Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PRECEDENT STUDY:
Prepared By:
MUHAMMAD AMIR KATZMAN BIN KAMARULZAMAN (2018267434), MUHAMMAD AMIRUL HAKIM BIN SABRI (2018656168),
MUHAMMAD AZMI ASHYRAFF BIN MUHAMMED NAZERI (2018698228), MUHAMMAD MUQRI BIN ANUAR (2018284706),
SITI AZZAHRA BINTI ZULNASRI (2018214274)
Group:
AP1195E
Prepared for:
PN. NURHIDAYAH BINTI SAMSUL RIJAL
All acclamation we praise to Allah, who has empowered and enable us to accomplish the task. We are grateful because we can complete our assignment about the
Precedent Study in the times given.
We would like to express our most profound appreciation to all who provided us the possibility to complete this report. Special gratitude gives to our lecturer, Madam
Nurhidayah Binti Samsul Rijal, whose contribution to simulating suggestions and encouragement helps us coordinate our project, especially in writing this report.
Thanks for providing everything, such as moral support, thanks for giving everything due to this Covid – 19 situations. By their advising, it has become one of the essential
keys to success in this assignment.
Besides, thanks to our group members, Katzman, Muqri, Azmi, and Azzahra, for forgiving each other, a lot of support, and teamwork to had done this assignment. Through
this teamwork, we can finish this report within a limited time.
Finally, we hope that this final year project may help us know many things, especially about building management. We also gain new knowledge and facts about the
project. We also hope this project can be beneficial for us when we start working as a building surveyor.
Table of Contents
Central Market Kuala Lumpur
1.0 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 1
2.0 BUILDING BACKGROUND................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 2
2.1 History of Building .............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 3
2.2 Timeline Chronology .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 4
3.0 SITE LOCATION .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 6
3.1 Plan of Central Market Kuala Lumpur................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 6
4.0 MEASURED DRAWING ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 8
4.1 Ground Floor Plan ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 8
4.2 Mezzanine Floor Plan .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 9
4.3 Front Elevation .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 10
4.4 Rear Elevation ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 11
4.5 Right Elevation .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 12
4.6 Left Elevation .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 13
4.7 Roof Plan ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 14
5.0 TOPOGRAPHY ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 15
6.0 WEATHER CONDITION AND TEMPERATURE ........................................................................................................................................................................................................... 18
7.0 SUN AND WIND ORIENTATION .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 19
7.1 Definition of Sun Orientation ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 19
7.2 Definition of Wind Orientation ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 19
8.0 VEGETATION ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 21
8.1 Definition of Landscape .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 21
8.2 Definition of Open Space or Green Space ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 22
8.3 List of Vegetation .............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 23
9.0 ACCESS ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 26
9.1 List of Name Road ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 28
10.0 ADJACENT BUILDING AND BOUNDARIES ................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 30
10.1 List of Adjacent Building .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 30
10.2 Boundaries ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 32
11.0 EXISTING/ PUBLIC UTILITIES AND FACILITIES ....................................................................................................................................................................................................... 35
11.1 List of Public Utilities and Facilities ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 35
11.2 Advantages of Public Utility/ Facility at Central Market ................................................................................................................................................................................................. 38
12.0 BUILDING ANALYSIS (BEFRORE AND AFTER REFURBISHMENT) ...................................................................................................................................................................... 40
12.1 DRAWING PLAN ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 40
12.1.1 Ground Floor Plan .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 40
12.1.2 Mezzanine Floor Plan..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 41
12.1.3 Roof Plan ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 42
12.1.4 Front Elevation ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 44
12.1.5 Rear Elevation ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 46
12.1.6 Right Elevation ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 48
12.1.7 Left Elevation ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 50
12.2 BUILDING SERVICES .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 52
12.2.1 Advantage of Building Services for the Central Market ............................................................................................................................................................................................... 57
12.3 DESIGN AND ARCHITECTURE ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 58
12.4 BUILDING ELEMENT AND MATERIALS .................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 61
12.5 BUILDING CONDITION SURVEY ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 63
12.5.1 Defect Sheet ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 65
12.5.2 Defect Analysis .............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 68
12.5.3 Building Condition Assessment ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 68
13.0 LOCAL AUTHORITIES REQUIREMENTS/ ACTS/ REGULATION ............................................................................................................................................................................. 69
13.1 Antiquities Act 1976 ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 69
13.2 National Heritage Act of 2005 .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 69
13.3 Local Government Act of 1976 ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 70
13.4 Town and Country Planning Act 1976.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 70
14.0 SWOT ANALYSIS ON BUILDING REFURBISHMENT (STRENGHT, WEAKNESS, OPPURTUNITIES, THREAT) ............................................................................................. 71
15.0 CONCLUSION .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 72
16.0 REFERENCES ..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 73
CENTRAL MARKET,
KUALA LUMPUR
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Refurbishment is the process of improvement by cleaning, decorating, and re-equipping. It may also include elements of retrofitting to make a building more energy-efficient
and sustainable. As a broad term, refurbishment is often used interchangeably with renovation or restoration (which is to do with restoring a building to its former condition).
In general, refurbishment can encompass such works as 'cosmetic' renovations (such as painting and decorating), upgrading, major repair work, alterations, conversions,
extensions, and modernizations. The lifecycle of a building can be significantly extended by significant refurbishment. As every structure is unique, structurally, technically,
and typologically, and in a local context, the correct approach to refurbishment should be assessed according to the particular conditions. Designers should seek to
understand existing buildings' actual uses and communicate with diverse stakeholders from the initial project phase to the refurbishment. For this task, students are required
to identify the refurbishment work that has been done to the existing building. So we have chosen the Central Market Kuala Lumpur as the case study.
1
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
TITLE DESCRIPTION
BUILDING NAME Central Market, Kuala Lumpur
Before: Open Wet Market
FUNCTION
After: Culture, Arts and Handicraft Centre
Jalan Hang Kasturi, 50050 Kuala Lumpur
LOCATION
(Situated at the town center, within walking distance)
The Central Market Kuala Lumpur is located at Jalan Tun Tan Cheng Lock (Foch Avenue) and the pedestrian-only section of Jalan Hang Kasturi (Rodger Street), a few
minutes away from Petaling Street. It was founded in 1888 and was initially used as a wet market, while the current Art Deco style building was completed in 1937. It has
been classified as a Heritage Site by the Malaysian Heritage Society, and it is now a landmark for Malaysian culture and heritage.
2
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
The original building was built in 1888 by the British in colonial British Malaya. It was used as a wet market for Kuala Lumpur citizens and tin miners. The Wet Market was
very convenient to the early city dwellers because it was within the Klang bus stand, the hub of feeder bus service for Kuala Lumpur, and the train station.
Further expansions were made in 1889, 1895, 1920, and 1921. By 1933, the warehouse's developments made the market now in its present size and cost around $167,000.
As Kuala Lumpur experienced its development rapidly in the 1970s, there were plans to demolish the site. The intervention of the Malaysian Heritage Society proved timely
as they successfully petitioned against its deconstruction, and the area was declared as a 'Heritage Site.'
During the construction of Dayabumi near Klang River banks in 1981, the market was saved from demolition. In 1985, the market was renovated into a vibrant and colourful
new style and had been officially known as Pasar Budaya since April 1986.
The Central Market Annexe, located at the back of the main building, formerly housed a cineplex and was opened in 2006. The Annexe houses a variety of eclectic art
galleries. It is one of the central art spaces in Kuala Lumpur and is a hub of activity all year long, which features artworks by local artists.
Located alongside the main building is the newly transformed, pedestrianized, and covered walkway, Kasturi Walk. Opened in 2011, Kasturi Walk boasts an alfresco
ambience featuring an exciting variety of stalls selling tantalizing local snacks and exquisite souvenirs. The street is noted for housing street musicians or "buskers."
3
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
This time chart shows how the Central Market Kuala Lumpur is transforming from the wet market 'Pasar Basah' into a cultural and art and handicraft center in Malaysia.
Based on the time flow, Central Market is built in 1888 by the British. In 1888, it became a 'Wet Market,' and the building was made from wood. From 1889 until 1933, the
market has become more extensive, and the structure of the whole building is changed into concrete. In late 1970 the Malaysian government has classified the market as
a Heritage building. In 1981, the Central Market was faced with demolition due to the expansion of the Dayabumi Complex located across from the Central Market. Still, it
has fortunately been safe from being demolished. In 1985, the Central Market was renovated into a new colourful style. In 1986, the Central Market was rebrand into Pasar
Budaya until now. In 2004, Central Market Sdn. Bhd is the responsible company that manages the 'Pasar Budaya' until now.
4
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Latest - 2018
The timeline above shows the differences in building structure from1888 until 2018 about the Central Market Kuala Lumpur. The whole of the property structure is started
construct using wood. But after the refurbishment work and renovation, the whole design of the property is used concrete, and the roof of the Central Market is now changed
from a Pitch roof into a Flat roof. They're also a refurbishment work that occurs on the finished used. For example, the paint on the wall now becomes more colourful and
attractive.
5
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
KEY PLAN
Kuala Lumpur
Figure 2.1
LOCATION PLAN
Figure 2.2
Based on figure 2.1 and 2.2, Central Market is located in Kuala Lumpur city. The hotspot places in Malaysia due to the property's strategic location near public transportation,
etc. This one of the advantages that will make the Central Market more popular.
6
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
SITE PLAN
Figure 2.3
Based on figure 2.3, the maps show the proposed location of the Central Market. The Central Market Kuala Lumpur is located in front of the Klang River and near the
Jalan Hang Kasturi. This Central Market is very strategic because it is also near specific transportation areas and accommodation such as hotels, restaurants, banks, LRT,
Public Bus, etc.
7
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
8
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
9
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
10
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
11
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
12
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
13
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
14
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
5.0 TOPOGRAPHY
Study of the shape and features of land surfaces. The topography of an area could refer to the surface shapes and features themselves or a description. Several types of
topography, ranging from a ridge to a valley, are used. Topography, in a narrow sense, involves recording relief or terrain, the three-dimensional quality of the surface, and
the identification of specific landforms. An objective of topography is to determine the position of any feature or, more generally, any point in terms of both a horizontal
coordinate system such as latitude, longitude, and altitude. Identifying components and recognizing typical landform patterns are also part of the field.
Topographic maps show the contours and any significant streams or other water bodies, forest cover, built-up areas or individual buildings, and other features and points
of interest. Their relief in the topographic map is called contour lines.
Relief and contour line connecting points of equal elevation. By reading contours, students interpret height, slope, and shape in topographic maps. If outlines are close
together, the slope is steep. But when contours are spread apart, the pitch is more gradual.
15
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
The history of Kuala Lumpur began in the middle of the 19th century with the tin mining industry's rise. In English, the name Kuala Lumpur means "muddy confluence." So
there is no doubt why Kuala Lumpur's geography is uneven because of the effect of massive mining of tin in the land of Kuala Lumpur. To read the topography map, we
must identify the uses of each colour. Firstly the colour brown denotes most contour lines on a map, which are relief features and elevations. Topographic maps use
green to mean vegetation such as woods, while blue represents water features like lakes, swamps, rivers, and drainage. In each of these cases, contour lines are also
drawn in blue. Finally, black is used to represent human-made objects, including trails. Red is used for human-made features, like main roads or political boundaries, and
purple for new changes or updates on the map that weren't previously represented. As we can see from the chart above, the green colour and blue color are the most.
16
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Based on online research, due to the typical situation, COVID-19 that hits Malaysia, Central Market Kuala Lumpur is nearer with bank river, so-called Klang River might
cause flash flood as the market is located at the low-altitude area.
17
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Month January February March April May June July August September October November December
Avg. Temperature
26.5 27.2 27.5 27.7 27.7 27.4 27 27.4 26.8 26.9 26.7 26.5
(°C)
Min. Temperature
21.7 22 22.2 22.8 23 22.6 22.1 22.9 22.1 22.3 22.3 21.9
(°C)
Max. Temperature
31.4 32.4 32.8 32.6 32.4 32.3 31.9 31.9 31.6 31.5 31.2 31.2
(°C)
Avg. Temperature
79.7 81.0 81.5 81.9 81.9 81.3 80.6 81.3 80.2 80.4 80.1 79.7
(°F)
Min. Temperature
71.1 71.6 72.0 73.0 73.4 72.7 71.8 73.2 71.8 72.1 72.1 71.4
(°F)
Max. Temperature
88.5 90.3 91.0 90.7 90.3 90.1 89.4 89.4 88.9 88.7 88.2 88.2
(°F)
Precipitation /
166 158 238 277 221 136 129 160 196 276 286 243
Rainfall (mm)
Table 1.1: Average Temperature and Precipitation in Kuala Lumpur City in 2019
The variation in the precipitation between the driest and wettest months is 157 mm. The variation in temperatures throughout the year is 1.2 °C. the weather is
highest on average in April, at about 27°C, while the lowest temperature on average in January is around 26.5°C.
18
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Sun path, sometimes also called day arc, refers to the daily and seasonal arc-like direction that the Sun appears to follow across the sky as
the Earth rotates and orbits the Sun. The Sun's path affects the length of daytime experienced and the amount of daylight received along a certain latitude during a
given season. The relative position of the Sun is a significant factor in the heat gain of buildings and the performance of solar energy systems.[1] Accurate location-
specific knowledge of sun path and climatic conditions is essential for economic decisions about solar collector area, orientation, landscaping, summer shading, and
the cost-effective use of solar trackers.
Wind direction is reported by the law from which it originates. For example, north or northerly wind blows from the north to the south.[1] Wind direction is usually
reported in cardinal (or compass) approach, or degrees. Consequently, a wind blowing from the north has a wind direction referred to as 0° (360°); a wind blowing
from the east has a wind direction referred to as 90°, etc. Weather forecasts typically give the direction of the wind along with its speed. For example, a "northerly
wind at 15 km/h" is a wind blowing from the north at a rate of 15 km/h.
19
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
MID-DAY
SUNSET
SUNRISE
Sun path refers to the daily and seasonal arc-like direction that the Sun appears to follow across the sky as the Earth rotates and orbits the Sun. At Central Market, the
Sun rises at the east from the building, which is, and when Sunset, the Sun will be at the west of the Central Market, which is. For the wind direction, the wind is from the
east of the Central Market from Indonesia. So there will be certain months that the weather in Kuala Lumpur will become low and cold because that place will be raining
for several days. Unfortunately, if it is continuously raining, it is possible to be flashflood in the surrounding area of Kuala Lumpur, especially the Central Market. It is
because the Central Market is near to the river.
20
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
8.0 VEGETATION
LANDSCAPE
A landscape is the visible features of an area of land, its landforms, and how they integrate with natural or man-made features. A landscape includes the physical elements
of geophysical defined landforms such as (ice-capped) mountains, hills, water bodies such as rivers, lakes, ponds and the sea, living elements of land cover including
indigenous vegetation, human elements including different forms of land use, buildings, and structures, and transitory elements such as lighting and weather conditions.
Combining both their physical origins and the cultural overlay of human presence, often created over millennia, landscapes reflect a living synthesis of people and place
that is vital to local and national identity.
The character of a landscape helps define the self-image of the people who inhabit it and a sense of place that differentiates one region from other regions. It is the dynamic
backdrop to people's lives. Landscape can be as varied as farmland, a landscape park or wilderness. The Earth has a vast range of landscapes, including the icy landscapes
of polar regions, mountainous landscapes, vast arid desert landscapes, islands, and coastal landscapes, densely forested or wooded landscapes including past boreal
forests and tropical rainforests, and agricultural landscapes of temperate and tropical regions. The activity of modifying the visible features of an area of land is referred to
as landscaping.
There are two main components in landscape design. These two parts are Softscape and Hardscape. Hardscape are design elements that are solid and unchanging as
the years go by. Softscape are elements that are fluid and changing as they mature. The ideal landscape is a balance of both hardscape and softscape.
Hardscape refers to the solid, hard elements in landscape design that stay the same for years. Some examples of hardscape are rocks, walkways, retaining walls, paver
patios, outdoor kitchens, water features, decks and driveways.
Softscape is unlike hardscaping in that it doesn’t have that long-term or permanent quality. It is the living animated part of a landscape. Softscape comprises the other
elements such as soil, plants, shrubs, trees, flowers, vegetables, vines, turf and colour schemes.
21
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Open space is any open piece of land that is undeveloped (has no buildings or other built structures) and is accessible to the public. Open space can include:
• Green space (land that is partly or completely covered with grass, trees, shrubs, or other vegetation). Green space includes parks, community gardens, and
cemeteries.
• Schoolyards, Playgrounds, Public seating areas, Public plazas, Vacant lots
• Open space provides recreational areas for residents and helps to enhance the beauty and environmental quality of neighbourhoods. But with this broad range of
recreational sites comes an equally broad range of environmental issues. Just as in any other land uses, the way parks are managed can have good or bad
environmental impacts, from pesticide runoff, siltation from overused hiking and logging trails, and destruction of habitat.
• Lack of community and public access to safe open and green space is a critical area of concern for urban residents in New England.
SITE VEGETATION
When designing an energy-efficient building, a clear understanding of the building site's environmental factors is needed. These factors will differ from summer to winter.
The fall and spring are similar and provide the third climate season. The design should incorporate those positive elements the environment offers and protect against
those detrimental to comfort. Vegetation is one of the greatest assets of the site for a natural, energy-efficient design. Not only is the existing vegetation useful, but it can
be added to, transplanted, or eliminated. Even though it might take time to mature, the landscape is reasonably flexible. Selective planting, in terms of growth rates, can
reduce the time element. Vegetation reduces the temperature while protecting against glare, dust, and erosion. Care should be taken to avoid placement where roots can
damage the foundation and clog drainage lines, where leaves can block gutters and trap moisture. A desirable air movement can be drastically reduced or directed the
wrong way. At the Central Market Kuala Lumpur, there are several types of vegetation located in the area. For example, Neat and Palm Tree, and Nitida Tree.
22
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
SCIENTIFIC ANALYSIS
NO COMMON NAME PHOTO ORIGIN
NAME (DESCRIPTION)
23
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
SCIENTIFIC ANALYSIS
NO COMMON NAME PHOTO ORIGIN
NAME (DESCRIPTION)
24
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Central Market
Figure 7.5: Vegetation at Central Market
Palma Tree located at the Edge
of the Central Market
25
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
9.0 ACCESS
The figures show the site access to the site location. There are three ways to access the site location: Jalan Petaling, Jalan Hang Kasturi, Jalan Tun Tan Siew Sin, and
Jalan Benteng.
26
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Leboh Pasar
Besar
Jalan Benteng
Jalan Hang
Jalan Petaling Kasturi
27
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
28
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Figure 8.5
Figure 8.6
Table 3.2: Name of Roads
29
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
The adjacent buildings at the Central Market's surroundings have been a hotspot by the locals and tourists. This is because this area was a strategic place to go for a
vacay. For example, Avenue J, Illusion 3D Art Museum, Ar-Rahnu Agrobank, and Dayabumi Complex is located near the Central Market. These places have always been
full by the locals for their purposes, such as shopping, banking, site visit, vacation, and more.
1. AVENUE J
This is a hotel near the Central Market. This place provides Avenue J hotel Located 300 m from Dataran
the tourist and local with a resting area: the bedroom, toilet, Merdeka, centrally located in Kuala Lumpur,
café, etc. within a 5-minute walk of Merdeka Square
and Jamek Mosque. it was located at No
13, Leboh Pasar Besar, City Centre, 50050
Kuala Lumpur, Wilayah Persekutuan Kuala
Lumpur
Figure 9.1: Avenue J
2. Dayabumi Complex
The Dayabumi Complex is a significant landmark in Kuala Dayabumi Complex is a 35-storey building
Lumpur, Malaysia. It houses several commercial facilities set along Jalan Sultan Hishamuddin, south
and is one of the earliest skyscrapers in the city. of Merdeka Square. It was located at Kuala
Lumpur City Centre 50050 Kuala Lumpur
Federal Territory of Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
30
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
31
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
10.2 Boundaries
The land boundary belongs to a building, or, where the land abuts a road, railway, canal, or river, the centerline of that road, railway, canal, or river. A relevant boundary
is 'the boundary or notional boundary that one side of the building faces and coincides with, and that is parallel or at an angle of a maximum of 80 degrees to that side of
the building. A national boundary is a boundary presumed to exist between two buildings on the same site. The border defines the extent of the legal limits of ownership
of any parcel of land.
At common law, the rule of 'marks before measurements' prevails in defining a boundary. There is also a presumption at common law that where land is described as
being bounded by a road, ownership extends to the middle of the road unless there is a clearly defined intent to the contrary (which is usually the case).
If the description of a boundary is ambiguous, otherwise uncertain, or in conflict with the occupations, Courts may settle the disputed boundary position. Courts have
established precedents granting priorities of weight where any two or more of the following boundaries features present conflicting evidence in the determination of a proper
boundary position, in order of importance:
32
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
AR-RAHNU AVANUE J
AGROBANK
ILLUSION
3D
MUSEUM
DAYABUMI
COMPLEX
33
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
AVANUE J
DAYABUMI
COMPLEX
AR-RAHNU
AGROBANK
ILLUSION
3D
MUSEUM
Figure 10.2: Map that shows the Adjacent Building and Boundaries
34
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
There are several public utilities have been provided at the Central Market.
35
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
4. Money Changer The best brand of money changer that can find
in Kuala Lumpur nearby Central Market was
offered by money changer Placid Express
which is conveniently located in the Central
Market.
36
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
37
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
The existing public utilities and facilities are essential to the occupant. For example, it can ensure the absence of discrimination. This is because the public utilities provide
uniform services at uniform rates to the users. There is no discrimination between the rich and the poor. The rich do not pay more, and the poor do not get any concessions
in public utility rates.
Furthermore, it will unify control. For example, the power of utilities is directly in the hands of the government. As a result, the command will be useful and specific, as the
government always favours the public interest at large. Finally, it also shows the service motive: Public utilities' primary objective is to offer services to the public and not
make profits. This ensures the provision of maximum benefit to society at the minimum cost.
38
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
LEGEND
NO. FACILITIES
1 ATM
2 Baby Changing Room
3 Information Counter
4 Money Changer
5 Post Box
6 Prayer Room/ Surau
7 Public Parking
6
4
5
1
3
39
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Remark
Blue Line:
Demolish
Red Line:
Renovation
40
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Remark
Blue Line:
Demolish
Red Line:
Renovation
41
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
42
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
43
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
44
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
45
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
46
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
47
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
48
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
49
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
50
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
51
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Building services are the systems installed in buildings to make them comfortable, functional, efficient, and safe.
➢ Energy distribution.
➢ Energy supply (gas, electricity, and renewable sources such as solar, wind, geothermal, and biomass).
➢ Lightning protection.
➢ Refrigeration.
➢ Water, drainage, and plumbing (including sustainable urban drainage systems (SUDS)).
52
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Building services play a central role in contributing to the design of a building, not only in terms of overall strategies and standards to be achieved, but also
in façade engineering, the weights, sizes, and location of significant plant and equipment, the position of vertical service risers, routes for the distribution of
horizontal services, drainage, energy sources, sustainability, and so on. This means that building services design must be integrated into the overall building design from
a very early stage, particularly on complex building projects such as hospitals. While it is usual for a building design team to be led by an architect
on buildings with complex building services requirements, a building services engineer might be appointed as the lead designer.
For this Central Market, several building services have been listed in the table below:
53
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
54
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
55
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
56
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Figure 13.11: Ceiling Mounted Figure 13.12: Pendant Fixture • Operation: 24 – HOURS
• Function:
a) Improve building performance
b) For safety
c) Make space brighter
d) Aesthetic value
It can have positive impacts on the environment for the building and people. Good quality and well-maintained building services are essential because it can also give
tourists positive thoughts about how attractive, safe, unique, comfortable, useful, and convenient public infrastructure and facilities around the central Market building in
Kuala Lumpur. For example, the CCTV system is essential to include it in a building because it can ensure visitors' safety. It also can increase the value and image tourism
of the tourism industry.
57
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Architectural design is a concept that focuses on components or elements of a structure. An architect is generally the one in charge of the architectural design. They
work with space and details to create a coherent and functional layout.
The Art Deco design style of the Central Market building's interior and exterior had a significant relationship with the local technology, climate condition, history, culture,
and beliefs. The main structure of the Central Market is made of reinforced concrete, supported on reinforced concrete piles because this is the most common and steady
material to use. As we have known, Malaysia's climate is hot and humid throughout the years. Therefore, the glass window of Central Market uses glazed blue-green
colored Calorex rolled plate glass, which only allows 20% of the Sun's heat and 60 % of daylight to penetrate. Moreover, the Kasturi Walk running the entire building's
entire length was glazed with the Calorex of a lighter tint. These have been the earliest use of heat-resisting glass to such extent in Malaysia. Besides, the Central Market's
exterior design was also affected by Art Deco Style, which originated from France because this architectural style is widely being used during the 30s and 40s.
Simultaneously, the building was first built in 1930, in which Art Deco is popular in the post-World War II era. Therefore, the Central Market is affected by France's
architectural culture.
58
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Central Market is considered the first energy-efficient building in Kuala Lumpur because it had made fair use of the local climate to create an energy-saving building. It had
used to be new leading building technology for that particular time. From the historical view, Central Market had used to be a wet market in which people gather from
different races, beliefs, and cultures, so it further developed to promote local culture. Therefore, there are Little India, Malay Street, and Straits Chinese, which represent
different cultures in Malaysia. The idea of building the Central Market is to house all the stalls under a shelter so that it will become a center where the citizens and tin
miners can get their daily supplies. It is arranged in a stall concept, representing the traditional Market in Kuala Lumpur since the 1800s. However, what makes this heritage
building so interesting to architectural heritage buff is its Art Deco Architecture. Art Deco, or Deco, is an influential visual arts design style introduced in France during the
1920s. It is said to have begun in 1925 when the International Exposition of Modern Decorative and Industrial Arts was held in France to showcase new applied arts ideas.
Art Deco is an eclectic style that combines traditional craft and ancient architectural motifs with Machine Age imagery and materials. The class is often characterized by
rich colors, bold geometric shapes, and lavish ornamentation. Art Deco gained popularity internationally from the end of the 1920s. He was used extensively for public
works projects during the 1930s, such as railway stations, ocean liners, movie palaces, amusement parks, etc. Historian Bevis Hillier defined Art Deco as "an assertively
modern style...[that] ran to symmetry rather than asymmetry, and the rectilinear rather than the curvilinear; it responded to the demands of the machine and of new
material...[and] the requirements of mass production." Unfortunately, its popularity waned in the early 1940s. According to National Heritage Act 2005(Act 645), building
means a building or groups of separate or connected buildings that, because of their architectural, homogeneity, or place in the landscape, are of the outstanding universal
value of history, art, or science. Each historic building has its unique quality, which must be protected for the use and enjoyment of this and future generation.
One of the unique features of the Central Market is the art deco design. Ancient architectural design is frequently applied in Art Deco. Therefore as we can see, a bold
ziggurat design has been chosen by the architect in many parts of this building, such as its terraced gable on its main entrance and other entrances. In addition to that, its
recessed main hall is said to create the illusion of a passageway to a stage set.
Meanwhile, Art Moderne, also known as Streamline Moderne, was a late design style related to Art Deco, which emerged during the 1930s. This architectural style
emphasized geometric forms, long horizontal lines, and nautical elements typical of later Art Deco details. The subtle horizontal band of pink textured concrete running
across the breadth of Central Market, in which bars or columns of contrasting materials are used to create a sense of line or division. Furthermore, geometric motifs can
be seen from the interlocking rings on each of its entrances.
59
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Concrete flagpoles were a common feature of the Art Deco building. In Central Market, the flagpole remains a purely decorative item, endorsing Art Deco architecture as
architecture of ornament. According to Art Deco motifs, Shanghai plaster, which could be sculpted, was also used in this building to create a stone-liked finish as it is
relatively cheaper than real stone. Besides, the Central Market is also the first energy-efficient building in Kuala Lumpur and probably the earliest building that has used
heat resistance glass to such an extent in Malaya.
Flagpole
Figure 14.3 Malaysia National Flag at the Main Entrance of Central Market
60
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
The building element is a physical part of a building such as a wall, floor, door, window, beam, column, etc. The Central Market Kuala Lumpur building is shown in the
table below.
Column central market. Some new column has been created to support some
and Beam of the original structure, including water tanks. All columns and beams
are made up of concretes after 1986 and made up of timber. The
refurbishment work occurred at mezzanine floor which is adding the
column.
Figure 15.1 Timber Column and Beam Figure 15.2 Concrete Column and Beam
Window of the whole building look better with colourex glass window.
Figure 15.3 Timber Window Figure 15.4 Window with Colourex Tinted
Glass
Table 7.1 The Material Used Before and After Refurbishment Work
61
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Central Market's wall has been entirely made up of timber since the
British government has built the central market building in 1888 until
the construction of a new central market in 1936 where all peripheral
wall is made up of 4 inches brickwork and remained until today.
Wall
However, the shop's division in the cluster is excluded from the
previous statement as the shop's owner have been permitted to
design their shops according to their style and therefore, the shop's
Figure 15.5 Timber Wall Figure 15.6 Brick Wall
wall currently made up of various types of material such as timber,
The first roof for the central market, which is in 1890, is made up of
zinc sheet with pitched roof design, then during extension in 1907, roof
material has changed from zinc sheet to asbestos sheet the re-roofing
process with the same material took place in 1923. In 1936, the whole
Roof building was demolished, and a new central market roof is made up of
concrete with a flat roof design added with a glazed colourex tinted
skylight running along the middle atrium. In 1986, adaptive reuse took
Figure 15.7 Zinc Sheet with Pitch Roof Figure 15.8 Concrete with Flat Roof
place, and a pair of a barrel-vaulted roof made up from the colourex-
Design Design
tinted glass, steel trusses, and the metal sheet has been added on the
top enhance natural lighting, and it remains until today.
Table 7.2 The Material Used Before and After Refurbishment Work
The Central Market use the other material for the refurbishment work to improve the looking of the site. Besides, using this material also makes the cost lower because it
does not change the building's whole part. This refurbishment work also can reduce the time of the renovation of a property. It is somewhat better than changing all the
structure of the building.
62
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
A condition survey is a detailed inspection of a building to establish its maintenance and repair condition at that time. It is done at a level that surveys each building element,
describing it and providing detail of its current state. A condition survey is commonly used as the basis to complete a Planned Maintenance Programme (PMP). A PMP is
a schedule of the maintenance required for each building element, prioritized, with a budgeted cost and timing, year by year. A condition survey provides information for
maintenance work that is needed immediately - all buildings require maintenance to their fabric over time. This survey also indicates when future repairs, maintenance,
decoration, and renewal of each part of the building should be anticipated. A condition survey gives visibility of future maintenance commitments that are likely.
From the observation at Central Market, several defects can be detected. The defects are shown in the table below:
Hairline cracks in tile may result from remote, obscure reasons such as improperly
Floor
cured concrete or flexing underlayments and joists.
63
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Peeling paint significantly lowers the attractiveness of a building. It can turn a beautiful
house into a rotting structure, a clean bathroom into an unsanitary mess. If the peeling
happens on the interior walls or ceiling, it can even cause health issues for the
occupants; falling paint chips can be harmful if they land in your eyes, and breathing
in paint dust can irritate your lungs.
It was impossible if the old building such as Central Market Kuala Lumpur did not have several or outside the building defects. From the observation, there are just several
minor defects in the building element of the building. It peels off paint at the internal building's finishes and a hairline crack at the tile floor. Moreover, this building also
occurred a diagonal crack. If the building's maintenance manager does not take it as a serious job, it can affect the whole of the building's structure.
64
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Possible Causes
Low workmanship
Wear and tear
Figure 16.4: Diagonal Crack at Wall
Unbalanced load (load distribution)
Prognosis
Bad appearance
Dangerous to occupant
Collapse
65
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Possible Causes
Low workmanship
Figure 16.5: Peeling off Paint Wear and tear
Material properties
Prognosis
Bad appearance
66
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Possible Causes
Low workmanship
Wrong installation
Wear and tear
Figure 16.6: Crack at Floor Tile
Unbalanced load (load distribution)
Prognosis
Bad appearance
Dangerous to occupant
67
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
TOTAL MARKS 19
NO OF DEFECTS 3
TOTAL SCORE 6.33
OVERALL BUILDING RATING FAIR
Table 8.6: BCA Analysis
Based on the BCA, Central Market Kuala Lumpur is suitable to be called the shelter, safe to be visited, and sustainable enough to enhance the users' comfortability.
Therefore, this building has almost met each standard of the Building Regulation, as stated in Uniform Building By-Law 1984 and CPBS 101. We were referring to defect
sheet no. 003, it is advised to take immediate action to this fair classified defect, which is a crack at floor finishes tile, to ensure its condition does not worsen. For the other
structure of the building, organized in good condition, it is also advised to the person in charge to keep on alert to any of the defects spotted and immediately take the
proper action, such as calling the suitable specialist to settle down the fault. This effort ensures the building condition can be maintained under the right stage in a more
extended period.
68
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
Malaysia is a developing country where new developments are primarily in momentum. This will cause old and historical buildings in Malaysia to demolish or renovated
without proper and adequate guidance. To conserve historical buildings, the government has appointed organizations to form various sectors to implement, monitor,
and supervise the conservation activities. They consist of the Malaysia Heritage Trust- Badan Warisan Malaysia (BWM), the Conservation and Townscape Unit of
Kuala Lumpur City Council (CTU), and the Museum and Antiquity Department of the National Museum (MAD). There are few laws on conservation in Malaysia to
control and supervise Central Market, such as the Antiquities Act 1976, the National Heritage Act 2005, Local Government Act 1976, and Town and Country Planning
Act 1976.
(a) Any moveable object which is or is reasonably believed to be at least fifty years old
(b) Any part of any such item which has at any later date been added or re-constructed or restored
(c) Any human, plant, or animal remains, or is reasonably believed to be at least one hundred years old.
69
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
From this act, the Minister shall be responsible for providing or issuing policies, statements, or directives regarding any matter, business, strategy, or conduct
on the conservation and preservation of heritage. The functions of the Commissioners stated in this act are:
1. To determine the designation of sites, registration of objects and underwater cultural heritage;
2. To supervise and oversee the conservation, preservation, restoration, maintenance, promotion, exhibition, and accessibility of heritage;
3. To advise and coordinate with the local planning authority, the Council, and other bodies and entities at all levels to safeguard, promote, and dealing with
any heritage;
4. To advise the Minister concerning any matter in respect of conservation and preservation of heritage.
70
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
STRENGTH WEAKNESSES
OPPORTUNITY THREATS
From the observation, Central Market Kuala Lumpur is located at a strategic location. This is because it is situated at hotspot places near Petaling street and Kasturi
road. Besides that, the site also has a beautiful environment and providing fresh air. It even is a landmark to identify the places, and it also can be a tourism hotspot.
But this Central Market also has some weakness which is limited parking. So it will make the locals and tourists need to walk far away. Besides that, this Central
Market also lacks maintenance in specific areas, making it look more dangerous to people and making it look not nice. Despite this weakness, this front lake also
has the opportunity to realize back lane site potential, which can allow the locals to open a new business. Moreover, this site also can be a social center due to the
environment. Unfortunately, some threats that will affect the central market will also be exposed to the accident because of the site location. Then it will be increasing
the crime rate due to the location of the central market. Last but not least, this lake is also exposed to the noises of the factory and lorries.
71
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
15.0 CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the Refurbishment process is one of the most challenging tasks faced by designers. The refurbishment design is restricted by the building's existing
condition, which makes the job more complex and tedious. The spectrum of threats is ever-changing, so that the risk analysis for each building might be unique and
changing. Structures also evolve through aging, wear and tear of use, and climate effects. Human factors and concepts of operations have to be considered, as well.
This refurbishment work is the last choice for a property to maintain its structure. This refurbishment has many advantages when it applies to a building or construction.
For example, it helps to improve the quality of the building structure. After that, this refurbishment work also helps to shorten the period to maintain the design. Finally,
this refurbishment work is vital for an old building that will transform into a new function. This is because refurbishment work will make the building look more safe
and pleasant for the occupant to be in there.
72
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
16.0 REFERENCES
II. (2019, July 09). Central Market - life after 131 year. Retrieved October 20, 2020, from
https://themalaysianreserve.com/2019/07/08/central-market-life-after-131-year/
III. 10+ Ficus nitida Tree ideas: Ficus nitida, ficus, tree. (2014, June 15). Retrieved November 02, 2020, from
https://www.pinterest.com/asamir2070/ficus-nitida-tree/
IV. REGULATION FOR INTERNAL RENOVATION WORK - Villa Flora Management Corporation,Taman Tun Dr Ismail, 60000 Kuala Lumpur. (n.d.). Retrieved
November 03, 2020, from
https://sites.google.com/site/villafloraowners/house-rules/4-regulation-for-internal-renovation-work
V. Alias, A. (1970, January 01). [PDF] Building Condition Survey and Assessment Report:The Useand Benefits in Sub-Sale Housing Property Valution:
Semantic Scholar. Retrieved October 24, 2020, from
https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Building-Condition-Survey-and-Assessment-Report:The-
Alias/79f5853a450178fc9015af77c5de7b807a43227b?p2df
VI. Arecaceae. (2020, October 18). Retrieved October 16, 2020, from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arecaceae
73
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
VIII. Central Market Kuala Lumpur - Kuala Lumpur Attractions. (n.d.). Retrieved October 20, 2020, from
http://www.kuala-lumpur.ws/attractions/central-market.htm
IX. Central Market, Kuala Lumpur. (2020, April 07). Retrieved October 18, 2020, from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Market,_Kuala_Lumpur
XI. Douglasloon Follow. (2016, December 12). Mapping the Townscape (Petaling Street & Central Market) Presentation... Retrieved October 21, 2020, from
https://www.slideshare.net/douglasloon/mapping-the-townscape-petaling-street-central-market-presentation-slides
XII. Eng, M., & Markeng.shang. (n.d.). Architecture Design Project - Final Report. Retrieved October 22, 2020, from
https://issuu.com/markeng.shang/docs/170724adpreport
XIII. Full Report Final CENTRAL MARKET CONSERVATION STUDY. (n.d.). Retrieved October 28, 2020, from
https://www.scribd.com/doc/11956876/Full-Report-Final-CENTRAL-MARKET-CONSERVATION-STUDY
74
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
XIV. How to Do a SWOT Analysis for Your Small Business (with Examples). (n.d.). Retrieved November 04, 2020, from
https://www.wordstream.com/blog/ws/2017/12/20/swot-analysis
XV. Joanne Yunn Tze Follow. (2015, July 06). Building Services Report. Retrieved October 24, 2020, from
https://www.slideshare.net/Joann931/building-services-50214458
XVI. Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia Today, Tonight & Tomorrow's Weather Forecast. (n.d.). Retrieved October 27, 2020, from
https://www.accuweather.com/en/my/kuala-lumpur/233776/weather-forecast/233776
XVII. Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia - Sunrise, Sunset, dawn and dusk times for the whole year. (n.d.). Retrieved November 02, 2020, from
https://www.gaisma.com/en/location/kuala-lumpur.html
XVIII. Ong93 Follow. (2019, July 12). SITE ANALYSIS REPORT. Retrieved October 23, 2020, from
https://www.slideshare.net/ong93/site-analysis-report-155133325
XX. Refurbishment and its advantages. (n.d.). Retrieved November 04, 2020, from
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/construction/refurbishment-and-its-advantages.php
75
BSR 303 - BUILDING REFURBISHMENT AND ADAPTION
XXII. Sun direction in Malaysia -- Sun Direction. (n.d.). Retrieved October 29, 2020, from
http://sun-direction.com/country/malaysia/
XXIII. The Mind Tools Content Team By the Mind Tools Content Team, Team, T., Wrote, B., Wrote, J., & Wrote, M. (n.d.). SWOT Analysis: – How to Develop a
Strategy For Success. Retrieved November 04, 2020, from
https://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newTMC_05.htm
XXIV. VideoCopilot.net. (n.d.). VIDEO COPILOT: After Effects Tutorials, Plug-ins and Stock Footage for Post Production Professionals. Retrieved November 02,
2020, from
https://www.videocopilot.net/docs/element/texturing_and_materials/building_materials_in_element_3d/
76