RTIM_Revitalisation Telegraph Island Musandam Technical Tender Evaluation Hoehler + AlSalmy SPC

Total Score:
Legend(SCR): 1-5 (5 being the highest score)
Structural Evaluation
A. Fahud tower Trading LLC.
B. Al Arabia National Engineering & contracting LLC.
C. Tilal Nimar Trad. & cont. LLC

Contractors A Fahud tower B Al Arabia National Tilal Nimar

C SCR
SR.# Field/Item SCR Comments SCR Comments Comments
Construction time for Jetty incl.
1 3 210 days 0 not submitted 4 120 days
design & approval
Construction time for Inland
2 4 165 days 0 not submitted 2 400 days
facilities

3 Project hand over date 4 1-Feb-25 0 not submitted 2 3-Jun-25

Submitted for both

4 Manpower Histogram 0 Not Submitted 0 Not Submitted. 5
contrat
HSE Policy, Planning &
HSE Policy &
procedure are submitted
Planning details are
in details. But, HSE
5 HSE 4 4 submitted. But, HSE 0 Not submitted
Certificates not submitted
Certificates not
submitted.
PQP submitted in details
for most of the acitivities submitted with Partly menyioned in
6 PQP (Project quality Plan) 3 5 1
details Campany capability

14 key staff CV 11 key staff CV

7 CV for Key staff 0 Not submitted 5 5
submitted submitted

Submitted with
Shortly described for each details for
8 Methodology of construction 4 4 0 Not submitted
stages of works road/pavment
construction

Details shown only for

submitted with 8 nos
9 List of sub-contractor 2 Jetty works & soil 0 not submitted 4
subcontractors
investigation

10 Statement for Site vist 5 Confirmed 0 not submitted 5 confirmed

11 Organization chart 5 Submitted clearly 5 Submitted clearly 0 not submitted

Total 12 nos completed & Submitted

Total 11nos projects
ongoing projects details experiences for 14
completed. 2 nos
12 Experience for last 10 years 3 are submitted. 4 projects. Most of 4
ongoing projects
Experienced in road them are found for
found.
construction road & culverts

mentioned clearly
mentioned clearly with 14 mentioned clearly
13 Plant & equipments details 3 3 with 33 types in a 3
types in a list with 12 types in a list
list

RTIM_231210_Technical Evaluation_STR 12/11/2023

RTIM_Revitalisation Telegraph Island Musandam Technical Tender Evaluation Hoehler + AlSalmy SPC

Masirah International Khimjis Ramadas

14 Sub-contractor for Jetty works 5 0 Not submitted 5
technical LLC Group

15 0 Not mentioned. 0 Not mentioned. 4 Al Khalili LLC

Structural steel subcontractor

3 nos relevant
Relevant project experience for Submitted only for
16 1 Not clearly mentioned 3 4 projects experience
structure road construction
shown

Prelim- 61,750 /-
Prelim- 250000 /-
Mooring Bay-
Prelim- 50,000 /- Mooring Bay- 87000/-
140000/-
Cost details for Contract-1 Mooring Bay- 100000/- Jetty/Gangway-
17 4 5 Jetty/Gangway- 1
(Jetty & mooring facility) Jetty/Gangway-200000/- 870,000/-
74800/-
total lumsum- 419750/- total lumsum-
Total lumsum-
1405,300.000/-
335,282.500 /-

Prelim- 50,000 /- Prelim- 64,500 /- Prelim- 350,000 /-

18 cost details for cotract-2 2 Total Lumsum- 2383,660 5 Total Lumsum- 1 Total Lumsum-
/- 896,698.240 /- 5718,192.725 /-

19

Total Skills Sum 52 43 50

Final Score 52 43 50

RTIM_231210_Technical Evaluation_STR 12/11/2023