PHILIPPINE COLLEGE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

Old Nalsian Road, Nalsian, Calasiao, Pangasinan, Philippines 2418

Tel. No. (075)522-8032/Fax No. (075)523-0894/Website:www.philcst.edu.ph
ISO 9001:2015 CERTIFIED, Member: Philippine Association of Colleges and Universities (PACU), Philippine Association of Maritime
Institutions (PAMI)

COURSE OUTCOMES ASSESSMENT PLAN

2nd Semester / A.Y. 2021-2022

(Written essay assessment)

CRIMINAL LAW BOOK 1 CLJ3A

COA1
Assessment Code

CILO1: Explain the theories, concepts and principles of criminal law.

Course Outcomes

Assessment Outcomes (Discuss the concepts in general of criminal law in the given scenario).

Duration 1 Hour
Assessment Area ASSIGNED CLASSROOM/MEETING ROOM

ANDROID CELLPHONE/DEVICE
Equipment Needed
LAPTOP/PC

a. Discuss the assessment instructions.

Assessor’s Action
Assessment Briefing
Students
Recommended Action
Assessment Debriefing
Assessment System
b. Ensure that the equipment/materials are complete before commencing the assessment.
c. Remind the student of the time left and actions not related to the assessment.
a. Explain the grading/scoring system of the assessment (RUBRICS)
b. Explain the RESIT policy
a. Prepare materials needed (Notes and other references)
b. Follow instructions
Not Applicable
A student must meet Performance Criteria to consider “COMPETENT” otherwise “NOT YET
COMPETENT” is recorded and subject to Resit.

Practical Assessment Not Applicable since the course is purely lecture course.

The assessment will be stopped when any of the following incidents occurred:
a. Student behaves beyond the proper decorum;
b. Student poses potential danger to the assessment procedures;
Failure State
c. Exceeded time allotment required in the assessment plan, and;
d. Any forms of cheating done by the students will be a ground for the assessment to be void
or invalid and should be cancelled.
The result shall be solely dependent on the performance of the student and assessor will only
Final Result measure the performance objectively by the use of the Rubrics. Students who failed will undergo
RESIT which is scheduled as per quality standards of the institution.
Students who FAILED will undergo RESIT which is scheduled accordingly. A student, who fails in
the same competence 3 times, shall be allowed to take RESITS until passing scores are met. If the
Re-Sit
students still failed to pass the assessment after 3 times of RESITs, it can be a ground for the
student to incur a failing grade.
Final Rating The student should get a minimum mark of THREE (3) USING THE RUBRICS to pass the
assessment.

COURSE CODE: CLJ3A PREPARED BY: VALIDATED BY: APPROVED BY:

ASSESSOR’S COPY ACTIVITY NO.: COA No.1 Atty. Esperanza LM. Aggalao-Ticangan Mr. AMBROSIO P. DETRAN, Ph.D.Crim Engr. RAUL B. GIRONELLA, D. Min.
Instructor College Dean VPAA
PERIOD: 2nd Sem
Page 1 of 4
 PHILIPPINE COLLEGE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
Old Nalsian Road, Nalsian, Calasiao, Pangasinan, Philippines 2418
Tel. No. (075)522-8032/Fax No. (075)523-0894/Website:www.philcst.edu.ph
ISO 9001:2015 CERTIFIED, Member: Philippine Association of Colleges and Universities (PACU), Philippine Association of Maritime
Institutions (PAMI)

SCENARIO:

Johnny, Elon and Franco, all of legal age, are friends. They have reputation in their barangay as gang
members whose main activity is to rob houses and other different establishments. Prior to executing their
plan of robbing the house of Doña Amber, the three conducted surveillance of the routinary activities in the
house of Doña Amber. They even posed as technician, electricians, delivery and errand boys and befriended
the maids therein in preparation of carrying out their plan. They also become friend with Benjamin, one of the
guards of the gate of the subdivision where the house of Doña Amber is located and even confided with him
their plan of robbing. As a matter of fact, they asked him to open the gate on the day that they will pursue
their plan to which he agreed.

On April 15, 2022, Doña Amber left for Boracay for a long holiday vacation. This fact is made known by
the group. As previously conceived, they prepared to carry out their plan on the said date. After they were let
in by Benjamin at the gate, they waited for nighttime. They were able to gain entry to the house by silently
drilling the wall of the back part of the house. They are aware that only Camille, one of the maids was left in
the house. Armed with short firearms, they entered the servant’s quarter and held Camille at gunpoint. They
instructed Camille to open the vault which is located in the study room of Doña Amber. The group knew that
Camille has access to the vault as she was befriended by Johnny and the information was divulged by Camille
herself. Camile, fearing for her life opened the vault. As soon as the vault was opened, Elon and Franco
amassed all the money and jewelries inside the vault. While Johnny is guarding Camille. On their way out,
Camille was able to press the alarm of the house. The alarm created a very loud noise. Fearing that someone
might come for help, Johnny and Elon immediately fled outside with the loots. Franco was bit left behind.
Outraged, Franco hit the nape of Camille. Then, he immediately went outside and rode with their getaway
vehicle together with Johnny and Elon. The following day, the robbery incident was all over the news with
them identified. After one week, they all appeared and surrendered at the police station and implicated
Benjamin as their companion. They were charged for robbery.

QUESTIONS:

1. Is robbery as in the instant case a felony or an offense? Explain your answer.

A felony because robbery in the title of revised penal code which is crime against property.

2. Discuss the participation of Johnny, Elon, Franco, Benjamin and Camille, if any in the instant case.
Johny, Elon and Franco the participation is direct participation. They have direct participation of
execution of crime.
Benjamin the participation is principle by indispensable cooperation because he serves as access
to the offender upon entering submission.
Camille the participation is none because she committed only a crime by means intimidation of
offender.

3. Except for evident premeditation which is inherent in the instant case, what are the circumstances
present in the above-mentioned facts that may affect the criminal liability of the accused? Cite all
identified applicable circumstances.
It is aggravating circumstances because the incident did in nighttime, there is a force of entry and
conspiracy.

4. Assuming the accused in the instant case were arrested and later on found to be guilty, in what
manner shall their criminal liability be totally extinguished?
The manner shall their criminal liability be totally extinguished by service of the sentence.

COURSE CODE: CLJ3A PREPARED BY: VALIDATED BY: APPROVED BY:

ASSESSOR’S COPY ACTIVITY NO.: COA No.1 Atty. Esperanza LM. Aggalao-Ticangan Mr. AMBROSIO P. DETRAN, Ph.D.Crim Engr. RAUL B. GIRONELLA, D. Min.
Instructor College Dean VPAA
PERIOD: 2nd Sem
Page 2 of 4
 PHILIPPINE COLLEGE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
Old Nalsian Road, Nalsian, Calasiao, Pangasinan, Philippines 2418
Tel. No. (075)522-8032/Fax No. (075)523-0894/Website:www.philcst.edu.ph
ISO 9001:2015 CERTIFIED, Member: Philippine Association of Colleges and Universities (PACU), Philippine Association of Maritime
Institutions (PAMI)

RUBRICS FOR ESSAY

CRITERIA / SCALE Description and Points

Content/Information (70%)
Ideas Most of the ideas The answer The idea is not The idea has no
The answer is are focused and contains ideas well-defined and clear sense of
clear and focused has some good which is basic and have too many purpose or
details general topics central theme
70 60 40 30 10
Organization and Format (30%)
Organization The order Most of the ideas The organization The sentence The writing
structure of presented are is good with little within the lacks a clear

COURSE CODE: CLJ3A PREPARED BY: VALIDATED BY: APPROVED BY:

ASSESSOR’S COPY ACTIVITY NO.: COA No.1 Atty. Esperanza LM. Aggalao-Ticangan Mr. AMBROSIO P. DETRAN, Ph.D.Crim Engr. RAUL B. GIRONELLA, D. Min.
Instructor College Dean VPAA
PERIOD: 2nd Sem
Page 3 of 4
 PHILIPPINE COLLEGE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
Old Nalsian Road, Nalsian, Calasiao, Pangasinan, Philippines 2418
Tel. No. (075)522-8032/Fax No. (075)523-0894/Website:www.philcst.edu.ph
ISO 9001:2015 CERTIFIED, Member: Philippine Association of Colleges and Universities (PACU), Philippine Association of Maritime
Institutions (PAMI)

sense of
direction. There
information is paragraph makes
is no
compelling and is organized. confusion. sense but is not in
identifiable
well-organized. order.
internal
structure.
20 18 15 10 5
A number of A number of So many
spelling, spelling, spelling,
Virtually no
Few spelling, punctuation and punctuation and punctuation
spelling,
punctuation and grammatical grammatical and
Sentence Construction punctuation of
minor grammatical errors are present errors are present grammatical
grammatical
errors. but does not really that already errors that
errors.
affect the affects the interferes with
thought. thought. the thought.
10 8 5 3 1

DECISION AND If your score is 75 points and above, then you are COMPETENT. You do not need to retake
RECOMMENDATION: your course outcome assessment.
*Scores will be provided in your If your score is below 75 points, the you are subjected to RESIT (RETAKE). Please wait for
LMS. the announcement of your instructor for the resit schedule in your respective course.

COURSE CODE: CLJ3A PREPARED BY: VALIDATED BY: APPROVED BY:

ASSESSOR’S COPY ACTIVITY NO.: COA No.1 Atty. Esperanza LM. Aggalao-Ticangan Mr. AMBROSIO P. DETRAN, Ph.D.Crim Engr. RAUL B. GIRONELLA, D. Min.
Instructor College Dean VPAA
PERIOD: 2nd Sem
Page 4 of 4