Criteria 4 3 2 1

Excellent Proficient Emerging Beginning

Exceeded the
expectation on timely Was responsible and Sometimes failed to
completion of tasks completed most of the complete most of the Frequently failed to
Responsibility and follow up task on time tasks on time complete task on time
Quality of Quality of Quality of
performance Quality of performance performance often
Quality of frequently exceeded performance met sometimes failed to failed to meet
Performance expectation expectations meet expectations expectations
Consistently listened Consistently listened Cooperative but Uncooperative and
to others' ideas and to others' ideas and occasionally unwilling unwilling to listen to
willing to sacrifice worked cooperatively to listen to or support and support group
personal interests to to accomplish the group mates to mates to accomplish
Cooperation accomplish the task task accomplish task task
Was a positive force Showed initiative in
in looking ahead and helping group mates Was supportive but
supporting other address concerns and displayed little
group mates to achieve its goals to initiative in completing Passive in respect to
Leadership complete the task complete task the task completion of task
Showed up during Extremely late or
Showed up during Showed up during meeting/s to absent during
Showing up during meeting/s to meeting/s to accomplish the task/s meeting and
the accomplishment accomplish the task/s accomplish the task/s but late most of the accomplish with no
of the task ahead of time on time time valid reason