Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Preface................................................................................................................ xiii
Acknowledgment ................................................................................................... xv
v
vi Contents
6.3.3 Flexible docking: flexible ligand and flexible receptor docking ............. 138
6.4 Standard methodology for molecular docking ................................................ 139
6.5 Softwares available for molecular docking ..................................................... 143
6.6 Conclusion........................................................................................................ 145
References ................................................................................................................ 152
Glossary .............................................................................................................351
Index ..................................................................................................................367
Preface
The main reason for proposing a new book in the field of CADD is increasing focus of
educational institution towards molecular modeling as a key and rational approach for drug
discovery. Research scholars, undergrad students and sometimes even teachers of drug
design and medicinal chemistry do not readily find books to guide their research ideas and
CADD-based experiments. Students as well as teachers usually gain theoretical knowledge
via various books available in the market but they lack proper experimental application of
these tools. Most of the books available in libraries focus on the theoretical concepts of
computer-aided drug design and use of molecular modeling in general. Thorough
examination of such books disappoint scholars and teachers as they do not provide any
insight into the actual application of these theoretical concepts into solving research
problems. Even the books providing discussion about different softwares utilized in in-silico
analysis fail in providing the clear guidelines to a “lay-man”, to utilize them. Therefore, we
wanted to write a book that reflects on the issues faced by researchers in the practical
application of concepts of CADD, rather than a theory book on definitions and explanations
of CADD. This book will be a handbook for practical applications of different in-silico
tools available today along with various information about hardware as well as list of
softwares commonly employed in CAMM.
Of all the current trends in medicinal chemistry, CADD based studies are most common
and rationale approach. More importantly the correct utilization of such tools is important
to obtain reliable results and therefore the user, which could be anyone from an undergrad
student to a doctoral fellow, should be well-versed about the application of such tools and
techniques. Additionally, experience in solving the problem arising during performing an
analysis is necessary. We were greatly intrigued by the vast application offered by this field
and believe that researchers would benefit more from a book that provide sample exercises
in each chapter to guide an end user in practising a CAMM exercise on any and every
software package/online servers. Users can re-perform the given exercises which will help
them in understanding the correct interpretation in context of their study.
xiii
xiv Preface
Such a book can facilitate the actual application of multiple CAMM based approaches
employed in the process of drug designing. Each user who utilize a CAMM based tools do
not actually have set standard to compare his/her obtained results. This book will provide
users with a standard protocol and results which can be utilized to validate their own results
and will aid in building confidence over the obtained results.
We also kept in mind that information regarding the general principles associated with the
basic concepts of molecular modeling is also imperative for the book to become a
significant piece of literature. We aimed at an approach that would make sense and appeal
to today’s research scholars. Thus we incorporated a subsection in each chapter that
specifically understated the update in the current knowledge in each tools and technique of
this field. To avoid complexity in discussions, we have provided graphical representations
of general protocol followed in each in-silico technique for drug designing. We have
deliberately omitted detailed discussion of obscure theoretical principles and have only
focussed on simple explanations and information on how to utilize computers and artificial
intelligence in the process of drug design. This book will also help the readers in
understanding the utility of freely available software tools for the purpose of understanding
the complex process of identification of a suitable drug for a pathological condition and
their development.
Each chapter will discuss the basic protocols utilized in the process of lead identification to
optimization and finally prediction of its mechanism of action. The book will provide a set
exercise which could be utilized by the researcher to optimize and validate the tool
employed by him. Additionally this book will provide good number of exercises to UG
students (B.Pharm, B.Tech (bioinformatics), BSc (bioinformatics), BSc (biotechnology),
BSc (biochemistry)) and PG students (M.Pharm (all streams), MSc (bioinformatics)),
valuable to train them for their practical applications. Thus, this book may serve well to the
beginners of molecular modeling. It may be followed by the graduate student to gain basic
knowledge about the tools and route exercises of molecular modeling.
Acknowledgment
Authors would like to thank Dr. Bhawna Vyas, Research Associate, Department of
Chemistry, Punjabi University, Patiala, Ms. Shalki Choudhary, Senior Research Fellow,
DPSDR, Punjabi University, Patiala and Ms. Himanshu Verma, Senior Research Fellow,
DPSDR, Punjabi University, Patiala, for their providing assistance and suggestions while
compiling this book. Authors are also indebted to the supportive, and at the same time
critical, faculty members of the department of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Drug Research.
Authors would also like to acknowledge the support and guidance from Samuel Young,
Editorial Project Manager, Elsevier and Rafael Teixeira, Acquisitions Editor, Cancer
Research/Oncology, Medical Informatics/Bioinformatics, Systems Biology and Biostatistics,
Elsevier, along with other members of the editorial team at Elsevier. Finally, the time spent
on the preparation of this book was made available only with the forbearance of our
families, friends, and research groups, and we thank all of them for their patience and
understanding.
A special mention to Prof. Mario Sechi, Department of Chemistry and Pharmacy,
University of Sassari, Sassari, Italy, for his constant guidance, support and for providing an
excellent environment during the execution of this work.
xv
CHAPTER 1
there have been several refinement in the methods utilized to represent molecules in in-
silico studies. To represent 3D structure of a molecule and electronic properties associated
with it, certain coordinate systems are required. Following coordinate system are generally
used for molecular representation.
In Cartesian coordinate system, two perpendicular lines are chosen in the plane and the
coordinates of a point are taken to be assigned as distances to the lines (Fig. 1.1A).
Similarly for 3-D representation of molecules, three perpendicular planes are chosen and
three coordinates of a point are assigned as distances to each of the planes (Fig. 1.1B).
Depending on the direction and order of the coordinate axis the system may be a right hand
or a left hand system (Fig. 1.1C) [3]. This coordinate system is important to understand the
orientation of the molecules in molecular space on computer as in Fig. 1.1B and 1.1C.
orientations of chair conformations of cyclohexane are different as their Cartesian
coordinate are different.
Figure 1.1
Coordinate system for representation of a molecule: Cartesian (A) 2D, (B) & (C) 3D and (D)
polar coordinate.
Fundamentals of molecular modeling 3
In this system, a point is chosen as the pole and a ray from this point is taken as
the polar axis. For a given angle θ, there is a single line through the pole whose
angle with the polar axis is θ. Then there is unique point on this line whose signed
distance from the origin is r for given number r. For a given pair of coordinates
(r, θ) there is a single point, but any point is represented by many pairs of
coordinates. For example, (r, θ), (r, θ 1 2π) and (-r, θ 1 π) are all polar coordinates
for the same point (Fig. 1.1D) [1].
A more chemically intuitive way of writing the coordinates is to use the internal
coordinates of a molecule (i.e. bond lengths, bond angles and torsion angles). Internal
coordinates are usually written as a Z-matrix [1]. Here is an example of a Z-matrix, for
ethene (C2H4):
Atom number Atom type Distance (Å) Bond angle ( ) Torsion angle ( )
1 C
2 C 1 1.31
3 H 1 1.07 2 121.5
4 H 1 1.07 2 121.5 3 180.0
5 H 2 1.07 1 121.5 3 180.0
6 H 2 1.07 1 121.5 4 180.0
The first line of the Z-matrix defines atom number 1 (carbon). Atom 2 is also a
carbon atom, and is at a distance of 1.31 Å from atom 1 (the approximate length of
a carbon-carbon double bond). The third column defines the atom to which the
distance in column 4 refers, i.e. atom 3 (a hydrogen) is 1.07 Å from atom 1 (the
length of the C-H bond). Similarly the atom numbers in columns 5 and 7 define
which atoms are involved in the bond angle and torsion angle (values given in
columns 6 and 8 respectively). So, for example, atom number 6 is a hydrogen. It is
1.07 Å from atom 2, the bond angle involves atoms 6-2-1, and the torsion angle is
for atoms 6-2-14. All the torsion angles are 180 , showing that the molecule is
planar. This system of coordinate is required to generate unique conformation of a
molecular system on computer screen.
overall image. Raster images might be compared to pointillist paintings, which are
composed with a series of individually-colored dots of paint. Each paint dot in a pointillist
painting might represent a single pixel in a raster image. When viewed as an individual dot,
it’s just a color; but when viewed as a whole, the colored dots make up a vivid and detailed
painting. The pixels in a raster image work in the same manner, which provides rich details
and pixel-by-pixel editing. Unlike raster graphics, which are comprised of colored pixels
arranged to display an image, vector graphics are made up of paths, each with a
mathematical formula (vector) that tells the path how it is shaped and what color it is
bordered with or filled by. Since mathematical formulas dictate how the image is rendered,
vector images retain their appearance regardless of size. They can be scaled infinitely.
Vector images can be created and edited in programs such as Illustrator, CorelDraw, and
InkScape [4].
On vector displays the lines making up the image are traced on the face of the CRT. The
lines are continuous strokes and appear very straight and smooth. However only lines and
dots can be drawn on vector systems. Filled areas such as molecular surfaces, must be
represented by many closely spaced lines or dots, which adds greatly to the complexity of
the image. On raster displays, the CRT is repeatedly horizontally scanned, as on a television
screen. The image is made up of discrete pixels. Lines can appear jagged, depending on the
resolution of the CRT being used. Because of the pixels method used in raster system, filled
areas are more readily drawn on these systems than on vector systems [5].
CPK models are physical models in which a color coded molecular model assembly kit is
provided for representing organic molecular structures (Fig. 1.2) [6]. These models consist
of shapes comprising two basic and complementary construction units capable of being
interlocked. The basic construction units are color coded plastic tubes which can be coupled
to second basic construction units, representing the bonds between adjacent atoms. The
second basic construction units are color coded coupling spheres, according to the valency
of the atoms to be joined, the center of said coupling sphere represent atom centers. These
coupling spheres have radial arms substantially located on the surface of a sphere with the
center of the coupling unit being the center of the sphere. These units are made up of
plastic and are of two types, one type adapted for planar-trigonal coupling of three said
tubes separated by angles of about 120 and the other type adapted for tetrahedral coupling
Fundamentals of molecular modeling 5
Figure 1.2
CPK model representation of quinazoline molecule.
of four said tubes separated by angles of about 109 . Said first and second construction
units are capable of being joined together and held immobile by friction by having said
radial arms and/or the cavities of said tubes tapered so that skeletal models of complex
organic macromolecules may be assembled such that the distance between the centers of
two directly connected coupling means represents the distance between joined atoms [7].
These models give a good representation of the shape of a molecule. They can be
manipulated to produce various conformations of the molecule. But they cannot be used to
present electronic properties of molecules and they cannot be superimposed upon one
another to compare molecular conformation and shape. The bond lengths and angles cannot
be adjusted in these models.
Dreiding models are physical models that use thin metal or plastic rods to represent
bonds [8]. Bond lengths and angles are fixed, although rotations around bonds can be easily
done. One can also demonstrate the ready conversion of one boat form into another and
then stop halfway between the two and preserve the twist form. Selection of appropriate
balls and use of rubber tubing connectors to form double bonds and C3-C4 cycloalkanes
permits construction of numerous interesting cis and trans olefins, optically active allenes,
and small ring-compounds, in some of which optical isomerism is superimposed on
geometrical isomerism. However, they give a poor representation of molecular volume and
cannot be used to show electronic properties. Depending on the complexity of the model,
they could possibly be superimposed upon one another for comparison of molecular
conformation (Fig. 1.3).
6 Chapter 1
Figure 1.3
Dreiding model representation of quinazoline molecule.
Figure 1.4
Computer model representation of ligand protein complex.
Figure 1.5
Filled color coded computer model representation of ligand.
A disadvantage of computer models is that they are not physical, three dimensional models.
Thus computer molecular modeling tools portray images in a way that seems three
dimensional. Initially the models were drawn on cathode ray tubes (CRTs) using special
purpose computer hardware. In CRTs the images were limited to two dimension. The third
dimension was realized by rapidly displaying slightly different two dimensional images. In
this method, time was used as a parameter to represent third Cartesian dimension. This
technique is referred to as real-time graphics. Another technique used to give graphics a
three dimensional look involved drawing “in front” parts of image more brightly than parts
which are “in back”. More updated computer graphic systems such as PS350 and the silicon
graphics IRIS work station allowed to combine the techniques of real-time graphics,
stereographics and intensity depth cuing to produce a 3-D image with multiple colors.
Figure 1.6
Representation of different molecular surfaces.
surfaces that plays important role in drug designing process such as van der waals surface
(VWS), solvent-accessible surface (SAS) and solvent excluded surface (SES).
VWS simply refer to the union of all possible overlapping balls. The interactions of these
surfaces are important in various chemical and biological processes such as formation of a
tertiary structure of biopolymer, electron tunneling in protein crystals etc. The probable role
of weak VWS interactions on reaction dynamics is an issue of great concern [10]. Usually,
for the macromolecules such as proteins and nucleic acid, VWS may be buried within the
interior of the molecule. van der waal Surface bound molecules are held together by weak
attractive forces like dispersive, electrostatic, charge transfer and hydrogen bond interaction
between closed shell atoms or molecules, and molecules bound to each other by these type
of attractive forces possess low dissociation energies. The understanding of both reactive
and non-reactive dynamics in VWS complexes requires detailed information on potential
energies [11]. The VW radii of each sphere varies slightly with its covalent bonding
environment and these radii are needed for the evaluation of protein volume, interior
packing and also the packing at the protein-water interface [12].
The solvent accessible surface can be recognized as the surface created by the center of the
solvent that is regarded as a rigid sphere, when it rolls around the van der Waals surface.
Fundamentals of molecular modeling 9
This term was initially coined by Richard and Lee, when going through a study on
protein interactions [13]. They were interested in analysing the interaction of protein
with the solvent molecules to determine the hydrophobicity and folding of proteins. In
order to obtain molecular surface that a solvent could access, a probe sphere is made to
roll over the van der Waal surface, and the traces of center of the probe sphere best
describe the SAS [14]. SAS has become a common thread for most of the researchers
especially in the case of the non-polar molecules, as the free energy of aqueous solvent
is proportional to SAS, which in turn proportional to the number of solvent molecules
that are in contact to the solute molecule. Thus, SAS is a central quantity in several
solvation models used in molecular mechanics (MM) [15]. This surface can be used to
determine the amino acid environment energy which depends on an accurate and rapid
estimation of SAS. It can also be used to compute partition coefficient (logP), which is
an important parameter extensively used in studying the structural-biological activity.
Further, in molecular modeling study, the interactions of the compound with non-polar
phase can be determined by utilizing SAS information both in vitro and in vivo [16].
The constructive solid operation geometry operation can be applied for the
representation of SAS and the implicit functions underlying the molecular surface can
be defined through some steps as displayed in Fig. 1.7. The first step is sign change of
these functions, then identification of atoms and definition of function used for the map
evaluation of molecular surface and eventually the clustering of atoms. Function fSAS
(.) can be computed by adding the contribution of those atoms [(C i,Ri)]iεIζI that belong
to the sphere of center x and radius 2r, which is a constructive solid geometry
operation [17].
Solvent excluded surface (SES) is one of the most popular surface definitions in the
field of biophysics and molecular biology. It is divided into two parts i.e. contact
surface and the reentrant surface. The contact surface, as a part of the van der Waals
surface of each atom is accessible to a probe sphere of a given radius. The reentrant
surface is described as the inward-facing part of the probe sphere, while in contact with
more than one atom [13]. Later, Connolly developed the mathematical representation of
the SES for arbitrary biomolecules in terms of concave patches, saddle patches, and
concex spherical patches [18]. Among these regions, the convex contact surface
segment of the van der Waals surface possess direct contact to the solvent surrounding
the system, and the concave re-entrant surface segment in which solvent sphere has
contact with two or more atoms spheres of the structure. Cannolly representation of SES
is standard tool in molecular modeling that allows quantitative and qualitative
comparison of molecules [14]. The actual representation of solvent excluded surfaces is
displayed in Fig. 1.8.
10 Chapter 1
Figure 1.7
Steps involved defining implicit functions underlying molecular surface.
The physical and chemical properties of charged partial surfaces (CPSAs) play important
role in specificity and selective interactions of ligand with protein. CPSAs were developed
to get the information about the molecular structure that in turn help in determining the
intermolecular interactions for QSAR. Practically, it is useful to ascertain the toxicity and
give description of local and global electrophilicity in non-covalent interactions. CPSA
descriptors have been used in distinguishing the antagonist and agonist that bind to estrogen
receptors. These descriptors also have utility in determining partial charge and
conformational changes [19]. Charged partial surfaces like hydrophilic and hydrophobic
surface area have their utility in various phenomenon related to protein adsorption. Usually,
absorption from hydrophobic surfaces is more effective than hydrophilic surface. Not only
the adsorption, but also some of the protein exchange processes occurs with more ease over
the hydrophobic surfaces than that of hydrophilic surfaces. There is a strong correlation of
Fundamentals of molecular modeling 11
Figure 1.8
Representation of molecular/solvent-excluded surface.
target selectivity with physical and chemical properties of these surfaces [20]. The
modulation in hydrophobic surface can be achieved by some of the factors, one of them is
temperature. Temperature, as one of the factor to induce exposure of hydrophobic surface
was identified by studying its effect on the chaperone activity of α-crystallin [21].
1.6 Workstations
Usually vector systems are preferred by molecular modelers because of their speed and high
quality of line drawing. Since these vector systems use special purpose hardware, they have
been more expensive than raster systems and are used as display devices separate from the
host computer which being used to store and modify molecular coordinates. However,
nowadays new computer graphic workstations have been introduced, which include raster
systems having a computer with full operating system and mass storage facility integrated
with the graphic display.
The general purpose graphics processing unit (GPU) computational resource is very fast and
has also become very popular. It is strongly dependent on the hardware. Many computers
have GPU boards that are used mainly for graphics. To utilize the GPU for an application
program, we must uninstall the GPU graphics driver software and install CUDA, a
computer language for use with GPU. Most of the GPU-MD programs adopt CUDA for
12 Chapter 1
GPU computations. The slot number of each GPU board in the computer must be explicitly
indicated in CUDA. Every year, new GPU hardware has appear in the market with updated
CUDA version. The GPU program should be tuned up for each GPU, since the performance
of GPU programs depends on the balance of the number of GPU cores and memory-band
width. In contrast to CPUs, which are used for all application programs, the application of
GPU is quite limited. This means that the GPU is used only when the GPU programs are
available.
GPU computing is particularly suitable to run molecular dynamics simulation programs like
AMBER, Gromacs, NAMD and psygene-G/myPresto. Some of these GPU programs are
freely available. However, one of the most serious problems for end users is how to set up
the GPU machine for these MD programs. The other problem is that the system size for the
GPU computation must be larger than the minimum size that is determined by the program.
Since most GPU programs adopt a space-decomposition method for parallel computing, the
system must be decomposed into sub systems. This means that the MD of a small system
(like a single molecule) is not suitable for GPU computing.
Molecular mechanics treats the molecule as collection of atoms held together by spring.
This assumption is made to apply Newtonian’s mechanics (Huck’s law of mechanics) for
calculating potential energy of molecular system by considering atoms held together by
elastic or harmonic forces. These forces can be described by potential energy functions of
structural features (internal coordinates) like bond-length, bond-angles torsional angle and
non-bonded interactions of a molecule. Non-bonded atoms (greater than two bonds apart)
interact through van der Waals attraction, steric repulsion, and electrostatic attraction/
Fundamentals of molecular modeling 13
repulsion. Any deviation from the normal ideal values of internal coordinates while we are
drawing molecules on computer screen, accompanies with strain and leads to increase in the
potential energy. For example ideal value of bond angle of sp3 hybridized carbon in
methane is 109 28v. Deviation from this value leads to angle strain and subsequent
increase in potential energy of methane molecules. Thus every molecular system
experiences different kind of strain viz. bond strain, angle stain torsional strain and strain
due to non-bonding interactions which are contributors of the potential energy of
conformation of that molecular system. The combination of these potential energy functions
is known as ‘force field’ which can be defined as it is a set of rule to parameterize
potential energy functions of molecules. Fig. 1.9 displayed these different kind of strains
along with the formulas used to calculate corresponding energy contributions for potential
Figure 1.9
Components of potential energy in force field arise from different kind of strains produced in a
molecule of four atoms.
14 Chapter 1
energy of conformation in FF. Thus, the energy, E or Etotal of the molecules in the force
field arise due to deviations from ‘ideal’ structural features and can be approximated by a
sum of strain derived energies contributed by these deviation. This can be expressed in the
most general form as
Etotal 5 Es 1 Eb 1 EðWÞ 1 Enb 1 (1.1)
where,
Es 5 energy of a bond being stretched or compressed from its natural bond length;
Eb 5 energy of bending bond angles from their natural values
E(W) 5 torsional energy due to twisting about bonds
Enb5energy of the non-bonded interactions;
Etotal 5 Differences in energy between real molecule and a hypothetical molecule where
all structural values like bond angles, bond length, dihedral angle are exactly at their
ideal value.
The objective of molecular mechanics is to predict the energy associated with a given
conformation of a molecule. However, molecular mechanics energies have no meaning as
absolute quantities. Only differences in energy between two or more conformations have
meaning. MM models predict the energy of a molecule as a function of its conformation.
This allows predictions firstly for the equilibrium geometries and transition states and
secondly for relative energies between conformers or between different molecules.
Different kinds of force-fields have been developed over the years. Some include additional
energy terms that describe other kinds of deformations. Some force-fields account for
coupling between bending and stretching in adjacent bonds in order to improve the
accuracy of the mechanical model [22].
minimum. Conjugate gradient methods take the second search direction to be a linear
combination of the current gradients and the previous one. Conjugate gradient methods are
more efficient than steepest descent and require fewer energy evaluations and gradient
calculations. Conjugate gradient methods can also induce large changes in the coordinates
while searching for a minimum but the convergence characteristics are better than with
steepest descent.
Next method is the newton-raphson procedure, it is a powerful, convergent minimization
procedure. In the newton-raphson algorithm, one needs to have the second derivative matrix
available. This method is based on the assumption that the energy is quadratically
dependent i.e., it behaves like a classical spring. If the energy function were quadratic, the
increments x would lead directly to the minimum in one step. This is of course almost
never the case for the potential surface of complex biomolecules. Newton Raphson methods
do not need to do linear interpolations like conjugate gradient, so energy evaluations can be
speeded up by a factor of about 23.
The best compromise is to use the method of fletcher and powell. This algorithm combines
the advantages of steepest descent with newton-raphson and requires only the first
derivatives, but builds up the second derivatives by successive approximations. This method
is both quadratically convergent and efficient [23].
June 21st.—We left Utica to-day in the three o’clock train for Auburn.
About four miles from the city we passed a small town called
Whitesborough, a pretty place, with two churches, an academy, and a
building called the Oneida Institute. There is also here a manual labor
school. A large unfinished building just outside of Utica, we learned was to
be a lunatic asylum, calculated to accommodate one thousand patients—
God pity them.
Several pretty towns lay upon our route: as Rome, Manlius, Canastola,
etc. Sweet retreats from the confusion of a city without the solitude of the
country. The canal and railroad which run through or near these towns
present facilities for trade or travelling. Rome is a place of considerable
importance, containing five churches, a court house, academy, several shops
and dwellings. The population, five years since, amounted to 4,800. When
arrived at Syracuse we drove up to a large good looking stone building
bearing the name of Syracuse House. There we stopped to take tea. This
place is sixty miles from Utica: enjoys considerable trade, but is still in its
teens, having arisen since the canal passed through that part of the country.
The Oswego canal joins the Erie here, which, with the salt works near,
brings them much business. The population is 7,000. We observed in
passing through it, several good churches, a pretty court house, substantial
ware houses, numerous shops and dwellings, with a lyceum and high
school, so that it would seem the inhabitants ought to be wealthy, refined,
and well educated. The salt springs are at Salina, one mile and a half from
Syracuse, where there are eighty manufactories of this material. These salt
springs flow from beds of slate, in some places two hundred feet thick.
Among the layers are masses of vermicular rock, whose interstices are
supposed once to have been filled with salt. In this region of country are
extensive gypsum beds; water lime is also found in profusion. Sandstone,
generally old red, and lime-stones, are the prevailing formations of the
county.
It was a beautiful evening when we left Syracuse. The sky, every where
of a clear deep blue, paled gradually as it approached the west, where it was
lost in a rich golden glow. The spires of the town behind us, reflected this
brilliant hue, and the country as we passed, looked like one of Turner’s one
colored pictures. Onondaga lake with the pretty village reposing upon its
shore, and the rich fields around it, were all touched with this golden pencil.
The fields were strewn with salt vats, where the salt was undergoing
evaporation, which were covered with low sheds, probably taken off in the
morning, as it was now late Saturday afternoon, and this might have been to
protect them from the weather. It was quite dark when we reached Auburn.
We left the cars at the railroad depot, and were provided with carriages to
the American Hotel. Here, large commodious bed rooms, and luxurious
mattresses, received your weary friends. I lingered a while to write you the
events of the day, but must now hasten to bid you—adieu.
June 27th.—I could not have believed parting with Niagara would have
caused such sorrow. The lofty, and celestial emotions which are produced
when in the presence of this one of God’s most beautiful creations you are
unwilling to lose. You feel ‘it is good to be here’—and you dread to leave
this holy ground to enter again into scenes which will do much to efface
these pure emotions. A glimpse of heaven has been vouchsafed you, and
most reluctantly you return to earth again. Slowly we sat out this morning
to take a last farewell. We had seen it in all its brightness and we now