transfer the lateral loads through vertical system, and response No lateral force acting, Hinge joint Applying Lateral Force Hinge Joint Without bracing, Lateral sway Making the joint fixed Moment Resisting Frame Moment frame, applying load after making joint fixed. Bending moment are transferred. Bracing of member -Lateral loads are transferred through axile Force -Pinned Joint -No moments are transferred Compressive axial force Slender member are prone to buckling Cross Bracing Advantage and disadvantage Differences BRACED FRAMES MOMENT RESISTING FRAMES • Pinned Connection is used to • Rigid Connection is used form beam column joints. between beam and columns • Beams takes loads by • The Connection do not transfer bending , and moments are moments. transferred through the connection. • It relies on the rigid • It depends on bracing system connection to transfer to transfer lateral loads to the lateral loads to the foundation, horizontal and foundation vertical bracing system are used. Braced Frames Moment Resisting Frames • Beam and columns are • Beam and columns are analyze under vertical loads analyzed under and axial only, assuming the bracing loads and moments. system supports all the lateral loads.
• It has less deformation • Moments resisting frames
capacity and more stiffness have more deformation compared to moment capacity and less stiffness resisting frames. compared to braced frames
• Provide more Stabilization • Not good as braced Frames
Braced Frames Moment Resisting Fram • Cost effective due to pinned • Expensive to construct. connection which is simply to analyze and easy to construct.
• It is not labor intensive • It is substantially labor
intensive • The analysis of braced • The analysis of the frames structure is easy and simple connection is fairly complex