Republic of the Philippines

Department of Education
REGION IV-A CALABARZON
GATE 2, KARANGALAN VILLAGE
1900 CAINTA, RIZAL

SUGGESTED SCHOOL – BASED MANAGEMENT MEANS OF VERIFICATION

The SBM Assessment Tool uses evidence to determine a school’s level of practice. DOD is means of evaluating the validity or truthfulness of the evidence. DOD is an acronym
for Document Analysis, Observation, and discussion. Essential steps in evaluating the validity of an evidence of an SBM practice below:
 Relevance. The evidence must be appropriate to the indicator being assessed. It is appropriate if the artefact or document is a tool or a product of a practice expressed in the
indicator.
 Accuracy. The evidence must be correct. If it is a lesson plan, then both content and procedure must be correct.
 Currency. The evidence must be present, existing or actual.
 Consistency. The evidence must be verifiable and generates the same results from most of the sources.
 Sufficiency. The evidence must be adequate or enough. If a student learning portfolio is presented as evidence of self-directed learning, its presence in only two or three classes is
not an adequate evidence of school- wide implementation.

Documentary evidence may show the schools’ focus on learner – centered learning like cooperative, interactive, problem solving and decision making. There is a need to obtain
process evidence to know if these are being practiced.

Process evidence is obtained by scrutinizing instructional, leadership, and management styles, methods, techniques, approaches, and activities used by the school community to
achieve the SBM goal. Evidence is identified through participant or non participant observations which may be conducted formally or informally. Individual or group interviews are held to
verify or clarify the evidence. Evidence is scrutinized for validity.

To measure the performance in terms of quality, the Division MPS will be utilized and a Regional Assessment for Quality be administered to measure quality for level 3 aspirant
schools.

“EXCELLENCE is a CULTURE and QUALITY is a COMMITMENT”

Trunkline: 02-8682-5773/8684-4914/8647-7487
Website: depedcalabarzon.ph
Document Inquiry: http://r4a-teadoc.com/inquire
Facebook: DepEd R-4A Calabarzon
Leadership and Governance
A network of leadership and governance guides the education system to achieve its shared vision, mission and goals making them responsive and relevant to the context of diverse environment.
Indicators Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
1. In place is a Development Plan
developed collaboratively by the
stakeholders of the school and
community.
2. The development plan is regularly
reviewed by the school community to
keep it responsive and relevant to
emerging needs, challenges and
opportunities.
3. The school is organized by a clear
structure and work arrangements that
promote shared leadership and
governance and define the roles and
responsibilities of the stakeholders.
- School Community Profile
- Minutes of the meeting in crafting of
SIP
- Attendance Sheets
- Photo Documentation
- Draft SIP with annexes
- Project Proposal
- Advocacy materials but not limited to
Poster/tarpaulin/flyers
- Info Board
- Proposed PPAs on matters of school
governance and operations initiated
by the schools and stakeholders
- Report of SIP/AIP review
- PPAs Monitoring Report
- Letter of invitation to the community
stakeholders
- Copy of the school memo on the
conduct of the activity for internal
stakeholders
- List of Organizational Structure and
their Roles and Responsibilities
a. SGC
b. PTA
c. SPG/SGC
- Approved SIP/AIP
- Approved Project Proposals
- Terms of Reference for SMEA
- Approved Monitoring Tool
Accomplishment report of the
implementation PPAs
- Open line communication through
Social Media, School Webpage,
flyers, SRC
- Enhanced SIP/AIP
- PPAs Monitoring Report
- Approved SIPAIP
- Approved Project Proposal (PTA,
SGC, SPC/SSG)
- Narrative report on School
implemented PPAs in varied forms
(general assembly, open line
communication)
- Updated and accurate Transparency
Board
- Quarterly SMEA Report
- Annual Plan (PTA, SGC, but not
limited to)
- Letter requests of external
organization in support to information
dissemination on SIP
- Narrative/Accomplishment Reports:
 Education Summit
 SOSA
 Symposium
- Request letter of stakeholders to
implement PPAs on matters of school
governance and operations
- Records of Stakeholders initiated
PPAs
- SGC minutes of the meeting
- Documentation of school Best
practices shared to other schools
- Logbook or Record of activities
- Narrative report on VMVs and
schools aspiration advocacy
- Letters for benchmarking
- Awards and Recognition certificates
- Report of AIP review: 100%
accomplished with identified value
added outputs
- Log book of benchmarking activities
from other schools
- Narrative Report on the schools’
benchmarked/ adopted
- Accomplishment Report
- Quarterly SMEA Reports
- Report and action taken based on the
SMEA feedback
- Identified best practices on
transparency and accountability were
shared to other school
- Certification of sharing of best
practices

4. A leadership network facilities
communication between and among
school and community leaders for
informed decision-making and
solving of school-community wide
learning problems.
5. A long-term program is in operation
that addresses the training and
development needs of school and
community leaders.
The curriculum learning systems anchored on the community and learners’ contexts and aspirations are collaboratively developed and continuously improved.
1. The curriculum provides for the
development needs of all types of
learners in the school community
2. The implemented curriculum is
localized to make it more meaningful
d. Etc.
- Organizational chart with position
- Personnel’s profile
- Feedback forms/ Suggestion box/
open line communication
- Approved M & E tools
- Organized M and E Team with TOR
-Training Needs Assessment
-IPCRF
-OPCRF
-NCBTS/TSNA Results
Curriculum and Instruction
- Learning Competencies
Legal basis on curriculum and
instruction
- Documented teaching learning
activities and resources provided
- Conduct of meeting on LRMDS
- DLLs/DLPs
- -List of Intervention Programs
- Sample learners portfolio
- Sample self-directed materials
- School based monitoring tool on
learning outcomes
- Reading assessment report
- Copy of curriculum guide
- Budget of work
- LR
- Teachers portfolio
- Budget of work
- Evaluation report of learning
materials
- Designation Order w/terms of
Reference
- Consolidation and Analysis of the
evaluation results from feedback and
M and E results with proposed
solutions/interventions
- Individual Plan for Professional
Development (IPPD)
- School Plan for Professional
Development (SPPD)
- Checked daily lesson log
- Evaluated instructional materials
- Documented teaching learning
activities provided
- Utilization of learning resource
materials
- DLLs DLPs of accomplished COTs
- Contextualized intervention programs
- Contextualized modules
- School- based monitoring results on
learning outcomes
- Class observation reports and post
observation
- No. of contextualized produced
materials
- Contextualized learning materials
- Performance level of learners
- Minutes of the meeting (discussing
feedbacks/results and proposed
solutions)
- Progress monitoring report on the
implemented solutions/intervention
- Documented processes of feedback
and monitoring mechanism
- Certification of sharing of best
practices on feedback and monitoring
mechanism
- Learning and Development Package
- Documentation of the conduct of
writes hops for learning materials and
training for updating teacher
competencies on curriculum and
pedagogy
- Improved teaching learning activities
and resources that results to sustained
improvement
- Assessment tool/feedback of pupils,
teachers and parents
- Accomplishment report
- Record of continuous and shared
practices in the community to
improve teaching and learning
activities
- District learning action cell/visual
aids/LMS exchange program
- LAC sessions focused on T-L
- No. of teachers trained in INSET
- Documented partnerships on
improving T-L activities and
resources (MOU) shared practices
- List of interventions and innovations
implemented
 to the learners and applicable to life in
this community.
3. A representative group of school and
community stakeholders develop the
methods and materials for developing
creative thinking and problem solving
- Inventory of available learning
resources/Inventory of needs- based
learning resources
- Feedback on the available learning
resources
- Records of utilization of available
learning materials
- Inventory of learning materials
- Identified school projects/intervention
per subject
- Needs assessment for the teaching
and learning outcomes
- Learners performance profile
- List of intervention or implemented
program for learners needs
- Teaching learning support
systems/PPAs implemented
- Copy of professional development
plan
- Implementation report on teaching
and learning support system
- List of 4Ps
Beneficiaries
Anecdotal records
Copy of performance outputs of
learners
- Intervention plan
- List of dropping outs
- Report of family mapping
- SPED and ALS Program
- Teachers portfolio
- Resources gaps analysis
- Utilization report
- Strategic intervention materials
concerning least mastered skills
- Compilation of localized curriculum
- Updated Inventory of LMs with
analysis and interpretation of data
- Project proposal on intervention
material used
- Least learned skills or competencies
by grading period
- Monitoring tools in the conduct of
innovations/intervention
- Evaluation and monitoring results
basis for action research
- Appropriate teaching learning support
system
- Results of monitoring the use of
crafted instructional materials
- Implementation report on teaching
learning support system
- Development needs plan of diverse
learners
- Reports on classroom teaching and
learning evaluation
- Attendance during school activities
- Progress. Monitoring report of
learning outcomes
- Analysis of test results
- LAC Session focused on teaching
- Action research on pedagogy and
content/Action researches conducted
focused on T-L process
- Best practices on the development
and implementation of innovative
needs-based learning resources
- Accomplishment report/
- Certification of sharing /adaption of
best practices
- Documentation of sharing best
practices through
benchmarking/adoption
- Shared information on the localized
materials with other community
stakeholders
- Parental involvement in the
production of innovative needs based
learning resources
- Awards and recognition system
- Documentation of the adoption of
best practices in developing needs-
based learning resources.
- MOA of stakeholders
- Consolidated report on the teaching-
learning support system
- Documentation of the
intervention/innovation conducted
- Continuously improved teaching
learning support system through
collaboration
- Certification of sharing/adoption of
best practices
- Feedback report/mechanism
- Immersion
- School initiative exchange program
- CI projects
- K to 3 T-L material
- LAC session focused on diversity of
learners
- COT Files
- Report on CIP
 - ISWP Files
- PPAs on curriculum and instruction
- Technical assistance report
4. The learning systems are regularly and - MPS monitoring
collaboratively monitored by the - Performance rating of learners
community using appropriate tools to - Observation tools and rating of
ensure the holistic growth and teachers
development of the learners and - Grading system
community. - Assessment tools/ strategies
implemented
- Conduct of INSET of the
differentiated strategies
(PRIMALS) documentation
- Assessment reports
- Quarterly assessment test
- Printed copy of PHIL-IRI results
- Copy of remedial support program
- Needs assessment survey
- Records of test result and other
forms of assessment
- Reading assessment
- Learning outcomes assessment
results
- M&E Tools
learning process
- Consultative meetings
- COT files focused on grouping
pattern
- RPMS
- Copy of school action plan per
learning area
- Year-end reports
- Minutes of the meeting regarding
collaboration with stakeholders on
innovative teaching and learning
- Daily lesson with differentiated
instruction
- Rubrics for differentiated
instruction
- Localized instructional materials
- Localized DLP
- Sample of differentiated quarter
assessment test strategies
- Portfolio assessment in all learning
areas
- Records on intervention on the
findings of test result and other
forms of assessment
- Availability of test materials and
assessment tools
- Copy of approved action plan
subject areas
- Registry of alternative differentiated
assessment strategies
- Remedial intervention programs
- Posting of assessment schedule
- Action plan on report LOA results
- Action research
- Mentoring and coaching program
- Documented partnership activities on
improving teaching learning support
system
- School – based M&E
- Action research on reported results
and interventions
- Revised or developed assessment
strategies in differentiated instruction
- Action Research
- Innovative assessment system on
differentiated strategies is sustained,
shared and continuously enhanced
- Learning materials are shared/ used
and implemented by the different
grade levels
- Certification of sharing/ adoption of
best practices
- Innovations on assessment system
- Conduct innovation and action
research
- Record of involvement of parents in
the development of school policies
and procedures
- Evidences of networking with
stakeholders
- Assessment progress report
- M&E tools
- Award and recognition
- Documented partnership activities on
improving assessment system design
5. Appropriate assessment tools for teaching
and learning are continuously reviewed
and improved, and assessment results are
contextualized to the learner and local
situation and the attainment of relevant
life skills.
6. Learning managers and facilitators
(teachers, administrators and community
members) nurture values and
environments that are protective of all
children and demonstrate behaviours
consistent to the organization’s vision,
mission, and goals.
7. Methods and resources are learner and
community – friendly, enjoyable, safe,
inclusive, accessible and aimed at the
developing self – directed learners.
Learners are equipped with essential
knowledge, skills and values to assume
responsibility for their own learning.
- Performance rating of learners
a. Summative
b. Formative
- Observation tools
- Assessment tools
a. Quarterly assessment test
b. MPS
- Needs assessment
- Reading assessment
a. PHIL IRI
b. EGRA
- EGMA
- Posted signage on safety security
- Posted memorandum of policies and
procedures on safety, child-friendly
and security
- Displayed of Crises Management
Plan (DRRM) and Org chart of
SDRRM Teams
- Posted Emergency Directory
List of diverse learners with special
needs i.e. IPs, SPED and ALS
- Draft of Equal Opportunity Policy
for Out of school youth, SPEd, IPs
- Posting of Citizen Charter
- Rubrics for differentiated instruction
- Differentiated quarterly assessment
test strategies
- Portfolio assessment in all learning
areas
- Records on intervention on the
findings of test results and other
forms of assessment
- Copy of approved action plan per
subject areas
- Registry of alternative differentiated
assessment strategies
- Intervention programs
- Student handbook which includes:
a. Proper Conduct, Discipline and
Infractions
b. Guidelines on school’s safe
secure and child friendly
environment
c. Legal basis of DRRM
d. Child protection policy
- File or copy of accomplishment
report of the implementation of
policies and procedures on Disaster
Preparedness. Child protection policy
and the like
- Documentation/Reports of learning
environment policies and procedures
implementation
- Narrative Report/Photo
Documentation of Inclusive Ed
Programs
- Copy of policies and procedures on
learning environment that promote
- Revised developed assessment
strategies for differentiated instruction
- Action Research
- Innovative assessment system on
differentiated strategies sustained,
shared and continuously enhanced
- Learning materials are shared/ used
and implemented by the different
grade levels
- Certification of sharing/ adaptation of
best practices
- Innovations on assessment system
- Conduct innovation and action
research
- Record of involvement of parents in
the development of school policies and
procedures
- Assessment progress report
- Partnership activities on improving
assessment system design
- Photo/Video Documentation of the
Crises/Disaster Management Activities
- Reports of Guidance Office Advocacy
on Child Protection Benchmarking
documentation of other schools on the
conduct of SDRRM practices
- Action Research
- Feedback from internal and external
stakeholders
- Awards/Recognition/Certification of
sharing/adoption of best practices
- Continuous Monitoring and Evaluation
Report
- Stakeholders’ quarterly feedback
- Review of the advocacy awareness
program

A clear transparent, inclusive and responsive accountability system is in place, collaboratively and developed by the school community, which monitors performance and acts
appropriately on gaps and gains.
1. Roles and responsibilities of
accountable person/s and collective
body/ies are clearly defines and agreed
upon by community stakeholders.
2. Achievement of goals is recognized
based on a collaboratively developed
performance accountability system;
gaps are addressed
Accountability and Continuous improvement
- Narrative report on the conduct of :
SOSA/Stakeholders Summit
- Advocacy materials but not limited
to Poster/tarpaulin/flyers
- Info Board
- Report AIP review: less than 100%
accomplished
- Copy of PPAs
inclusive Education i.e ALS, SPED,
IPs
- Copy of Policies and procedures
implemented i.e. Equal Opportunity
Policy
- Proposed PPAs on the - Request letter of stakeholders to implement PPAs
matters of school on matters of school governance and operations
governance and - Logbook
operations initiated by - Records of Stakeholders initiated PPAs
the schools and - SGC minutes of the meeting
stakeholders
- Accomplishment report
of the implemented
PPAs
- Report of AIP review: - Report of AIP review: 100% accomplished with
100% accomplished identified value-added outputs
- PPAs Monitoring Report - Gaps are addressed with appropriate action.
- Documentation of
conducted PPAs

3. The accountability system is owned by
the community and is continuously
enhanced to ensure that management
structures and mechanisms are
responsive to the emerging learning
needs and demands of the community.
4. Accountability assessment criteria and
tools, feedback mechanisms and
information collection and validation
techniques and processes are inclusive
and collaboratively developed and
agreed upon.
- Letter of invitation to the community - Narrative report on - Updated and accurate Transparency Board
stakeholders School implemented - Strategic direction to address the gaps
- Copy of the school memo on the PPAs in varied
conduct of the activity for internal forms(general assembly,
stakeholders open line
- Narrative report on the conduct of communication)
the activity
-PPAs posted on Bulletin Board,
school newspaper, SRC, Posters and
tarps/electronic means, etc.
- Clients’ Satisfaction Survey - Consolidation/Analysis - Progress monitoring report on the implemented
- Parent’s Opennionaire of the evaluation results solutions/intervention
- Checklist Form from feedback and M
- Survey Questionnaire and E results with
- Tracer study Tool proposed
solutions/interventions

5. Participatory assessment of
Performance is done regularly with the
community. Assessment results and
lessons learned serve as basic for
feedback, technical assistance,
recognition and plan adjustment.
- SGC minutes of the
meeting (discussing
feedbacks/results and
proposed solutions)
Status of the school’s performance Consolidation and Analysis of - Progress monitoring report on the implemented
-nutritional Status the evaluation results from solutions/intervention
-feeding program Feedback and M and E results - -Technical
-status of performance indicators with proposed solutions/ - -Assistance Initiated
 Access interventions - Recognition/project praise
 Efficiency -SIP/AIP Adjustments - Plan
 quality -Minutes of the meeting
(discussing feedbacks/results - Adjustment
and proposed solutions
-

Management of Resources
Resources are collectively and judiciously mobilized and managed with transparency, effectiveness and effectively

1. Regular resources inventory is SIP/AIP/APP Approved - Each PPA must be supported by the
collaboratively undertaken by Resource Inventory E-SIP/AIP/APP/School Calendar of following:
learning managers, learning 1. Human (Pupils & Personnel Activities 1. activity proposal
facilitators and community a. Performance indicators a. Highlighting the Project Work plan 2. school memo
stakeholders as basis for resource b. Learning Support and Resource and Budget Matrix 3. attendance
allocation and mobilization materials (Resource Inventory) 4. completion report
c. Etc. 5. SMEA report
2. Technological 6. Program of Works (Infra)
3. Physical 7. Deed of Donations
a. School Titling 2. Resource Allocation and Mobilization
b. School developmental plan Plan
4. Financial
a. Canteen report
b. MOOE allocation
c. etc

2. A regular dialogue for planning and -file copy of the Procurement Law (RA Approved SIP/AIP/APP - Committee on resource management
resources programming, that is 9184) - Human resource Dev’t Plan with defined roles and functions that
 accessible and inclusive
continuously engage stakeholders
and support implementation and
community education plans.
3. In place is a community developed
resource management that drives
appropriate behaviors of the
stakeholder to ensure judicious,
appropriate and effective use of
resources.
4. Regular monitoring, evaluation and
reporting processes of resources
management are collaboratively
developed and implemented by the
learning managers, facilitators, and
community stakeholders
5. There is a system that managers the
network and linkages which
- Conduct of orientation and procurement
process and utilization of funds (School
Activity report)
-List of BAC chair and members with TOR
-Monthly disbursement/liquidation report
- Fidelity bond document
-School MOOE
(Disbursement/liquidation)
- inventory of resources
- file copy of asset management
policy
- report on the orientation on policy
of Asset Management
- Asset Management Plan
- Memo on acquisition and disposal
of supplies
- Legal basis for asset/property
Management
- Financial reports
- Physical and financial target/plan
- Updated MOOE liquidation
- Updated and audited canteen report
- Income generating projects with
Financial Statements
- Legal basis for physical and
financial requirement
- Partnership database
- School Project Teams with roles
(HRDP)
- Financial Mgt. Dev’t Plan (FMDP)
- Technology Resource Improvement
Plan (TRIP)
- School Physical Dev’t Plan (SPDP)
- monthly cash program
- -approved APP
- -SUB ARO
- -disbursement documents
- -Schedule of disbursement versus
actual disbursement
Validated/approved disbursements
Aligned to the Rules and Regulations of
Accounting and Auditing:
-List of Assets
-File copy of asset management policy
-Report on school asset management
-Inventory of machine/equipment
-Inventory of buildings/facilities
-Monitoring report on compliance to asset
management plan
-Legal basis for asset/property management
-Financial reports
-Approved Physical and Financial plan
-Updated MOOE liquidation
-Updated and Audited Canteen Report
-Income generating projects with Financial
Statement
-Legal basis for physical and financial
requirement
- Utilization of DPDS
- School Project Teams with roles and
will perform the ff:
- Updated data-base resource
information system (procurement
documents)
- Schedule of Procurement that will
ensure timely and efficient delivery
of good and services
- Memo and minutes of meeting of
meeting on reporting of
disbursement to stakeholders
- Schedule of disbursements versus
actual disbursement
- Validated /approved disbursement
- Documented evidence of reporting
of disbursements to stakeholders
- Accomplished Annual Monitoring
of all assets of Schools and audited
by the ff stakeholders
- 1. Division
- 2. District
3. Other Stakeholders
- SMEA reports (plan adjustment)
- Financial reports (with positive
indication of timeliness/accuracy)
- Communication to stakeholders
thru:
 SOSA
 SRC
 Bulletin / transparency
Board
- Memo and minutes of meeting on
regular review and adjustment of
AIP
- Reports on PPAs
implementation/utilization of fund
- Parents’ approval
- Resolution
- MOOE Canteen, IGP reports posted
on transparency board
- Memo and minutes of regular
meeting
 strengthen and sustain partnership
for improving resource
management
and functions
- AIP
- Planning meeting/reporting of the
development of resource
mobilization management system
- Deed of donation
- Resource inventory
functions
- AIPs
- List of generated resources
- School Project Teams with roles and
functions
- AIP
- MOA/M OU with partner
- M&E report on the implementation of
resources management system
- List of resources programmed for
Access, Quality and Governance
- Copy of rules and regulation on
resource management
- Brigada Eskwela report
- List of generated resources
- School Project Teams with roles and
functions
- AIP
- MOA/M OU with partners
- Program for Resource Mobilization
- Progress monitoring report thru
media on resource mobilization

KEY PROCESS PERSON INVOLVED LINK

DISTRIBUTION/RETRIEVAL VOP-TEACHERS https://tinyurl.com/SLCPVOP
CONDUCT OF ONLINE CLASS VOP-ODL TEACHERS ONLY https://tinyurl.com/CONDUCTOFODL
ORIENTATION OF SLCP
ONLINE DELIVERY LEARNING (ODL)
RETRIEVAL/DISTRIBUTION PROCESS (MDL)
ONLINE DELIVERY LEARNING (ODL)
ORIENTATION OF SLCP
PPAs REVIEW AND ADJUSTMENT TOOL
MONITORING AND EVALUATION TOOL FOR
ENHANCED SCHOOL LEARNING
CONTINUITY PLAN (SLCP)-MNHS
VIRTUAL KUMUSTAHAN
VOP-TEACHING/NONTEACHING https://tinyurl.com/SLCPORIENTATIONMNHSSTAFF
VOP-STUDENTS/PARENTS https://tinyurl.com/ODLSTUDPAR
VOP-STUDENTS/PARENTS https://tinyurl.com/MDL3RD
VOP-STUDENTS/PARENTS https://tinyurl.com/ODL3RD
VOP-STUDENTS/PARENTS https://tinyurl.com/SLCPStakeholdersOrientation
VOP-TEACHING/NONTEACHING https://tinyurl.com/MNHSPPAs
VOP-TEACHING/NONTEACHING/ https://tinyurl.com/MNHSEnhancedSLCP
STAKEHOLDERS
VOP-TEACHING/NONTEACHING/ https://bit.ly/2W9dAVi
STAKEHOLDERS