Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PRINCIPLES OF FLIGHT
- 081 04 Stability
• Static and Dynamic Stability
24/06/2020 1
Principles of Flight
This Presentation
• Static and Dynamic Stability
– Location of Centre of Gravity
– The Cm vs α graph
– Manoeuvering Stability
24/06/2020 2
Principles of Flight
Syllabus Progress
POF 1-3 POF 4-6 POF 7-9 POF 10-12 POF 13-15
POF 16-18 POF 19-21 POF 22-24 POF 25-27 POF 28-30
POF 31-33 POF 34-36 POF 37-39 POF 40-42 POF 43-45
POF 46-48 POF 49-51 POF 52-54 OPS 55-57 OPS 58-60
24 June 2020 3
Principles of Flight
𝑀 = 𝐶𝑀. 𝑄. 𝑆. (𝑀𝐴𝐶)
Or,
𝑀
𝐶𝑀 =
𝑄. 𝑆. (𝑀𝐴𝐶)
The pitching moment coefficients contributed by all the various components of the aircraft are
summed up and plotted versus lift coefficient (angle of attack).
Study of the plots of CM versus CL is a convenient way to relate the static longitudinal stability of
an aeroplane.
24 June 2020 4
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 5
Principles of Flight
• If the aeroplane were disturbed to some higher CL (point y), a negative or nose-down
pitching moment is developed which tends to decrease AoA back to the trim point.
• If the aeroplane were disturbed to some lower CL (point x), a positive or nose-up pitching
moment is developed which tends to increase the angle of attack back to the trim point.
The degree of static longitudinal stability is indicated by the slope of the curve (red line).
24 June 2020 6
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 7
Principles of Flight
An aeroplane which demonstrates a positive slope of the CM vs CL curve (blue line) would be
unstable. If the unstable aeroplane were subject to any disturbance from equilibrium at the
trim point, the changes in pitching moment would only magnify the disturbance.
• When the unstable aeroplane is disturbed to some higher CL a positive change in CM occurs
which would illustrate a tendency for continued, greater displacement.
• When the unstable aeroplane is disturbed to some lower CL a negative change in CM takes
place which tends to create continued displacement.
24 June 2020 8
Principles of Flight
The curve of CM vs CL will show a good stable slope at low values of CL (high speed).
Increasing CL gives a slight decrease in the negative slope hence a decrease in stability occurs.
With continued increase in CL, the slope becomes zero and neutral stability exists. Eventually,
the slope becomes positive and the aeroplane becomes unstable or “pitch-up” results.
Remember, at any lift coefficient, the static stability of the aeroplane is depicted by the slope of
the curve of CM vs CL.
24 June 2020 9
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 10
Principles of Flight
𝑀
𝐶𝑀 =
𝑄. 𝑆. (𝑀𝐴𝐶)
Thus, any pitching moment coefficient (CM) - regardless of source - has the common
denominator of dynamic pressure (Q), wing area (S), and wing mean aerodynamic chord (MAC).
24 June 2020 11
Principles of Flight
All changes in lift coefficient effectively take place at the wing aerodynamic centre. Thus, if the
wing experiences some change in lift coefficient, the pitching moment created will be a direct
function of the relative location of the AC and CG.
24 June 2020 12
Principles of Flight
Stability is given by the development of restoring moments. As the wing AC is forward of the
CG, the wing contributes with an unstable pitching moment to the aircraft
Since the wing is the predominating aerodynamic surface of an aeroplane, any change in the
wing contribution may produce a significant change in the aeroplane stability.
24 June 2020 13
Principles of Flight
In fact, an increase in angle of attack produces an increase in the unstable pitching moment
without the development of lift. The pressure distribution which creates this unstable moment
on the body is shown below. An increase in angle of attack causes an increase in the unstable
pitching moment but a negligible increase in lift.
24 June 2020 14
Principles of Flight
The tail moment is determined by the CG position and the effectiveness of the tailplane. For a
given moment arm (CG position), the effectiveness of the tailplane is dependent upon:
• Longitudinal dihedral.
24 June 2020 15
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 16
Principles of Flight
If the CG is arbitrarily set at 30% MAC, the contribution of the wing alone is destabilizing, as
indicated by the positive slope of CM vs CL. The combination of the wing and fuselage increases
the instability. The contribution of the tail alone is highly stabilizing from the large negative
slope of the curve. The contribution of the tail must be sufficiently stabilizing so that the
complete configuration will exhibit positive static stability.
24 June 2020 17
Principles of Flight
The vertical location of the thrust line defines the direct contributions to stability. If thrust line
is below the CG, a thrust increase will produce a nose-up moment and a destabilizing effect.
24 June 2020 18
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 19
Principles of Flight
The deflection of the slipstream by the normal force at the propeller tends to increase the
downwash at the horizontal tail and reduce the contribution to stability.
24 June 2020 20
Principles of Flight
The combined direct and indirect power effects contribute to a general reduction of static
stability at high power, high CL and low dynamic pressure. It is generally true that any
aeroplane will experience the lowest level of static longitudinal stability under these conditions.
Because of the greater magnitude of both direct and indirect power effects, the propeller
powered aeroplane usually experiences a greater effect than the jet powered aeroplane.
24 June 2020 21
Principles of Flight
As the CG is gradually moved aft, the aeroplane static stability decreases, then becomes neutral
then unstable.
The CG position which produces zero slope and neutral static stability is referred to as the
“neutral point”. The neutral point may be imagined as the effective aerodynamic centre of the
entire aeroplane configuration.
With the CG at the neutral point, all changes in net lift effectively occur at that point and no
change in pitching moment results.
The neutral point defines the most aft CG position without static instability..
24 June 2020 22
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 23
Principles of Flight
Coffee Break
24 June 2020 24
Principles of Flight
• In order to trim the aeroplane at point (1) a certain amount of up elevator is required, and
zero stick force is obtained with the use of the trim tab. To trim the aeroplane for higher
speeds corresponding to points (2) and (3), less and less aircraft nose-up tab is required.
• When the aeroplane is properly trimmed, a push force is required to increase airspeed and a
pull force is required to decrease airspeed, resulting in stick force stability with stable “feel”
for airspeed.
24 June 2020 25
Principles of Flight
• Thus, on decreasing stick-force stability it is evident that smaller stick forces are necessary to
displace the aeroplane from the trim speed.
24 June 2020 26
Principles of Flight
• If the CG is aft of the neutral point, stick force instability will exist, e.g. the aeroplane will
require a push force at a lower speed or a pull force at a higher speed.
24 June 2020 27
Principles of Flight
Manoeuvering Stability
When the pilot pitches the aircraft, it rotates about the CG and the tailplane is subject to a
pitching velocity. Due to the pitching velocity in manoeuvring flight, the longitudinal stability of
the aeroplane is slightly greater than in steady flight conditions.
24 June 2020 28
Principles of Flight
Manoeuvering Stability
• The tailplane experiences an upwards component of airflow due to its downwards pitching
velocity. The vector addition of this vertical component to the TAS provides an increase in
effective angle of attack of the tail, which creates an increase in tail lift, opposing the nose-
up pitch displacement.
• Since the negative pitching moment opposes the nose-up pitch displacement but is due to
the nose-up pitching motion, the effect is a damping in pitch (aerodynamic damping).
• An increase in TAS, for a given pitching velocity, decreases the angle of attack due to pitching
velocity.
24 June 2020 29
Principles of Flight
Manoeuvering Stability
The pitching moment from aerodynamic damping will give greater stability in manoeuvres than
is apparent in steady flight. The CG position when the tail moment would be the same as the
wing moment during manoeuvring is known as the manoeuvre point, and this “neutral point”
will be further aft than for 1g flight.
In most cases the manoeuvre point will not be a critical item, if the aeroplane demonstrates
static stability in 1g flight, it will have stability in manoeuvring flight.
24 June 2020 30
Principles of Flight
• The aeroplane with positive manoeuvring stability should demonstrate a steady increase in
stick force with increase in load factor or “g”.
• The manoeuvring stick force gradient - or stick force per “g” - must be positive but should be
of the proper magnitude. The stick force gradient must not be excessively high or the
aeroplane will be difficult and tiring to manoeuvre. Also, the stick force gradient must not be
too low or the aeroplane may be overstressed inadvertently when light control forces exist.
24 June 2020 31
Principles of Flight
• As the CG moves aft, the stick force gradient decreases with decreasing manoeuvring
stability and the lower limit of stick force gradient may be reached.
24 June 2020 32
Principles of Flight
• Thus, a decrease in manoeuvring stick force stability can be expected with increased
altitude.
24 June 2020 33
Principles of Flight
• If a spring is added to the control system and it will tend to centre the stick and provide a
force increment depending on stick displacement.
• When the control system has a fixed gearing between stick position and surface deflection,
the centring spring provides a contribution to stick force stability according to stick position.
24 June 2020 34
Principles of Flight
• A down spring added to a control system is a means of increasing airspeed stick force
stability without a change in aeroplane static stability.
• It consists of a long pre-loaded spring attached to the control system which tends to rotate
the elevators down (aircraft nose-down). The effect of the down spring is to contribute an
increment of pull force independent of control deflection or airspeed.
24 June 2020 35
Principles of Flight
• The bobweight is an effective device for improving stick force stability. It consists of an
eccentric mass attached to the control system which, in unaccelerated flight, contributes an
increment of pull force identical to the down spring.
• A bobweight added to the control system of an aeroplane produces an effect identical to the
down spring. The bobweight will increase the airspeed stick force gradient and increase the
feel for airspeed.
24 June 2020 36
Principles of Flight
• Dynamic Stability will exist when the amplitude of motion decreases with time, and;
24 June 2020 37
Principles of Flight
The required degree of dynamic stability is usually specified by the time necessary for the
amplitude to reduce to one-half the original value: the time to damp to half-amplitude.
The longitudinal dynamic stability of an aeroplane consists of two basic modes of oscillation:
While the longitudinal motion of the aeroplane may consist of a combination of these modes,
the characteristics of each mode are sufficiently distinct that each oscillatory tendency may be
studied separately.
24 June 2020 38
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 39
Principles of Flight
• Pitch attitude;
• Altitude and;
• Airspeed, but;
• Nearly constant angle of attack (not much change in load factor).
The phugoid is a gradual interchange of potential and kinetic energy about some equilibrium
airspeed and altitude.
The period of oscillation in the phugoid is between 1 and 2 minutes. Since the pitch rate is quite
low and only negligible changes in angle of attack take place, damping of the phugoid is weak.
However, such weak damping does not necessarily have any great consequence. Since the
period of oscillation is so great, long period oscillation is easily controlled by the pilot.
24 June 2020 40
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 41
Principles of Flight
Short period oscillation at high dynamic pressures with large changes in angle of attack could
produce severe ‘g’ loads (large changes in load factor).
Short periods that correspond closely with the normal pilot response lag time, e.g. 1 or 2
seconds or less. There is the possibility that an attempt by the pilot to forcibly damp an
oscillation may actually reinforce the oscillation (PIO) and produce instability.
If short period oscillation occurs, release the controls; the aeroplane is designed to demonstrate
the necessary damping.
24 June 2020 42
Principles of Flight
The short period oscillation can generate damaging flight loads due to the rapid changes in ‘g’
loading, and it is adversely affected by pilot response lag (PIO).
It has been stated that the amplitude of the oscillations are decreased by pitch damping, so the
problems of dynamic stability can become acute under the conditions of flight where reduced
aerodynamic damping occurs.
High altitude, and consequently low density (high TAS), reduces aerodynamic damping.
24 June 2020 43
Principles of Flight
An aircraft in such a condition can appear to be switching between upward and downward
directions.
24 June 2020 44
Principles of Flight
This will make them more difficult to fly than a stable aircraft. However by being unstable it
makes them a much better and more maneuverable fighter.
By being unstable, they can turn, roll, and climb easier and much more rapidly than a stable
aircraft. The flight computers constantly monitor and control the aircraft’s attitude.
24 June 2020 45
Principles of Flight
Questions
24 June 2020 46
Principles of Flight
Revisions (1)
The distance between the ___
Aft ___ minimum
CG limit and the neutral point gives the required _________
margin
static stability ________.
24 June 2020 47
Principles of Flight
Revisions (2)
Noticeable changes in static stability can occur at high CL (low speed) if:
If the thrust line is below the CG, a thrust increase will produce a _______ up moment
positive or nose ___
destabilizing
and the effect is ___________.
24 June 2020 48
Principles of Flight
Revisions (3)
positive or nose ___
If the thrust line is below the CG, a thrust increase will produce a _______ up moment
destabilizing
and the effect is ___________.
increase in stick
The aeroplane with positive manoeuvring stability should demonstrate a steady _______
g
increase in load factor or “__”.
force with ________
24 June 2020 49
Principles of Flight
Revisions (4)
The stick force gradient must not be excessively ____
high or the aeroplane will be difficult and tiring
low or the aeroplane may be
to manoeuvre. Also, the stick force gradient must not be too _____
overstressed inadvertently when light control forces exist.
24 June 2020 50
Principles of Flight
Revisions (5)
centring springs, _____
A flying control system may employ _______ down springs or ____
bob weights to provide
satisfactory control forces throughout the speed, CG and altitude range of an aircraft.
While static stability is concerned with the initial tendency of an aircraft to return to equilibrium,
motion with _____.
dynamic stability is defined by the resulting _______ time
24 June 2020 51
Principles of Flight
Revisions (6)
The longitudinal dynamic stability of an aeroplane generally consists of two basic modes of oscillation:
Angle of _______.
The phugoid oscillation occurs with nearly constant ______ Attack
Long _______
The period of oscillation is so great, the pilot is easily able to counteract _____ period oscillation.
Angle of _______.
Short period oscillation involves significant changes in ______ Attack
not _______
Short period oscillation is ____ easily controlled by the pilot.
24 June 2020 52
Principles of Flight
a) Very small forces are required on the control column to produce pitch;
c) Very high stick forces are required to pitch because the aircraft is very stable;
24 June 2020 53
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 54
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 55
Principles of Flight
d) The flight crew can adjust the CG during flight to keep it within acceptable limits
for landing.
24 June 2020 56
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 57
Principles of Flight
a) The stick force per g can only be corrected by means of electronic devices
(stability augmentation) in case of an unacceptable value;
b) The stick force per g increases, when centre of gravity is moved aft;
c) The stick force per g must have both an upper and lower limit in order to assure
acceptable control characteristics;
24 June 2020 59
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 60
Principles of Flight
a) Larger;
b) Smaller;
c) Unchanged;
24 June 2020 61
Principles of Flight
24 June 2020 62
Principles of Flight
24/06/2020 63