Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract- In this paper, parameter plane synthesis of a three- frames shows that the synchronously rotating PI current
phase neutral-point clamped bidirectional rectifier has been controller has zero steady-state error and very good steady-
performed. The converter involves one outer-loop PI voltage state accuracy, while the stationary PI current controller
controller and two inner-loop PI current controllers for the results in an inherent tracking (amplitude and phase) error
closed-loop control. D-partition technique has been employed even in the steady state [3]. These synchronously rotating
for the precise design of the voltage controller. An experimental inner PI current controller and outer PI voltage regulator
prototype of the converter has been developed and the need to be designed.
experimental investigation of the converter performance in
closed loop has been carried out. DSP DS1104 of dSPACE has The main motivation of this work is to design the outer-
been used for real-time implementation of the designed loop PI voltage regulator [5-6] using D-partitioning
controller. The converter gives a very good performance in technique in order to regulate the output voltage under load
steady-state and dynamic state (for rectification as well as perturbations. The parameter plane synthesis method (D-
inversion modes of operation) using the designed controller partition technique) [7-9] is used for finding the region in the
parameters. parameter plane which ensures stable operation of converter.
Outer-loop PI voltage controller has been designed using
Index Terms- Adjustable-speed drives (ASDs), Improved power
this technique. Inner-loop PI current controllers can also be
quality converters (IPQCs), Voltage-oriented control (VOC),
dSPACE, Neutral-point clamped converter (NPC). designed using the same procedure. The performance of the
three-phase NPC rectifier has been investigated based on
designed controller parameters (Kp and Ki) which ensure
I. INTRODUCTION regulation of load voltage under different operating
conditions.
The rapid growth of AC adjustable-speed drives (ASDs)
in industry exacerbates the problem of harmonic pollution of II. SYSTEM MODELING AND DESCRIPTION
the power system caused by commonly used front-end diode The three-phase NPC rectifier [10-17] as shown in Fig. 1
and SCR-based rectifiers. The three-phase improved power provides smooth powering and regeneration capability with
quality converters (IPQCs) constitute the best solution to this twelve semiconductor power switches. Its current regulators
power quality problem with an additional advantage of the can control the power factor close to unity and the boost
bidirectional power flow. Various control techniques have inductance L limits the magnitude of the input current ripple,
been reported in the literature [1-4] however; the voltage thus reducing harmonics and it also serves as an energy-
oriented control (VOC) technique is still in common use storage device to allow the overall converter circuit to act as
because of the established theoretical concepts and the a boost rectifier. Now, the input three-phase voltage supply
advantages like fixed switching frequency, application of can be written as,
advanced PWM strategies, and insensitivity to line
inductance. v a V cost
The performance of a three-phase neutral-point clamped 2
rectifier largely depends on the quality of applied current v b V cos t
control strategy. Although the development of PWM current 3
control methods is still in progress, the current-controlled 2
techniques can be classified in two main groups, linear and v c V cos t (1)
non-linear controllers [2]. Linear control schemes have 3
clearly separated current error compensation and voltage where V and are the peak phase voltage and angular
modulation parts as compared to the non-linear controllers. frequency of the power source.
This concept allows to exploit the advantages of open-loop
modulators like SPWM, SVPWM, etc., which give a The voltage oriented control scheme for the three-phase
constant switching frequency, well-defined harmonic NPC rectifier [4] is shown in Fig. 2(a) and the coordinates
spectrum, and optimum switching pattern. Also, fully for the rectifier control scheme are shown in Fig. 2(b). The
independent design of the overall control structure as well as Voltage Oriented Control (VOC) technique is still in
open-loop testing of the converter and load can be easily common use because of the established theoretical concepts
performed. A linear current controller can be carried out in and advantages like fixed switching frequency, application
either stationary or synchronous rotating frames. The of advanced PWM strategies and insensitivity to line
performance of a current-controlled voltage-regulated PWM inductance. Thus in this paper VOC has been employed for
rectifier in stationary and synchronously rotating reference the control of three-phase neutral-point clamped converter.
1
i1 Io
Vc1
C1
D2 Tb2 D4 D6
Va R L Vo
A a
va L
Vb R L O
B o A
b
vb io D
Vc R L c
C vc
Tb1'
C2
Vc2
D3 D5
D1
i2
(a)
Fig. 1 Three-level diode-clamped bidirectional rectifier
2
controllability as follows:
di d
0L v d
dt
di q
0L v q (11)
dt
Thus the overall current controller equation (9) in the
synchronous d-q reference frame relaxes the burden of the PI
(a)
current controllers and improves the input current waveform.
Fig. 3(b) shows the decoupled control diagram for the
synchronous NPC rectifier.
III. BASIC CONCEPT OF D-PARTITION TECHNIQUE
The partition of the coefficient space of a characteristic
equation into regions corresponding to the same number of
roots lying to the left of imaginary axis is called D-partition.
In order to understand the basic concept of D-partition
technique, the following characteristic equation is
considered
3
In order to construct the boundary of the D-partition, it is
necessary to determine the α and β for each , by solving
simultaneously the two equations
u 0 & v 0 (15)
If in each of them, we separate the terms containing α
and β, then we obtain a system of two equations with two
unknowns
(a)
u S1 Q1 R1 0 (16)
1 2
& (18)
(b)
Where
Fig. 5 (a) Block diagram of voltage control loop
(b) Simplified block diagram of voltage control loop
S1 Q1 R1 Q1 S1 R1
; 1 ; 2
the p-plane is the reflection of the boundary of the D- S2 Q2 R2 Q2 S2 R2
partition, and crossing of the latter in the coefficient space is
represented by the roots in the root plane crossing the The equations u 0 and v 0 determine one
imaginary axis. This suggests the method for determining value of α and one value of β for each only when these
the D-partition boundary: its equation is found in parametric equations are simultaneous and independent. If for some
form by replacing p by jω in the given polynomial (where value of , the numerator and denominator become zero,
is a variable). From this equation, the boundary may be then for this value of , one of the equations
constructed by varying the value of from to .
u 0 or v 0 is a consequence of the other, and
The D-partition in the space of coefficients of for this value of , we obtain not a point but a straight line
characteristic equation was considered above. Of course, in a in the α-β plane. In this case, either of the equations
similar way, the D-partition for the space of any parameters u 0 or v 0 is the equation of this straight line
(time constants and amplification coefficients) on which the when this value of is substituted.
coefficients of characteristic equation depend can be
constructed. The aim of the analysis is to isolate the region If the coefficient of the highest term of the characteristic
of stability, the region D(n,0). equation depends on the parameters α and β, then by
equating this coefficient to zero, we obtain the equation of
Now suppose the coefficients of the characteristic another straight line corresponding to . These straight
equation of the system as given by equation (12) depend on
lines are called singular or spatial lines.
two parameters, α and β. Reducing the equation (12) to the
form In order to shade the boundary of the D-partition, we
must move along the boundary in the direction of
Sp Qp Rp 0 (13) increasing, and shade it on the left edge at those points for
For example, the equation which 0 and on the right edge at those points for which
0. Usually, the curve is traversed twice; once when
5p 2
p 5p 1 3 0 goes from to 0, and once when it changes from 0 to
, but it is shaded both times on the same side, since
Can be reduced to the form, usually the sign of ∆ changes for 0 or . Singular
5p2 p 3 5p 1 0 or spatial lines pass through these points most frequently.
The rule for shading the spatial lines is that near the point of
In this case, intersection of the curve and the spatial line, their shaded
sides must be directed towards one another.
Sp 5p 2 p , Qp 3 , R p 5p 1
IV. DESIGN OF PI VOLTAGE CONTROLLER
Putting p j and separating the real and imaginary The DC-bus voltage control loop can be modeled with
parts, we get the block diagram of Fig. 5(a). The gains and time constants
associated with the various elements of the block diagram
S j Q j R j u jv (14) are as follows –
4
Tdv is the feedback-loop delay due to
sampling, processing time and feedback filter;
Kp is the gain of PI regulator;
Ti is the time-constant of PI regulator;
The inner current-control loop is modeled with the first-
order transfer function Hci given by,
I 1
H ci (19)
I * 1 pTet
1
1 pTi 0 From equations (24) and (25), various terms are defined
as follows:
K p pTi 1 pTi .pC
S1 R e F1 p ; Q1 R e K L ; R1 R e F2 p
1 1
Putting
Kp
and
Ti
, and arranging various S2 I m F1 p; Q1 R e K L ; R 2 I m F2 p
terms, we get Where
p 3Tev C p 2 C p 0 S1 Q1 R1 Q1 S1 R1
1 2
p T C p C p 0
; ; (26)
3
i
2
(22) S2 Q2 R2 Q2 S2 R2
5
(a)
(b)
Fig. 8 (a) D-partition boundaries for voltage controller design for
different values of
(b) Transient response of voltage control loop
After computing , 1 and 2 , we can find For fixed , the locus of the vector D j is
and as follows plotted in real-imaginary plane with the variation in . The
characteristic curve is shaded once on its left-hand side as
1 2 increases from to . The system is stable at this
, (27)
operating point if the origin lies in the inner most shaded
region. In this case, the entire probable stable region,
Putting p j in equation (27) and varying determined earlier, is the stable region.
from to for constant , the D-partitioning The locus of D j for 0.0 is shown in Fig.
boundary is plotted in plane as shown in Fig. 6 for 7(a). To ensure the stability of this region, another point is
0.0. To obtain the region having maximum number of considered outside this region and the characteristic equation
roots in the left-half of p-plane, the D-partitioning boundary vector Dp is plotted again. The locus of D j at
is shaded according to the sign of the denominator of this point, as shown in Fig. 7(b), does not enclose the origin;
or ( ) as given by the equation (27). Facing the hence the region outside ‘A’ is unstable in the parametric
direction in which is increasing, the boundary curve in plane. To ensure maximum relative stability, is increased
plane is shaded twice on the left side if 0 and on from minimum value of zero. The D-partition boundaries for
the right side if 0. The inner most region is the most variation in are shown in Fig. 8(a). It is found that the
probable stable region as it happens to be the region having region with higher degree of stability goes on decreasing as
maximum number of roots in the left half p-plane. The is increased.
6
The final selection of the controller parameters is done Table 1 Performance indices of voltage
by comparing the transient response of the voltage control controllers for Kp and Ti
loop at different operating points in the stable region. The Gain Time constant % Overshoot Settling-time
mathematical block diagram of Fig. 5(b) is used for Case (sec)
(Kp) (Ti)
obtaining the transient response of the system. The closed-
loop transfer function of the control loop is obtained as 1 0.02 0.1 10 1
G o p
Mp
2 0.1 0.05 6 0.19l
(29)
1 G o p H o p 3 0.5 0.04 2 0.07
Using this transfer function, the transient response of the 4 0.01 0.05 No 1.7
voltage loop for step voltage reference variation from
1.0 p.u - 1.05 p.u is obtained. For final selection of voltage
controller parameters, the transient response is computed at V. PERFORMANCE INVESTIGATION
different points (for different values of Kp and Ti) in the
A laboratory prototype of the NPC converter has been
most stable region. Few representative points are mentioned
developed and experimented. Space vector PWM is used as
in Table 1. The transient response curves at these points are
the modulation algorithm [17-20] for the converter
shown in Fig. 8(b).For minimum overshoot and settling
operation. DSP DS1104 of dSPACE [21] has been used for
time, the controller parameters chosen from Table 1 are as
the real-time implementation [22] of the designed controller
K p 0.5 and time constant Ti 0.04. Thus, the selected parameters. Fig. 9 shows the block diagram of DSP-based
transfer function of the PI voltage regulator is given by NPC rectifier implementation. Table 2 shows system
hardware details as well as the system parameters chosen for
(1 0.04p) experimentation of the laboratory prototype. Fig. 10 (a)
0.5 depicts the waveforms for phase voltage, line current and
0.04p load voltage in rectification mode of operation of the
In a similar way, inner-loop PI current controllers can be converter. As shown in the frequency spectrum of line
designed. The designed current controller parameters are current in Fig. 10 (b), the current drawn is nearly sinusoidal
K p 2 and time constant Ti 0.2 with a THD of 4.4% only. Fig. 11 (a) depicts the waveforms
7
Table 2 System Parameters for Experimentation
vc
Vo
ic
v
100V
aia
(a)
(a)
Vo
100V
va
ia
(b)
Fig. 12 (a) Load voltage, source voltage and source current waveforms
(b) for a step decrease in load X-axis: time – 20 mS/div. Y-axis:
Fig 10 (a) Phase voltage, line-current and load voltage waveforms Vo –15 volts/div, va – 20 volts/div & ia – 10 A/div.
x-axis: time – 5 mS/div. Y-axis: vc – 20 volts/div, (b) Load voltage, source voltage and source current waveforms
ic – 10A/div, Vo – 25 volts/div. for a step increase in load X-axis: time – 20 mS/div. Y-axis:
(b) Frequency spectrum of line-current Vo –15 volts/div, va – 20 volts/div & ia – 10 A/div.
8
[11] Fukuda, S., and Matsumoto, Y., “Neutral point potential and unity
power factor control of NPC boost Converters,” Proc. Power
for phase voltage and line current waveforms in inversion Convers. Conf., vol. 1, pp. 231-236, 1997.
mode of operation of the converter. Again, the current drawn [12] Bose Bimal K., “Modern Power Electronics And AC Drives,”
is nearly sinusoidal with a THD of 4.8%, as shown in Fig. Singapore: Pearson Education, 2003.
[13] Lin B. R., Lee Y. C. and Yang T. Y., “Implementation of a Three-
11(b). Fig. 12(a) shows the load voltage, source voltage and Phase High-Power-Factor Rectifier with NPC Topology,” IEEE
line-current waveforms for load perturbation (sudden Trans. On Aerospace and Electronic Systems, vol. 40, no. 1, January
decrease of load on the converter). As can be seen, the load 2004, pp. 180-189.
voltage correction is achieved within 5 cycles after load [14] L. Yacoubi, Kamal Al-Haddad, F. Fnaiech, and L. A. Dessaint, “A
disturbance is introduced. Fig. 12(b) shows the load voltage, DSP-Based Implementation of a New Nonlinear Control for a Three-
Phase Neutral Point Clamped Boost Rectifier Prototype,” IEEE Trans.
source voltage and line current waveforms for another load Ind. Electr., vol. 52, No. 1, Feb. 2005, pp. 197-205.
perturbation (sudden load increase on the converter). Again, [15]Bhat, Abdul Hamid and Agarwal, Pramod, “Three-phase, power quality
the controller quickly acts and brings the load voltage back improvement ac/dc converters,” Elsevier, Electric Power Systems
to the desired value within 5 cycles after the introduction of Research, vol. 78, 2008, pp. 276-289.
load perturbation. Thus the experimental results for the [16] Bhat, Abdul Hamid and Agarwal, Pramod, “Implementation of a
designed controller parameters verify excellent closed-loop Neural-network-based Space-vector Pulse-width Modulation for a
Three-phase Neutral-point clamped High-power Factor Converter,”
performance of the converter. Electric Power Components and Systems, vol. 37, pp. 210-233, 2009.
[17] M. Malinowski, “Sensorless Control Strategies for Three-phase PWM
VI. CONCLUSION Rectifiers” 2001.
Parameter plane synthesis of a three-phase neutral-point [18] Holmes D. G. and Lipo T. A., “Pulse Width Modulation for Power
Converters: Principles and Practice,” Wiley-InterScience 2003.
clamped bidirectional rectifier has been performed. [19] Malinowski M., Jasinski M., and Kazmierkowski M. P., “Simple
D-partition technique has been employed for the precise Direct Power Control of Three-Phase PWM Rectifier using Space-
design of the voltage controller. The designed controller Vector Modulation (DPC-SVM),” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 51,
parameters give a highly satisfactory closed loop No. 2,pp – 222-230 April 2004.
performance of the converter during experimentation. The [20] A. Bendre, S. Krstic, J. V. Meer, and G. Venkataramanan,
“Comparative Evaluation of Modulation Algorithms for Neutral-
converter regulates the load voltage at the desired voltage Point-Clamped Converters,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Applicat., vol. 41, No.
level and acts quickly against sudden load perturbations to 2, March/April 2005, pp. 634-643.
correct the error and quickly settles the converter at its [21] dSPACE User’s Guide, Digital Signal Processing and Control
desired load voltage. The current controllers also work Engineering, dSPACE, Paderborn, Germany,2003.
properly and cause the reactive component of source current [22] Youssef N. B. H., Al-Haddad K. and Kannan H. Y., “Real Time
to vanish indicating a unity power factor operation with only Linear Control Implementation Based on Experimentally Validated
Small Signal Model of a Three-Phase Three-Level Boost-Type Vienna
the d-component of current flowing which is responsible for Rectifier,” IEEE IECON’06, 2006, pp. 37-42.
the flow of power demanded by the load.
VII. References
[1] Martins D. C., Oliveria A. H. D., and Barbi I., “Three-phase rectifier
using a SEPIC DC-DC converter in continuous conduction mode for
power factor correction,” in Proc. Record IEEE INTELEC’98, 1998,
pp. 491-497.
[2] Kazmierkowski M. P. and Malesani L., “Current control techniques for
three-phase voltage- source PWM converters: A survey,” IEEE Trans.
on Industrial Electronics, vol. 45, No. 5, Oct. 1998, pp. 691-703.
[3] Dain K., Liu P., Xiong J., and Chen J., “Comparative Study on Current
Control for Three-Phase SVPWM Voltage-Source Converter in
Synchronous Rotating Frame Using Complex Vector Method”, in
Conf. Rec. PESC’03, 2003, vol. 2, pp. 695-700.
[4] Malinowski M., Kazmierkowski M. P., and Trzynadlowski A. M., “A
Comparative Study of Control Techniques for PWM Rectifiers in AC
Adjustable Speed Drives,” IEEE Trans. Power Electronics, vol. 18,
No. 6, Nov. 2003, pp. 1390-1396.
[5] Alexandridis, A. T., Bourdoulis, M. K.,“PI controller design of grid-side
PWM-regulated ac/dc converters via stability analysis based on
passivity”, 3rd IEEE International Symposium on Power Electronics
for Distributed Generation Systems (PEDG), 2012, pp. 241-248.
[6] Konstantakopoulos, I.C., Bourdoulis, M. K., Alexandridis, A. T.,“An
alternative PI controller design approach for PWM-regulated ac/dc
Three-phase converters”IEEE International Conference on Industrial
Technology (ICIT),2012, pp. 944-949.
[7] Aizerman M. A., “Theory of automatic control”, Pergaman Press, New
York, 1963.
[8] Agarwal P., and Verma V. K., “Parameter plane synthesis of a dual
converter fed variable speed D. C.drive system”, Electrical Machines
and Power Systems, vol. 12, no. 1, 1987, pp. 57-68.
[9] Agarwal P. and Verma V. K., “Synthesis and performance of a
digitally controlled current source”, Electric Machines and Power
Systems, 1992, pp. 149-160.
[10] Lai, J. S., and Peng, F. Z., “Multilevel Converters: A new breed of
power converters,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. IA-32, No. 3, pp.
509-517, May/June 1996.