Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Textbook Prostitution and Sex Work in Global Cinema New Takes On Fallen Women 1St Edition Danielle Hipkins Ebook All Chapter PDF
Textbook Prostitution and Sex Work in Global Cinema New Takes On Fallen Women 1St Edition Danielle Hipkins Ebook All Chapter PDF
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-pimping-of-prostitution-
abolishing-the-sex-work-myth-julie-bindel/
https://textbookfull.com/product/wolfendens-women-prostitution-
in-post-war-britain-samantha-caslin/
https://textbookfull.com/product/unheard-voices-women-work-and-
political-economy-of-global-production-farah-naz/
https://textbookfull.com/product/class-on-screen-the-global-
working-class-in-contemporary-cinema-sarah-attfield/
Police and the Policed: Language and Power Relations on
the Margins of the Global South Danielle Watson
https://textbookfull.com/product/police-and-the-policed-language-
and-power-relations-on-the-margins-of-the-global-south-danielle-
watson/
https://textbookfull.com/product/love-and-sex-in-a-new-
relationship-1st-edition-cate-campbell/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-informal-economy-seasonal-
work-street-selling-and-sex-work-1st-edition-dominique-boels-
auth/
https://textbookfull.com/product/doing-memory-research-new-
methods-and-approaches-danielle-drozdzewski/
https://textbookfull.com/product/global-perspectives-on-same-sex-
marriage-a-neo-institutional-approach-1st-edition-bronwyn-winter/
GLOBAL
CINEMA
Prostitution
and Sex Work in
Global Cinema
New Takes on Fallen Women
edited by
Danielle Hipkins and
Kate Taylor-Jones
Global Cinema
Series Editors
Katarzyna Marciniak
Ohio University
Los Angeles, CA, USA
Anikó Imre
University of Southern California
Claremont, CA, USA
Áine O’Healy
Loyola Marymount University
Los Angeles, CA, USA
The Global Cinema series publishes innovative scholarship on the trans-
national themes, industries, economies, and aesthetic elements that
increasingly connect cinemas around the world. It promotes theoreti-
cally transformative and politically challenging projects that rethink film
studies from cross-cultural, comparative perspectives, bringing into focus
forms of cinematic production that resist nationalist or hegemonic frame-
works. Rather than aiming at comprehensive geographical coverage, it
foregrounds transnational interconnections in the production, distribu-
tion, exhibition, study, and teaching of film. Dedicated to global aspects
of cinema, this pioneering series combines original perspectives and new
methodological paths with accessibility and coverage. Both ‘global’ and
‘cinema’ remain open to a range of approaches and interpretations, new
and traditional. Books published in the series sustain a specific concern
with the medium of cinema but do not defensively protect the boundaries
of film studies, recognizing that film exists in a converging media environ-
ment. The series emphasizes a historically expanded rather than an exclu-
sively presentist notion of globalization; it is mindful of repositioning ‘the
global’ away from a US-centric/Eurocentric grid, and remains critical of
celebratory notions of ‘globalizing film studies.’
Prostitution and
Sex Work in Global
Cinema
New Takes on Fallen Women
Editors
Danielle Hipkins Kate Taylor-Jones
Department of Modern Languages Department of East Asian Studies
University of Exeter University of Sheffield
Exeter, Devon, UK Sheffield, South Yorkshire, UK
Global Cinema
ISBN 978-3-319-64607-7 ISBN 978-3-319-64608-4 (eBook)
DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-64608-4
v
vi Acknowledgements
and family who have supported her through this project. In particular
she thanks colleagues and administrative staff at the University of Exeter
for their support in the organization of the conference that gave rise to
the book.
Kate Taylor-Jones wishes to thank the various groups of students over
the last few years to whom I have taught the topic of representation of
prostitution—your responses have both inspired and frustrated me in
equal measure. I also wish to thank E J-yong and M-Line Distribution
who allowed me to see The Bacchus Lady before festival release in the
UK. My gratitude is extended to the various friends and colleagues that
over the years I have discussed this topic with—whether we have agreed
or disagreed, the conversations have been important. I want to thank my
co-editor Danielle Hipkins for her collaboration and friendship over the
last few years—finally we have actually managed to finish this!
Notes
All Japanese, Korean and Chinese name appear in the traditional fashion with
the surname first.
An earlier version of Jane Arthurs’ ‘Distant Suffering, Proper Distance:
Cosmopolitan Ethics in the Film Portrayal of Trafficked Women’ was
previously published in the International Journal of Media and Cultural
Politics, (2012) 8:2, 141–158. Reproduced with thanks.
A modified version of Molly Hyo Kim’s chapter ‘The Idealization of
Prostitutes: Aesthetics and Discourse of South Korean Hostess Films
(1974–1982)’ previously appeared in Acta Koreana (2014) 17:1, 455–
477. Reproduced with thanks.
Contents
1 Introduction 1
Danielle Hipkins and Kate Taylor-Jones
Index 293
Editors and Contributors
xi
xii Editors and Contributors
Contributors
xv
xvi List of Figures
Introduction
D. Hipkins (*)
Department of Modern Languages, University of Exeter, Exeter, UK
K. Taylor-Jones
Department of East Asian Studies, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
key idea that the figure of the female prostitute in all her varieties is a
malleable cultural symbol that has been used to address a myriad of social
fears and desires across global cinemas.1 As the example of Much Loved
suggests, the figure is still interpreted in the light of the ‘whore stigma’,
as a result of which her representation is felt to haunt all women,2 while
her body also often remains entangled with the discourse of nationhood.
With this book, we aim to ask how frequently nineteenth-century nar-
ratives of female prostitution, hence the label ‘fallen women’, are still
recycled in contemporary visual contexts, and to understand how wide-
spread and in what contexts the destigmatization of female sex work is
underway on screen. We do this by bringing together the forms of rep-
resentation in different national and transnational contexts and engaging
international scholars in the question of how cinema has represented a
figure that to many is simply labelled ‘prostitute’.
The terminology is important to consider here. The terms themselves,
‘sex workers’, ‘prostitutes’ and ‘sex-trafficked women’, are culturally
and politically loaded. All the chapters contained herein, explore how
the broad term ‘prostitute’ can cover a variety of experiences and repre-
sentations and we engage with the linked terms ‘sex work’, ‘sex traffick-
ing’ and the figure of the prostitute, and even ‘whore’. Contemporary
debates surrounding sexuality continue to remind us of persistent and
often highly damaging patriarchal ideologies, and the presence of pros-
titutes and prostitution in all its forms acts as an ideal site through which
to debate contemporary gender politics. In this way, visual representa-
tions of prostitutes/sex workers/sex-trafficked women enable us to
understand attitudes towards female mobility, sexuality, ethnicity and
emancipation that cross national divides and affect gender identities
(although all three figures function differently).
The rise of commercialised sex in the post-modern age has resulted in
a polarisation of the debate. For writers such as Feona Attwood, we are
seeing a sexualisation of western (and global) culture.3 This process of
sexualisation has resulted in female sexuality being constructed as ‘active,
recreational material, independent, consumerist and consumed, a key site
of conflict, resistance and division’.4 This rise in the academic study of all
aspects of sexuality has seen the figure of the prostitute once more come
into wider public circulation and debate. The sex worker movement and
its supporters, rejecting the word ‘prostitute’ as degrading, have called
for the movement of sex work into the category of embodied labour and
the end of stigmatisation.
1 INTRODUCTION 3
representation and then focus all one’s analytic attention there […] is,
at least in part, to reify that dominance.’9 Similarly, by focusing only on
one small, if powerful, segment of the heterogeneous mediascape—for
example, the globalised conglomerate of Hollywood’s film and televi-
sion production—we risk producing a limited and one-sided debate on
the representation of the prostitute and/or sex worker. A good exam-
ple of this is the highly influential Pretty Woman (Garry Marshall 1990)
that, as Hilary Radner notes, reflects a promotion of the American capi-
talist dream made attractive by the addition of romance.10 In this end-
lessly popular film, the prostitute has, therefore, become the idealised
neo-liberal subject that speaks to a small minority audience in the face of
global inequality. Not least of all, Julia Roberts’ iconic image keeps the
white female consumer at the centre of the narrative, while this collection
will tackle in detail visual representations of this figure from countries that
extend not only beyond Anglophone domination, to Romania, Germany
and Italy, but also beyond a white homogeneity with contributors writing
on Hong Kong, Japan, South Korea, India, Nigeria and Mexico.
One of the formative books for considering the prostitute on screen
is Russell Campbell’s 2006 oft-quoted book Marked Women: Prostitutes
and Prostitution in the Cinema. Campbell’s study constitutes the first
and highly important attempt to look at representations of the prostitute
on the screen across cultures and has been fundamental to the develop-
ment of this book. While Campbell’s work covers a wide field of sur-
vey, he himself has declared that any claims to universal validity for his
models ‘are tentative and suspect’ as a result of his Western bias.11 With
our volume, screen studies from different national backgrounds, which,
in Campbell’s words typically ‘tend to work from too small a pool of
examples’ are finally brought into dialogue, thus building on his work.
A more recent 2015 book that addressed the representation of sex work
on screen is Selling Sex on Screen: from Weimar cinema to zombie porn; in
the introduction to this book, Karen Ritzenhoff and Catriona McAvoy
observe that ‘four main themes reappear: class differences and female
economic independence; law, crime, and sex work; capitalism/commodi-
fication; and war and violence’.12
Our book, which extends beyond the USA and European scope of
Selling Sex, will touch on all these themes. However, we argue that when
we examine these films on a global scale, representation is also marked
by many more intersections. Across the five sections of this book, the
affects generated by sex work’s increasing mobility; the rapidly changing
1 INTRODUCTION 5
nature of the urban space; the prostitute as the site of transgression; and
the recurrence of the global melodramatic tradition repeatedly intersect
across cultures and over a time frame that stretches from the 1800s to
the present day. A leitmotif of this collection is a preoccupation with the
story of the ‘fall’ as a narrative that makes a statement about how poverty
penalises women in particular or reinforces women’s status as victims—
the return to this narrative across radically different contexts offers a
series of takes on ‘fallen women’, many of which are new, but some of
which are also haunted by an intersection with nineteenth-century affects
of pity and ambivalence.
The Chapters
how these texts were circulated and interpreted within particular discur-
sive contexts, in this case, NGO and government anti-trafficking cam-
paigns in Western Europe that took place in the early 2000s. Utilising
Lilie Chouliarki’s idea of a ‘cosmopolitan’ aesthetics of spectatorship (in
which our philanthropic compassion for ‘distant suffering’ needs to be
accompanied by a reflexive engagement with political questions about
causes and solutions),14 Arthurs argues that we need to see these women
as more than voyeuristic objects of compassion. Using Rosi Braidotti’s
vision of a nomadic ethic, she calls for us to take into account issues of
agency and the right to mobility when approaching the question of aid
to those who are victims of sex trafficking. As she concludes,
An open and reflexive subjectivity is the necessary condition for a truly cos-
mopolitan ethics to emerge in which we decenter our own privilege and
power and pay attention to emergent forms of representation that express
migrants’ embodied, shifting desires and experiences in all their complex-
ity so that we are open to being transformed by this encounter. Only then
might we be able to answer the questions ‘why?’ and ‘what needs to be
done?’ in ways that could promote global justice.
This idea of global justice and the right to mobility and indeed
agency are echoed in Alice Bardan’s chapter, ‘“Through Hardships To
the Stars”: The Moldovan prostitute in Nicolae Margineanu’s Schimb
Valutar (Exchange 2008)’. Focusing on the figure of the Moldovan
prostitute working inside Romania, Barden asks us to reconsider norma-
tive modes of representation of Eastern European sex workers as either
repressed victim or over-sexed consumerist. Her analysis of Exchange
opens up the reader/viewer to the multiple levels of ‘exchange’ that are
taking place inside the film and explores how the dynamics of mobility,
consumerism and vulnerability are presented via the relationship between
a Romanian migrant and a Moldovan prostitute. In particular, she uses
postfeminism as a critical tool in order to understand the female prosti-
tute’s complex complicity in her difficult experience.
Transgressive Women?
This third section of the book offers an opportunity to drill down in
more depth into the ambivalence associated with the prostitute discussed
1 INTRODUCTION 9
postmodern hooker chic film’. For all its flamboyant postmodern irony,
she argues, the film engages the very ‘master narratives’ of ‘prostitu-
tion discourse, gender norms, racialization, and hetero-normativity’.
Examining the film in relation to Cukor’s Camille (1936), another ver-
sion of Moulin Rouge (John Huston 1952), and ending with an analysis
of the ‘Lady Marmalade’ music video (2002) produced by Missy Elliot,
while drawing on Rosalind Gill’s notion of a ‘postfeminist media sensibil-
ity’, Johnson argues that the recent re-cycling of this figure of Camille
relates to a new and deadly (for feminism) attachment to the female
body as fetishised object. By contrast with what Hipkins and Mitchell
conclude about the feminist and female-directed Un giorno speciale in
relation to its re-writing of the ‘fall’, Johnson finds that this mainstream
popular narrative leaves little space for female agency. Returning to the
theme of the female voice that offers a fil rouge through this particular
section, women in Luhrman’s Moulin Rouge!, Johnson argues, are quite
literally drowned out by ‘men’s voices, plotlines, and songs’. If the per-
formances of the courtesan analysed by Sharma in Chap. 9 challenge the
dominance of the male gaze through an attention to female experience,
Satine’s performances in Moulin Rouge! stage her solely as the object of
desire.
Any one who experiments with magnets must be struck with the
distance at which one magnet can influence filings or another
magnet. If a layer of iron filings is spread on a sheet of paper, and a
magnet brought gradually nearer from above, the filings soon begin
to move about restlessly, and when the magnet comes close enough
they fly up to it as if pulled by invisible strings. A still more striking
experiment consists in spreading filings thinly over a sheet of
cardboard and moving a magnet to and fro underneath the sheet.
The result is most amusing. The filings seem to stand up on their
hind legs, and they march about like regiments of soldiers. Here
again invisible strings are suggested, and we might wonder whether
there really is anything of the kind. Yes, there is. To put the matter in
the simplest way, the magnet acts by means of strings or lines of
force, which emerge from it in definite directions, and in a most
interesting way we can see some of these lines of force actually at
work.
Place a magnet, or any arrangement of magnets, underneath a
sheet of glass, and sprinkle iron filings from a muslin bag thinly and
evenly all over the glass. Then tap the glass gently with a pencil, and
the filings at once arrange themselves in a most remarkable manner.
All the filings become magnetized by induction, and when the tap
sets them free for an instant from the friction of the glass they take
up definite positions under the influence of the force acting upon
them. In this way we get a map of the general direction of the
magnetic lines of force, which are our invisible strings.
Many different maps may be made in this way, but we have
space for only two. Plate III.a shows the lines of two opposite poles.
Notice how they appear to stream across from one pole to the other.
It is believed that there is a tension along the lines of force not unlike
that in stretched elastic bands, and if this is so it is easy to see from
the figure why opposite poles attract each other.
Plate III.b shows the lines of force of two similar poles. In this
case they do not stream from pole to pole, but turn aside as if
repelling one another, and from this figure we see why there is
repulsion between two similar poles. It can be shown, although in a
much less simple manner, that lines of electric force proceed from
electrified bodies, and in electric attraction and repulsion between
two charged bodies the lines of force take paths which closely
resemble those in our two figures. A space filled with lines of
magnetic force is called a magnetic field, and one filled with lines of
electric force is called an electric field.
A horse-shoe magnet, which is simply a bar of steel bent into the
shape of a horse-shoe before being magnetized, gradually loses its
magnetism if left with its poles unprotected, but this loss is prevented
if the poles are connected by a piece of soft iron. The same loss
occurs with a bar magnet, but as the two poles cannot be connected
in this way it is customary to keep two bar magnets side by side,
separated by a strip of wood; with opposite poles together and a
piece of soft iron across the ends. Such pieces of iron are called
keepers, and Fig. 13 shows a horse-shoe magnet and a pair of bar
magnets with their keepers. It may be remarked that a magnet never
should be knocked or allowed to fall, as rough usage of this kind
causes it to lose a considerable amount of its magnetism. A magnet
is injured also by allowing the keeper to slam on to it; but pulling the
keeper off vigorously does good instead of harm.
If a magnetized needle is suspended so that it is free to swing
either horizontally or vertically, it not only comes to rest in a north
and south direction, but also it tilts with its north-pointing end
downwards. If the needle were taken to a place south of the equator
it would still tilt, but the south-pointing end would be downwards. In
both cases the angle the needle makes with the horizontal is called
the magnetic dip.
PLATE III.
(a) LINES OF MAGNETIC FORCE OF TWO OPPOSITE POLES.
(b) LINES OF MAGNETIC FORCE OF TWO SIMILAR POLES.
In the previous chapter attention was drawn to the fact that there are
many close parallels between electric and magnetic phenomena,
and in this chapter it will be shown that magnetism can be produced
by electricity. In the year 1819 Professor Oersted, of the University of
Copenhagen, discovered that a freely swinging magnetized needle,
such as a compass needle, was deflected by a current of electricity
flowing through a wire. In Fig. 15, A, a magnetic needle is shown at
rest in its usual north and south direction, and over it is held a copper
wire, also pointing north and south. A current of electricity is now
sent through the wire, and the needle is at once deflected, Fig. 15, B.
The direction of the current is indicated by an arrow, and the
direction in which the needle has moved is shown by the two small
arrows. If the direction of the current is reversed, the needle will be
deflected in the opposite direction. From this experiment we see that
the current has brought magnetic influences into play, or in other
words has produced magnetism. If iron filings are brought near the
wire while the current is flowing, they are at once attracted and cling
to the wire, but as soon as the current is stopped they drop off. This
shows us that the wire itself becomes a magnet during the passage
of the current, and that it loses its magnetism when the current
ceases to flow.
Further, it can be shown that
two freely moving parallel wires
conveying currents attract or
repel one another according to
the direction of the currents. If
both currents are flowing in the
same direction the wires attract
one another, but if the currents
flow in opposite directions the
wires repel each other. Fig. 16
shows the direction of the lines
of force of a wire conveying a
current and passed through a
horizontal piece of cardboard
covered with a thin layer of iron Fig. 16.—Magnetic Field round wire
conveying a Current.
filings; and from this figure it is
evident that the passage of the
current produces what we may call magnetic whirls round the wire.
A spiral of insulated wire through which a current is flowing
shows all the properties of a magnet, and if free to move it comes to
rest pointing north and south. It is attracted or repelled by an
ordinary magnet according to the pole presented to it and the
direction of the current, and two such spirals show mutual attraction
and repulsion. A spiral of this kind is called a solenoid, and in
addition to the properties already mentioned it has the peculiar
power of drawing or sucking into its interior a rod of iron. Solenoids
have various practical applications, and in later chapters we shall
refer to them again.
If several turns of cotton-covered wire are wound round an iron
rod, the passing of a current through the wire makes the rod into a
magnet (Plate II.b), but the magnetism disappears as soon as the
current ceases to flow. A magnet made by the passage of an electric
current is called an electro-magnet, and it has all the properties of
the magnets mentioned in the previous chapter. A bar of steel may
be magnetized in the same way, but unlike the iron rod it retains its
magnetism after the current is interrupted. This provides us with a
means of magnetizing a piece of steel much more strongly than is
possible by rubbing with another magnet. Steel magnets, which
retain their magnetism, are called permanent magnets, as
distinguished from electro-magnets in which soft iron is used, so that
their magnetism lasts only as long as the current flows.
Electro-magnets play an extremely important part in the
harnessing of electricity; in fact they are used in one form or another
in almost every kind of electrical mechanism. In later chapters many
of these uses will be described, and here we will mention only the
use of electro-magnets for lifting purposes. In large engineering
works powerful electro-magnets, suspended from some sort of
travelling crane, are most useful for picking up and carrying about
heavy masses of metal, such as large castings. No time is lost in
attaching the casting to the crane; the magnet picks it up directly the
current is switched on, and lets it go the instant the current is
stopped. In any large steel works the amount of scrap material
produced is astonishingly great, hundreds of tons of turnings and
similar scrap accumulating in a very short time. A huge mound of
turnings is awkward to deal with by ordinary manual labour, but a
combination of electro-magnet and crane solves the difficulty
completely, lifting and loading the scrap into carts or trucks at
considerable speed, and without requiring much attention.
Some time ago a disastrous fire occurred at an engineering
works in the Midlands, the place being almost entirely burnt out.
Amongst the débris was, of course, a large amount of metal, and as
this was too valuable to be wasted, an electro-magnet was set to
work on the wreckage. The larger pieces of metal were picked up in
the ordinary way, and then the remaining rubbish was shovelled
against the face of the magnet, which held on to the metal but
dropped everything else, and in this way some tons of metal were
recovered.
The effect produced upon a magnetized needle by a current of
electricity affords a simple means of detecting the existence of such
a current. An ordinary pocket compass can be made to show the
presence of a moderate current, but for the detection of extremely
small currents a much more sensitive apparatus is employed. This is
called a galvanometer, and in its simplest form it consists essentially
of a delicately poised magnetic needle placed in the middle of a coil
of several turns of wire. The current thus passes many times round
the needle, and this has the effect of greatly increasing the deflection
of the needle, and hence the sensitiveness of the instrument.
Although such an arrangement is generally called a galvanometer, it
is really a galvanoscope, for it does not measure the current but only
shows its presence.
We have seen that electro-motive force is measured in volts, and
that the definition of a volt is that electro-motive force which will
cause a current of one ampere to flow through a conductor having a
resistance of one ohm. If we make a galvanometer with a long coil of
very thin wire having a high resistance, the amount of current that
will flow through it will be proportionate to the electro-motive force.
Such a galvanometer, fitted with a carefully graduated scale, in this
way will indicate the number of volts, and it is called a voltmeter. If
we have a galvanometer with a short coil of very thick wire, the
resistance put in the way of the current is so small that it may be left
out of account, and by means of a graduated scale the number of
amperes may be shown; such an instrument being called an
amperemeter, or ammeter.
For making exact measurements of electric currents the
instruments just described are not suitable, as they are not
sufficiently accurate; but their working shows the principle upon
which currents are measured. The actual instruments used in
electrical engineering and in scientific work are unfortunately too
complicated to be described here.
CHAPTER VIII
THE INDUCTION COIL