900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Issuer: Contractor Comment Sheet ID.: F08643S-Z0205-01 Issued on: 25.12.2020

Contactor: hanlei@china-hei.com Stage: Detail Design Completion Date: 27.12.2020

Reviewer KE Document Control TEG Document Control NESPAK Document Control RE2 Document Control
Contact: ...............@ke.com.pk piotr.sputo@tractebel.engie.com haseeb.saqib@nespak.com.pk ke.design@renewableresources.com.pk

Drawing/Document ID: F08643S-Z0205-01

Drawing/Document Title: RAIN WATER DRAINAGE TRENCH LAYOUT (1)

The Categories of Approval: 1 = Approved, no comments / reviewed

Cat:
Besides the information discussed in the following, it is assumed that
2 = Approved with comments / reviewed as noted
subjects and the document itself are at least in accordance with the
Contract specification. Approval or comment will not relieve the 3 = Not approved, rejected / returned for correction
Contractor from fulfilling his contractual obligations. 4 = For information only

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
Hydraulic Calculation and Sketch Drawing Comments.

1. 0 NES NIL For G5 point in Hydraulic Statement, the considered HEI will update the calculation. All parties agreed.
freeboard is less than 0.20. Please check and correct the
depth of flow.

2. 0 NES NIL The surface runoff from the area of 0.39 Ha near the Raw HEI will increase the width of All parties agreed.
water Pumps & basin has not been included in hydraulic drain for B4 to 1.9 m and from
Statement. HEI to check and include the surface drain B9 to B12 to 2.1m, considering
upstream of point B2. the missing areas of 0.39 Ha &
0.5 Ha.

Moreover, the surface runoff from the road and adjacent

area (0.5 Ha) connecting south side to north side i.e.
between B2 to B5 points has not been considered in the

Page 1 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
hydraulic Statement. Please check.

3. 0 NES NIL Considering the aforesaid missing areas and very little HEI will increase the width of All parties agreed.
margin in sizing for B4 and B9, the capacity of drain will drain for B4 to 1.9 m and from
become undersize after incorporation of additional runoff. B9 to B12 to 2.1m, considering
the missing areas of 0.39 Ha &
HEI are advised to recheck the hydraulic statement and
0.5 Ha.
revise the sections accordingly. (Point B4 may be
widened to 1.9 m similar to B3 and B9 may also be
suitably adjusted)

4. 0 NES NIL The adopted value of Rainfall intensity does not conform As per the management Group All parties agreed.
to DDRM conclusion for rainfall hydraulic Calculation meeting dated Dec XX, 2020, it
dated November 17, 2020. has been concluded that the
rainfall intensity shall be
As per conclusion the 17 mm per ten minute rainfall
considered as 10 mm per 10
intensity needs to be provided.
minute.
Please check and update the drain sizing calculation
Accordingly, the design has
accordingly.
been finalised.
Layout Drawing

5. 0 KE NILL It shall be ascertained by the designer that the width, HEI confirm to coordinate the All parties agreed.
depth and slope of the trenches shall be consistent with civil detail (size, depth etc. ) of
the designed sections in submitted calculation sheet. Rainwater drain with approved
hydraulic Statement.

6. 0 KE NILL The coordinates and the grading plan shall be verified by HEI confirm. All parties agreed.
the General Layout Engineer.

7. 0 KE NILL The trench I1-I2 marked in the calculation sheet is not I1-I2 will not provide due to Open: To be clarified
present. It shall be ensured that the approved layout and space limitation. Also this road regarding design of fence
sections are produced as Z0205. is single slope and towards on road side.
south automaticly to the BQPS
Page 2 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
1 rain water trench. Fence may obstruct the
flow of water.
Meeting Conclusion (21-4-
2021):
KE /OE highlighted that the
existing trench will get
obstructed by walkway and
water cannot drain
smoothly. HEI agreed to
provide small grooves in
existing walkways as per
site condition. Note shall
be marked in Drawing
accordingly.

8. 0 NES NIL The road centre line elevations, top of HEI will submit in later stage, Open:
kerbstone/walkway, adjacent ground elevation (to road) now this drawing is under
incorporated in the most areas of layout drawing does not design.
match with the Levels marked on Sketch drawing for It is highly advised that HEI
calculations. Please check and reconfirm. shall submit the Grading
Plan at the earliest.
In such non-conformity, the correlation between
calculations & rainwater drain layout and levels cannot be
confirmed.
Status on 27-12-2020:
As agreed in Meeting on
17-12-2020, HEI to submit
the grading plan in two
weeks. Please expedite the
submission. The details will
be finalised after DDRM
Discussions and
Page 3 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
submission of Grading
Plan.
Meeting Conclusion 21-04-
2021:
Based on discussions of
Grading Plan drawing, HEI
will first update the Grading
Plan and then plot the rain
water drain on latest
version of Grading
Drawing.
HEI will submit the Garding
Plan and Rainwater Drain
layout drawing on 28-04-
2021.

9. 0 NES NIL Please incorporate the locations of walkway provided HEI will incorporate the typical Open: Not incorporated.
along road in layout drawing, so that the grading, location details of walkways, road and
Meeting Conclusion 21-04-
of drain and finished elevations of road centreline and drain at different sections in
2021:
kerbstone is reviewed and finalised accordingly. updated drawings.
Based on discussions of
Grading Plan drawing, HEI
will first update the Grading
Plan and then plot the rain
water drain on latest
version of Grading
Drawing.
One point related to top
level of walkway (Sleeve
Page 4 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
underneath or gravel on
one side) is open in
grading plan drawing, HEI
to discuss and close it
before submission of
Grading Plan.
HEI will submit the Garding
Plan and Rainwater Drain
layout drawing on 28-04-
2021.

10. 0 NES NIL HEI are advised to submit the Grading Plan drawing of HEI will submit in later stage, Open:
Whole Plant area in parallel to Rain water Trench now this drawing is under
It is highly advised that HEI
submission. design.
shall submit the Grading
The adequacy of inverts and flow patterns for rain water Plan at the earliest.
drain cannot be verified without the Grading Plan.

Status on 27-12-2020:
As agreed in Meetinon 17-
12-2020, HEI to submit the
grading plan in two weeks.
Please expedite the
submission. The details will
be finalised after DDRM
Discussions and
submission of Grading
Plan.
Meeting Conclusion 21-04-
2021:
Page 5 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
Based on discussions of
Grading Plan drawing, HEI
will first update the Grading
Plan and then plot the rain
water drain on latest
version of Grading
Drawing.
HEI will submit the Garding
Plan and Rainwater Drain
layout drawing on 28-04-
2021.

11. 0 NES NIL For main drain Section A-A to D-D, as already confirmed HEI will add the details in All parties agreed.
during DDRM Discussions, HEI will consider the updated Drawing.
expander (transition) of channel (upstream of all
connection points i.e. B2, B3 etc.) conforming to hydraulic
sizing requirements.
Please incorporate the details of transition length and
slopes for expansion zone both in terms of depth & width
on the drawing.

12. 0 NES NIL We understand that the provision of fence in GIS Outside Also this floor slope is towards All parties agreed.
facility area (west side) will not obstruct the surface flow west and rain water can drain
of rainwater into the provided drain. directly to the rain water trench.
It is advisable that small catch pits within the fenced area

Page 6 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
are provided and connected to the rain water drain.

13. 0 NES NIL HEI to confirm and check that the Grading of whole plant HEI will submit in later stage, As agreed in Meeting on
area is suitable and adequate to effectively drain off all now this drawing is under 17-12-2020, HEI to submit
the rainwater in to the provided drains. design. HEI confirm that there the grading plan in two
will be not accumulate in the weeks. Please expedite the
It shall be ensured that there will be no low laying areas
power plant. submission. The details will
and storm water will not accumulate in any area of the
be finalised after DDRM
Power Plant.
Discussions and
submission of Grading
Plan.
Meeting Conclusion 21-04-
2021:
Based on discussions of
Grading Plan drawing, HEI
will first update the Grading
Plan and then plot the rain
water drain on latest
version of Grading
Drawing.
HEI will submit the Garding
Plan and Rainwater Drain
layout drawing on 28-04-
2021.

14. 0 NES NIL Layout and details of road to be provided in south side of This will be discussed in later Meeting Conclusion 21-04-
GIS and connecting to outdoor area in Southwest of GIS stage. As per detailed design, 2021:
building is missing. there is less space to provide
Open. Point will be closed
this road. The width need to
Page 7 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
Please refer to discussions during the Outdoor Tunnel discuss also. after resolution of road
from GIS to BQPS-I drawing approval, a new road has layout point.
been added in this area. HEI to check and provide detail
of road, kerbstones and rainwater drain in that area.

15. 0 NES NIL Please check the location of rainwater drain (63.44 m This is locate at the edge of All parties agreed.
length) provided in north side of Admin Building. The road. This road is 4m, the
drain is provided in the middle of road. Please check and trench is 0.3m far from the road
clarify. egde.

16. 0 NES NIL Layout and details of Drain I1 to I2, designated as per L1-L2 will not provide due to Open: To be clarified
Hydraulic calculations is missing. Please check. space limitation. Also this road regarding design of fence
is single slope and towards on road side.
south automaticly to the BQPS
Fence may obstruct the
1 rain water trench.
flow of water.
Meeting Conclusion (21-4-
2021):
KE /OE highlighted that the
existing trench will get
obstructed by walkway and
water cannot drain
smoothly. HEI agreed to
provide small grooves in
existing walkways as per
site condition. Note shall
be marked in Drawing
accordingly.

17. 0 NES NIL Entry of A14 into B1 shall be bell mouth/wing wall HEI agreed to provide the bell Noted. However, the detail
arrangement. mouth arrangement (50 mm for connection of minor
each side and 0.5 meter and major trecnhes of
approaching length) for all internal network is not

Page 8 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
the connecting drains. added.
Meeting Conclusion (21-4-
2021):
HEI will update the drawing
and resubmit by 28-04-
2021.

18. 0 NES NIL Please confirm that fence around RLNG Area will not Confirmed. Closed.
obstruct the surface drainage of rain water and it will
ultimately discharge into the nearby drains.

19. 0 NES NIL We understand that the future area shall be graded to Confirmed Closed. It shall be finalised
drain the surface runoff as well. after receipt of Grading
Plan.

20. 0 NES NIL At the major interface points such as A8 & A13, it must be HEI agreed to provide smooth Open: Detail not
ensured that the section size is increased prior to transition for all major trench incorporated
connection of branch line with the main line. interfaces similar to point # 17
Meeting Conclusion (21-4-
above.
2021):
HEI will update the drawing
and resubmit by 28-04-
2021.

21. 0 NES NIL Please mention the width (B) of Main Drain (B1 to B12) in HEI will update the drawing. All parties agreed.
layout Plan. At the sections where the width is increased,
the upstream transition length shall also be marked.

Page 9 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
22. 0 NES NIL Please incorporate the inverts/ bottom elevation at HEI will update the drawing. Point B7 shall be upstream
upstream of Section B2, B3, B4 etc. as per hydraulic of connection of branch
Statement. trench.
Meeting Conclusion (21-4-
2021):
The width of 2.0 m is
continued across point B7
same as B, therefore not
need to consider.

23. 0 NES NIL A typical section detail of Walkway, Road & kerbs HEI will incorporate the typical Not incorporated. Section
and rainwater drain running adjacent/parallel to road details of walkways, road and F-F in isolation cannot be
shall be incorporated in the drawing. drain at different sections in approved.
updated drawings.
Submit all typical sections
for review.
Meeting Conclusion (21-
4-2021):
Point will remain open
until the typical
arrangement of road,
walkway & drain is
finalised.

24. All storm water with the potential to be contaminated with Please refer to H0804, All drain Closed as per conclusions
oily waste or spills from Plant equipment or maintenance have been discussed in of Chemical Group.
and storage areas shall be routed through Oil separators Chemical group.
prior to discharge into Storm Water Drainage System.
It is preferable that an oil separator shall be placed as
close as possible to each contamination source to
prevent the oily contaminants emulsifying in the storm
Page 10 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
water. Typical areas requiring collection of contaminated
storm water runoff including but not limited to following
are:

 Oil-filled equipment areas.

 Runoff from parking lot.
 Fuel handling area and other areas vulnerable to
spillage of oil
 Transformer Area etc.

25. It is obvious that an independent layout / drawing of Please refer to H0804, All drain Closed as per conclusions
following drainage system complying with Contractual have been discussed in of Chemical Group.
Requirements shall be submitted for our review and Chemical group.
comment
 Contaminated Storm Water Runoff (Oily water
sewer system)
 Potentially contaminated floor drainage system
from plant, equipment, or maintenance and
storage areas
 Waste Water Drainage System
26. 0 NES NIL The connection point of drainage lines from sump pits This will not show in this Open: Not clear. What
provided in all trenches & tunnel with the Storm water drawing, it will be site route. mean of site route. Shall be
drainage channels is missing. discussed in DDRM
Discussions.
As per Plant drainage scheme, all the water from the
sumps provided inside the outdoor & indoor cable Meeting Conclusion (21-
trenches & tunnel shall be ultimately connected to storm 4-2021):
water drainage system.
HEI will add a note in
drawing regarding the
provision of sleeve for
drainage from sump pits
of tunnel/trench to rain
water drains as per site
Page 11 of 12
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
conditions.

One behalf ofthe Owner On behalf of the Owner’s Engineer On behalf of the Contractor
Name:

Signature
:

Date:

Page 12 of 12