
07 2000 .
03 1996 .
98
/
// 19/421/2000 03 2000 .
08
08 // /
. 47/67
1971 . 33
/
/ 16
2000 .
///. 1000
/
?
/
110/87
. 47/1967
110/1987
/
//
. 47/1967
99
336/2000 21 2000 . /////. 348/1/
2.
. 110/87
/////. 343
3.
::
100
//. 37339
28 21 .
- / -
- -
57224 17
2 . 35533 3
2 .
21 2 .
337
9713.12 /
/
21 2 .
101
1. ?
2. ?
16
1999 .
25/1988
289
54637
-
37
-
102
-
57234 17 2 .
-
25/88 4
1. 57224 17 2 .
2. 35533 3 2 .
3.
341/1/
4.
5. 54637
28 2 .
103
//. 3716
3 21 .
- - /
- -
/
/senior teller/ 1
3
219 / / 24/5/99
..
/ / 14
219( )
/BPR/
/
/ /BPR/
/
/
/
104
/// -
///
377/96
138 142/1/
142/1/
142/1// //
/ ///
138/1/ -
/// /
105
//. 39085
3 2001 .
- - /
- / (87 )
/
15
1999 . 4/96 -
/
/ / / 64577
1 2000 . /
7 2000 . /
?
368/95
/ /
4/1996
106
/
/
/ /
(executive provocative) /
/
/
1. / / 98010 14/5/2000 .
/ / 64527 1/11/2000 . /////
348/1/
2. /
3.
4.
::
107
//. 38745
1 21 .
- 1. / - 2
2. -
- -
23 2000 .
/ /. 26/98 19 2000 . 08 1999 .
/ /
09 1998 .
/ 6 1998 .
/
/
/ 26/98 08/1999 . /
1700 ( )
23 2000 .
/////. 78/1/2/
/ /
//
/ /
/ // / /. 26/98 19 2000 .
27/08/1990 . 01/02/1993 .
/. 26/98 08/1999 .
108
23 2000 .
DHIIL 62/3/3-1/93 01/1993 . /
1700 ( )
// /
/ 14
2001 .
/
1700( )
/
/
/. 48/94 28 1990 .
. DHIILU 62/3/3-1/93 01/1993 .
/
/
/
/ /
109
1. /. 26/98 19 2000 .
/////. 348/1/
2.
/
3. /
4. 14 2001 .
::
110
//. 36677
3 21 ..
- /
- /
/ 16/99 27 2
.. 19
2 ..
8
25/1988
47/1967
/
343
/
1982 ..
111
? ?
1982
..
188/1992
4
-
- //
- 188/1992
4 1
25/1988
188/92 4 1
1.
2.
3.
3 21 ..
112
// 37866
19 2001 .
- -
- - / /
/ /
//
//
18 2000 .
? . 34691
( )
/ 454/97 2(4)
1. / . 46438 21 2000 .
// . 34888 21 2000 . //// 348(1)
113
2.
114
//. 41608
22 2001 .
- -
- / -
/ 06 /
/
()
-
. 12/96 5/3/
815/1/ 100 ( )
/ /
/ / ?
14 1/1986 10/2/
17/1//
/
/
/////. 348/1/
/ / /
115
/ / /
/////. 337
24 2001 . // /
/
// . 12/96 5/3/
1/86 10/2/ 17/1/ / /
/
(100) ( )
/ /
/
/ /
/////. 337
/ ?
/ . 12/96 . 31/99
31/99
/ /
/
// 1225
/ /
1. / /. 0207 2/5/2000 / /.
877/00 01/9/2000 /. 08015 12/2/2001
2. / // /
3.
116
117
//. 42139
30 2001 .
- -
- -
//
/
-
/
//
14 2001 . /
?
/. 3-29779 . ()
118
119
// 42309
30 2001 .
- -
- -
674(1) (2)
-
/
/
23 2001 . /
?
?
///// .246(1)/
/ 3
1999 . 12 1994 .
120
674
26 1996 .
674(1) (2)
//
. 674(2) (1)
1. / ..86581 9 2000 .
/ . 63225 23 2001 . //// 348(1)
2.
3.
121
122
//. 38289
23 21 ..
- / -
- / - /
/ /. 3497 24 2 ..
/
45,
( )
/
/
3 2 ..
//
//
//
123
//
//
// . 2792/1/
1. / /. 21113 2 2 ..
/ /. 3497 24 2 .. //// . 348/1/
2. /
3.
/
124
//. 43875
16 21 ..
- - /
- - /
24 21 .. //
/ /. 22624 17 21 ..
/
/
6 .
/ / /
/
/ //. 446 14/2 ..
/ /. 8618 18 2 .. /
/////. 348/1/
///
/ /
/ /
12/21 ..
/
///// 348/1/
125
11/87
/
/
/
3 21
/
//
/
/
/
?
/
///// 59 /////
8092 93
///// 92(3)
/
1. // / / . 22624 17 2001 .
///// 348(1)
2. / /
///// 343(1)
3. /
4. 24 2001 .
126
//. 37799
29 2001 .
- - /
- - /
/ /
/
2,200,856.43( )
590
/
/ / /
?
?
37/90 2/1/
127
3/6/ /7/ 3/6/
2/1/ (exception)
7 6
7 (exception)
/
///. 2251
37/90
683/3/
1. / / /. 28225 7/08/2000
2. / / /. 40949 5/3/99
3.
4.
/
128
//. 34621
30 2001 .
- / -
- / - /
22 2000 . /
//. 41455 23 2000 .
/
(
) 14 1997 .
( ) /( )
( ) 3-37484/3-04254
129,333.93(
) 42 4
129
17251727 1720(1)
/ /
/ //. 41455 23 2000 .
/////. 348/1/
/ 22
2000 . -
( )
07 2000 . /
1. ?
2. ( )
?
3. ?
?
-
1725 1727
1720(1)
657
130
//. 24703
09 2000 . /
///. 1725 1727
///. 1720/1/
17 1995 .
/
//. 683
/
/
//. 566////. 2251
( )
/. 566 ///. 2251
/
1. / /. 43650 16 1997 .
/ //. 41455 23/2000 . /////.
348/1/
2. 129,333.93(
) 14/1997 . 9%
3.
131
132
//. 33954
2 21 .
- / -
- -
344 19 1999
. 59124 27 2 .
16 2 .
29
21 1, / /
29 21
29 21
/
29 21
29 21
29 21
133
29 21
1, / /
29
21 124
29 21
127
127 2//
29 21
29 21
29 21
124 127
145 1
1/ 29 21
2/ 29 21
134
3/
2 21 .
135
//. 33470
2 2001 .
- / -
- -
/
/
/
-
/
/
30 2000 .
?
/
/
.271
273
136
/
/
/
1. / /. 05140 26 1998 .
/ /. 48762 26 1999 .
//// . 348/1/
2.
3.
/
4.
137
/ 34945
2 2001 .
- - / -
- - - /
// /
6/21/1998
// /
/ //
/
/ / 7,
( )
/
542
/
138
/
/ /
///.22 1677(1)
1. //
/ 22/1999 .. / 55299 / /
12/2 .. / 55333
2. ///
3.
///// 343 (1) //
/
4. /
//. 31264
139
5 2001 .
- / -
- 2 . 29 // /
//
2 29 449
67
3,000( )
/ / /
3/1/87 /
2/1/89 / /
1998 / /
342,000 ( )
3,000( )
/
4000( )
//
/
140
54,000( )
3,000( )
/ / /
/ /
145/1/
/
/
145
2 29 449
/
3/1/87 /
/ / /
/
145/1/
145/1/
3
3
141
/term/?
3
////2959
3
//
/
//
142
//. 34586
28 2001 .
- -
- 1. / -
2. - /
3. 22 04 -
4. -
/
//////358
/
22 04 596
/
22 04 596
16 1992 . /
/ /
//////360(2) /
143
/
/ /
//////358
22
04 596
16 1992 .
/
/Set aside/
/
////1161
/Incorporeal
144
movable/ 124
////1161
//////358 ////1161
//////360(2)
/ /
1. / 2901/91 / . 414/93
/ 01424 20/3/2000 . ///// 348
(1)
2. /// . 2901/91
//////360(2)
3. 22 04 596
4.
5. /
145
//. 43315
18 21 .
- ///
- -
/
7 2 .. 187877 1, /
/
///// 286 -
13 2 ..
2, 1, 12 2
/ / 123416 12/2/21 ..
/ / 74146 26/5/21 ..
/
9 21 ..
///// 284
-
- /////
285/1/ 2
/
146
/
//. 717/1/
/
/ / -
/
/ - -
1. / / 123416 12 21 ..
/ / 74146 26 21 ..
///// 348/1/
2. /
/ ///// 341
3.
147
148
//. 42253
8 21 .
- -
- / -
/
9
410/96 260,000
/ / 7
/ 9
20 410/96 34(4) 100,180,00
/ /
/ /
100,000 / /
7 7
140,00 / /
4 2001 . -
410/96 34/(4)
100,000 / /
2
2001 .
5,000( )
? -
///. 2027
149
(extra contractual)
(breach of
contract)
/
/
410/96 34(5)
34(5)
- - - - -
410/96
/
///. 1791(2)
///. 1792(1)
///. 1792(2)
///.1771(1)
///.791(1)
///. 1790(2) 2090 2123
/
410/96
7
410/96 7
1. 9 19
/
150
/
(public display of original or copies of the work)
410/96 34(4) 100,000 / /
100,000 / /
/ /
1. / / 25/99 11/3/2001 .
/////. 348(1)
2. / /
/////. 348(1) 100,000 / /
140 / / 100,140 /
/
3.
151
152
//. 21214
4 21 .
- -
- 1/ -
2/ -
3/ -
.. 627
14/1997 .
11/1997 .
/ /
3 / // 6
29/1997 .
3/1997 .
.. 627 14/1997 . . 377/1996 139/1//
/////. 9/2/
153
17/1997 .
. 377/1996 154 ... - 8
?
/ / -
. 377/1996 154/1/
153
//
.377/1996 140
154 139/1//
1/ .. 627 14/1997 .
/////. 348/1/
2/
. 377/1996 14 154/1/
/////.
341
3.
154
//. 35391
25 2001 .
- - / /
- / -
24 1999 .
1992 . 39,974.35(
) 30 1998 .
2%( )
345/1995 01 1995 . 30 1998 .
41,573.32( ) 01 1998 .
30 1999 . 8,474.56( )
50,047.88 ( )
/
/
1992 . 1998 .
/
/ /
/ 27 2000 . /
1992 .
30 1998 .
155
18 2000 .
16 2000 .
345/1995 7/3/ 2%(
)
1992 .
39,974.35( )
30 1998 . 345/95
///. 2024//
1992 .
49/1967
345/1995 .
2% / / 7/3/
01 1995 .
52/1/ /legal situations/
345/1995 . 01
1995 . 56
1992 . 30 1995 .
01 1995 .
345/1995
///. 2024//
///. 2024//
01 1995 . (2%)
156
(2%)
/ 345/1995
1. / /. 77477 10 1999 .
/ /. 56348 15 2000 . /////. 348/1/
2. 01 1995 . 30 1999 .
1992 . 39,974.35/
/ (2%)
3.
9% / /
4.
/
157
//. 37375
11 2001 .
- -
- ... -
22 2000 . ...
. 12 /2029/2037 14 2000 .
/ /. 62758 25 2000 .
/////. 337
9 2000 .
10 1998
. 199/92
8/1/ 5
/ / /.
62758 25 2000 . /////. 337
22 2000 .
12 01 1981 . 30 1985
. 01 1985 . 1988 .
01 1989 . 14 1995 .
1981 .
199/1992 8/1/
5
5
158
23 2000 .
5
8/1/
?
-
199/1992 8/1/
5
(1981 . ) 10 1998 .
4
2 6 8 13
5
5
? 5
1. . 12 /2029/2037 14 2000 .
/. 62758 25 2000 .
/////. 348/1/
2. / . 199/1992
8/1/
3.
159
//. 375
3 21 .
- -
- / -
/ 2 1999
. ... 539/1/
26 1998 . 4 /
/ /
/
/
8 1999 . /
/
/ /
/ /
/ /
/
/ /
/
/
/
4 2 . 7// /
-
/
160
/ 9 2
. 1 21 .
/
4 1999 . 8 1999 .
/
/ /
/ /
...
-
....
13/1/
-
-
-
... -
2/5/ -
/
-
- /
-
161
1. / /. 1/99 1/2/1999 ..
/ 23 2 .. /////.
195/2/1/
2. -
3. -
/
4. /
162
//. 38237
21 21 .
- -
- 1.
2. //
3. /
4. / -
//// / / 232
1 2 ..
/
/. 32/94 12/9/94 ..
/////. 5
1973 .. /// 1/1/
/ ///// 5/1/
15
/ / /
///// 5/1/ /
3 2 .. -
-
19 1993 ..
/////. 5/1/
163
- /// 1/1/
// /
- 22 21 ..
1-3
///// 5/1/
- /
/
5/3/21
/
19
1973 ..
6 1999 ..
/// 1/1/
1973 .. 6 1999 ..
26
/
/
/
/// 1/1/
3
1. / // 232
1/9/2 .. ///// 348/1/
2. /// 1/1/
3. / /
164
4. /
22/4/21
165
// 37184
9 21
- -
- 1. -
2. -
71/ /
142 / /
142
34,8.00 / /
17,4.00
/ /
/
/
///// 337 /
/ 9 2 . /
-
166
26 2 ..
/
/
1 2 ..
17 1989 ..
/
/
///. 1726 1727 279 2787 282
1922/3/
///. 2779
/
/
/
167
/
/ /
// /. 2149
/
/
/
/conclusive
evidence/
/ 17/3/1989
/admissibility/
///. 26/1/
71 / /
///. 1922/3/
/
/ /
/ -
17 1989 ..
///. 2779
2799
71 / /
168
17,4.00 / /
71 / /
71 / / 17,4.00 /
/
/
17/3/1989 ..
1. / 2 2 ..
/ /. 22296 28 2 .. /////. 348/1/
2. 71 / / 17,4.0000
/ /
3.
4.
5. /
169
//. 37163
23 2001 .
- - / / -
- / - -
04 2000 .
200.000/ /
/ /
17 2000 .
/
/
/
5850.50( )
/
/////. 337
13 2000 . /
170
22 2000 .
28 2000 .
200,000.00 /
/ /
///. 1688/2/
///. 3167/1/ /
///. 1688/2/ //. 3168
/
/
/
/ /
/
/
/
/
/
171
1. / 03 2000 . // /
//. 1017 08 2000 . /////. 348/1/
2.
3.
/
172
//. 38794
24 21 .
- -
- -
3 1994 .
8 199
. 170,122.75 /
/
/
23/2/9 .
/
/conciliation/ ///. 3322/2/
/ /
25 2 . 3 // /
23/2/9 .
/
/
/
17 2 .
173
/
23 199 .
8 199 .
/ / 23 199
. 8 199 .
/arbitration/
/conciliation/ ///. 2322/2/
/conciliation/ /mediation/ /arbitration/ /Negotiation/
/
/conciliation/ /arbitration/
/conciliation/ 3
3 ///. 3318 - 3324
/arbitration/
3 ///. 3325 - 3346
/////. 315 - 319 35 - 357
///. 3325- 3346
///. 3325
/elements/ /arbitral submission/
/valid/
///.3345 /////. 317/1/
/ /
/////. 35 / /
///. 3345/2/
174
///. 3325' ' ///. 1731
/ 23 199
.
8 199 .
/
23/2/199 . ///.
3322/2/ ///.
3318-3324 ///. 3325-3346
23/2/199 . 8 199 .
/
/////. 317
/ arbitration /
23/2/199 .
/ /conciliation/
/arbitration/
///. 3325- 3346 /////. 315-319 35-357
2/ 17,122.75 /
/
3/ ///
4/
175
// 39529
11 2001 .
- / /
- 1. / -
2. /
3. /
4.
5. /
6. /
( ) 2026 443
/
/
176
/ / /////.
337
18/2000 //
/
/
()
/
/
. /
/ /////. 231
177
1. / . 99300 27/5/2000 / .
65637 24/08/2000
2. /
3.
178
//. 40752
28 21 ..
- / /2 / - /
- -
/ / / /
/
/ / /
/ / / /
23,886( )
/ / / / /
177/1945 2// 1,( )
25.( ) 23,886( )
/
177/1945 2// 1, /
/ 25. / /
179
/ /
1. / / / 121/93 15/7/2 .. / / /.
26/2 7/11/2 ..
2.
23,886 / /
3. .. 2
4. /
/
180
//. 4133
2 21 .
- - -
- // / - / -
2/2 ..
/ //. 145/99 26/2 .. /
/. M105/02/07/99 18/1999 .. /////. 348/1/
/
183,744 / /
//
/
33/1985 5/2//
-
96/3/ 33/85 4
. 33/85 5/2//
183,744 /
/ 7 / / 19,744
/ /
.
33/85 5
181
. / /3442/32 9/5/99 ..
/
/ ///. 145/99 26/2 ..
/ / / /////. 348/1/
2/2 ..
. 19/96
/ - 96/3/ . 33/85 5/2//
/
13/21 ..
14 21 ..
/
- 96/3/ - 97/1/
- . 33/1985
- 1/1/
. 33/85
/
-
/ /
1. ? ?
2.
/ ? ?
/
19/1996
/
33/1985
5/2//
33/1985 5/2// - 97 1
182
-
33/1985 5/2//
//
/
-
97
- 96/3/
-
96/3/ 33/1985 5/2//
? ?
. 33/1985
5/2// -
97 1 /
33/1985 5/2//
183
184
//. 41385
3 2002 .
- // -
- 1. -
2. -
3. -
4. -
5. -
6. -
/
()
(
)
377/96 30
/
-
/
11 2001 .
185
/
-
?
() 30
()
? /
26 30
28
/2/
(
) /2/ //
/
1. / /. 39571 28 2000 .
/ /. 70771 8 2001 . /////.
348/1/
2.
3.
4.
186
// 42361
05 2002 .
- / -
- ... - /
-
- / 38316
-
24 2001 . 4()
27 2001 .
-
(Relief)
187
377/96 43(3)
43/3/
371
377/96 43(3)
377/96 162
/// 1845
// 32545
1. / 42459 28 2000 .
/ 68296 10 2001 .
///// 348(1)
2.
188
//. 42818
10 2002 .
- . -
- / -
377/96
19 2001 .
27 1//
377/96 27
- 348 1
1.
2.
189
//. 41767
8 2002 .
- / /
15
2000 . 25 1997 .
-
377/96 27/3/
/
30 2001 .
-
-
18 2001 .
-
24 2001 .
190
377/96 27/3/
-
/ 16 1999 .
21 2000 .
16 1999 . 06 1999 .
01 2000 . 21 2000 . 13
28 .377/96 27/3
377/96 27/1//
1. / / 39185 13 2000 .
/ / 68366 22 2001 . /////. 348/1/
2.
3.
191
/ 42923
22 2002 .
- 1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
- -
- / -
377/1996
1971.00 ( )
2366.00(
)
377/96 14(1/)
-
///// 337
19 2001 .
337/96 14(1/)
22
2001 .
(Equal Pay Discrimination)
11 2001 .
192
... - 42(1/)
377/96
14(1/)
discriminate between workers on the basis of nationality, sex, religion, political
outlook, or any other conditions shall be unlawful for an employer.
1. / 23005 28 2000 .
/ 70763 26 2001 .
///// 348(1)
193
2.
2366.00 /
/
3.
194
//. 4441
1 22
- / -
- // -
2 .. 29
2 .. 28
27 2
..
2 ..
1999 .. 29 1999
///// 337
14 21 ..
27 2 ..
195
/ /? ? ?
27 2 ..
27 2 ..
-
-
377/96 43/4/
494/98 2//
377/96 39/1//
377/96 4 41
38
196
1. / 12978 28 21 ..
/ 73958 6 21 ..
///// 348/1/
2. 377/96 43/4/ 441 38
3. 2 ..
4.
197
//- 47807
6/4/2002
- - /
- 1. / -
2. / - /
/ 24
1974 . 1 2000 . /
/
377/96 -
/
/
198
377/96 97
/ /
/ /
95/2/
/
/ 377/96 110/1/ // //
/2/
377/96 95/2/
/occupational injury/ /occupational disease/
97
97
/proximate cause and effect relation ship/
/strict/
/state of
mind/ 96
97
199
97 /accident/
95/2/ 97
/Natural cause/
377/96 95 97
/
/ / /
1. / /. 75634 27 2001 .
// /. 13539 6/4/2001 .
2.
3. /
200
/ 45889
20 2002 .
- -
- -
- -
/
/
/// // /
/
13 2001 .
/
/
()
// /
/ /Review of judgment/
judicial review
201
/
//
? /
?
()
() ()
/ //
Judicial Review
202
//. 47806
20 2002 .
- / -
- -
/
/
27 2001 .
/. 18419 4 98 .
/
203
1. / /. 27517 10 2001 .
/ /. 04821 13 2001 . ////
348/1/
2.
/
3.
204
// 47469
15 2002 .
- 1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
- -
- (22 )
- -
377/1996
20 2000 .
08 2001 .
377/1996 10(1/)
/ 18832
205
20 2002 .
// 11924
10
377/96 10
01 1998 . 01 1999 .
377/96 10
18832
377/1996
206
10
1. / 19930 20 2001 .
/ 03718 18 2001 . /////
348(1)
2.
3.
207
//. 47784
20 2002 .
- -
- -
21 2001
.
23 1984 .
(disturbance allowance) 300/ /
12 1995
1853
12 1995 .
20(16) (17)
1852 1853
208
?
?
1.
377/96 162 3 162
3
1852
1853
12 1995 .
377/96 164 3
164
1852
1853
1853
12 1995 .
6 1999 .
6 1998 .
163 3
12 1995 . 5 1998
.
6 1998 .
2. 6 1998 .
16 () 17
209
6 1995 .
1.
2.
3.
/
210
//. 49057
5 2002 .
- // -
- -
. 377/96
/
/
/
7 2002 .
. 377/96 30
?
/
. 377/96 30
?
( )
30
211
- 28/2/
/ 30
1. / /. 42790 27 2001 .
/ /. 82438 18 2001 . /////. 348/1/
2.
3.
212
//. 46276
11 22 ..
- -
- 1. -
2. -
/
/
/// /
27 21 ..
/ /
/
/
213
/
214
//. 42985
25 2002 .
- -
- (11 ) -
// /
/
/ / /
10//
/
377/96 28/2//
/
/
39/1//
215
1. // / /. 34121 28 2001 . / /
/. 70887 25 2001 .
2.
216
//. 49958
12 2002 .
- /// - / -
- -
/
/ / /
-
/ 21/2002 .
377/96 27/1/
43/1/
/ /
27/1/
12 2002 .
/
/
377/96 27/1/
27/1/
217
/
/
377/96 13/2/
27/1/
/
/
1. / / /. 40658 / / /. 83563
/////. 348/1/
2. 377/96 27/1/ -
218
//. 40529
10 2002 .
- - /
- - /
377/96 110
6,500 / / 9,750 / /
2000 / / 60,000 /
/ /
377/96 110/3/ // 18 10%
60,000 / / 10,000 ( )
/ /
/
/ 110/3/
/
/ 110
. 377/96 110
110/1/
18
219
110/2/
110/3/
110/3/ -
(100%)
377/96
110/4/
3 (100%) (
) 100%( )
110/4/
()
110/3/ -
() 110/3/
110/4/
110/3/ // 20% 80%
( )
/
10% 110/4/
10%( ) (100%)
/ 10%
110/3/
/
1000 / / 110/3/
220
/ 60,000 (
)
1. / / /. 22962 / / /. 66031
////. 348/1/
2. 377/96 110/4/
60,000 ( ) /
/
221
// 48648
24 2002 .
- -
- 1.
2.
377/96
29 2001 .
13 2000 .
03 2000 .
8 21 .
-
///// 337
01 2001 .
-
-
222
13 2002 .
19 2002 . 12
2002 .
-
?
377/96
10(1)
1. / / 30005 03 2001 .
/ 52383 30 2001 . /////
348(1)
2.
29 2001 .
223
/ 47825
25 2002 .
- . - /
- 1.
2.
377/96
29 2000 .
28 2000 .
01 2000 .
6338.84(
) 14430.93( )
///// 337
24 2001 .
?
23
2002 .
224
25 2002 .
03 2002 .
29 2000 .
28 2000 .
01 2000 .
?
()
1. / 35175 30 2001 /
/ 80204 06 2001 .
///// 348(1)
2.
3.
225
//. 47535
20 2002 .
- - / /
- -
- /
/
/
/ /
/
30
/
/
/. 377/1996
/
377/96 27/4/
30
30
2001 .
226
51
30
30
/
30
30
1. - / /. 5852 21 2001 . /
/ /. 96588 4 2001 .
/ /. 00973 18 2001 .
2.
3. 2001 .
4.
227
// 49750
30 2002 .
- 02/01 -
- -
377/96
01 2001
. 01 1997 .
314( ) 24 2001 .
-
///// 337
06 2002 .
-
-
25 2002 .
09 2002 .
228
- 377/96
13(2)
27(1/)
134(2)
13(7)
1. / 56547 09 2001 .
/ 83500 21 2001 .
///// 348(1)
2.
3.
229
/ 49797
30 2002 .
- -
- / -
54585 17 2001
. 2 2002 .
10,000( ) 11 2001
.
30
2001 .
()
-
230
-
?
247
377/96 27 2
- 241
- 248
-
1.
2. ()
-
343(1)
3.
231
//. 50009
06 2002 .
- / - /
- -
/
/
-
377/96 27/1//
/
/
-
232
1. // / /. 30209 22/2001 . / /
/. 83534 /////. 348/1/
26 2002 .
233
/ 50205
20 2002 .
-
377/96
377/1996 39(1/) 40 2 44
234
43 4()
377/1996
- 348(1)
1.
2. 4 2002 .
3.
235
//. 48476
12 2002 .
- / - / -
- -
515/1999
29 1996 .
/
515/99 87
21 2001 .
10 2002
.
236
515/1999 78/1/
87
87
1. // 00721/2001 22
2001 . / / 45242 28 2001 .
/////. 348/1/
2.
237
/ 49273
27 2002 .
- -
- ///
/
/
// /
24,900 / /
/ / / 65%
/ 377/96 109(3)()
65% 16,185.00 /
/ /
/. 377/96 109(3) ()
65%
/ 377/96 101(2)
65%
238
109(3)()
/ 109(3)()
1. / / / 77981 23 2001 .
2. 24,900 ( )
3. / /
4.
239
/ 50148
04 2002 .
- 1.
-
2. /
- -
/
1481 30 2001 . / 1481 30 2001 .
11 2001 .
1999 .
06 2001 .
71,000.00
5789 20343 30%
30 2002 .
///// 378
240
? ?
///// 378
/ 1481 30 2001 .
/// 1771(2)
///// 378
71,000.00 5789 20343 30%
-
1. / 1631 07 2001 .
/ 2067 25 2002 .
///// 348(1)
2.
3.
- 03 2002 .
241
/ 49931
21 2002 .
- -
377/96
12 2002 .
19 2001 .
17 2002 .
30 2002 .
16 2002 .
242
- 80(3/) 25/88 10
377/96 43(3)
1. / 14112 14 2001 .
/ 80323 10 2001 . /////
348(1)
2.
30 2002 .
243
/ 50838
12 2002 .
- - -
- 1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1 2002 .
131/99
()
377/96 28
244
377/96 147 -
377/96 28
1.
2.
245
/ 45746
6 2002 .
- /// - /
- -
// /
4 4 2000
.
26 2000 .
/
-
/ /
/
/ 377/96
27(1/)
-
-
-
23 2000 .
4 2000 .
4 / 377/96 27(3)
26 2000 .
246
/
// / -
/
1. // / / 33592 16 2001 . / / /
78022 4 2001 .
2.
3. 1 2001 .
247
/ 44405
19 2002 .
- .. -
/ / -
- -
377/96
2000 .
2000 .
///// 337
14 2001 .
377/96
36
30 2002 .
15 2002 .
248
2000 .
377/96 36
36 37
38
377/96 36 38
1. / 35485 27 2001 .
/ 75673 28 2001 . /////
348(1)
2.
249
/ 53064
17 2002 .
- -
- - .
377/96 43(4)
/ 43(4)
43
/
377/96 43/3/
250
/
-
377/96 43(3)
1.
/ / 17733 12/5/2001 / / 24165 17/11/2001
88091 28/3/2002 . ///// 348/1/
2. 377/96 43/3/
43/4/
251
//. 50182
13 2002 .
- -
- -
2 2002 .
1 2001 .
11
()
337
12 2
377/96
252
377/96 13 2
33 231
377/96 13 2
1.
2.
3.
253
//. 44218
13 2002 .
- -
- ( 21 ) -
/
1996 .
2000 . 20%
20%
// /
6
377/96 14
20%
/ / /
/
/. 377/96 14
/
/
/ -
-
254
/
/
10
/
/. 377/96 10
10
9
/
4.1.3
10/1//
/
?
377/96 14//
/ 43197
/
255
256
/ 46363
19 2002
- - -
- -
1 2001 .
4 1999 .
//
//
377/96
105
-
337
MCM
/////.
377(3)
257
377/96 105
?
377/96 105
1.
2.
3.
377/96 105
377/96 105
105
377/96
377/96 124
377/96 105
MCM
377/96
258
1.
2.
3. MCM
377/96
4.
259
//. 50923
19 2002 ..
- - -
- - -
377/96
1 1977 / 22 21 ..
22 1996 ..
377/96
5 2002 ..
-
377/96
25 22 ..
12 22 ..
260
377/96
?
22 1996 ..
261
1. / 78810 25 2002 ..
///// 348/1/
2.
3.
262
// 51912
07 2002 .
- - / -
- / -
/
/
/ 377/96 138
1 2000
. // / /
24/11/2000 . 10/05/2001 . /6/
/ /
/
/
/ 14 2002
. /
/ / 16648 /
/
263
4 2002 . 1 2000
. 10 2001 . 6 10
/
/ 24/11/2000 .
24/11/2000 . /
1
2000 . 10 2001 .
377/96 162
162(4)
1
2000 . 10 2001 .
/
/ / 24 2000 .
24 2000 .
136
/ 138
/
/ 16648 /
/ 24 2000
. / / 16648
163
163(2)
/ /
264
1. / / / 23/2002
/ //// 348(1)
2. 377/96 162(4)
3. /
265
//. 55189
30 2002 .
- - / -
- - / -
// /
/
- 3
/ / /
- -
/ 377/96 43/3/
/
/ 377/96 43/3/
/
/
/
-
-
/ 377/96
43/3/ -
266
/
1. // / / 33071 20 2002 . / /
/ 91456 6 2002 .
2.
3. 19 2002 .
267
//. 53358
18 2002 .
- -
- -
/
/
()
/
26 2002 . /
? 377/96
27/3/ 27
/3/
30//
268
30//
/
1. / /. 32585 14 2002 .
/ /. 89003 16 2002 .
/////. 348/1/
2.
3. /
?
//- 341/1/
4.
269
//. 43160
22 22 ..
- 1. -
2. -
- -
/
/
/ 377/96 1
//
/
//
/
27 22 ..
. 377/96 1
1
9
270
271
//. 52459
16 2002 .
- / -
- / -
// /
1984 . 21 2000 .
1 1994 .
/
/ / /
/ / 45264
/ 377/1996
77(5)
272
24(2)
/
1994 .
/
1. // / / 39535 7 2002 . / / /
86994 12 2002 .
2.
3. /
// / ///// 343(1)
273
//. 45170
8 2002 .
- / -
- / -
/
11 2000 . 5 2000 .
377/96 27/1///
/ /
/
/
/
/ 2000 .
/
13/1/
21 2001 . /
/
274
4 2000 .
377/96 13/1/
1. / /. 04326 01/07/2001 .
2. 14 2001 .
275
-
276
//. 43424
10 2002 .
455/97 3/1/ 4/1/
- 06 2001 . 3()
-
09 2001 .
277
?
///// 39/1/ 40/2/
/////. 40
-
-
278
2.
/////. 343/1/
3.
4.
279
// 43410
30 2002 .
- - /
- -
- / /
/ / -
/ ///// 69(2)
/ 14 2001 .
-
- ///// 73
62(2) -
- /
//// 65
-
/
///// 73
- 32(2)
///// 69(2) -
-
///// 73 69(2)
/ ///// 69(2)
/
- /
/ ///// 73
69(2)
280
281
//.47551
06 2002 .
- - /
- -
// /
6
/
/ / /
-
-
/ 6
-
6
/
/ /
-
/
/
-
282
-
1. / / /. 79174 12 2001 .
2. // / /. 27244 14 2001 .
3.
283
//. 40229
15 2002 .
- / - /
- 1. / -
2. -
///// 358
/
/// /
8-2-2000 .
///
21 1998 . ( )
///// 358
-
/ /
///// 358 /
284
///// 358
///// 358 ///// 41
///// 41 ////
/
///// 41(4)
/ ///// 358
/
285
// 43731
8 2002 .
- ... -
- -
/
//// .72
/
/
16 2001 .
/ . 13262 7 2001 .
/
/ //// .78(1)
//// /
//// 69(1)
-
//// .69 78
( )
286
/ //// . 70()
?
/
//// . 72
()
//// . 78(1)
/
//// . 72 78
//// . 78(1)
/ . 78(1)
/
()
/
/
//// . 72
1. / . 13262 7 2001 .
/ . 72956 2 2001 . //// 348(1)
2. /
3.
287
//. 39581
25 2002 .
- - /
- - /
// / /
// /
/
/
/ ///// 280 ///// 71(2)
/ ///// 280
-
/ /
/
/
/
/ ///// 280
/
/ ///// 280 -
-
/
/
288
/
/
/ -
///// 71(2) /
- ///// 69(2)
- ///// 70()
- -
/
/
///// 280 -
- / -
///// 209
/
21/4/2000 . /
/ ///// 280 -
- ///// 280
///// 71(2) -
-
1. // / / 92294 13 2000 . / /
/ 64486 28 2000 .
2.
3.
289
// 45984
26 2002 .
- / -
- -
/
/
/
/
/ /
/
-
/ / /
/
/ /
/
/
/
29/05/2001
.
/
290
/
/
-
- -
-
-
/
/
///// 223(2) 234
/
/
/
///// 91
- /
- - 20(4)
1. / / 20744 20 2001 .
/ / 07592 19 2001 . /
/ 79715 12 2001 .
2. /
///// 343(1)
3.
291
//. 47252
26 2002 .
- /
18 2000 .
66502 10 2001 .
27 1998
5 1998 .
1 1998 30 1998 .
1
1998 . 1 1998 .
663,863 ( )
331,931.50( ) 21
1998 .
/
27 1998 . 5 1
1998 . 1 1998 .
292
2 2
?
-
241
- 248
1 1998 .
( / )
1 1998 30
1998 . ()
2 2
1 1998 30 1998 .
- 248
1 1998 30 1998
.
/
27 1998 5
2
2
27 1998 .
1
1998 3 1998 . /
1 1998 . 30 1998 .
416,680 (
)
2 2 5
1 1998 30 1998 .
331,931.50 (
) 1734
2 27 1998 . 2 2
293
1.
2. 1 1998 . 30 1998 .
/
2 2
- 343 1
3.
26 2002 .
294
//. 43821
5 2002 .
- / - -
- / -
/////. 6
///
/ / //
/////
19 2001 .
295
/////. 6
/// /. 16624
////. 6
/////. 6
/////.
358
/ /
. (1)() ()
296
.
()
( )
. 6 ////
()
()
/////. 223
234 /
/////. 264
. 137
. 256 /
297
. 345
()
( )
. /1/ ..
298
. /1// // -
/ ( )
. 6/1// ( )
/////. 6
/. 16624
299
/ . 454/97 2/1/
/. 16624
1. / /. 01789 5 2001 . //
2. 16624
3. /////. 6
4. /
5.
300
//. 42871
12 22 ..
- 7 32 / - / -
- / -
18 1994 .. 58 59
13 1995 .. ///// 6
///// 6
//// 6
15 21 ..
-
///// 6
19 22 ..
27 22 ..
301
/
///// 6/3/ -
///// 6/3/ /4/
... -
8/3// 25/1988 1 22
///// 6/3/ /4/
-
302
1. / 4111 28 2 ..
/. 7548 28 21 ..
///// 348/1/
2.
3.
4.
303
//. 37214
25 2002 .
- - /
- 1. - /
2. /
3.
/ /
450,000
250,000 150,000
/////. 418
/////. 421
/.
137/93 /. 11684
- /
/ / / /
////. 421 /////. 418
/////. 421
/
/
/////. 421
304
///// 421
/////. 418
/////. 421
/ /
/
01520
/ /. 137/93
/ 26 1995 .
/
/ /////. 418
/. 01520
/////. 421 /.
01520 /////.
421
///// 421
-
305
//. 44634
22 2002 .
- -
- / -
// /
22
// /
/ /
/
/ /
/
/
/ /
/////. 225/1/
(one who alleges in the
affirmative shall prove it) /
/
306
1. // / /. 51214 6 2000 .
/ / /. 60553 25 2001 .
2.
307
//. 45371
8 2002 .
- - / - /
- 1. -
2. -
3. / -
// / /
6
/
/ / / /
/
/
6
25 2000 . 6
/ /////.
280
308
/////. 280
309
//. 36776
7 2002 .
- / / -
- -
/////. 216(4)
/
100,000 ( )
///// 216
/
/ /
/////. 216
/ /
/
/
1,675.00( )
100,000( )
///// 216(3)
/
/
/ /
/////. 216
- /
/////. 216
2
3 2
310
3
/
100,000( )
/ 689,306.49(
) 24
1997 .
/
100,000( )
/////. 216(3)
/ / 33585
24 1997 .
100,000( )
10 03/09/1997 100,000( )
///// 216(3)
1. / / 22131 18 2000 .
2.
311
//. 44545
07 2002 .
- - /
- -
24 1996 .
- / 21
1984 . /
08 1985 .
/////. 358
/////. 360(2)
/
15 2001 .
/
06 2002 .
312
/////. 341342343
-
1. /. 49541
27 2001 . /////. 348/1/
2.
/////. 341/1/
3.
313
// 44883
8 2002 .
- -
- -
/ /
3
152,222.40(
)
276 247
25
1997 .
/
112,738.80( )
/ /
25 1997 .
/
/
/
314
97/90
///. 2211 -
6
///// 394(2) 428(2)
/
24 2002 .
? ? ? ?
97/90 3
216/92 2
///// 394-449
6
-
- 423(1) 426
-
97/90 -
( 7 )
-
315
1. / / 12810 4 2001 .
/ 00557 27 2001 .
2.
316
//. 39799
21 2002 .
- / / -
- / -
/// /
///// 43
/// /
/
/// 3-13690 .
3-06622 /
() //// 43
/
/ /
44,451(
) (100)
() (100,000)
()
/
/ ////
43(1)
/
//
25/88 5(6)
317
//
//// 43(1) ()
/
//// 43(1)
-
//// 43(1)
/ 23692
/ 23692 ////
43(1) 76
// 1896 1897 1908 1909 687,688 683
//// 43
(indemnity)
/
454/97 2(4) /
////
43(1)
//
43(1)
318
1. // / 47210 25/2000 .
//// 348(1)
2. //
//// 343(1) /
319
//. 43845
20 2002 .
- -
- // -
/ 07 1998 .
-
60,858.82( )
9%( )
20 2001 .
-
68/89 48/7/,/11/ 10/1996
12 2002 .
18 2002 .
320
?
60/89 47
()
60/1989
48 7 8
6
1/5/
57/1/
55
10/1996
-
10/1996
60/89
48 10/1996
321
1. /. 66236 23 1999 .
/. 59649 28 2001 . /////. 348/1/
2.
/////.
343/1/
3.
322
//. 44931
20 2002 .
- / -
- -
- /
/ (
)
/
/ /
/ 6001 001
/ /////. 208 /
/
/
/
/ /////. 337 /
/////. 208 -
/
/. 45172 /. 44931
/
/ /////. 377
/ /
/
?
323
/
/////. 320/1/ 348/1/
/
/////. 320/2/ /
- -
/////. 209 /////. 6
/
/ /////. 208
/
/
- /
/ /
/
- /
/
-
1. / /. 00248/2001 1 2001 .
2. /
3.
4. /. 45172
324
//. 48237
06 2002 .
- /
///// 480
07 2001 .
///// 480
///// 480
///// 480
325
-
///// 480
10,000.00( )
1. / 42643 30 2001 .
2.
326
//. 50022
29 2002 .
- 5 .. -
- -
/ /
/ /
//// .78
/
/
24 2002 .
/
//// .78
/
/ /
//// .97
(
) /
////
/ -
327
/
//// .95(3) 97
//// .105 /
//// .78(1)
1. / . 12201 3 2001 .
/ . 04822 11 2002 . //// .348(1)
2. //// .78(1)
3. /
328
//. 45038
23 2002 .
- 1. / -
2. -
- / / -
/
/// /
8/2002 . /
02
/ 772 /
/
/ / /. 2284 2/13/98 .
02 /
/
/
329
/
//// 374
/
/
1. / /. 17589 2/2001 .
//// /. 20042 /.
00580 /////. 348/1/
2.
/////. 343/1/
/
3. /
330
//. 43005
19 2002 .
- 1.
2. /
3.
///// 481
22 2001 .
07 2001 .
18 2001 .
07 2001 /
331
13 2001 .
///// 481
452(1)
///// 481 452(1)
1. / 128857 20 22 2001 .
/ 75302 21 2001 .
2.
332
//. 45839
5 2002 .
- / - /
- / - / (1,2,3,5
) 4
/ /
/
/////. 6
/
// /
9 2000 .
/ /
/////. 6
/////. 6
/
/
333
/
/
/////. 6
/
1. // / / 12405 24 2001 .
2.
334
// 39853
21 2002 .
- 1.
2. /
// / 23
12 1801/01 09 1989 .
900( )
23 1990 .
30 1998 .
///
2024()
/
/// 2024()
900.00( )
/ / /
/// 2025()
2
/// 2024()
/// 2024() /// 2024()
335
/
/// 2025()
/// 2025()
? /
/ /
/
/////
327(3) 345() /
///// 145 /
-
/ ///// 256 345
/ /
///// 327
/
/ /
/
/// 2025()
/
/
-
///. 2024()
/
/
/
336
/ /
///// 337
-
1. / / / 65544 18 2000 .
2. /
///// 343(1)
3.
337
//2 41526
2 2002 .
- . - -
- .. -
332,834.27(
)
39,600.00( )
332,834.27(
)
( )
39,600.00( ) BB430772
03325 /
38,808.00
( )
293,234.27( )
/ 38,808.00( )
16 2001 .
38,808.00
( )
338
38,808.00(
)
?
21 2001 .
21 2002 .
? ?
?
... -
80(3()) 25/1988 10
1. / 59208 04 2000 .
/ 61553 2001 . ///// 348(1)
2.
339
//. 52752
16 2002 .
- 1
2 .
- 1
2 /
.
30
2000 .
///// 277(1)(2)
10 2002 .
340
?
26 2002 .
09 2002 .
/ 4
///// 277
///// 277
341
1. / 81625 24 2002 .
///// 348(1)
2.
08 2002 .
342
//. 45247
17 2002 .
- -
- -
149,000.00(
) 145,000.00( )
10,000.00( )
/////. 337
16 2002 .
343
?
10,000.00( )
///.
2273/2/
465/97
3/2/
///. 1740
1. / /. 13195 20 2001 .
/ /. 73431 19 2001 . /////.
348/1/
2.
3.
344
4.
5.
345
//. 49857
30 2002 .
- / - /
- / / -
/
/
-
( /) //// 78
/
/
/////
/
17 2002 .
?
/////. 78 -
346
( ) ()
/
////
5/1/
-
2.
3.
347
// 48632
14 2002 .
- -
- -
( ) /
/ / /
28 2001 .
( ) /
-
//// 235(2)
//// 83
/
/
348
1. / / 05257 / / 27266
// . 88090 ////
348(1)
2. / ()
//// 343(1)
3. /
349
//. 49660
22 2002 .
-1. /
-
2. /
- -
377/96
-
27 1999 . 22 2001
.
/////. 337
09 2002 .
-
-
? 26
2002 .
17 2002 .
350
///// 223234137249 256
-
-
-
1. / / 29808 06 2001 .
/ 82545 19 2001 .
///// 348/1/
2.
///// 343/1/
3.
12 2002 .
351
//. 52525
29 2002 .
- / -
- -
/// /
/
/. 345/97 14/6/2001 . /
/
/
(res judicata) /
/
/
//// 91/4/
/ /
-
352
//// 5/1/ ?
//// 5/1/
//// 5/1/
// (res judicata) - 5/1/
1. / /. 88224 17/05/2002 .
///// 348/1/
2. / /. 06008 4/7/2001 . /
/. 19080 24/11/2001 .
353
//. 43331
19 2002 .
- -
- () -
//// / 22866 //
/
/ / /
/
/
/
/. 4665 ( )
/
/
/
/ 110/99 /
/ /
/
/
?
//// 341/1/ /
/
/
354
/
/ /
/ / -
-
-
/
/ /
/
/ / -
/ /. 4665
/
/ /
/. 22866 -
355
//. 36730
30 2002 .
- -
- -
/ 27947 8 2000 .
20224 16 2000 .
23 2000 .
377/96 164 1
2
21 2000 . / /
//
/ /
377/96
- 337
356
23 2000 .
-
377/96 162 164 147
1851//
1 2000 .
? ?
16648
//
-
28690 10 2000 .
24 2000 .
16648
357
1.
377/96 138
147
? ?
28690
182 1
2.
377/96 164 1
-
-
9 23 1//
1851//
- 231 1//
358
1852 1
3.
- 37
377/96
? ?
-
4.
Limitation periods are to be construed strictly so as not to take away the
right of the plaintiffs
16648 - 278
3
(Analogy)
()
- 37
1 4
16648 454/97
4
359
- 80
3// 25/88 10
- 348/1/
1.
2.
3.
4. 8 2000 .
5.
360
//. 50376
12 2002 .
- / - -
- 07/08 /
2 2002 .
4
2000 .
-
78
4 2000 .
361
- 105 1
4 2000 . - 78
2
4 2000 .
1. 6 2002 .
2. 4 2000 .
3.
- 343(1)
4.
362
/ 1 - 7 /
- 1
. //
.
1 18180 .
. .42/85 138(1) 147 29/1997
2 15493 / /
///. 1845 224 29/1997
3 17361 / / - /
/////.49, ///.1856 25/1997
4 17352 // / /
/////.215 32(2) 207 211(2) 28/1997
5 14605
( ) 29/1997
. 59 591 ///.1792
6 17068 / /
19/1997
///.1856 224, /////. 89
7 14974 / / (
) ///. 2188 2189 228 229, /////. 57 58 28/1997
8 14184
( ) /////. 73 29/1997
9 14047 / / /
( ) 28/1997
///. 1856 224
10 15835 / /
/////. 7 233 29/1997
11 15992 //
/ ///. 1719 172 (1) 1723 1726 1727 1845 19/1997
12 17191 / /
///. 1711 1731 1676(2) 2635 264 2646 29/1997
2
.
//
.
13 13223 /
9/1998
/////. 182(2) 342 345(1)()
14 14414 / . 42/85
/ . 42/85 2(1) 3(2)() 1/1998
15 15270
/////. 33(2) 231 (1)(), .47/67 28/1998
16 15410
1/1998
. 42/85 147
363
17 16273 /
22/1998
.377/96 9 1 138 142, /////. 33
18 16624 / / /////. 6(1)
/////. 6(1) 18/1998
19 16720 /
( ) 22/1998
/////. 378(3)()
20 16896 /
16/1998
///. 1711 1731(1)
21 17077
14/1998
///. 1928(1)(2)
22 17189
17/1998
. 42/85 27(1) () 53(1) 54
23 17429 /
21/1998
///. 881
24 17533
18/1998
. 6/89 2(18) 43(1) ()
25 17712 /
/ ///. 1195(1) 1196 (1) 16/1998
26 18307 ..
25/1998
///. 2534 254 2541(1)
3
. //
.
27 15815
///. 257 2573 2574 2571 1/1998
28 16648
( ) . 42/85 162 163 164 165 166, . 377/96 20/1998
29 17483
/ . 42/85 162(1) 20/1998
30 11924 /
.42/85 9 1 24 15/1998
31 14057
. 42/85 79(2) (5) 77(5) 77(3) 30/1998
32 16270
17/1998
///. 266(2) 2086(2) 2081 2091 2102 292
364
33 18581
/ . 42/85 23(1) 43(3),40(1) (2) 44 20/1998
34 15631 ( )
///. 11(2) 1168 1845 1853 17/1998
35 15551
29/1998
///. 1716(1) 1815 1816 1817
36 16062 /
///. 2143(1) 2143(2) 19/1998
37 14554 /
///. 188(2) 1198(2) 20/1998
38 15672
/////. 442 27/1998
39 16301
. 99 /////. 13 15 2/1998
40 10797 /
( ) 27/1998
/////. 378
41 18199 / ( ) /
- 7/1998
/////. 429
42 16378 1 ///
46/53 . 29/55 3(2) 17/1998
43 18342
( ) .38/88 11(1) /////. 4 17/1998
44 14699
258/55 29 7/1998
4
. //
45 20885 /
. 42/85 9 1 3/1999
46 15531 /
6/1999
47 21730 / /
. 377/96 43(5) 11/1999
48 21119
. 42/85 (2) 18/1999
49 21961 //
. 377/96 27(1) 18/1999
50 20457 / /
. 42/85 43 53(1) 54 20/1999
51 24153
. 377/96 27(1) 26/1999
52 16653 /
27/1999
365
53 25526
16/1999
. 42/85 9 1
54 15662 /
13/1999
///. 2298 1733
55 19081
( ) 18/1999
///. 1677 191
56 23320
( ) 20/1999
57 14493 /
13/1999
///.2298 1733
58 18786 /
18/1999
/ ///. 1771(1) 1785(2) 1789
59 21448 / /
( ) ///. 1723 1727 2877 2878 30/1999
6 15557 / /
11/1999
61 22260 / /
( ) /////. 463 18/1999
62 17984 /
///. 1817(1) (2) 20/1999
63 19205
/////. 395 25/1999
64 19479 /
( ) 20/1999
. 47/67
65 16109 /
12/1999
///. 1587 162 1613 2878
66 14094 . 47/67
18/1999
///. 1195 47/67 /////. 33/2/
67 17937 /
///. 1677 . 1845 20/1999
///. 17 68 1 1677 1845
68 20938 / /
11/1999
69 22243 /
126(1) 143() () 16/1999
7 17058 /
///. 881 884 892 996-1 /////. 5 25/1999
71 22712
// 9/1999
/
366
( ) ///. 881
72 22162
9/1999
73 23339 /
. 368/95 6(2) 13/1999
74 16195 /
/ ( ) 11/1999
. 4187 11(1) .47/67 21(2), ... - 74(4)
75 22317
18/1999
. 6/89 5-6 ///. 21(2)
76 12025
1949 .656() () 18/1999
5
. //.
77 17320 /
( ) 18/2000
///. 349(2) 2206(1)
78 20809 /
1/2000
79 23861
14/2000
/////. 58
8 26399 /
( ) 5/2000
///. 188 1816 2191(2), 2193
81 32241 /
(Conflict of interest) 9/2000
/
( )
///. 2187(1)
82 21355
3/2000
///. 1923(2)
83 25115
5/2000
84 26565 /./
(Force majeure) 19/2000
/./ /////. 1792(2)
85 17742 /
( ) ///. 1678() 1715 2/2000
86 23921 /
12/2000
///. 2458(1)
367
87 32337 /
21/2000
/ ///. 913
88 22891 / / /
( ) 24/2000
89 31737 / / ///. 2472
27/2000
9 24173 //
/ 24/58 11/2000
. 24/58 5 51 53 54
91 24574 ////// -
11/2000
92 25434 ///.1738
25/2000
// ///. 1738
93 29369
9/2000
///. 1771(1) (2)
94 19338
2/2000
///. 212
95 21296 //. 289
///. 289(1) (2) 1/2000
96 22509 /
7/2000
97 24818
4/2000
///. 289(2)
98 27565
( ) 1/2000
99 27623
24/2000
/
. 38/88 5 8 11
10 28612
///. 291 25/2000
101 28750
24/2000
///. 235 1896
102 28865
24/2000
///. 227
368
103 30032
1/2000
/
.74/1994 46(5) ()
104 30442
/ 3/2000
///. 295 87 812
105 31099 /
14/2000
/ ///. 295 269(1)
16 32144
23/2000
/
///. 2116
17 32250 / /
( ) 25/2000
///. 295(2)
18 33975
25/2000
/ .455/97 7(1)
19 34138 ( )
() 26/2000
11 34906 /
/ 5/2000
111 21740 / /
///. 699(1) (2) 28/2000
112 23021 /
12/1999
/ 96 97(1)
113 23493 / /
26/1999
114 23632 /
26/2000
///// . 75/96 235(1) ... - 36(2)
115 24625 / /
28/2000
116 25005 /
3/2000
62(1) , 63(1)
117 25281 /
() 29/2000
92
///. 1131 1132
118 25588
6/2000
119 26839 /
10/2000
57 86(1)
369
12 26953 / / / //
13/2000
121 27697 / /
19/2000
85 -93
122 27869 ///
3 1/2000
/
( )
517() ()
///. 2878
68(1) 69(2)
123 29343 / ( ) /
7/2000
. 47/67 11(1)
124 29402 /
19/2000
125 30959 / / ( )
( ) 1/2000
154 156 157
126 31430 /
// 73(1) (2) 7/2000
127 31891 ( ) /
///. 14290/ 14/2000
128 31946 /
... - 34(2) 35(2) 9(1) 14/2000
129 32130 ( )
18/2000
/ // . 79/95 154()()
13 33411 /
3 25/2000
131 33440 / /
21/2000
154
132 33875 / /
4 97(2) 25/2000
133 34149 /
147(1) 97(2) 25/2000
134 34387 /
14/2000
135 35376 ( )
28/2000
/ 62(1) 7(1)
136 23389 /
1/1999
( ) . 367
370
137 25306
12/2000
. 898(1)
138 27161 /
12/2000
( ) /////. 28
139 28923
. ( ) 7/2000
. 28/92 5(1) 6(1)
14 23608
/ 3/2000
.11/87 4(1) 5(3)
141 27548
18/2000
/ ( ) ///.1196(1)
142 29822 6 2 /
/ 28/2000
/ /// 1196(1)
143 29860 / 47/67
18/2000
/ ( ) 47/67 13(1)
144 31490 /
2/2000
/////. 244 341
145 31682
/ 12/2000
( ) . 47/67
.11/87
146 32376 ///10/11 //
/ / 19/2000
/ . 361/95 41()
147 34249 /
28/2000
/////. 4(2)
148 22857 ( )
15/2000
/ /
( ) /
/////. 274(1) 275 (1) 277(1)
149 25912
///. 3312 2/2000
15 29386 /
25/2000
///. 18
151 30536 / ( )
() 23/2000
371
152 20036 //
16/1998
/ 95 96 97
153 25899 /
28/2000
. 29/55 3(2)
154 26480
14/2000
12/91 9(4)
155 28883 //
26/2000
. 25/88 11(2)
156 29005 /
14/2000
( ) . 361/95 1(2) 30
. 18/97
157 30298 /2000
///. 171(1)
. //.
158 08751 / /
( ) 26/2000
/////. 6
159 19142 / / -
( ) 26/2000
/////. 32 (3)
16 20465 322/95
/ 26/2000
. 322/95 ... - 8(2)
161 21270
/ 3/1999
/ ///// 158 . 97/9
162 22556
( ) 14/2000
163 22603 // 20 / /
26/1999
/ /////. 255 257
164 23363
( ) 26/2000
. 665(2)
165 23628 . . //
( ) 21/2000
. 1
372
166 23692 /////. 43
3/1999
. 687 /////. 4(2) 43
167 23744 / //
( ) 26/1999
/////. 32(1) (3)
168 23769
12/1999
169 24111 /
11/2000
/ / /////. 7() 195
17 24627 /
/ 3/2000
.11/ 87 3(1)
171 24775
21/2000
/////. 241(1) 233
172 25026 /
14/2000
/////. 328(2) 182(2)
173 25890 3
( ) 18/2000
/////. 41
174 26670
3/2000
/////. 428(2)
175 27739 /
28/2000
/ /////. 231(2)
176 27808
( ) 7/2000
/////. 153 (2)
177 28522
3/2000
/ ( ) /////. 5
178 28802 /
/////.182(2) 8/2000
179 29738 79/6 /
/ 14/2000
. 25/88 1(1)
18 29761 ( )
( ) 14/2000
.361/95 41()
181 29780 / /
/////. 5 29/2000
182 30631 / / ( ) / /
10/2000
. 11/87
373
183 30704 47/67 //
18/2000
/
( ) /
. 11/87 . 47/67
184 31547 / /
/////.182 7/2000
185 31833
14/2000
/ / ( ) /////. 136
186 32147
9/2000
/////. 231(1) ()
187 32376 ///10/11 // -
19/2000
/ .361/95 41()
188 32638 / /
( ) 12/2000
/////. 358
189 33606 (
) 2/2000
/////. 158
19 34249
28/2000
/////. 4(2)
191 34313
25/2000
/////.43(1)
192 35403
14/2000
/
( )
/////.78
193 22008 / (
) ///.2164 3/1999
194 22297 / /
24/1999
195 22469 /
( ) 5/1999
///.1578
196 22719 /
14/2000
///. 1195
374
197 23608
/ 3/2000
(Binding)
.11/87
198 24269 // //
24/2000
. 292/78 7(1)
199 26130 /
4/2000
/ /
. 47/67
.... - 4(3)
85
2 27506
19/1999
/
21 27600
6/2000
( ) ///.366
22 29005 / /
14/2000
( )
. 36/95 1(2)
. 1/95 / . 18/97
23 30101 /
( ) 24/2000
///. 1179(1) (2)
24 30461
. 8/89 6(18) 3/2000
25 33499
25/2000
///. 1178(2)
26 33711 3 7 /
23/2000
/
27 33831
14/2000
28 33924 /
16/2000
///. 1195(1)
29 34406 /
7/2000
/ ///. 2143(1)
21 20295
5/1999
///. 1(1)
375
211 25567 / ///. 1
12/2000
///. 999 1
212 25664
7/2000
///. 1845
213 26422 /
28/2000
///. 1(1)
214 28686
24/2000
///. 1845 1846
215 28997
///.1851() 1/2000
216 29920 ///
/////. 5(3) 26/2000
217 31185
///. 1852(1) 12/2000
218 31217
. 377/96 162(3) 14/2
219 31857
17/2
. 377/97 27(3)
22 32788
18/2
.377/96 164(3)
221 34011 /
///. 1(2) 25/2
222 31748
18/2
///. 1677(1),1845
223 18832
3/2
. 42/85 43(4)()
( )
224 20416
8/2
/////. 91
225 21329
19/2
226 22275
1/1999
/ -
(out sourcing)
. 377/96 35
376
227 25317
. 377/ 96 39(2) 110(2) 40 1/2
228 25511
. 377/96 39 2/2
229 26077
12/1999
.377/96 134(2)
23 27704 -
5/2000
. 377/96 43(5)
231 27959
3/2
.377/96 79(5)
232 29692
12/2000
233 29740
2/2000
234 29866
7/2000
235 29949
19/1999
236 30956 5
9/2000
237 31402
30/2000
. 377/96 24(3)
. 345/95 12(1)()
238 32545
14/2000
. 377/96 162
///. 1677(1) 1845
239 33314 97/9
28/2000
. 377/96 16
( ) . 97/9
240 33513
27/2000
.377/96 138
241 34588
5/2000
.377/96 27
242 35440
. 377/96 28(1) 19/2000
243 29415
27/2000
. 377/96 27(2)()
244 32822 .
. 377/96 27(1) () 27/2000
377
245 32229
3/2000
/ / /////. 5
7
. //.
246 12719 ///
17/2000
/// ///. 1734, 1952/1/
247 20232
24/1999
. 715, ///. 1706, 1679
248 23609
15/2000
///. 2573, 2574/2/, 2570/2/, 2577, 2562
249 30298 3
20/2000
///. 171
25 16218 . 97/9
16/2000
/ ( )
. 97/90 3 4, . 216/92
251 25863 / / ( )
///. 3088, 3052, 3081,3059 26/2000
252 29269 /
15/2000
( ) /////. 403
///. 3041, 3044, 3059/1/, /////. 403,154
253 29375 /
19/2000
/ ///. 3066 . 97/90
254 33295 / ( )
21/2000
///. 3052, 3053,1605, 1607, 1606
255 23024 /
24/1999
/////. 40/5/
256 24221 4 /
24/2000
257 25938
/ 7 / / 25/2000
( )
///. 1719/1/,1719-1930, 2898/3/
258 28025
/ // 20/2000
378
///. 2966/1/
259 31601 / ( )
11/2000
. 361/95, /////. 227/2/, 226
26 31634 2
// 4/2000
/ //
( ) ///. 2024//
261 32521
7/2000
262 34456
14/2000
/ ///. 2966
263 18380 / /
( ) /////. 231/1/// 5/2000
264 22448 / //
/////. 378/1/ 28/2000
265 22860
18/2000
///. 2002
266 23331 /
( ) 1/2000
267 24974 ( ) /
( ) 8/2000
///. 1771,1784, 1785
268 26996 / ( )
18/2000
///. 1715, 1815
269 27349
8/2000
///. 1765, 1731/1/
27 28663 / ///. 658
///. 658, 686 27/2000
271 29233 ///. 1723
/// 1815 7/2000
///. 1723, 1720/1/, 1815
272 32222
///. 2876, 1723, 3019, 3020/2/ 4/2000
273 32899 /
21/2000
274 23322 / /
///. 956 19/2000
275 25869 /
19/2000
/ ///. 1272, 1273
276 30158 / // -
19/2000
/ ///. 1000/2/ ... - 40
379
277 32414 / /
( ) 24/2000
///. 996/1/, 998/1/, 973, 996/2/
278 34076 /
( ) / 10/2000
/////. 23
279 24703
//// ///. 1725, 1727 651, 654, 657 9/1999
28 22069 //
///. 522 /1/ // 28/2000
281 22452 / ///. 522/1/ //
///. 522/1/ // 30/2000
282 23855
26/2000
. 60/89 74 . 388/95 80/3/
283 24278 . 214/74 13/1/
/// /// ///// // 10/2000
284 28952 /////. 122/2/
16/2000
/////. 122/2/, /5/
285 29325
////. 161/1/ 18/2000
286 31734 /
15/2000
/////. 67//
287 34077
9/2000
288 34280
/. 192,194 14/2000
289 34521 /// 3/2000
//. 184, 179
29 35611
19/2000
///// 193/1/
291 18809 75/1993
12/2000
75/93 2/9/ 78/94 24/2/ //
292 19258
12/1999
293 23389 /
( ) 10/1999
/. 364,365,367
294 28923 /
7/2000
. 208/1992 5/1/, 6/1/ //, . 182/1992
295 10489 / /
24/1999
380
///
/////. 404
296 18576 / /
26/2000
/ ///. 944, 946, 956, 960, 996
297 19283 /
9/2000
298 22481
4/2000
/////. 422/3/, 428/5/, 455, 428/1/
299 22930 /
// 30/2000
/ /
30 23733 / ( )
/// 24/2000
( )
301 23989 //
17/2000
///. 2878
302 25031 / / /////. 418
/////. 358,418 1/2000
303 26553 3
3/1999
///. 3059/1/, 3084, /////. 418, 426, 423/2/ //, 445-447, 415
304 27574 / /
/////. 215/1/, 319/2/ 26/2000
305 28019 / /
1/2000
306 28154 3
/ 14/2000
/////. 418/1/, 419
307 29344 / /
5/2000
/ /////. 358, 418
308 29653
9/2000
/////. 358, 418
309 33760 //
18/2000
127
381
382