Residential Development at Hosur Project Structural Design Details

PROJECT RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AT HOSUR
CLIENT VIDIYAL RESIDENCY PRIVATE LIMTED

PMC TATA CONSULTING ENGINEERS LIMITED ARCHITECT BHASKAR ARCHITECTS
R0-Structure DBR (Submitted by BA on 18-11-2021),
Document Title R1-DBR submitted on 27-11-2021, Resubmitted R1 DBR submitted on 02-12-2021
R2-DBR submitted on 18-03-2022
BA Compliance / TCE Response/ BA Compliance /

TCE Response on BA Compliance / Clarification
Sl. TCE observations Clarification Comments on R1 Clarification
Description R1 DBR submitted TCE Response/ Comments on dated
No. dated 19-11-2021 dated DBR submitted on dated
on 28-11-2021
27-11-2021 02-12-2021
1 Clause 2- Please mention brief Precast Not incorporated Incorporated Closed

Structural description of building design construction for all
scheme philosophy such as type of residential
framing system and buildings.
foundation system, Conventional
conventional RCC structures can be
/precast/structural steel or done with precast
any other important structural or coventional
feature (including shed, technology.
WTP/STP/UG tanks etc.) in
DBR.
2 For better clarity it is better as given in the Not incorporated Not incorporated.
to add site plan in the DBR architectural
and mark all buildings in the drawings For better clarity it is
scope of work in the site plan better to add site plan
in the DBR and mark Not incorporated. Please add site
all buildings in the plan in DBR and mark all buildings
scope of work in the
site plan
3 Mention the external as given in the Not incorporated Not incorporated.

development works and architectural
indicate the civil works drawings Please indicate the
related to compound wall, external development Incorporated. Closed
storm water drain etc. in the works in DBR.
external development.
4 Clause 4.3 - Since DBR is basis for Based on final Not incorporated Clause 8.1 Concrete:
Concrete design, BOQ and estimate, it design
grade is preferable to mention 1. Please include the
different grades of concrete grade of concrete for
considered for all buildings all other structures
including water retaining including water
structures in the DBR instead retaining structures
of mentionng appropriate other than dormitory.
grades.
3. Please clarify what
is 20 - OPC/OPC
mentioned in table
3. Type of cement Incorporated. Closed

shall be either OPC or
PPC. Please mention
the type of cement
used in project intsead
of mentioning
OPC/PPC
5 Please provide basis of Necessary cover Not clarified Not clarified Not clarified
considering mild exposure for concrete taken
condition for structural care for all
elements above ground level strcutures
6 Please mention the thickness Based on final Not incorporated Incorporated Closed
and grade of PCC below design
foundations
7 Clause 4.5- Please mention buildings All residential Not incorporated Incorporated Closed
Structural which are with precast buildings will be
system - concrete and buildings with done with precast.
Precast conventional concrete. Other commercial
elements buildings and
external strcuture
to be done with
conventional
technology
Clause 4.5- Mention design philosophy The scope of Not incorporated Not incorporated Not incorporated
Structural followed for precast buildings design, fabrication,
system - erection will be
Precast with the precast
elements vendor. The design
philosophy will
cover the relevant
codes for
earthquake, wind
loads and loading
of the buildings as
per usage

on 28-11-2021
27-11-2021 02-12-2021
8 Clause 4.6- Indicate the values of Based on final Not incorporated Incorporated Closed
Stiffness stiffness modifiers considered design and inputs
modifiers for beams, columns and RC from the precast
wall in the DBR vendor
9 Please correct the IS 1893 Not incorporated This clause is removed Closed
clause number as 6.4.3.1 from revised DBR.
instead of 6.3.4.1 Hence not applicable
10 Clause 4.7 - List down all the AS per IS and the Not incorporated 1. Combinations are
Load combinations considered for soil test report not updated as per IS
combinations following. recommendations 875 Part 5, Clause 8.1,
a) For foundation design and Note 3
deflection check (limit state
of serviceability 2. Please clarify the
b) For concrete design load combinations
c) For steel design from S. NO. 21 to 34
and 49 to 53
Load factors in the
combinations shall be 3. Please check and
mentioned clearly by clarify the following
considering IS 875 Part 5, sentence in clause 2.4
Clause 8.1, Note 3. As per Load combinations. Incorporated. Closed
clasue whenever imposed 'Building is situated in
load is combined with zone IV so earthquake
earthquake load, the in vertical direction
appropriate part of imposed shall be considered'.
load shall be considered for
the combined load effects in
combinations.
11 Clause 4.8 - It is mentioned in the DBR Precast structures Not incorporated This clause is removed
Loads - that choice of AAC block or may not need from revised DBR.
a) Dead load brick masonry to be finalised. internal walls, Hence not applicable
This needs to be concluded however,
and actual requirement to be conventioneal
mentioned in DBR. buildings will be
done with the need Closed
of the end user as
described in the
architectural DBR
12 Precast wall panels are to be taken up by Not incorporated Not incorporated

mentioned in Architecture the precast vendor Closed
DBR clause IX. Include the Precast wall panels wil be as per
dead load of precast wall precast design.
panels in structure DBR.
13 Mention the values of MEP Not incorporated Incorporated

service load considered for Closed
analysis.
14 150 mm sunken depth is may vary for IWC Not incorporated Sunken depth is
mentioned in structure DBR. & EWC and hence removed from revised
But 230 mm sunken depth is areas may have DBR. Mention the
mentioned in drawings. 150 or 230 as sunken depth in DBR Please mention the sunken depth in
Please check and update DBR required DBR
15 Mention the screed thickness As per Not incorporated Incorporated

and load for terrace archietctural Closed
waterproofing. detailed design
16 Mention the values of Solar panel loads Not incorporated Only solar panel load
equipment load to be is mentioned in
considered in terrace. revised DBR. Closed
Please clarify whether Only solar panels are located on
any other equiment is terrace.
planned on terrace
17 Mention the capacity and As per Not incorporated Not incorporated Incorporated. Closed
load to be considered for archietctural
water tank in DBR detailed design
18 Clause 4.8 - As per IS: 875 (Part 2) – for residential Not incorporated Incorporated Closed
Loads - 1987, imposed load on purposes 3 KN/m2
b) Imposed balconies shall be 4 kN/m2 may be good
load instead of 3 kN/m2 . Please enough
update in DBR
Clause 4.8 -
Loads -
b) Imposed BA Compliance / TCE Response/ BA Compliance /
Sl. load TCE observations Clarification Comments on R1 Clarification
on 28-11-2021
27-11-2021 02-12-2021
19 Mention the imposed loads of as per IS Not incorporated 1. As per IS: 875 (Part 1. Incorporated. Closed
following rooms. 2) – 1987, imposed
a) Dining room load on dining room 2. Incorporated. Closed
b) Store room and cafeteria shall be 4
c) Electrical room, UPS kN/m2 instead of 3 Two different loads are mentioned
room, battery room, panel kN/m2.Please check for pharmacy. Please check and
room and revise correct.
d) Service room
e) Refuge area 2. Please include
f) Laundry imposed load for
g)Common room service room, refuge
h) Lift machine room area, common room,
lift machine room
20 Mention the imposed loads of as per IS Not incorporated Not incorporated. Incorporated. Closed
following buildings
a) Commercial Complex Please include
b) Maintenance Office imposed load for all
c) Recreation Complex other buildings other
d) Medical Centre dormitory in DBR
e) Pump Room
f) Fire station
21 Clause 4.8 - Mention the formula Not incorporated Incorporated

Loads - considered for time period
c)Earthquake calculation. 1. It was confirmed during EC
load clearance application that the project
site falls under seismic zone-II .
Please change in DBR accordingly.
2. Ductile detailing as per IS: 13920

–2016 is not required for Zone II
strucrues. Please update in DBR
accordignly
2. Reinforcement steel shall be Fe

500 for zone II as considered in
BOQ. Please modify DBR clause
8.2.
22 Mention the type of soil to be Not incorporated Incorporated Closed

considered for analysis in
DBR
23 Clause 4.8 - Mention the values of as per codes Not incorporated Incorporated Closed
Loads - following wind load
Wind load parameters for various
buildings in DBR
a) Basic wind speed

b) k1, k2, k3, k4
c) kd, ka, kc
d) design wind pressure for
each building
24 Surcharge Mention about surcharge based on soil test Not incorporated Not incorporated. Incorporated. Closed
load, earth load, earth pressure, water recommendations Please mention about
pressure and pressure etc. to be considered surcharge load, earth
hydrostatic for design of underground pressure, water
pressure structures in DBR. pressure etc. to be
considered for design
of underground
structures in DBR.
25 Expansion Mention about provision of as required by the Not incorporated Clause 11:
joint expansion joint precast vendor Temperature and
shrinkage effect
1. Please follow the

provisions given in IS
codes as the design of
strucrures are as per IS
standards. As per IS
standards, for 62m
length without
expansion joint, Not incorporated.
thermal analysis is
26 Include expansion joint width required. Expansion joint is indicated in
calculation in the DBR drawing. Please modify DBR clause
2. Expansion joint is accordingly.
indicated in drawing.
Please modify DBR
accordingly.

on 28-11-2021
27-11-2021 02-12-2021
27 Soil Indicate the soil condition, based on soil test Not incorporated Clause 7-Foundation Incorporated. Closed
condition, ground water table, bearing recommendations Indicate the soil
ground water capacity at various founding condition, ground
table and level etc. in DBR. water table, bearing
bearing If soil investigation report is capacity at various
capacity not available, mention the founding level etc. in
assumed values in DBR and DBR.
indicate that final values will If soil investigation
as per soil investigation report is not available,
report mention the assumed
values in DBR and
indicate that final
values will as per soil
investigation report
28 Clear cover Mention the clear cover of precast Not incorporated Incorporated Incorporated. Closed
structural elements such as
foundation, columns, walls,
beams, slabs et. in DBR
29 Structural Mention the properties of as per the design of Not incorporated Not incorporated
steel structural steel works such as the PEB vendor
properties grade of steel, grade of bolts, Please mention the 1. Wind speed is not matching with
connections, weld details, properties of structural clause 2.2. Please check.
painting, grout etc, in DBR steel in DBR Wind speed and other wind
conditions shall be as clause 2.2 in
DBR.
2. The project site falls under

seismic zone-II according to the IS
Seismic Zoning Map. Please change
accordignly.
3. Earthquake load, soil parameters

etc. shall be as clause 2.3 in DBR.
30 Content page Beam column junction is precast vednor Not incorporated Removed from
-Sl No 6 mentioned in content page, design revised. Hence not
Sl. No. 6. But this is not applicable
Closed
covered in the DBR. Please
check.
COMMENTS IN R1-REVISED DBR SUBMITTED ON 02-12-2021

31 Clause 2 Imposed loads are not
Design loads permanent loads.
Imposed loads are
temporary or
changeable loads
acting on a structure.
Or imposed loads are Incorporated. Closed
live loads. Please
modify DBR
32 Clause 2 superimposed loads

Design loads are not live loads.
These are oads that is
in addition to the dead Incorporated. Closed
weight. Please modify
DBR
Please check and

correct the year of all
codes mentioned in the
table.
It is observed latest
year is not mentioned
Design for IS 3370 -Part 1, IS
33 1905, IS 808, IS 1161, Incorporated. Closed
standards
IS 4923, IS 2062, IS
1904, SP 6 etc. in the
table

Residential Development at Hosur Project Structural Design Details

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Residential Development at Hosur Project Structural Design Details

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

PROJECT RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT AT HOSUR

CLIENT VIDIYAL RESIDENCY PRIVATE LIMTED

BA Compliance / TCE Response/ BA Compliance /

1 Clause 2- Please mention brief Precast Not incorporated Incorporated Closed

3 Mention the external as given in the Not incorporated Not incorporated.

3. Type of cement Incorporated. Closed

BA Compliance / TCE Response/ BA Compliance /

12 Precast wall panels are to be taken up by Not incorporated Not incorporated

13 Mention the values of MEP Not incorporated Incorporated

15 Mention the screed thickness As per Not incorporated Incorporated

21 Clause 4.8 - Mention the formula Not incorporated Incorporated

2. Ductile detailing as per IS: 13920

2. Reinforcement steel shall be Fe

22 Mention the type of soil to be Not incorporated Incorporated Closed

a) Basic wind speed

1. Please follow the

BA Compliance / TCE Response/ BA Compliance /

2. The project site falls under

3. Earthquake load, soil parameters

COMMENTS IN R1-REVISED DBR SUBMITTED ON 02-12-2021

32 Clause 2 superimposed loads

Please check and

You might also like