Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Inggris

    Uploaded by

    Shitį Putriåna
    3 views2 pages
    The document discusses the roles of the Indonesian National Military (TNI) and National Police (Polri) and whether they should cooperate. It presents two perspectives: 1) Some argue against cooperation as the TNI and Polri each have separate duties and authorities established by law. Cooperation could undermine reforms aimed at making the police independent and professional. 2) Others argue cooperation could be an important step to achieving shared goals of community welfare and security through synergies between the institutions. Working together could have a positive impact on security.

    Original Description:

    dscn text

    Original Title

    inggris

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The document discusses the roles of the Indonesian National Military (TNI) and National Police (Polri) and whether they should cooperate. It presents two perspectives: 1) Some argue against cooperation as the TNI and Polri each have separate duties and authorities established by law. Cooperation could undermine reforms aimed at making the police independent and professional. 2) Others argue cooperation could be an important step to achieving shared goals of community welfare and security through synergies between the institutions. Working together could have a positive impact on security.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    3 views2 pages

    Inggris

    Uploaded by

    Shitį Putriåna
    The document discusses the roles of the Indonesian National Military (TNI) and National Police (Polri) and whether they should cooperate. It presents two perspectives: 1) Some argue against cooperation as the TNI and Polri each have separate duties and authorities established by law. Cooperation could undermine reforms aimed at making the police independent and professional. 2) Others argue cooperation could be an important step to achieving shared goals of community welfare and security through synergies between the institutions. Working together could have a positive impact on security.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 2

    TNIPOLRIasagoal

    inl
    i
    fe

    TheTNIandPolr
    iar
    esymbolsofstrengt
    hf ort
    heunitar
    ystateoftheRepublicofIndonesia
    (NKRI).wheret
    heTNIisastatei
    nstr
    umentt askedwithdef
    endingstatesover
    eigntyand
    carryi
    ngoutdef
    enseandprevi
    ousl
    ytheTNIwascal ledABRI.whilePOLRIisanor ganizat
    ion
    taskedwit
    hensuri
    ngsecur
    ityandpubl
    icorder.

    TheTNIPol ripl
    aysaroleasanactorinthef i
    eldofdefenseandsecurit
    y,andt heTNIPolr
    i
    i
    nstitut
    ionall
    yhasseparateduti
    esofauthori
    tyandr esponsi
    bil
    it
    y.WheretheTNIi sinchargeof
    defenseandt hePolrii
    sinchargeofsecuri
    ty.Howev er,t
    heTNIPolr
    iinthesecur i
    tyanddefense
    system isreal
    lyneededbecauseiti
    sani mportantfactori
    nsurvi
    valanation.(
    Issue)

    Doy
    ouagr
    eeornott
    hati
    ncar
    ryi
    ngoutt
    hei
    rdut
    iest
    heTNIandPol
    rimustwor
    ktoget
    her
    ?

    Accordingt ooneoft hepeopl einI ndonesia,theystatedthattheydidnotagreewi ththe


    cooperati
    onbet weent heTNIandPol ribecauset heTNIandPol r
    ialreadyhadtheirowndut i
    es
    andauthor i
    ti
    esandagr eedwi thoneoft hestudent satSMANeger i2LahatthatiftheTNI
    coll
    aboratedwi ththePol ri,thegoal ofreform woul dbet oeradi
    cateanumberofpol i
    cies.
    ABRI'scontroversyundert henewor derdidnotwor k.becauseatt hattimetheNat ional Pol
    ice
    waspar tofABRI( TNI)butatt histi
    met heNat ional Pol
    i
    cehasbecomeaci vi
    li
    aninst i
    tution
    underthepr esident.Ther efore,theproblem ofABRI '
    sdual f
    uncti
    onorwhatcoul dbecal ledthe
    separati
    onoft hepol iceandABRIneedst obedonesot hattheNationalPoli
    cebecomesa
    prof
    essional andindependenti nst
    it
    ution.(ArgumentCont r
    a)
    Apartfr
    om that,t
    herear
    eal sopeoplewhoagreewit
    hthecoll
    aborati
    onbetweentheTNI
    andPolri,
    oneofwhi chisateacheratSMANeger i2Lahatwhosaidthatift
    heTNIandPolri
    uni
    te,i
    twi l
    lbeanimpor t
    antstepinachievi
    ngt
    hesamegoal ,namel
    ywel f
    areandsecuri
    tyf
    orthe
    communi ty.andhaveapositiveimpactonensur
    ingsecuri
    tyandsynergybetweent
    heTNIand
    Pol
    ri.
    (ArgumentPr o)

    You might also like