errand rf
physicsworid
evar URS
AMPS UC Cue es Eek ee}
€
Shifting principles How Leo Szilard changed his view on nuclear weapons
Baby science Applying physics to conception, pregnancy and toddlerhood
Chatbot revolution Are large language models a help ora hindrance for physicists?Contents: March 2023
physicsworld
Quanta
Research Updates
Muon se er yptogzanty «Entanglement aps uons
‘Quast fundin-foxsaned ning
‘Themalonductty rps eth pressre «Wind energy
‘oudpowerMars base
Nows & Analysis 8
UKplansXay ee -elecrn laser «New UX hash Nh
rewert agency NIST aces deficient, sas repo.
‘Europe advances quantum echnaoges'»UCereatas
‘edad soence mini» Dear eloknear ight
‘The latbotrvluton: Mat Hodgson tas bute Denes
‘and danger oar angsage models orphyses
‘Gravational nave seaentocontnue
Comment, 15
Pro bute
Forum a
The pele with briiance in pss Any Si
Transactions 18
EMieneyversuscstlames MeMencie
Critical Point 19
Tyner changes obo Cesce
ears
Fc
Seen
acer
Features
Ithappens more than you think
‘arel ren hghghts te stuglesPAD tudes fae, om
‘estore en finding problems tones sues an
‘elves
The surprising physics of babies 27
Meet rks okt examen cance pregnancy and
styood fom a plea tence perspective, hichis
‘rod sh insghsina the capabitiesofftehunan boy
‘When Leo Szilard changed his mind a1
‘eo Selard amas) ced forte development of meer
‘weapons before shifts stance on wheter should be
{ied Bute fen are his ews, as stan Haga expans
Reviews 36
‘WhoWed Geer Bec? Ants Chandan om echtearto
teat leader Nate Groner
2
Careers a
Guide generaton stonomes Rob Les
‘Aske ayting Jessie Janes.
Recruitment 44
Lateral Thougnts 48
iden vais on Randal
Multimedia
sua wine ysis nos ety
psa of 16 Fearne
Fteen cae pata,
reaganQuanta
Seen and heard
Forhighereducation and research, =
there are no new opportunities and ofthe waveguide, findingthatabouta ith
‘no actual possible upsides from
Se tae gtt se
Se rare
ae tn depo ge
ee umecare Serre
ae ere
ee, I 0 nan oar
nena Shape siting rat Se emul ince Nee
Neat woeatytosaynich | imc racmercae_ welanieearerae fife
conaesvae ‘Stam incncngne Serene
raped On| fcreyyentie eee pees hetero
Sei cnanang an Soarhcacenncnmlaets. hte Cineshearva
ILcisshoel ready, endifyou gyeus | Mntetstcannyandecebiy —_oloertempersturin myo Chine
‘the money, we're going to build it 0.10164}. matt.2022.12.003). First, they concise, The study found that the
ere Stee aewbatandlet ne
eee eater ee | ence
sgt Re eee alan deer
een era
era chao jeter,
eetedeernta tec ennai ere
Ne aie ee eeeeer eg | eee eserecd tases ate
tenance | ee ean oesteaterat
Sate ee Ee | sear ces vot eo aaaey neers
seston SaIan er a
bakes
Fence heehee tobe detected by the recipient, Howard —_results in oscillations that never repeat ~
Birageseystat te ely atmahings tical calleagsa the Unveritywithcomputesimulatonsofthe ecu
eeiteep ndonanay enact Exteryandhaveaow foundaposile diplyingchotc haps call range
mokas Rsv etn Tatton tothisoptclspent (Pe Rew stracloe:Aterpey goldmithsto
"Bort00) by fitngacepesting cylindrical cet the atractor terns proved
That appicationwas actualybom —jatemflatnsepulseeTheovealeect_ too tek wang traditional ehniqus
‘tof personal experience ceterpipeati-dny stat Teese area D pag
Fngne' tony Chengtom bem Site | ssroundeacoresfunpertarbedairat | cesesmould hat he galdsntisthen
they qed ay Kigherdenity Inoter words, theyiad_aedtocresethe designs Tereae even
Cree eretnattrsedaren, made moptalwavepudethitactemoch —planefranexhbtion basen chaos hat
araectscuesocnrmstoavosmedin WeanopicafibreTotettrelfeacyatanbealapedforisterational museums,
sae reaee transmitnginfrmation the teaumflued_ withthe tam sayingthat the jewelery
Inuchweskerlighpulertroaghthecore could se or edcstioal rps
Pen we 2022 3Research updates
Muons used for cryptography system
‘Anew scheme that encodes and decodes messages using the random anival of cosmic-ray muons
could be more secure than other ayptographic systems. Edwin Cartidge reports
“Therandomarsnl time ofcosmi
ray muons al the Harts sures an
‘Bouse o encode and decode cont
‘ential meninges. That according
‘Hoya Tanaka sttbeUniveety
tenet mre secure than ber
rypogrphic ster si does not
pris larder ead ester of
Imessage to exchange «sett key
Uieneedoi101016 et 2022
105697, Having confirmed impor
tant apts ofthe tchnolgy in the
[abana thinks could be come
mercialy competitive fr use orer
‘hort dtc
Cypiographic protocols invave
generating and dsribting a secret
Seythatinasdtoeneyptand decrypt
essges Unfortunate conimonly
ted eyptography syste could be
racked by quantom computers of
the fare One option for deaing
‘rh thstheet tous Hesenbergs
{neertanty pepe to ensure cat
tty would be eevedeoppercoanet
Steal the key without revealing tee
Preseneinthe proces
oyever even this "ant key
stb ba it le, Seti
bare shows i psn to expat
‘weknesns in th encryption bard
trae such shining bg ight on
Sale photon detectors tun than
foto casa devices The problem
fanbeavided yang thd party
{who need nt be trustworthy t
feet key bts, bt hi aerangement
Is'nore expensive than sight
Keeand purty nero
“Tanaka new propolis designed
to defeat eavesdroppers by instead
leeningtosatural and ever pert
revouree of andomnere conc:
Fay sors, Com ys cho
Imanly protons, ran Joven on the
Eth fom deep pace and peste
showers of los andoter partis
‘nen they elie with nce nthe
Stmogphere Those pons then deeay
fntomuons vbichereheny versions
tthe detron, These mons hit the
Earths surface completly inde
pendely of one another and ean
‘strong age amounts sl
Pater whe only Tosa 3 all
Fact ofthe energy By onng
them
"Taal dea is 0 postion the
resis sender and receiver close
Cougs together so that they are
both exposed tothe same cone
ay showers. They ean therefore
mak hl own Separate detections
‘of spedic moon win a shower
pay thse partes whose
ecto costs the detectors a both
Sndivale By each recording the
trial ie of thore muons nd
Sing he time stamp a the
dom dita for eryptographie key,
these and resercan npn
Aenlygnerate the name secret keys
thm hago send the ey to
coeamiher
nsing that sender and eevee
tse th same muons terete the
leyresson workingoutthe prec
tume delay etree the two dete
tos which done by knowing the
dlutune between he detectors wile
ffteluly synchronizing docks at
ach eal. Synchronization can be
Sched sing abl positioning
Systeme coordinate the king of
Ioealcckschaseeysalosllars.
“Tana calls his ocnigue "Cor
mle Ching ® Transfer” (COS.
MOCAT) and uses two detectors
‘that measire mon arival with
atc icntilstorsndsphotomul
le tbe Carrying out tests on fu
{ire days hestomedtht mons
rive a andor pts ime =
{he pray of abserng a ven
telnet
number of evets ina certain perod
Efalowing « Poisson disrvution
He alo showed thatthe wo dete:
tor conaitey prods! he ams
andor tne top
weve, ig limitations in
the GPS signals td the etic,
sed to carryout the experiment,
“Tanaka was ony able fo este
Iu common muoe detections (as
‘opposed to intereeption of other
‘indom parties) i abou 208 of
ses, Overcoming this problem
favael the seo oog lt
‘le keys to Tey and decode given
Inesage and then moving on the
‘ext message oly once the eter
nd ignated sce,
Ssmartldings
‘These exta steps ad time to the
deeyption proces ands dow dow
‘he te at whlch data can Be ane
Inited: Nevertheless Tanaka says
{hat the sytem woul sl be con
"ideal ike than existing tech
ology. Indeed, agreed detetions
tookplace tan average of around
ott iplyog data ranenion
‘ateafat eat 1OMDps This ser
than the kbps thas pel as
Teel network system suc a Bae
tooth Low Energy. He thinks that
thie geser buh shoud ake
the nw scheme tractive or short
age vision comarenaton ck
‘sconnectingsensorswithin"soat™
buildings and securely exchanging
Infomation daring the powering of
fete ler vehi,
Tanaka ackoledges that amon
detection rates place limits on the
tecncogy bat nits tha eles are
doquatfowiess communication
ter distances of uptoabout 1m. In
Hr demonstration be use detectors
‘exchmeascingntomasizethe
‘Bteate However Tana reckons he
‘hal shrink the eestor tit
tthe cumea seb upg tele
‘seneration ate fact of ee
Se that he sho ave» working
rape within the next Me yearResearch updates
=a
Quantum entanglement maps gluons inside nuclei
nthe US hoe ue quate
mnt to map te stun oon pas th taam ean eae the
ons hl strc ul at eer ston the esi the neces
recon than previ ose.
The TAR eaaoraton 2 Bootes
| Gatcanbe rated the poration
‘entantemet ot theoposten caged MR SJ othe ton ht oat interctes
plone crated who ghee gd ' ‘th hon and rvs ational
acl passer cose osahather, ‘atermaton sbout scan
(Se.48 east {hogan thin tbo mcs. Toie
Sezerdingto quantum home: permet semen epstion
‘antes, ons re modest fmision ography, beh eeles
UMesvongneclearece tien binds Stings ashe he bua dy
‘iartsnieprtesennesrony,DolScndecor, ae arundady cede ptne ng pase gamma pone
nda boléspretensond weutons eT) >0heai tate teary polraedmspectic. erat ama dea paces.
eguteramct twee, tise He STR eeagtetaetetienecet
Ateats cael the propertoset_sbotinane
ener silencer systems sect 86 apa te os an ce
{sid otosandnantons. "NTSC | byl eetingtve opoing sharing une dstrbaton. Tr
‘sare hsetshare poor ‘eas of gdm oh ebsratns mathe p wthbeth
tnderstndng aho o Bonswiin gateolie The paindptnens” hate! rae
‘rut i aceor mato Nevescie, —Spuemalga mils ean iy suture aswel ab xprinont
Posts inthe SAR cotaorton Mctite ne qantas, menareent ing oh
students it th leh on itrct whe gubesintehiqus The STAReoaberton
aly Ls Relate ean Theothrmclosastpssoshy These Hopes tat arter wor wil eee
‘Car ch celts caged Intratons produce eto shot etn ere deta nage he
leo ee sta Ines ch py deny Intro mc
Racetonparinets a he lise Ino apaiefopeste cagedpon, Sam are
Condensed matter
. ee ere
Natural quasicrystal found in ‘fossilized lightning
1g more conventional eubic atic
3 The quaserysal has equally spaced
omic layer, each tha 1 ad
Fotationa symmetry ~ something
tistmponeinerdinaryeytls
‘ith rational symmety
‘Steinhardt and cllenger bive
thatthe strona elect dichare
‘rageofentcmestunkalcecra)_ fmt the sme own, aluinimalo fom he power
Indoptslpropertia Quaskysal With thechemslcompostion STORE Steaua ict ae rom he
wrerefistidetfedin Ean ance May Shs,CoAh ue the ss fad. Soha tem hopes that
Then several den tecoiqes or eral wae liter ied ie lcover coud ead to new ch
ihelrgtbesshne been developed grin tapped inside the fuga ‘hue gles aythe
Inching pour depositions the Toe the guar coxin th Sonim
‘Wind energy could power human habitations on Mars
wind energy coud help to power oud the wn slice
aman enderourson Macy Fatt “the tenn loka ts hypotet
thecondson ofa study hated cal generation ster tat compies
tate modes of Mars tcl tbe colarpandeandantnercoa Bind
‘Bort tem andenonal vail of fF urne Theater sa dium sted
‘rind power tht woul be generated commercial vale sytem that
byrturbines onthe ed plat The rotor diameter of 389 an
"ocucher sugget thi the wld ated a power out of 30K
oul supply stent energy ons fon Earth Hartwick snd elias
‘en or be ued in conjunction wih calculate at thc turbine could oper
‘ola or micleat pomer (Net. Atron. fe atansterage pertionl power
‘decor t0J0s4s0 022018514) ‘upto abot IOLW on Ma The
revourilsofstevibltyore teu cacaitons sh tha he
«red misono Mars ave fused bin wood increase the percentage
fon acct to physical resources stime that the poe rom the com
Inciting the svalablty of water lownanay Maran windhadotbeeareguded. bind system exceeds 24K from
thle and hive not uecsarly ASolyoquns ave val coegy resource NASAS_ IM Gol arays soe 10 60-90%
ACeounted forthe energy gecraton Catena Victoria Hartwick and collages. (ol ps winch, The aie 24K is
CGpabiies of potential actions. ¥oMneanbietes have found, however that Sspte significa ees i considered
Whiethetastecnatatoteseath SOOO Nar thin amospere, winds ae minimus power egulremen 1
fn solar and: miclar energy as USES Sullncongenough'oproduepover_ supports siren isin
Maran engysoures naar °C, Scom lange pote ofthe Maran Whi he sty sows tat ead
power harbours potential himan PEMME=SAHO Srfce The sady suggests that_gracratntspsaletwoukoniybe
Filsandeurentodcrotutargy 22% ind could workin combination self culdbedane leans
tec th energy storage cpa: ‘rth other energy sources such son Mars hit are sual fran
ty to compensate or day ad “aro bospergecon This habitation, Hartwick eget that
‘inoal rats in generat, ould be eopecly heal daring saingacesnton of wind rbins
Marlow stmorperc dna ical and global dst storms, when andorra cul allow isons
sean that wind onthe plane! pro Soar power deceues end erable. floes trougoutalargpoton af
ices sigaiicany kes force Cha Windpower nereaee Wind would. theplane.
Sri! on Earth, Portis resson, the Mobeavieulesouredtnightend Cael anes
Condensed matt
Surprising heat transfer in new semiconductor under high pressure
"ethmal condi fmatie semanas mats
cone eneen tn st E ‘reciesenum arsed
Srenigt panes Ieee Indestoeyeatirng Te tean__presreaaga West
‘tthe aor, ae {ontatsectney ha pees ovr tirfaingent he fe
gts 0a ne nal “Sits after nto ethestvaseundr ene
Cope tne este ‘owas btn ft ean
re toomnedeniatnca foronareni thom oda
‘Soe pansein setenv Senta ‘yin stat a
Thetgsu canst ay Truedangws tee te tutored nestndng
‘naan apron aneeaesgegecantunet stnencharae cst
Sire codons sche eee itfarot pints hrm wenbe
‘Senator ier hrs ‘Soetoro onc tpraton
Sretnnaemet pea ‘timate cangs
ttowceiaesy nore etn ce np te
tcrencrcer ny ogiat, festa dercpoetet no mats or
avplecicratoperaretteee Seam ‘mortem ita
‘Trae tapispcedbotwantre SEs ‘Sr done state
dlamonisnannate ayer” Sse} ‘fumes
‘amined the stm wraens 85 “ones atoms eertagtherhest__ eran reesarerone olsun,
tthe ryt latin change th ‘noes though the vt fasey offal terracing
Inctesing presses opt 320Pa ‘tomy stn nam reser plt
Toot they ese ava Thorsaleaeosugenst tate abate umeNews & Analysis
UK kicks off X-ray laser design
Researchers have started work on the conceptual design review fora new UK-based X-ray
{free-electron laser to see whatscience the facility should focus on. Michael Banks reports
The UK bas officially Ince ul your ow
the start of design work fora next. Fra resulta the growing demand
eneraion Key freer er 2 fr xr the Scene and Technol
{EL} ity. Over 150 eeserchers "ogy Facies Counc (STFC) ~ one
‘etatthe Roja Solty sn ate ama ihenine revere fundingagences
ytoducas plana forthe UK sed Inthe UK condacedaterslecton
KXPEL that if given the go ahead, laser srt review, which com
ould be bit inthe coming dade. edn 2016 Therevew oncaded
[Researchers wil now hold a series ee thatthe UK shuld ensures ina
of meetings across the UK to gauge pasion ota he fn decison on
Inurestinsck iit and dss ‘hathr obi an XFEL" by 2000,
hat ind ofsclenceit ny produce "The UK mised that deadline
‘WihilesynchetonsuseXaysto erator that can eclerte electrons. SMngeM but id publish» UK XTEL sence
produce sate images orsnapsots. Yo 1.5GeV. The ality produces factarar tie cae that year More thin 10 ste
{fa sample under investigation, pseeofXrays27000timerpereesepesor ts frm around the wort helped
XPELS cam study dynamial pro” onfitheich pulelistinglesban weet ace to Graf the reports which tect
ess because they geneate ples 10feIn2022morethan ladarices MMaMbueendedthe UK oulda machin tht
fitensecoheren Rraybeamstens weepublshedbascdonexperments CHM. a6 Can produce Keays wilh am nergy
‘fthousndsaftinespersecond ee peformed atthe felt. topmnionsses Setyeen Oke and 150KeV ands
box opposite) Fach pulse lasts ess The UK was inal noe
than OD 0""shseichmeunethat_ the European XFEL by developing
fesearchers can forexample, cate tehnolgy designing lstrumeat,
afetona.cobemnt pale duration of 10attseconds
rayoametenet PE
pean october 2022 the UK XEBL
movie of chemeal bonding po-cotibuing To contruction and ropoul wat boosted by €3.2m
cesssor aalsethe sy vibrational jiningstercongota The UK Ds From UK Reseach and Innovation
nergy owsacrosamateril. tn Light Source ia Oxford he umbels organization forthe
TXEELs ave note, with the fit_alorts to KEEL haben the UK’ research councils = to carry
suchficityocomeonlinebeingtse pial and ifeences—whete UK tuts concptsl design review tit
Lins Coherent Ligh Source (LCLS) Uses the Europes XPEL arena ‘expected to tke some thre years
tthe SLAC National Accelerator. ported with raining sample prepa tercomplete and wl lo involve
Laboratory in the US. Constuc- falonand dataprocesing Uupdatingthescencecaze. Acoring
tion began in 2005 and wer com- In 2018 the UK bea the 120 tophyai lan Walmsley, provost
‘lee four yearslte The ety countryto join the Eorpean XFEL, Inperial allege Landon the eke
‘how undergoing a major upgrade ~contrutng she E208 = or 2% Isan"importa ste frte projec.
Krownas LCISII- hat wiliwaie_tovardstheeort of uldingthe Daring the eventtthe Royal soc
boosting the number of Xray ules The U loge pay 2s esgich seal tended by some
per sccond fom 120 in LCLS fo enna operating ost at 1S0proleonline sents outings
Filion a Cit igure tas aw sn 0% th te shat new acy might
‘Other XFELs soon opened in Uk being involve ina snl pe ‘The wok inder quantum mater
Japan, Germany, South Koren and. certageof experiment als dynamic tractor boogy and
‘Shiutland, meaning tha there ae The operational cons of XFEL ven as pips and XFEL oer
ow five such wer flies around. facity canbe significant. The Ema McBee fom Queens Unt
the weld In 2006 the UX epin to Euupean REEL, for example hs ‘ety Belt expaned = getting «
look into Bowing so dedicated an annual running cost of C1, better undertanding of te cond
XPEL but the pane fled to guin_eing tat the 100 experiments ons ine plants
traction The UK instead chove to cai ot at the Ilys eur David Danning. a physicist Geom
Join the European Xray Fee Ele ead cot sboat €L.4m to ron. Bt the Accelerator Science and Teh
{eon Laser (European XFEI) atthe wih he European XFEL beng fie ology Cente (AST) at the STC
DESY kbnear Hamburg, Germany. ines oversbaried thee ecapc Daresbury Laboratory lees tht
The European XFEL, which tyfor move machine ~ prompting UKXPEL operating an 4 epee
achieved fist ightin 207 eatress_theKtostrere-ctminngthecae ondictinglnesaeclrto-would
2m mapercondactingliner ace fre owa XFL, over alt ofthe sence bse thatNows & Analysis
ame out ofthe urvey of potential
‘ers, Tht energy requirement wil
ow beled daring eco
‘cepa design reve
‘Community ongagomont
‘survey af esearch groups inthe
Uk, condacted as part of the UK
XFEL slence case, indicated that
‘tive lvavement in REEL ince
inthe lst decade. But fon Maran
fos fom Imperial Calege London,
to UK XFELs alence en, ays
rile creil inthe cong yes
tobroaien heengagement ofthese
aif commanity to make sure that
SXPEL scence dove not tan into 4
‘ligqueot ser.
As ptf the concept design
revi serie of "ow-all”le
rents and workshop wil now
terheld around the county. The
STFC hops these meetings wilt
1 explan fo siete aboot hat
these machines can do, One event
‘Akeytheme toemergeatthe Roya
Society meting wat the need ee
the UK to thnk as cay as posable
Shoat the necesny regulatory pro
Paley
Now an X-ray free-electron
laser works
‘ets why acelaang hues feletesin aes
‘lrartgiplebone
{hen poised hough "at
There
‘wl soso pahandent sere atin.
‘sth ots ae aly chet and ect ted oe
sharowrnge ofwoengs, els antec
erase pity arses no
Somaru ono
slapd
Whee ctor ave ugh te ut, the et
‘teyom iene ntheerantaoung beard
eprint poston ad pas the The
‘eet eats bre up st
je ard ns
‘eden phase ar Hr monty.
Tht hes yao EL
sone iOoaesefmapatde gotta easy
rater scien igtsanes Tre wove te
be scandy catalog tery
cokratorrte mage
fide rds a gece Xj a vaogth as
fea
tlm intel
ces gen tht UKXFEL Wl rob
ship haveto be bull tes in part,
nage are, im Cake fom
ASTEC highligh
ted that st
‘ity will a bes key prt of
esi Thiscould include for exam
ovegerpimcirs ea
Feguoncy caves hat can operate
dec attrac above.
‘ilcnat theLondon ne wre
cen to acho that he an
‘mgucnent ors OK XPEL i hat
I Should hare capable ot ee
rely posible eer, That iw
Irhcked up by LOLS director ike
Dan, wok deletes ht ino
Sexe genrtin gow Cs
Ik the 2030s or 2040 maybe
‘ry dirt today henge
“Thedcaontottwerkona co
cept desig reve doe how
ver men that a UK XPEL wil be
SSH Repent atthe Royal Sst
meeting made deat. the review
mgt cnc that he machin i
thoexpenivesndtatabeterpton
would eto suport developments
Tiddeepentet ether ty.
Baile Ui-besedopon deed
the Best bet and there fading
‘ble the next tp would bean
inecing dein on the oar
op sr nly eieig to
Scratch the surface of wht these
Imachinescan dos notes ede
UK creates ‘high-risk, high reward’ research funding agency
Ane hig ih ear” scence
fa techtog nang be athe UR
‘ho ndvoeed esearch a ive
‘gene ABA) bch a ee ace
Theat ienthing and ong
revutaoaratene an tecnlg at
‘eed om wariectess sees.
bureaucracy bmi hres
ors peal pleat Mere"
‘hatean per pant ny
ther Uandng gees. The UK
Sorat sys emt AIA
{Serote-tantomatinal rcoteh
‘rogrmees th tpt |
{reat ntact apis
{arte benett otha
‘rnew tenes th gees
beard ae alo been amoung Tay
E
Inco te be pre vinnie
{hives asso management opr
‘Stephene an aah ante,
otal intra pb oy a. the
{iogfnde oon ate”
‘Thyra Hate Bigham ore
‘hire be UK cies kre; and
“ian tice oft Ut atone ergy
ater. lr as RU ee!
{nan ind operaons few
‘Conlin te borate
|g xsncnverar
reo
mesma
rei announced apelin
ek aloes, the UR erat
‘hfs ser nar
‘trae and at Co eet
‘sect othe tla ene et
xeon Fst srg th
fencnment sci te tr =
‘ARWs oaite eit ase tar
fede rpc demosttes
Usa eat oat
hentia npn et,
sth contain sreneaeat
‘ecarch ae"
Teal etapa eter ead
actos to ovesce AR formation,”
ote Gaede
‘tn agomet AA mae ble
Bets that erage stngts et
‘theresa stom oa wo
‘hanging beakthouz”
alNews & Anal
Freie strata egies er Cos
‘rom Vest of Cerat,
NIST labs are ‘deficient’, says report ss.
Instohabodstat tatitis "sere"
ompremling the ogee yo
tanto Tate cncsin
report he US Hatin eadeias ot
‘cnc, Engeering ant ede, y {nal the natnface cunt and
‘icin hte wis PEA ‘hmunghatenen he aad
“he pael endef NIST
nro iver ante eas plan tat eon the US Congress
Ides hav dostojetnsrumants Reporte taprnide on eta $300-AD0eia
Datgontions. eedthengneytoabandon STs
IST wie porto theUs ‘Dasameat tom tatvarteeder— Naesane
DapartnentofCommarce at astlar tesrchonquatameoneting toa
reco ctenment wih norhatDrnghad wate cetsts Mtn
Islbstovngseferleatothe phe esmetimoserntadtwapond Es
Mabelps tthe 18-agn report, isnt ate pretentpome
one", aes, ich weld aera
invest work Teor
sr yo Teste tS
archi anu
oye Ts, th reper sass
ang siieon impairment» ayy seat 8 months do poe "aan oats eva ST
sok IsscontnsIasen after morng chlrngs ison entre
nove lb nsoude forexamyle, temoro modern abs IS at ete
soniye ‘itom crop eae,
Srcurgenaietingnaie® —wlchea rye ya Wns
‘crmewcerinapeneaiay” Mal battoapht eer
esate
Europe is at the forefront of quantum-based technologies
mpeg the cop San tet i comircandoerthingrelto
ent uanem bod moog, Teese Seopa eco One
Xda s ae part fom Een oth ser ethedeoneta
iSinpen!ConmisicnThe pert moter font eres
fcaminrtervebel@ yearby ages eh terataees
‘Quantum ‘Technologies Flagship "HES hs teny tips Oihswarelhc nce pred
Sime to Boost quantutn research in 2S0-ims swe eopeuctyping prodactiowend
Non quantum echnologes suchas ‘Someot those sues wiltacledby
ceestum seming commuteton Durngefinttieepenvate the Fuopenn Chips fc wh
Scompaat rogrnine the fapip ed 25 appre dewey of ed
There eiesthe acts [agrees eens ad pletion nae
darth agi op oy pe 131 spp wh another urngend ting quai cp
Elin ander the Hort 2023 Rastnlaftotcmtecerwee Area peal or onmnneton
out tts moran 1503 Sontrncs‘or enichops were ye ieee hain ee
‘ean core srpitel The Maghipvao ail thine rated ee
‘ee 7p iemsand sere {Shane parted tl ates sche he bene
Cepinton Tipe bdo inguin chal fghipewetar ganna
‘SRD oct that an om 28 ‘cing te pr coord Wingy tum rena foi
ton snd weston! poets angromt tania stay oconmec pian
Thame enn SE pankidicrecaigwnduteosape horsesx
Science elevated to cabinet position in government
retary of state for digital, culture, MieleDonean, ‘Torn Grinyee, group chief execu- » Anew report by the Institute
ls 0 sent to minh That tet
mong met Onoda Cock
vay 10sec it eange see
2o10.en a 100 senda me The
teste mars the ss pao bel
stems ming n 147 Tnabows
sys sista aus ewan Uae,
hier ening tesa "as's
ening west eseaitncf tent
tere ety ata heb aps
inte vars undomning ts agse
nc he "beakdnnof ban ane
nstatersneaseta ngs ss see sts
th aercngtechnges nd aloes!News & Analysis
Enter the chatbot revolution
‘Theoretical physicist Matt Hodgson from the University of York talks
‘to Hamish Johnston about the role that large language models, or
chatbots, can play in physics
{What are arg langage model or
chatots?
‘large lnguage modal (LL is
‘jpeotartclimeligence. ego
ofthe moda isto generate human
liketertinresponseto prompts
‘oer Thicould beantwering ques
‘ions writiige-mallsapd even weit
{ngpoore snd stories One LLM th
Fas ben making headline recently
[ChatGPT ishighiyadancedast
letuinedanan entemousameountl
ata wth the current vero sing
Internet data upto 202,
How dou bocome iteresteain
chathts?
have ben using neural networks
~ stypeot artical intlgence to Untuk althoghnatwhattisdegnedtods
Jook at complex mathematical ear Phoietit i¢candobaie mathe. woul abwaye
onships Simla chabots learn Heong eyo tae designed for ater.
language baedsltionsips and Satesinhdsty cy Woliant Alpha, wht has
been recently aware ofthe poten ®t proven tak rcod
tia of chathots and specially
(ChatGP, thanks tos cllaboctor What abut computer code?
eho specializes in AI then began Yer found parca wef or
Experimenting with ChatGPT snd ‘wring computer code You could
Aidcovered that cou be uf in {Sk ChatGP took ove our ce
many daly take id Wenty mistaken I aot
Tike having eva tutor who eas
‘Any xamples? spot your miter and tel you howe
Tre them fo wt ais sum TDimpeoreyoureode
marzealonge-mall i dont have
{hetimeto red meshingato Doyou ave any examples?
fe aleture and gta portant [as wetting a lecture on solving
atleast hat Schridingers equation and T gave
bottosummarie in jet couple of the mathemati fot my sha
bul pots writen abt or Homo Cat Tand asked tow
sconfrnceandi realize actualy ‘Python code tha generates GI
Hed 00 characte ot 100, Inswarabe to wnt code ew
andifThavletiiothelast mint, econ isnt ht col have
‘anghveittochtbotandsay"nake tenth code sb ste
thst 500 character” eons. Consuming, Wha wold hae taken
aysreend the ouput justo make ‘me 30 mines before naw theses
Sure the chatbot har intrdaced than five mines an saving that
‘nything dost He lime has gen se the opportenity
to improve the quality of my lee
Can chathts be used for maths? torerandistrodacemoreinteetng
Chabot ae anguage-bsed mod ‘ramplestomystdents,
dls so you ant enpect itt solve
vanced mathematical expres Aro chathots widalyused in
Sone: Howcret ths been tine cadens?
‘examples where people have per They arent used as muchas hey
formed mathematic derivations show eI fet that we have bee
‘aught off guard ite bt by the
‘explosion of ChatGPT, Wee now
lyingcath-up pesto whichistry
Ingto protect the cade inegety
cofoue course In physic we dont
have the same problem that disc
pln with more esay wring hve
Yetwe aeady deal with advanced
tool capable farting the works
ght des on a diy basis, Por
Bexample, Wolfram Alps has been
round fora lng time, sn for 8
yes student that more ic
five cheating tal ecase i can per
form quite advanced mathemati
derivations But we shoud become
too complacent snd underestimate
‘ht habs can ds
Isitgod or students tus thon?
[isrealyimporanttat westreso
Courstadens that they have o pac
tie fundamental hls beloe they
ase something like ChatGPT
Understanding the wading con
«pts and principe i necestary to
he thee oa etetvety and inter
ret thee results. Thisisas tre for
(estes workssitiformathenats
Thatinlodr wring apes sad per
forminga itertareteview. Fyouget
fs chatbet todo to ou oa netet
learawhatagooditertrescvien's
Weshoneediothinkandsbot hw
ve are ping to change the way we
earthing kb reports Do we
ow tart lacking at osed book ab
reports or do we set higher evel
‘ils s0 were looking fr the dep
Alysha chtboteannot dot
hate can chatot playin
selec pblshing?
Tibia there shoulda be aot of
ence around this, but gui, we
‘Hoult become to complacent
Byery tol designed to make work
ror productive and we shoulda
‘ay entely om he fol todo the
job, The tol there for people to
{cand to create something beyond
‘what they could do without ew
‘hr ould tat Beste hese
‘thot ares acre, oorals
‘might se an enormous increase
Uogaspapersthatarewriteneney
bchatbs and that ould be eat
problem, Youthen rn hii hat
the chabot wees the paper andthe
shatbt reads the paper and humans
tuebypssed ently Like wth any
thing fis abused to that extent,
sa poblem.a News & Analysis
Doyouthinkitsa goodideathat Vie ready _«ilnt ies, but then it fas tobe ing inlsve anguage you could
Seretbeenratansa: WOAIRaCY ee epee fut et te asad sy
Heemertpeboccrmmneg — SCUNTN — Spndinacdnicoringceimetiinaewabay
nth to ocean thay Snbnphysce theses semain wary and tod og
‘used the chatbats? ‘tools capable ity of papers is poor compared to the entirely on the chatbot to do this for
Srnec mpucrdihe ofasiting Gallet feu Wel eens
SGicisessowiyiheaitmater the waka nulls
olanecucltaa pw pysestaoes ral chtbae ohlp Synge tosis hem br you
Mremtuetccbi races peed Geeeeraetay —_etendtithesart inde
welttoncicboateness 2 We intipa Gacenstabutny eontuboybehecionna
‘dent, saya literature review that's. P@SIS- work, because there is some overlap
chet writen A acon Riese ttc tk Aryeh heat
Simatic le iRofhintandccattemtearar aor
rc thee aed cha edith yond unde Tekh get ange
Pieper nsedton weet Stelle Inprving tec tee
Tat ey we a he eee Motte wre hnsberct_ sing esol erlainare
Ictoppae oie wien dng eee cntseace caso. Sot gets ck
tie deseo os ha etl ning chont. eth intone aor
Natu tnghd ts opoed he Slalealy ung welt wt they med pring
Tea cpa ‘Trp were becuse Kind of erasing pa 1 or
‘iechung: the ncsipot wha MOO peo bebe ago our
‘md chats be a god ter ‘ein Sop yn
{Seeopmedent hae Engn ‘incre he seas te
Gout tatingaget Coulthrobe vsysueswith tnt athe stent can
Ma Thats feo chats Eaotn ego Ws spar
thet ape tes Metal yes fu eh to be tsar at eae
‘Necubity fr ents whe oe erties tates theif tc chet
Smt) hee bey ert gt SEStomomehtem divine? mpd are
fetapbccson clo ‘Slvheberthadouehataqct come
Exp ae pee whe oe itr oy tt
poe cmmubiate ates ne ott uct fo sane SS ST
"fesse some ae Tejon py and did tee
Feces
Search for gravitational waves resumes after COVID
TloosmyetsatActatetin Sty nd austen ed coi
Nomnanetate seo ecu nr enka
tase ea vet etre
fin Tenet berate athe
beset eurth-was meant start
Ietyear tnt ns pstponed to pment ees
‘gina lays resting om the
‘oMb-1 pane Then
lenges ae, 8 ont
rent
‘epends eres th ns we
obec
Tatts aneer a ie pata”
Reserbesspotiedtfist ‘tert fart, boc
fovtnonatnaein2016tome ‘Ihe unders em snags sectors ate expected
SharylocklemerprSaeten _Jxpn cme operat 2019.1 ner orb opeatesprtela
‘other 92 etetonsbnebeen made jane pros run nab 2020 {athe cstngs sed on ho minors
terthesbseratinal rns te lest|_ ott cnn asa shat ato "enw entings cre i8
‘ohio coed nto 2020, tepanene avapeat pase, a Asso
‘ewe ofpgadestht tae been» Wa AORA cures pore ‘att othe he atte
anfodeatto ta aedVige —thanVigeandUGDttecting Inmate The wpenmig]
‘eters epsteta dealer pavtatna woes, ts sent ‘lato he sentient be
nati oveienstarmerges. lasso proviso deter Ineresed ie th cotngdsiens
‘Weeaspavtateales wee upad RAGRA wi operat ooe fae and then est ases are
tetectadanetery chine monhlethe peng abel blng Popre ferth flsing rene
Pearson chown Stdoroinprvenets. Ms bepee eating expec abet
hold owbeplled py toy. Sat tht KARA enon ferthe th breton, eh
Ttepetvalvonssoboittom tenttves monn nxt yea. einen 2026.
JapnnsRacaaetosy which” " "Motopeareataocartist ieee
eyo wren 202 BComment
physicsworld
STE aetna
—
‘arnt ont peace Cv ha ope
‘an atnminting
‘inten
Sipebeientsan tana
Seiten,
‘nts apenas
eo za3 Prato ari
Scmetiee
Pare etm
encore esate meee
Sa eooeaeot
Sa
sino mane dn i,
‘womb
HOP Publishing
PhD blues
‘Taday's Pu studonts face unprocedentod challenges but lack nough support
youve ever done PRD in phys, yull know ican be tough experience Youre
een the art of eeach and trying to get eal acetic eu frthe fit ten
ourcaer There are theories to understand, experimental techniques to master and
[Sitar codes ear, You might even be ina dillerent country, coping with new
Tanguigeor culture. And then there can be workplace problems to contend with: i
fcaltcallegues,uaplesint discrimination and unseen hierarchies.
Bul life ae been eapectally hard for[
‘day's PD sadents whose workchas been
Hit by the COVID-19 pandemic. They ve
ad fo cope with labs Being shut, expert
rent stoping and conact with sper
visors and colleagues belng disrupted.
1s Physics Word contributing colons
arel Green describes ie pp2l-29), may
students have not surprisingly, fallen
tehind with thir workand struggled oye
‘enough results Sure, PRDs students have l=
Always faced such problems, but they've
Teen exacerbated the retictons imposed dung the pandemic
‘Green whois ding PRD inastrophysis, has based her arte not just one own
cexperencesbutalso thse ofothersinasinilar postion toher own, Asshe discovered,
Some students have simply ben ett sinko swim. Despite the COVID disruption,
{nev not necessarily ben given ex money orenough ere ie towne wp thls
Ds Andeveniftheyhave received additonal suppor they ve often bat Bight or
tne fending or rackit down under heir own eam Stadents fe their problem are
ster being ignored or swept under the carpet.
Greens article undelines wider eoncerns rete very nature of PADS which were
‘ncescenasadoor into permanent acadencreseuch career for asec bandoftop
students These days, however, universes to often see PAD students a frm of|
‘heap labour with nt enough consideration given to the ely tat may wll goon
‘bwork outside academia. What’ worse, PD projects aren always wel thought out
rasperised withsomestadents collecting data without proper directo, seucture
‘rlypothess
Forthore stent who successfllyampalltherehurdlerandasmitathess, there
‘ze further concerns ofr the nature ofthe PAD vt. Inthe UK, theres stan
‘ed length for this oral exam, while the sobjet knowledge of the examiner an vary
Villy fom one student tothe net puting some aa disadvantage through no lt
theicown,
"Troubles those whoend upin academic posts havea reason to question what went
‘wrong fr those who struged you've gat your PRD, why worry about anyone who
Tas? Bul hose who the system has led arin danger abel witha our a
tuseintheir mouths, potentially quitingphyskcslhogether, And thatcannotbe god
foranyone concerned abot the Ftureofthe subject
Matin Da
Forni, Pyses Word
‘iinet vcore ance enactForum
The problem with brilliance in physics
‘Amy Smith argues that we need to rethink how we mark achievements in physics
Whips dierent from otherscences?
‘While our perception of who does science
vebvosdenng at leastin terms of gender
ur dealt image of ys emainn
ely stack i the pst. Recet stds ave
own that we il pict pps ae
proplwio are mereianaly bila nare
ocklly awkward and let collaborative
than thocin oer sent dciplines
These stereotypes are not only Wrong
they can be damaging ad can een pat
rospetivephyacrotadetsffeteingthe
ject For those aed inthe el sich
ereoypercan make them fa more uncer
{ain about the pace ysles loge,
But whee d these stereenypes came rom?
‘While the media ae len blamed for
carleatured depictions of physi, and
Sometins righty sth persatnce ofthe
Uulancestereotypernay bedown tous
Tone recent sty, undergradate
physics students in the UK = along
$ide thelr non-pysies peers - decribed
‘Pipseses egeiing moe ilipnce ad
Eetgharderthananyothersclene je.
Pethape we sould be surprised ven
{hat you ned such god geese Hy
physics at univers, whieh embeds the
‘otion af piss aan elite sujet and an
pio ol forthe very best.
Teis no all of phys, bower, that
sen a elit. A sty eatied ot in 2020
{und that some py ciples such as
tReretica phytcs wee seen a more