You are on page 1of 53

Manual of Forensic Science: An

International Survey 1st Edition Anna


Barbaro
Visit to download the full and correct content document:
https://textbookfull.com/product/manual-of-forensic-science-an-international-survey-1
st-edition-anna-barbaro/
More products digital (pdf, epub, mobi) instant
download maybe you interests ...

Introduction to Data Analysis with R for Forensic


Scientists International Forensic Science and
Investigation 1st Edition Curran

https://textbookfull.com/product/introduction-to-data-analysis-
with-r-for-forensic-scientists-international-forensic-science-
and-investigation-1st-edition-curran/

Forensic Plant Science 1st Edition Bock

https://textbookfull.com/product/forensic-plant-science-1st-
edition-bock/

Forensic Textile Science 1st Edition Carr

https://textbookfull.com/product/forensic-textile-science-1st-
edition-carr/

An Introduction to Survey Research, Volume I: The


Basics of Survey Research 2nd Edition Emeritus L.
Cowles

https://textbookfull.com/product/an-introduction-to-survey-
research-volume-i-the-basics-of-survey-research-2nd-edition-
emeritus-l-cowles/
Assessment of Autism Spectrum Disorder Critical Issues
in Clinical Forensic and School Settings 1st Edition
Anna P. Kroncke

https://textbookfull.com/product/assessment-of-autism-spectrum-
disorder-critical-issues-in-clinical-forensic-and-school-
settings-1st-edition-anna-p-kroncke/

A philosophy for the science of well-being 1st Edition


Anna Alexandrova

https://textbookfull.com/product/a-philosophy-for-the-science-of-
well-being-1st-edition-anna-alexandrova/

Ethical Standards in Forensic Science 1st Edition


Harold Franck (Author)

https://textbookfull.com/product/ethical-standards-in-forensic-
science-1st-edition-harold-franck-author/

An Introduction to Survey Research, Volume II: Carrying


Out the Survey 2nd Edition Emeritus L. Cowles

https://textbookfull.com/product/an-introduction-to-survey-
research-volume-ii-carrying-out-the-survey-2nd-edition-emeritus-
l-cowles/

Scientific computing an introductory survey 2nd Edition


Heath M.T

https://textbookfull.com/product/scientific-computing-an-
introductory-survey-2nd-edition-heath-m-t/
Manual of Forensic Science
Manual of Forensic Science: An
International Survey

Edited by
Anna Barbaro
CRC Press
Taylor & Francis Group
6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300
Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742

© 2018 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC


CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business

No claim to original U.S. Government works

Printed on acid-free paper

International Standard Book Number-13: 978-1-4987-6630-2 (Hardback)

This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information,
but the author and publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use. The authors and publishers have
attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this form has
not been obtained. If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and let us know so we may rectify in any future reprint.

Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic,
mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval
system, without written permission from the publishers.

For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the
Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses
and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged.

Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent
to infringe.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Names: Barbaro, Anna, editor.


Title: Manual of forensic science : an international survey / edited by Anna Barbaro.
Description: 1 Edition. | Boca Raton : CRC Press, [2018] | Includes bibliographical references and index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2017015348| ISBN 9781498766302 (hardback : alk. paper) |
ISBN 9781315181424 (ebook)
Subjects: LCSH: Forensic sciences—Handbooks, manuals, etc. | Criminal investigation—Handbooks, manuals, etc.
Classification: LCC HV8073 .M25545 2017 | DDC 363.25—dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2017015348

Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at


http://www.taylorandfrancis.com

and the CRC Press Web site at


http://www.crcpress.com
Contents

Editor vii
Contributors ix

Chapter 1 Crime Scene Investigation 1


Anita Zannin and Linda Huber

Chapter 2 Crime Scene Investigation in the Underwater Environment: Underwater Forensics 21


Mack S. House, Jr.

Chapter 3 Bloodstain Pattern Analysis 35


Anita Zannin

Chapter 4 Latent Print Examination 59


Andrew R. Reitnauer

Chapter 5 Forensic Biology 79


Samar Ahmed and Amarnath Mishra

Chapter 6 Forensic Genetics 89


Anna Barbaro

Chapter 7 Forensic Facial Recognition 111


Shelina Khalid Jilani and Stephen Driver

Chapter 8 Forensic Odontology 135


Alan Diego Briem Stamm, and María Cecilia Pastor Carson

Chapter 9 An Introduction to Digital Audio Forensics 159


Michael Dixon

Chapter 10 Forensic Toxicology 167


Amarnath Mishra and Nino Nardareshvili

Chapter 11 Clinical Forensic Medicine: Child Sexual Abuse 179


Dalia M. Al-Saif and Lori D. Frasier

Chapter 12 Forensic Entomology 211


Adrienne Brundage, Jason Byrd, and Lerah Sutton

Chapter 13 Forensic Veterinary Science and Medicine 235


Víctor Toledo González and Francisco Carvallo Chaigneau

v
vi Contents

Chapter 14 Ethics in Forensics 255


Ghada Hasabo

Chapter 15 Forensic Digital Imaging 263


Michael Dixon, Mark Wood, and Stephen Cole

Appendix Ethical, Legal, and Professional Aspects: The Art of Cross-Examination 279
Filomena Paciello and Kay Michiels
Index 283
Editor

Anna Barbaro earned a PhD in forensic genetics from of Rome La Sapienza, Italy along with several other
the University of Santiago de Compostela, Spain, a courses. She is an expert consultant for the Italian
post-degree diploma from the School of Specialization Court of Justice and is the author of more than 100
in Applied Genetics (University La Sapienza in Rome) papers on forensic DNA analysis. She serves as the
and a master diploma in Psychological and Behavioral founder and president of the Wordwide Association
Techniques of the Criminal Investigation (Msc) from of Women Forensic Experts (WAWFE), she is the
the University La Sapienza in Rome (Italy). She also Honor Dean of the Superior School of Criminalistics
has a diploma of Expert in Criminal Investigation and and Criminology (Spain), and Honor Member of sev-
a diploma of Superior Expert in Criminal Profiling. eral international scientific associations. She is also a
She is the Chief of the Forensic Genetics Department at member of the editorial board for various international
Studio Indagini Mediche E Forensi (SIMEF) in Reggio scientific journals and serves as an expert reviewer for
Calabria, Italy. She teaches forensic genetics at the sec- some forensic journals; and is a speaker at national and
ond master level in forensic sciences at the University international conferences.

vii
Contributors

Samar Ahmed is an associate professor in the Department entomologist and diplomate of the American Board of
of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, Ain Shams Forensic Entomology. He was twice-elected President of
University, Cairo, Egypt. She is education oriented and is a the American Board of Forensic Entomology, and is both
leading educationist by training. She is also responsible for a past and the current President of the North American
program development and evaluation as well as interna- Forensic Entomology Association. He served for over a
tional projects. She graduated from Ain Shams University decade as a faculty member of the Virginia Institute of
and after earning her doctorate degree attained a master’s Forensic Science and Medicine and currently serves as an
degree in health professions education from Maastricht executive manager for the International Veterinary Forensic
University and a fellowship in health professions educa- Sciences Association and as the Director of Education for
tion from the FAIMER Institute in Philadelphia. the ASPCA Veterinary Forensic Sciences Program. Dr.
She has experience in forensic curricula development Byrd has combined his formal academic training in ento-
and has taken many initiatives in the development of the mology and forensic science to serve as a consultant and
learning of forensic science at various stages of education. educator in both criminal and civil–legal investigations
She is a reviewer for many journals in the area of medical throughout the United States and internationally.
education and is an expert in the area with a large body
of international publications in the field. Dr. Ahmed has Maria Cecilia Pastor Carson graduated with a DDS in
an interest in forensic psychiatry and has been involved Odontology from the Faculty of Odontology, Catholic
in many initiatives to work with patient offenders funded University Santa Maria, Arequipa, Peru. She specialized
by the European Union. She is currently creating a Center in orthodontics (UAP University, Lima, Peru); expertise
of Excellence in Forensic Psychiatric Research. dentistry from col. number 018 (Col Lima, Peru); and
forensic odontology (University Cientifica del Sur, Lima).
Dalia M. Al-Saif, MD, is a consultant Forensic Medical She serves as the WAWFE coordinator of Peru and is the
Examiner and Head of the Education and Training vice president of the Peruvian Association of Forensic
Section, Center of Forensic and Legal Medicine, Eastern Dentistry (APOFOR). She is a member of the Peruvian
Province, Saudi Arabia. She is board certified in forensic Society of Legal and Forensic Dentistry and Criminology,
medicine and works as an expert witness in medicolegal the Argentina Society of Legal Odontology (SADOL), the
cases including child abuse. She is a lecturer and pro- Iberoamerican Society of Odontoestomatology (SOFIA),
vides training on the evaluation of sexual abuse victims. the South American Association of Forensic Dentistry
Al-Saif is a member of many local and international asso- (AOFS), the American Association for Orthodontics
ciations related to forensic medicine and child abuse, and (United States), the Paulista Society of Orthodontics
has published many scientific papers related to this field. (Brazil), and the Society of Six Elements (Peru). She is
also a speaker at national and international conferences.
Adrienne Brundage, MD, is a forensic entomologist and
lec-turer at Texas A&M University, and an adjunct pro- Francisco R. Carvallo Chaigneau, DVM, DSc, DACVP,
fessor at the University of Florida. She has been consult- obtained his DVM from the Universidad Austral de Chile,
ing on casework for nearly 20 years, and is a member of Valdivia (2001), a doctor of science from the Universidad
the American Board of Forensic Entomologists. Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, Mexico City (2007),
and completed a 3-year veterinary pathology residency
Jason H. Byrd, MD, is an associate professor and asso- at the University of Connecticut, Storrs, and received
ciate director of the William R. Maples Center for Diplomate status from the American College of Veterinary
Forensic Medicine at the University of Florida’s College Pathologists in 2011. He then moved to the Universidad de
of Medicine, Gainesville. He is a board certified forensic Chile, Department of Animal Pathology where he served

ix
x Contributors

as an assistant professor. He joined the California Animal Linda Huber graduated from the University of
Health and Food Safety Laboratory System (CAHFS), California, Los Angeles and is a forensic scientist at the
at San Bernardino, as an assistant professor of Clinical Orange County Sheriff’s Department in Los Angeles,
Diagnostic Veterinary Pathology in 2014. Dr. Carvallo has California. She also serves as an adjunct professor at
had numerous presentations in international conferences Citrus Community College, Glendora, California.
and publications in peer-reviewed journals.
Shelina Khalid Jilani is a forensic expert specializ-
Stephen Cole works with Acumé Forensics, Ltd. ing in facial mapping at Acumé Forensics. As a foren-
sic and medical science graduate from the University of
Michael Dixon is a technical director at Acumé Forensics Bradford, she is currently pursuing a PhD at the Centre
(West Yorkshire, United Kingdom), with a first class hon- of Visual Computing, University of Bradford, West
ors degree and is a professional member of the Chartered Yorkshire, United Kingdom. She is a professional mem-
Society of Forensic Sciences. An expert in digital media ber of the Chartered Society of Forensic Science and
and how it can be used in the field of forensics and law British Association of Human Identification (BAHID).
enforcement, he works in television, producing recon- Her research interests include ethnic classification of
structions and technical graphics. faces and human verification from photographic images.

Stephen Driver is a facial imaging expert and forensic Kay Michiels, LLM, teaches law and forensics at Avans
artist. University of Applied Sciences, the Netherlands. She is
the coordinator of the minor Chain of Evidence and proj-
Lori D. Frasier, MD, is a professor of pediatrics and ect member of the EFEN network.
director of the Center for the Protection of Children at
Penn State Health Children’s Hospital and Penn State Amarnath Mishra, PhD, is an assistant professor at the
Hershey College of Medicine, Hershey, Pennsylvania. Amity Institute of Forensic Sciences, Amity University,
She is board certified in pediatrics and child abuse pedi- Noida, India. Dr. Mishra has worked as an associate
atrics. Dr. Frasier has written extensively and lectured professor in the Department of Forensic Medicine of
internationally on topics in child abuse and child sex- Tribhuvan University, National Medical College, Nepal.
ual abuse. She has been a part of many committees and He received an MSc in forensic science with a special-
expert panels which have developed the guidelines and ization in DNA forensic and toxicology from Allahabad
current medical approaches to sexually abused children Agricultural Institute–Deemed University, Allahabad,
and adolescents. India in collaboration with the Central Forensic Science
Laboratory, Hyderabad, India; and an MSc in biochem-
Ghada Hasabo, MD, is a lecturer of Forensic Medicine istry from UPRTOU, Allahabad, India. He received an
and Clinical Toxicology, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo MPhil with a specialization in DNA forensic and toxi-
University, Egypt. She is also an International Certified cology from Vinayaka Missions University, Salem, Tamil
Professional Trainer at the Management Development Nadu, India. He received a PhD in forensic science with a
Institute, Missouri State; and an anesthesiology, pain specialization in forensic and analytical toxicology from
management, and postsurgical ICU specialist. Dr. Sam Higginbottom Institute of Agriculture, Technology
Hasabo has been published and serves as a reviewer and and Sciences, Deemed University, Allahabad in col-
editor for a number of international publications in the laboration with Central Forensic Science Laboratory,
field of forensic and toxicology sciences. She is also a Chandigarh, India. He has published 2 books and more
member of many international organizations for women than 15 research articles in reputed peer-reviewed inter-
rights and refugee aid. national and national journals. He has also participated
in various oral and poster presentations during interna-
Mack S. House, Jr., is a crime scene investigator diver tech- tional and national conferences and seminars. He serves
nologist (CSIDT), published author, and internationally as editor, guest editor, reviewer, and editorial board
reputed expert in underwater forensics crime scene inves- member with various international and national journals
tigation. He invented the CSIDT International Weapons of concerned specialization and subjects. He is a member
and Body Containment Devices and is an active member of various international and national professional bod-
of the International Crime Scene Investigators Association ies. He is also a visiting/guest faculty at various colleges
(www.icsia.org), Forensic Experts Incorporated (www. and universities.
feinc.net), the International Association of Coroners and
Medical Examiners, and the Evidence Partnership Ltd. Nino Nardareshvili serves with the Ministry of Internal
of Forensic and Policing Service Association and Global Affairs of Georgia—Forensic Criminalistics Main
Forensic Directory. Division, Tbilisi, Georgia.
Contributors xi

Filomena Paciello has a law degree from the University is the past treasurer of the Argentinian Society of Legal
of Perugia, and a master’s in forensic science—crimi- Dentistry (SADOL); past chairman of the Iberoamerican
nology, investigation, security, and intelligence—from Society of Forensic Odontoestomatology (SOFIA). In
the University of Rome “La Sapienza,” Italy Stage at addition, he is the author of articles in scientific journals
SIMEF Study Medical and Forensic Investigations Study and a speaker at national and international conferences.
in Reggio Calabria, School in Ethics and Techniques of
Criminal Law at Criminal Chamber of Rome. She is also Lerah Sutton is a doctoral candidate in forensic anthropol-
an Expert Criminologist and Expert in Civil–Military ogy at the University of Florida (UF), Gainsville, specializ-
Cooperation. ing in decomposition, forensic taphonomy, and comparative
osteology. She works as a graduate assistant at the William
Andrew R. Reitnauer is a Certified Senior Crime R. Maples Center for Forensic Medicine and a research
Scene Analyst (CSCSA) through the International fellow at the UF-ASPCA Veterinary Forensic Sciences
Association for Identification. For the past 12 years, he Program. She is also a teaching assistant for the forensic
has been an active Latent Print Examiner, Senior Crime science master’s degree program, UF, the nationally rec-
Scene Responder, Forensic Photographer, and Section ognized Hume Honors College, and the UF-ASPCA vet-
Supervisor. In addition to casework duties, he has also erinary forensic sciences master’s degree program. In her
served as a primary trainer for new examiners and out- positions, she responds to death investigation scenes, speaks
side agencies, and is the owner of Delta Forensics, LLC, at workshops and conferences, consults and offers hands-
where he performs case consultations and offers training on field exercises and trainings for law enforcement, con-
classes to members of the professional community. He is ducts original research, and interacts with students seeking
a Past-President and current Chairman of the Board of higher education in the forensic sciences. Sutton earned a
Directors for the New York Division of the IAI and is an master’s degree in forensic science from the University of
active member of three IAI Divisions. He was an initial Florida after earning a bachelor’s degree in anthropology
member of the OSAC Friction Ridge Subcommittee and with the highest honors, also from the University of Florida.
was the Chairman of the Latent Print Technical Working She has been employed by the UF Maples Center through-
Group for the State of New York. out her higher education. Sutton previously worked at the
Florida District 7 & 24, Office of the Medical Examiner,
Alan Diego Briem Stamm, graduated Odontology DDS where she provided administrative support and assisted in
from the Faculty of Odontology of the University National the morgue. After completing her PhD in 2017, she plans
of Northeast, Corrientes, Argentina. He is a Diploma to obtain a faculty position teaching forensic science and
school graduate specializing in legal dentistry (University medicine, conducting research, and working as a consultant
of Rosario, Argentina); a Diploma school graduate spe- to law enforcement agencies. She is also currently working
cializing in Forensic Medicine (University of Corrientes, on developing a new master’s degree program in forensic
Argentina); and a Diploma school postgraduate level medicine to be offered at the University of Florida.
1 and 2 course in Forensic Odontology (University of
Córdoba, Argentina). He is currently pursuing a doctor- Víctor Toledo González obtained his veterinary sci-
ate in dentistry, 3rd cohort at the University of Corrientes. ence degree in 1999 and master’s degree in 2009 from
He is a professor of legal dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, the Universidad de Chile. He developed his professional
University of Buenos Aires (UBA), Argentina; a subdi- career as an assistant professor in the Anatomy Unit in
rector specializing in forensic odontology, Faculty of the Department of Biological Sciences and then in the
Dentistry, University of Buenos Aires; a professor foren- Animal Pathology Department (last 4 years) in Santiago,
sic odontology, Licenciature in Criminalistic, University Chile. He is currently pursuing a doctorate in forensic
Institute of Federal Police (IUPFA); a subdirector of sciences at the University of Alcalá de Henares, Henares,
Forensic Science International Management, Worldwide Spain. Dr. Toledo is the creator, founder, and president of
Group Police; a professor of forensic odontology at level the Iberoamerican Association of Medicine and Forensic
1 and 2 Multidisciplinary Course International Forensic Veterinary Sciences AG. In addition, he is the General
Science and Criminalistic, Fiep Foundation, Worldwide Secretary and Director of the Department of Veterinary
Group Police; a dentist expert in the Forensic Medicine Forensic Veterinary Medicine in Chilean Criminalists
Division of the National Gendarmerie Argentina; the Association AG (COLCRIM). He has participated as a
and the coordinator in Argentina for the Worldwide monitor in activities related with crime scene investiga-
Association of Women Forensic Experts (WAWFE). tion of wildlife animals in technical programs of collabo-
He is a member of the Peruvian Society of the Forensic ration between Chile and the United States. He has given
Dentistry and Criminalistic (SPOLFOC) and of the South numerous presentations at national and international
American Association of Forensic Dentistry (AOFS). He conferences related with forensic veterinary science.
xii Contributors

Mark Wood is a graphic designer and photographer, courses at Syracuse University, taught as faculty and
with more than 20 years of experience as a creative pro- a lab instructor at more than 10 Bloodstain Evidence
fessional and educator. He has developed professional Institutes, a 40-hour basic bloodstain pattern interpre-
training classes and taught both undergraduate and tation course, and is a visiting professor at Francisco
postgraduate courses. In addition, he has delivered train- Marroquin Law School in Guatemala where she pri-
the-trainer courses for the Apple Authorized Training marily teaches crime scene and homicide investigation.
Program. Wood is the author of the only Apple autho- Prior to entering the forensics field, Zannin worked and
rized book on Pages, Numbers, and Keynote, and writes studied in the medical field for many years. Zannin is a
on a broad range of digital imaging topics. member of several professional organizations and is an
internationally recognized expert in bloodstain pattern
Anita Zannin, MSFS, holds two bachelor of science analysis and has been accepted as an expert in both fed-
degrees, one in forensic chemistry and a second in crim- eral and state courts. She has worked on criminal and
inal justice, and a master of science degree in forensic civil cases in the United States, Canada, Australia, and
science. She taught both graduate and undergraduate the United Kingdom.
CHAPTER 1
Crime Scene Investigation
Anita Zannin and Linda Huber

CONTENTS

1.1 Introduction 1
1.2 Classification of the Crime Scene 2
1.3 General Crime Scene Procedures 2
1.3.1 First Responder 3
1.3.2 Crime Scene Security 3
1.3.3 Crime Scene Investigator(s) 4
1.3.4 Security and Safety 4
1.3.5 Initial Walk-Through 4
1.3.6 Final Walk-Through 5
1.3.7 Post-Scene Communication with Investigators 5
1.3.8 Submission of Evidence 6
1.4 Documentation 6
1.4.1 Photography 6
1.4.2 Videography 8
1.4.3 Note-Taking 8
1.4.4 Sketching 8
1.5 Search Methods 9
1.6 Evidence Collection and Packaging 10
1.6.1 Fingerprinting 10
1.6.1.1 Physical 11
1.6.1.2 Chemical 12
1.6.2 Trace Evidence Collection 12
1.6.3 DNA and Blood Evidence Collection 16
1.6.4 Firearms and Related Collection 16
1.6.5 Miscellaneous Evidence Collection 18
1.6.6 Comparison Samples 18
1.6.7 Presumptive Field Tests 18
1.7 Chain of Custody 19
1.8 Reconstruction 19
1.9 Conclusion 19
Bibliography 20

1.1 INTRODUCTION successful prosecution (the right person being pros-


ecuted for the right crime) or the exoneration of an
Crime scene investigation may occur as a result of rela- innocent individual, and an unsuccessful prosecution
tively minor offenses such as property crimes or thefts (either that charges cannot be brought, or an innocent
to very violent crimes such as rape, torture, and murder. person is wrongly prosecuted). The old cliché “garbage
The crime scene investigator (CSI) is the “gatekeeper” in, garbage out” was never as appropriate as in this
to the criminal justice system. The evidence that is col- context! If the CSI fails to recognize evidence, or the
lected, the procedures that are followed, and a thor- potential probative value of a piece of evidence, crimes
ough understanding of the potential value of different may remain unsolved or unprosecutable, or the wrong
kinds of evidence can make the difference between a person is charged.

1
2 Manual of Forensic Science: An International Survey

Behavioral: A crime scene may be defined by the


apparent behavior associated with the scene, such as
organized, disorganized, passive, or active.
Size: Less commonly, a scene may be defined as mac-
Victim Suspect
roscopic or microscopic. An example of a macroscopic
scene might be a stabbing victim, stabbed in a house,
who is transported in a car, and the body dumped in
Physical a creek. All the associated scenes would be considered
evidence to be under the heading of macroscopic. A microscopic
scene is more related to the physical and trace evidence
associated within the macroscopic scene and body itself.
Using the previous example, this could include hairs and
Object Crime scene
fibers in the vehicle used to transport the body or on the
knife, tire tracks or footwear impressions located near
the body, and bloodstains located on the victim, in the
house or in the car utilized for transporting the body.
Site of first alleged criminal activity: More commonly,
when there are multiple scenes related to a particular
FIGURE 1.1 The interrelationships between people, event, they may be referred to as primary, secondary, and
places, and things within a crime scene. tertiary. The primary scene is the site of the first criminal
The goal of a crime scene investigation is to recog- activity. This is not necessarily where the body is located. In
nize, collect, preserve, and test physical evidence in an the stabbing example from the previous Size category, the
effort to reconstruct the events that occurred. Physical house where the stabbing occurred would be the primary
evidence can link suspects to victims, individuals to scene. Some agencies utilize only primary and secondary
objects, and crime scenes, and vice versa. This concept is classifications, where secondary refers to any subsequent
represented in Figure 1.1. scenes as secondary. Therefore, in the above example, both
The tenet that physical evidence can provide link- the car and dump site would be secondary scenes. Other
age to people, places, or things is based upon Locard’s agencies utilize secondary and tertiary designations, where
exchange principle, which states: secondary scenes include any subsequent scenes, such as
dump sites, paths to/from, and so on and tertiary refers
Whenever two objects come into contact, there is to any vehicles utilized in the crime. Referring again to
always a transfer of material. The methods of detec- the above example, the primary scene would be the house
tion may not be sensitive enough to detect this, or the where the stabbing occurred, the secondary scene would
decay rate may be so rapid that all evidence of trans-
be the body dump site, and the car would be the tertiary
fer has vanished after a given time. Nevertheless, the
transfer has taken place.
scene. Suppose that the body was transferred from a car to
a van that then took the body to the dump site; both the
—Edmond Locard (1877–1966) car and the van would be tertiary scenes using this clas-
sification method.
Crime scene investigation can be defined as a legal, It is important to note that the designations of
purposeful, planned, and systematic process, conducted by primary, secondary, and tertiary in no way signify the
competent investigators who possess the requisite knowl- importance or priority of scenes, rather, simply a sequence
edge, skills and abilities to search for, discover, protect, of events. Scenes may also be referred to as dynamic
document, collect, package, label, preserve, and trans- or static. A scene and the evidence contained therein is
mit physical evidence associated with a suspected crimi- always undergoing change and/or degradation, even if not
nal event to a forensic science facility for safekeeping and visible to the naked eye, including during the investigative
eventual scientific examination and analysis (Rini, n.d.). process, until the evidence is collected. With this under-
standing, an unprocessed scene is considered dynamic.
1.2 CLASSIFICATION OF After a scene has been processed, it is considered static.
THE CRIME SCENE
Crime scenes may be classified in several ways: 1.3 GENERAL CRIME
Type of crime: Homicide, suicide, sexual assault, SCENE PROCEDURES
robbery, and so on, are examples of defining a scene by
the type of alleged crime or incident. The first person to arrive at a scene is referred to as the
Location: A scene may be described by its physical loca- first responder. Depending on how a call comes in, this
tion, such as indoor, outdoor, vehicle, aquatic, and so forth. may be police officers, fire department, or emergency
Crime Scene Investigation 3

medical personnel. For the purposes of this writing, the scene. For instance, if, upon arrival, a victim
when referring to the “first responder,” this will refer to is found prone in a small space between the sink
the first responding police officer. and bathtub, and the first responder had to pull
the victim out and turn him over to check for signs
of life, this is critical for the investigators to know,
1.3.1 First Responder as it is no longer a pristine scene and will have
undoubtedly created some artifactual evidence.
The first responder(s) will be the only individual(s) to
observe a scene in its most pristine state, and their obser-
vations are critical. There are a number of duties that the 1.3.2 Crime Scene Security
first responder must carry out: most importantly, he/she
must ensure safety of the scene and the people associated Because crime scene investigation procedures are based
with it, including him/herself and the victim(s). upon Locard’s exchange principle, it is of utmost impor-
tance to establish scene security so as to avoid unneces-
• If the victim is alive, the first responder should sary contamination by nonessential personnel. This can
assist the victim until appropriate medical be accomplished by using multiple layers of security, for
personnel arrive to take over. If the victim is example:
deceased, the first responder should take mea-
sures to prevent any changes to the body. • Zone (or Level) 1—Is the immediate crime scene,
• If the suspect is still on scene, search for and where the highest level of restriction is in force.
arrest, as appropriate. Only essential personnel (those processing the
• Detain witnesses—If possible, witnesses should scene) should be in this area. For example, if a
be separated both from each other and from crime occurred in the gymnasium of a school, only
the scene in order to preserve their objectivity. essential personnel should be in the gymnasium.
For the same reason, witnesses should not be • Zone (or Level) 2—Is a wider perimeter around
returned to the scene. This is not to say that an Zone 1, where access should be restricted to only
individual would deliberately mislead (although individuals performing official duties. This is the
some will); however, if they are returned to the zone in which incident command or a command
scene, the possibility exists that their minds will center would be located. Using the above exam-
subconsciously attempt to “fill in the blanks” ple, Zone 2 could be the entire school building.
and/or explain why certain pieces of evidence • Zone (or Level) 3—Is an even wider perimeter
appear as they do (e.g., “Well, he must have than Zone 2, where members of the media can
fallen backward to have blood in that location— be located, while excluding the general public.
I thought I saw him fall to the side”). It is well Again using the school example, Zone 3 could
documented that the majority of wrongful con- be the entire school property.
victions are based on erroneous eyewitness testi-
mony. Most people are not expecting to witness Figure 1.2 illustrates this concept using the school
a violent crime, and therefore are not prepared example above.
to “record” every detail. Knowing that witness
statements may vary, conflict, and/or contain Zone 3—General public restriction (School grounds)
inaccuracies, every effort should be taken to
Zone 2—Restricted to those performing
avoid additional “contamination.” official duties
• Establish scene security—How this is accom- (entire school building)
plished will depend on the location of a crime
scene and can include official vehicles to block Zone 1—
Highest restriction
off streets, barrier tape, or other means available
until additional assistance arrives. A crime scene (Gymnasium)
log should be initiated, documenting the name,
date, in/out times, and duty or agency of those Command
individuals with access to the crime scene. This center
helps prevent unauthorized individuals or offi-
cials from entering the scene. No eating, drink-
ing, smoking, restroom use, and so on, should be Media
allowed within the secured area.
• Document and communicate to the investigator
all movements, actions, and any alterations within FIGURE 1.2 Example of multilevel scene security.
4 Manual of Forensic Science: An International Survey

It is important to note that the perimeter(s) initially to protect the CSI(s) while they are processing the scene
established may have to be adjusted once the crime scene should be dealt with. Additionally, the description of
personnel arrive and evaluate the scene. the scene from the first responder will help the CSI to
assess potential hazards and determine what personal
protective equipment (PPE) is likely to be needed or if
1.3.3 Crime Scene Investigator(s) additional assistance from specialty teams like hazmat
or bomb squad is required before beginning scene pro-
Upon arrival to the scene, the CSI(s) should sign in on cessing. The CSI(s) must evaluate the scene and use their
the previously established crime scene log. If one has judgment and training to determine the safety of a situa-
not yet been initiated, the CSI should initiate the crime tion. CSI personnel should not feel pressured to process
scene attendance log and obtain as much information as a scene or perform a procedure if they reasonably believe
possible regarding other undocumented individuals who their personal safety will be compromised.
may have been at the scene. After signing in, the CSI
should have a conference with the first responder and/or
on-scene detective (if arrived) to understand the circum- 1.3.5 Initial Walk-Through
stances of the scene as known at that time. This does not
mean the CSI’s “theory” of what occurred and should The initial walk-through is also referred to as the primary
include only facts known. survey. The only individuals who should be included in
CSIs must also ensure that they will be conducting the walk-through are the first responder, CSI, and case
a legal search. In the United States, searches can be con- detective (if on scene). This orients the CSI and detective
ducted in the following circumstances: to the scene, and the first responder should describe his/
her paths within the scene in addition to any item that
• Consent—The person who owns or has the legal was changed, removed, or otherwise altered. This infor-
ability to consent can give permission to conduct mation is critical, especially in scenes where there was
a search of an area of interest. a great deal of activity prior to the CSI arrival, when it
• Exigent circumstances—Exigent circumstances comes time to reconstruct the scene. It can be helpful to
are those situations where evidence will be dam- take some initial “establishing” photographs during the
aged or lost if it is not collected immediately, or walk-through, as this is the most pristine state that the
if there is an immediate risk of serious injury or CSI will observe the scene. The CSI should:
death. An example of an exigent circumstance
could be that, upon police arrival, a suspect runs • Be aware of current and upcoming weather and
to the bathroom to attempt to flush drugs, and environmental conditions that might alter or
the drugs were recovered. This would not give destroy evidence. Precautions should be taken
permission to search the rest of the bathroom to protect and collect any evidence that might
or house for drugs. With the drugs and suspect be affected by adverse weather or environmental
secured, a search warrant should be obtained to conditions. For example, strong winds or rain
search the remainder of the residence. could potentially alter or destroy evidence. If this
• Search warrant—A legal, thorough search war- situation occurs, the evidence should be photo-
rant is the best way to gain access to the area of graphed, documented with measurements, and
interest, as this reduces the likelihood of evidence collected as soon as possible.
later being deemed inadmissible for various rea- • Make note of transient and/or conditional evi-
sons, such as the individual from whom consent dence that will require immediate processing,
was obtained didn’t have the legal authority to collection or protection. Transient evidence is tem-
do so or the judge disagrees that exigent circum- porary evidence, such as odors or hair/fiber evi-
stances existed. dence that is not adhered to something, such that
it might be lost with normal actions performed
during scene processing. Conditional evidence is
1.3.4 Security and Safety evidence that is the result of an action, such as
entries and exits (transferred evidence), lights (did
During the initial conference, potential safety issues, first responder turn on/off?), or moved furniture
both situational and infectious, should be considered (occurred during incident or to create access for
and discussed. For example, if there has been a multiple first responder?). Evidence may be both transient
shooting, the scene must be cleared by police prior to and conditional, for example, a cigarette burn-
entry of the crime scene team. If there is apparent unrest, ing in an ashtray. The burning cigarette is tran-
suspect(s) still at large, or it is a high-profile case, a plan sient because it will stop burning at some point
Crime Scene Investigation 5

and conditional because someone had to light the • Note-taker


cigarette to cause it to burn (this may also give • Sketcher
information as to when the incident occurred). • Evidence collector(s)
• Identify points of entry and exit and note con- • Evidence custodian
tamination caused by first responder(s). Also
identify paths of movement within the scene. Many departments are too small to have a differ-
Ideally, there should be only one point of entry ent individual assigned to each role, and one person may
and exit, and a path through the scene for per- have to fill two or more roles, so this requires a bit more
sonnel and equipment. attention when planning the scene approach, to ensure
• Brief initial observations should be recorded. an efficient work-flow that maintains the integrity and
This is not the detailed narrative that will be thoroughness of the search and collection of evidence.
completed at a later time, but rather a “snap- CSI personnel should not be rushed or allow themselves
shot” that deals with the nuts-and-bolts infor- to be rushed by others, should take control, and be firm
mation of who, what, where, when, and how. if necessary. Ultimately, the CSI personnel are the ones
• Determine needs in terms of personnel, equip- responsible for the integrity of the evidence collected and
ment, PPE, and specialists (if applicable and presented in court.
available). Notify appropriate parties, as per After the approach is decided and roles are assigned,
policy, as to necessary additional personnel, a search for evidence is conducted, documented, and col-
equipment, or specialists that are needed. lected (to be described in greater detail below).
• Determine the extent of your search area. As
mentioned above, this may result in the expan-
sion of your initial crime scene perimeter. 1.3.6 Final Walk-Through
• If there is a decedent present, coordinate pro-
cessing with the coroner/medical examiner Prior to releasing the scene, a final walk-through is con-
personnel. ducted to ensure that no evidence was inadvertently
• Determine the need for barriers to reduce obser- overlooked and all equipment has been retrieved. The
vation by the public and press photographers. possibility of returning to a scene once it has been released
Situations may also arise that require CSI per- is highly unlikely; therefore, this is a good time to review
sonnel to process an area of the scene in order to your notes to ensure that all measurements and obser-
create a pathway to the decedent. vations have been documented. Discuss the scene search
• Conduct the walk-through slowly, being very and evidence recovered with relevant personnel. This is a
cognizant of where personnel are stepping and good time to photograph the scene in its final condition if
anything that is touched. Take extreme care not damage was done during processing (e.g., demolition of
to disturb the scene in any way during this initial walls to recover bullets). All death investigations should
walk-through. be conducted as homicide investigations, until the evi-
• Take in the big picture and do not mark or move dence proves otherwise. There is only one opportunity to
anything. collect the evidence, and this mind-set will help prevent
• Look for evidence mentioned by the briefing overlooking evidence that may be important later as the
officer and investigator. Does what is seen fit the investigation develops.
information provided? Try and think through
the actions of the perpetrator. Does the evidence
observed fit the hypothesis? Or, does it reveal a 1.3.7 Post-Scene Communication with Investigators
different scenario? Note that it may not always be
possible to accurately reconstruct the actions of After the evidence associated with the crime scene inves-
the perpetrator due to lack of sufficient evidence. tigation has been submitted to the crime laboratory, the
crime scene investigator becomes the case manager or
Once the walk-through is complete, the lead CSI liaison between the crime lab and the investigators.
(team leader) will determine the best approach to the Once evidence is transported back to the CSI office/
scene that will result in the most efficient, but thorough lab, follow-up examinations can be performed. This
search for and collection of evidence, and determine the can include things like processing certain pieces of evi-
roles of each team member. In the most ideal circum- dence for fingerprints that could not be performed at the
stance, the following roles should be assigned: scene, photographing pieces of evidence in more detail,
or examining clothing for the presences of gunpowder
• Team leader particles that requires the use of illuminated magnifiers
• Photographer/videographer and microscopes. Additionally, the detective’s ongoing
6 Manual of Forensic Science: An International Survey

investigation of the case may lead to additional infor-


mation that may require another search and/or collec-
tion of evidence.

1.3.8 Submission of Evidence

It is not practical or financially feasible to submit every


piece of evidence to the laboratory for testing. Therefore,
based on the particular case circumstances, evidence
selected for testing should be those which will, regardless 1
of results, provide the most useful information in deter-
mining the essential facts of the case. Similarly, not all
pieces can be utilized for all types of testing. One may
have to choose which testing will yield the most proba-
tive information. For example, consider a pistol with a
textured grip. Should it be submitted for fingerprint pro-
cessing or DNA to attempt to establish possession? In
this case, since it is difficult to obtain latent prints from
this type of surface, submitting it for low copy number
(sometimes called “touch”) DNA may be more probative.
If the subject was not wearing gloves, it is more likely
that skin cell and/or sweat (especially in the context of
committing a crime) can be recovered than fingerprints
from the grip of the pistol. FIGURE 1.3 Overall photograph. (From the authors’ files.)

together for a panoramic depiction of the room(s).


1.4 DOCUMENTATION A convenient way to achieve this is to utilize the
corners of the room as your focal point, or uti-
1.4.1 Photography lize the four compass points: north, south, east
and west. These should also include doors/door-
Proper scene photography is critical to thoroughly doc- ways into and out of the scene, and windows
umenting a scene for proper case disposition at a later and routes leading to and away from the scene.
time. The goal of photo-documenting the scene is to Overall photographs provide context and show
provide a true and accurate representation of the scene relationships between pieces of evidence.
when it is reviewed by others at a later time and/or use • Mid-range photographs (Figure 1.4)—As the
in court proceedings. The photographs should provide title suggests, these photographs are taken at a
the viewer with a “snapshot” of the scene, as seen by the distance between overall and close-up, and the
photographer, and reveal the different stages of the scene focus is individual pieces of evidence in relation-
investigation. Typically, photography is done after the ship to one another and other items within the
initial walk-through or after videography. An organized, scene. The number of photographs taken in this
systematic method should be utilized, with the general range will vary based on the specifics of the par-
flow of: ticular scene, and should progress in a step-wise
manner. Different lenses, f-stops, or lighting
• Overall photographs (Figure 1.3)—These pic- may need to be utilized to achieve good-quality
tures are also known as “establishing” pictures results.
and include interior and exterior photographs. • Close-up photographs (Figure 1.5)—These pho-
These are typically done prior to any movement tographs again feature the individual pieces of
of evidence or placement of evidence markers evidence, but at a much closer range to show
as a way of documenting the scene in its initial greater detail and should be examination qual-
state. Exterior views should include outbuildings, ity. The photograph of a 1 millimeter bloodstain
surroundings, street signs, address placards and/ is going to require a different technique than a
or mailbox showing address, and paths to/from bloodstained shoe. Generally, the flash will need
the scene. Interior views should be overlapping to be detached from the camera body, or a ring
in order to be able to “stitch” the photographs flash utilized. Different lighting techniques may
Crime Scene Investigation 7

FIGURE 1.5 Close-up photograph. (From the authors’ files.)

invaluable. Therefore, a log should be created as part of


standard procedure so the photographer doesn’t have to
decide whether the scene warrants one or not.
Whenever possible, photographs should be taken 90
degrees from the subject of interest in order to minimize
distortion. This is a necessity if the photograph is going
to be considered examination quality. The photograph
FIGURE 1.4 Mid-range photograph. (From the authors’ files.) should be free of distortion, correctly exposed, and in
sharp focus. This may require stools, stepladders, tri-
need to be utilized to capture sufficient detail. pods, and bubble levels to accomplish. Efforts should
These photographs should be both with and with- be made not to capture personnel, hands, feet, or other
out scales. Therefore, there should be a progres- extraneous objects.
sion of overall, mid-range, close-up without scale, Last, the camera should be set to “continuous” num-
close-up with scale, photograph area underneath, bering mode so that each photograph has its own unique
behind, and so on, after the item is collected to number and numbering doesn’t reset to zero when the
show there is or is not additional evidence covered camera is turned off or the SIM card is replaced. Once
by the object, for example, a cartridge case found photographing a scene is finished, the pictures should be
on the ground after the gun is collected. downloaded to a “master” file that is never altered. Make
three CDs—one for the unit, one for the prosecutor, and
It is good practice, after the overall or mid-range one for the defense—and seal them in an evidence bag.
photographs are taken, to place the evidence markers Once these steps are taken, a copy of the master folder
and re-photograph from at least the overall perspective. can be made, to which corrections can be made (bright-
This is of great assistance to individuals who have to ness, contrast, hue, etc.). Some departments have soft-
examine the photographs at a later time. Camera settings ware through which the photos must be imported, and
that provide the best depth of focus should be utilized. It the software assigns its own number to the photograph.
is also good practice to start the photograph series with Photographs should never be deleted, even if they are of
a placard that contains the name of the case, date, time, poor quality or captured inadvertently. The SIM card
photographer name, and a gray scale. can be forensically wiped and reused, or, some depart-
Given the prevalence of digital cameras today, there ments use a new card for each scene.
is debate as to whether photography logs are necessary, The digital camera has made it much easier to take
since all the camera information and settings are con- many photographs and allows an immediate review of
tained within the metadata. Some are of the thought that quality so additional photographs can be taken if one or
“the picture should speak for itself.” While that is true, more are not of acceptable quality. Therefore, photogra-
realistically, some scenes are more difficult to photo- phers should not go into a scene with a predetermined
graph than others, and optimal views may not be able to number of photographs that they will take, or be con-
be obtained, and the photograph’s context is unclear. In servative in their photography—if in doubt, photograph
these types of situations, a photo log that includes, at the it! And remember the axiom if it wasn’t photographed,
very least, the picture number and description would be it wasn’t seen.
8 Manual of Forensic Science: An International Survey

There are several “special” photography scenarios that Fulsome note-taking will be invaluable if and when
may need to be utilized, including, but not limited to, low the case goes to court, as many cases do not go to court
light photography, aerial photography, and photographing for a year or longer, and will assist in giving a complete
the scene post evidence retrieval that documents changes “picture” to the reader. Cryptic notes tend to cause more
or damage that occurred as a result of evidence collection questions and skepticism.
activities (e.g., wall damage after projectile retrieval). Every The following information should be included in
potential scenario cannot be described in detail here due crime scene notes:
to space requirements. However, there are many resources
that describe and instruct in great detail how best to deal • Case Information
with a variety of photography situations/challenges. • Date, time and method of notification, and
what information was received.
• Date, time of arrival, transportation method,
1.4.2 Videography individuals present upon arrival, and any
notifications that may need to be made.
Many agencies routinely videotape crime scenes. This • Description of Scene
gives the viewer a much better sense of spatial orienta- • Location type and condition, weather (and
tion that cannot be achieved with still photography. impending weather, if applicable), major
Videography should be completed after the initial walk- structures, and any transient or conditional
through, prior to still photography. evidence identified.
Audio should be turned off, and the video should • Victim description (note that in most areas,
not be narrated. As with still photography, personnel and the body cannot be moved without the per-
equipment should not be seen in the video. Additionally, mission of the medical examiner or coroner),
as with still photography, the approach should be planned position, clothing, obvious wounds, lividity,
and systematic, and the video should begin with a placard jewelry (also important to document a lack
with the case name, date, time, location and videographer’s of jewelry), and presence or absence of any
name. The video should start from the outside of the struc- identification.
ture, surroundings, and route to the scene. Once in the • CSI team: personnel names and roles, initial
scene, the goal should be to provide a general orientation and final walk-through times, beginning and
of the scene. Remembering to cover all four compass points ending times of activity and any variations
should assist in thorough video documentation. Also very from procedure, unusual circumstances, or,
useful is to record video from the victim’s viewpoint; get if evidence was moved or somehow altered,
as close as possible to the victim without compromising why and how that occurred.
evidence, and again, cover the four compass points. • Location of Evidence
Transitions should be smooth, movement slow and • Where the individual items of evidence were
even, and not jump from area to area. If the scene is dark discovered. Measurement from two fixed
or there are a large amount of shadows, extra lighting points allows for accurate reconstruction.
should be utilized. Review the tape on-scene after com- • Designate pieces of evidence or groupings of
pletion, and re-shoot if needed. Videos should never be evidence with numbered or lettered evidence
edited or erased and, in most situations, must be in their markers.
original condition to be admissible as evidence. This • Evidence List
recording is now evidence and should be handled in a • Both a general statement of evidence col-
manner similar to the still photographs. lected (e.g., “45 pieces of evidence were
recovered from the kitchen and bedroom”)
in addition to a detailed evidence log that
1.4.3 Note-Taking describes the piece of evidence, any visible
manufacturer information (e.g., brand name,
Note-taking is an activity that is completed as an on- serial numbers, headstamps), time collected,
going activity at the time the tasks are performed, so and who collected it.
that there is a contemporaneous written record of crime
scene activities that is not affected by memory loss at a
later time. Notes should be taken in chronological order, 1.4.4 Sketching
detailed and legible. Sloppy notes or vague statements
can later be misinterpreted in court. Notes should never Sketching is a very important task to complete, as this
be discarded or erased. Errors are corrected according to is what depicts the scene and the relationships among
each agency’s policy and procedures. evidence items with accurate measurements, at a glance.
Crime Scene Investigation 9

Sketches are useful in depicting the overall layout of the What to include in the sketch:
scene and allow for selectivity by including only details
that are important to the case. The two most popular • Case identifier, date, CSI personnel drawing
sketching perspectives are the bird’s-eye view (overhead, sketch
as seen from above, looking straight down) and the ele- • A scale or designated “not to scale” note some-
vation (side view). The overhead view depicts items in a where on the sketch
scene on a single horizontal plane, while the side view • Legends that are used to designate important
is useful when a vertical plane is necessary (e.g., blood- features in the sketch (e.g., color red for blood).
stains present on a wall). The two basic types of sketches • Directionality (i.e., compass or indication of
are the rough sketch (an example can be seen at: http:// north direction)
www.tpub.com/maa/12740_files/image608.jpg), which • All significant objects, structures, and items of
is done at the scene and is not usually to scale, and the evidence with measurements
finished sketch (an example can be seen here: http://www.
creatiline.com/tag/finished-sketch-crime-scene). Keep in Three methods for obtaining measurements for a
mind that the information obtained for the rough sketch crime scene sketch:
will be utilized to create the finished sketch for presenta-
tion in court. If you are unsure about whether or not to • Triangulation—Two fixed points (things that are
take a measurement, or include an item, it is better to not easily changed, such as corners in a room,
obtain more information than necessary than to need it door frames, trees) are selected and the distance
and not have it. The finished sketch is completed from from each point to the piece of evidence is noted.
the information from the rough sketch, but “cleaned up” If, for example, there is a body on the floor, and
(in the sense that it is neater) and done with the presence the legs are spread apart, measurements from
of relevant measurements, scale, orientation, and legend. each fixed point to the top of the head and to
Three-dimensional laser scanning systems are cur- the bottoms of the right foot and left foot should
rently being adopted by an increasing number of law be recorded. These measurements would allow a
enforcement agencies. These scanners can be quickly body to be positioned in the most accurate posi-
deployed to measure and map indoor and outdoor scenes. tion possible, rather than if measurements were
This mobile laser device has the capability of collecting taken only from the fixed points to the head (this
thousands of measurements per second while an embed- would allow the rest of the body to be placed
ded high-resolution digital camera takes photographs. anywhere in a 360-degree circumference).
Once the information is scanned and photographed, • Polar coordinates—This method also uses two
computer software can generate diagrams, perform scene fixed points, but also uses angles. For example,
reconstruction, and provide accurate measurements. evidence #1 is located 2´3˝ from a wall and 20
There are templates available of commonly encoun- degrees southeast. Angles can be measured with
tered items that can be easily used in the field that allow a compass or transit.
the preparer to create a rough sketch more neatly and • Baseline—Again, two fixed points are utilized,
easily. An example is shown in Figure 1.6. such that a straight line is drawn between the
points. The evidence is measured by its distance
down the line and perpendicular to the line.

Computer software is available to assist in finished


sketches and/or create professional, scaled renderings.

1.5 SEARCH METHODS

A variety of search methods exist, as there are many


different types of scenes. This allows investigators to
select the most appropriate method(s) for their specific
scene. The choice of method may be dictated by the loca-
tion, size, or circumstances of the scene. Once the search
FIGURE 1.6 Arrowhead Forensics master crime scene method has been selected, conduct a cautious search of
sketching kit (http://www.crimescene.com/store/A-6340 all the visible areas, focusing on avoiding loss of evidence
CSK.Shtml). Variously themed templates are available or evidence contamination. After this search has been
for purchase individually to customize as needed. conducted and the evidence has been photographed and
10 Manual of Forensic Science: An International Survey

Packaging will be evidence dependent and CSI personnel


should determine what type is appropriate (e.g., paper
bags, envelopes, cans, jars, boxes). Each package of evi-
dence should be sealed at the closure in a way that access
into the package would be obvious. This can be done by
using tamper-evident evidence tape or other nonremov-
able tape marked with the date and initials of CSI per-
sonnel who collected the item.
The outer packaging (there should be at least two
layers to protect the integrity of the evidence in the event
that the outer packaging is damaged or otherwise com-
promised) should be marked with the following informa-
FIGURE 1.7 Search methods. tion: case identifiers, item descriptions, date and time of
collection, and who collected the evidence. This initiates
documented, a more vigorous search can be conducted of the evidence trail or chain of custody. This is the most
those areas that are concealed (e.g., moving furniture to commonly accepted method for authentication of evi-
look for cartridge cases). This general-to-specific approach dence. It documents the transfer of custody of evidence
ensures a thorough search of the scene. Figure 1.7 is a from one person to another starting with its collection at
graphic summarizing the methods described. the crime scene, through various analysts at the crime lab
conducting examinations of the evidence, and its possible
Link—Very common, based upon the linkage the- presentation in court. This ensures that what it presented
ory: once a piece of evidence leads to another (e.g., in court is the same item collected. Each transfer is docu-
a fingerprint on a murder weapon is identified to a mented with a signature, date, and time. A record of the
known individual, individual’s house and vehicle chain of custody protects against the possibility of evi-
searched and reveals bloody clothing, DNA test- dence being adulterated or tampered with. Therefore, a
ing of those clothes is consistent with victim), break in the chain of custody can result in evidence being
experiential, logical, and systematic. Works with inadmissible in court.
all scenes: small, large, indoor or outdoor. As noted previously, proper packaging is key to evi-
Line—Often used for large, outdoor scenes. A dence preservation and is specific to the type of evidence
coordinator is needed and searchers are often collected. The following are examples of the different
volunteer and need instruction. types of evidence that may be encountered at a crime
Grid—Similar to line; essentially two line searches scene and how they should be properly packaged.
that are 90 degrees from one another. This
method can be quite productive, but is more
time-consuming. 1.6.1 Fingerprinting
Zone—Best for defined zones, such as houses or
buildings with rooms. Often combined with Fingerprints fall in the category of pattern evidence, and
other methods; good for search warrants. Teams because no two people (to date) have been found to have
are assigned small zones for searching. identical fingerprints, including identical twins, it is evi-
Wheel or Ray—Used in special circumstances, lim- dence that can be used to identify (or exclude) individu-
ited applications: small, circular scenes. als. The two main features upon which the discipline of
Spiral—Best used on scenes without physical bar- fingerprint analysis are (1) uniqueness—as previously
riers (e.g., open water), limited applications, spi- mentioned, each individual’s fingerprints are unique;
rals may be inward or outward, must be able to and (2) persistence—fingerprints do not change over an
trace a regular pattern with fixed diameters. individual’s lifetime, provided there is no damage to the
dermal layer. This discipline is concerned with identify-
ing friction ridge characteristics, composed of ridges and
1.6 EVIDENCE COLLECTION furrows on the skin, and can be found on the fingers,
AND PACKAGING palms, and soles of the feet.
The three types of fingerprints generally found at
Evidence collection begins after the scene has been crime scenes and/or on pieces of evidence are as follows:
searched, evidence has been located and marked, pho-
tography has taken place, and sketches have been 1. Patent—A patent print is visible to the naked
drawn. Evidence should be collected in such a manner eye and does not require additional processing
as to protect it from breakage, contamination, and loss. in order to identify it as a fingerprint. It may even
Crime Scene Investigation 11

be suitable for comparison without additional The MagnaBrushTM was the first magnetic fingerprint
processing. These fingerprints can be made of “brush” available, and this is a variant on the standard
several kinds of substances such as dirt, blood, brush-and-powder approach. There is no actual brush in
grease, etc. a magnetic device. Rather, there is a magnet within the
2. Latent—Is not visible to the naked eye and device that creates a “brush” out of metal-based, mag-
requires additional processing or enhancement netic powder. Because there is no actual brush, and the
in order to visualize and possibly make a com- wand can remove excess powder from the substrate, this
parison. These are typically composed of sweat, is a less abrasive method; therefore, it has less chance of
lipids, and/or proteins secreted from the pores inadvertently damaging a print. See Table 1.1 for a sum-
on the skin. There are many contaminants from mary of methods.
the environment that may also be present within Tape lifting is another physical method of process-
the chemical composition of the fingerprint. ing fingerprints, where the print (either processed or pat-
3. Plastic—More correctly referred to as an ent) is physically removed from the surface by means of
“impression” because it is a recognizable fin- transparent lifting tape. The tape is then adhered to a
gerprint indentation in a soft substrate, such as backing that provides optimal contrast. There are a vari-
putty, tar, wax, soap, etc. These fingerprints are ety of products that provide both the lifting tape and the
three-dimensional and may not require addi- background on which to mount it (e.g., hinge-lifters).
tional processing in order to visualize. Figure 1.8 is an example of scaled hinge lifts available at
Arrowhead Forensics.
Occasionally, a latent print can be enhanced suffi-
ciently and photographed simply with oblique lighting or
use of an alternate light source. The processing of latent
prints will be largely dependent upon the surface on
which the print is located. This is accomplished by two
general categories, described below.

1.6.1.1 Physical
Physical processing does not involve utilizing chemicals
or chemical reactions to increase visibility. Dusting with
powder is a common and economical method. When a
print is gently dusted, with brushes composed of fine
fibers, fine particles of the dust adhere to the residue that
created the print, providing enhanced contrast and vis-
ibility. There are several powder colors available, with
different formulations (e.g., carbon, aluminum) in order
to create optimal contrast, since prints may be found on FIGURE 1.8 Arrowhead Forensics scaled hinge lifts
a wide variety of substrates (see Table 1.1). (http://www.crimescene.com/store/A-2801KC.shtml).

TABLE 1.1 Fingerprint Processing Method Examples


Method Composition Best Surfaces Application
Powder Carbon, aluminum, lycopodium based Nonporous, select porous Fiberglass, camel hair, or
feather brushes*
Magnetic Iron oxide (may be mixed with black carbon and Nonporous, porous Magnetic wand
silicon dioxide, aluminum, titanium dioxide,
lycopodium, etc.) for colored and dual contrast
formulations
Lifting Transparent adhesive tape and backing cards Nonporous, select porous Transparent adhesive tape,
manual pressure
Small Particle Various compositions and colors ex, molybdenum Wet or previously wet Fine mist spray
Reagent disulfide, zinc carbonate, crystal violet, etc. surfaces
* Due to the increased sensitivity of DNA testing, some agencies use disposable, one-use-only brushes to avoid cross contamination
of surfaces and of the powders (re-dipping into a powder jar). Additionally, powder can be dispensed in smaller amounts from its
original container to a separate “working” container, for use only on the scene at hand and any remaining powder in the “work-
ing” container discarded upon completion of the scene processing in order to avoid contamination of the stock powder.
12 Manual of Forensic Science: An International Survey

Small particle reagent (SPR) is also considered a These are just a very few of the methods available,
physical method, although it is liquid and sprayed onto and further research is recommended. The processing
the surface. It is essentially a liquid fingerprint powder method(s) chosen are most often based upon the sur-
for use on wet or previously wet items. SPR will adhere face to be developed, with the two biggest categories of
to the print residues and the excess SPR is removed with porous or nonporous. It is not uncommon to find tape,
a spray bottle of water. duct or otherwise, that has been used during the com-
mission of a crime. Dry ice, sub-zero freezers, or liquid
1.6.1.2 Chemical nitrogen may be used to separate layers of tape with-
There are a number of chemical reagents and processes out damaging latent prints that may be present on the
available for processing latent prints, so that it is not fea- adhesive side. Dye-type stains have often been used, and
sible to discuss every available option here. Some of the there is also a product called “sticky side powder” that
most commonly used at crime scenes (as opposed to in is now available, specifically for this situation. Various
the laboratory) will be addressed. methods and combination of methods have been utilized
Ninhydrin—reacts with the amino acids in the fin- to attempt to develop latent prints on human skin, with
gerprint residue and turns a purplish color. It may be greater or lesser levels of success. Because human skin
applied via spraying, dipping, or painting and is very conditions (alive, deceased, submerged in water, decom-
useful on porous substances. The reaction process may posing, etc.) and the conditions in which they are found
be somewhat slow and may be accelerated by heat and will vary significantly, there is no standardized method(s)
humidity. It can be used alone, or as part of a multistep for developing latent prints on human skin.
process. There are also derivatives, or analogues that The Chesapeake Bay Division of the International
assist with better visualization in conjunction with lasers Association for Identification (2013) website provides
and/or special illumination methods. an excellent reference list with clickable links that
Iodine fuming—Elemental iodine is a substance that detail composition of reagent/method, how to utilize
sublimes. In other words, it can pass from solid to gas the method, the most appropriate materials on which
form without turning into a liquid. It is applied via a the method should be used, along with the positive and
fuming gun, or in a cabinet that then becomes filled with potentially problematic issues associated with each. This
iodine fumes. This is a good method for items that may reference can be accessed here: http://www.cbdiai.org/
be valuable, as without also using a “fixing” component, Reagents/main.html.
the iodine enhanced print does not last indefinitely. Photography should always be performed prior to
Cyanoacrylate—Also known as “super glue fum- any processing or lifting. After an establishing photo-
ing.” This method is also somewhat slow and requires graph, to show context, a macro lens or setting should
a cabinet or chamber (portable chambers are available, be used, the print should fill the frame, and the camera
or can be created easily, but care should be taken to should be perpendicular to the surface being photo-
ensure scientific protocols and controls are utilized) in graphed. Locations such as light switches, door handles,
which the fuming can occur. Heating can accelerate the and so on, that may need to be used by crime scene per-
process. The cyanoacrylate is heated to induce fuming, sonnel should be processed and preserved immediately.
and a moisture source is needed to create optimal relative Items that can be removed should be packaged so as to
humidity. Alternatively, a vacuum method is also avail- prevent any alteration of potential fingerprint evidence
able. A “test” latent print of the individual performing and submitted to the crime laboratory for processing.
the enhancement can be added to the chamber in a loca- Documentation should include the name or initials
tion that is viewable from the outside of the chamber in of the individual collecting the evidence, date/time/loca-
order to monitor the progress of development. If a print tion of collection, and the case number. If small items, or
is not fumed enough, it can be subjected to another fum- pieces removed from larger items, are submitted, infor-
ing session. However, overfuming a print may render it mation regarding the component’s orientation should be
unusable. A cyanoacrylate processed print will be a whit- submitted (up, down, front, back, compass points, etc.).
ish color. At this point, the print may be enhanced suf-
ficiently to allow comparison, but is often followed by
dusting or another processing, like dye staining. This 1.6.2 Trace Evidence Collection
method is useful on a variety of surfaces.
Amido Black—Used to enhance bloody prints. Arson evidence—Generally comes in two different forms:
Therefore, these prints are not strictly latent, as there is fire debris and liquid samples. Fire debris containing
usually some visualization of at least a partial pattern in possible ignitable liquids should be sealed in new metal
order to prompt the use of the amido black. Although friction lid containers (paint cans) to prevent the loss of
not specific for blood, this reagent also reacts with the vapors to the outside environment. Note that the inte-
proteins found in blood and turns a dark blue/black. rior of the can should be Teflon coated (to guard against
Crime Scene Investigation 13

corrosion). Liquid samples (flammable or otherwise) is extremely important if a direction-of-force determina-


should be collected in glass jars or vials (never plastic) tion will be required. All glass fragments present should
and sealed with Teflon-coated caps. As an added precau- be collected, as even very small pieces may be able to be
tion, the jar or vial should be placed into an appropri- used in fracture match comparisons (and other testing).
ately sized paint can containing padding material. This Glass evidence should not be packaged in glass con-
ensures that in the event of breakage or leakage, the liq- tainers. Container selection will be at the investigator’s
uid remains contained and avoids possible contamina- discretion, depending on the nature and size of fragments
tion of other evidence. in addition to the examinations that will be required. Paper
The evidence submitted for explosives analysis con- bindles, coin envelopes, small plastic vials, and puncture-
sists of pre-blast or post-blast materials. Pre-blast sam- proof plastic containers are examples that may be used.
ples are often small in quantity, and post-blast samples Fragments should be packaged, sealed, and labeled sepa-
typically consist of the remnants of an exploded device. rately. Textiles and tools (such as clothing, shoes, bats,
Often, explosive residue may exist on the post-blast mate- rocks, etc.) that may contain microscopic glass fragments
rials. The amount of sample that is available will dictate should be handled minimally (wet or bloodstained items
the method of collection. Glassine bindles and 1 dram should be allowed to air-dry first) and then wrapped com-
vials are ideal for collecting small amounts of powder. pletely in paper, sealed, and labeled. More than one layer
Larger samples, usually involving post-blast materials, of packaging may be prudent. If size prevents collection of
can be packaged in metal friction lid containers (paint all the glass, samples should be collected near the point(s)
cans). of impact and from distant corners, then packaged, sealed
Glass—There are several different types of glass: and labeled separately. The investigator should also be
soda-lime glass is the type most commonly found in cognizant of other potential evidence that may be pres-
windows and bottles. PyrexTM is borosilicate glass and ent, such as blood, hair, or fibers that may be present on
is more resistant to shock, and heat changes and resists the glass, and prioritize collection and processing of the
alteration by nearly every chemical except hydroflu- various types of evidence.
oric acid. Tempered glass is also sometimes referred to Hair and fibers—Can be valuable in many differ-
as “safety glass.” Tempered glass is stronger than typi- ent types of cases, including, but not limited to, rape,
cal window glass and, when broken, “dices” into small assault, burglary, hit-and-run, and homicide. Hair and
pieces without sharp edges as opposed to breaking into fiber evidence can be useful in linking suspects with vic-
shards with sharp pieces and edges. This glass is com- tims, places, and/or items.
monly used in vehicle side and rear windows but may When hairs or fibers are visible and firmly attached
also be found in large commercial windows, doors, and to an object:
even shower doors and some home windows, depend-
ing on their location. Laminated glass is what is usually • They should be left intact and in place.
found in vehicle windshields and is usually composed of • Diagram and note the number of hair/fibers and
two layers of tempered glass, with a high-strength sheet exact location of each fiber on each item, in addi-
of plastic sandwiched in between the layers. This sand- tion to photography.
wich construction increases the strength of the glass, and • After documentation is complete, label and pack-
the plastic can hold on to broken pieces upon breaking, age separately and securely to prevent the hair/
among other capabilities. What is referred to as “bul- fibers from becoming dislodged during trans-
letproof glass” is usually composed of multiple layers of portation, but such that they will be contained
laminated glass. within the packaging in the event that they do
Glass evidence may be found in a variety of incidents become separated from the item.
such as burglaries, hit and run accidents, and homicides. • Packaging selection should be appropriate for the
Glass evidence may be evaluated for fracture match type of item to which the hair/fibers are adhered.
comparison (fitting pieces together, as in a jigsaw puzzle), • Labeling should be referenced in notes.
to determine the sequence of events (such as gunshots, as
a fracture pattern can assist with determining the order If hair/fibers are visible but loosely attached, or if
of shots) or the direction of force or, by their optical and firmly attached to an item that cannot be sent to the labo-
chemical properties, comparing fragments found at the ratory (e.g., due to size):
scene to fragments found on victims or suspects.
Glass evidence should be meticulously documented, • Diagram and note the number of hair/fibers and
both photographically, in notes, and sketches. Orientation exact location of each fiber on each item, in addi-
documentation (ex. inside/outside surfaces), in addition to tion to photography.
documenting whether the fragments were collected from • Carefully remove hair/fibers with clean tweezers.
the inside or outside and should be packaged separately, It would be appropriate to utilize more than one
14 Manual of Forensic Science: An International Survey

set of tweezers such that one can be wiped with • Fold and wrap (dry) articles separately in new
disinfectant and allowed to dry while other hair/ paper bags or butcher/craft-type paper wrap-
fibers are being collected. The exact procedure will ping. At least two labeled layers are advisable.
involve judgment based on number and types of
fibers being collected, but should always be done To collect hairs/fibers that may be present in the hair
in a manner that eliminates or reduces potential of victims or suspects, hair should be combed with a new,
cross-contamination as much as possible, and in fine-toothed comb over a new piece of clean (preferably
accordance with departmental procedures. white) paper. Using care, fold the paper, together with
• Hair/fibers can be packaged in a variety of con- the comb, into a bindle, to avoid loss of trace evidence.
tainers including but not limited to paper bin- The secure bindle can then be placed into a labeled outer
dles, coin envelopes, and plastic or glass vials wrapping or bag.
(that seal tightly). Care should be taken to ensure Control samples—Should be submitted, as these are
that the hair/fibers do not come into adhesive comparative analyses. For example, if fibers are found on
during collection or packaging. the socks or shoes of a victim who alleges being raped in
• Label (case, description, location/source, item a car, samples of the car’s floor mats should be obtained.
number, date/time, and name of collector) and Hair control samples—Head, pubic, and animal hair
reference in notes. control samples may need to be collected, and should
• Other circumstances may exist where an alternate include the roots. This means that the hairs have to be
method can/should be employed. For instance, pulled out:
if the investigator arrives at a site where a body
has been dumped, actions like moving the body Head: Approximately 50 representative pulled
or removing clothing to be sent to the lab can head hairs should be obtained optimally includ-
cause the loss of hair and fiber evidence. Further, ing hairs from both temple areas, crown, and
perhaps it is a night scene and with limited light- the base of the neck. If there are multiple col-
ing available. The best solution is to tape lift the ors/lengths, samples from each color and length
body (or clothing on the body) in situ. If the situ- should be obtained, and each area, color, and
ation does not permit the immediate tape lifting length should be packaged and labeled sepa-
to occur, then the body is placed in the body bag rately. Documentation should include the indi-
clothed and the body is tape-lifted back at the vidual’s age and overall hair color in addition to
coroner’s office prior to autopsy and the body any signs of hair treatment.
bag is collected for trace evidence examination. Pubic: Approximately 30 representative pulled pubic
Tape lifts are labeled according to area (i.e., front hairs should be obtained from different parts of
of shirt, back of shirt, etc.). Tape lifts may also the pubic area, packaged, and labeled separately
be appropriate when there is a large number of to include the individual’s name, case number,
hairs/fibers, or item is covered in hairs/fibers. and area from which the hairs were collected,
along with the CSI’s name/initials and date/time.
If the victim or suspect clothing may has hair/fiber Note: If the individual is not deceased, he/she can
evidence: be asked to pull both head and pubic hairs them-
selves in the presence of the investigator.
• Each item should be diligently kept separate. Animal: Both combed and pulled should be col-
Victim and suspect clothing should be examined lected, packaged, and labeled separately. Pulled
in different rooms or areas. hairs should be collected from the head, back,
• Identification marks should be placed on the tail, and belly areas and include both the coarse
garment in an easily accessible place that does outer hair and the finer fur hair as well as sam-
not damage or obscure potential evidence on ples from all major color areas (if multicolored
the item. Garment labels are a good location for or striped). Each area should be packaged and
these marks. labeled separately to include CSI name/initials,
• Examine for and avoid disturbing other types date/time, case and item numbers, body area from
of evidence that may be present on the clothing, where the sample was obtained, species (cat, dog,
such as blood or other biological fluids, soil/dirt, rodent, etc.), and other available ID information
dust or other material adhering to the item. If for the animal that will distinguish it from other
other types of evidence are present on the item, animals that may be involved in the case.
prioritize what should be enhanced/collected/
sampled prior to packaging using established Investigators should always exercise extreme dili-
protocols. gence and caution when handling suspect and victim
Crime Scene Investigation 15

items to prevent cross-contamination, as it may not be to prevent loss. Consideration should be given to
known until sometime later in the investigation if hairs other types of evidence that may be present (e.g.,
or fibers are contained within submitted evidence. fingerprints, DNA) and processing prioritized
Paint—Paint-chip evidence may be present and useful accordingly. Samples from all areas that the tool
in cases such as hit-and-run incidents, motor vehicle acci- is suspected to have been in contact with should
dents, burglaries, or other incidents involving forced entry be obtained and should again be full thickness.
or the forcing open of safes, cash registers, and so on. The tool may also have transferred material onto
the areas it was utilized; therefore, tool marks
Automobile: Samples should be obtained from should be carefully examined for this type of evi-
any areas exhibiting fresh damage on pertinent dence. Never attempt to “fit” the tool into marks
vehicles, collecting all layers down to the metal or impressions at the scene, as this can result in
substrate. Although the outer color of the vehicle additional transfer of materials, rendering subse-
may appear to be the same, there may be dif- quent analysis useless in terms of significance of
ferent types or compositions in different areas presence/absence of a particular substance.
on the same vehicle. This is especially true if the
vehicle is repainted. Optimally, if full-thickness If the entire item can be submitted to the lab, this
chips can be recovered by slightly bending the will ensure that all layers are present, and is especially
metal and flaking off the sample chips, this is useful if the specimen is small or difficult to remove.
preferable. If not, a clean knife blade can be uti- Paper bindles, small glass or plastic vials with secure
lized to scrape off a full thickness sample. The lids are good choices for packaging this type of evidence.
blade should be thoroughly wiped off, or a new Envelopes (bindles may be placed in envelopes) are not
blade used between different areas of the vehicle optimal unless the specimen is of a larger size; however,
to prevent cross-contamination. Samples from personnel must ensure that all edges are sealed. Likewise,
different areas should be packaged and labeled plastic bags are not the best choice for this type of evi-
separately. dence, as it can be difficult to remove small chips.
If cross-transfer is suspected (for example, a hit-and- Labeling should include CSI name/initials, date/
run involving more than one vehicle), control time, case numbers, and source information.
samples should be taken from areas immediately Insects—Entomological evidence can be useful for
adjacent to each area of transfer collected. This will several aspects of an investigation, such as postmortem
assist in distinguishing the paint that was originally interval (PMI), especially in deaths that occurred long
on the vehicle from paint that was transferred. enough prior where rigor mortis, algor mortis, and livor
Clothing: Paint transfers on clothing may be very mortis are not very useful in assisting with PMI, if a body
small or even microscopic. If the clothing is wet, has been moved/disturbed after death, presence and/or
it should be dried (air-dried or drying cabinet) position of wound sites, drugs/poisons (entomotoxicol-
before packaging. Avoiding excessive handling, ogy), length of neglect or abuse in living victims and in
carefully fold or roll in paper or place into a new, wildlife crimes.
clean paper bag. Again, a second outer wrap is Of the major insect groups associated with cadavers,
advised to prevent loss or contamination if the blowflies, flesh flies, and house flies are among the insects
packaging should get damaged or otherwise com- that arrive in the early stages of decomposition. Carrion
promised. Loose chips may be collected, packaged beetles are early to mid-range arrivals, and cheese skip-
in paper bindles, and submitted with the clothing pers and dermestids arrive later in the process. The life
in order to prevent damage/breakage of the chip. cycle of the fly is the most reliable to assist in determining
Prior to collection, documentation (sketch, notes, an approximate time of death.
photography) should be done in order to identify Collect both live and fixed specimens—Several of
the location of the chip on the clothing. the largest larvae should be collected in various areas of
Loose chips: May be located on clothing (as above) the body, in addition to the “wandering” larvae that are
or on the ground near impact points and should moving away from the body (can be a radius of several
be collected and packaged in paper bindles. feet) to locate an appropriate place to generate pupal cas-
Documentation should include the location from ings. Use anatomical drawings in your notes to document
where the chips were collected. where specimens were collected.
Forced entry/burglary: Tools used to gain entry may Approximately half the larvae should be kept alive
contain paint evidence, in addition to other mate- by placing them into a cardboard container with air holes
rials like drywall, plaster, safe insulation, etc. The and a small amount of wet cat food or other raw meat.
ends of the tools suspected to have been utilized Live larvae can be raised/hatched to determine the length
should be wrapped in a paper bag, sealed with tape of the life cycle and speciation determined.
16 Manual of Forensic Science: An International Survey

The other half should be fixed by first immersing in With the potential for touch (low copy number) DNA
water brought to boiling and then heat turned off for 1 to be present on a body for collection, it is important for
to 5 minutes immediately after collection (hours should CSI personnel to understand where touch DNA might
not elapse from collection to fixing). Then the larvae are be present for various situations. Collecting knuckle,
removed from the hot water and preserved in 70%—80% hand, and facial swabs from a decedent who may have
alcohol (ethanol is preferential, but can be difficult to been in a physical altercation with the suspect prior to
obtain, 50% isopropyl alcohol can also be utilized). This his death can yield touch DNA. Other potential avenues
provides a “snapshot” in the larval growth cycle at the can include swabbing the neck of a victim who has been
time of collection. manually strangled or swabbing the clothing of a victim
Adult flies can also be collected; however, without who has been moved or dragged. Each case and situation
proper equipment (nylon nets), this may be difficult for is unique. Understanding touch DNA and how it may
a typical crime scene unit. Adult blowflies can be kept relate to certain situations is a valuable tool when deter-
alive in a vial with the lid screwed on—no air is required. mining where evidence can be found.
Consultation with an entomologist may be the best
course of action for this, and advice regarding collection
and fixation of other insects that may be present, as the 1.6.4 Firearms and Related Collection
types of insects found will be unique to the geographical
area. Likewise, if a qualified entomologist can attend the Firearms should be unloaded and packaged in an
scene, he/she will be able to rapidly discern the most use- appropriate-sized cardboard box (special crime scene col-
ful specimens. lection boxes designed to package various-sized firearms
are available for purchase, and examples of Arrowhead
Forensics tie-down boxes are shown in Figure 1.9) and
1.6.3 DNA and Blood Evidence Collection secured in a way to ensure safety and prevent the loss
of fingerprints, trace evidence, and DNA evidence. Cable
DNA can be found in all cells of the body that contain ties can be used to secure the firearm to the interior of
a nucleus. This includes the cells in blood, saliva (from the box. In the event that a firearm cannot be unloaded
buccal cells and white blood cells carried within saliva, (due to damage), precautions must be taken to ensure the
as saliva is 99.5% water), hair, semen, vaginal secre- safety of all personnel involved in the collection, trans-
tions, skin, and sweat. The majority of DNA evidence port and examination of this piece of evidence. Magazines
is collected using sterile cotton-tipped swabs, often with
“ultra-pure” water (distilled/sterile), if the evidence has
dried on the collection surface. The swabs are then air-
dried and stored frozen prior to analysis.
Fingernail and knuckle swabs are generally collected
when the decedent appears to have been involved in a
struggle or altercation. Sexual assault swabs are collected
from six locations for women and four locations for men.
Peri-anal, anal, oral, and exterior penile swabs are col-
lected from men. Peri-anal, anal, peri-vaginal, vaginal,
oral, and breast swabs are collected from women. Buccal
swabs are generally collected from suspects to analyze as
a DNA standard.
Current DNA technology has become much more
sophisticated than the methods originally established
in this field. Sensitivity levels in the detection of DNA
have increased to the point the “touch DNA” is being
collected and analyzed as evidence. These are situations
where DNA has been successfully recovered from objects
or victims that have had skin contact with the suspect.
Other situations where DNA has been identified from
individuals that have simply spoken while positioned
over the evidence has led to increased precautions involv-
ing contamination. Individuals in close proximity to FIGURE 1.9 Arrowhead Forensics tie-down weapon
objects or victims with potential touch DNA are advised storage boxes (http://www.crime-scene.com/store/a-
to wear masks. 1070-weapons-storge-box.shtml).
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
much alike; and the boy who has not energy enough to set his face
resolutely against the early discouragements of any particular
calling, will, in all probability, be successful in no other. It is, however,
so great an advantage to have a young person’s own feelings, and
his point of honour heartily engaged in the cause in which he has
embarked, that, if circumstances render such a thing at all expedient,
or not quite unreasonable, the choice of a profession may often be
conceded with advantage. But such free choice ought to be
afterwards burdened, with a positive interdict against change. In the
case of a sea life, this appears to be quite indispensable; for the
contrast is so striking, in most cases, between the comforts of home
and the discomforts of a ship—to say nothing of rough fare, hard
work, sea-sickness, and strict discipline—that, if an opening be
constantly presented for escape, few youngsters will have resolution
enough to bear up against those trials to which they must be
exposed, and which they ought to hold themselves prepared to meet
with cheerfulness.
Perhaps the naval profession owes a good deal of its peculiar
character to these very disadvantages, as they are called; and
though we may often regret to see young men, of good abilities,
dropping out of the navy, who, if they had only cast on the right tack,
might have done the service and themselves much honour—yet
there is no denying that their more vigorous-minded and sterner-
framed companions, whom they leave afloat, are, upon the whole,
better fitted to make useful public servants.
In many other professions, it is possible to calculate, beforehand,
with more or less precision, the degree and kind of work which a
young man is likely to be called upon to perform; but there is peculiar
difficulty in coming to any just conclusion upon these points, even in
a vague way, in the life of a sailor. His range of duties includes the
whole world,—he may be lost in the wilderness of a three-decker, or
be wedged into a cock-boat;—he may be fried in Jamaica, or frozen
in Spitzbergen;—he may be cruising, or be in action during six days
of the week, in the midst of a fleet, and flounder in solitude on the
seventh; or he may waste his years in peaceful idleness, the most
fatal to subordination, or be employed on the home station, and hear
from his friends every day, or he may be fifteen months, as I have
been, at a time, without getting a letter or seeing a newspaper. He
may have an easy-going commander, which is a very great evil; or
his captain may be one of those tight hands, who, to use the slang of
the cock-pit, keeps every one on board ‘under the fear of the Lord
and a broomstick.’ In short, a man may go to sea for twenty years,
and find no two men, and hardly two days alike. All this, which is
delightful to some minds, and productive in them of every kind of
resource, is utterly distracting, and very often ruinous, to others.
Weak frames generally sink under its severity; and weak minds
become confused with its complication, and the intensity of its action.
But, on the other hand, the variety of its objects is so boundless, that
if a young man have only strength of body, to endure the wear and
tear of watching and other inevitable fatigues; and have also strength
of character enough to persevere, in the certainty of openings
occurring, sooner or later, by which his talents or his industry may
find profitable employment,—there can be little doubt that the
profession of a sailor might be made suitable to most of those who,
on entering it, are positively cut off from retreat.
Supposing that this ticklish question, of the choice of a profession,
has been conceded to a boy, there remains the still more perplexing
problem—what is the fittest method of training him beforehand, so
that he may enter his new life with best effect? The difficulty arises, I
suspect, from two causes, one of which applies to education
generally, the other to the particular case of a lad intended for the
navy. Most people seem to think, and very naturally, that the object
of a school is to teach knowledge which shall afterwards be
practically available in the business of life; and they cannot well
understand what is the use of teaching Latin and Greek, which
appear to be so little applicable to real work. Much of this difficulty
vanishes, however, if it be considered that the chief purpose of
education is to discipline the mind, and to train up the character, so
that it may be found equal to any task, no matter how unlooked-for it
may be. In such a view, the Classics are as good, and probably
better than any other.
If the principles, the faculties, and the feelings of a boy be duly
cultivated at school, he may be expected to enter the world in as fit a
state to profit by the opportunities in his path, as his nature will allow
of; nor does it, perhaps, much matter by what artificial machinery this
degree of perfection in mental culture has been attained. All that
seems essentially of importance is, that the endowments given him
by nature, should have been so well exercised, that when brought to
bear on the real, manly business of life, they may act with effect. If
the process of education has been well managed, its utility will
probably not be the least sensibly felt, in cases where the pursuits to
be followed in earnest are dissimilar to those, by means of which the
boy’s faculties were originally developed at school.
In the instance of young men intended for the navy, I think this rule
applies with particular force. The early age of thirteen, at which they
must of necessity go on board ship, renders it almost impossible that
they can have acquired any great stock of what is usually called
knowledge. But, by proper management, they may, previous to that
age, have secured a very large stock of that particular description of
information which will be of most use to them in the outset of life; and
their growing minds may have been fitted, by a good system of
school discipline, to submit with cheerfulness, as well as advantage,
to that singular mixture of constraint and freedom, which forms the
most striking feature of a sea life. If this be true, it is perhaps of no
great consequence whether the ground-work of such an education
be the ancient classics, the mathematics, or modern languages: for
the real object to be arrived at, viz. mental training, may, by proper
management, be equally well attained by any of these methods.
No two boys, perhaps, out of a dozen, intended for the sea, may
require the same training; but still there is no reason why the whole
number should not be equally well fitted, by previous education, to
advance themselves in the service, according to their respective
talents, though some of them, at starting, may be altogether ignorant
of those subjects, generally supposed to be of the most
indispensable utility at sea.
Antecedent, therefore, to the age of thirteen, after which a boy
ought never to commence his naval career, it appears to matter
extremely little what he learns, provided his mind be kept fully
occupied. It will be better, no doubt, if a boy’s taste happen to lie in
that direction, that his occupations at school have as direct a
reference as possible to his future pursuits. If, for instance, he have
a turn for mathematics, or for modern languages, he ought certainly
to be indulged in his fancy. But the essential objects to be attended
to, at this stage of his education, lie a great deal further from the
surface, and consequently make much less show. The formation of
character, upon the solid basis of religion, and a due cultivation of
manners, especially of those branches which relate to temper and
self-denial, are quite within the range of education antecedent to the
age of thirteen. If, then, a boy be only well grounded in his principles,
and if he be taught to think and feel and act like a gentleman, before
he is turned adrift on the wide ocean, and he have also acquired
habits of industry and obedience, together with the ordinary
elements of knowledge—reading, writing, and so on—it matters little,
as I conceive, whether he has acquired much information besides—
for all else that is wanting will follow in good time.
The consideration of what system of instruction should be pursued
afterwards, at the naval college, or on board ship, is a totally different
affair, and deserves to be treated by itself.
CHAPTER II.
FIRST GOING AFLOAT.

I know not what other persons may have felt on these occasions; but
I must own, that, in spite of all my enthusiasm, when the actual time
came for fairly leaving friends and home, and plunging quite alone
and irrevocably into a new life, I felt a degree of anxiety, and distrust
of myself, which, as these feelings were quite strange, I scarcely
knew how to manage. I had been allowed to choose my own
profession, it is true, and was always eager to be off; yet I almost
wished, when the actual moment arrived, that I had not been taken
at my word. For the first time in my life, I knew what was meant by
the word responsibility, and all the shame of failure stared me in the
face. When at school, nine-tenths of my thoughts had always
rambled abroad, to those unknown regions, upon which my
imagination loved to feast, day and night. Still, I can well remember,
my heart sunk within me, and I felt pretty much as if I were on the
verge of death, when the carriage that was to convey me away,
drove up to the door. I still believed that there was, even on this
earth, a new and a much better world before me; but when I tasked
my judgment, to say upon what grounds this belief rested, the
answer was so meagre, that I began to dread I had done a mighty
foolish thing in setting out to seek for it.
“What a scrape I shall be in,” I said to myself, “if the gloomy
representations of these sad fellows the poets be true pictures of life!
What if this existence of ours be but a scene of gradually-increasing
misery! How shall I be able to get on at all, if a sea life be not more
enjoyable than that of the High School of Edinburgh? and what kind
of figure shall I cut, when driven back, by sheer distress, to petition
my father to take me home again, to eat the bitter bread of idleness,
or to seek for some other profession, wherein all the rubs and tugs
may prove just as bad as those of the sea, and possibly not very
much better than those of school?”
I took good care, however, to let none of these unworthy doubts
and alarms find any expression in word or in look; and, with a heart
almost bursting, I took leave of the holyday scenes of the country I
had loved so well, and which, to my young fancy, appeared the most
beautiful spot on earth,—a judgment which, as I before observed, a
tolerably extensive acquaintance with the rest of the world has only
tended to confirm. Of course, I had a regular interview and leave-
taking with my capital friends the fishermen, whom I had long held to
be the best-informed persons of my acquaintance, merely because
they knew most about ropes and ship matters generally. I cannot say
that these worthy mariners stood the test of after-communication,
quite so well as the romantic coast-scenery near which they resided.
I remember, on returning from my first voyage, going down to the
beach, in my uniform jacket, and in no very modest spirit, to shew off
my superior nautical attainments to these poor fellows, who had
been sticking fast to their rocks during the interval, much after the
fashion of their own shell-fish. Their reception, of course, was highly
flattering; but their confined views of the profession, and scanty
knowledge of many of its details, made me look back with wonder to
the time when I had hailed them as first-rate masters in the noble art
of seamanship.
On the 16th of May, 1802, I left home; and next day my father said
to me, “Now you are fairly afloat in the world, you must begin to write
a journal;” and, suiting the action to the word, he put a blank book
into one hand, and a pen into the other, with a hint for me to proceed
at once to business. The following is a fair specimen of the result,
which I certainly little imagined was ever destined to attain the
honour of being printed:—
“May 17.—Journey to London.—Left Dunglass. Breakfasted at the
Press Inn, and changed horses. Got to Belford; changed horses.
Alnwick—dined there, and got to Morpeth, where we slept. Up early;
breakfasted at Newcastle. Stopped at Durham. Walked forward till
the chaise should overtake us; got into the chaise. Stopped to give
the horses some drink. Saw two deep draw-wells. Observed some
coal-carts at Newcastle coal-pits. The wheels are so constructed,
that they run down-hill upon things in the road, which are made for
the purpose. The horse follows the cart, to draw it up the hill, after it
has emptied the load.”
The rest of the journal is pretty much in the same style—a record
of insignificant facts which lead to nothing, useless as
memorandums at the time, and of course not more useful at the
distance of eight-and-twenty years. I would give a good deal, at this
moment, to possess, instead of these trashy notices, some traces,
no matter how faint, of what was actually passing in my mind upon
the occasion of this journey. The resolutions we make at such a
period, together with the doubts and fears which distract us, may
have a certain amount of value, if then jotted down in good faith; but
if these fleeting thoughts be once allowed to pass without record,
they necessarily lose most of their force. There is always, indeed,
something interesting, and often much that is useful, in tracing the
connexion between sentiment and action, especially in the
elementary stages of life, when the foundations of character are laid.
But the capacity of drawing such inferences belongs to a very
different period of life; and hence it arises, that early journals are
generally so flat and profitless, unless they be written in a spirit
which few people think of till too late.
I shall have so many better opportunities than the present of
speaking on the copious subject of journal-writing, that I shall merely
remark, in passing, for the consideration of my young readers, that
what most people wish to find recorded there, is not so much a dry
statement of facts, however important these may be, as some
account of the writer’s opinions and his feelings upon the occasion.
These, it may be observed, are like the lights and shades and
colours of a painting, which, while they contribute fully as much to
the accuracy of a representation as the correctness of the mere
outline, impress the mind of the spectator with a still more vivid
image of the object intended to be described.
I ought to have mentioned before, that the object of this journey
was to ship me off to sea; and it was arranged that I should join the
flag-ship of Sir Andrew Mitchell, then fitting in the River for the
Halifax station. We, of course, set out for London, as the grand focus
from which every thing in the English world radiates. But I find
nothing in the memorandums of that period worthy of being
extracted, nor do I recollect any incident which excited me strongly,
except the operation of rigging myself out for the first time in
midshipman’s uniform. There was something uncommonly pleasing,
I remember, in the glitter of the dirk and its apparatus; and also in the
smart air, as well as new cut of the dress; but the chief satisfaction
arose from the direct evidence this change of garb afforded that
there was no joke in the matter, but that the real business of life was
actually about to begin. Accordingly, in a tolerable flutter of spirits, I
made my first appearance on the deck of one of his Majesty’s ships.
The meagre journal of that day is as follows:—
“Went to Deptford after breakfast in a hackney-coach—when we
got there, we got out of the coach, walked down the street, and met
the captain of the Leander. Went with him to the clerk of the
cheque’s office, and had my name put in some book or other. Went
with him to his lodgings, where he gave us a list of some things I was
to get. Got a boat and went on board the Leander for the first time.
Came home on a stage-coach—got a boat at London bridge—went
up in it to the Adelphi—got out and went to the hotel.”
In most other professions, the transition from the old to the new
mode of life is more or less gradual; but in that of the sea, it is so
totally abrupt, and without intervening preparation, that a boy must
be either very much of a philosopher, or very much of a goose, not to
feel, at first, well nigh overwhelmed with the change of
circumstances. The luxuries and the kindnesses of home are
suddenly exchanged for the coarse fare of a ship, and the rough
intercourse of total strangers. The solicitude with which he has been
watched heretofore, let the domestic discipline have been ever so
strict, is tenderness itself, compared to the utter indifference,
approaching to dislike, with which a youngster, or ‘squeaker,’ as he is
well called, is received on board. Even if he possess any
acquaintances amongst his own class, they have few consolations in
their power; and, generally speaking, are rather disposed to laugh at
the home-sick melancholy of a new comer, than to cheer him up,
when his little heart is almost breaking.
It so happened that I knew no one on board the ship, excepting
two middies similarly circumstanced with myself. I was introduced
also to a very gruff, elderly, service-soured master’s mate, to whose
care, against his own wishes, I had been consigned by a mutual
friend, a captain with whom he had formerly served. Our own
excellent commanding officer had a thousand other things to look
after, far more pressing than the griefs and cares of a dozen of boys
under his charge.
I felt bewildered and subdued, by the utter solitude of my situation,
as my father shook me by the hand, and quitted the ship. I well
recollect the feeling of despair when I looked round me, and was
made conscious of my utter insignificance. “Shall I ever be able,”
thought I, “to fill any respectable part in this vast scene? What am I
to do? How shall I begin? Whom can I consult?” I could furnish no
satisfactory answer to these queries; and though I had not the least
idea of shrinking from what I had undertaken, yet, I confess, I was
not far from repenting that I had been so decided about the matter.
There is a vehement delight, no doubt, in novelty—but we may
have too much of it at once; and certainly, if my advice were asked
as to this point, in the case of another, I should recommend that a
boy be gradually introduced to his future home; and, if possible,
placed under the auspices of some one older than himself, and who,
from having a real interest in him, might soften the needless rigours
of this formidable change. I had no such preparation; and was
without one friend or even acquaintance on board, who cared a
straw for me. I was also very little for my age, spoke broad Scotch,
and was, withal, rather testy in my disposition. The cock-pit, it is true,
is a pretty good place to work the bad humours out of a crotchety
young fellow, and to bring him to his due bearings; but I think I have
seen a good many tenderer plants than I was, crushed down under
the severity of this merciless discipline. Perhaps it is all for the best;
because youngsters who cannot, or will not stand this rough rubbing,
are just as well out of the way, both for themselves and the public.
There is one practice, however, which, as I invariably followed it
myself, I know to be in every boy’s power, and I venture strongly to
recommend it to others in the same situation; nor is it very likely that
many will be exposed to greater trials, in a small way, than I was at
first. The maxim is, always, in writing home, to put the best face
upon matters, and never, if possible, to betray any inevitable
unhappiness. Such a practice is doubly useful—for it contributes
essentially to produce that character of cheerfulness in reality, which
is partly assumed at the moment of writing, in order to save our
friends from distress on our account. It would be wrong, indeed, to
say, in writing home, that we are very happy, when in truth we are
very much the reverse; but, without stating any falsehood, or giving
into any subterfuge—which is still worse—those particular things
may very fairly be dwelt upon which are agreeable, almost to the
exclusion of those which are otherwise. We should learn, in short, to
see and to describe the cheerful things; and, both in our practice and
in description, leave the unpleasant ones to take care of themselves.
For example, I remember, as well as if the incidents had occurred
yesterday, most of the details which are stated in the following letter,
written only the day after I was left to my fate—amongst strangers—
in the unknown world of a man-of-war. I certainly was far from happy,
and might easily have made my friends wretched by selecting chiefly
what was disagreeable. I took a different course.

“H. M. Ship Leander, June 12, 1802,


Cock Pit.
“DEAR FATHER,
“After you left us, I went down into the mess-room; it is a
place about twenty feet long, with a table in the middle of
it, and wooden seats upon which we sit. When I came
down there were a great many cups and saucers upon the
table. A man came in, and poured hot water into the tea-
pot. There are about fourteen of us mess at the same
time. We were very merry in this dark hole, where we had
only two candles.
“We come down here, and sit when we like; and at other
times go upon deck. At about ten o’clock we had supper
upon bread and cheese, and a kind of pudding which we
liked very much. Some time after this I went to a
hammock, which was not my own, as mine was not ready,
there not being enough of clues at it, but I will have it to-
night. I got in at last. It was very queer to find myself
swinging about in this uncouth manner, for there was only
about a foot of space between my face and the roof—so,
of course, I broke my head a great many times on the
different posts in the cock-pit, where all the midshipmen
sleep. After having got in, you may be sure I did not sleep
very well, when all the people were making such a noise,
going to bed in the dark, and the ship in such confusion. I
fell asleep at last, but was always disturbed by the
quarter-master coming down to awake the midshipmen
who were to be on guard during the night. He comes up to
their bed-sides and calls them; so I, not being accustomed
to it, was always awaked, too. I had some sleep, however,
but, early in the morning, was again roused up by the men
beginning to work.
“There is a large hole which comes down from the
decks, all the way through to the hold, where they let
down the casks. The foot of the hammock that I slept in
was just at the hole, so I saw the casks all coming down
close by me. I got up at half-past seven, and went into the
birth (our mess-room), and we were all waiting for
breakfast till eight, when the man who serves and brings
in the dishes for the mess came down in a terrible
passion, saying, that as he was boiling the kettle at the
stove, the master-at-arms had thrown water upon the fire
and put it out. All this was because the powder was
coming on board. So we had to want our breakfast for
once. But we had a piece of bread and butter; and as we
were eating it, the master-at-arms came down, and said
that our candles were to be taken away: so we had to eat
our dry meal in the dark.
“I then went upon deck, and walked about, looking at
the Indiamen coming up the river, till eleven, when I and
one of my companions went and asked the lieutenant if he
would let us go on shore in the jolly-boat, as it was going
at any rate. We intended to take a walk in some of the
fields. We got leave, and some more of the midshipmen
went with us. There are about six men row the boat, and
we sit any where we like. Got on shore, and ran about the
park you were mentioning when in the boat. Then came
back to an inn, where we had some rolls and butter and
coffee, to make up for the loss of our breakfast in the
morning. We then took a walk to the church at Dartford,
where we lounged about till we were tired—then came
back through the fields to the boat, which we got into, and
made the ship.”

Professional eyes will detect a curious mixture of ignorance and


knowledge in the above production, in which, if the nautical terms—
such as ‘hole’ for hatchway—be not too severely criticised, the
information may pass pretty well for twenty-four hours’ experience.
In a letter written a few days afterwards, from the Nore, I find some
touches of the same kind.
“On Sunday, about three o’clock in the morning, I was awakened
by a great noise of the boatswain’s mates and the captain bawling
for all hands up to unfurl the sails. As I thought I could not sleep
much more, I got up in the dark and went upon deck. All the men
were hauling the anchor in: they were a good while about it. As soon
as the anchor was got in, all the men ran up the masts like so many
cats, and went out on the yard-arms and untied the sails. In a little
while all the sails were set, and we scudded down the river, very
quick. Got to the Nore about twelve o’clock, where we now lie for
three or four days.”
In another letter, of the same date, after giving an account of the
“confounded noise made by the men, and the boatswain’s mates
ordering the anchor to be drawn up”—and describing, more correctly
than in the above extract, that the sailors “ran up the shrouds,” I
proceed to plume myself, rather prematurely, upon being already a
voyager.
“About twelve o’clock we made the Nore—the first time I have
been in open sea!” I half suspect that the motion of the ship, which,
even at that stage of our progress, began, as I well remember, to
overturn the serenity of my stomach, may have led me to conclude
we were at sea. In the same epistle, in spite of the open ocean, there
occur the following sentences:—
“I like my station very much indeed. Have some very agreeable
messmates, and the schoolmaster is a very pleasant man, who has
travelled a great deal. We have not begun our school yet, as we are
all in confusion, but shall, as soon as we have tripped our anchor for
Halifax.”
The next letter was written from Spithead, and is characteristic
enough.

“H. M. S. Leander, Spithead, June 18.


“I am much better pleased with my situation than I
suspected I would at my first coming on board. We have in
our mess four Scotchmen, six Englishmen, and two Irish,
so that we make a very pleasant company down in the
cock-pit. We dine at twelve, and breakfast at eight in the
morning. At breakfast we get tea and sea cake: at dinner
we have either beef, pork, or pudding. But when we come
into a harbour or near one, there are always numbers of
boats come out with all sorts of vegetables and fresh
meat, which are not left long in the boat—for the people all
run, and buy up the soft bread, and fresh provisions.
“About nine o’clock on the 17th, we anchored in the
Downs—the famous Downs—but, instead of seeing a
large fleet of great ships thundering out a salute to us on
our entrance, there was not one but a Dane and a Swede;
so we had to moor ship in the now solitary Downs. All the
hills along the coast are chalk. I should have liked to have
gone on shore at Dover to get you a piece of the rock, but
could not, as the ship was sailing as we passed it.
“We saw the coast of France, but were not near enough
to see any thing that was going on in the French
territories.
“We midshipmen are upon watch every night for four
hours together; we do nothing but walk the quarter-deck, if
the ship is not sailing. There is always half the crew upon
deck when the ship is sailing, and we and the lieutenants
order them to do so and so about the ropes and sails. All
the men’s hammocks are brought upon deck, and laid in
places at the side for the purpose, both to give room for
the men to work under the decks, and to give them air. All
the decks are washed and well scrubbed every morning,
which is very right, as they are often dirtied.
“There is a sort of cylinder of sail-cloth, about two feet in
diameter, which is hung above the deck, and is continued
down through the decks to the cock-pit. The wind gets in
at the top, and so runs down and airs the cock-pit, which
is a very pleasant thing, down here, at the bottom of the
ship.
“This morning, about eight o’clock, we arrived at
Spithead, and saw the celebrated Portsmouth, but I did
not go ashore the first day, as so many others were going;
but I intend to go as soon as I get leave. As we were
coming along we saw the Isle of Wight; it is very pretty
indeed, viewed from the ship, whatever it might be were
we on it. I saw some pretty places there, with plenty of
wood round them. The sun was fast setting on the water in
the opposite horizon, which had a fine effect, and cast a
light upon the island, which I cannot describe to you, as it
is such a rich country, and contains so many objects—it is
too pretty to describe. There are some ships at Spithead,
both large and small. In my next letter, if I go to
Portsmouth, I will give you an account of all the harbour
and docks, &c. &c. We remain here for ten days, I
believe.”

These extracts, though of course sufficiently boyish, help to shew


what may be made out of the most common-place details, when all
things are totally new both to the writer and the reader. It is on this
account I give a place to these juvenile lucubrations; for it is not
about the particular incidents that we care, in such cases, so much
as the state of feeling and genuine opinions of a young person,
exposed, for the first time, to the actual contact of the world. It would
be unreasonable to expect such ideas to be expressed in so many
words; but they may be picked up, in some degree, by the very
terms used in describing the most ordinary transactions.
The following letter shews how little difficulty people find in
expressing themselves when well charged with their topic. On
reading it over at the distance of nearly thirty years, I cannot help
remarking how different, and yet how much alike, the same person
may be at various periods of his life—how much changed in thought
—in sentiment—in action! It is curious also to discover, how
independent the man at one stage of life is of the same man at
another stage—though, after all, they may possibly be more nearly
allied in character, at bottom, than any two other persons who could
be placed in comparison. At the same time, under the circumstances
described in this letter, I really do not see that I should act differently
at this hour.

“Portsmouth, June 19.


“We were very near all being destroyed, and blown up,
last night, by an alarming fire on board. As I was standing
making my hammock, last night about ten o’clock, near
two others making theirs, we were alarmed by seeing a
large burst of sparks come from one corner of the cock-pit.
Without going to see what was the matter, I ran into our
birth, or place where we mess, and got hold of all the pots
of beer which the midshipmen were going to drink. I
returned with these, and threw them on the fire, while
others ran for water.
“When I came back, I saw the purser’s steward covered
with fire, and rubbing it off him as fast as he could, with a
pile of burning sheets and blankets lying at his feet. One
of us ran up to the quarter-deck, and seizing the fire-
buckets that were nearest, filled them, and brought them
down. We also got some of the men out of their
hammocks, but took good care not to awaken any of the
rest, for fear of bustle and confusion.
“The sentry, as soon as he discovered the smell, went
down to the captain and lieutenants, who immediately
came to the cock-pit, and whispered out ‘Silence!’ They
then got more buckets of water, and quenched the flames,
which, as they thought, were only in the purser’s steward’s
cabin. But one of the men opened the door of the
steward’s store-room, and saw a great deal of fire lying on
the floor. Water, of course, was applied, and it also was
quenched; the store-room was then well flooded.
“The captain ordered the purser’s steward to be put in
irons directly, as well as his boy, who had stuck the light
up in the cabin. The captain next went with the master-at-
arms into the powder magazine, which was close to the
purser’s steward’s cabin, and found the bulkhead or
partition half-burnt through by the fire in the cabin!
“All this mischief was occasioned by sticking a naked
light upon the beam above the cabin, from whence it had
fallen down and set fire to the sheets. The steward, in
trying to smother it with more, had set fire to the whole
bundle, which he then flung in a mass into the store-room.
There was a watch kept all night near the spot. Nobody
has been hurt.
“I am very sorry for the purser’s steward, for he was a
very good-natured and obliging man, and much liked by all
of us. He gave us plums, &c. when we asked them from
him. He is broke, I fear. I will give you the issue in my next
letter.”

This incident served, in a small way, to bring me into notice; for the
very next day, to my great satisfaction, I was ordered by the first
lieutenant to go in the jolly-boat, which was manned alongside, with
some message to a ship which he named, lying near us at Spithead.
I hesitated; and upon his asking me why I did not ‘be off,’ I replied
that I did not know which was the ship in question. “Oh,” said he,
looking over the gangway hammocks, “that ship with the top-gallant-
masts struck.”
Now, I had not the remotest idea what the term ‘top-gallant-mast
struck’ might mean; but as the officer seemed impatient, I hurried
down the side. The bow-man shoved the boat off, and away we
rowed, making a very zig-zag course; for, though I had the tiller in my
hand, I knew very imperfectly how to use it. The strokesman of the
boat at last laid his oar across, touched his hat, and said, “Which
ship are we going to, sir?”
I answered, in the words of the first lieutenant, “the one with the
top-gallant-masts struck.”
“Oh, sir,” exclaimed the fellow, smiling, “we have past her some
time—there she lies,” pointing astern.
Round we pulled—and I was much inclined to ask the man to
steer the boat; for, although my old associates, the fishermen on the
coast of Scotland, had edified me a little on this matter, I found it
quite a different affair to take a boat alongside a man-of-war at
Spithead, in a tide’s way, from what it had been to run a cobble on
the beach. Accordingly, I first ran the jolly-boat stem on, and, in
trying to remedy this lubberly blunder, gave orders which had the
effect of bringing the boat head and stern—which is about as wrong
in seamanship, as it would be in a horseman to put his right foot into
the stirrup in mounting, which, of course, would bring him with his
face to the tail.
Nevertheless, I crawled up the side, gave my message, and
returned to report the answer. The only salutation I received from the
first lieutenant was in the following words—uttered in a sharp, angry
tone:—
“Where the deuce have you been, youngster, all this time? and
what possessed you to go cruising about amongst the whole fleet at
such a rate?”
“I hope I shall learn to do better, sir,” I stammered out.
“There is much room for improvement, I am sure,” he cried.
I was made painfully sensible, by the tartness of this reproach, that
there was no very extraordinary degree of professional sagacity in
what I had recently done about the fire near the magazine. I had
been taking some credit to myself for not bawling out ‘fire! fire!’ and
especially for having thought of the pots of beer—but this brilliant
piece of service seemed now all forgotten!
Officers, and other persons in authority, should therefore be
careful how they strike young folks with their tongues; for, although
the wounds made do not shew upon the skin like those caused by
steel or lead, they often sink deeper into the feelings, and frequently
remain rankling there much longer than was intended, or than is
useful.
Of course, I was excessively mortified; but the justice of the
officer’s censure was so obvious, and the ridicule of the seamen in
the boat, even subdued as it was, so fair, that I soon saw I had
nothing to do but to set about learning to steer forthwith, and to lose
no time in finding out what ‘striking top-gallant-masts’ could possibly
mean.
CHAPTER III.
SPECIMENS OF COCK-PIT DISCIPLINE.

I skip over many other anecdotes at Portsmouth, in order to get fairly


out to sea; for I never felt completely disengaged from the thraldom
of school, and fully adrift on the wide world of independent life, till we
had left the white cliffs of old England many leagues astern. The
following brief despatch was penned just before starting; and I can
remember the mixture of exultation, and undefined dread of
something that was to come which I experienced, while I was writing
it:—

“H. M. S. Leander, Spithead, July 11, 1802.

“Yesterday the captain received his sailing orders, and


we have now got up a Blue Peter at the fore-top, which is
a signal for immediate sailing. We are just going to
unmoor ship, and shall sail for Halifax immediately. So,
farewell to England!”

Off we set, accordingly; and it may be interesting, and perhaps


useful, for youngsters in similar circumstances, to know, that all the
pleasurable anticipations came to pass sooner than any of those
which were gloomy in their promise. Yet it is curious, that, since
those days, when I was first launched upon blue water, I have very
rarely set out upon a voyage without experiencing many misgivings,
often amounting almost to a wish that some accidental incident might
arise to check the expedition altogether. This is the more strange, as
I have seldom, if ever, failed to find the reality more delightful than
was expected, the difficulties more easily overcome, and the harvest
of amusement and instruction more fertile, than any previous reading
or conversation, had led me to suppose the jog-trot course of a
professional life could possibly afford.
I don’t deny that I had sometimes a plaguy tough job of it to keep
my spirits up to this mark; and though I never quite lost heart, I was
often very low in the scale of resolution. So much so, that, on looking
back to those times, I fear I can discover moments when, had good
opportunities offered, I might perhaps have been tempted to cut and
run. Fortunately for me, however, there never was the least choice
left between perseverance and poverty; and I had been long taught
to consider, that the bread of idleness, however supplied, was the
most degrading food a gentleman could eat. It is true I was not then
so strongly convinced as I am now, that many of the essential
advantages of the primogeniture law, lie on the side of the younger
sons, yet I always felt, that it was my duty, as well as my interest, to
illustrate, practically, the truth of this seeming paradox.
The first damper to this magnanimous resolution, of making myself
useful in the world, was caused by a speech of our excellent captain,
who, calling all the youngsters into his cabin, a few days after we
were out of sight of land, addressed us in the following words:—
“Now, younkers, I have sent for you all, to tell you that you are not
of the smallest use on board the ship; in fact, if any thing, you are
rather in the way: but since you are here, I have no objection to your
learning your business, if you have a mind to do so. You shall,
therefore, have your choice, either to keep watch or not, exactly as
you please; only, recollect this,—if any of you decide to do your duty
in the way proposed, you shall be made to perform it in earnest. So,
mind what you are about, and give me an answer to-morrow
morning. Now, little fellows, be off with you!”
Out of about a dozen, I think there was only one other besides
myself who decided upon keeping watch. Most of this party had
been a cruise or two at sea before, and knew that pacing up and
down the deck for four hours in the night, over and above the tasks
of the day, was no joke; and they rather chuckled at the prospect of
being let off so easily. For my part, I was so grievously annoyed at
the contemptuous official assurance of being of no use, that I never

You might also like