Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EXPERIMENT TITLE
BERNOULLI’S THEOREM
LOSSES IN PIPING SYSTEM
GROUP NUMBER 03
SECTION 03F
NO CONTENT PAGE
0
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
1.0 INTRODUCTION OPEN END LAB
Water pressure is described as the force or strength that is used to push water through pipes or other
pathways and is created by altitude or height. For example, almost every single city has a water tower, which
is typically located high on a hill. This water tower is a large tank that holds the city’s water supply. The
height of the tank will determine the amount of pressure that the supply of water will have.
Water pressure is also often affected by gravitational pull. Water is much denser than air, so the water is
affected even more by small height differences.
Refer to the question given which is “Architect for new residential project at Mahkota Aman, Kuantan
design a unique shape of water tank. Briefly explain about the effect of their design to water supply for that
residential.’ We know that the Mahkota Aman residential is a large population. There are many factors that
need to be consider to design a water tank that may cause the water pressure which is the change in flow and
pressure. It is cause bythe sudden shutdown of pumps at the pump station this also known as the water
hammer.
Based on the question also, we as an engineer need to find the solution to overcome this problem. Before that
we need to do the experiment to identify which experiment is the best for us to solve this problem which
water pressure problem. Here, we have losses in piping system experiment.
1
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
2
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Bernoulli’s theorem, in fluid dynamics, relation among the pressure, velocity, and elevation in a moving
fluid (liquid or gas), the compressibility and viscosity (internal friction) of which are negligible and the flow of
which is steady, or laminar. First derived (1738) by the Swiss mathematician Daniel Bernoulli, the theorem
states, in effect, that the total mechanical energy of the flowing fluid, comprising the energy associated with
fluid pressure, the gravitational potential energy of elevation, and the kinetic energy of fluid motion, remains
constant.
Bernoulli's Principle is one of the most versatile principle ever. This is an important principle involving the
movement of a fluid through a pressure difference. Suppose a fluid is moving in a horizontal direction and
encounters a pressure difference. This pressure difference will result in a net force, which by Newton's 2nd
law will cause an acceleration of the fluid. The fundamental relation,
In other words,
which is known as Bernoulli's principle. This is very similar to the statement we encountered before for a
3
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
freely falling object, where the gravitational potential energy plus the kinetic energy was constant (i.e., was
conserved).
Bernoulli's principle thus says that a rise (fall) in pressure in a flowing fluid must always be accompanied
by a decrease (increase) in the speed, and conversely, if an increase (decrease) in, the speed of the fluid
results in a decrease (increase) in the pressure. This is at the heart of a number of everyday phenomena. As
a very trivial example, Bernoulli's principle is responsible for the fact that a shower curtain gets “sucked
inwards” when the water is first turned on. What happens is that the increased water/air velocity inside the
curtain (relative to the still air on the other side) causes a pressure drop. The pressure difference between
the outside and inside causes a net force on the shower curtain which sucks it inward.
Bernoulli's principle states, "For a perfect incompressible liquid, flowing in a continuous stream, the
total energy of a particle remains the same, while the particle moves from one point to another." This
statement is based on the assumption that there are no losses due to friction in the pipe. Mathematically,
where,
z = Potential Energy
= Kinetic Energy
= Pressure Energy
If a fluid is flowing through a horizontal pipe of varying cross-sectional area, the fluid speeds up in
constricted areas so that the pressure the fluid exerts is least where the cross section is smallest. This
phenomenon is also called the Venturi effect. The Venturi effect has several applications including that
associated with generating lift atop an aerofoil, making all forms of flight on aeroplanes, gyroplanes, and
helicopters possible.
4
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
2.0 PRINCIPLES
Consider a flow of incompressible fluid through the convergent-divergent pipe shown in Figure 1. The
cross- sectional area at the upstream (section 1) is A1, at the throat (section 2) is A2 and at any other arbitrary
(section n) is An. Piezometer tubes at these sections registered as h1, h2, and hn as shown
Assuming that there is no loss of energy along the horizontal pipe, and that the velocity and piezometer
heads are constant across each of the sections considered, then Bernoulli’s theorem states that
𝑣1 2 𝑣22 𝑣𝑛2
+ℎ = +ℎ = + ℎ (1)
2𝑔 1 2𝑔 2 2𝑔 𝑛
Where v1, v2, and vn are the velocities of the flow through section 1,2 and n
𝑣2 2 𝐴 1 2 𝑣2 2
( ) + ℎ1 = + ℎ2 (3)
2𝑔 𝐴 2 2𝑔
2𝑔(ℎ1−ℎ2)
𝑣2 = √ 𝐴 2 (4)
1− ( 1)
𝐴2
In practice, there is some loss of energy between sections 1 and 2, and the velocity is not absolutely constant
across either of these conditions. As a result, measured values of Q usually fall a little as calculated from
equations (3) and this discrepancy is usually written as
2𝑔(ℎ1−ℎ2)
𝑄 = 𝐶𝑑 𝐴2√ 𝐴1 2
(5)
1− ( )
𝐴2
In which Cd is known as the flow coefficient of the Venturi meter, which can be established by experiment.
Its values vary slightly from one meter to another, and even for a given meter it may vary slightly with
discharge, usually lies within the range 0.92 – 0.99.
The ideal pressure distribution along the convergent-divergent pipe can be derived from Bernoulli’s
equation:
For the purpose of calculation and comparison of the experiment results, it is convenient to express (ℎ𝑛 −
ℎ1) as a fraction of the velocity head at the throat of the meter, i.e.
2 2
ℎ𝑛−ℎ1
𝑣 22
= (𝑣1 ) − (𝑣𝑛 ) (7)
𝑣2 𝑣2
2𝑔
Substituting on the right hand side area ratios in place of velocity ratios from the equation of continuity (2),
the ideal pressure becomes:
𝐴 2 𝐴 2
ℎ𝑛−ℎ1 = ( 2) − ( 2 ) (8)
𝑣 22 𝐴 𝐴
1 𝑛
2𝑔
6
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
3.0 OBJECTIVES
1. To determine the variation of flow coefficient, Cd with Q through the Venturi meter.
2. To make comparison between measured and ideal pressure distribution along the Venturi meter.
7
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
4.0 APPARATUS
APPARATUS NAME
Hydraulic bench
Stopwatch
8
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
5.0 PROCEDURES
9
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
6.0 RESULT
Volume = 5 L = 0.005 m3
10
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
Table 3 Measurement of pressure distribution along Venturi meter as a fraction of
velocity head atthroat
Q = 5.51 x 10-4 m3 /s
Piezometer Q = 5.88 x 10-4 m3 /s
tube number
Q = 4.82 x 10-4 m3 /s
Piezometer Q = 5.19 x 10-4 m3 /s
tube
number
hn hn – h1 (hn – h1) hn hn – h1 (hn – h1)
(mm) (m) (v2 2 /2g) (mm) (m) (v2 2 /2g)
A (1) 330 300
0.000 0 0.000 0
B 320 292
-0.010 -0.02976 -0.008 -0.02787
C 214 202
-0.116 -0.34524 -0.098 -0.34146
D (2) 42 54
-0.288 -0.85714 -0.246 -0.85714
E 62 72
-0.268 -0.79762 -0.228 -0.79443
F 136 134
-0.194 -0.57738 -0.166 -0.5784
G 186 178
-0.144 -0.42857 -0.122 -0.42509
H 210 200
-0.120 -0.35714 -0.100 -0.34843
J 230 214
-0.100 -0.29762 -0.086 -0.29965
K 242 225
-0.088 -0.2619 -0.075 -0.26132
L 248 231
-0.082 -0.24405 -0.069 -0.24042
11
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
Calculation:
For Q1:
volume (V)
𝑄=
time (t)
0.005
=
8.50
= 5.88 x 10-4 m3 /s
2g (ℎ1 − ℎ2)
𝑣=
√ 1 − (𝐴2)2
𝐴1
2(9.81) (0.376)
=√
1 − 0.143
= 2.934 m/s
𝑄 = 𝐶𝑑𝐴2𝑣
For Q2 :
volume (V)
𝑄=
time (t)
0.005
=
9.07
= 5.51 x 10-4 m3 /s
2g (ℎ1 − ℎ2)
𝑣=
√ 1 − (𝐴2)2
𝐴1
2(9.81) (0.342)
=√
1 − 0.143
= 2.798 m/s
12
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
Given, 𝑄 = 𝐶 𝐴 2g (ℎ1 − ℎ2)
2
𝑑 2√ 1−(𝐴2)
𝐴1
𝑄 = 𝐶𝑑𝐴2𝑣
𝐶𝑑 = 0.979
For Q3 :
volume (V)
𝑄=
time (t)
0.005
=
9.64
= 5.19 x 10-4 m3 /s
2g (ℎ1 − ℎ2)
𝑣=
√ 1 − (𝐴2)2
𝐴1
2(9.81) (0.288)
=√
1 − 0.143
= 2.568 m/s
𝑄 = 𝐶𝑑𝐴2𝑣
5.19 × 10−4 = 𝐶𝑑(2.011 × 10−4)(2.568)
𝐶𝑑 = 1.005
For Q4 :
volume (V)
𝑄=
time (t)
0.005
=
10.38
= 4.82 x 10-4 m3 /s
13
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
2g (ℎ1 − ℎ2)
𝑣=
√ 1 − (𝐴2)2
𝐴1
2(9.81) (0.246)
=√
1 − 0.143
= 2.373 m/s
𝑄 = 𝐶𝑑𝐴2𝑣
𝐶𝑑 = 1.010
14
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
7.0 DISCUSSION / ANALYSIS
QUESTION:
1. Graph of variation of Cd versus Q through Venturi meter.
1
0.99
0.98
0.97
0.96
0.95
5.88 5.51 5.19 4.82
Q x 10-4 (m3 /s)
Series 1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.5
-0.6
-0.7
-0.8
-0.9
Distance from datum, (mm)
15
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
Calculation of Qtheory,
2𝑔∆ℎ
Qtheory = √ 1 1
( 2− 2)
𝐴 𝐴
2 1
16
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
4. From your graph, discuss the variation of Cd versus Q through Venturi meter.
The experiment is conducted using the Venturi meter apparatus which is an instrument for
measuring the drop in pressure that takes place as the velocity of a fluid increases. This
apparatus shows measured pressure at three places which is the entrance, the point of
constriction (throat), and the exit.
For our experimental result, in the first graph, it shows flow coefficient (C d) versus Qactual. Cd
is stated as the ratio between the actual flow discharge and theoretical flow discharge.
However, there might be some error happen during the experiment and we could not get
the specified value for Qactual which resulting the Cd value obtained is out of range.
Based on the Bernoulli’s principle, conservation of energy using liquids, observing how
water flows through pipes of varying diameter. In a segment of pipe with a relatively large
diameter, water flowed slowly, but as it entered a segment of smaller diameter, its speed
increased. This is because as fluid moves from a wider pipe to a narrower one, the volume
of that fluid that moves a given distance in each time does not change. But since the width
of the narrower pipe is smaller, the fluid must move faster to achieve that result. Clearly the
volume of water flowing through the narrower pipe at any given moment was less than that
flowing through the wider one. This suggested, according to Boyle's law, that the pressure in
the wider pipe must be greater.
This principle can be seen from the second graph, if we compare the pressure at upstream
(tube A), at the throat (tube D) and at any other arbitrary, the pressure is the highest at
upstream (tube A) and started to decrease when diameter of the tube decreasing until the
lowest at the throat (tube D), and the pressure started to increase back when the diameter
of the tube increasing at the downstream.
17
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
5. Give your suggestion on how to minimize the difference between the measured
and ideal pressure.
Based on the result that we obtained from the experiment, the values of
measured pressure are difference from ideal pressure as shown in the graph of
the measured and ideal pressure distribution along Venturi meter. There are due
to some causes and errors which lead to the difference between the measured
and ideal pressure. Precautions can be taken during the experiment to minimize
the different between the measured and ideal pressure.
Here is a few causes and errors in the experiment that causing that causing the
experimental value vary with the theoretical.
1. Parallax error because of your eye being positioned at an angle while taking the
reading of the water level in piezometer.
2. Human errors while taking the time taken by using stopwatch for 5 Litres of water to
fill in the container.
3. Errors while taking the water level of piezometer due to the inconsistency of its
water level.
4. Improper maintenance of the apparatus.
5. Environment factors such as the air movement which cause movement of the
equipment as well as the meniscus.
iii. We only need to take the reading when the equipment in a stable condition.
iv. Repeat the experiment for few times and get the average reading to improve the
accuracy of the results.
18
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
8.0 CONCLUSION
From the experiment, we have calculated the flow rate Q and flow coefficient 𝐶𝑑 .
For case 1, the flow rate, 𝑄1 that obtained from the experiment is 5.88 × 10−4 𝑚3/𝑠 and
𝐶𝑑 is 0.997. For case 2, the 𝑄2 is 5.51 × 10−4 𝑚3/𝑠 and 𝐶𝑑 is 0.979. For case 3, the 𝑄3
is 5.19 × 10−4 𝑚3/𝑠 and 𝐶𝑑 is 1.005. For case 4, the 𝑄4 is 4.82 × 10−4 𝑚3/𝑠 and 𝐶𝑑 is
1.010. From the calculation, we can see the flow are consistent from case 1 to case 4. So,
the first objective of the experiment has been achieved as we able to determine the
variation 𝐶𝑑 coefficient Cd with Q through Venturi meter.
From the graph we have plotted above, the measured pressures deviate from the ideal
pressures. It because the reading is affected by some errors such as parallax error and
improper maintenance of the equipment. The second objective of this experiment had been
achieved as well as we are able to do a comparison between measured and ideal pressure
distribution along the Venturi meter.
To minimize the error and improve the experiment, proper precautions must be taken
before the experiment starts. First, the eyes of observer may not be parallel to
measurement reading and it will cause the parallax error. To prevent this from happen
during the experiment, the eyes must be perpendicular to the measurement reading so it
will reduce parallax error. Besides that, make sure the read the measurement of water level
after the water was calm. Then, the reading of the venturi meter level should be taken more
than 3 times to get an accurate value.
Bernoulli principle is related to our daily life and have several of applications. One of the
Bernoulli application are Pitot tube which is used to measure the velocity of flow in an open
channel. Besides, Bernoulli principle also used in application of Venturi meter which is usually
used to measure the velocity in a closed conduit. The last application of the Bernoulli principle
in our daily life is pipe orifices. A pipe orifice is a plate with an opening which is fitted in a
pipeline. It produces a constriction within the flow and the cross-sectional area of the flow at
the orifice is much smaller compare to the cross-sectional area of the pipeline.
19
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
(1)
V2 = √2gh (2)
20
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
9.0 REFERENCES / APPENDICES
1. https://global.britannica.com/science/Bernoullis-theorem
2. http://www.codecogs.com/library/engineering/fluid_mechanics/fundamentals/bernoull
is-theorem.php
3. https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-bernoullis-theorem
4. Civil Engineering Laboratory Manual (Third Edition)
5. http://faculty.mu.edu.sa/public/uploads/1411294866.4652Varification%20of%20Bernau
lli's%20Equation%20-Experiment.pdf
21
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
3.0 LOSSES IN
PIPING SYSTEM
22
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Head loss is a measure of the reduction in the total head (sum of elevation head, velocity head
and pressure head) of the fluid as it moves through a fluid system. Head loss is unavoidable in
real fluids. Total head is the combination of elevation head (z), pressure head (h=P/ɣ), and
velocity head (/2g). The two types of energy loss predominate in fluid flow through a pipe
network; major losses, and minor losses. Major losses are associated with frictional energy loss
that is caused by the viscous ffects of the medium and roughness of the pipe wall. Minor losses,
on the other hand, are due to pipe fittings, changes in the flow direction, and changes in the
flow area.
Water flow in pipelines requires energy and the energy is in a form of elevation, velocity
and pressure. Between points of flow, there also occur lost energy or what is called head loss.
The head loss effects pressure and/or velocity within the pipelines. This in turn impacts the
flow capacity of water within a piping system. The science in hydraulics is primarily concerned
with determination of the magnitude of energy loss or head loss (HL) under various
circumstances. Due to the complexity of the piping system and the number of fittings that are
used, the head loss coefficient (K) is empirically derived as a quick means of calculating the
minor head losses.
23
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
2.0 PRINCIPLE
Total Head (Total Energy) = Pressure head, + Elevation head + Velocity head,
Based on the law of conservation of energy, the total energy at each point in the piping system
is :
(1)
Where;
24
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
However in the actual situation, there is energy loss due to friction in pipe during the flow of
water. Thus, the equation above includes the head loss or energy loss.
(2)
Where:
In the experimental test, the piezometric head can be measured which is the reading on the
manometer tube. The above formula can be simplified by substituting piezometric head
(equation 1) into the formula:
(3)
Where:
(4)
(5)
25
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
Where loss coefficient K depends upon area ratio between point 1 and 2
A2/A1 K
0 0.50
0.1 0.46
0.2 0.41
0.3 0.36
0.4 0.30
0.6 0.18
0.8 0.06
1.0 0
(6)
Where:
L = pipe length
D = pipe diameter
(7)
26
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
Where:
The relationship between head loss, HL and flow rate, Q in piping system can be expresses
as,
(8)
Where:
27
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
3.0 OBJECTIVES
1. To determine the relationship between head loss and flow in the piping system.
4.0 APPARATUS
APPARATUS NAME
Piping system
Hydraulic bench
28
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
Stop watch
29
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
5.0 PROCEDURES
• The valve located on the light blue pipeline as well as the hole in the
tank were closed. At the same time, the timer was started and the
2 reading atr tube 3 and 4 was taken.
• The timer was stopped when the collected water in the hydraulic bench
3 reached 5 litres.
• Step (2) to (3) were repeated with at least 5 different flow rates, Q by
4 adjusting the valves opening.
• Step (2) was repeated, however at this time the valve located on yhe
dark blue pipeline was opened. the reading at tube at tube (7),(8),(9)
5 and (10) was taken.
• The timer was stopped when the collected water in the hydraulic bench
6 reached 5 litres.
• Step (5) was repeated with at least 5 different flow rates by adjusting
7 the valve opening.
30
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
6.0 RESULT
1. LONG PIPE
1 17.22 0.290 x 10-3 1.996 27145.6 0.031 0.715 0.415 0.300 0.423 29.08
2 18.94 0.264 x 10-3 1.820 24752 0.03 0.685 0.410 0.275 0.341 19.35
3 21.91 0.228 x 10-3 1.569 21338.4 0.029 0.655 0.405 0.250 0.245 2.04
4 24.15 0.207 x 10-3 1.425 19380 0.028 0.625 0.405 0.220 0.195 12.82
5 28.13 0.178 x 10-3 1.225 16660 0.027 0.595 0.395 0.200 0.139 43.88
31
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
2. EXPANSION SECTION
Calculated Head
Peizometer Tube Experimental
Test Time, t Flow rate, Q Velocity, v1 Velocity, v2 Loss Errors
Reading (m) Head Loss
No. (s) (m3/s) (m/s) (m/s) (%)
(h7 - h8)
(7) (8)
1 18.91 0.264 x 10-3 1.820 0.490 0.555 0.610 -0.055 0.090 161.11
2 19.88 0.252 x 10-3 1.734 0.468 0.530 0.580 -0.05 0.082 160.98
3 21.12 0.240 x 10-3 1.652 0.445 0.505 0.550 -0.045 0.074 160.81
4 22.93 0.218 x 10-3 1.500 0.404 0.485 0.520 -0.035 0.061 157.40
5 25.22 0.198 x 10-3 1.363 0.367 0.460 0.490 -0.03 0.051 158.82
32
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
3. CONTRACTION SECTION
Calculated Head
Peizometer Tube Experimental
Test Time, t Flow rate, Q Velocity, v2 Loss Errors
Reading (m) Head Loss
No. (s) (m3/s) (m/s) (%)
(h9 – h10)
(9) (10)
1 18.91 0.264 × 10-3 1.820 0.595 0.580 0.015 0.061 75.41
33
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
CALCULATION:
0.005
Flow Rate, = 0.290 x 10-3 m3/s
17.22
0.290 ×10−3
Velocity, = 1.453 × 10−4 = 1.996 m/s
Error = x 100%
0.423−0.300
Error = | | x 100% = 29.08%
0.423
34
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
For Expansion Section:
g = 9.81 m²/s
0.005
Flow Rate, Q = = = 18.91 = 0.264 x 10-3 m3/s
𝜋 (0.0136)2
Area, = = = 1.453 x 10-4 m2
4
0.264 ×10−3
= = = 1.820 m/s
1.453 × 10−4
𝜋 (0.0262)2
Area, = = = 5.391 x 10-4 m2
4
0.264 ×10−3
= = = 0.490m/s
5.391 × 10−4
(ⱱ1 − ⱱ2 )2 (1.820−0.490)2
Calculated Heat Loss, HL = = = = 0.090m
2𝑔 2×9.81
Error = x 100%
0.090−(−0.055)
Error =| | x 100% = 161.11%
0.090
35
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
For Contraction Section:
0.005
Flow Rate, Q = = = 0.264 x 10-3 m3/s
18.91
Area, = = = 5.391 x
Area, = = = 1.453
0.264 ×10−3
= = 1.453 × 10−4
= 1.820 m/s
(0.36)(1.820)2
Calculated Heat Loss, HL = = = 0.061m
2×9.81
Error = x 100%
0.061−0.015)
Error = | | x 100% = 75.41%
0.061
36
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
7.0 DISCUSSION / ANALYSIS
1. Plot graph
EXPERIMENTAL THEORETICAL
Log HL Log Q Log HL Log Q
-0.523 -3.538 -0.374 -3.538
-0.561 -3.578 -0.467 -3.578
-0.602 -3.642 -0.611 -3.642
-0.658 -3.684 -0.710 -3.684
-0.700 -3.750 -0.857 -3.750
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
Log HL
-0.5
-0.6
-0.7
-0.8
-0.9
-3.8 -3.75 -3.7 -3.65 -3.6 -3.55 -3.5
Log Q
37
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
(ii) Log HL against log Q for expansion section.
EXPERIMENTAL THEORETICAL
Log HL Log Q Log HL Log Q
-1.260 -3.578 -1.046 -3.578
-1.300 -3.600 -1.086 -3.600
-1.350 -3.620 -1.131 -3.620
-1.460 -3.662 -1.215 -3.662
-1.523 -3.703 -1.292 -3.703
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
Log HL
-0.8
-1
-1.2
-1.4
-1.6
-3.72 -3.7 -3.68 -3.66 -3.64 -3.62 -3.6 -3.58 -3.56
Log Q
38
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
(iii) Log HL against log Q for contraction section.
EXPERIMENTAL THEORETICAL
Log HL Log Q Log HL Log Q
-1.824 -3.578 -1.215 -3.578
-1.602 -3.600 -1.260 -3.600
-1.400 -3.620 -1.301 -3.620
-2.301 -3.662 -1.387 -3.662
-1.523 -3.703 -1.469 -3.703
-0.5
-1
Log HL
-1.5
-2
-2.5
-3.72 -3.7 -3.68 -3.66 -3.64 -3.62 -3.6 -3.58 -3.56
Log Q
39
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
2. Develop relationship between head loss, HL and flow rate, Q for all graphs.
From all the graph of log HL against log Q for each case, all graphs have a positive
slope value, the log HL is proportional to log Q. When log Q is increasing, the log H L also
increases. At the same time, it also means that when the flow rate, Q is increasing, the head
loss, HL also increasing for each condition which is long pipe, sudden expansion and sudden
contraction.
40
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
3. Briefly discuss the relationship between head loss, HL and flow rate, Q obtained for all
cases.
Based on the experiment that we have done, we achieved the objective of the
experiment. There are 3 cases of experiments had been carried out which are head losses
for straight long pipe, expansion, and contraction. The results for the experiment are
calculated by applying the formula provided in the laboratory manual. The graph of log HL
against log Q for each case is plotted. From the plotted graph of log HL versus log Q, the
log HL is directly proportional to the log Q and show in straight line graph with the positive
slope for all three cases. When the flow rate, Q is decreasing, the value of H L will also
decrease. The experimental values show the same characteristics with the theoretical
results. Therefore, from the result of the experiment, we can conclude that the head loss is
increases as the flow rate increases.
Fluid properties and the flow rate in the system have been proven through the
experiment. By observation, the head loss is roughly proportional to the square of the flow
rate in most engineering flows (fully developed, turbulent pipe flow). This observation
leads to the Darcy-Weisbach equation for head loss due to friction:
𝑓𝐿 2
∆ℎ𝑓 = 2𝑔𝐷
𝑣
The experimental and theoretical head loss for these losses in piping system experiment is
slightly different, the percentage of error between the experimental and calculated head loss
in long pipe system is in the range of 2.04 % - 43.88 %. Whereas for the expansion section
system, the percentage of error lies between 157.40 % - 161.11 %, it is considered less
accurate for our experimental results when compare to the theoretical results. There is a
great difference between theoretical and experimental result in contraction section system,
where the percentage of error is in the range of 20.00 % - 188.24 %. The inaccuracy is due
to there is cause and error occurred when the experiment is carried out.
41
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
Causes and errors during the experiment are:
i. Human error. The control of the amount of water flow also carried out by human
hand, students unable to control the water flow accurately due to limitation in
human.
ii. The water level in the piezometer is fluctuate and not stable when the reading takes
lead to the inaccurate of the results.
iii. Parallax error due to the eyesight of observer didn't parallel to the piezometer while
taking the reading of water level in piezometer.
i. Place your eye perpendicular to the reading while taking the reading of water level
to prevent parallax error occurs.
ii. Ensure there are no bubbles in the pipeline system to eliminate disturbance to the
fluid flow and affecting the results.
iii. Start the stopwatch immediately when the water level reached 0 label and stop
immediately when the water level reached 5 Litres to minimize the systematic error.
iv. Repeated experiment for several time so that to get an average of data to increase
accuracy of results.
4. What will happen to the head loss, HL if we use different type of pipe material
for instance steel?
According to the formula of head loss the head loss is directly proportional to friction factor,
f, length of pipe, L and velocity of liquid flow, v, while inversely proportional to
gravitational acceleration, g and diameter of pipe, d. Therefore, when either the friction
factor, length of pipe or velocity of liquid increase, the head loss will increase. On the other
hand, when the diameter of the pipe increases, the head loss will decrease. This is because
when the diameter is larger, the flow area increases and the velocity of liquid at a given
42
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
flow rate is reduced. At the same time, when the velocity is reduced there is lower head
loss due to friction in the pipe. On the other hand, if the inside diameter of the pipe is
reduced, the flow area decreases, the velocity of the liquid increases and the head loss due
to friction increases.
There are many types of pipe materials for instance cast iron, commercial steel and
wrought iron, concrete, galvanized iron, drawing tubing, plastic (PVC) or glass, riveted
steel etc. All these materials have their specific roughness, some of them are having smooth
surface while some are rough. For a smooth pipe, the friction factor is near to zero but not
zero. That is, there is a head loss in any type of pipe materials made, no matter how smooth
the surface is made. This is a result of the no-slip boundary condition that requires any fluid
to stick to any solid surface it flows over. There is always some microscopic surface
roughness that produces the no-slip behavior (and thus f = 0). The head loss along the pipe is
affected by the different type of piping material. Water flow smoothly without loss many
energies for a smooth pipe wall while loss more energy for a rough pipe wall. Therefore,
head loss will be affected depends on the roughness of the pipe wall.
43
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
8.0 CONCLUSION
At the end, all the objectives of the experiment are achieved by doing this experiment. The
estimation of pressure loss is done by pressure loss measurements to be made on several small
bore pipe circuit components such as sudden changes in area of flow. The relationship between
head loss as a function of volume flow rate and friction factor as a function of Reynolds
Number is determined. The measured head loss across a sudden expansion and sudden
contraction with the calculated value is compared with the plotting of graphs as well.
From the experiment, it is found that there is a relationship between the head loss and
flow rate. When the flow rate is higher, the head loss is higher. This is because as the water
flows with higher velocity in an area of pipe, the flow rate is higher, and the hydraulic pressure
of the water is higher too. This increases the resistance in piping system and thus maximizes
the head loss due to higher friction and velocity per unit area in long pipe. At sudden expansion
and sudden contraction, it shows that the head loss of the liquid increases when the flow rate
also increases at the same rate. From the 3 pipe of long pipe, expansion and contraction we can
see that head losses decrease in experiment and theoretical.
The head loss is related to the square of the velocity so the increase in loss is very quick.
There is just a slight difference between experimental and theoretical values. This may cause
by errors such as systematic errors and random errors. But the trend is still same for the values
which mean they either drops or rises. There are some precautions steps in this experiment.
Before switching off the pump, close both the globe valve and the gate valve. This prevents air
gaining access to the system and so saves time in subsequent setting up. Besides, make sure
your eyes are perpendicular to the meniscus of reading when you are taking the water head in
piezometers. Put additional alertness when checking the time in stopwatch. If you are wearing
any items of gold or silver, remove them. The valve must be control carefully to maintain the
constant values of the pressure difference as it is quite difficult to control.
44
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
9.0 REFERENCES
i. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/total-pressure-loss-ducts-pipes-d_625.html
ii. University Malaysia Pahang :Civil Engineering Laboratory Manual (Third Edition)
iii. http://www.learneasy.info/MDME/MEMmods/MEM23006A/fluid_mech/lab-pipe-
45
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
During system design, the friction loss must be considered to reduce the effect on velocity
and fluid pressure. From the losses in piping system experiment that we conduct, we found
out that there are few reasons why the friction loss happens in piping system which is,
fittings, bends, valves, expansion joints and any change in direction.
When fluid flow is constricts, it will increase the pressure drop within the piping system. This
can be seen when we conduct Bernoulli’s Theorem, at the throat area, the velocity of water
flow increasing compare to at the bigger pipe diameter, thus pressure at the smaller diameter
pipe (throat) is lower. There is no sufficient to design a unique shape of water tank due to
water supply problem.
46
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
The water pressure of the delivery systems must be maintained to ensure that water of
acceptable quality is supplied in acceptable quantities. Loss of water pressure due to pipe
breaks, extreme leakage, excessive head loss at the walls of the pipe, failure of the pump or
valve can affect the delivery of water and increase the risk of contamination by intrusion of
water supply.
To solve problem water pressure at residential that always having the problem, after we
conduct the experiment Bernoulli’s theorem and losses in piping system test we identify
that when at residential area using a unique shape of water tank the water pressure is low
due to their shape and capacity, we must make or change the size of water tank and the
diameter pipe bigger than the original pipe so that the velocity is lower than before and thus
the pressure will higher than before and the problem water pressure is can be solved and the
residential area no more facing this problem.
From these two experiments that we already done, we identify that the Bernoulli’s
theorem is the most suitable test to identify the problem of water pressure.
47
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
DETAILED EVALUATION FORM FOR ENGINEERING LAB III REPORT (BAA2941)
SUBJECT/CODE: Engineering Laboratory III (BAA2941) -
GROUP NO./SECTION: GROUP 3 FLEXI
TITLE OF EXPERIMENT: BERNOULLI’S THEOREM, LOSSES IN PIPING SYSTEM
TOTAL MARKS 50
MAX: Maximum
48
Faculty of Civil Engineering & Earth Resources
Hydraulic & Hydrology Laboratory
_____________
NAME %
NO ID NO. REPORT TOTAL
49