Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3.1 INTRODUCTION
The following example illustrates the design of a single span T-Beam Bridge Structure using the
AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specification 1998.
The T-Beam Bridge should be designed in accordance with the following parameters:
It shall be a reinforced concrete 2 lane bridge with an overall width of 12.27m and a span of 12.60m
between centreline of bearings. The bridge shall be designed to carry pedestrians on each side and the
HL93 live load. Allowance should be made for a bituminous overlay of 50mm with an additional
allowance of 50mm for future overlays. Strength of concrete shall be taken as 28MPa cylinder strength and
reinforcement yield strength of 500MPa.
The overall dimensions of the structure and those used in future calculation are shown listed below.
No.of Girders = 5
C to C Girder Spacing = 2.4 m
Clear span Lc= 12 m
No. of spans = 1
Width of abutment= 0.6 m
Center to center of abutment perpendicular to Support S = L = 12.6 m
Total length of superstructure = 13.2 m
Clear width between barriers = 8 m
No. of Barriers = 2
Barrier width = 0.385 m
No. of Walkways = 2
Width of walkway = 1.75 m
Total width of superstructure= 12.27 m
No. of lanes = 2
Cross fall= 2 %
Skewness angle= 0 Deg.
Overhang = 1335 mm
Critical load combinations are selected by inspection and are lised below:
DC- DW-
DC-MIN MAX DW-MIN MAX LL
Strength 1 0.9 1.25 0.65 1.5 1.75
DC DW LL
Service 1 1 1 1
Service 2 1 1 1.3
Service 3 1 1 0.8
Fatigue 0 0 0.75
For the purpose of this example the deck thickness shall be taken as 220mm.
Stiffness parameters and distribution factors are calculated from the given internal and external beam
dimensions listed below. The formulas used in these calculations are located in the AASHTO LRFD
specification as indicated against each item below.
AASHTO LRFD
Stiffness Parameters Reference Stiffness Parameters
Multiple Lanes Loaded LRFD Table 4.6.2.2.2d-1 and Multiple Lanes Loaded
Dm = 0.69148 ………. 2b-1
LRFD Table 4.6.2.2.3a-1 and ………… Dm = 0.458352
Ds = 0.81636 ………. 3b-1 ………… Ds = 0.408178
Applicable Distribution Factors Applicable Distribution Factors
3.8 LOADING
The tables which follow, contain the envelope of moments and shears of the evenly distributed permanent
loads at 20th points along the girder, for both the Serviceability Limit State and the Strength Limit State.
These have been summarised for both the internal and external girder. Each Limit State is factored in
accordance with the relevant factors outlined above.
According to AASHTO LRFD Section 4.5.1 dead load of and on the deck may be distributed equally to all
girders.
The wearing surface DL includes an allowance of 100mm AC in total.
The Tables which follow, contain the envelope of moments and shears of the distributed pedestrian loads at
20th points along the girder, for both the Serviceability limit State and the Strength Limit State. These have
been summarized for both the internal and external girder. Each Limit State is factored in accordance with
the relevant factors outlined above. The pedestrian load has been distributed in accordance with the Lever
Rule of AASHTO LFRD Section 4.6.2.2.1. Accordingly all pedestrian load is taken by the external girder.
For ease of calculation these tables DO NOT contain the permanent load elements which will change with
each iteration.
Accordingly these appropriately factored permanent load elements of the combinations will be added as
the calculations proceed.
Designers are advised that the design lane values tabulated below were obtained by use of the QConBridge
program developed and freely distributed by the Washington State Department of Transport, Bridge and
Structures Office. Advice on freely obtaining this software is included in the ACCRA Bridge Design
Manual.
The QConBridge program builds into the output the appropriate range of load factors and permits the
designer to edit these to a particular design case.
1) Strength 1 - 1.25 Girder DL + 1.25 Barrier L + 1.5 Wearing Course + 1.75 HL93 + 1.75 Ped L
2) Serviceability 2 - 1.0 Girder DL + 1.0 Barrier DL + 1.0 Wearing Course + 1.3 HL93 + 1.3 Ped L
Serviceability Limit State Combination Serviceability 2
Internal Girder
Span Min Max
Ratio Distance Min Shear Max Shear Moment Moment
kN kN kNm kNm
0.00 0.00 0.00 612.68 0.00 0.00
0.05 0.63 -10.39 564.15 0.00 325.72
0.10 1.26 -21.09 515.93 0.00 611.33
0.15 1.89 -33.19 468.02 0.00 856.85
0.20 2.52 -49.81 420.42 0.00 1062.26
0.25 3.15 -66.73 373.13 0.00 1226.95
0.30 3.78 -83.97 326.15 0.00 1352.17
0.35 4.41 -101.51 281.09 0.00 1446.41
0.40 5.04 -119.37 237.20 0.00 1518.67
0.45 5.67 -137.54 194.35 0.00 1550.27
0.50 6.30 -156.02 156.02 0.00 1541.90
0.55 6.93 -194.35 137.54 0.00 1550.27
0.60 7.56 -237.20 119.37 0.00 1518.67
0.65 8.19 -281.09 101.51 0.00 1446.41
0.70 8.82 -326.15 83.97 0.00 1352.17
0.75 9.45 -373.13 66.73 0.00 1226.95
0.80 10.08 -420.42 49.81 0.00 1062.26
0.85 10.71 -468.02 33.19 0.00 856.85
0.90 11.34 -515.93 21.09 0.00 611.33
0.95 11.97 -564.15 10.39 0.00 325.72
1.00 12.60 -612.68 0.00 0.00 0.00
3.9 Design
The design of the T-Beam works through a series of steps. These steps are summarised as follows:
no of reo layers = 3
c/c layer spacing = 80 mm
dr3 = 787 mm
dr2 = 867 mm
dr1 = 947 mm
d= 867 mm
f'c = 32 mPa
Fsy = 500 mPa
Ec = 28600 mPa
Es = 200000 mPa
n(ST) = 6.99
n(LT) = 13.99
b1 = 0.821
Gross section:
Ig=bh3/12= 6.46E+10 mm4
External Girder:
Slab width B = 2535 mm
Slab Depth D = 1000 mm
Reo. Cover = 25 mm
Reo Dia. = 32 mm
Ast = 5630 mm2
Ligs = 12 mm
no of reo layers = 3
c/c layer spacing = 80 mm
dr3 = 787 mm
dr2 = 867 mm
dr1 = 947 mm
d= 867 mm
f'c = 32 mPa
Fsy = 500 mPa
Ec = 28600 mPa
Es = 200000 mPa
n(ST) = 6.99
n(LT) = 13.99
b1 = 0.821
Gross section:
Ig=bh3/12= 6.57E+10 mm4
The following calculations determine the required section properties of the T-Beam in accordance with the
AASHTO LRFD. These section properties include:
1. Cracked T-Beam section moment of inertia. This is required for both live load and permanent loads.
2. Cracking moment. This is used in estimating the effective inertia used in deflection calculations.
3. The effective moment of inertia for both short and long term loads.
Internal Girder
where :
a= 1200
b = 44993.6
c = -4E+07
And x = 163 mm
Neutral axis is in the Flange
Icr (ST) = 2.58E+10 mm^4
External Girder
The depth x to the neutral axis of a
cracked section is:
x = -nAs/b + { ( nAs/b)^2 + 2nAsd/b}^0.5
where :
a= 1200
b = 44993.6
c = -4E+07
And x = 163 mm
Neutral axis is in the Flange
Icr (ST) = 2.32E+10 mm^4
Internal Girder
where :
a= 1200
b = 89987.2
c = -8E+07
And x = 220 mm
The neutral axis is in the web - x taken as flange ts
This yeilds a Icr (Long Term) = 4.62E+10 mm^4
External Girder
where :
a= 1200
b= 89987.2
c= -8E+07
And x = 220 mm
The neutral axis is in the web - x taken as flange ts
This yeilds a Icr (Long Term) = 4.62E+10 mm^4
Internal Girder:
yt= 710.23 mm
LRFD Art 5.4.2.6 fr= 3.56 Mpa
LRFD Eq.5.7.3.6.2-2; Mcr = frIg/yt= 324.23 KNm/m
External Girder:
yt= 716.48 mm
LRFD Art 5.4.2.6 fr= 3.56 Mpa
LRFD Eq.5.7.3.6.2-2; Mcr = frIg/yt= 326.60 KNm/m
(c) Section Effective Moment of Inertia for both Long and Short term Loads
Internal Girder:
SLS Max Moment Ma = 1550.27 kNm
(Mcr/Ma)^3 = 0.01
Ief (Short Term) = 2.61E+10 mm4
Ief (Long Term) = 4.64E+10 mm4
External Girder:
SLS Max Moment Ma = 1370.90 kNm
(Mcr/Ma)^3 = 0.01
Ief (Short Term) = 2.37E+10 mm4
Ief (Long Term) = 4.65E+10 mm4
Internal girder dc = 50 mm
ys = 133 mm
A= 12635 mm
External girder dc = 50 mm
ys = 133 mm
A= 12635 mm
Because the serviceability limit state cracking criteria usually governs the quantity of flexural
reinforcement required, this is an appropriate stage in the design process to select the actual amount of
reinforcement.
Reinforcement Area
(Required Reinforcement Bar No. known)
INPUT - Diameter of Reinforcement Bars 32
X-Area of Reinforcement Bars 804
INPUT - Known Number of Bars 8
Required Reinforcement Area 6434
mm^2/m
Area = 6434 i.e. = 32 @ 90
Reinforcement Area
(Required Reinforcement Bar No. known)
INPUT - Diameter of Reinforcement Bars 32
X-Area of Reinforcement Bars 804
INPUT - Known Number of Bars 7
Required Reinforcement Area 5630
mm^2/m
Area = 5630 i.e. = 32 @ 90
The reinforcement for the strength limit state maximum moment is calculated by considering only the
tension steel (compression steel is conservatively ignored). This is done by solving the second degree
polynomial in terms of As, developed from LRFD art 5.7.3.2.2-1 as follows:
This is the Quadratic solution in the form of:[ -b + { b^2 - 4ac }^0.5 ] / 2a
Where:
a= 1.72
b= -3.90E+05
c= 2.06E+09
Therefore:
Required ULS As = 5407 mm^2/m
( Note: SLS case governs )
a = b1*c = 49.28 mm
d= 867 mm
c/d = 0.07 < 0.42
OK, Under-reinforced
Check greater than minimum is used (ie greater than 1.2 Mcr or approx 0.03*f"c/fy):
Ag = 824400 mm^2
r = As/Ag = 0.00309
r min = 0.03*f"c/fy = 0.00192
Asmin = 1582.85 mm^2
OK, Sufficient Reinforcement
Where:
a= 1.63
b= -3.90E+05
c= 1.82E+09
Therefore:
Required ULS As = 4753 mm^2/m
( Note: SLS case governs )
Check greater than minimum is used (ie greater than 1.2 Mcr or approx 0.03*f"c/fy):
Ag = 824400 mm^2
r = As/Ag = 0.00683
r min = 0.03*f"c/fy = 0.00192
Asmin = 1582.85 mm^2
OK, Sufficient Reinforcement
3.9.5 Check the strength limit state shear capacity and calculate the
additional shear reinforcement required.
External quarter of Girder:
Maximum (ULS) shear = Vu = 815.65 kN/m
Vn max = 0.25*fc*bv*dv = 2372.11 kN/m
OK,Shear required < PermissibleMaximum!
Vc = 0.083*2*fc^.5*bv*dv = 321.15 kN/m
NOT GOOD, Require shear REO
Shear reo spacing = 150 mm
No. of legs at each spacing = 2
Area of transverse reo per leg = 106 mm^2 / leg
Vs = 275 kN/m
Note: 12 mm dia bar; As = 113mm^2 & 16 mm dia bar; As = 201mm^2
Minimum shear Reinforcement = 26.7626 mm^2 / leg @ S
OK, Shear steel provided greater than minimum!
Span Max
Ratio Distance Max Shear 0.5 Vs Moment Min As
kN kN kNm mm^2
0.00 0.00 815.65 137.359905 0.00 1538
0.05 0.63 751.23 137.359905 433.01 2628
0.10 1.26 687.22 137.359905 812.61 3567
0.15 1.89 623.64 137.359905 1138.68 4354
0.20 2.52 560.48 137.359905 1411.35 4990
0.25 3.15 497.73 137.359905 1630.68 5475
0.30 3.78 435.40 49.0493654 1796.68 5986
0.35 4.41 375.65 49.0493654 1921.11 6208
0.40 5.04 317.49 49.0493654 2016.41 6350
0.45 5.67 260.71 49.0493654 2059.07 6345
0.50 6.30 210.03 49.0493654 2047.70 6200
0.55 6.93 260.71 49.0493654 2059.07 6345
0.60 7.56 317.49 49.0493654 2016.41 6350
0.65 8.19 375.65 49.0493654 1921.11 6208
0.70 8.82 435.40 49.0493654 1796.68 5986
0.75 9.45 497.73 137.359905 1630.68 5475
0.80 10.08 560.48 137.359905 1411.35 4990
0.85 10.71 623.64 137.359905 1138.68 4354
0.90 11.34 687.22 137.359905 812.61 3567
0.95 11.97 751.23 137.359905 433.01 2628
1.00 12.60 815.65 137.359905 0.00 1538
Span Max
Ratio Distance Max Shear 0.5 Vs Moment Min As
kN kN kNm mm^2
0.00 0.00 594.28 75.8680003 0.00 1169
0.05 0.63 543.42 75.8680003 373.87 2121
0.10 1.26 492.77 75.8680003 703.20 2946
0.15 1.89 442.34 75.8680003 987.91 3645
0.20 2.52 392.11 75.8680003 1228.07 4217
0.25 3.15 342.09 75.8680003 1423.74 4663
0.30 3.78 292.28 5.81655883 1574.92 5123
0.35 4.41 243.76 5.81655883 1689.39 5341
0.40 5.04 196.03 5.81655883 1775.41 5480
0.45 5.67 149.00 5.81655883 1817.40 5495
0.50 6.30 105.01 5.81655883 1814.44 5389
0.55 6.93 149.00 5.81655883 1817.40 5495
0.60 7.56 196.03 5.81655883 1775.41 5480
0.65 8.19 243.76 5.81655883 1689.39 5341
0.70 8.82 292.28 5.81655883 1574.92 5123
0.75 9.45 342.09 75.8680003 1423.74 4663
0.80 10.08 392.11 75.8680003 1228.07 4217
0.85 10.71 442.34 75.8680003 987.91 3645
0.90 11.34 492.77 75.8680003 703.20 2946
0.95 11.97 543.42 75.8680003 373.87 2121
1.00 12.60 594.28 75.8680003 0.00 1169
For the External Girder the actual reo stress = fs = n*M*(d-x)/Icr = 108.54 Mpa
Since this is less than the allowable range, fatigue is
deemed OK.
To assist in determining cut off points for steel reinforcing it is necessary to determine governing steel
requirements for the Strength I Limit State, Serviceability II Limit State and Combined Flexure and Shear
requirements.
This is achieved by plotting envelopes of steel requirements for each criteria at 20th points along the girder
and finding those which govern. The governing requirements are shown in the table "Minimum Reo
Envelope" table.
7000
Main reinforcement area provided = 6434 sq mm ie. 9 / 32 dia bars
6000 Reinforcement
Reinforcement Area Area
Envelope Envelope for
For Internal Girder External
Combined Flexural and
5000 Shear Girder shown for
REINFORCEMENT AREA (sq mm)
4000
Theoretica Area of 6 / 32 dia
l bars
cut-off Strength Limit State Flexural
reinforcement
3000 point
Note: Because theoretical cut-off of 3 bars is
Servicability Limit State close to the beam end, each bar will extend the full
Flexural Reinforcement length
2000 of the T-Beam.
1000
Strength Limit State
minimum
Flexural Reinforcement
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12