Professional Documents
Culture Documents
35 (2), 2022
فاعلية البرنامج التداخلي في اداء الممرضين تجاه اجراء سحب سوائل التنبيب الرغامي لحديثي الوالدة
Alaa Q. Ahmed Yas, MScN *
Khatam M. Hattab, PhD**
* Clinical Nurse Specialist, Ghazi al-Hariri Surgical Specialties Hospital, Ministry of Health and Environment.
E: mail: alla.qasem.1204@conursing.uobaghdad.edu.iq
** Professor, Pediatric Nursing Department, University of Baghdad, College of Nursing, Iraq.
E: mail: dr.khatam@conursing.uobaghdad.edu.iq
المستخلص
وكذلك لمعرفة، ولتحديد فاعلية البرنامج التداخلي على ممارسات الممرضين، لتقييم ممارسة الممرضات تجاه إجراء شفط الرغامي لحديثي الوالدة:االهداف
.العالقة بين ممارسة الممرضين وخصائصهم الديموغرافية
دائرة مدينة/ تم أجراء دراسة ذات تصميم قبل تجريبي (تصميم لمجموعة واحدة الختبار قبلي وبعدي) في مستشفى حماية االطفال التعليمي:المنهجية
تم اختيار تقنية أخذ العينات غير.2022 حزيران31 كانون الثاني إلى17 بدأت من. أجريت على ممرضي وحدة العناية المشددة لحديثي الوالدة،الطب
الخصائص- الجزء االول: بعدها تم وضع قائمة مرجعية تتكون من جزئين.احتمالية (غرضية) ألربعة وعشرين ممرض لتحقيق أهداف الدراسة
وايضا تم تحديد.) فقرة لتطبيق االجراء60( ) محاور و3( يتكون من نموذج لممارسات الممرضين في-الديموغرافية للممرضين اما الجزء الثاني
.) ممرضين5( بينما تم تحديد مدى موثوقيتها من خالل االختبار وإعادة االختبار على،خبيرا
ً )13( صالحية األداة من قبل لجنة مكونة من
) لم يكن لديهم مستوى مالئم من الممارسة في24( أظهرت نتائج البيانات أن جميع ممرضات وحدة العناية المركزة لحديثي الوالدة وعددهم:النتائج
. إجراء. بينما كانت نتائج االختبار البعدي بعد تنفيذ البرنامج كافية من خالل تطبيق جميع خطوات الشفط،االختبار القبلي
بينما كان هناك تغيير واضح نحو. البرنامج التداخلي بعد تطبيقه كان له تأثير ايجابي وفعال على ممارسات ممرضي وحدة العناية المشددة:االستنتاجات
.األفضل في نتائج أدائهم بعد تنفيذ البرنامج
يوصي الباحث بتنفيذ وتعميم البرنامج التداخلي لممارسات الممرضين وإدراجه في من هج التمريض وايضا يوصي وزارة الصحة بتعيين وتوزيع: التوصيات
.حملة الشهادة الجامعية فقط في جميع وحدات العناية المشددة لحديثي الوالدة وإلزامية الممرضين المشاركة في الدورات التدريبية وبشكل مكثف ومستمر
. حديثي الوالدة، التنبيب الرغامي، اجراء سحب سوائل، اداء الممرضين:الكلمات المفتاحية
Abstract
Objective(s): To evaluate nurses’ Practice toward neonatal endotracheal suctioning procedure, and to
determine the effectiveness of the interventional program on nurses’ practices, as well as to find out the
relationship between nurses’ practice and their demographic characteristics.
Methodology: A Pre-experimental, one group design, was carried out to achieve the objectives of the current
study using the evaluation approach and the implementation of the education program for the period from
January 17 to June 31, 2022. A non- probability, purposive sample of (24) nurses were selected from the
Neonatal Intensive Care Unit at Pediatric Teaching Hospital/ Medical City Department. A checklist was
developed consists of two parts: part I: Nurses’ demographic characteristics, and part II: Evaluation of
nurses' Practice toward neonatal endotracheal suctioning procedure which consist of three domains (60) item,
using the observation technique for data collection….
Results: The results of the data showed that all of the (24) neonatal intensive care unit nurses had an
Inadequate level of Practice in the pre-test, while the results of the post-test after implementing the program
was adequate through apply all steps the suctioning procedure.
Conclusions: The intervention program, after its application, had a positive and effective effect on
the practices of neonate intensive care unit nurses. While there was a clear change for the better in
their practices after apply the program.
Recommendations: The researcher recommends the implementation and generalization of the
interventional program for nurses' practices and its inclusion in the nursing curriculum. It also recommends
that the Ministry of Health appoint and distribute university degree holders only in all neonatal intensive care
units and compulsory nurses to participate in training courses intensively and continuously.
Keywords: Nurses’ Practice, Endotracheal, Suctioning Procedure, Neonatal
82
Iraqi National Journal of Nursing Specialties, Vol. 35 (2), 2022
to be more adhered to when the intervention This part includes nurses' sociodemographic
was implemented (10). characteristics of gender, age, level of
education, years of employment, years of
Methodology employment in NICU.
Design of the Stud Part II: Evaluation of Nurses’ Practice
A Quasi-experimental (Pre- Check lis
experimental) design was carried out on This part is composed of (3) domains of
nurses who work at NICU in Pediatric general preparations by the nurse before
Teaching Hospital. An application of pre- performing Endotracheal Suctioning
post- test approach was used to evaluate Procedure; Implementation of Neonatal
nurses’ practices toward Neonatal Endotracheal Suctioning Procedure, and
Endotracheal Suctioning Procedure in NICU. Nurses' interventions after Endotracheal
The study was started from the January 17 to Suctioning Procedure which include (60)
June 31, 2022 items. The time of apply questionnaire items,
Setting of the Stud for each nurse tooks about 10-15 minute (pre
The study is conducted at Neonatal and post-test)
Intensive Care Unit in Pediatric Teaching
Hospital. The Interventional Program
Implementation
Sample of the Stud The interventional program was
A purposive (non-probability) sample presented to nurses to develop their practices
of 24 nurses working at neonatal intensive toward neonatal endotracheal suctioning
care units in pediatric teaching hospital were procedure throughout the period from 27th
selected to achieve the objectives of the study. February to 26th May 2022.
The study sample was exposed to the
intervention program. Validity of the Study:
The content validity of the program and the
Ethical Considerations: study tools are determined through a review
The researcher distributed an informed by a panel of (13) experts with an experience
consent sheet to all participating NICU nurses of more than (9) years in their specialty
in order to obtain their permission to related to the study. The experts' suggestions
participate in the current study. In addition, and recommendations were taken into
they were informed that they could opt out of consideration and the final copy of the
the research or refuse to answer a specific constructed instrument and program has
question and participate in the practice at any become acceptable as a tool for conducting
time. Submit an informed consent form the study.
.
The Program and Instrument Construction Reliability of the Study Instrument:
According to the findings of nurses’ Internal consistency reliability is employed
assessment needs (preliminary assessment) of for the determination of the study
their practices toward neonatal endotracheal instrument’s adequacy. Cronbach alpha
suctioning and an intensive review of related correlation coefficient is computed on
literatures to construct the intervention responses of (5) nurses working at ICU in at
program, a questionnaire as a checklist is pediatric teaching hospital. Finding of this
constructed based on the program contents computation indicates that the correlation
which consisted of two parts: coefficient is approving that the instrument is
adequately reliable measure for the
Part I: Demographical Characteristics of phenomenon underlying the present study
the Nurses
84
Iraqi National Journal of Nursing Specialties, Vol. 35 (2), 2022
Rating and Scoring of the Study The data were collected from (24) nurses who
Instrument: work in NICU for the period from 27th
The check list questionnaire form style has February to 26th May of 2022 by using the
been scored and rated on two levels study questionnaire (observational checklist).
dichotomous scale (2) for applying the The purpose and objectives of the study were
practice and (1) for not applying based on explained to all participants and the nurses'
three observations. The items were rated practice was evaluated before implementing
according to the Likers' scale of the three the intervention program (pre-test) for all
observations then rated to (3) apply always, participants. All nurses in the study were
(2) apply sometimes, and (1) for not apply. exposed to the program. Then, they were
The higher grade of scoring, the greater subjected to post-test (in the manner of direct
practice and according to high (2.5 - 3), observation by the researcher for each nurse
moderate (1.5– 2.5), and low (1. – 1.5). The for three times performing procedure
practice improvement effect result from the suctioning practice on the neonatal).
application of the interventional program was
exposed as (apply). Statistical Analysis
SPSS (Statistical Package for Social Sciences)
Data Collection Method version 24.0 is used to analyze the study data.
Result
Table (1): Distribution of NICU Nurses’ Demographical Characteristics (n=24)
Study Sample
Variable Groups
Freq. %
Male 9 37.5
Gender Female 15 62.5
Total 24 100.0
19- 23 7 29.2
24 – 28 8 33.3
29 – 33 3 12.5
Age Group 34 – 38 1 4.2
39 – 43 2 8.3
44 – 48 2 8.3
49 and more 1 4.2
Total 24 100.0
Nursing school graduates 1 4.2
Graduate of a secondary nursing
3 12.5
school
Graduate of the Nursing Institute 4 16.7
Educational level Nursing college graduate 14 58.3
Higher education in nursing
2 8.3
graduate
Other 0 0
Total 24 100.0
85
Iraqi National Journal of Nursing Specialties, Vol. 35 (2), 2022
1–5 13 54.2
6 – 10 6 25.0
11 – 15 3 12.5
years of experiences in Nursing
16 – 20 1 4.2
21 and more 1 4.2
Total 24 100%
1–5 16 66.7
6 – 10 3 12.5
years of experiences in Neonatal 11 – 15 3 12.5
Intensive care unit 16 – 20 1 4.2
21 and more 1 4.2
Total 24 100%
Sharing in training sessions related to Yes 8 33.3
neonatal Endotracheal suctioning in No 16 66.7
NICU Total 24 100.0
Sharing in training sessions related to Outside Iraq 0 0
Neonatal Endotracheal Suctioning in Inside Iraq 8 33.3
NICU which was established by other Not sharing 16 66.7
institutions Total 24 100.0
One 0 0
Two 8 33.3
Three and more sessions 0 0
Number of training sessions
16 66.7
Not sharing
Total 24 100.0
Less than one week 8 33.3
More than one week 0 0
Duration of training sessions
Not sharing 16 66.6
Total 24 100.0
Yes 6 25.0
Updating Information No 18 66.7
Total 24 100.0
Internet (Social media) 14 58.3
Internet (Specified Scientific
5 20.8
websites)
Journals and magazines 1 4.2
Source of updating the information Libraries 1 4.2
Television 1 4.2
Other sources 1 4.2
Not updating 1 4.2
Total 24 100.0
Freq.= frequency, % = percentage
Table (4.1) showed that the majority of nurses were females (62.5%), within the age group of
(19-28 years) (62.5%), most of them were graduated from nursing college (58.3%), with (1-5) years
86
Iraqi National Journal of Nursing Specialties, Vol. 35 (2), 2022
of experience in nursing (54.2%). The majority of them have (1-5) years of experiences in Neonatal
Intensive care unit.
Table (2): Comparison Significant of Pretest and Posttest Practice Score for NICU Nurses
Pre-test post test P-
Main domain of Practice N t Sig.
M.S SD df M.S SD Df value
Domain One: General
preparations by the nurse
-
before performing 24 1.17 0.381 23 2.42 0.504 23 .000 H.S
11.519
Endotracheal Suctioning
Procedure.
Domain Two: .000
Implementation of Neonatal -
24 1.38 0.495 23 2.54 0.509 23 H.S
Endotracheal Suctioning 10.122
Procedure.
Domain Three: Nurses' .000
interventions after
24 1.13 0.338 23 2.29 0.464 23 -8.972 H.S
Endotracheal Suctioning
Procedure.
- .000
Total 24 1.22 0.381 23 2.41 0.495 23 H.S
10.063
N: Number, M. S: Mean Score, SD: Standard Deviation, df: degree of freedom, t: t. test, H.S:
high significant at P value ≤ (0.05)
This table revealed the significant change in nurses’ practices toward neonatal Endotracheal
suctioning procedure at pre and post-test of the major domains at P. value equal to 0.000.
Table (3): Relationship between Nurses’ Practices and their Socio-demographic
Characteristics
Socio. Demographic
Study Sample (N=24)
Variables
Pretest Posttest
Sum of P value Sum of P value
Df M.S F Df M.S F
squares Sig. squares Sig.
Between
.075 1 .075 .469 1 .469
groups
Gender Within
5.550 22 .297 .591 N.S 5.156 22 2.003 .171 N.S
groups
.252 .234
total 5.625 23 5.625 23
Between
8.008 1 8.008 9.669 1 9.669
groups
Age Group
Within 2.555 .124 N.S 3.161 .089 N.S
68.950 22 67.289 22 3.059
groups 3.134
total 76.958 23 76.958 23
87
Iraqi National Journal of Nursing Specialties, Vol. 35 (2), 2022
Between
.208 1 .208 .136 1 .136
Educational group
level Within .211 .651 N.S .137 .041 S
21.750 22 21.822 22 .992
groups .989
Total 21.958 23 21.958 23
Between
1.008 1 1.008 .003 1 .003
years of groups
experiences Within 823 .374 N.S .002 .963 N.S
26.950 27.956 22
in Nursing groups 1.225 1.271
total 27.958 23 27.958 23
years of Between
.533 1 .533 .178 1 .178
experiences groups
.407
in Neonatal Within .530 N.S .134 .718 N.S
28.800 22 1.309 29.156 22 1.325
Intensive groups
care unit total 29.333 23 29.333 23
Sharing in Between
.033 1 .033 1 .000
training group
sessions Within
5.300 22 .000 22
related to groups
.138 .713 N.S 5.333 .000 1.000 N.S
Neonatal .242
.241 5.333
Endotracheal
Total 5.333 23 23
Suctioning in
NICU
Sharing in Between
.033 1 .033 .000 1 .000
training groups
sessions Within
5.300 22 5.333 22
related to groups
Neonatal
Endotracheal
.138 .713 N.S .000 1.000 N.S
Suctioning in
.241 .242
NICU which
total 5.333 23 5.333 23
was
established
by other
institutions
Between
.033 1 .033 .000 1 .000
Number of groups
training Within .138 .713 N.S .000 1.000 N.S
5.300 22 5.333 22
sessions groups .241 .242
total 5.333 23 5.333 23
88
Iraqi National Journal of Nursing Specialties, Vol. 35 (2), 2022
Betwee
n .075 1 .075 .025 1 .025
Duration group .08 .02 .86
N. N.
of training Within 19.55 2 4 .774 19.60 2 8 8
S S
sessions groups 0 2 .889 0 2 .891
19.62 2 19.62 2
Total
5 3 5 3
Betwee
n .000 1 .000 .011 1 .011
Updating groups .00 .05 .81
1.00 N. N.
Informatio Within 2 0 2 4 8
4.500 0 S 4.489 S
n groups 2 .205 2 .204
2 2
total 4.500 4.500
3 3
Betwee
2.40 2.02
Source of n 2.408 1 2.025 1
8 5
updating groups
.79 .66 .42 N.
the Within 66.55 2 .038 S 66.93 2
6 6 3 S
informatio groups 0 2 3.02 3 2 3.04
n 68.95 2 5 68.95 2 2
Total
8 3 8 3
M.S: Mean of Score, df: degree of freedom, NS: Non-Significant at P> (0.05), S: Significant at
P< (0.05)
Table (3) Showed there were significant relationships between Nurses’ practices and their
source of updating information in pretest level at (P value = 0.038) and, educational level in posttest
at (p value = 0.041).
Discussion
The results of study presented nurses' study found that most of the study samples
demographic characteristics, it is revealed that were males (70%) and the rest were female
most nurses’ gender is female (62.5%). Two (60%) aged 20-29) years in nursing, (68%) of
thirds of them aged within the age group of them have a training course in the intensive
(19-28 years) (62.5%). Concerning their care unit (11, 12).
education, more than half of sample were It was mentioned that intensive care
nursing college graduate (58.3%). In regarding unit nurses at a Lahore children's hospital were
to their years of experience in the nursing field, the principal subject of the investigation. A
more than half of nurses in the study have total of 98 nurse participated in the study, 70%
service of (1-5 years) (54.2%). In relation years of them were between the age of 20 and 29,
of experience in the ICU, the majority of with the majority holding a nursing diploma
nurses have (1-5 years), approximately nearly (80%). Most of the critical care unit's staff (51
of three- quarters (66.7 %). employees) had worked in the field for at least
A study used a cross-sectional design to three to five years, and just 15% had been there
evaluate ICU Iraqi nurses' knowledge and less than three years (13).
practice about endotracheal suctioning. The
89
Iraqi National Journal of Nursing Specialties, Vol. 35 (2), 2022
A cross-sectional descriptive study was with internet (Social media and Specified
conducted for 48 nurses working in the Scientific websites) at p value >0.05.
newborn critical care unit at ahvaz medical No significant relationship between
sciences training facilities; 83.4 percent of nurses’ age, gender, years of employment in
employees were female, 16.6 percent were neonatal intensive care unit, and participation
male, and the majority were between the ages in training session, source of the information
of 26 and 35. 54.1 percent obtained on-the-job with internet and their practice after
intensive care training. 52.1 percent of nurses’ implementing the program but there is
work in intensive care units for less than five significant relationship between level of
years (7). education (graduate of nursing college) their
The effectiveness of the intervention practice after implementing the intervention
program is observed through the results of program at p value >0.05.
table (2) for all three domains, nurses’ practice Significant relationship between years
at the pretest was at low level but changed in to of experience (1-5) and pretest for nurses’
high level at the posttest. there are high practice.
significant differences between pre and posttest Conclusions
of the study sample in all (3) main domains at Study concluded that the practice of most
(P. value =.000). nurses in the neonatal care unit towards the
A thirty randomly chosen nurses from application of scientific steps for neonatal
Maulana's Maharishi Markandeshwar Institute Endotracheal suctioning procedure have been
of Medical Sciences and Research Hospital improved after implementing the program.
how were interviewed before and after the Recommendations
intervention. The activity was repeated until a The study recommends that the
score of >80% was achieved. The study found interventional program can be presented to all
that endotracheal suctioning by nurses at the nurses working at the NICU and could be
post-implementation for knowledge and included in the critical care nursing
practice scored significantly higher than pre- procedures curriculum. Encouraging nurses
implementation scores (p 0.001) (14, 15). working in intensive care to review reliable
No significant relationship between and practical scientific sources such as
nurses’ practice and their age, gender, scientific websites and medical journals
educational level, years of employment in issued by the Ministry of Health (Journal of
neonatal intensive care unit, and participation Medicine City). Suggestion to the Ministry of
in training session before implementing the Health to appoint only academic nurses to
program but there is significant relationship work at NICU and them with organized
between source of updating the information training courses.
References Wong%27s+nursing+care+of+infants
+and+children-E book.
1- Barfield, W. D., Papile, L. A., Baley, 3- Copnell, B., Tingay, D. G., Kiraly, N.
J. E., Benitz, W., Cummings, J., Carlo, J., Sourial, M., Gordon, M. J., Mills, J.
W. A., ... & Watterberg, K. L. (2012). F., ... & Dargaville, P. A. (2017). A
Levels of neonatal care. Pediatrics, comparison of the effectiveness of
130(3), 587-597. open and closed endotracheal suction.
2- Hockenberry, M. J., & Wilson, D. Intensive care medicine, 33(9), 1655-
(2018). Wong's nursing care of infants 1662.
and children-E-book. Elsevier Health 4- Maraş, G. B., Güler, E. K., Eşer, İ., &
Sciences. available by http://www. Köse, Ş. (2017). Knowledge and
practice of intensive care nurses for
90
Iraqi National Journal of Nursing Specialties, Vol. 35 (2), 2022