Contract No.

: BCD513CA
CONTRACTOR REVIEW/COMMENT
RESPOND SHEET Page 1 of 2

DOCUMENT NO.

CONTRACTOR: PT INDO CIPTA GEMILANG

PROJECT NAME: DETAIL ENGINEERING DESIGN GTG &WHRU Installation at BGP
DOCUMENT TITLE: BCD3-690-45-CAL-4-009-00 CALCULATION SHEET FOR WALKWAY BRIDGE
INCOMING TRANSMITTAL: RECEIVED DATE:
Approved with no comment
Approved with comment (work may proceed, doc to be
DOCUMENT REVIEW STATUS: revised and resubmitted for final approval)
Commented (document to be revised for review and approval)
Rejected
DETAILS OF COMMENTS
No Ref Description Response by Remarks
CTR
1 Page ii Missing table of content Noted and Updated
2 Page ii Provide drawings in attachment Noted and updated
3 Page 2 Reference Reference was using unit
weight of material. The
calculation update as per
actual which not using fence,
so fence load was removed
from this calculation
4 Page 3 Pipe quantity Pipe quantity is only 1, refer
to piping for open drain
5 Page 4 Numbers of piping load shall be equal Noted and Updated
with pipes quantity
6 Page 4 Sketch is not clear Noted and Updated
7 Page 5 Provide section A Noted and Updated
8 Page 5 From which profile, se comment in Noted and Updated, use
STAAD input H350 Beam
9 Page 9 How the joint connection to be design Please refer attachment B,
sectional drawing of joint
connection
10 Page 9 One side should be roll support to Noted and Updated
accommodate temperature (to be
advice)
11 Page 9 How is the support connection with Please refer attachment B,
concrete abudment sectional drawing of joint
support connection
12 Page 11 Why the reaction is jumping high Noted and Updated, result is
updated
13 Page 11 What is the Mz due to excentricity ex1 Noted and Updated
and ex2
14 Page 11 Horizontal force due to soil, pore water Noted and Updated
an LL on ground surface to be consider
 Contract No. : BCD513CA
CONTRACTOR REVIEW/COMMENT
RESPOND SHEET Page 2 of 2

DOCUMENT NO.

as well
15 Page 12 Consider Mz due to excentricity ex1 & Noted and Updated
ex2
16 Page 13 Check shear strenght Noted and Updated
17 Page 13 Reinforcement at weak axis shall be Noted and Updated
design as well
18 Page 14 Consider lateral load from bridge Noted and Updated
reaction
19 Page 14 Consider excentricity between footing Noted and Updated
area and vertical load
20 Page 15 Consider lateral load from bridge Noted and Updated
reaction as well
21 Page 15 Which one is greater between pipe Pipe steel strength is greater
steel shear strength or concrete
strength
22 Page 15 Check guling (rolling) Noted and Updated
23 Page 16 Consider also moment due to: Noted and Updated
1. Lateral load from bridge
reaction horizontal at
abudment
2. Soil lateral pressure
3. Excentricity between vertical
loads from bridge + sw of
abudment and centre of
footing
4. Selfweight of footing