You are on page 1of 17

JCLES?HC EP™DG AM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ?

CJ B G Q C Ä M 1

@mqoschmq amlacnrs_jcq, I^bumilo^`fÉkabs^of^plm`flkbpabafpbÇl^qo^s}pab_lpnrbglpo|mfalpbprkj}qlalnrbIrk^o* rk^


abi^p /.`ljm^ÇÅ^pbpq^alrkfabkpbpabaf`^a^p^iafpbÇlabmolar`qlpnrbcrbolkd^i^oalk^a^pob`fbkqbjbkqbmloi^obsfpq^
@sqglcqqUcci* rqfifw^m^o^`ob^omolar`qlp_biilpvj^o`^pbufqlp^p, &Amprcqá_ bc Jsl_p Bcqgel',

GLRPMBSAAGML
Glbcnclbgclrckclrc bc j_ jcles_ osc f_`jc* j_ ecl+ _qgel_bm _ jmq npmwcarmq w qmprc_p j_q pcqrpgaagmlcq bc
rc bc rmbm cj kslbm srgjgx_ jmq bg`shmq rÉalgamq n_p_ rgcknm, J_ amkslga_agâl epÅdga_ cdcargt_ r_k`gÉl cq
amkslga_p qsq gbc_q, J_ pcnpcqclr_agâl epÅdga_ cq sl_ sl_ tclr_h_ cl cj kcpa_bm ejm`_j* bmlbc jmq kgck+
dmpk_ `Åqga_ w l_rsp_j bc amkslga_agâl osc lm cqrÅ `pmq bcj cosgnm lm lcacq_pg_kclrc amkn_prcl sl
tglasj_b_ _ sl kmkclrm m jse_p, Cq* cl agcprm qclrg+ gbgmk_ amkål,
bm* sl jcles_hc slgtcpq_j, Bcj kgqkm kmbm osc jmq a_pnglrcpmq _npclbcl _
J_ amlapcagâl bc gbc_q* bcqbc j_q kÅq qgknjcq sq_p j_q fcpp_kgclr_q bc qs mdgagm* jmq gleclgcpmq* _p+
f_qr_ j_q kÅq cj_`mp_b_q* pcosgcpc bcj rp_`_hm cl osgrcarmq* bg`sh_lrcq* bgqcà_bmpcq* d_`pga_lrcq w rÉa+
cosgnm, Sl npmbsarm* kÅosgl_* cqrpsarsp_ m qgqrck_ lgamq _npclbcl _ cknjc_p j_q fcpp_kgclr_q bcj bg`shm
lsctm nscbc cvgqrgp cl j_ k clrc bc sl gleclgcpm m sl rÉalgam, Cjjmq _npclbcl kÉrmbmq cqncaÖdgamq n_p_ pc+
bgqcà_bmp* ncpm _lrcq bc osc nscb_ tmjtcpqc sl_ pc_+ npcqclr_p gbc_q* bgqcàmq w cqncagdga_agmlcq bc sl_ k_+
jgb_b* j_ gbc_ bc`c qcp amkslga_b_ _ ksaf_q w bgqrgl+ lcp_ amlqgqrclrc osc jmq bckÅq nscb_l clrclbcp, Qcp
r_q ncpqml_q, J_ a_n_agb_b bc amkslga_p amlacnrmq sl amkslga_bmp epÅdgam cdga_x _qcesp_ osc cj npmbsa+
bc bgqcàm cl dmpk_ pÅngb_ w npcagq_ _ rp_tÉq bc bg+ rm* qgqrck_ m cqrpsarsp_ gk_egl_b_ qc npmbsxa_ qceål
`shmq rÉalgamq cq aj_tc n_p_ q_rgqd_acp cj npcqsnscqrm j_q cqncagdga_agmlcq,

   
2 A?N≠RSJM / JCLES?HC EP™DGAM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M

c^ 
(
=:+$+%õ< @LJMOBKPFßK ABI
T v3 OLI ABILP AF?RGLP
%-∏T- 1 % - +
(
Q{@KF@LP
@b!r O
Jmq bg`shmq w cqncagdga_agmlcq amlrpmj_l
j_ ep_l a_lrgb_b bc bcr_jjcq gltmjsap_+
bmq cl j_ d_`pga_agâl* cj clq_k`jc w cj
k_lrclgkgclrm bc sl npmbsarm, R_lrm
j_ d_agjgb_b bcj `mqoschm _ k_lm _jx_b_
amkm j_ a_n_agb_b bc sq_p j_q amknsr_+
I %- g (/(3 bmp_q n_p_ npmbsagp bg`shmq rÉalgamq qml
sl`sq+ f_`gjgb_bcq ksw t_jgmq_q cl cj kcpa_bm
ejm`_j, Cj bg`shm rÉalgam pcosgcpc amlm+
acp j_q lmpk_q osc ncpkgrcl osc jmq bg+
`shmq amkslgoscl bc k_lcp_ amlagq_ jmq
/,/ Bcr_jjc bc sl `mqoschm bc aÇjasjm, &Amprcqá_ bc H, Hcddpcw Xcpp', bgqcàmq _jpcbcbmp bcj kslbm,
Jmq bg`shmq rÉalgamq nscbcl rmk_p
ksaf_q dmpk_q* clrpc mrp_q8 `mqoschmq
bc sl_ gbc_ m sl amlacnrm &nmp chcknjm*
jmq `macrmq bc j_ nÅegl_ _lrcpgmp'* `mq+
oschmq bc aÅjasjm* `mqoschmq bc bgqcàm*
bg`shmq bc bgqcàm* nj_lmq bc j_q ngcx_q*
nj_lmq bc chcasagâl m amlqrpsaagâl* cq+
osck_q cjÉarpgamq* nj_lmq bc glqr_j_agâl
w cqosck_q bc clq_k`j_bm, Jmq `mqosc+
hmq* jmq bg`shmq A?B cl 0B w jmq km+
bcjmq A?B cl 1B qml dmpk_q bc bg`shm
rÉalgam, ?jeslmq bc cqrmq rgnmq bc bg`s+
hmq rÉalgamq qc kscqrp_l cl j_q dgesp_q
/,/ _ /,4, A_b_ slm bc cqrmq rgnmq bc bg+
`shmq* w mrpmq kÅq* rgclcl sl jse_p cl cj
npmacqm bc bgqcàm w amlqrpsaagâl bc sl
npmbsarm* sl qgqrck_ m sl_ cqrpsarsp_,
f i k t ? jw s g_
AC AML RPM , Cl eclcp_j* jmq bg`shmq rÉalgamq qgptcl
&SCPRM >I T?bM
n_p_ slm bc rpcq npmnâqgrmq8
í Sfpr^ifw^`fàk
F I S R?LOSC ?J T?A≠M é @ljrkf`^`fàk
é Al`rjbkq^`fàk
/,0 Cvrp_arm bc sl cqosck_ bc clq_k`j_bm, &Amprcqá_ bc Ummbq Nmucp+Epgn
Am,* Gla,', F_w sl_ _knjg_ t_pgcb_b bc npmdc+
qgmlcq osc sq_l bg`shmq rÉalgamq n_p_
amkslga_p w bmaskclr_p bgqcàmq, ?jes+
lmq chcknjmq qml j_ gleclgcpÖ_ agtgj* j_
,53. gleclgcpÖ_ kcaÅlga_* j_ gleclgcpÖ_ cjÉa+
PCD
rpga_* j_ _posgrcarsp_* j_ gleclgcpÖ_ cl
- pcaspqmq `gârgamq* cj bgqcàm bcj n_gq_hc*
- j_ _posgrcarsp_ bcj n_gq_hc* cj bgqcàm gl+
-
bsqrpg_j* j_ gleclgcpÖ_ bc j_ amlqrpsaagâl*
5 j_ rcalmjmeÖ_ bc j_ amlqrpsaagâl* j_ apc_+
-
agâl bc n_rpmlcq* j_ ecqrgâl bc npmwca+
rmq* cj clq_k`j_hc w j_ k_lsd_arsp_9 qgl
ck`_pem* f_w ksafmq mrpmq,
- Qg sqrcb cqrÅ bgqcà_lbm sl nsclrc*
X
p glqr_j_lbm jÖlc_q cjÉarpga_q qs`rcppÅlc_q
- cl sl_ qs`bgtgqgâl* m bgqcà_lbm sl_
-
- a_pa_q_ bc njÅqrgam n_p_ sl_ lsct_ rmq+
Jb r_bmp_* j_ amknpclqgâl w cj sqm bcj bg+
QCARGML ? +?
`shm rÉalgam qml f_`gjgb_bcq aj_tc osc
lcacqgr_pÅ,
/,1 Nj_lm bc sl_ ngcx_, &Amprcqá_ bc Bwlmhcr Pcqc_paf* Gla,',

   
JCLES?HC EP™DG AM S L G T C P Q ? J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M 3

&Amprcqá_ bc Qcwkmspnmucjj',

MOLVB@QL SBIL @FA >A


J_ kmrmagajcr_ CLT &BjfppflkKbrqo^iSbef+
a b * SbeÖ`rilabBjfpflkbpKbrqo^i' amkclxâ
amkm sl npmwcarm qcapcrm cl j_q mdgagl_q bc
Qcwkmspnmucjj cl Dsjf_k* Glej_rcpp_, J_ e_+
/,2 @mqoschm bc bgqcãm, &Amprcqá_ bc Qcwkmspnmucjj', j_pbml_b_ amkn_àÖ_ bc bgqcàm glbsqrpg_j dsc
qcjcaagml_b_ bc clrpc sl_ jgqr_ bc as_rpm dgl_+
jgqr_q `pgrÅlga_q n_p_ kmqrp_p j_ rcalmjmeÖ_ gl+
lmt_bmp_ bcq_ppmjj_b_ nmp Glrcjjgeclr Clcpew*
jÖbcp cl rcalmjmeÖ_ bc acjb_q bc amk`sqrg`jc,
J_ amkgqgâl dsc amlacbgb_ cl 0..1, Npg+
kcpm* Qcwkmspnmucjj ammpbglâ sl_ qcpgc bc
r_jjcpcq aml cj ncpqml_j amkcpag_j w rÉalgam
bc Glrcjjgeclr Clcpew n_p_ bcrcpkgl_p w nmlcp
_ npsc`_ sl_ qcpgc bc amlacnrmq nmrclag_jcq,
Amglagbgcpml cl j_ gbc_ bc sl_ kmrmagajcr_
osc qc bgqcà_p_ _ n_prgp bc sl_ ngj_ bc amk+
`sqrg`jc cvrck_, J_ dmpk_ w j_ dslagâl bc j_
kmrmagajcr_ qc bcpgt_pÖ_l bgpcar_kclrc bcj sqm
bc j_ ngj_ aclrp_j bc amk`sqrg`jc,
Slm bc jmq npgkcpmq bcq_dÖmq dsc _aml+
bgagml_p j_ ngj_ bc amk`sqrg`jc w bc qs amk+
`sqrg`jc bc fgbpâeclm bclrpm bc sl_ slgb_b
mpbcl_b_ w amkn_ar_, Bsp_lrc sl rgcknm qc
fgagcpml ksaf_q kchmp_q _ j_ kmrmagajcr_*
/,3 Bg`shm A?B cl 0B, &Amprcqá_ bc Qcwkmspnmucjj', r_lrm rÉalga_ amkm tgqs_jkclrc, J_q npgkc+
p_q grcp_agmlcq bc cqrgjm bgcpml nmp pcqsjr_bm
sl _qncarm bc bcnpcb_bmp* jm osc qsegpgâ cj
lmk`pc bc °P_nrmp¢ n_p_ cj npgkcp kmbcjm*
ncpm j_ qmpnpclbclrc cvncpgclag_ bc bcqjgx_pqc
qgjclagmq_kclrc _jpcbcbmp bc sl n_posc bs+
p_lrc j_ npgkcp_ npsc`_ bc j_ kmrmagajcr_ glq+
ngpâ cj lmk`pc bc °Cspci_¢, BcqnsÉq qgesgc+
pml kcqcq bc rp_`_hm _pbsm* pcdgl_kgclrm w
npsc`_q rcalmjâega_q cvf_sqrgt_q,
CLT* j_ npgkcp_ kmrmagajcr_ amlqrpsgb_
n_p_ sq_p acjb_q bc amk`sqrg`jc bc fgbpâeclm*
dsc j_lx_b_ cl k_pxm bc 0..3 cl cj Ksqcm
bcj Bgqcàm bc Jmlbpcq aml sl Évgrm kslbg_j
cvrp_mpbgl_pgm, J_ cjce_lrc w qgjclagmq_ kmrm+
agajcr_* osc _bckÅq lm amlr_kgl_* nscbc _ja_l+
x_p tcjmagb_bcq bc 3. knf,
Cj qck_l_pgm jÖbcp bcbga_bm _ j_q kmrmag+
ajcr_q cl Ep_l @pcr_à_* J@K* amkclrâ8 °|qrc
nmbpÖ_ qcp cj j_lx_kgclrm kÅq gknmpr_lrc bc
/,4 Kmbcjm A?B pclbcpgx_bm &fkqbomobq^al' cl 1B, sl_ kmrmagajcr_ cl j_ fgqrmpg_¢, N_p_ kÅq gl+
&Amprcqá_ bc Qcwkmspnmucjj', dmpk_agâl* tgqgrc uuu,clt`gic,amk,

   
4 A?N≠RSJM / JCLES?HC EP™DGAM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M

/,5 Qgbbf_prf_ qc clasclrp_ aml j_ kscprc, Rá`cr* qgejm vtk, gmq af_rglpvmfkqro^ppbe^krp^alqo^af`flk^ijbkqb
m^o^`ljrkf`^ofab^ppfkm^i^_o^p*lm^o^^`i^o^oilnrbbpq|bp`ofql, &Amprcqá_ bcj ?pafgtm bc ?prc-Ksqcm Esgkcr
bc N_páq-B_ejg Mprg',

Ae^qfko ]npÉope_koupÅ_je_ko
J_ pcnpcqclr_agâl epÅdga_ qc f_ bcq_ppmjj_bm _ jm j_pem bc bmq jÖlc_q
bgqrglr_q8 &/' _prÖqrga_ w &0' rÉalga_,
Cj fmk`pc qgcknpc f_ cknjc_bm bg`shmq _prÖqrgamq n_p_ cv+
npcq_p gbc_q cqrÉrga_q* dgjmqâdga_q s mrp_q gbc_q _`qrp_ar_q, ?lrcq bc
osc qc bcq_ppmjj_p_l mrp_q rcalmjmeÖ_q bc amkslga_agâl* j_ eclrc
qc gldmpkâ _ rp_tÉq bc j_ amltcpq_agâl w kgp_lbm cqasjrsp_q* ngl+
rsp_q m bg`shmq cl jse_pcq nå`jgamq, J_q nglrsp_q dscpml sl_ dsclrc
npgkmpbg_j bc gldmpk_agâl osc rmbmq nmbÖ_l clrclbcp, Cl j_ dgesp_
/,5 qc kscqrp_ slm bc jmq gllskcp_`jcq chcknjmq bc nglrsp_q osc
asclr_l fgqrmpg_q,
Jmq bg`shmq rÉalgamq qml sl_ dmpk_ bgqrglr_ bc bg`shm, Bcqbc
cj amkgclxm bc j_ fgqrmpg_ pcegqrp_b_ qc f_l srgjgx_bm bg`shmq n_p_
pcnpcqclr_p cj bgqcàm bc m`hcrmq osc bc`cl cj_`mp_pqc m amlqrpsgpqc,
Qâjm oscb_l tcqrgegmq bc jmq npgkcpmq bg`shmq &nmp chcknjm* j_ dg+
esp_ /,6'* ncpm jmq bg`shmq bc`gcpml f_`cpqc srgjgx_bm* m j_ eclrc lm
fs`gcp_ nmbgbm bgqcà_p w amlqrpsgp cqrpsarsp_q r_l amknjch_q,
J_q cvnpcqgmlcq ncpqml_jcq m asjrsp_jcq cl cj bgqcàm qscjcl bc+
lmkgl_pqc bgqcàm bpqÉqf`Lv cl r_lrm osc j_q kchmp_q _j bcq_ppmjjm
bc sl npmbsarm qc amlqgbcp_l sl bgqcàmcrk`flk^i, J_ cqrÉrga_ w j_
dslagml_jgb_b nscbcl rp_`_h_p cl amlhslrm n_p_ apc_p sl npmbsarm
osc lm qâjm _ep_bc _ jmq qclrgbmq* qglm osc r_k`gÉl q_rgqd_e_ j_q bc+
k_lb_q cqncaÖdga_q bcj npmbsarm* amkm qc kscqrp_ cl j_ dgesp_ /,7,
J_ apc_rgtgb_b hsce_ sl n_ncj r_lrm cl j_ cqrÉrga_ amkm cl jmq
_qncarmq dslagml_jcq bcj bgqcàm, Cl cqrc a_nÖrsjm sqrcb _npclbcpÅ
_jesl_q rÉalga_q n_p_ kchmp_p qs apc_rgtgb_b,
/,6 Dmpr_jcx_ a_jbc_, Bpqbmi^klabmi^kq^m^o^bi
afpbÇlabrk^cloq^ibw^* bi^_lo^almlobifkdbkfbol
`^iabl@rab^* crbdo^_^albkrk^q^_ibq^abmfbao^, Bp Bh lnk_aok `a `eoaÜk
klq^_ibi^pfjfifqraabbpqbmi^kl`lkilpob^ifw^alpmlo Cj cldmosc mpe_lgx_bm w mpbcl_bm n_p_ pcqmjtcp npm`jck_q qc am+
ilp^onrfqb`qlp^`qr^ibp*^mbp^oabnrbcrb af_rg^al lmac amkm mol`bplabafpbál* cj as_j cl gleclgcpÖ_ rmk_ cl asclr_
jfibpab^Çlp^kqbpabnrbpbfksbkq^o^bim^mbi, j_q lcacqgb_bcq* jmq bcqcmq w jmq npm`jck_q bc j_ qmagcb_b kcbg_lrc
&Bc Qo^kp^`qflkp>P@B* k_wm bc /67/', j_ _njga_agâl bc npglagngmq agclrÖdgamq* cvncpgclag_ w apc_rgtgb_b,

   
JCLES?HC EP™DG AM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M 5 \

/,7 I^iÅkb^Mefifmp+>ibppfabmolar`qlpm^o^`l`fk^
bprkbgbjmilabafpbÇlnrb`lj_fk^i^bpq}qf`^vi^
crk`flk^ifa^a, &Npmwcarm apc_bm w bcq_ppmjj_bm nmp
Nfgjgnq Bcqgel',

Rkfkdbkfbolabmolvb`ql`lk`^p`lpbfk`ifk^m^o^bu^jfk^orkmi^kl
abmolvb`ql, &Amprcqá_ bc Bcllgq K_aBml_jb-Nfmrm Cbgr* Gla,',

Jmq bgdcpclrcq rgnmq bc bg`shmq rÉalgamq rgclcl sl_ dslagâl cq+


ncaÖdga_ cl cj npmacqm bc bgqcàm bc gleclgcpÖ_, Nmp chcknjm* jmq Gbclrgdga_agål
`mqoschmq _ k_lm _jx_b_ a_nrsp_l w bmaskclr_l cj npmacqm bc bcj npm`jck_
gbc_agâl, Cl cj _t_lac bcj npmacqm* jmq kmbcjmq w bg`shmq A?B
a_nrsp_l cj bgqcàm w cqncagdga_l jmq bcr_jjcq lcacq_pgmq n_p_ qs d_+
`pga_agâl,
Cj npmacqm bc bgqcàm n_p_ as_josgcp npmbsarm pcosgcpc sl_
U Gbc_agål

amknpclqgâl aj_p_ bc j_q dslagmlcq w cj pclbgkgclrm cqncp_bm bc /


cqc npmbsarm, Qc f_ cqrgk_bm osc clrpc 5. w 6.# bc jmq amqrmq Npmacqm bc bcagqgål-
bc bcq_ppmjjm w d_`pga_agâl bc jmq npmbsarmq qc bcrcpkgl_ bsp_lrc Qcjcaagålu b
bcj bgqcãm
j_q d_qcq bc bgqcàm glgag_j, ?slosc ksafmq epsnmq glbsqrpg_jcq nsc+
bcl gbclrgdga_pÖ_q qceål qs kmbm cqncaÖdgam bc f_acp j_q amq_q* cj E
O
npmacbgkgclrm n_p_ bgqcà_p sl npmbsarm lsctm m kchmp_bm amlqr_
Pcdgl_kgclrm
bc j_q qgesgclrcq cr_n_q* osc qc kscqrp_l cl j_ dgesp_ /,/.8
/, Gbclrgdga_agâl bcj npm`jck_8 cl npgkcp jse_p* bc`c cqapg`gpqc sl_
k_lgdcqr_agâl aj_p_ bc j_ lcacqgb_b w jmq m`hcrgtmq bcj bgqcàm,
0, Gbc_agâl8 aml dpcasclag_ qc cknjc_l `macrmq rÉalgamq n_p_ rp_lq+ ?lÇjgqgq
kgrgp amlacnrmq _ cosgnmq ksjrgbgqagnjgl_pgmq,
1, Pcdgl_kgclrm-_lÅjgqgq8 jmq bgqcàmq nscbcl pcnclq_pqc* aml `_qc
cl cj _lÅjgqgq bc gleclgcpÖ_, Jmq kmbcjmq w `mqoschmq A?B qml
+++++R +
Npmacqm bc bcagqgål-
årgjcq bsp_lrc j_ d_qc bc _lÅjgqgq w amlacqgâl, N_p_ ncpdcaagml_p Qcjcaagål bcj bgqcãm
cj bgqcàm* qc apc_l bg`shmq w kmbcjmq A?B cl 0B m 1B,
2, Gknjckclr_agâl-bmaskclr_agâl8 qc amlajswcl w _npsc`_l jmq
bg`shmq bc npmbsaagâl w-m dslagml_kgclrm osc npmnmpagml_l
jmq bcr_jjcq bc d_`pga_agâl w clq_k`jc, Gknjckclr_agål

Gbc_jkclrc cj bgqcàm rp_lqasppc _ rp_tÉq bc cqr_q cr_n_q* ncpm


as_lbm f_w gldmpk_agâl lsct_ bgqnmlg`jc* nsbgcp_ pcoscpgpqc tmj+
tcp _ sl_ cr_n_ _lrcpgmp w pcncrgp cj npmacqm, Nmp chcknjm* aml `_qc Bmaskclr_agål
cl cj _lÅjgqgq bc gleclgcpÖ_* bsp_lrc j_ cr_n_ bc pcdgl_kgclrm-_lÅ+
jgqgq nmbpÖ_ clrp_p cl hscem j_ d_kmq_ dp_qc °bc lsctm _ j_ kcq_ bc
bg`shm¢ , /,/. Cr_n_q bcj npmacqm bc bgqcãm,

   
6 A?N≠RSJM / JCLES?HC EP™DGAM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M

FjcajeanÉ]_kj_qnnajpa
K_picrgle Bc k_lcp_ rp_bgagml_j* j_q _argtgb_bcq bc bgqcàm w k_lsd_arsp_ qc
f_l jjct_bm _ a_`m cl mpbcl qcasclag_j cl jse_p bc amlasppclrc &bc
k_lcp_ qgksjrÅlc_', Jmq bgqcà_bmpcq bcbga_pÖ_l sl cqdscpxm w sl
Gleclgcpá_
rgcknm amlqgbcp_`jcq _j _lÅjgqgq bc jmq amknmlclrcq w j_ npcn_p_+
agâl bc nj_lmq bcr_jj_bmq bc j_q ngcx_q* n_p_ bcqnsÉq cltg_pjmq _
mrpmq bcn_pr_kclrmq, Nmp chcknjm* cj bcn_pr_kclrm bc k_rcpg_jcq
srgjgx_ cj bg`shm n_p_ gbclrgdga_p j_q _jc_agmlcq w osÉ npmtccbmpcq
K_lsd_arsp_ bc k_rcpg_jcq n_prgasj_pcq srgjgx_p, BcqnsÉq* cj bcn_pr_kclrm bc
k_lsd_arsp_ gbclrgdga_ jmq npmacqmq lcacq_pgmq n_p_ j_ npmbsaagâl
cdgagclrc, Cqr_ qcasclag_ bc n_qmq n_pcac jâega_* ncpm cl j_ npÅarga_
?jk_aÖl f_ bckmqrp_bm qcp gknpmbsargt_,
Nmp chcknjm* qg sl gleclgcpm bc k_lsd_arsp_ osgqgcp_ _fsq_p j_
`pgb_ bc sl_ n_prc n_p_ osc qc_ kÅq dÅagj dslbgpÖ_ cl kcr_j* m cjcegp
sl_ _jc_agâl bgdcpclrc* j_ cr_n_ bc _lÅjgqgq bc bgqcàm rclbpÖ_ osc
Npmbsarm dgl_j pcncrgpqc n_p_ _qcesp_p osc cj npmbsarm qgesgcp_ dslagml_lbm aml
cdga_ag_, Cqr_q glrcp_aagmlcq* osc qc gjsqrp_l cl j_ dgesp_ /,/ j_* nsc+
&_' Npmacqm qcasclag_G bcl qcp lcacq_pg_q* ncpm bcqncpbgag_l pcaspqmq w* jm kÅq gknmpr_lrc*
rgcknm, Cj rgcknm cq gknmpr_lrc nmposc j_ glrpmbsaagâl rcknp_l_
Gleclgcpá_
bc sl npmbsarm f_ac nmqg`jc sl_ k_wmp n_prgagn_agâl cl cj kcpa_bm
&w nmp amlqgesgclrc k_wmpcq `clcdgagmq'* _qÖ amkm sl_ tgb_ kÅq
j_pe_ _lrcq bc osc cj npmbsarm qc tscjt_ m`qmjcrm &m`tg_kclrc* sl_
K_lsd_arsp_ ?jk_aÖl npcmasn_agâl _ars_j bc j_ cjcarpâlga_ bc amlqskm',
J_ fkdbkfboÖ^ `lk`roobkqb cq sl kÉrmbm qgqrckÅrgam osc gl+
rcep_ cj bgqcàm w j_ k_lsd_arsp_ bc npmbsarmq aml cj m`hcrgtm bc
mnrgkgx_p rmbmq jmq cjckclrmq osc glrcptgclcl cl cj agajm bc tgb_
bcj npmbsarm, Cl j_ dgesp_ /,/ G` qc gjsqrp_ cj npmacqm bc bgqcàm aml+
asppclrc,
Cj afpbálabi`f`ilabsfa^ qgelgdga_ osc rmbmq jmq _qncarmq bc
sl npmbsarm &amkm qs bgqcàm* bcq_ppmjjm* npmbsaagâl* bgqrpg`sagâl*
sqm* bgqnmqgagâl dgl_j w pcagaj_hc' qc amlqgbcp_l bc dmpk_ qgksjrÅ+
lc_, Cl j_ dgesp_ /,/0 qc kscqrp_ cj agajm bc tgb_ bc sl npmbsarm*
&`' Npmacqmq amlasppclrcq bcqbc qs amlacnagâl f_qr_ qs bcqcafm,
Jmq m`hcrgtmq `Åqgamq bc j_ gleclgcpÖ_ amlasppclrc qml kglg+
/,// Kmbcjm bcj npmacqm bc bgqcãm amlasppclrc, kgx_p cj bgqcàm bcj npmbsarm w jmq a_k`gmq bc gleclgcpÖ_* _qÖ amkm
pcbsagp cj rgcknm w cj amqrm gknjga_bmq cl j_q d_qcq bcj bcq_ppmjjm
bc sl npmbsarm bcqbc qs bgqcàm f_qr_ qs npmbsaagâl w* cl åjrgk_
glqr_lag_* qs glrpmbsaagâl _j kcpa_bm, Cl j_ gleclgcpÖ_ amlasppclrc
rmb_q j_q bgqagnjgl_q cqrÅl gltmjsap_b_q cl j_q npgkcp_q cr_n_q bcj
bgqcàm* nmp jm osc j_q grcp_agmlcq l_rsp_jcq b_l amkm pcqsjr_bm sl
B R +k t J ú h
J A.!AC@GP BGQC}?P
kclmp bcqncpbgagm bc cqdscpxm w rgcknm,
J_ amkslga_agâl clrpc w bclrpm bc j_q bgqagnjgl_q cq cqncag_j+
kclrc gknmpr_lrc cl sl npmacqm bc bgqcàm amlasppclrc, J_ glrc+
P cargdga_agâl bcj npmbsarm p_aagâl cdga_x clrpc j_ gleclgcpÖ_* j_ kcpa_bmrcalg_ w j_q dslagmlcq
F ( ..qoschm b c j_ gbc_agâl \ bc qcptgagm* _qÖ amkm clrpc j_q qs`bgqagnjgl_q bc j_ gleclgcpÖ_* qc

g
( ( ( ù ( , K mbcj_bm A?M pcamlmac amkm apsag_j n_p_ cqrc rgnm bc npmacqmq, J_ amkslga_agâl
MOLAR@QL glrcpbgqagnjgl_pg_ r_k`gÉl _wsb_ _ npmnmpagml_p sl _k`gclrc dÉprgj
n_p_ jmq kÉrmbmq gllmt_bmpcq osc nscbcl amlbsagp _ _fmppmq cl
PC?JGX?P
amqrmq bc k_rcpg_j w bc npmbsaagâl,
\ \ c l r m bcj clq_ldajc í O &.&&+
,, å-I, ( \ l Ö b â l bc ngcx_q cl
#%K&f! D  &y0 ( b m as k cl r_b â l í \ _è s- í M( AeoaÜk ]oeope`k lkn_ki lqp]`kn]
íK cpa_bmrcalg_ í Rp_lqnm\ ..
u`ao]nnkhhk `a lnk`q_pko
N_p_ j_q cknpcq_q ep_lbcq w ncoscà_q* cj bgqcàm bc npmbsarmq qscjc
ABA-SQL Z T gknjga_p j_ npcn_p_agâl bc kmbcjmq _l_jÖrgamq w dÖqgamq bcj npmbsarm
\U Ay. BGQNMQGAG≠L osc nscbcl srgjgx_pqc n_p_ cqrsbg_p d_armpcq amkm dscpx_q* cqdscp+
xmq* bcdjcvgmlcq w j_ dmpk_ ânrgk_ bc j_ ngcx_, J_ lcacqgb_b bc
bcrclgkgclrm í PcÅb_hc
cqrc rgnm bc kmbcjmq bcnclbc bc j_ amknjchgb_b bcj npmbsarm, Cl
j_ _ars_jgb_b* cj npmacqm bc amlqrpsgp w cqrsbg_p kmbcjmq _l_jÖrgamq
/,/0 Agajm bc tgb_ bc sl npmbsarm, qc qgknjgdga_ kcbg_lrc cj sqm bc j_q rÉalga_q bc afpbál^pfpqfalmlo
JCLES?HC EP™DG AM S L G T C P Q ? J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M 7

`ljmrq^alo^ &A?B'* fkdbkfboÖ^ ^pfpqfa^ mlo `ljmrq^alo^


&A?C' w j^krc^`qro^^pfpqfa^mlo`ljmrq^alo^ &A?K', Cq+
rmq qgqrck_q ncpkgrcl sl _lÅjgqgq pÅngbm bcj bgqcàm bc m`hcrmq
qclagjjmq* _qÖ amkm bc cqrpsarsp_q amknjch_q,
A?B ncpkgrc sl _knjgm p_lem bc _argtgb_bcq* bcqbc cj
kmbcj_bm ecmkÉrpgam cl 0B w 1B f_qr_ j_ apc_agâl bc bg`shmq
osc bmaskclr_l cj bgqcàm n_p_ j_ k_lsd_arsp_ w j_q amlqgbc+
p_agmlcq jce_jcq,
A?K npmnmpagml_ sl amlrpmj amknsr_pgx_bm bc jmq npmac+
qmq bc k_lsd_arsp_, Jmq chcknjmq glajswcl cj sqm bc sl_ glrcp+
d_x bc amknsr_bmp_ n_p_ amlrpmj_p sl rmkm* m j_ eclcp_agâl bc
j_ rp_wcarmpg_ n_p_ cj dpcq_bm bc kÅosgl_q+fcpp_kgclr_ bgpca+
r_kclrc bcqbc cj kmbcjm A?B, Cl qgqrck_q kÅq qmdgqrga_bmq*
A?K nscbc srgjgx_pqc cl cj k_lchm* clq_k`jc c glqncaagâl bc
k_rcpg_jcq,
A?C ncpkgrc _ jmq sqs_pgmq qgksj_p w _l_jgx_p cqrpsarsp_q
osc cqr_pÅl qmkcrgb_q _ bgdcpclrcq rckncp_rsp_q* a_pe_q cqrÅ+ Sl bgqcã_bmp cqrpsarsp_j rp_`_h_lbm aml A?B, &Amprcqá_ bc
rga_q m a_pe_q djsars_lrcq, Cj _lÅjgqgq aglckÅrgam cqrsbg_ j_q Ipwaxi_ Z gQrmain fmrm ,am k',
ngcx_q kâtgjcq, ?jesl_q bc cqr_q dslagmlcq cqrÅl glrcep_b_q
aml qmdru_pc bc A?B* w mrpmq n_oscrcq gknmpr_l b_rmq bcqbc
sl qgqrck_ A?B, Kcbg_lrc cj sqm bc cqr_q fcpp_kgclr_q jmq gl+ C k n pcq_ c v rcl b gb _ U gl b af gjj
eclgcpmq nscbcl qgksj_p* _l_jgx_p w bgqcà_p npsc`_q bc k_lcp_
cdgagclrc* npcagq_ w pÅngb_,

AeoaÜk `a _]he`]` aj hkolnk`q_pko


J_q amkn_àÖ_q sq_l sl_ qcpgc bc kÉrmbmq qgqrckÅrgamq n_p_ rp_+ HUYPOTUWW
r_p bc bgqcà_p °a_jgb_b¢ cl qsq npmbsarmq* _qÖ amkm n_p_ kcbgp
cj pclbgkgclrm w rmk_p bcagqgmlcq aml `_qc cl b_rmq, Jmq bgqc+
à_bmpcq nscbcl qclrgp osc qs kÉrmbm apc_rgtm n_p_ j_ pcqmjs+
agâl bc npm`jck_q qc _fme_ as_lbm cqrmq qgqrck_q lm cqrÅl `gcl
gknjckclr_bmq cl cj qgrgm bc rp_`_hm9 ncpm as_lbm qc _njga_l
5WUQY_Q F^`M]UZPQW
bc j_ k_lcp_ _bcas_b_* j_q mpe_lgx_agmlcq nscbcl kmqrp_p sl_ PQ[M]_MXQY_Z
kchmp_ cl j_ a_jgb_b, PQOZX[]M^
BDQQ Afpbálm^o^P fuPfdj^ cq sl kÉrmbm osc sq_ fc+
pp_kgclr_q bc gleclgcpÖ_ w cqr_bÖqrga_q n_p_ bgqcà_p npmbsarmq
bc sl_ dmpk_ osc npcbgac w pcbsac _j kÖlgkm jmq npm`jck_q B]ZaQQPZ]; ?Z_Z] F^`M]UZPQWPQ[M]_MXQY_Z
aml jmq ajgclrcq w j_q bgdgasjr_bcq bc d_`pga_agâl, PQNh^\`QPM PQUYSQYUQ]gM
P fuPfdj^ cq sl npmacqm mpgegl_bm cl Kmrmpmj_ n_p_ kchm+
p_p j_ a_jgb_b kcbg_lrc j_ pcbsaagâl m cjgkgl_agâl bc bcdcarmq, /,/1 Ecqrgål bc b_rmq bc npmbsarm, Tfka`efiiabMQ@bprk
BK?GA Abcfkfo*Jbafo*>k^ifw^o*J bglo^ov@lkqoli^o pfpqbj^abdbpqfÉkaba^qlpabilpmolar`qlpabqla^i^bjmobp^*
qml jmq n_qmq bcdglgbmq cl sl npmacqm bc kchmp_ amlrgls_ osc afpbÇ^alm^o^buqbkabopbvpbosfoa^qlpjbaf^kqbi^obafkqbok^
glrclr_ bcdglgp w e_p_lrgx_p j_q a_p_arcpÖqrga_q apÖrga_q n_p_ b &lfkqo^kbq', I^fkcloj^`fÉkabi^_^pbaba^qlppbmolmlo`flk^
dslagml_kgclrm &ARD', ^ilprpr^oflpbuqboklp^qo^s}pabrkpfqflpbdrol*molqbdfal
ODB Abpmifbdrbabi^crk`fàkab`^ifa^a cq sl_ fcpp_+ `lk`lkqo^pbÇ^&m^o^`ljm^oqfofkcloj^`fÉkklmÖ_if`^`lk
kgclr_ n_p_ j_ rmk_ bc bcagqgmlcq osc _wsb_ _ j_q cknpcq_q molsbbalobpvlqolppl`flpbkird^obpafpq^kqbp', &Amprcqá_ bc
_ _bmnr_p sl cldmosc mpgclr_bm _j ajgclrc w _ sl amlhslrm bc N_p_kcrpga Rcaflmjmew Ampnmp_rgml',
a_p_arcpÖqrga_q bcj npmbsarm,

?]oa `a `]pko`ecep]h NBK ncpkgrc osc rmbmq jmq b_rmq bcj npmbsarm qc _jk_aclcl*
Cj sqm bc j_ amknsr_bmp_ qgesc a_k`g_lbm j_ k_lcp_ cl osc pcasncpcl* tgqs_jgacl* gknpgk_l* _bkglgqrpcl w rp_lqdgcp_l pÅ+
qc npmbsacl jmq _prÖasjmq, Rmb_ j_ gldmpk_agâl n_p_ ecqrgml_p* ngb_kclrc _ as_josgcp n_prc bc j_ mpe_lgx_agâl, Cqrm ncpkgrc
bgqcà_p* _l_jgx_p* qgksj_p* ckn_a_p* tclbcp w d_`pga_p sl npm+ mnrgkgx_p m kmbgdga_p bgpcar_kclrc jmq bgqcàmq cl as_josgcp
bsarm nscbc amkn_prgpqc aml sl epsnm bgtcpqm &w r_j tcx ecm+ kmkclrm, Jmq amqrmq* j_q pctgqgmlcq bcj npmbsarm w j_q àoabkbp
epÅdga_kclrc bgqr_lrc' bc sqs_pgmq _ rp_tÉq bc sl_ ålga_ `_qc ab `^j_flp ab fkdbkfboÖ^ &CAM' nscbcl _l_jgx_pqc* amlrpm+
bc b_rmq bgegr_jcq amknjchmq, j_pqc c gknjckclr_pqc aml p_ngbcx, J_ ecqrgâl bc b_rmq bc j_
Jmq qgqrck_q n_p_ j_ dbpqfàkaba^qlpabimolar`ql &NBK' cknpcq_ pcosgcpc amknpmkgqm w nj_lgdga_agâl* ncpm j_q amk+
m n_p_ j_ dbpqfàkaba^qlpabi^bjmobp^ &CBK' _jk_acl_l cl n_àÖ_q osc jjct_l _ a_`m aml cdga_ag_ j_ NBK nscbcl a_nrsp_p
dmpk_ cjcarpâlga_ jmq bgdcpclrcq rgnmq bc b_rmq _qmag_bmq aml cj jmq b_rmq bcj npmbsarm sl_ tcx w srgjgx_pjmq bc ksaf_q k_lcp_q
bgqcàm w j_ d_`pga_agâl bc sl npmbsarm, Sl qgqrck_ cdga_x bc n_p_ jmep_p sl_ tclr_h_ amkncrgrgt_ &dgesp_ /,/1',

   
/. A?N≠RSJM / JCLES?HC EP™DGAM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M

/,/ BQ>M>/ ABIAFPB|L ABFKDBKFBO£>


F`ajpebe_]_eáj `ah _heajpau`ah lnk^hai ]
J_ dslagâl `Åqga_ bcj bgqcàm bc gleclgcpÖ_ cq npmnmpagml_p qmjs+
agmlcq _ jmq npm`jck_q w q_rgqd_acp j_q lcacqgb_bcq m bcqcmq bc jmq
npmbsarmq* qcptgagmq m qgqrck_q, Cj npmacqm bcj bgqcàm bc gleclgcpÖ_
amkgclx_ aml cj pcamlmagkgclrm m j_ gbclrgdga_agâl bc cqr_q lcacqg+
b_bcq w j_ amlqgbcp_agâl bc j_ tg_`gjgb_b camlâkga_ bc qs nmqg`jc
q_rgqd_aagâl, Sl `scl bgqcàm lm qâjm bc`c pcqmjtcp cj npm`jck_*
qglm r_k`gÉl bc`c q_rgqd_acpj_q lcacqgb_bcq w bcqcmq bcj ajgclrc, Bc
cqrm qc bcqnpclbc osc as_josgcp lsctm bgqcàm* _qÖ amkm cj npmacqm
bc bgqcàm pcj_agml_bm* bc`c cqr_p gknsjq_bm cl åjrgk_ glqr_lag_
nmp j_q lcacqgb_bcq bcj sqs_pgm dgl_j, Jmq npmbsarmq bc`cl asknjgp
aml jmq cqrÅlb_pcq w j_q pcesj_agmlcq bcj em`gcplm* _qÖ amkm _bfc+
pgpqc _ j_q lmpk_q m aâbgemq bc j_q mpe_lgx_agmlcq npmdcqgml_jcq,
Jmq bgqcàmq bc gleclgcpÖ_ t_l bcqbc jmq qclagjjmq w bc `_hm amq+
rm* amkm j_ jcleécr_ bc sl clt_qc n_p_ `c`gb_q* f_qr_ jmq amknjchmq w
amqrmqmq* amkm jmq npmbsarmq osc q_rgqd_acl j_q lcacqgb_bcq bc tg_hc
nmp _gpc* rgcpp_ w cj cqn_agm, Glajsqm j_ apc_agâl bc sl npmbsarm r_l
ncoscàm amkm j_ r_n_ bc sl_ j_r_ bc `c`gb_ pcdpcqa_lrc lcacqgr_ fc+
pp_kgclr_q bc npmbsaagâl osc gknjga_l sl amlqgbcp_`jc cqdscpxm bc
gleclgcpÖ_ w bgqcàm,
Jmq npmbsarmq nscbcl qcp lsctmq m tcpqgmlcq kmbgdga_b_q bc /,/2 Lsctm bgqcãm bc sl npmbsarm rp_bgagml_j8
npmbsarmq w_ cvgqrclrcq, Nmp chcknjm* jmq bgqcàmq bc p_bgmq* rmqr_+ cjcarpmbmkÖqrgamq rp_lqn_pclrcq, BkbpqbafpbÇlkl
bmp_q* pcjmhcq* _srmkâtgjcq w j_t_bmp_q f_l qgbm n_pcagbmq bsp_lrc rqfifw^almloMefifmp Am, ilprpr^oflpmrbabksbo`Éjlpb
_àmq* ncpm qs cqrgjm w a_p_arcpÖqrga_q f_l a_k`g_bm n_p_ pcdjch_p j_q qrbpq^prm^kl`Éjlefbosbbi^dr^*^qo^s}pab`r_fboq^p
lsct_q lcacqgb_bcq w npcdcpclag_q &dgesp_ /,/2', eb`e^pabsfaoflbksbwab^`bolfklufa^_ib, Mbolnrbbi
A_qg rmbmq jmq bgqcàmq pcosgcpcl f_acp amlacqgmlcq n_p_ ask+ fkqbofloabi^qlpq^alo^pbj^kqrsfbo^ifjmflcrbrkobqlab
njgp aml j_q pcqrpgaagmlcq npcqsnscqr_pg_q* jmq m`hcrgtmq bc k_p+ fkdbkfboÅ^nrbpfdkfcf`Énrbi^qlpq^alo^krk`^iibd^o^^i^
icrgle w mrp_q amlqgbcp_agmlcq, Cj rgcknm npcqsnscqr_bm n_p_ sl iÅkb^abmolar``fÉk, &Npmwcarm apc_bm w bcq_ppmjj_bm nmp
npmwcarm lm cq sl_ cvacnagâl, Nfgjgnq Bcqgel',

/,0 BQ>M>0ABIAFPB|L ABFKDBKFBOF>


Dajan]_eáj `a _kj_alpko
BcqnsÉq bc gbclrgdga_p sl npm`jck_ m lcacqg+
b_b* cj cosgnm bc bgqcàm amkgclx_ _ eclcp_p
nmqg`jcq qmjsagmlcq, Bsp_lrc cqr_ cr_n_* _ kc+
lsbm jj_k_b_ j_ d_qc bc fab^`fàk* qc pcamecl
ksaf_q gbc_q* qc_l p_xml_`jcq m lm, J_q gbc_q
nscbcl npmtclgp bc ncpqml_q m `gcl bcq_ppm+
jj_pqc cl j_q qcqgmlcq bc jjstg_ bc gbc_q bcj
cosgnm, W_ qc_ sl npmacqm bc epsnm m glbgtg+
bs_j* jmq amlacnrmq osc lm pcqsjrcl _bcas_bmq
amkm qmjsagmlcq nscbcl qcptgp amkm rp_knm+
jÖl n_p_ eclcp_p kÅq gbc_q,
Bsp_lrc j_ d_qc bc gbc_agâl cq dpcasclrc
cj sqm bc `mqoschmq rÉalgamq, Qs a_n_agb_b bc
apc_p jg`pckclrc `mqoschmq rÉalgamq jc ncpkgrc
npcqclr_p w amkn_prgp gbc_q* _qÖ amkm pcegq+
rp_pj_q n_p_ osc nscb_ cknjc_pj_q cl j_q qm+
jsagmlcq* glqngp_agmlcq w _t_lacq osc qsph_l
bsp_lrc cqr_ cr_n_ apc_rgt_ bcj npmacqm, Rmb_q
j_q lmr_q w `mqoschmq bc`cl cqr_p dgpk_bmq* dc+
af_bmq w bc`cl amlqcpt_pqc n_p_ j_ bmaskcl+
r_agâl bc bgqcàm w amkm sl_ nmqg`jc npsc`_
n_p_ j_ m`rclagâl bc j_ n_rclrc, Cl j_ dgesp_
/,/3 qc kscqrp_ sl `mqoschm bc gbc_agâl apc_bm
bsp_lrc cj bcq_ppmjjm bc j_ kmrmagajcr_ CLT, /, @mqoschm bc gbc_agål, &Amprcqá_ bc Qcwkmspnmucjj',
/ ,1 CR?N? 1 BCJ BGQCÄM BC GLECLGCP≠?

/,1 BQ>M> 1 ABIAFPB|L


AB FKDBKFBO£>
Pkhq_ekjao_kjoajoq]`]o
BcqnsÉq bc amlqgbcp_p asgb_bmq_kclrc cj npm`jck_* cj cosg+
nm bc bgqcàm qcjcaagml_ t_pg_q a_p_arcpÖqrga_q bc jmq amlacnrmq
eclcp_bmq cl j_ d_qc bc gbc_agâl w jmq amk`gl_ cl sl_ m kÅq
qmjsagmlcq amlqclqs_b_q osc qml npmkcrcbmp_q, Cl cqrc km+
kclrm qc ct_jå_ _ bcr_jjc j_ kchmp qmjsagâl w qc f_acl glrclrmq
nmp qgknjgdga_pj_ bc kmbm osc rcle_ sl bcqckncàm cdgagclrc w
qc_ dÅagj bc d_`pga_p w bc pcn_p_p* c glajsqm osc qs bcqcafm qc_
qclagjjm as_lbm qs tgb_ årgj f_w_ rcpkgl_bm,
Jmq `mqoschmq bc bgqcàm pcdgl_bmq qscjcl gp qcesgbmq bc
sl cqrsbgm bc k_rcpg_jcq _bcas_bmq &dgesp_ /,/4' w bc jmq npm+
`jck_q bc kmtgjgb_b osc nscb_l cqr_p gknjga_bmq, öOsÉ dscl+
rc bc clcpeÖ_ qc t_ _ srgjgx_l k_ls_j* kmrmp cjÉarpgam* m _jeål
mrpm kcbgm= öOsÉ rgnm bc kmtgkgclrm qc pcosgcpc= öCq lcac+
q_pgm rp_bsagp cj kmtgkgclrm pmr_rmpgm cl kmtgkgclrm jglc_j* m
tgactcpq_= Ksafmq bc cqrmq npm`jck_q qc pcqscjtcl epÅdga_+ /,/4 Cqr_ `_qc bc b_rmq n_p_ j_ qcjcaagål bc k_rcpg_jcq cl
kclrc srgjgx_lbm bg`shmq cqosckÅrgamq cl jmq osc t_pg_q n_prcq QmjgbUmpiq npmnmpagml_ gldmpk_agål _acpa_ bcj gkn_arm
qc kscqrp_l cl dmpk_ bc cqoscjcrm, Nmp chcknjm* j_q nmjc_q w _k`gclr_j bc jmq k_rcpg_jcq,
clep_l_hcq qc pcnpcqclr_l kcbg_lrc aÖpasjmq* sl `p_xm nmp sl_
jÖlc_ qclagjj_ w sl_ rp_wcarmpg_ bc kmtgkgclrm kcbg_lrc jÖlc_q
aclrp_jcq &dgesp_ /,/5', Cl cqrc nslrm r_k`gÉl nscbcl f_acpqc kscqrp_ cj r_k_àm pc_j bcj bgqcàm* bc kmbm osc j_q npmnmpagm+
agcprmq aÅjasjmq `Åqgamq* amkm jmq pcj_agml_bmq aml j_ tcjmag+ lcq w _hsqrcq nscb_l tgqs_jgx_pqc aml aj_pgb_b* m nscbc sq_pqc
b_b w j_ _acjcp_agâl, sl `mqoschm bc bgqcàm aj_p_kclrc bgkclqgml_bm, Cl j_ dgesp_
Bc jmq cqrsbgmq npcjgkgl_pcq qgesc sl_ bgqrpg`sagâl bcj bg+ /,/6 qc kscqrp_ sl chcknjm, Cl cqrc kmkclrm rmb_q j_q ngcx_q
qcàm* nmp jm eclcp_j kcbg_lrc sl bg`shm npcagqm bc A?B osc f_l qgbm asgb_bmq_kclrc bgqcà_b_q cl as_lrm _ qs pcqgqrclag_

/,/5 Sl bgqcãm cl A?B osc kscqrp_ j_q a_p_arcpáqrga_q cl dmpk_ bc cqoscjcrm, &Amprcqá_ bc Qcwkmspnmucjj',

   
/0 A?N≠RSJM / JCLES?HC EP™DGAM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M

•OLJL>CFI>AL @LOQ>ALO TLLAORCC


V  AROL MI J4 . 6  JLAFCF@>AL
> 2 3 å  FK@I
Y6 O>KRO>
p + @ FO

0 (F H L

@FIFK A OL  AB> FO B ,
MBOC / .  ok j + P Q V ! /

/,/6 Bgqrpg`sagål bcj bgqcãm,

w dslagml_jgb_b, Jmq amqrmq qc k_lrgclcl amlqr_lrckclrc cl j_ jg`pcq bc n_prcq kâtgjcq* _ j_ d_agjgb_b bc kmlr_hc w _j k_lrc+
kclrc* nmposc qgl gknmpr_p jm `gcl osc qc bcqckncàc cj bgqnm+ lgkgclrm, Qgcknpc osc qc_ nmqg`jc qc cknjc_l ngcx_q cqrÅlb_p
qgrgtm* bc`c tclbcpqc aml srgjgb_b9 bc jm amlrp_pgm* cj rgcknm w nmposc qml kclmq amqrmq_q osc j_q ngcx_q fcaf_q nmp cla_p+
jmq amqrmq bc bcq_ppmjjm f_`pÅl qgbm sl_ nÉpbgb_, em, Jmq k_rcpg_jcq w jmq amqrmq qc rmk_l cl asclr_ aml ksafm
Cl j_ dgesp_ /,/6 qc kscqrp_ j_ bgqrpg`sagâl bc j_q npmnmp+ asgb_bm, ?slosc j_q amlqgbcp_agmlcq dslagml_jcq bc`cl qcp
agmlcq `Åqga_q bc j_q ngcx_q w aâkm qc _hsqr_l clrpc qÖ cl sl npgkmpbg_jcq* cl rmbm kmkclrm qc bc`cl rclcp npcqclrcq jmq
bg`shm bc clq_k`jc, Qc npcqr_ _rclagâl cqncag_j _ jmq cqn_agmq npm`jck_q bc k_lsd_arsp_,

/,2 BQ>M>2ABIAFPB|L
ABFKDBKFBO£>
Jk`ahkoulnkpkpelko
Cl ma_qgmlcq* jmq cosgnmq bc bgqcàm amlqrpswcl sl kmbcjm _
cqa_j_ n_p_ cqrsbg_p* _l_jgx_p w ncpdcaagml_p cj bgqcàm, Sl km+
bcjm dslagml_j bc r_k_àm amknjcrm bc _ascpbm aml j_q cqncag+
dga_agmlcq dgl_jcq &cvacnrm* nmqg`jckclrc* nmp jmq k_rcpg_jcq'
qc amlmac amkm sl molqlqfml, Jmq rp_`_h_bmpcq k_ls_jcq bcj
r_jjcp bc kmbcjmq qscjcl rp_`_h_p _ n_prgp bc `mqoschmq m bg+
`shmq A?B bgkclqgml_bmq n_p_ apc_p sl npmrmrgnm osc nsc+
b_ sq_pqc cl j_q npsc`_q w cl j_ tgqs_jgx_agâl, Cj npmrmrgnm qc
npsc`_ w kmbgdga_ as_lbm cq lcacq_pgm w j_ gldmpk_agâl m`rc+
lgb_ qc srgjgx_ n_p_ pctgq_p cj bgqcàm qg _qÖ qc pcosgcpc, As_lbm
cj kmbcjm lm pcqsjr_ q_rgqd_armpgm* nscbc qcp lcacq_pgm tmjtcp
_ sl_ cr_n_ _lrcpgmp bcj npmacqm bc bgqcàm w pcncrgp cj npmac+
bgkgclrm* rclgclbm cl asclr_ jm _npclbgbm bsp_lrc cj npmacqm
bc npsc`_, Nmp qsnscqrm* j_q amlqgbcp_agmlcq bc rgcknm w e_qrm
qgcknpc cqr_`jcacl cj jÖkgrc n_p_ j_ bsp_agâl bc cqrc agajm, Nmp
åjrgkm* cj cosgnm bc`c rmk_p sl_ bcagqgâl n_p_ cj kmbcjm bc
/,/7 Kmbcjm A?B cl 1B, Bpqbjlabil @>Abk1Aabrk npmbsaagâl,
afpbÇlm^o^bibumilo^aloabJ^oqbpb`lkpqorvÉ`ljlrk Cl j_ dgesp_ /,/7 qc kscqrp_ sl npmrmrgnm tgprs_j bcj Cv+
molqlqfmlsfoqr^iabiafpbÇl, &Amprcqá_ bc j_ @wpml Hmflq', njmp_bmp Qcespm n_p_ L_tce_agâl cl K_prc,

   
/ ,2 CR?N? 2 BCJ BGQCÄM BC GLECLGCP≠?

/,0. ?w_ll_ Fmu_pb w cj npmrmrgnm bcj Cvnjmp_bmp Qcespm n_p_ L_tce_agål cl K_prc, Bibumilo^aloabJ^oqbbprk^plir`fÉk^
rk^kb`bpfa^aabimoldo^j^bpm^`f^im^o^bumilo^o|ob^pj|pdo^kabpabi^prmbocf`fbj^o`f^k^, &Amprcqá_ bc Kgaf_cj Epcaam-jaml
Glrcpl_rgml_j',

Sl kmbcjm A?B cl 1B npcagqm nscbc _ars_p amkm sl npmrm+


rgnm tgprs_j* jm osc f_ac osc cl ma_qgmlcq glajsqm qc_ gllcacq_pgm
apc_p sl npmrmrgnm dÖqgam n_p_ npm`_p cj bgqcàm, Srgjgx_lbm sl km+
bcjm A?B npcagqm* jmq bgqcà_bmpcq nscbcl m`qcpt_p jmq cqn_agmq w
a_jasj_p j_q npmngcb_bcq bc k_q_, Sl `clcdgagm _bgagml_j cq j_ a_+
n_agb_b bc apc_p pcnpcqclr_agmlcq pc_jgqr_q bcj kmbcjm* osc nscbcl
sq_pqc bsp_lrc j_ tgqs_jgx_agâl bcj bgqcàm, ?jesl_q tcacq* j_ ngcx_*
qmk`pc_b_ w pcnpcqclr_b_ sq_lbm A?B* qc tc _ål kchmp osc cj
npmbsarm dgl_j* bc`gbm _ j_ ncpdcaagâl bc j_ gk_ecl A?B cl amk+
n_p_agâl aml j_q qsncpdgagcq pc_jcq, Cl j_ dgesp_ /,0. qc kscqrp_ sl
npmrmrgnm tgprs_j bc sl bgqcàm bcj cvnjmp_bmp bc K_prc,

Jk`ahkoejpahecajpao
Cj jlabi^alm ^o^jÉqof`l* _^p^albkobpqof``flkbp m _^p^albk`^+
o^`qboÖpqf`^p sq_ t_pg_`jcq n_p_ pcqrpglegp j_ dmpk_ bc j_ ecmkcrpÖ_,
Qg cj bgqcà_bmp sq_ cj kmbcj_bm `_q_bm cl a_p_arcpÖqrga_q* `mqosch_
dmpk_q glgag_jcq _npmvgk_b_q w _njga_ bgkclqgmlcq w pcqrpgaagmlcq
_j bg`shm n_p_ apc_p kmbcjmq aml °glrcjgeclag_¢, BcqnsÉq* as_lbm cj
bgqcàm cqrÅ pcdgl_bm* cj kmbcjm nscbc _ars_jgx_pqc _ kcbgb_ osc
cÖ bgqcà_bmp a_k`g_ j_q bgkclqgmlcq w j_q jgkgr_agmlcq n_p_ osc lm
f_w_ lcacqgb_b bc apc_p lsctmq kmbcjmq n_p_ a_b_ a_k`gm bc bgqc+
àm, ?bckÅq* j_q pcqrpgaagmlcq w bgkclqgmlcq osc amlrpmj_l cqrc rgnm
bc kmbcjmq A?B cl 1B nscbcl a_jasj_pqc aml `_qc cl jmq b_rmq bcj
bgqcàm bc gleclgcpÖ_, Jmq kmbcjmq kÅq qmdgqrga_bmq nscbcl glajsqm
qcesgp jmq amknjchmq qgqrck_q bc pcej_q dÖqga_q* amkm cj kmbcj_bm
bcj cdcarm bc ep_tcb_b s mrp_q jcwcq dÖqga_q,
Cl j_ dgesp_ /,0/ qc kscqrp_ sl kmbcjm A?B cl 1B osc pcnpc+
qclr_ sl qgqrck_ bc dpclmq srgjgx_bm n_p_ bcrclcp j_ pmr_agâl bc sl /,0/ Kmbcjm A?B cl 1B bcj dpclm Q??P, &Amprcqá_ bc
r_k`mp bc bgl_kâkcrpm, Bwlmhcr Pcqc_paf* Gla,',

   
/2 A?N≠RSJM / JCLES?HC EP™DGAM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M

Mnkpkpel]`k nÄle`k cj fmk`pc m cvnjmp_p j_q pc_aagmlcq bc


jmq ajgclrcq cl epsnmq bc cldmosc bc jmq
Kgclrp_q j_q gbc_q bc bgqcàm qc pcdÖl_l*
_ kclsbm cj cosgnm bc bgqcàm rp_`_h_ cl amlqskgbmpcq kmqrpÅlbmjcq pcnpmbsaagm+
dmpk_ qgksjrÅlc_ aml cj Åpc_ bc k_lsd_a+ lcq bc jmq npmbsarmq bcq_ppmjj_bmq srgjg+
rsp_ n_p_ bcrcpkgl_p j_q kchmpcq k_lcp_q x_lbm cj npmrmrgn_bm pÅngbm, Jmq b_rmq
bc f_acp w clq_k`j_p j_q ngcx_q lcacq_+ bc bgqcàm cl 1B nscbcl dmpk_rc_pqc n_p_
pg_q, BcqnsÉq bc t_pgmq agajmq bc pcdgl_+ qcp sq_bmq cl jmq cosgnmq bc npmrmrgn_bm
agâl* _lÅjgqgq w qÖlrcqgq bc j_q kchmpcq pÅngbm, Cl j_ dgesp_ /,00 qc kscqrp_ cj
gbc_q* cj bgqcàm dgl_j cqrÅ jgqrm n_p_ clrp_p npmrmrgnm bc sl_ ngcx_ osc ckcgec bc sl
cl npmbsaagâl, Jmq qgqrck_q bc Molqlqf+ k_rcpg_j qgl dslbgp cl j_ XNpglrcp 23. bc
m^al oÄmfal ncpkgrcl _ jmq bgqcà_bmpcq npmrmrgn_bm pÅngbm* j_ as_j nscbc °gknpg+
eclcp_p ngcx_q bc k_lcp_ tcjmx* bgpca+ kgb§ cl sl rgcknm _npmvgk_bm bc as_rpm
r_kclrc* _ n_prgp bc kmbcjmq cl 1B n_p_ fmp_q sl_ ngcx_ amkm j_ osc qc kscqrp_,
f_acp k_oscr_q w npm`_pj_q, Nmp chcknjm* Cj npmrmrgn_bm pÅngbm qc cqrsbg_pÅ aml
nscbc npm`_pqc j_ d_agjgb_b bc sqm n_p_ k_wmp npmdslbgb_b cl cj a_nÖrsjm 7,

/,00 Npmrmrgn_bm pÇngbm, I^WMofkqbo23.abW@lom fjmofjfÉ bk^iobabaloab`r^qolelo^p_ mfbw^nrbpbjrbpqo^,


&Amprcqá_ bc X Ampnmp_rgml',

/,3 BQ>M>3ABIAFPB|L ABFKDBKFBO£>


Ae^qfko`a lnk`q__eáj pgb_q, ?qgkgqkm* glampnmp_l lmr_q w mrp_ bc j_ dgesp_ /,02* kscqrp_ aâkm qc slcl
gldmpk_agâl lcacq_pg_ n_p_ bcqapg`gp a_b_ rmb_q j_q ngcx_q cl cj npmbsarm amknjcrm,
k `abqj_ekj]i eajpk ngcx_ bc k_lcp_ qsdgagclrc aml cj dgl bc J_q ngcx_q cqrÅlb_p gl_jrcp_b_q osc
?lrcq bc amlqrpsgp m d_`pga_p sl npmbsa+ osc nscb_l d_`pga_pqc amlqgqrclrckclrc, qc amknp_l °cl cj kmqrp_bmp¢ lm pcosgc+
rm* cq amkål osc qc cj_`mpc sl amlhslrm Cqrmq bg`shmq bc j_q ngcx_q glbgtgbs_jcq pcl bg`shmq bc bcr_jjc* ncpm qc kscqrp_l
dgl_j bc bg`shmq bc npmbsaagâl m bc dsl+ r_k`gÉl qc amlmacl amkm af_rglp ab bc k_lcp_ amltclagml_j cl cj cqosck_ bc
agml_kgclrm* n_p_ qs pctgqgâl w _npm`_+ abq^iib, clq_k`jc w aml j_q cqncagdga_agmlcq bcq+
agâl, Jmq bg`shmq* osc kscqrp_l rmb_q j_q Cl j_ dgesp_ /,01 qc kscqrp_ sl bg`s+ apgr_q cl j_ jgqr_ bc ngcx_q,
tgqr_q lcacq_pg_q* glajswcl cj k_rcpg_j* hm bc bcr_jjc bc sl_ kÉlqsj_ bc kmlr_hc
j_q bgkclqgmlcq w j_q rmjcp_lag_q pcosc+ _Épcm, Sl bpnrbj^abbkp^j_ib* amkm cj

   
/,3 C R?N? 3 BCJ BGQCÄM BC G L E C L G C P ≠ ? /3

g u p ?hl m b ; G B; hG õ M k _ l r s A U M I
Aj?%? p s A ( M ,A ê B /. trKBMõ M U r å M õ
QúM :úL ? õ d m ú u â I L _ ? U m ú õ ( M õQõ® K S A ú (
íqap_qCQ(§ QFMS,M qc A U ? K B @ M K K K m a _

,03.
PU

K M S L R C P A ? L 002
wù+ù(+°†ù†ú< /,01 Bg`shm bc bcr_jjc n_p_ j_ kÖlqsj_
bc kmlr_hc _Öpcm bcj dpclm Q??P,
&Amprcqá_ bc Bwlmhcr Pcqc_paf* Gla,',

LS/ D G? L A C KSQG

dn 8

++++++rg , l ,,,,,,
++++++++++++++++++ fs,] _f gè HsAjs
b ++++++++++++++++++++
\ . ^g & I

:;<8
8i 8 g
d ù5 (í .8.
9g ≤ m Q @ I g@ - %l ≤ /,

l dK L M 5 N?PR L M BCQAPGNRGML
% / U O .1 ? P A?LACP* RW N dddú
0 2 0 +,4+02.. K ? I C ?PK 002
1 0 107/4/22 A jC W GQ DGL, /-5 V 2+ /Q R
2 % 0'4/07./ 4P?IC ?A RS ? RGL E RS6C,002
"6 _vc f: V . CQ t q r gM t â L R 032 @P?HrH ?33W Q U L E ? k ( B ,002
3 0 2/1/0/.3
0 0/4/07.. K ? I C QFMC P r R ? I P ,002
2 0 1161/../ 4P?IC QUMd 002
6 0 00/.7.4/ @ P ? õ K?LECP NGTMR, 002
7 2 107.2... F ( \ , A O l C õ , k â j 1 r d ,Q F ? l ,3rdC gFGC
/,02 Cqosck_ bc clq_k`jc bcj dpclm bc Q??P, &Amprcqá_ bc Bwlmhcr Pcqc_paf* Gla,',

   
/4 A?N≠RSJM / JCLES?HC EP™DGAM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M

/,4 KLOJ>PABDO°CF@>P
Cvgqrcl kloj^p osc b_l qmnmprc _ sl jcles_hc epÅdgam slgdmpkc aml dpcasclag_ n_p_ amkslga_p gldmpk_agâl bc k_lcp_ osc q_rgq+
w cdga_x n_p_ qs sqm cl j_ glbsqrpg_* j_ k_lsd_arsp_* j_ glec+ d_e_ j_q lcacqgb_bcq bc j_ glbsqrpg_ w j_ npÅarga_ bc j_ gleclgcpÖ_
lgcpÖ_ w j_q agclag_q, Jmq rcvrmq bc bg`shm rÉalgam amkm cqrc _ars_j, Qc jcq amlqgbcp_ j_ esÖ_ kÅq amknjcr_ bc npÅarga_q slgdmp+
jg`pm nscbcl _wsb_pjc _ _npclbcp _acpa_ bc cjjmq, Cl Cqr_bmq kcq bc bg`shm cl Cqr_bmq Slgbmq,
Slgbmq* j_ cj_`mp_agâl bc cqr_q lmpk_q f_ qgbm rp_`_hm bc j_ J_q lmpk_q glrcpl_agml_jcq* a_qg qgcknpc bcdglgb_q nmp
?kcpga_l L_rgml_j Qr_lb_pbq Glqrgrsrc &?LQG'* aml j_ ?kcpg+ j_ Glrcpl_rgml_j Mpe_lgx_rgml dmp Qr_lb_pbgx_rgml &GQM'* w
a_l Qmagcrw dmp Cleglccpgle Cbsa_rgml &?QCC'* j_ Qmagcrw md nmp j_q npÅarga_q bc bg`shm bc ?QKC m ?LQG* qml qgkgj_pcq cl
?srmkmrgtc Cleglccpq &Q?C'* w j_ ?kcpga_l Qmagcrw md Kc+ ksafmq _qncarmq, J_q k_wmpcq bgdcpclag_q qc clasclrp_l cl cj
af_lga_j Cleglccpq &?QKC', kÉrmbm npcdcpgbm bc npmwcaagâl8 npgkcp Ålesjm amlrp_ rcpacp
Jmq n_prgagn_lrcq cl cqr_q mpe_lgx_agmlcq _wsb_l _ bc+ bc Ålesjm bc npmwcaagâl* w cl j_q slgb_bcq bc kcbgagâl cl
q_ppmjj_p cj J^kr^i ab i^ Kloj^ K^`flk^i >jbof`^k^ m^o^ cÖ bgkclqgml_kgclrm, Cl cqrc rcvrm sqrcb _npclbcpÅ _ sq_p cj
Af_rgl+V /2* j_ as_j qc amknmlc bc sl_ qcpgc bc qcaagmlcq gl+ kÉrmbm bc npmwcaagâl bcj rcpacp Ålesjm, As_lbm qc_ npÅargam*
bcnclbgclrcq ns`jga_b_q amkm lmpk_q _npm`_b_q* as_lbm qc qc npcqclr_pÅ j_ gldmpk_agâl n_p_ pc_jgx_p jmq bg`shmq r_lrm cl
amknjcr_l Éqr_q &tc_ cj ?nÉlbgac /', Cqr_q lmpk_q qc _ars_jgx_l Cqr_bmq Slgbmq amkm cl cj pcqrm bcj kslbm,

/,5 Q{@KF@>P AB@OB>QFSFA>A


?jesl_q ncpqml_q cqrÅl l_rsp_jkclrc bmr_+
b_q n_p_ cj bgqcàm w cj bg`shm* ncpm rmb_q
j_q ncpqml_q nscbcl kchmp_p qs a_n_agb_b
bc bgqcàm qg _npclbcl _ srgjgx_p j_q fcpp_+
kgclr_q w rÉalga_q _bcas_b_q, Cj npmacqm
cq n_pcagbm _j bc _npclbcp _ rma_p sl glqrps+
kclrm ksqga_j9 cl _jesl_q ncpqml_q qc b_
bc k_lcp_ kÅq l_rsp_j osc cl mrp_q* ncpm
rmbmq nscbcl _npclbcp _ rma_p qg np_arga_l,
öAâkm bcq_ppmjj_ sqrcb lsct_q gbc_q=
?osÖ rgclc _jesl_q rÉalga_q amknpm`_b_q
aml j_q as_jcq nscbc np_arga_p,

Bt]ieja lnk`q_pko
i ]jqb]_pqn]`ko
Cq amkål osc jmq gleclgcpmq bc bgqcàm bcq+ Sl_ qgcpp_ bc a_bcl_* bcqkmlr_b_, &B_tc Igle ò Bmpjgle Iglbcpqjcw*
k_lrcjcl npmbsarmq k_lsd_arsp_bmq aml cj
Amprcqá_ bc ?lbpc_q Qrgfj* Jrb,',
dgl bc ct_js_p w cqrsbg_p aâkm cqrÅl bgqcà_+
b_q qsq n_prcq w aâkm dslagml_l cl amlhsl+ J_ abp`ljmlpf`fàkcrk`flk^i cq sl @kjoqhpa h] Oa`
rm, As_lbm sqrcb sqc w cv_kglc npmbsarmq rÉpkglm n_p_ bcrcpkgl_p j_q qs`dslagmlcq
k_lsd_arsp_bmq bc`c npceslr_pqc8 öaâkm Cl j_ Umpjb Ugbc Uc` nscbcl claml+
osc n_prgagn_l cl cj bgqcàm w jscem sq_p+
nscbcl kchmp_pqc= öOsÉ nmbpÖ_ f_acpqc bg+ rp_pqc cvacjclrcq pcaspqmq n_p_ j_ glec+
j_q n_p_ pcamlqrpsgp sl npmbsarm qgkgj_p,
dcpclrc= öAâkm nmbpÖ_ _knjg_pqc-a_k`g_pqc lgcpÖ_ w cj bgqcàm, J_ jcarsp_ bc `jmeq bc
cj bgqcàm n_p_ e_p_lrgx_p sl kchmp pclbg+ rcalmjmeÖ_ w j_ tgqgr_ _ qgrgmq lmrgagmqmq
kgclrm= öOsÉ nmbpÖ_ f_acpqc n_p_ _knjg_p Bopq`ea ah iqj`k j]pqn]h w bc gleclgcpÖ_ cq sl_ dmpk_ bc k_lrc+
j_ tgb_ bcj npmbsarm= öAâkm nmbpÖ_ f_acpjm ?j m`qcpt_p aâkm dslagml_l c glrcp_a+ lcpqc _j bÖ_ w cqr_p cl amlr_arm aml qsq
kÅq cdgagclrc* kÅq pclr_`jc* craÉrcp_= rå_l j_q bckÅq apg_rsp_q w ml_lgqk mq amjce_q, Jmq qgesgclrcq qgrgmq uc` qml
FkdbkfboÖ^fksbop^ cq sl rÉpkglm osc bclrpm bc qs clrmplm nscbc m`rclcp+ årgjcq n_p_ cj bgqcàm bc gleclgcpÖ_8
qc pcdgcpc _j bgqcàm bc npmbsarmq `_q_bmq qc sl_ ep_l a_lrgb_b bc gldmpk_agâl ï frrn8--uuu,w_fmm,amk-fc_bjglcq-
cl bgqcàmq cvgqrclrcq* nmp jm eclcp_j _ rp_+ w dsclrcq bc apc_rgtgb_b, Amq_q amkm Qgrgm bc W_fmm aml j_q kÇq pcagclñ
tÉq bc j_ kcbgagâl w j_ bcqrpsaagâl bc sl j_q amjkcl_q w j_q rcj_p_à_q qml m`p_q rcq lmrgag_q qm`pc rcalmjmeá_ w sl
npmbsarm cvgqrclrc, Sl_ jÄnrfk^ ab j b+ k_cqrp_q bc bgqcàm cqrpsarsp_j osc f_l _práasjm qck_l_j,
af`fàkmlo`lloabk^a^p &AKK' _wsb_ _ glqngp_bm _ jmq bgqcà_bmpcq fsk_lmq bs+ ï f rrn 8--u u u ,rc af u c ` ,am k -R c af +
_acjcp_p cj rgcknm cl cj osc qc pc_jgx_ j_ p_lrc qgejmq, J_q _j_q bc sl amjg`pÖ qml
Uc` Qgrgm bc kcbgmq bc AKN,
gleclgcpÖ_ gltcpq_ bc _jeslmq npmbsarmq, k_p_tgjj_q _cpmbglÅkga_q, F_w ksafm
osc _npclbcp bcj cqrsbgm bc j_q dmpk_q ï frrn8--uuu,sqnrm,emt-Qgrgm n_p_ `éqñ
Sl_ AKK kgbc cj m`hcrm kcbg_lrc sl_
l_rsp_jcq w j_ cvn_lqgâl bc qsq bgqcàmq* oscb_ cl jálc_ bc j_ Mdgagl_ bc n_ñ
qmlb_ m sl jÅqcp* w _jk_acl_ j_ gldmpk_+
amkm Jcml_pbm b_ Tglag fgxm aml qs rclrcq bc Cqr_bmq Slgbmq,
agâl ecmkÉrpga_ ncprglclrc cl sl_ `_qc bc
b_rmq bmlbc nscbc k_lgnsj_pqc aml A?B, kÅosgl_ tmj_bmp_ &dgesp_ /,03',
/,5 R ~ A L G A ? Q BC A P C ? R G T G B ? B /5

/,03 PÖnjga_ bc k_bcp_ _ cqa_j_ pc_j bcj Mkgrånrcpm* kÇosgl_ tmj_bmp_ aml _j_q kåtgjcq amlac`gb_ nmp Jcml_pbm b_ Tglag,
&Amprcqá_ bc Ncrcp Af_bugai ò Bmpjgle Iglbcpqjcw',

Fjraopecqa `e^qfko`a l]pajpao


J_q n_rclrcq nscbcl qcp sl_ ep_l dsclrc bc gbc_q, Cl Cqr_bmq Slg+
bmq* w cl _jeslmq mrpmq n_Öqcq* cj em`gcplm ckgrc sl_ n_rclrc w aml+ rm( Slgrcb Qr_rcq N_rclr bm* Nkak Lm,8 S Q 5*/56*710 @ j
acbc _j rgrsj_p cj °bcpcafm _ cvajsgp _ mrpmq bc d_`pga_p* srgjgx_p m @saik_l &ú3< B_jc md N_jclg8 Ic`, 0.*0..5
tclbcp¢ sl npmbsarm cqncaÖdgam bsp_lrc sl ncpgmbm cqncaÖdgam, Cj &32' úSGFT, GGS+Krj
npmacqm bc j_ n_rclrc dsc bcq_ppmjj_bm nmp npgkcp_ tcx amkm sl_ .†' j_ u _ † I , K i js p g ? @ r_ @ MR UGS K J NGM, Mp_

dmpk_ bc npmkmtcp j_ bgtsje_agâl bc jmq _t_lacq rÉalgamq, Sqrcb 570, N H K} K R &S Q ' 37(3=

&ï ' L prl p V _ ` hI j rm j qc b l a S l v p , rfr K m á G'k


nscbc gltcqrge_p cj cqr_bm _ars_j bcj bgqcàm bc qs gbc_ bc npmbsarm õKG ,ñ ` d + r g k K ,ú ù U :kd_p K
sqc,
HA , gp(
q g á `(' `w m b p ,,
cl cj qgrgm bc `åqoscb_ cl jÖlc_ bc j_ Mdgagl_ bc n_rclrcq w k_pa_q &0/' ? d d r Lm j g _ s h j '
bc Cqr_bmq Slgbmq &uuu,sqnrm,emt' m bc qs n_Öq* j_ as_j rgclc pc+ &00' D_ar H _ q , 2 , 0(.2

esj_agmlcq cqrpgar_q cl as_lrm _ aâkm npcqclr_p jmq bgqcàmq cl mi^+ &3/' j_JAJ
k qs fs t &0.MFMG'
/ôk j j fÖ j

klpabm^qbkqb< bc kmbm osc jmq bg`shmq qc_l dÅagjcq bc pcnpmbsagp


&52' ((c Ö o j + K é s d j G Ii<GG
GQ M F 0 -j: ( T $ /.(, H d r g k
0 GU G2 R , 0 ü (
&dgesp_ /,04', &† ' GT K m† ü r_rS?r_rjsl T † ü f †40/.3*
T U F } ,,U = , 0/† /2=, g ( 0 , ( 2 ?nn_gk† G j b i a S m _ g gk d_rlü f S m g `ark? rs t s w
Qüt _nnjl_jkKg B i ` ra l m dM prr r m l f f † t ü t _ l p ` a m K ü jcm_ /2 G` _ u _ q a m d m l s g q^ ü Ga _ l a gr '
rf pm l d s /2 † rk f n i t gg ü jgjjMRlj u jfl<(_` ( n i l jé '
&QÖ' GK gglk AÖjpd
Dnqlko`a `eoaÜk
m d ü p b gI S 02 f l † & _ ? u 00 gf k t ü , ? luo:r_:`,% 02 "∏
S Hr N ? k (p k l u v P amlr_gl †ü _ Klap† m q gfa `rjk b j g l r †K`
†∏ a jl m a l g H H ds† pptf_pnl( ü`c ≠KMART ( dpc m
S Å , G F > é / G U G f w † ]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]] K G SI jS_f m á rru u a rr † ü k s bKnmKb as gf p
_ ( jMKRm f ( ( ( ( + ]]]]]
Aml cj npmnâqgrm bc mdpcacp npmbsarmq w qgqrck_q amknjchmq _j kcp+ ? í s j
ù ,r k ,o r  > í G K '
Q âU ( hî _g
&s l b g
ú ú : 8(
, %( ú
a_bm* j_ k_wmpÖ_ bc j_q ncpqml_q rcpkgl_l rp_`_h_lbm cl sl _k`gcl+ ? ( ( u(g Q K K õ _g , %( ú G G & ` j l , õ j j k j o Q fõpr,

rc bc cosgnm, Jmq cosgnmq amk`gl_l j_ cvncpgclag_ bc glbgtgbsmq


d_kgjg_pgx_bmq aml k_rcpg_jcq* npmacqmq bc npmbsaagâl* k_picrgle*
dgl_lx_q* cra,* nmp jm osc j_ k_wmpÖ_ bc jmq npmwcarmq qc amltgcp+
rcl cl sl cqdscpxm bc cosgnm ksafm _lrcq bc osc sl npmbsarm qc
d_`pgosc w amkcpag_jgac, ?bckÅq bc npmnmpagml_p j_ cvncpgclag_
t_pg_b_ osc qc pcosgcpc n_p_ jjct_p sl_ gbc_ bcqbc cj amlacnrm f_qr_
j_ d_`pga_agâl* j_ glrcp_aagâl clrpc ncpqml_q bc bgtcpqmq r_jclrmq
hsce_ sl n_ncj gknmpr_lrc cl cj npmacqm bcj bgqcàm apc_rgtm, J_
a_n_agb_b bc apc_p w amknpclbcp bg`shmq rÉalgamq _wsb_ _ osc jmq
kgck`pmq bcj epsnm amlrpg`sw_l w qc `clcdgagcl bc j_ amkslga_+
agâl bclrpm bcj cosgnm,

/,6 ABCFKF@FßKABIMOLAR@QL
Aâkm qc bghm _lrcq* jmq epÅdgamq rÉalgamq rgclcl rpcq dslagmlcq
gknmpr_lrcq8 tgqs_jgx_agâl* amkslga_agâl w bmaskclr_agâl, Jmq /,04 Nj_lm bc n_rclrc bcj a_qam slgtcpq_j bc qcespgb_b,

   
/6 A?N≠RSJM / JCLES?HC EP™DGAM SLGTCPQ?J N ? P ? CJ B G Q C Ä M

bg`shmq w kmbcjmq A?B qml sl_ n_prc gknmpr_lrc bc j_ bcdglgagâl bcj


npmbsarm, J_ abcfkf`fàk abimolar`ql qc pcdgcpc _ j_ amjcaagâl bc
bmaskclrmq bgegr_jcq w cl n_ncj osc cqncagdga_l jmq pcoscpgkgclrmq
dÖqgamq w dslagml_jcq bc sl npmbsarm, Cqrmq nscbcl t_pg_p bcqbc sl
kmbcjm A?B cl 1B osc cqncagdga_ jmq pcosgqgrmq bc d_`pga_agâl
bclrpm bcj _pafgtm A?B f_qr_ sl `mqoschm aml bgkclqgmlcq `mq+
osch_bm cl n_ncj,
Ksaf_q cknpcq_q npcdgcpcl _jk_acl_p gldmpk_agâl cl sl bgq+
nmqgrgtm aml dmpk_rm bgegr_j nmposc cj amqrm bc _jk_acl_kgclrm cq
pcj_rgt_kclrc `_hm w jmq b_rmq nscbcl qcp jma_jgx_bmq* pcasncp_bmq
w srgjgx_bmq aml d_agjgb_b nmp ksaf_q ncpqml_q, Cl j_ dgesp_ /,05
qc kscqrp_ sl_ qcpgc bc amknmlclrcq osc nscbcl dmpk_p n_prc bcj
amlhslrm bc b_rmq bc j_ bcdglgagâl bc sl npmbsarm, N_p_ nmbcp n_p+
rgagn_p aml Évgrm cl cj amkncrgrgtm kcpa_bm kslbg_j qc pcosgcpc sl
amlmagkgclrm npmdslbm bcj jcles_hc epÅdgam* bcqbc jmq `mqoschmq
fcafmq _ k_lm f_qr_ jmq kmbcjmq amknjchmq cl 1B,
/,05 Amlrclgbm nmqg`jc bc sl amlhslrm bc b_rmq cl 1B,

/,7 MOBPBKQ>@FßKABIMOL@BPLABAFPB|LBKRK MLOQ>CLRL


Sl nmpr_dmjgm cq sl_ kscqrp_ pcnpcqclr_rgt_ bc qs rp_`_hm* 0, Kscqrpc j_q npÅarga_q amppcar_q bc bg`shm, Bc k_lcp_ cq+
osc jc _wsb_ _ amkslga_p qsq f_`gjgb_bcq w r_jclrmq* nmp jm ncag_j* qg jm osc `sqa_ cq sl_ nmqgagâl bc bg`sh_lrc* c gl+
eclcp_j _ sl nmqg`jc cknjc_bmp m ajgclrc, Ksaf_q cknpcq_q w ajsqm qg qs dscpx_ cq j_ apc_rgtgb_b* _qceåpcqc bc osc jmq
n_prgasj_pcq amjma_l qsq nmpr_dmjgmq cl j_ Pcb n_p_ npmkmtcp epmqmpcq bc jÖlc_* j_q _amr_agmlcq* j_q lmr_q w mrp_q n_prcq
qsq a_n_agb_bcq w jmepmq, J_q cknpcq_q ep_lbcq rgclbcl kÅq bcj bg`shm qc _hsqrcl _ j_q lmpk_q bc bg`shm rÉalgam,
_ kmqrp_p kmbcjmq w npmwcarmq pc_jgx_bmq* nmposc jmq bg`shmq 1, K_lrcle_ t_pg_q tcpqgmlcq bc qs nmpr_dmjgm _ars_j* amkm
bc rp_`_hm nscbcl qcp gldmpk_agâl amldgbclag_j, J_q ncpqml_q* sl_ amng_ gknpcq_* sl_ bgegr_j w qs npcqclag_ cl j_ Pcb,
cqncag_jkclrc jmq cqrsbg_lrcq m pcagÉl cepcq_bmq* nscbcl acl+ Srgjgac dmpk_rmq ksw _aacqg`jcq &nmp chcknjm* NBD m
rp_pqc kÅq cl kmqrp_p qsq npÅarga_q bc cj_`mp_agâl amppcar_ bc NmucpNmglr' n_p_ osc qsq rp_`_hmq bgegr_jcq qc_l dÅagjcq
bg`shmq w qsq f_`gjgb_bcq apc_rgt_q n_p_ pcqmjtcp npm`jck_q, bc amlqsjr_p, Qg glajswc qs bgpcaagâl uc` cl j_ amppcqnml+
Qg sqrcb cq gleclgcpm amlqsjrmp* _posgrcarm* bgqcà_bmp gl+ bclag_* cjjm ncpkgrc osc j_q ncpqml_q tc_l qs rp_`_hm m osc
bsqrpg_j m bg`sh_lrc* w cvnmlc kscqrp_q bc qs rp_`_hm* rgclc sl_ amlqsjrcl j_q kscqrp_q _ qs amltclgclag_,
tclr_h_ qm`pc _oscjjmq osc qâjm f_`j_l bc cjjm, Jmq bg`shmq 2, Lsla_ amldÖc cvajsqgt_kclrc cl cosgnmq cjcarpâlgamq, Gl+
qml sl_ npsc`_ bc osc sqrcb lm qâjm rgclc `scl_q gbc_q* qglm ajsqm qg rgclc sl_ npcqclr_agâl bgegr_j ep_lbc* jjctc amlqg+
r_k`gÉl j_ f_`gjgb_b n_p_ amkslga_pqc bc k_lcp_ aj_p_ w npc+ em sl nmpr_dmjgm bc kscqrp_q gknpcq_q, Jmq bg`shmq bc`cl
agq_ bsp_lrc rmb_q j_q cr_n_q bc sl npmwcarm* bcqbc cj amlacnrm qcp jgkngmq w jceg`jcq, Bcnclbgclbm bc qs bgqagnjgl_* sqrcb
f_qr_ qs dgl_jgx_agâl, nscbc bcqc_p sl_ as`gcpr_ kÅq ep_lbc m kÅq ncoscà_ n_p_
Qg jm osc cqrÅ `sqa_lbm cq sl cknjcm bc lgtcj glgag_j* lm qs nmpr_dmjgm* rclgclbm cl asclr_ osc qc_ qs rp_lqnmpr_agâl
qc npcmasnc qg qs nmpr_dmjgm jsac amkm cj bc sl_ ncpqml_ cl cqc w tgqs_jgx_agâl qc_l aâkmb_q, Nscbc glajsgp bg`shmq bm+
lgtcj, Sl rp_`_hm cqrsbg_lrgj jgkngm w amppcarm cq sl `scl gl+ `j_bmq bc ep_l r_k_àm* qgcknpc osc qc_l dÅagjcq bc q_a_p
bga_bmp bc qs nmrclag_j, Lm rp_rc bc as`pgp j_ d_jr_ bc chcknjmq w tcp,
`gcl bg`sh_bmq aml sl_ as`gcpr_ kÅq a_p_ n_p_ qs nmpr_dmjgm* m 3, Es_pbc jmq `sclmq chcknjmq amldmpkc qc apccl, Cq dÅagj
_j npcqclr_pjm ksw bcamp_bm, Cl a_k`gm* e_qrc cq_ clcpeÖ_ cl mjtgb_p jm osc fgxm cj _àm n_q_bm* m as_rpm _àmq _rpÅq,
amknjcr_p sl npmwcarm osc kscqrpc qs a_n_agb_b, Es_pbc amng_q &r_lrm bgegr_jcq amkm cl n_ncj' bc qs kchmp
Sl nmpr_dmjgm cq sl_ mnmprslgb_b bc amlr_p fgqrmpg_q amlag+ rp_`_hm cl sl _pafgtm n_p_ kscqrp_q bcj nmpr_dmjgm* w lm
q_q bc Évgrm, Nmp chcknjm* osgxÅ bcqcc kmqrp_p bc as_rpm _ qcgq mjtgbc es_pb_p r_k`gÉl _jeslmq `mqoschmq bc bcq_ppmjjm
npmwcarmq* glajswclbm j_ bcqapgnagâl glgag_j bcj bgqcàm &m sl bc qsq npmwcarmq cvgrmqmq,
npm`jck_ _qgel_bm'* jmq `mqoschmq* bg`shmq bc bcq_ppmjjm w j_ 4, Bcnclbgclbm bc qsq m`hcrgtmq npmdcqgml_jcq* cq `sclm bc+
npcqclr_agâl dgl_j &glajsgbmq nj_lmq* pcnpcqclr_agmlcq w jmq km+ h_p osc qs nmpr_dmjgm pcdjchc cj Åpc_ osc bcqc_ cvnjmp_p, Qg
bcjmq dÖqgamq m cl 1B' n_p_ a_b_ slm, Qs nmpr_dmjgm bc kscqrp_q cqrÅ `sqa_lbm sl_ nmqgagâl apc_rgt_ w rgclc j_q f_`gjgb_bcq
apc_ ep_lbcq rck_q bc amltcpq_agâl cl sl_ clrpctgqr_* _qÖ osc pcoscpgb_q &amkm cj bg`shm m j_ dmrmep_dÖ_ _prÖqrga_' nscbc
_npmtcafc j_ mnmprslgb_b n_p_ kmqrp_p aâkm cldpclr_ bcq_dÖmq glajsgp chcknjmq _npmng_bmq, Qg qs glrcpÉq npglagn_j cq sl_
amkm j_ pcbsaagâl bc amqrmq* j_ kchmp_ bcj dslagml_kgclrm m j_ nmqgagâl bc bg`sh_lrc* cq nmqg`jc osc bcqcc glajsgp kÅq
qmjsagâl _ jmq npm`jck_q osc qspecl bsp_lrc rmbm cj npmacqm, bg`shmq w kmbcjmq bc rp_`_hm,
?jeslmq amlqchmq _bgagml_jcq n_p_ j_ apc_agâl bc sl nmp+ ? jm j_gem bc cqrc jg`pm* j_q qcaagmlcq bc Nmpr_dmjgm jc npcqclr_l
r_dmjgm cvgrmqm qml8 _jeslmq bg`shmq pc_jcq osc qc _njga_l _ jmq rck_q rp_r_bmq cl
/, Kclmq cq kÅq, Qc qsnmlc osc cl sl nmpr_dmjgm kscqrp_ qs a_b_ a_nÖrsjm, Nmp chcknjm* j_ qcaagâl bc Nmpr_dmjgm cl cqrc a_+
kchmp rp_`_hm* nmp jm osc _jeslmq `sclmq chcknjmq t_jcl nÖrsjm kscqrp_ j_ dmpk_ cl osc sl cqrsbg_lrc bc bgqcàm glbsq+
kÅq osc sl kgjjâl bc chcknjmq kcbgmapcq, Nmp jm eclcp_j rpg_j f_ bgdslbgbm cj npmacqm bc bgqcàm _ rp_tÉq bc sl_ nÅegl_
`_qr_ npcqclr_p clrpc as_rpm w qcgq npmwcarmq rcpkgl_bmq, bc nmpr_dmjgm `gcl amlac`gb_,

   
0, / ?JD?@CRM BC J ≠ L C ? Q 07

Jálc_ tgqg`jc

Jálc_ masjr_

Jálc_ bc qcaagål

Jálc_ aclrp_j

Qgkcrpá_
Dgl_

Jálc_ bc ∏7.,3 ∏ jglc_ bc bgkclqgål


bgkclqgål* Dgl_
jálc_ bc + 64 +
cvrclqgål
\ £ Amj_ fmpgxmlr_j bc 1 kk &,/ 0 3 '
-
Glbga_bmpcq
 Pcaf_ bc 1 kk
&,/03ü',
jglc_ bc cvrclqgål

jglc_q bc nj_lm
bc amprc

Jálc_q bc nj_lm
bc tgqgål

+ ( h z\£/,4 kk &,. 4 ' 1,0 kk &,/ 0 '£ g z£


Jálc_ d_lr_qk_
Dgl_ G /7+16 kk G
p(û&,5 3 +/ ,3 '+ (%j

/ ,4 k k &,. 4 '£ (YY(z /,4 kk & ,. 4 '£+h z+†+

Jálc_q nslrc_b_q A gù m R b 3 jálc_b c . ,1 6 ≠,3 3 kk &,./ ù . 0 \ -


/,4 kk &,. 4 ' £ ∫ G£

/,4 kk &,. 4 '+ £ G G+£ /,4 kk &,. 4 '


Jálc_q bc a_bcl_
Epscq_ G /7+16 kk
f & ,5 3 + / ,3 ' +

0,5 ?jd_`crm bc jálc_q &r_k_ãm pc_j',

   

You might also like