Detailed Engineering Assessment

Table of Contents
DECLARATION ..................................................................................................................................................................2
ABSTRACT OF THE REPORT ................................................................................................................................................3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: .....................................................................................................................................................4
A. BUILDING CONFIGURATION:................................................................................................................................................... 4
B. SERVICEABILITY: ................................................................................................................................................................... 4
C. STRUCTURAL MEMBER: ....................................................................................................................................................... 4
1.0. GENERAL OVERVIEW OF THE BUILDING:.................................................................................................................6
PHYSICAL OBSERVATION ...................................................................................................................................................6
2.0. INPUT PARAMETER OF THE DEA REPORT: ...............................................................................................................7
2.1. STRUCTURAL SYSTEM: ............................................................................................................................................................ 7
2.2. ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA FOR THE EVALUATION OF LINEAR ANALYSIS: .............................................................................................. 8
2.2.1. CODE AND PRACTICE: ......................................................................................................................................................... 8
3.0. LOAD DEFINITION AND INPUT PARAMETERS: .............................................................................................................9
3.1. DEAD LOADS (D): ................................................................................................................................................................. 9
3.2. LIVE LOAD (L): ..................................................................................................................................................................... 9
4. WIND LOAD (W):......................................................................................................................................................... 10
4.1. UBC 94 AUTO WIND LOAD CALCULATION ............................................................................................................................... 10
4.2. AUTO WIND LOAD CALCULATION ........................................................................................................................................... 11
5.0. METHOD OF ANALYSIS: ............................................................................................................................................ 12
6.0. LOAD DEFINITION FOR FEM ANALYSIS: ..................................................................................................................... 13
7.0. LOAD COMBINATION: ACCORD COMBINATION ........................................................................................................ 13
8.0. METHOD OF ANALYSIS AND ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA: ................................................................................................14
8.1. CHECK FOR SERVICEABILITY REQUIREMENTS .............................................................................................................................. 15
I. Drift evaluation ......................................................................................................................................... 15
II. Torsional Irregularity Check ...................................................................................................................... 17
III. Foundation Evaluation.............................................................................................................................. 17
IV. Column Evaluation.................................................................................................................................... 23
V. Shear Wall Evaluation .............................................................................................................................. 42
VI. Beam Evaluation ....................................................................................................................................... 43
VII. Typical Slab Evaluation ............................................................................................................................. 43
8.2. RETROFITTING DESIGN CHECK FOR FAILURE COLUMN. .................................................................................................................. 44
9. REFERENCES:...............................................................................................................................................................45
Page 1 of 46
Declaration
We declare that this assessment has been done based on collected data and test results by field
investigation, following mainly ACI Code, BNBC 2006 and ACCORD Guideline. The objective is to
support the ACCORD program.
All rights reserved. This report and all other documents related to this project are confidential and may
contain information that is privileged or otherwise protected from disclosure and are only for the
intended recipient.
ABSTRACT OF THE REPORT
On 14 December 2013, Arup carried out a visual structural survey of this project. They
have major concern about the following conditions in this factory.
 Design check all columns, beams and slabs. Create loading plans and heights to match
actual structural code capacity.
 Mezzanine: Uncontrolled loading on cantilever
 Mezzanine: Plan and height restrictions to be introduced to prevent future overloading.
(Loading plans in line with design loads from engineer)
We carried out a Detailed Engineering Assessment of this structure especially considering the
conditions described above and step by step carried out the remediation criteria.
A detailed calculation and analysis has been described in the rest of the report.
Executi ve Summar y:
Our company was engaged to perform a detailed structural engineering assessment of Proposed 09 (nine) storied
factory building for a factory building located at Konabari, Nilnagar, Gazipur, Bangladesh. The main purpose of
this analysis is to determine, whether the factory building, in its current condition, has sufficient capacity to
support the anticipated vertical and lateral loads as per Bangladesh National Building Code (BNBC)
- 2 0 0 6. According to NTPA reduced load combination and live load 42 psf, this assessment has been
summarized in this report.
Few observations based on DEA report are stated as follows:
A. Building Configuration:
Torsional Irregularity: This is a torsional regular building.
B. Serviceability:
Drift limit is within allowable limit for code prescribed lateral load in both direction which can be verified in
the serviceability check section.
C. Structural Member:
This building is essentially composed of RC frame structure, beam, column, shear wall moment frame
system.
I. Columns: PMM ratio of 98.5% of the columns is within the limit (compliant) based on structural analysis
considering 2KPa (42psf) live load along with code prescribe lateral load.
II. Beam: Almost all the beams found adequate in size and reinforcement for both flexure and shear can be
verified from the visuals of ETABS for beam design. Check the model file “before retrofitting”.
III. Slab: Existing slab thickness and reinforcement of typical slab floor is adequate enough to resist code
prescribed vertical load all these are represented through the well processed SAFE analysis based on
ETABS analysis value.
IV. Foundations: Building is supported by isolated footing foundation system. Thus a FEM analysis has been
performed to determine the design load; and then checked with available bearing area in order to
determine safe bearing capacity; plus punching is also checked against governed load in order to
determine section adequacy of footing against punching. Reinforcement provide for foundation is safe
against its developed load. Provided footing area is adequate as per soil test report.
Comments on DEA report:
We recommended following steps need to carry out:

1. Keep & monitor the live load plan before & after retrofitting.
2. Retrofit the two failure columns at two consecutive stories as per the indication, only.
This page is intentionally left blank.
Page 5 of 46
1.0. General Overview of the Building:
Based on the information provided by the factory representatives it has been confirmed that the construction of the
building was accomplished in the year 2006. Review of the available documents indicates that, as-built
architectural and structural documents are available on-site. These drawing do not match with as built condition
completely. Therefore these documents are considered partially credible.
Structural dimension of the building is of approximately 139'- 10" ×100'-3"on plan. Height of the building from
the ground level to roof is 118'-7".
Accord report’s finding needs to be incorporated here.
 Uncontrolled loading on cantilever

 Plan and height restrictions to be introduced to prevent future overloading.
 Plan and height restrictions to be introduced to prevent future overloading in mezzanine floor (Loading
plans in line with design loads from engineer)
 The RCC structure has been observed visually to identify the physical distresses or any other
findings. Summary of the findings has been tabulated below.
Physical Observation
Table 2-1: Physical Observations Remedial Plan

Observation SL
01 Dampness has been observed on the Remove the plaster from the dampness
south-east corner side surface then re-plaster
ceiling at 8th floor. the area.
02 Water ponding has been observed at 1. Provide 2% slope on the roof level.
roof top floor at the south side extension This slope will help to maintain proper
roof top. drainage.
2. Provide barrier to resist the entrance

of rain water to that floor and provide
proper drainage system to avoid that
type of ponding.
03 Presence of rust is evident on the Remove the Rust by rubbing and then
unlocked rebar of roof top provide anti-corrosive
column. material.
04 Un braced racks have been Adequately anchor and brace all
observed at the west side of 1st non-structural elements to resist
& 7th floor earthquake or any lateral forces. Also,
case of future installation, do provide
bracing and anchorage to the non-
structural elements.
Page 6 of 46
The following Table 1.1 shows the basic information of the building.
Table 1.1: Basic information of the building
Information Description
Structural Reinforced Concrete Frame Structure

System
Floor Area All floor 1, 48,000sft.
Number of 09 Storied building

Stories
Construction Year Started in 2006
Foundation Type Isolated footing
Construction Stone chips has been used for concrete in footing, columns up to 6th floor,
materials brick chips for columns in 7th,8th and roof. Brick chips has been used for
concrete in beam and slab.
Architectural & As built architectural & structural drawings are available.
structural drawing
Floor usage  Main production building
2.0. Input parameter of the DEA report:
2.1. Structural System:
No of Story: Existing 09 storied building having a mezzanine floor.

Frame Type: Reinforced concrete frame
Foundation System: Isolated footing with foundation beam and basement slab.
Estimation of Concrete and Reinforcing Bar:
Strength of concrete was estimated from cylinder test report as shown below. ACCORD audit team has
confirmed verbally that cylinder test (lowest value) value can consider to prepare the design report but those
cylinder test result can be used as per equivalent concrete core equation ACI562.
Table 2.1: Material properties for design
1 Yield Strength of steel fy 60,000
psi
2 Cylinder Strength of Concrete for f’c 4297 psi

Column (stone chips)
Cylinder Strength of Concrete for f’c 3469 psi
Column (brick chips)
3 Cylinder Strength of Concrete for f’c 2873 psi
Beam
5 Cylinder Strength of Concrete for Slab f’c 2873 psi

6 Young’s Modula’s of Concrete (stone chips) Ec 57000√f’c
Table 2.2: Concrete cylindrical result for column, beam & slab by using equation ACI 562.
2.2. Acceptance Criteria for the Evaluation of Linear Analysis:
2.2.1. Code and Practice:

For the present project, Guidelines of ACCORD have been used for analysis. For the reinforced concrete
design, American Concrete Institute (ACI 318, 1999) code has been consulted, according to NTPA reduced
load combination and 42 psf live load.
3.0. Load Definition and Input Parameters:
Prior to structural analysis it is essential that the loads that may act upon the building during its lifetime be
duly considered and incorporated in the analysis. The loads that may act upon the structure are as follows:
3.1. Dead Loads (D):
Dead loads (D) are those gravity load which remain acting on the structure permanently without any change
during the structures normal service life. These are basically the loads coming from the weight of the
different components of the structure. For the sake of convenience in the analysis, sometimes this kind of
loads are divided into following types, namely
 Self‐weight of the structure (SW), weight of slab, beam, and column.
 Weight coming from floor finish (FF).
 Weight coming from partition wall above beam (WB).
 Weight coming from partition wall above slab (SB).
 The non‐structural permanent components of the building.
For the analysis and evaluation of the building, following are the values of unit weight considered to obtain the
self‐weight.
 Unit weight of reinforced concrete = 150 pcf
 Unit weight of brickwork = 120 pcf
 Floor finish = 25 psf
3.2. Live load (L):

Live load is the gravity load due to non‐permanent objects like machines, furniture, and human. Analysis has been
carried out base on reduced load recommended by NTPA guideline and actual load acting on building. Following
are the live load values used in the analysis.
Table 3.1: Typical live loading of building considered for linear static analysis
Floor Type of Loading Code Specified Minimum Design Live Load (Q C) in
KN/m2 for Light Garments Factory Building.
Live Load 2
Ground Floor Live Load 2
Mezzanine floor Live Load 2
1st Floor Live Load 2
2nd Floor Live Load 2
3rd Floor Live Load 2
4th Floor Live Load 2
5th Floor Live Load 2
6th floor Live Load 2
Roof Live Load 1.5
water tank bottom Live Load 14.94

slab
All stair case Live Load 4
4. Wind load (W):

Bangladesh is typically a storm prone area where due consideration to the thrust due to storm must be given in
the analysis and design of building and structures. Wind load due to storm is typically modeled as lateral thrust
force causing sway or overturning of the building. Detailed specifications on wind loading on buildings are
outlined in BNBC (2006). The present project is located at Ambagh Road, Konabari, Nilnagar, Gazipur,
Bangladesh.
INPUT PARAMETER:
Following seismic parameters are considered for the finite element analysis as per BNBC 2006:
Basic wind speed, Vb 210 kmph

Exposure category A
Structural Importance Factor, I 1
4.1. UBC 94 Auto Wind Load Calculation

This calculation presents the automatically generated lateral wind loads for load pattern WL X according
to UBC 94, as calculated by ETABS.
Exposure Parameters
Exposure From = Diaphragms
Exposure Type = Exposure B
Wind Direction = 0;90 degrees
Basic Wind Speed, V V = 130.5 mph
Windward Coefficient, Cq,wind [UBC Table 16-H] Cq,wind = 0.8
Leeward Coefficient, Cq,lee [UBC Table 16-H] Cq,lee = 0.5
Top Story = MRT

Bottom Story = G.F
Include Parapet = Yes, Parapet Height = 3
Factors and Coefficients
Importance Factor, IW [UBC Table 16-K] IW = 1
Lateral Loading
Wind Stagnation Pressure, qs [UBC 2
Table 16-F] ≥ 10psf qs = 43.59744
qs = 0.00256V
Design Wind Pressure, P [UBC Eq. 18-
1] P = (Ce,wind Cq,wind + Ce,lee Cq,lee)qsIw

Applied Story Forces
Story Eleva X-Dir Y-Dir
tion
ft kip kip
MRT 135.2 9.884 0
5
MRB 126.7 47.28 0
5 1
OHWTB 120.7 49.52 0
5 9
Roof 111.2 68.28 0
5 2
Story8 101.2 68.87 0
5 7
Story7 91.08 68.15 0
33 7
Story6 81 65.41 0
9
Story5 71 64.16 0
3
Story4 61 63.02 0
9
Story3 50.66 64.17 0
67 5
Story2 39.83 65.24 0
34 5
Story1 27.66 81.74 0
67 1
G.F 8.5 43.71 0
Base 0 0 0
4.2. Auto Wind Load Calculation

This calculation presents the automatically generated lateral wind loads for load pattern WL Y according
to UBC 94, as calculated by ETABS.
Exposure Parameters
Exposure From = Diaphragms
Exposure Type = Exposure B
Wind Direction = 90;180 degrees
Basic Wind Speed, V V = 130.5 mph
Windward Coefficient, Cq,wind [UBC Table 16-H] Cq,wind = 0.8
Leeward Coefficient, Cq,lee [UBC Table 16-H] Cq,lee = 0.5
Top Story = MRT

Bottom Story = G.F
Include Parapet = Yes, Parapet Height = 3
Factors and Coefficients
Importance Factor, IW [UBC Table 16-K] IW = 1
Lateral Loading
Wind Stagnation Pressure, qs [UBC 2
Table 16-F] ≥ 10psf qs = 43.59744
qs = 0.00256V
Design Wind Pressure, P [UBC Eq. 18-
1] P = (Ce,wind Cq,wind + Ce,lee Cq,lee)qsIw
Applied Story Forces

Story Elevatio X-Dir Y-Dir
n
ft kip kip
MRT 135.25 0 6.703
MRB 126.75 0 72.12
8
OHW 120.75 0 75.55
TB 8
Roof 111.25 0 95.13
6
Story8 101.25 0 95.96
5
Story7 91.0833 0 94.96
3
Story6 81 0 91.14
7
Story5 71 0 89.39
7
Story4 61 0 87.81
8
Story3 50.6667 0 89.41
4
Story2 39.8334 0 90.90
5
Story1 27.6667 0 113.8
89
G.F 8.5 0 66.92
2
Base 0 0 0
5.0. METHOD OF ANALYSIS:
Depending on the type of project, there are several well‐established methods among which Finite Element
Method (FEM) is perhaps the most sophisticated and all‐encompassing one. For analysis and evaluation of the
building, powerful finite element based structural design software package ETABS has been employed for
analysis. Some aspects of the analysis process are discussed in the following paragraphs.
A full three dimensional modeling of the structure has been developed using frame and plate/shell elements.
The frame elements are typical two‐nodded frame elements in space having six degrees of freedom per node
– three translations and three rotations in three mutually perpendicular axes system. The plate/shell elements
are of rectangular (or quadrilateral) and triangular shape. The quadrilateral element has four nodes at its four
corners. Each node has six degrees of freedom – three translations and three rotations in a 3D space
configuration. The frame elements are used to model the columns while the plate/shell elements are used to
model the ribs and the roof shell etc. At base level, the columns are assumed to be held fixed.
6.0. Load Definition for FEM Analysis:

The basic sources of loads are described in earlier section. These loads are applied on the model in nine basic
categories. These are as follows:
 Load Case 1: Self‐weight of structure (SW)
 Load Case 2: Live Load (LIVE)
 Load Case 3: Partition wall (PW-Full/PW-8//BW)
 Load Case 4: Floor Finish (FF)
 Load Case 5: Wind load on East‐West Direction. (Wx)
 Load Case 6: Wind load on North‐South Direction. (Wy)
Table 6.1 - Load Patterns
Self Weight
Name Type A
Multiplier
Dead Dead 1
Live Live 0
FF Superimposed Dead 0
PW-Full Superimposed Dead 0
PW-8"BW Superimposed Dead 0
Parapet Superimposed Dead 0
RLL Roof Live 0
WL X Wind 0
WL Y Wind 0
7.0. Load Combination: Accord Combination

Following Methods of Load combination are used on FEM for evaluating the existing RMG building: These
five basic load cases are analyzed in ETABS. The results are then combined in accordance with the
specifications set forth by ACCORD/NTPA guideline. These guidelines specifies a number of combination
options.
These are as follows:
ACCORD Combination 1 = (1.2 * D.L + 1.6 * L.L)
ACCORD 2 = (1.05 * D.L + 1.25 * L.L ± 1.0 * W.x)
ACCORD 3 = (1.05 * D.L + 1.25 * L.L ± 1.0 * W.y)
Where D stands for total dead load i.e. D = (FF+SW+BW+SW), L stands for live load i.e. L=LL, W (Wx, Wy)
stands for wind load. When these basic load cases are combined accordingly considering the direction of
lateral loads, we obtain, after simplification.
The above combinations are factored combinations, i.e. factors like 1.2 or 1.6 are used to multiply the basic
load cases before they are added. These combinations are useful for the purpose of reinforcement design
checking using USD method. In the above combinations Wx mean wind force acting in from north towards
south direction while ‐Wx means the same force acting in the opposite direction i. e from south towards north
direction. Similar explanation applies for other lateral loads. The above load combination is considered for
the assessment of factory Building.
Fig: 3D FEM model by Etabs
8.0. Method of analysis and acceptance criteria:

I. Drift evaluation
II. Torsional irregularity check
III. Foundation evaluation (SAFE analysis)
IV. Column & Shear wall evaluation
V. Floor beam evaluation
VI. Floor slab evaluation
Method of Analysis: Liner Elastic Analysis
8.1. Check for Serviceability Requirements

I. Drift evaluation
TABLE: Maximum Governing Story Drift -X Direction
Maximum Allowable
Story Height Load Case/Combo Direction Drift Drift Remarks
ft in in
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL +
1.0 WX)
MRT 135.25 X 1.471169 3.24 Compliant
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL +
1.0 WX)
MRB 126.75 X 1.379411 3.04 Compliant
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
1.0 WY)
OHWTB 120.75 Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) X 0.340751 2.89 Compliant

Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
Roof 111.25 X 1.545464 2.67 Compliant
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
Story8 101.25 X 1.418241 2.43 Compliant
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
Story6 81 X 1.118626 1.944 Compliant
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL -
G.F 8.5 X 0.038125 0.204 Compliant
1.0 WY)
TABLE: Maximum Governing Story Drift -Y Direction
Maximum Allowable
Story Height Load Case/Combo Direction Remarks
Drift Drift
ft in in
MRT 135.25 Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0 Y 1.41 3.24 Compliant

WY)
MRB 126.75 Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0 Y 1.35 3.04 Compliant

WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
OHWT WX)
120.75 Y 2.11 2.89 Compliant
B Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
Roof 111.25 Y 2.01 2.67 Compliant
WX)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WX)
Story8 101.25 Y 1.88 2.43 Compliant
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WX)
Story6 81 Y 1.53 1.944 Compliant
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WX)
Story2 39.8334 Y 0.95 Compliant
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY) 0.519997
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WX)
Story1 27.667 Y 0.66 Compliant
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
WY) 0.256146
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0
G.F 8.5 Y 0.204 Compliant
WX) 0.071364
Page 16 of 46
II. Torsional Irregularity Check
Table: Torsional Displacement Check for Wind Load (Wx)

Average Average
E-S S-W N-E N-W
Displaceme Displaceme Remarks
Corner Corner Corner Corner
nt nt
Δx - max Δx - min Δx - avg. Δx - max Δx - max Δx - avg.
Torsional
2.08 1.6 1.84 2.08 1.6 1.84
Regular
Table: Torsional Displacement Check for Wind Load (Wy)

Average Average
S-W E-S N-E N-W
Displaceme Displaceme Remarks
Corner Corner Corner Corner
nt nt
Δy- max Δy - min Δy - avg. Δy - max Δy - min Δy - avg.
Torsional
0.25 0.24 0.245 3.16 3.15 3.155 Regular
Page 17 of 46
III. Foundation Evaluation
Note: Soil bearing capacity is considered 4.84 KSF (F.S=2.75) as per soil test report, considering bore hole 1 and 3, (lowest value have been considered)
TABLE: Adequacy of Footings due to Design Column Forces
1. General Info 2. Punching Check 3. Bearing Check
Ultimate
Footing ID Service Punching Nominal
Column ID Required Developed Soil
& Footing Load, P Shear Shear
Arch.Grid & Comments Thickness, Stress, qds Bearing FoS Remarks
Size, B x L x [From, Stress, Vp Resistance,
Sizes if any Capacity,
t ETABS] Vc
qult
B ft x ft x in Kip Psi Psi KSF KSF

C1 (12 x F1
2/A 277.5 80.43 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 7.76 13.31 1.56 OK
17) 6.5 x 5.5 x 26
C2 (14 x F2
11/A 256 72.28 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.63 13.31 2.61 OK
17) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C3 (14 x F2
11/B 305 86.11 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.52 13.31 2.19 OK
17) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C4 (14 x F2
11/C 281.5 79.47 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.1 13.31 2.37 OK
17) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C5 (14 x F2
11/D 283 79.90 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.12 13.31 2.36 OK
17) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C6 (14 x F2
11/E 307 86.67 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.56 13.31 2.18 OK
17) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C7 (14 x F2
11/G 274 77.36 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.96 13.31 2.44 OK
17) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C8 (17 x F3
4/A 577 126.81 131.10 OK 28 inches 6.83 13.31 1.77 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
Page 17 of 46
Ultimate
t ETABS] Vc
qult

C9 (17 x F3
5/A 487.5 107.14 131.10 OK 25 inches 5.77 13.31 2.1 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C10 (17 x F3
6/A 485 106.59 131.10 OK 25 inches 5.74 13.31 2.11 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C11 (17 x F3
7/A 482 105.93 131.10 OK 25 inches 5.7 13.31 2.12 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C12 (17 x F3
8/A 461 101.32 131.10 OK 25 inches 5.46 13.31 2.22 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C13 (17 x F3
9/A 429.5 94.40 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.08 13.31 2.38 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C14 (17 x F3
10/A 456 100.22 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.4 13.31 2.24 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C15 (17 x F3
4/G 187.5 41.21 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 2.22 13.31 5.45 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C16 (17 x F3
5/G 563 123.74 131.10 OK 28 inches 6.66 13.31 1.82 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C17 (17 x F3
6/G 579 127.25 131.10 OK 28 inches 6.85 13.31 1.77 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
Page 18 of 46
Ultimate
t ETABS] Vc
qult

C18 (17 x F3
7/G 588 129.23 131.10 OK 28 inches 6.96 13.31 1.74 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C19 (17 x F3
8/G 568 124.84 131.10 OK 28 inches 6.72 13.31 1.8 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C20 (17 x F3
9/G 549.5 120.77 131.10 OK 27 inches 6.5 13.31 1.86 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C21 (17x F3
10/G 528 116.04 131.10 OK 27 inches 6.25 13.31 1.94 OK
24) 13 x 6.5 x 28
C22 (22 x F5
4/B 888 103.98 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 6.34 13.31 1.91 OK
30) 14 x 10 x 38
C23 (22 x F5
4/C 660 77.28 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.71 13.31 2.57 OK
30) 14 x 10 x 38
C24 (22 x F5
4/D 636 74.47 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.54 13.31 2.67 OK
30) 14 x 10 x 38
C25 (22 x F5
4/E 658.5 77.11 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.7 13.31 2.57 OK
30) 14 x 10 x 38
C26 (27 x F4
5/B 740 83.24 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.57 13.31 2.65 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C27 (27 x F4
5/C 703 79.08 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.34 13.31 2.79 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
Page 19 of 46
Ultimate
t ETABS] Vc
qult

C28 (27 x F4
5/D 675 75.93 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.17 13.31 2.9 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C29 (27 x F4
5/E 714.5 80.37 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.41 13.31 2.74 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C30 (27 x F4
6/B 739.5 83.18 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.56 13.31 2.65 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C31 (27 x F4
6/C 700.5 78.80 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.32 13.31 2.8 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C32 (27 x F4
6/D 663.5 74.63 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.1 13.31 2.95 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C33 (27 x F4
6/E 695.5 78.23 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.29 13.31 2.82 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C34 (27 x F4
7/B 738.5 83.07 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.56 13.31 2.65 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C35 (27 x F4
7/C 702 78.97 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.33 13.31 2.79 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C36 (27 x F4
7/D 664.5 74.75 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.1 13.31 2.95 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C37 (27 x F4
7/E 693.5 78.01 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.28 13.31 2.83 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
Page 20 of 46
Ultimate
t ETABS] Vc
qult

C38 (27 x F4
8/B 704.5 79.25 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.35 13.31 2.78 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C39 (27 x F4
8/C 670.5 75.42 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.14 13.31 2.92 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C40 (27 x F4
8/D 633.5 71.26 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 3.91 13.31 3.09 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C41 (27 x F4
8/E 660 74.24 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.07 13.31 2.97 OK
30) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C42 (D18 = F6
2/C 304 84.73 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.5 13.31 2.2 OK
16 x 16) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C43 (D18 = F6
2/D 298 83.05 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.39 13.31 2.24 OK
16 x 16) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C44 (D18 = F6
2/E 300.5 83.75 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.44 13.31 2.22 OK
16 x 16) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
C45 (26 x F4
9/B 645.5 74.37 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 3.98 13.31 3.04 OK
28) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C46 (26 x F4
9/C 610.5 70.33 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 3.77 13.31 3.21 OK
28) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C47 (26 x F4
9/D 591 68.09 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 3.65 13.31 3.32 OK
28) 13.5 x 12 x 38
Page 21 of 46
Ultimate
t ETABS] Vc
qult

C48 (26 x F4
9/E 625 72.00 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 3.86 13.31 3.13 OK
28) 13.5 x 12 x 38
C49 (27 x F5
10/B 811.5 92.74 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.8 13.31 2.09 OK
28) 14 x 10 x 38
C50 (27 x F5
10/C 675 77.14 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.82 13.31 2.51 OK
28) 14 x 10 x 38
C51 (27 x F5
10/D 669 76.46 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 4.78 13.31 2.53 OK
28) 14 x 10 x 38
C52 (27 x F5
10/E 823.5 94.11 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 5.88 13.31 2.06 OK
28) 14 x 10 x 38
C53 (14 x F2
2/B 333.5 88.41 131.10 OK Not Reqd. 6.04 13.31 2 OK
22) 8.5 x 6.5 x 26
Page 22 of 46
IV. Column Evaluation
TABLE: Story-wise Concrete Column P-M-M Envelope
PMM
Col. Ratio
Story ID Labe Section Governed P-M-M Combo P Mmajor Mminor or Remarks
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRT C15 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) -9.62 -12.3 -10 0.082 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRT C25 C5-(28x20) 15.23 38.22 -84.7 0.169 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRT C44 C6-(D18) 8.83 -6.95 -26.1 0.243 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRB C15 C3-(15x22) -18.4 -7.42 26.79 0.178 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRB C25 C5-(28x20) 28.82 41.04 -71 0.154 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRB C44 C6-(D18) 24.76 -15 7.033 0.128 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRB C116 C5-(28x20) 10.53 20.59 73.57 0.124 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
MRB C118 C1-(15x10) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) -1.04 -1.3 -7.51 0.095 OK
MRB C119 C9-(20x12) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) -3.54 -3.5 14.71 0.095 OK
MRB C120 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 5.55 22.9 -9.71 0.1 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRB C121 C3-(15x22) -10.5 -17.1 5.007 0.081 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRB C122 C3-(15x22) -2.99 -14.3 -5.63 0.064 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRB C123 C8-(26x25) 20.63 -58.2 56.54 0.14 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
MRB C124 C8-(26x25) 30.67 -46.2 -52.7 0.117 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
MRB C125 C2-(12x15) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 3.41 -6.05 -2.4 0.068 OK
MRB C126 C2-(12x15) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) -4.46 6.569 0.356 0.062 OK
MRB C127 C2-(12x15) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) -5.39 -6.14 -0.43 0.062 OK
MRB C128 C2-(12x15) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 4.19 6.911 -2.01 0.071 OK
2.36E
MRB C129 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 0.21 0 0.018 OK
-04
2.36E
MRB C130 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 0.21 0.022 0 OK
-04
2.36E
-04
2.36E
-04
2.36E
-04
2.36E
MRB C134 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 0.21 -0.02 0 OK
-04
2.36E
MRB C135 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 0.21 0 -0.02 OK
-04
2.36E
MRB C136 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 0.21 -0.02 0 OK
-04
2.36E OK
MRB C137 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 0.21 0.022 0
-04
Page 23 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
2.36E
-04
MRB C139 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 2.48 -0.28 0 0.001 OK
MRB C141 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 2.48 0.279 0 0.001 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C1 C1-(15x10) 23.42 -5.72 -25.8 0.341 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C2 C2-(12x15) 45.78 -23.5 -12.5 0.303 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C3 C2-(12x15) -4.85 16.68 -6.42 0.189 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C4 C2-(12x15) 9.33 8.484 7.295 0.135 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C5 C2-(12x15) 9.39 8.612 7.29 0.136 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C6 C2-(12x15) 1.79 -19.7 -11 0.251 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C7 C2-(12x15) 44.51 16.04 -10.1 0.223 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C8 C3-(15x22) 113.3 37.55 -43.5 0.3 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
OHWTB C9 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 4.13 0.433 0 0.005 OK
OHWTB C10 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 4.13 -0.43 0 0.005 OK
OHWTB C11 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 4.13 0 -0.36 0.005 OK
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C14 C3-(15x22) 19.19 32 -38.6 0.245 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C15 C3-(15x22) -9.51 -35.9 19.41 0.186 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Page 24 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C21 C3-(15x22) -20.5 35.83 -3.15 0.156 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C22 C5-(28x20) 160 16 81.5 0.16 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C23 C5-(28x20) 25.42 27.67 -38 0.092 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C24 C5-(28x20) 24.55 23.43 -43.1 0.09 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C25 C5-(28x20) 52.57 -26.3 49.69 0.109 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
OHWTB C29 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 10.8 0 1.296 0.006 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C42 C6-(D18) LL - 1.0 WY) 16.08 -6.66 -22.9 0.188 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C43 C6-(D18) LL - 1.0 WY) 16.87 -6.52 -26.7 0.218 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C44 C6-(D18) 38.02 -3.7 28.96 0.222 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C49 C8-(26x25) 152.2 -35.4 48.2 0.125 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C50 C8-(26x25) 20.44 31.82 -13.9 0.055 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C51 C8-(26x25) 20.56 28.23 -20.4 0.057 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Page 25 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C52 C8-(26x25) 160.3 40.8 -58 0.14 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
OHWTB C54 C9-(20x12) 40.26 -16.9 35.31 0.285 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C1 C1-(15x10) LL - 1.0 WY) 51.19 -7.42 -22.6 0.341 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C2 C2-(12x15) LL - 1.0 WY) 71.45 -22.4 -8.07 0.263 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C3 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 25.12 16.04 -6.94 0.192 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C4 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 28.64 10.39 2.291 0.11 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C5 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 28.04 9.265 2.243 0.1 OK
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C6 C2-(12x15) 32.85 -15.6 -6.98 0.19 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C7 C2-(12x15) 72.03 18.72 -8.06 0.238 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C8 C3-(15x22) 169.2 17.76 -37.6 0.263 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C9 C3-(15x22) 46.71 24.88 -38 0.229 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C10 C3-(15x22) 44.72 15.61 -36.5 0.203 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C11 C3-(15x22) 44.79 16.33 -35.4 0.2 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C12 C3-(15x22) 42.68 22.4 -34 0.206 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C13 C3-(15x22) 41.28 16.69 -34.2 0.194 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C14 C3-(15x22) 62.91 15.64 -35.9 0.207 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Roof C15 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 7.34 -60 13.47 0.218 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C16 C3-(15x22) LL + 1.0 WY) 55.4 -23.8 11.11 0.118 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C17 C3-(15x22) 56.98 12.76 -10.7 0.092 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C18 C3-(15x22) 57.97 13.31 -12.7 0.101 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C19 C3-(15x22) 56.35 20.82 -14.3 0.123 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C20 C3-(15x22) 54.31 17.55 -12.5 0.106 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C21 C3-(15x22) 48.59 21.89 18.71 0.142 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C22 C5-(28x20) 239.1 23.91 28.33 0.167 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Roof C23 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 104.7 -12.1 12.56 0.074 OK
Roof C24 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 100.9 -11.1 -5.23 0.071 OK
Roof C25 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 140.1 -15.3 16.81 0.099 OK
Page 26 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C26 C4-(28x25) 82.83 30.69 -9.94 0.063 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C27 C4-(28x25) 76.58 25.33 -15.4 0.058 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C28 C4-(28x25) LL - 1.0 WY) 76.73 22.12 -16.2 0.056 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C29 C4-(28x25) LL - 1.0 WY) 80.96 20.69 -32.5 0.067 OK
Roof C30 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 93.21 10.49 11.83 0.055 OK
Roof C31 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 87.7 9.866 -3.6 0.052 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C33 C4-(28x25) LL - 1.0 WY) 78.78 14.62 -31.8 0.062 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C37 C4-(28x25) LL - 1.0 WY) 78.86 14.74 -29.8 0.061 OK
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C39 C4-(28x25) 72.29 23.99 -10.7 0.053 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C40 C4-(28x25) 72.35 23.78 -8.68 0.052 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C41 C4-(28x25) 75.61 21.87 -26.8 0.062 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C42 C6-(D18) 50.73 -10.9 9.792 0.128 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C43 C6-(D18) 47.53 -11.9 -13 0.145 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C44 C6-(D18) LL + 1.0 WY) 61.26 -7.88 24.33 0.208 OK
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C45 C7-(26x24) LL - 1.0 WX) 73.09 -14.7 24.52 0.062 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C48 C7-(26x24) 71.56 10.74 -24.4 0.058 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Roof C53 C9-(20x12) LL + 1.0 WY) 76.02 -14.9 24.46 0.228 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C1 C1-(15x10) LL - 1.0 WY) 79.46 -8.5 -23.6 0.369 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C2 C2-(12x15) LL - 1.0 WY) 93.7 -26.6 -7.5 0.306 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C3 C2-(12x15) 57.85 18.52 -8.44 0.231 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Page 27 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C4 C2-(12x15) 55.37 12.82 -4.43 0.162 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C5 C2-(12x15) 57.55 -11 -4.6 0.154 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C6 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WX) 66.15 -16.9 -7.14 0.216 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C7 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 98.28 21.67 -9.57 0.292 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C8 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) 225 23.63 -41.8 0.32 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C9 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) 100.4 20.64 -31.3 0.206 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C10 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) 97.68 10.26 -32.6 0.193 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C11 C3-(15x22) 97.58 10.25 -31.6 0.189 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C12 C3-(15x22) 91.89 19.15 -28.6 0.189 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C13 C3-(15x22) 90.16 9.467 -31 0.182 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C14 C3-(15x22) 112.4 22.92 -38.1 0.243 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C15 C3-(15x22) 35.66 -63.7 15.44 0.229 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Story8 C16 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 135.5 -7.45 11.86 0.157 OK
Story8 C17 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 142.7 1.818 -12.5 0.165 OK
Story8 C18 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 145 2.57 -12.7 0.169 OK
Story8 C20 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 137.1 1.439 -12 0.158 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C21 C3-(15x22) 109.5 27.45 23.36 0.192 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Story8 C22 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 322.7 3.464 38.72 0.225 OK
Story8 C23 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 182 -18.2 -0.05 0.127 OK
Story8 C24 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 180.8 -18.1 -6.68 0.127 OK
Story8 C30 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 181 6.967 21.72 0.107 OK
Page 28 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C42 C6-(D18) 83.31 -13.7 10.2 0.172 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C43 C6-(D18) 81.15 -12.9 -14.1 0.18 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C44 C6-(D18) 86.9 -8.26 27.33 0.238 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story8 C53 C9-(20x12) LL - 1.0 WX) 116.1 -15.8 28.31 0.272 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C1 C1-(15x10) LL - 1.0 WY) 108.4 -10 -23.4 0.415 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C2 C2-(12x15) LL - 1.0 WY) 117.4 -28.5 -9.39 0.352 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C3 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 91.3 22.09 -9.84 0.289 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C4 C2-(12x15) 82.47 14.64 -6.6 0.214 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C5 C2-(12x15) 84.27 -13 -6.74 0.206 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C6 C2-(12x15) 91.04 -21.4 -7.28 0.269 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C7 C2-(12x15) 117.6 26.33 -9.41 0.339 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C8 C3-(15x22) 281.6 29.57 -42.2 0.374 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C9 C3-(15x22) 155.3 16.3 -36.1 0.247 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C10 C3-(15x22) 150.4 15.79 -34.9 0.239 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C11 C3-(15x22) 150.3 15.78 -34.2 0.237 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C12 C3-(15x22) 143.3 15.05 -33.6 0.23 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C13 C3-(15x22) 138.7 14.56 -34.5 0.23 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C14 C3-(15x22) 162.4 17.05 -41.6 0.273 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Page 29 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C15 C3-(15x22) 49.18 -66.1 15.61 0.242 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C21 C3-(15x22) 180.3 18.93 28.55 0.244 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Story7 C23 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 261 -8.78 31.32 0.182 OK
Story7 C24 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 258.6 -9.98 -31 0.18 OK
Story7 C25 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 290.4 -29 5.612 0.203 OK
Story7 C33 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 268 30.15 -18 0.158 OK
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C42 C6-(D18) 116.8 -16.2 11.09 0.223 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C43 C6-(D18) 116.8 -16.1 -11.1 0.223 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C44 C6-(D18) 112.5 -10.7 27.32 0.266 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Story7 C49 C8-(26x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 400 45 23.33 0.249 OK
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story7 C53 C9-(20x12) LL - 1.0 WX) 156.7 -16.5 28.91 0.313 OK
Page 30 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C1 C1-(15x10) 138.1 -12.6 -25.4 0.494 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C2 C2-(12x15) 141.2 -32.5 -11.3 0.413 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C3 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 125.6 26.78 -12.7 0.37 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C4 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 116.5 16.66 -9.32 0.278 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C5 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 114.1 15.4 -9.13 0.268 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C6 C2-(12x15) LL - 1.0 WY) 123 -25.8 -9.84 0.344 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C7 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 149.9 29.33 -12 0.405 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C8 C3-(15x22) 338.7 -35.6 -46.4 0.439 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C11 C3-(15x22) 203.5 21.37 -36.8 0.287 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C12 C3-(15x22) 194.3 20.4 -36.4 0.277 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C13 C3-(15x22) 188.4 19.78 -37.2 0.276 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C14 C3-(15x22) 214.1 22.47 -46.7 0.33 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C15 C3-(15x22) 55.35 -73.7 17.51 0.27 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C21 C3-(15x22) LL + 1.0 WY) 242.5 25.46 33.38 0.315 OK
Story6 C25 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 365.8 -14 43.89 0.255 OK
Page 31 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Story6 C35 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 337.8 38 -0.91 0.199 OK
Story6 C37 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 355.6 40 -15.8 0.209 OK
Story6 C42 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 161 -10.7 -15.6 0.28 OK
Story6 C43 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 161.4 -10.8 -15.3 0.281 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C44 C6-(D18) 138.2 -13.1 29.83 0.307 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story6 C53 C9-(20x12) 197.8 -18.9 32.24 0.372 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C1 C1-(15x10) 168.8 -14.5 -25.6 0.55 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C2 C2-(12x15) 167.9 -34.3 -13.4 0.463 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C3 C2-(12x15) 161.1 30.16 -14.9 0.44 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C4 C2-(12x15) 146.6 19.17 -11.7 0.342 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C5 C2-(12x15) 143.2 17.96 -11.5 0.331 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C6 C2-(12x15) 154.8 -28.9 -12.4 0.41 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C7 C2-(12x15) 179 31.87 -14.3 0.464 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C8 C3-(15x22) 396.2 -41.6 -48.3 0.499 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C12 C3-(15x22) 245.8 25.81 -41.9 0.34 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C13 C3-(15x22) 238.1 -25 -42.6 0.334 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C14 C3-(15x22) 266.8 28.01 -50.2 0.382 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C15 C3-(15x22) 55.01 -76.7 16.95 0.275 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Page 32 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C21 C3-(15x22) 305.4 32.06 36.87 0.384 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Story5 C44 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 206.7 -10.5 19.63 0.359 OK
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story5 C53 C9-(20x12) 239.5 -19.8 33.54 0.429 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C1 C1-(15x10) LL - 1.0 WY) 200.1 -16.1 -25.6 0.605 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C2 C2-(12x15) LL - 1.0 WY) 192.4 -36.9 -15.4 0.516 OK
Page 33 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C3 C2-(12x15) 197.8 33.69 -17.3 0.512 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C4 C2-(12x15) 177.6 21.79 -14.2 0.408 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C5 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 177 19.02 -14.2 0.397 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C6 C2-(12x15) LL - 1.0 WY) 186.7 -31.8 -14.9 0.476 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C7 C2-(12x15) LL + 1.0 WY) 216 33.07 -17.3 0.527 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C8 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) 454.1 -47.7 -49.9 0.56 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C12 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) 300.3 31.53 -42.6 0.393 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C13 C3-(15x22) 290.5 -30.5 -43.6 0.386 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C14 C3-(15x22) 321 33.7 -53.9 0.442 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C15 C3-(15x22) 46.83 -78.4 18.22 0.28 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Story4 C23 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 497 -49.7 -0.34 0.347 OK
Page 34 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Story4 C42 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 233.5 -11 -23.9 0.406 OK
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story4 C53 C9-(20x12) 281.5 -22.5 34.46 0.492 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C1 C1-(15x10) 231.9 -17.6 -24.9 0.669 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C2 C2-(12x15) 216.5 -39.1 17.32 0.565 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C3 C2-(12x15) 235.9 36.87 -19.7 0.585 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C4 C2-(12x15) 209.4 24.11 -16.8 0.476 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C5 C2-(12x15) 208.1 21.79 -16.6 0.464 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C6 C2-(12x15) 218.8 -34.4 -17.5 0.539 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C7 C2-(12x15) 247.3 35.87 -19.8 0.592 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C12 C3-(15x22) 353.1 -37.1 -46.2 0.452 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C13 C3-(15x22) 341.4 -35.8 -47.9 0.445 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C14 C3-(15x22) 376.4 -39.5 -56.7 0.501 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C15 C3-(15x22) 37.31 -80.3 19.03 0.286 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Page 35 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Story3 C24 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 570 -57 -3.75 0.397 OK
Story3 C42 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 270 -11.4 25.65 0.469 OK
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story3 C53 C9-(20x12) 324.2 -25.9 34.2 0.556 OK
LL - 1.0 WX)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C1 C1-(15x10) 263.9 -19.8 -27.5 0.756 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C2 C2-(12x15) 240.7 -46.6 -19.3 0.648 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C3 C2-(12x15) 274.6 37.6 -22 0.648 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C4 C2-(12x15) 242 29.27 -19.4 0.555 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C5 C2-(12x15) 240 27.41 -19.2 0.544 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Page 36 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C6 C2-(12x15) 251.5 -36.9 -20.1 0.604 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C7 C2-(12x15) 278.6 42.3 -22.3 0.677 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C8 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) 571.2 -60 -65.9 0.711 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C13 C3-(15x22) 392.5 -41.2 -51.6 0.503 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C14 C3-(15x22) 432.5 -48.6 -77.8 0.612 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C15 C3-(15x22) 253.2 -11.2 22.16 0.295 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C21 C3-(15x22) LL + 1.0 WY) 498.1 52.3 64.27 0.636 OK
Page 37 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C49 C8-(26x25) 713.4 153.2 235.6 0.584 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C50 C8-(26x25) 570.9 145.3 207.1 0.501 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C51 C8-(26x25) 560.6 126.8 207 0.483 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C52 C8-(26x25) 750 84.37 -246 0.561 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story2 C53 C9-(20x12) 367.7 -29.4 38.55 0.63 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C1 C1-(15x10) 301.5 -42.3 -95.3 1.611 Not OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C2 C2-(12x15) 280.2 -64 -30.2 0.863 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C3 C2-(12x15) 328.9 -52 37.88 0.891 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C4 C2-(12x15) 298.8 31.98 -41.1 0.776 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C5 C2-(12x15) 296.3 31.66 -40.8 0.77 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C6 C2-(12x15) 302.3 58.96 33.94 0.877 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C7 C2-(12x15) 325.6 59.72 -36.7 0.923 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C8 C3-(15x22) 650.7 -75.4 -126 0.954 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C14 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) 503 101.3 84.24 0.765 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C15 C3-(15x22) LL - 1.0 WY) 311.6 -11.1 27.27 0.364 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C21 C3-(15x22) 577.1 66.27 104.6 0.822 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C22 C5-(28x20) 888.7 -98.1 -307 0.753 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Page 38 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Story1 C37 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 805.6 -0 -96.7 0.474 OK
Story1 C42 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 346 -32.9 10.51 0.6 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C44 C6-(D18) 313.2 -10.3 -52.7 0.603 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C49 C8-(26x25) 802.4 190.2 274.6 0.679 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C50 C8-(26x25) 669.7 175.1 265.7 0.611 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C51 C8-(26x25) 669.3 164.8 266.1 0.604 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
Story1 C52 C8-(26x25) 845.2 100.2 329.1 0.686 OK
LL - 1.0 WY)
Story1 C53 C9-(20x12) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 0 0 0 O/S Not OK
G.F C1 C1-(15x10) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 357.4 -26.8 -22.4 0.963 OK
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
G.F C2 C2-(12x15) LL - 1.0 WY) 332.5 -16.3 -26.6 0.673 OK
G.F C3 C2-(12x15) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 388.6 1.588 -31.1 0.77 OK
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
G.F C7 C2-(12x15) 355.2 22.62 -28.4 0.739 OK
LL + 1.0 WY)
Page 39 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba
r%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
G.F C8 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 748 -7.01 -65.5 0.861 OK
G.F C9 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 627.5 -65.9 -20 0.72 OK
Accord - 3 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25
G.F C15 C3-(15x22) 364.9 15.83 31.93 0.426 OK
LL + 1.0 WX)
G.F C16 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 719.9 75.59 19.99 0.828 OK
G.F C20 C3-(15x22) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 703.9 -73.9 18.84 0.81 OK
G.F C22 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 1154 115.4 8.25 0.805 OK
G.F C23 C5-(28x20) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 851 -85.1 -1.11 0.593 OK
G.F C26 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 969.4 -109 -0.56 0.57 OK
G.F C29 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 919.6 2.306 -110 0.541 OK
G.F C30 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 968 -1.83 -116 0.569 OK
G.F C31 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 917.9 -103 -1.65 0.54 OK
G.F C33 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 896 100.8 -9.33 0.527 OK
G.F C36 C4-(28x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 862.9 0.342 -104 0.508 OK
G.F C42 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 384.5 -36.5 11.55 0.666 OK
G.F C43 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 376.3 -6.37 -35.7 0.651 OK
G.F C44 C6-(D18) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 378.6 -5.84 -36 0.655 OK
G.F C49 C8-(26x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 1042 117.2 6.042 0.649 OK
Page 40 of 46
PMM
Col. Ratio
l Reba r
%
kip kip-ft kip-ft
G.F C52 C8-(26x25) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 1058 119 -14.5 0.659 OK
G.F C53 C9-(20x12) Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) 0 0 0 O/S Not OK
Note: The TABLE: Concrete Column PMM Envelope’s red filled cells values indicate the failure of the
corresponding column due to the non-compliance of ‘column load (P)-Moment in Major Axis (M)-Moment
in Minor Axis (M) Ratios’ or, to the non-compliance of provided Rebar Percentage. Here, column labelled as
“C53”-section size: 20// x 12//, section ID: C9, has failed in two consecutive stories because of i.) Over
stressing due to provided percentage of rebar as compared to the section & ii.) Governing column load here;
both of the phenomena indicating the corresponding column section needs to be retrofitted to RC9-
(28”x20”) and RC1- (23”x18”). Please, also note that, since, this table has been extracted after design,
that’s why, the columns P, Mmajor & Mminor shown with no value caused O/S; specifically, it’s O/S # 5. In
case of type: O/S # 5, P, Mmajor
& Mminor values will be shown zero by ETABS; & this O/S type causes if the column factored axial load
exceeds Eulers force.
Page 41 of 46
V. Shear Wall Evaluation
TABLE: Check of Adequacy of Shear Walls based on Nominal Strength
Maximum
Effectiv Area Nominal
Ultimate Compressive
e Area of Yield Axial
Story Pier Load Axial strength of
Loc. of shear provi strength strength Remarks
/Level ID Combo Force Wall
wall (Ag- ded of steel with
from Materials,
As ) steel bending
ETABS
Pu f/m Ae As fy P0
Kip Ksi in2 in2 Ksi Kip
Accord 3
(1.05 * D.L
Complia
GF P1 + 1.25 * Bot. 200.6 4.297 4580.6 9.4 60.0 11417.3
nt
L.L + 1.0 *
WX
Accord 2
(1.05 * D.L
Complia
GF P2 + 1.25 * Bot. 286.0 4.297 12836.9 15.1 60.0 31347.2
nt
L.L - 1.0 *
WX)
Accord 5
(1.05 * D.L
Complia
GF P3 + 1.25 * Bot. 538.0 4.297 12836.9 15.1 60.0 31347.2
nt
L.L - 1.0 *
Wy)
Accord 2
(1.05 * D.L
Complia
GF P4 + 1.25 * Bot. 161.0 4.297 12836.9 15.1 60.0 31347.2
nt
L.L - 1.0 *
WX)
Accord 3
(1.05 * D.L
Complia
GF P5 + 1.25 * Bot. 189.0 4.297 4580.6 9.4 60.0 11416.5
nt
L.L + 1.0 *
WX
TABLE: Check of Adequacy of Shear Walls due to Shear Force
Area Shear
Major Shear
Wall of Modul Strength Nominl
Story Pier Wall Steel Shear Strength
Heig provi ar provided Shear Remarks
/Level ID Length Ratio from provided
ht ded Ratio by Strength
ETABS by Rebar
steel Concrete
ft ft in2 Kip Kip Kip Kip
GF P1 3.75 8.5 9.42 0.025 8 63.69 947.7 54236.2 55184 Compliant
GF P2 10.5 8.5 15.12 0.014 8 139 2653.5 87091.2 89745 Compliant
GF P3 10.5 8.5 15.12 0.014 8 145 2653.5 87091.2 89745 Compliant
GF P4 10.5 8.5 15.12 0.014 8 142 2653.5 87091.2 89745 Compliant
GF P5 3.75 8.5 9.42 0.025 8 56 947.7 54144.0 55092 Compliant
Page 42 of 46
VI. Beam Evaluation
Table: Adequacy of Beams as per ACCORD Standard considering live load of 42 psf
Story No of Beams Remarks
Passed Deficient
Roof 100% Nil Ok
8th floor 100% Nil Ok
3rd floor 100% Nil Ok
2nd floor 100% Nil Ok
1st floor 100% Nil Ok
GF 100% Nil Ok
VII. Typical Slab Evaluation
Figure: SAFE Slab Analysis Output Moments for ACCORD Load Combination -1
Note: From the above analysis, it can be assessed that the floor slab is safe under live load 42 psf with structural dead
load. Floor slab is restricted to carry below live load 42 psf in all floor. From the legend bar of SAFE slab analysis for
load combination ACCORD -1: (1.2 x DL + 1.6 x LL), its limited to such a way that, it can clearly be seen that, the
slab is OKAY against the governing moment.
Page 43 of 46
Figure: SAFE Slab Analysis Output Punching Design Indications for ACCORD Load Combination -1
Note: The punching shear design also showing there’s no concern of shear failure of slab as all the stiffened locations
are showing N/C. So, the slabs provided thickness is OKAY.
8.2. Retrofitting design check for failure column.
TABLE: Retrofitted Concrete Column PMM Envelope

Lab M PMM Ratio or
el Story Section Loc P M Major Minor PMM Combo Rebar %
kip kip-ft kip-ft
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL +
484.74 50.51 -69.17 0.588
RC1- Top 1.25 LL - 1.0 WY)
C1 Story1 (23x18) Bot 275.5 Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL +
514.75 54.03 0.994
tom 1 1.25 LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL +
575.04 127.62 -9.20 0.526
RC9- Top 1.25 LL + 1.0 WY)
C53 Story1 (28x20) Bot Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL +
586.78 -134.38 6.97 0.542
tom 1.25 LL + 1.0 WY)
Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL +
561.71 53.36 -90.37 0.685
RC1- Top 1.25 LL - 1.0 WY)
C1 G.F (23x18) Bot Accord - 5 ( 1.05 DL +
564.80 -41.79 60.72 0.649
tom 1.25 LL - 1.0 WY)
Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL +
586.78 -134.38 6.97 0.542
RC9- Top 1.25 LL - 1.0 WX)
C53 G.F (28x20) Bot Accord - 2 ( 1.05 DL +
591.99 -137.53 14.25 0.553
tom 1.25 LL - 1.0 WX)
9. References:
1. ACI 437R-03, Strength Evaluation of Existing Concrete Buildings, American Concrete Institution.
2. ACI 318-99, Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete, American Concrete Institution, 1999.
3. ACI 562, Code Requirements for Evaluation, American Concrete Institution.
4. ASTM E2018-08, Standard Guide for Property Condition Assessment: Baseline Property Condition Assessment
Process.
5. American Society for Testing and Materials, 2008.
6. BNBC - 2006, Bangladesh National Building Code.

Detailed Engineering Assessment

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Detailed Engineering Assessment

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Table of Contents

Comments on DEA report:

We recommended following steps need to carry out:

 Uncontrolled loading on cantilever

Table 2-1: Physical Observations Remedial Plan

2. Provide barrier to resist the entrance

Structural Reinforced Concrete Frame Structure

Number of 09 Storied building

Floor usage  Main production building

2.0. Input parameter of the DEA report:

2.1. Structural System:

No of Story: Existing 09 storied building having a mezzanine floor.

2 Cylinder Strength of Concrete for f’c 4297 psi

5 Cylinder Strength of Concrete for Slab f’c 2873 psi

2.2. Acceptance Criteria for the Evaluation of Linear Analysis:

2.2.1. Code and Practice:

3.2. Live load (L):

Mezzanine floor Live Load 2

1st Floor Live Load 2

2nd Floor Live Load 2

3rd Floor Live Load 2

4th Floor Live Load 2

5th Floor Live Load 2

6th floor Live Load 2

7th floor Live Load 2

8th floor Live Load 2

Roof Live Load 1.5

water tank bottom Live Load 14.94

4. Wind load (W):

Basic wind speed, Vb 210 kmph

4.1. UBC 94 Auto Wind Load Calculation

Top Story = MRT

1] P = (Ce,wind Cq,wind + Ce,lee Cq,lee)qsIw

4.2. Auto Wind Load Calculation

Top Story = MRT

1] P = (Ce,wind Cq,wind + Ce,lee Cq,lee)qsIw

Applied Story Forces

5.0. METHOD OF ANALYSIS:

6.0. Load Definition for FEM Analysis:

7.0. Load Combination: Accord Combination

8.0. Method of analysis and acceptance criteria:

8.1. Check for Serviceability Requirements

OHWTB 120.75 Accord -1 (1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) X 0.340751 2.89 Compliant

MRT 135.25 Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0 Y 1.41 3.24 Compliant

MRB 126.75 Accord - 4 ( 1.05 DL + 1.25 LL + 1.0 Y 1.35 3.04 Compliant

Table: Torsional Displacement Check for Wind Load (Wx)

Table: Torsional Displacement Check for Wind Load (Wy)

1. General Info 2. Punching Check 3. Bearing Check

B ft x ft x in Kip Psi Psi KSF KSF

1. General Info 2. Punching Check 3. Bearing Check

B ft x ft x in Kip Psi Psi KSF KSF

1. General Info 2. Punching Check 3. Bearing Check

B ft x ft x in Kip Psi Psi KSF KSF

1. General Info 2. Punching Check 3. Bearing Check

B ft x ft x in Kip Psi Psi KSF KSF

1. General Info 2. Punching Check 3. Bearing Check

B ft x ft x in Kip Psi Psi KSF KSF

1. General Info 2. Punching Check 3. Bearing Check

B ft x ft x in Kip Psi Psi KSF KSF

TABLE: Check of Adequacy of Shear Walls due to Shear Force

Story No of Beams Remarks

VII. Typical Slab Evaluation

8.2. Retrofitting design check for failure column.

TABLE: Retrofitted Concrete Column PMM Envelope