Republic of the Philippines

PROVINCE OF BUKIDNON
Provincial Capitol 8700

Bukidnon Environment and Natural Resources Office

DATE : September 13, 2022

FOR : MS. CECILLE M. EGNAR
PENR Officer

FROM : MR. DENNIS G. DAGOOC

Administrative Aide-III, BENRO

MR. ROGER A. SALUBO

EMS-I, MGM Division Head, BENRO

SUBJECT : TRAVEL ACCOMPLISHMENT REPORT

Field area : Municipal-LGU of Malitbog, Bukidnon
Location : Municipal-LGU of Malitbog, Bukidnon
Name of
Supervisor : Mr. Roger A. Salubo
Monitoring team : ---------------
Date : September 8, 2022
Purpose of
Travel : Urgent: Attend SB-Malitbog session invitation re: Quarry application of Mr. Eddie
Domo

PRELIMINARIES:

This pertains to an invitation letter from SP-Malitbog submitted in the Bukidnon Environment and
Natural Resources Office regarding the quarry application BUKLIK represented by Mr. Eddie Domo.

Please be informed that the undersigned attended the regular session relative to the invitation

ACTIONS/UNDERTAKINGS TAKEN:

 Coordinated with SP-members

FINDINGS AND OBSERVATIONS:

DATE City/Municipality/ Findings/Observations Recommendations Remarks

Barangay
Sept. 8, Municipality of
2022 Malitbog, Bukidnon
 SP-Malitbog  Kagawad Emano raised the  The undersigned  The BENRO
 concern regarding the quarry advised the SP- office should
application of BUKLIK Malitbog to request though its
represented by Eddie Domo; assistance with the technical
 During the discussion it was BENRO technical personnel may
raised by Datu ”Mandublahan” personnel regarding call for a
Noel S. Dagpong that he is the applications related consultative
newly authorized representative to quarry/sand and meeting with
of BUKLIK; gravel; the SP board
 It was found out that their was  The undersigned members
no Special Power of Attorney advised Datu specially the
excuted in behalf of Datu Dagpong to submit chairperson on
Dagpong, only a hand written to the BENRO office Environment
authorization letter signed by Mr. a copy of the and
Eddie Domo executed in favor of executed SPA as the MENRO/City
Datu Dagpong legal representative ENRO to
 Kagawad -Chairman on of BUKLIK; discuss
Environment raised that since  The Undersign concerns
they were newly elected officials, provided Datu related to
they wanted to be properly Dagpong a copy of mining and
guided with the provisions of the list of mandatory other related
law related to R.A. 7942, known requirements. activities.
as the “Philippine Mining Act of
1995” and R.A. 7076 known as
the Peoples Small Scale Mining
or “Minahan ng Bayan”,
implementing rules and
regulations, and other related
policies both national and local;
 The undersigned discussed
thoroughly together with SP
board members and Datu
Dagpong the list of mandatory
requirements;
 Datu Dagpong was instructed by
the SP board member and the
undersigned to secure a Special
Power of Attorney

Prepared by:

MR. ROGER A. SALUBO MR. DENNIS G. DAGOOC

EMS-I, MGM Division Head, BENRO Administrative Aide-III, BENRO
 Republic of the Philippines
PROVINCE OF BUKIDNON
Provincial Capitol 8700

Bukidnon Environment and Natural Resources Office

DATE : September 26, 2022

FOR : MS. CECILLE M. EGNAR
PENR Officer

FROM : MR. DENNIS G. DAGOOC

Administrative Aide-III, BENRO

SUBJECT : TRAVEL ACCOMPLISHMENT REPORT

Field area : CSAG Permit area: Duffon Chua
Location : Brgy. Lumbo and Maapag, Valencia City
Name of
Supervisor : Mr. Julian Jaryn O. Fuentes
Monitoring team : Arthur Otero/ Field Supervisor
Date : September 14,15,16, 2022
Purpose of
Travel : Validation of the incident reports submitted in the BENRO.

PRELIMINARIES:

This pertains to the letter complaint of a certain Danilo Dumlao regarding his claim of a parcel of land
wherein the CSAG permit area of Mr. Duffon Chua encroached the said land.

Please be informed that the undersigned conducted an investigation based on the complaint.

ACTIONS/UNDERTAKINGS TAKEN:

 Coordinated with the barangay-LGU and Officer in charge;

 Gather information regarding the issue at hand;
 Gather Geo-tagged photos in the contested area.

FINDINGS AND OBSERVATIONS:

DATE City/Municipality/ Findings/Observations Recommendations Remarks

Barangay
Sept. 14, Valencia City,
2022 Bukidnon
 Brgy. Lumbo  Kagawad Naroding Macarambon  Inform the  The BENRO
Dura, Chairman on Agriculture complainant through office should
and was the Officer of the day at a letter to lodge the though its
 the time of our visit in the complaint to the technical
barangay, the undersigned barangay concern so personnel shall
discussed with him issue at that the council will attend the
hand. He was also informed that be the one to call for meeting
the complainant was not able to a meeting/dialogue; /dialogue to
assist the undersign because he  Invite the respondent address
was out of town; Mr. Duffon Chua, properly the
 During the discussion it was during the meeting issue..
raised by Kagwad Dura that they /dialogue;
were not aware of any complaint
form a certain Danilo Dumlao;
 It was then advised by Kagawad
Dura that the complainant must
lodge a complaint with
Barangay-LGU of Lumbo so that
the council will address it
properly;

Sept. 15  Brgy. Maapag  The under conducted an initial  It was recommended  The BENRO
area verification to verify the said to the care taker and office should
contested area; backhoe driver to though its
 The undersign was not able to conduct their technical
spoke to Mr. Duffon Chua, but extraction activity personnel shall
was able to interview his care within the approve attend the
taker Mr. Junriel M. Ochia and permit area of Mr. meeting
the Backhoe driver Toribio Chua to avoid any /dialogue to
Pranciliso, Jr.; further conflict with address
 According to them their current the contested area; properly the
operation was situated within the  Conduct interview issue..
approved permit area as with Mr. Chua.
instructed to them by Mr. Chua;
 During the verification
conducted, most of their activity
was focused in the access road
development;
 Based on the initial area
verification, the activity was
situated within the approved
permit area of Mr. Chua;
 They used a backhoe to make a
ramp along the river bank to
rectify the river embankment;
 After the conduct of the
interview, contacted Mr. Chua to
schedule for a meeting on the
next day.
Sept. 16,  Brgy. Maapag  The undersign conducted an  It was recommended  The BENRO
2022 inter as per schedule given by to Mr. Chua to talk office should
Mr. Chua; with the complainant though its
 According to Mr. Chua, he for possible technical
operated the near the contested resolution of the personnel shall
area but based on the sketch issue; attend the
map and the markers placed meeting
near the boundary it was within /dialogue to
his approved area; address
 Mr. Chua also added that his properly the
CSAG approved area was within issue..
his titled property that was
currently where the river was
situated.
Prepared by: Noted by:

MR. DENNIS G. DAGOOC JULIAN JARYNE O. FUENTES

Administrative Aide-III, BENRO EMS-II, ERDPPM Division head
Photos taken During the conduct of the inspection.

Contested area, Previously

operated by Mr. Chua

Current activity of Mr. Chua’s

area. Backhoe ramp
 Republic of the Philippines
PROVINCE OF BUKIDNON
Provincial Capitol 8700

Bukidnon Environment and Natural Resources Office

DATE : September 26, 2022

FOR : MS. CECILLE M. EGNAR
PENR Officer

FROM : MR. DENNIS G. DAGOOC

Administrative Aide-III, BENRO

SUBJECT : TRAVEL ACCOMPLISHMENT REPORT

Field area : CSAG Permit area: Villamor Dao-ayan
Location : Brgy. Nabag-o, Valencia City
Name of
Supervisor : Mr. Julian Jaryn O. Fuentes
Monitoring team : Arsenio Briones/ Field Supervisor
Date : September 20, 2022
Purpose of
Travel : Attend dialogue: as per request by Brgy. Nabag-o, re: settlement of conflict related to
CSAG applied areas.
PRELIMINARIES:

This pertains to an invitation of Barangay Nabag-o, by Hon. Ricarte Benigno, regarding the continuation
of the dialogue between the complainant Ms. Vergie Yap against her claim in the CSAG permit area of Mr.
Villamor Dao-ayan.

Please be informed that the undersigned attended the dialogue/meeting together with Mr. Joemarie P.
Licawan as per invitation

ACTIONS/UNDERTAKINGS TAKEN:

 Coordinated with the Barangay Captain;

FINDINGS AND OBSERVATIONS:

DATE City/Municipality/ Findings/Observations Recommendations Remarks

Barangay
Sept. 20, Valencia City,
2022 Bukidnon
  Brgy. Nabag-o  Cap. Benigno, discussed the  It was recommended  The BENRO
background of the issue; to Mr. Lito to advise office should
 Ms. Yap discussed that if the the Dao-ayan’s endorse to the
side of the Dao-ayan’s will not together with their DENR-MGB
enter in to a comprise lawyer to proceed to regional in
agreement they will lodge the the BENRO office on case of non-
complaint with DENR-MGB September 26, 2022 reconciliation
panel of arbitrators for filing of in the morning; in issues like
case;  The undersigned this.
 The Dao-ayan’s only sent a advise Ms. Yap, that
representative to send a legal if the Dao-ayan’s will
opinion, Mr. Lito not enter into a
 It was discussed to the parties settlement, they
that what the BENRO and have the right to
barangay-LGU of Nabag-o was proceed to the
aiming was to reconcile both of DENR-MGB-10 for
them and enter into win-win proper filing of case.
settlement to avoid filing of
cases. But if the wishes to lodge
the complaint with the DENR-
MGB, it is their right;
 Mr. Lito, asked the parties to let
him talk to the Dao-ayan’s
together with their lawyer to the
BENRO technical personnel for
further discussion;
 Ms. Yap agreed, but if the result
is contrary, they will proceed to
the DENR-MGB-10 for proper
filing of case.

Prepared by: Noted by:

MR. DENNIS G. DAGOOC JULIAN JARYNE O. FUENTES

Administrative Aide-III, BENRO EMS-II, ERDPPM DIVISION HEAD
 Republic of the Philippines
PROVINCE OF BUKIDNON
Provincial Capitol 8700

Bukidnon Environment and Natural Resources Office

DATE : September 27, 2022

FOR : MS. CECILLE M. EGNAR
PENR Officer

FROM : MR. DENNIS G. DAGOOC

Administrative Aide-III, BENRO

SUBJECT : TRAVEL ACCOMPLISHMENT REPORT

Field area : CSAG Permit area: Duffon Chua
Location : Brgy. Lumbo and Maapag, Valencia City
Name of
Supervisor : Mr. Julian Jaryn O. Fuentes
Monitoring team : Allan Cabaylo, Jeffrey Sintao, Lennon Santiago/ Field Monitoring
Date : September 21,22,23, 2022
Purpose of
Travel : Validation of the incident reports submitted in the BENRO.

PRELIMINARIES:

This pertains to the incident report submitted by the BENRO field monitoring regarding the operation of
certain CSAG permit areas within Valencia City, Bukidnon.

Please be informed that the undersigned conducted an area verification based on the incident report
submitted.

ACTIONS/UNDERTAKINGS TAKEN:

 Coordinated with the barangay-LGU;

 Gather Geo-tagged photos.

FINDINGS AND OBSERVATIONS:

DATE City/Municipality/ Findings/Observations Recommendations Remarks

Barangay
Sept. 21, Valencia City,
 2022 Bukidnon
 Brgy. Kahaponan  CSAG permit area of Nelmar  Ms. Mullanida was  The BENRO
Mullanida; advised to continue technical
 During the conduct of area the dumping of personnel must
verification, it was observed that screened gravel include in their
Ms. Mullanida’s river has stones to the recommendati
collapsed; contested area as on during their
 According to her it was due to part of her conduct of te
the operation of her operator, rehabilitation; EMCRR the
Mr. Agdon;  She was also rehabilitation of
 Portion of her land has already advised to stop any Ms. Mullnida’s
been collapsed with more or less activity or excavation river
5 meters from the edge of the near the river embankment
embankment inwards; embankment; to avoid further
 According to her, she never miss  She was advised to damage to the
any chance to orient and inform rectify the area.
her operator not to excavate embankment to
near the river embankment; avoid further erosion
 There were traces of waste of the soil;
materials dumped within the  Observe the 10
damaged embankment. (see meter buffer zone as
attached photos) mandated in the
 Lastly, markers were established ECC terms and
but not so visible condition;
 Establish visible
boundary marker/
witness corners.

Sept. 22  Brgy.  Mr. Vicente Dumadag CSAG  It was recommended  The BENRO
Sinanuagan permit area; to the care taker to technical
 Mr. Dumadag was not present in tell Mr. Dumadag to: personnel must
the area during area verification, 1. Establish include in their
it was represented by his boundary markers recommendati
checker Ms. Jonnie; properly; on during their
 It was observed that river 2. Continue the conduct of the
embankment was properly embankment EMCRR.
established by dumping rectification and
screened gravel stones to rectify observe the 10
the embankment; meter buffer zone.
 Established boundary markers
but only on the upstream side;

Sept. 23,  Brgy. Sugod  ULTICON BUILDERS INC. rep.  It was recommended  The BENRO
2022 by Mr. Carlo Pio Pacana; to the Pollution technical
 During the conduct of the area Control Officer(PCO) personnel must
verification there was no to establish include in their
operation, traces of stockpile boundary visible recommendati
situated within the river boundary markers; on during their
embankment;  To contain there conduct of the
 No proper and visible markers operation within the EMCRR.
were established; approved area;
 Portion of the river embankment
were excavated.

Prepared by: Noted by:

MR. DENNIS G. DAGOOC JULIAN JARYNE O. FUENTES

Administrative Aide-III, BENRO EMS-II, ERDPPM DIVISION HEAD

Photos taken during the conduct of Area Verification

CSAG PERMIT AREA OF MS. NELMAR MULLANIDA

Screened gravel used for

embankment rectification
 Subject area for
rehabilitation

CSAG PERMIT AREA OF MR. VICENTE DUMADAG

Screened gravel dumped within the

embankment for rectification;

Boundary Marker established

but not so visible
 Screening and stockpiling out side the
river bed

ULTICON BUILDER INC. CSA PERMIT AREA

Traces of stock pile within river

embankment
No visible boundary markers
established