Professional Documents
Culture Documents
! !
! !!
! ! !
´ ´q´ ´;´´a´ ´g´ ³´´ ´
@^[{A´ª´B4^ ´rh´ 2%,8G «´¨©C´
Di´ ¢!´5"#´ b£¬´|E¤F±$ ´ ¥GcHj´Ik´
\%´ dZe&´ Y'2(6²l´ J´K´ L}) Mm´*]
&!#D'>3-G 9G / 4:G G N7_+´ ;? )G
<O8s,=-´9tn´ X`uP´ ].´>Q´ R][~S´:vo´
fwp¡¦x´ Ty´ ®´ ¯´ .@57EG U^´?°/´
F*G 1AG $"0G <G 3§^0´ G _1´W^zV´
G =BG 6( + CG
1/34
*UDFLHOD0RQWHV
(GLFLRQHV6DQWLOODQD6$
'HHVWDHGLFLyQ
(GLFLRQHV6DQWLOODQD6$
$Y/HDQGUR1$OHP &$$3
3DUD'RGRTXHPHHQVH±³DVHUSHUUR
&LXGDG$XWyQRPDGH%XHQRV$LUHV$UJHQWLQD
,6%1 3DUD3DEORSDUD'LHJR\SDUD/DXUD
+HFKRHOGHSyVLWRTXHPDUFDODOH\ TXHOH\HURQHVWDKLVWRULDFRQODDOHJUD
,PSUHVRHQ$UJHQWLQD3ULQWHGLQ$UJHQWLQD
3ULPHUDHGLFLyQHQHURGH
FRQTXHVHURHXQKXHVR
3ULPHUDUHLPSUHVLyQPD\RGH
&RRUGLQDFLyQGH/LWHUDWXUD,QIDQWLO\-XYHQLO0DUtD)HUQDQGD0DTXLHLUD
,OXVWUDFLRQHV0DUtD5RMDV
'LUHFFLyQGH$UWH-RVp&UHVSR\5RVD0DUtQ
3UR\HFWRJUiILFR0DULVRO'HO%XUJR5XEpQ&KXUULOODV\-XOLD2UWHJD
0RQWHV*UDFLHOD6LOYLD
/DEDWDOODGHORVPRQVWUXRV\ODVKDGDV*UDFLHOD6LOYLD0RQWHVLOXVWUDGR
SRU0DUtD5RMDV
DHG&LXGDG$XWyQRPDGH%XHQRV$LUHV6DQWLOODQD
SLO[FP 1DUDQMD
,6%1
/LWHUDWXUD,QIDQWLO\-XYHQLO,5RMDV0DUtDLOXV,,7tWXOR
&''
2/34
QRHVDOJRTXHVHOHSXHGDUHSURFKDUDODSREUH/LOL/RTXH
VXFHGHHVTXHHQODYLGDDOJXQRVKHPRVDSUHQGLGRDOJXQDV
FRVDV \ RWURV RWUDV /D /LOL VDEH DMXVWDU WXHUFDV FRQ ORV
GLHQWHV SRU HMHPSOR DOJR TXH \R PH FRQVLGHUR
325 48e 7(1*2 48( 6(535(&,6$0(17( <2(/ DEVROXWDPHQWH LQFDSD] GH KDFHU < HVR SRUTXH OD /LOL YLYH
48(&8(17((67$+,6725,$ MXVWRDOODGRGHORGH7RJQD]]LHOGHOWDOOHUPHF¡QLFR\VH
SDVD ODV WDUGHV SDVH¡QGRVH PX\ RURQGD SRU HQWUH ORV
PRWRUHVGHVDUPDGRVGHORVDXWRV
1R WHQJR P¡V UHPHGLR TXH SRQHUPH D FRQWDU OD KLVWRULD 0LFDVRHVRWUR<RMDP¡VSLV©XQWDOOHUPHF¡QLFRSHUR
GH OD JUDQ EDWDOOD TXH WXYR OXJDU HQ QXHVWUR EDUULR SRU OD HQFDPELRPHKHSDVDGRGDVHQWHURVYLHQGRF³PR6LOYLD
VHQFLOOD UD]³Q GH TXH QR SDUHFH KDEHU QLQJºQ RWUR 0XV FRUULJHJDOHUDV
GLVSXHVWRDKDFHUOR7DOYH]DDOJXQRVOHVOODPHODDWHQFL³Q
ߚ&KLFRVQRKDJDQUXLGRTXHWUDMHXQPRQW³QGHJDOHUDV
TXH PH KD\D PHWLGR D QDUUDGRU HVSHFLDOPHQWH VL VH WLHQH
SDUDFRUUHJLUߚVXHOHGHFLU6LOYLD0XV
HQ FXHQWD OD HVSHFLH D OD TXH SHUWHQH]FR 0H OODPR
1HSRPXFHQR 0XV 1HSR SDUD FDVL WRGR HO PXQGR \ VR\ &RQILHVR TXH OD SULPHUD YH] TXH OD R GHFLU TXH WUDD XQ
SHUUR (VSHURTXHQRVHDQXVWHGHVGHODFODVHGHSHUVRQDV PRQW³Q GH JDOHUDV FUH TXH QRV EDPRV D GHGLFDU D OD
TXH SUHJXQWDQ D FRQWLQXDFL³Q ߡ'H TX© UD]D"ߢ 0XFKR PH FRQIHFFL³QGHVRPEUHURVGHFRSD <HQHVHFDVRKDEUDQ
WHPRTXHHQPLFDVRUHVXOWDUDGLIFLOUHVSRQGHUDHVRVR\ VLGR RWUDV PLV KDELOLGDGHV WDO YH] HVWDUD KR\ PLGLHQGR
SHUURDVHFDV FDEH]DV HQ OXJDU GH FRQWDU KLVWRULDV 3HUR GHVSX©V PH GL
FXHQWDGHTXHODVJDOHUDVGH6LOYLD0XVWHQDQP¡VTXHYHU
$ PL PRGR GH YHU QR WLHQH QDGD GH SDUWLFXODU TXH XQ
FRQ ODV SDODEUDV \ ORV OLEURV TXH FRQ ORV VRPEUHURV (OOD
SHUUR QDUUH XQD KLVWRULD DFHUFD GH KXPDQRV DFDVR QR
OODPDEDߡJDOHUDVߢDXQRVSDSHOHVPX\SHURPX\HVFULWRV<
KXERPXFKRVKXPDQRVTXHFRQWDURQKLVWRULDVGHSHUURV"
WDPEL©Q EDVWDQWH PDO HVFULWRV D PL MXLFLR b/OHQRV GH
3HUR UHFRQR]FR TXH QR HV OR P¡V KDELWXDO ,QFOXVR SXHGR
HUURUHV +DED OHWUDV FDPELDGDV GH OXJDU OHWUDV UHSHWLGDV
DFHSWDU TXH DOJXQRV KXPDQRV ߚORV P¡V YDQLGRVRVߚ VH
OHWUDVWRUFLGDVOHWUDVIXJDGDV/RTXH6LOYLD0XVWHQDTXH
VLHQWDQ DOJR RIHQGLGRV \ KDVWD PX\ RIHQGLGRV WDO YH] DO
KDFHU HUD HQFRQWUDU ORV HUURUHV \ VH±DODUORV 8QD HVSHFLH
SXQWRGHQHJDUVHURWXQGDPHQWHDVHJXLUOH\HQGRXQOLEURHQ
GHMXHJR1XQFDHQWHQGSRUTX©6LOYLD0XVHVWDEDWDQVHULD
HO TXH KD\ XQ QDUUDGRU TXH QR SHUWHQHFH D VX HVSHFLH
PLHQWUDV FRUUHJD D P PH SDUHFD GLYHUWLGVLPR SRUTXH D
3HUR HQ ILQ OHV JXVWH R QR QR KD\ YXHOWD TXH GDUOH HVWD
YHFHV ODV OHWUDV GH SXUR HTXLYRFDUVH WHUPLQDEDQ GLFLHQGR
KLVWRULDODFXHQWDXQSHUUR
GLVSDUDWHV +DED XQ OLEUR PX\ VHULR GH *HRJUDID SRU
&ODUR HVW¡ TXH QR FXDOTXLHU SHUUR SXHGH PHWHUVH D HMHPSOR HQ HO TXH VH OHD ߡ/D 3DWDJRQLD HV XQD JUDQ
FXHQWDFXHQWRV/D/LOLODSHUUDGH&DPLODVLQLUP¡VOHMRV PDVLWDߢ<RWURXQDQRYHODGHWHUURUGRQGHODSURWDJRQLVWD
HVLQFDSD]GHGLVWLQJXLUODOHWUD8GHXQDPRUFLOOD3HURHVR DOYHUDOYDPSLURߡODQ]DEDXQIULWRGHVHVSHUDGR
3/34
6LOYLD0XVVHSDVDODVKRUDVVDFDQGROHWUDVTXHVREUDQ
SRQLHQGROHWUDVTXHIDOWDQ\HQGHUH]DQGROHWUDVWRUFLGDV<
IXHDVFRPRDSUHQGDHVFULELU6LHQOXJDUGHTXHGDUPHHQ
FDVD FRQ HOOD FRUULJLHQGR JDOHUDV KXELHVH DFRPSD±DGR D
VX PDULGR D 6HEDVWL¡Q 0XV FXDQGR VDOH D UHFRUUHU
DOPDFHQHV \ VXSHUPHUFDGLWRV SDUD YHQGHU GXOFHV GH (/&8$572'(/26'265(,126
%DULORFKH VHUD RWUR HO FDQWDU < KR\ \R VDEUD GLIHUHQFLDU
XQD PHUPHODGD GH PRUD GH XQD PHUPHODGD GH URVD 1R WHQJR GHPDVLDGD H[SHULHQFLD FRPR HVFULWRU SHUR
PRVTXHUD SHUR QR VDEUD QL SRU DVRPR TXH ߡKDPDFD VH VXSRQJRTXHHOFDSWXORGRVHVHOLQGLFDGRSDUDSUHVHQWDUD
HVFULEHFRQKDFKH ORV SHUVRQDMHV &XDQGR KDEOR GH SHUVRQDMHV PH UHILHUR D
$XQTXHVDEHUHVFULELUSDODEUDVQRHVWRGRHQODYLGDGH WRGRVORVTXHWRPDURQSDUWHHQODKLVWRULDGHVGHODSULPHUD
XQHVFULWRU7DPEL©QKD\TXHWHQHUDOJRSDUDFRQWDU<\RQR HVFDUDPX]D KDVWD HO DUPLVWLFLR PRMDGR $KRUD ELHQ ORV
PHHVWDUDWRPDQGRHOWUDEDMRGHHVFULELUORTXHHVFULER QL SHUVRQDMHV GH HVWD KLVWRULD VRQ PXFKRV YLYLPRV HQ XQ
WDOYH]XVWHGHVGHOHHUORTXHOHHQ VLQRIXHVHSRUTXHHVWR\ EDUULRSRSXORVR QRPHSDUHFHMXVWRTXHSUHWHQGDQTXHORV
FRQYHQFLGR GH TXH ©VWD HV XQD KLVWRULD TXH PHUHFH VHU QRPEUH D WRGRV 1R PH DOFDQ]DUD D P OD PHPRULD QL D
FRQWDGD8QDKLVWRULDHQFLHUWRPRGRH[WUDRUGLQDULD3RUTXH XVWHGHVODSDFLHQFLD(QFDPELRORTXHVPHSDUHFHMXVWR
QR KD\ QDGD GH H[WUDRUGLQDULR HQ TXH VH SHOHHQ XQ HVSUHVHQWDUOHVSRUORPHQRVD)HOLSH0XV\D&HFLOLD0XV
KHUPDQR\XQDKHUPDQD<PXFKRPHQRVH[WUDRUGLQDULRHV SRUTXH IXHURQ SUHFLVDPHQWH )HOLSH 0XV \ &HFLOLD 0XV ORV
TXHKD\DJXHUUDHQWUHODVFKLFDV\ORVYDURQHV3HURVHV TXHLQDXJXUDURQHOFRQIOLFWR7DQWRTXH)HOLSHPHUHFHUDHO
UDUR\KDVWDDVRPEURVRTXHHQXQEDUULRFXDOTXLHUDHQXQ QRPEUH GH 0RQVWUXR )XQGDGRU \ &HFLOLD HO GH +DGD
EDUULRFRPRHOQXHVWURTXHGHH[WUDRUGLQDULRQRWLHQHQDGD )XQGDGRUD
KD\D XQD YHUGDGHUD XQD DVRPEURVD EDWDOOD HQWUH ORV )HOLSH\&HFLOLDVRQKHUPDQRV\FXDOTXLHUDVDEHTXH\D
PRQVWUXRV\ODVKDGDVߋ HVR VROR HV XQ EXHQ PRWLYR SDUD SHOHDUVH 3HUR DGHP¡V
)HOLSH\&HFLOLDVRQODVDO\HOD]ºFDUODPRVWD]D\HOGXOFH
GHOHFKH7LHQHQJXVWRVPX\GLIHUHQWHV\GLIHUHQWHPRGRGH
6LOYLD0XVHVODPDGUHGH)HOLSH0XV\GH&HFLOLD0XVORVSURWDJRQLVWDV$OJXQRV
YHU ODV FRVDV < HVR GHVGH VLHPSUH 'HVGH TXH HUDQ
HVWDUDQWHQWDGRVGHOODPDUODߡPLSDWURQDSHURDPQRPHSDUHFHDSURSLDGRTXHVHOD FKLTXLWRV \ 6LOYLD 0XV ORV OOHYDED D WRPDU XQ KHODGR D
OODPHDV\DTXHPHFRQVLGHURLQGHSHQGLHQWH 1GHO3 &HFLOLDOHJXVWDEDHOGHIUXWLOOD\HOGHOLP³QOHKDFDVDOWDU
ODVO¡JULPDVD)HOLSHOHHQFDQWDEDHOGHOLP³Q\VLOOHJDED
DYHUXQDIUXWLOODHQVXKHODGRYRPLWDED
1R HV TXH )HOLSH \ &HFLOLD QR VH TXLHUDQ (Q PL RSLQL³Q
VH TXLHUHQ PXFKR \ KDVWD PH DQLPR D GHFLU TXH VH
4/34
DGPLUDQXQRDORWURHQVHFUHWR /RTXHVXFHGHHVTXHORV
GRV VRQ GH WHQHU LGHDV IXHUWHV < VHJºQ KH QRWDGR ODV
LGHDV PX\ IXHUWHV QR VXHOHQ GHMDU OXJDU SDUD RWUDV LGHDV
GLIHUHQWHV
3RUHVRODFXHVWL³QGHORV'RV5HLQRV
/RV 0XV YLYLPRV HQ XQD FDVD GLPLQXWD 3DUD TXH VH
KDJDQ XQD LGHD GH OR GLPLQXWD TXH HV SXHGR GHFLUOHV TXH
SDVDUGHODFRFLQDDOED±RQRUHTXLHUHP¡VHVIXHU]RTXHHO /DVYHQWDQDV\HOSODFDUGVHFRQVLGHUDQELHQHVFRPXQHV
GHVDFXGLUODVRUHMDVSDUDHVSDQWDUXQDPRVFD<TXHFDGD GH PRGR TXH )HOLSH OH FHGH XQR GH ORV YLGULRV D &HFLOLD
YH] TXH DOJXLHQ DEUH OD SXHUWD GHO KRUQR ORV GHP¡V SDUD TXH HOOD SHJXH VXV FDOFRPDQDV < HO SODFDUG VH
WHQHPRV TXH VDOLU DO SDWLR 6HEDVWL¡Q 0XV \ 6LOYLD 0XV UHSDUWH GHO VLJXLHQWH PRGR GRV FDMRQHV SDUD &HFLOLD GRV
GXHUPHQHQHOFRPHGRU TXHHQWUHSDU©QWHVLVHVWDPEL©Q FDMRQHV SDUD )HOLSH \ XQ HVWDQWH SDUD FDGD XQR 'H ODV
PL GRUPLWRULR DGHP¡V GH VHU VDOD HVFULWRULR \ GHVSHQVD VLHWH SHUFKDV &HFLOLD XVD FLQFR \ )HOLSH GRV TXH OH
SDUD ORV IUDVFRV GH GXOFH )HOLSH \ &HFLOLD FRPSDUWHQ HO DOFDQ]DQ\KDVWDOHVREUDQVLVHWLHQHHQFXHQWDTXH)HOLSH
RWURFXDUWR HVHOLQYHQWRUGHXQDQRYHGRVDW©FQLFDSDUDJXDUGDUODURSD
(VXQFXDUWRFKLFRFRPRSDUDXQDFDPD HQ IRUPD GH EROOLWRV $ FDPELR GH VXV SHUFKDV H[WUD
&HFLOLDSHUPLWHTXH)HOLSHJXDUGHVXSDWLQHWDHQOD]RQDGH
3HURORV0XVVRPRVPX\HPSHFLQDGRV\SXVLPRVGRV/D
ORV]DSDWRV
GH)HOLSHHVW¡XELFDGDGHEDMRGHODYHQWDQD\ODGH&HFLOLD
MXQWRDOSODFDUGFHUFDGHODSXHUWD<VLQHPEDUJRFKLFR\ 'HMDQGRGHODGRODYHQWDQD\HOSODFDUG)HOLSH\&HFLOLD
WRGRHOFXDUWRGDSDUDTXHKD\DGRVUHLQRV WLHQHQ SHUPLVR SDUD GHFRUDU VXV UHLQRV FRPR PHMRU OHV
SDUH]FD < HVR HV OR TXH KDFH TXH HO FXDUWR GH )HOLSH \
(QWUH XQD FDPD \ OD RWUD FDVL VLHPSUH KD\ XQD IURQWHUD
&HFLOLD VHD DOJR HVSHFLDO DOJR DYHQWXUHUR OR FRQYLHUWH HQ
TXHPDUFDHOOPLWHGHOD]RQDGHFDGDXQR$YHFHVHVV³OR
XQVLWLRTXHPHUHFHVHUHOFRPLHQ]RGHXQDKLVWRULD
XQD UD\D WUD]DGD FRQ WL]D EODQFD HQ HO VXHOR 2WUDV YHFHV
XQDILODGHODWDVYDULDVSLODVGHOLEURVRGRVEDQFRVDWDGRV 3XHGHQFUHHUPHFXDQGROHVGLJRTXHDWUDYHVDUHOFXDUWR
FRQ XQ SLROQ OD FXHVWL³Q HV VH±DODU KDVWD G³QGH OOHJD HO GHVGHODSXHUWD ]RQDGH&HFLOLD KDVWDODYHQWDQD ]RQDGH
UHLQRGH)HOLSH\FRPLHQ]DHOGH&HFLOLD\G³QGHWHUPLQDHO )HOLSH \ YXHOWD D OD SXHUWD HV XQD H[SHULHQFLD DOXFLQDQWH
GH&HFLOLDSDUDTXHHPSLHFHHOGH)HOLSH ,QFOXVRSDUDXQSHUURFRPR\RTXHKDWHQLGRXQDMXYHQWXG
FDOOHMHUD \ KD YLYLGR SRU OR WDQWR FLHUWDV DYHQWXUDV
HPRFLRQDQWHV TXH WDO YH] WHQJD RFDVL³Q GH FRQWDU DOJºQ
GDVLHVTXHOHWRPRHOJXVWLWRDHVWRGHQDUUDUKLVWRULDV
5/34
ERUGHV \ GHVSX©V VH SDVDED ORV UDWRV HOLJLHQGR HO PHMRU
VLWLR GRQGH SHJDU OD ILJXULWD (OOD OR OODPDED VX ߡ5DP³Q
)ORULGRߢ SRUTXH OH KDFD DFRUGDU D QR V© TX© KLVWRULD GH
DPRUH[DJHUDGRGH©VDVTXHDHOODOHHQFDQWDOHHU&HUFD
GHO 5DP³Q HVWDEDQ ORV 3DSHOLWRV $]XOHV /RV 3DSHOLWRV
(/5$0Ð1)/25,'2 $]XOHVVLUYHQFRPR\DYHUHPRVOXHJRSDUDFRFLQDUKDGDV
(UDOLQGRHQWUDU\YHUWDQWDVIORUHVDOO¡HQHOIRQGR(OFXDUWR
SDUHFDPXFKRP¡VJUDQGH
&HFLOLD HV HQFDQWDGRUD 6LHPSUH TXH OD YHR UHFRUWDQGR
FRQ VX WLMHULWD IRWRV GH IORUHV GH ODV UHYLVWDV SDUD SHJDUODV
HQVXSDUHGSLHQVRTXHHVODFKLFDP¡VOLQGDGHOEDUULR<D
KHPRV WHQLGR DOJXQDV GLVFXVLRQHV FRQ RWURV SHUURV DO
UHVSHFWR &LULOR HO SHUUR GHO FDUQLFHUR GLFH TXH WLHQH OD
QDUL] GHPDVLDGR FKDWD \ ORV GLHQWHV XQ SRFR VHSDUDGRV
3HUR HVW¡ FODUR TXH HVR QR WLHQH OD PHQRU LPSRUWDQFLD
%DVWD YHUOD FRQ VXV FDEHOORV EULOODQWHV VXV KHELOODV HQ
IRUPD GH PDULSRVD \ VXV RMRV OOHQRV GH SHVWD±DV SDUD
GHFUHWDUTXHHVXQHQFDQWR8QDYHUGDGHUDKDGDQLP¡VQL
PHQRV ,JXDOLWD D ODV TXH GLEXMDQ HQ ORV OLEURV GH FXHQWRV
(V FLHUWR TXH DKRUD \D QR XVD HVDV KHELOODV VLQR TXH
PXFKDV YHFHV VH UHFRJH HO SHOR FRQ XQD WUHQ]D GH ODQD
KDVWDTXHSDUHFHXQFKRUURGHDJXDEURW¡QGROHGHODFLPD
GH OD FDEH]D SHUR VLJXH VLHQGR GH WRGDV IRUPDV OD P¡V
OLQGDGHWRGDV
3DUDOD©SRFDHQTXHFRPHQ]³HVWDKLVWRULDHOUHLQRGH &HFLOLD PH VDEH UDVFDU ODV RUHMDV FRPR QDGLH $ YHFHV
&HFLOLDHVWDEDSLQWDGRGHURVDGHEODQFR\GHD]XO <HQ FXDQGRHVW¡XQSRFRWULVWHRXQSRFRVRODPHOODPD\QRV
ODSDUHGGHOIRQGRKDEDXQJUDQUDPRGHIORUHV/HKDED WLUDPRV ORV GRV HQ OD FDPD HOOD FRQ ORV SLHV HQ OD
OOHYDGR PHVHV \ PHVHV FRQVWUXLUOR UHFRUWDED MD]PLQHV DOPRKDGD SDUD SRGHU YHU HO 5DP³Q )ORULGR HO QXHYR
FULVDQWHPRV PDUJDULWDV FODYHOHV PDOYRQHV JLUDVROHV \ SRUTXHHODQWLJXRVXIUL³ODVFRQVHFXHQFLDVGHODJXHUUD \
D]XFHQDV TXH HQFRQWUDED GLEXMDGRV R IRWRJUDILDGRV HQ \R HQ PL SRVLFL³Q IDYRULWD FRQ OD FDEH]D DSR\DGD HQ VX
GLDULRV \ UHYLVWDV YLHMRV \ ORV LED SHJDQGR GH D SRFR 1R SDQ]D \ ORV RMRV HQWUHFHUUDGRV HVSHUDQGR HO PRPHQWR
WHQD DSXUR /H JXVWDED UHFRUWDU FRQ PXFKR FXLGDGR ORV PDUDYLOORVR HQ TXH HOOD HPSLHFH D UDVFDUPH ODV RUHMDV
6/34
VXDYHFLWRVXDYHFLWR
1RVRWURVORVSHUURVGHVFUHHPRVGHORVFRORUHV\HVV³ORHQFRQFHVL³QDPLVOHFWRUHV
TXHLPDJLQRVREUHWRGRKXPDQRVTXHXVRSDODEUDVFRPRߡURVDߢRߡD]XODODVTXH
SDUHFHQGDUYD\DXQRDVDEHUSRUTX©WDQWDLPSRUWDQFLD 1GHO3 /26$6&26</26021675826
'HORWURODGRGHODIURQWHUDODVFRVDVVRQPX\GLIHUHQWHV
6L KD\ DOJR TXH )HOLSH 0XV GHWHVW³ VLHPSUH VRQ ODV IORUHV
FRQTXH&HFLOLDOOHQDODVSDUHGHV
(OUHLQRGH)HOLSHHUDPX\RWUDFRVD3DUDHPSH]DUQDGD
GH EODQFR URVD R D]XO 8QD SDUHG URMD \ OD RWUD YLROHWD \
URJ³ \ URJ³ KDVWD TXH OH GLHURQ SHUPLVR SDUD SLQWDU XQ
SHGD]R HOTXHFRQWHQDODFROHFFL³Q bGHQHJUR6LOYLD0XV
VXVSLUDED\GHFDTXHMDP¡VLEDQDSRGHUYROYHUDGDUOHXQ
FRORU GHFHQWH D XQD SDUHG TXH IXH QHJUD SHUR 6HEDVWL¡Q
0XV LQVLVWL³ HQ TXH )HOLSH VH GLHUD HO JXVWR (Q ILQ TXH OD
SDUHGQHJUDGH)HOLSHIXHPRWLYRGHXQDP¡VGHODVWDQWDV
SHOHDV D TXH QRV WLHQHQ DFRVWXPEUDGRV ORV 0XV (VR KL]R
TXH &HFLOLD OD GHWHVWDUD HVSHFLDOPHQWH \ TXH )HOLSH VH
DSXUDUD D SHJDUOH HQFLPD VX FROHFFL³Q GH $VFRV \ GH
0RQVWUXRV
(Q UHDOLGDG OD FROHFFL³Q GH $VFRV \ GH 0RQVWUXRV QR
SHUWHQHFH V³OR D )HOLSH WDPEL©Q SHUWHQHFH D VX DPLJR
$QWRQLR %XUUXFKDJD DOLDV %XUUXFKD /D IXHURQ DUPDQGR
MXQWRV (PSH]DURQ KDFH XQ EXHQ WLHPSR FXDQGR HVWDEDQ
WHUPLQDQGRWHUFHUJUDGRVLPDOQRUHFXHUGR3HURDXQTXH
OD FROHFFL³Q OHV SHUWHQHFH D ORV GRV HO PXVHR HVWXYR
VLHPSUHH[FOXVLYDPHQWHHQFDVDGH)HOLSH(OGDHQTXHDO
SREUH%XUUXFKDVHOHRFXUUL³SHJDUXQRGHVXV$VFRVHQHO
YLGULR GH VX YHQWDQD OD PDGUH WXYR XQ DWDTXH GH QHUYLRV
7/34
YHUGDGHUDPHQWH HVSDQWRVR 7DQ HVSDQWRVR TXH %XUUXFKD GLFHQHVDVRHVDV¡RWLHQHORVGLHQWHVDV\ODVSLHUQDV
FRPSUHQGL³GHXQDYH]\SDUDVLHPSUHTXHQRV³ORHVWDED DV¡SRUTXHRSLQDQTXHORVPRQVWUXRVVRQFRVDVSULYDGDV
FRQGHQDGR D QR DQGDU MDP¡V HQ SDWLQHWD D QR YLYLU MDP¡V 'XUDQWH XQ WLHPSR WHPEODEDQ GH V³OR SHQVDU HQ ORV
FRQ XQ SHUUR XQ JDWR XQ UDWRQFLWR R WDQ VLTXLHUD XQD 'UXERQJRV 'HVFRVLGRV \ OHV FRUUD XQ VXGRU IUR FXDQGR
WRUWXJD \ D QR WRPDU MDP¡V OHFKH FKRFRODWDGD VLQR TXH KDEODEDQGHORV$OLFLRWHV)UXPRVLHQWRV3HURFRQHOWLHPSR
DGHP¡VMDP¡VQXQFD\SRUQLQJºQPRWLYRSRGUDSHJDUHQ ORV GRV FRLQFLGLHURQ HQ TXH HO JUDQ PRQVWUXR HO PRQVWUXR
VX FXDUWR QL XQ VROR $VTXLWR SDUD QR KDEODU GH ORV GH WRGRV ORV PRQVWUXRV HO P¡V WHPLEOH HUD HO &RORI³Q
DWHUUDGRUHV5HFXHUGRVGHO0RQVWUXR 'HILQLWLYR 'H PRGR TXH OH GHGLFDURQ D ©O FDVL WRGRV ORV
(V SRU HVR TXH %XUUXFKD VXHOH SDVDUVH ODV WDUGHV DTX SHQVDPLHQWRV
DXQTXH WLHQH XQ FXDUWR WUHV YHFHV P¡V JUDQGH TXH HO GH
)HOLSH
/RV$VFRVVHGLYLGHQHQGRVFODVHV(VW¡QORV$VFRVSDUD
0LUDU \ ORV ,PDJQDWH /RV $VFRV SDUD 0LUDU VRQ XQRV
KHUPRVRV GLEXMRV \ FROODJHV TXH KDFHQ )HOLSH \ %XUUXFKD
ORV GDV GH OOXYLD 3RU HMHPSOR XQ KRPEUH TXH HQ YH] GH
RMRVWLHQHGRVOHQJXDV\XQDILODGHFDUDFROLWRVTXHOHVDOHQ
GHODJXMHURGHODQDUL]\VHOHYDQPHWLHQGRSRUORVDJXMHURV
GH ODV RUHMDV /RV ,PDJLQDWH HQ FDPELR VRQ VXJHUHQFLDV
HQ IRUPD GH JUDIILWL TXH HVFULEHQ FRQ WL]D EODQFD VREUH OD
SDUHGQHJUD6LHPSUHHPSLH]DQFRQߡ,PDJQDWHTXHߢ3RU
HMHPSORߡ,PDJQDWHTXHHVW¡VSRUSLQFKDUXQDSDSDIULWD\
HOWHQHGRUVHWHFRQYLHUWHHQPRFRߢ $PLPRGRGHYHUORV
,PDJQDWH VRQ PXFKVLPR P¡V DVTXHURVRV TXH ORV $VFRV (Q OD SDUHG QHJUD GH )HOLSH 0XV KDED SHJDGRV SDUD
SDUD0LUDU FXDQGR FRPHQ]³ HVWD KLVWRULD GLHFLRFKR $VFRV ߚVLHWH
< GHVSX©V HVW¡Q ORV 0RQVWUXRV &XPSOHQ IXQFLRQHV $VFRV SDUD 0LUDU \ RQFH ,PDJLQDUHVߚ \ VLHWH 5HFXHUGRV
GLIHUHQWHV ORV $VFRV VRQ SDUD UHSXJQDU \ ORV 0RQVWUXRV GHO 0RQVWUXR WRGRV UHIHULGRV SRU VXSXHVWR DO &RORI³Q
SDUDGDUPLHGR 'HILQLWLYR 3RU HMHPSOR KDED XQ GLEXMR GH XQ KXHYR \
$ GLIHUHQFLD GH ORV $VFRV ORV 0RQVWUXRV VRQ QDGD P¡V GHEDMR GHFD ߡ(O KXHYR D]XO TXH SXVR OD ºOWLPD JDOOLQD
TXHXQQRPEUH$)HOLSH\D%XUUXFKDOHVHQFDQWDLQYHQWDU EDWDUD]DºQLFDVREUHYLYLHQWHGHODWHUFHUDPDVDFUHOOHYDGD
QRPEUHV DWHUUDGRUHV 'HVSX©V VH TXHGDQ ORV GRV HQ DFDERSRUHO&RORI³Q'HILQLWLYRߢ2XQDJUDQPDQFKDHQWUH
VLOHQFLR SHQVDQGR HQ HO PRQVWUXR DO TXH FRUUHVSRQGH HVH YLROHWD \ YHUGRVD \ OXHJR XQD IOHFKD \ OHWUDV JUXHVDV
QRPEUH 3HUR QXQFD FRPSDUDQ VXV SHQVDPLHQWRV MDP¡V GRQGH GHFD ߡ6RPEUD TXH GHMD OD VRPEUD GHO PDQWR GHO
8/34
&RORI³Q 'HILQLWLYRߢ (Q UHDOLGDG VRVSHFKR TXH )HOLSH \
$QWRQLR QR WHQDQ OD PHQRU LGHD GH F³PR SRGD VHU OD
VRPEUDGHXQDVRPEUDSHURVHJXUDPHQWHOHVSDUHFL³XQD
I³UPXOD DSURSLDGD SDUD GHMDU WRGR HQ HO P¡V FRPSOHWR
PLVWHULR
&XDOTXLHUD SRGUD SHQVDU TXH XQ FKLFR WDQ DIHFWR D ORV &2&,1$1'2+$'$6
$VFRV\ORV0RQVWUXRVUHVXOWDUDSRFRFDUL±RVR3HURQRHV
DV)HOLSH0XVHVFUHRPLPHMRUDPLJR1RFRQR]FRQDGLH
TXHVHSDMXJDUPHMRUTXH©ODOWLUD\DIORMDFRQXQWUDSLWRb< 'XUDQWH XQ WLHPSR \R HVWDED FRQYHQFLGR GH TXH 9LROHWD
KHPRVSHOHDGRDOJXQDVHVSO©QGLGDVEDWDOODVHQFLPDGHVX VH DSHOOLGDED 0LPHMRUDPLJD SRUTXH &HFLOLD VLHPSUH OD
FDPD 3XHGHQ FUHHUPH TXH VDEH SHOHDU D YHFHV SLHQVR OODPDEDDVFXDQGRLEDQDOMDUGQGHLQIDQWHV
TXH ELHQ PHUHFHUD VHU XQ SHUUR 6LHPSUH WHUPLQDPRV ߚ+R\TXLHURTXHYHQJDDMXJDU9LROHWD0LPHMRUDPLJDߚ
HPSDWDGRV FDQVDGRV \ FRQWHQWRV ©O UL©QGRVH \R GHFD
PRYLHQGRODFROD\ORVGRVPLUDQGRFRQRUJXOORODSDUHGGH
&HFLOLD\9LROHWDWLHQHQQXHYHDKRUD\FRPRVRQDPLJDV
ORV$VFRVPLHQWUDVLQWHQWDPRVUHFXSHUDUHODOLHQWR
GHVGH ORV FLQFR VXSRQJR TXH \D VH KDEU¡Q FDQVDGR GH
(QILQTXHKD\GDVHQTXHQDGDPHKDFHP¡VIHOL]TXH MXJDUDWRGRVORVMXHJRV3HURPHGR\FXHQWDGHTXHKD\XQ
XQD VLHVWD MXQWR DO +DGD \ RWURV GDV HQ TXH SUHILHUR XQD MXHJR XQ MXHJR YLHMR GHO TXH QR VH FDQVDQ QXQFD DO TXH
UHYROFDGD FRQ HO 0RQVWUXR < HVR PH FRQYLHUWH FRPR VH VLHPSUH YXHOYHQ D MXJDU (V XQD HVSHFLH GH VHFUHWR HQWUH
SRGU¡Q XVWHGHV LPDJLQDU HQ WHVWLJR FDVL LPSDUFLDO GH HVWD HOODVOROODPDQߡ&RFLQDQGRKDGDVߢ
VLQJXODUJXHUUD
ߚ'DOHYDPRVDFRFLQDUKDGDVߚGLFH&HFLOLD
<9LROHWDVLHPSUHHVW¡GLVSXHVWD
(QPLRSLQL³QQRKD\MXHJRTXHOHVGHP¡VDOHJUDTXH
©VH &XDQGR WHQDQ FLQFR VH SDUHFD DO MXHJR GH KDFHU
FRPLGDV GH PHQWLUD \ VH OODPDED OD ߡFRPLGLWD GHO KDGDߢ
&RLQFLGRFRQ6LOYLD0XVHQTXHHUDXQYHUGDGHURHQFKDVWUH
PH]FODEDQDJXDD]ºFDUSDSHOLWRVYLQDJUHSHOXVDVEROLWDV
GHSODVWLOLQDJDOOHWLWDVWULWXUDGDVILGHRV\WDPEL©QPHFRUUH
XQ IUR SRU HO ORPR GH V³OR UHFRUGDUOR bSHOLWRV GH SHUURV
ERQGDGRVRV \ SDFLHQWHV 6H PH]FODED WRGR ELHQ VH GHFD
DEUDFDGDEUDRDOJRSRUHOHVWLOR\TXHGDEDOLVWDODߡFRPLGLWD
GHO KDGDߢ &RQ HVH PHMXQMH VH SRGD FRQVHJXLU FXDOTXLHU
9/34
PLODJUR5HFXHUGRHOGDHQTXH&HFLOLDPHORHFK³VREUHOD EROVLOORXQRVFXDQWRVGHFRORUYHUGH
FDEH]D PLHQWUDV 9LROHWD VDOWDED HQFLPD GHO FROFK³Q \ ߚb6RQYHUGHVߚSURWHVW³&HFLOLD
JULWDED ߚ%XHQR D]XOHV OR TXH VH GLFH D]XOHV QR VRQ SHUR XQ
ߚb4XHWHFRQYLHUWDVHQJDWRb4XHWHFRQYLHUWDVHQJDWR SRFRD]XOHVVVRQSRUTXHVRQYHUGHV
b4XHWHFRQYLHUWDVHQJDWR $V TXH HVW¡ ELHQ GHFLU TXH VRQ D]XOHV SRUTXH VRQ
/D KXPLOODFL³Q \ HO YLQDJUH TXH VH PH HVFXUUL³ VREUH HO YHUGHV\ODVFRVDVYHUGHVWDPEL©QVRQD]XOHVHQHOIRQGR
RMRPHKLFLHURQVXIULUEDVWDQWH
&RQHOFRUUHUGHORVD±RVHOMXHJRVHIXHWUDQVIRUPDQGR &HFLOLD QR GLMR QDGD P¡V &UHR TXH IXH SUXGHQWH GH VX
<DQRVHWUDWDEDGHFRFLQDUODߡFRPLGLWDGHOKDGDߢVLQROLVD SDUWH 9LROHWD WLHQH HVH GHIHFWR HV PX\ GLVFXWLGRUD (Q
\ OODQDPHQWH GH ߡFRFLQDU KDGDVߢ $OJR VXPDPHQWH FXDQWR DOJXLHQ OD FRQWUDGLFH OHYDQWD OD SXQWD GH ODV FHMDV
SHOLJURVR SDUD ORV KXPDQRV DO SXQWR GH VHU FDSD] FRPR KDFLD DUULED KDVWD TXH OH IRUPDQ XQD YH FRUWD DO UHY©V \
YHUHPRV GH GHVHQFDGHQDU XQD JXHUUD SHUR SRU IRUWXQD HPSLH]DDGLVFXWLU<GLVFXWH\GLVFXWH\QRSDUDGHGLVFXWLU
WRWDOPHQWHLQRIHQVLYRSDUDORVSHUURV KDVWD TXH FRQVLGHUD TXH \D JDQ³ OD GLVFXVL³Q 6H SXHGH
3DUDGDUOHVXQDLGHDGHF³PRVHFRFLQDQODVKDGDVYR\D SDVDU KRUDV GLVFXWLHQGR XQD YH] TXH SXVR HO PRWRU HQ
WUDWDU GH UHFRQVWUXLU OR PHMRU SRVLEOH OR TXH VXFHGL³ HQ HO PDUFKDHVPX\GLIFLOGHWHQHUOD
&XDUWRGHORV'RV5HLQRVHOGDGHODSULPHUDHVFDUDPX]D $VTXH&HFLOLDSUHILUL³FDOODUVH\SXVRORVSDSHOLWRVHQHO
(Q UHDOLGDG HO FXDUWR HVWDED VXSHUSREODGR HVD WDUGH VXHOR /RV 3DSHOLWRV $]XOHV VRQ ORV LQJUHGLHQWHV SDUD
©UDPRVFLQFR&RUUD RVHDUUDVWUDEDP¡VELHQ HOPHVGH FRFLQDU ODV KDGDV /RV 3DSHOLWRV \ WDPEL©Q HO 5DP³Q
GLFLHPEUHOORYD\KDFDXQFDORUHVSDQWRVR<RQRSDUDED )ORULGRDXQTXHHO5DP³Q)ORULGRHQUHDOLGDGV³OROHVVLUYH
GH VDFXGLU ODV RUHMDV SDUD HVSDQWDUPH ODV PRVFDV (Q OD GH DORMDPLHQWR D ODV KDGDV SHUR SULPHUR KD\ TXH
]RQDGHODYHQWDQD)HOLSH\%XUUXFKDLQWHQWDURQXQFDEH]D FRFLQDUODV
GHXQDSXQWDDODRWUDGHODFDPDSHURODSHORWDQRSDUHFD <D QR XVDQ YLQDJUH QL ILGHRV FRPR DQWHV SHUR VLJXHQ
GLVSXHVWD D MXJDU FRPR HV GHELGR HQ XQD FDQFKD WDQ XVDQGR SDSHOLWRV 6³OR TXH DKRUD ORV SDSHOLWRV WLHQHQ
PQLPD \ VH OD SDVDED HVWUHOO¡QGRVH FRQWUD HO YHODGRU 'H SDODEUDV ORV QRPEUHV GH ORV LQJUHGLHQWHV FRQ TXH VH
PRGR TXH VH VHQWDURQ ORV GRV HQ HO VXHOR FRQ XQ SDSHO FRFLQDQ ODV KDGDV 3RU HMHPSOR ORV SDSHOLWRV QXHYRV TXH
WUDWDQGRGHLQVSLUDUVHSDUDGLEXMDUXQ$VFRYHUGDGHUDPHQWH KDEDWUDGR
LQPXQGRRVHDFDSD]GHHVFDQGDOL]DUD&HFLOLD\D9LROHWD 9LROHWD GHFDQ 2-26 '( )8(*2 0$5,326$
(QWUHWDQWRHQHOUHLQRGHDOODGR&HFLOLD\9LROHWD\DVH 1(*5$81$-$8/$(1(/620%5(52
KDEDQFDQVDGRGHOURPSHFDEH]DV\VHGLVSRQDQDFRFLQDU ߚ<RKLFHGRVߚGLMR&HFLOLD\OH\³EDMDQGRODYR]SRUTXH
KDGDV QRW³TXHHQHORWURUHLQR)HOLSH\%XUUXFKDSDUDEDQODRUHMD
ߚ7UDMH P¡V 3DSHOLWRV $]XOHV ߚGLMR 9LROHWD \ VDF³ GHO ߚ3(/2'(/81$<3,(6&21$/$6
10/34
ߚ3(/2'(/81$HVP¡VELHQWULVWHQR"ߚGLMR9LROHWD &HFLOLD GH &DUPHQ OD GH OD URVD 'HVSX©V XQ GD
ߚ<DWHGLMHTXHDPQRPHJXVWDTXHODVKD GHVDSDUHFHQ\\DQRVHYXHOYHDKDEODUGHHOODV
ߚb6VVVKKKKKK ߚGLMR &HFLOLD KDFL©QGROH XQD VH±D HQ
GLUHFFL³Q DO UHLQR GH )HOLSH GRQGH KDED XQ VLOHQFLR PX\
VRVSHFKRVR
ߚQRPHJXVWDTXHODVߡKDFKHVߢߚ\VXEUD\³FRQODYR]
ODSDODEUDߚQRVVDOJDQWULVWHV /DGHODVHPDQDSDVDGD
VTXHHUDVLPS¡WLFDWRGDGHDPDULOORFRQSHTXLWDV
ߚ6 SRUTXH OH SXVLPRV XQD PRFKLOD FRQ EHUHQMHQDV \
HUDHVRORTXHQRVGDEDULVDSRUHVRQRVVDOL³WDQDOHJUH
3HURVHPDQG³DPXGDUHQVHJXLGDRQR"$PPHJXVWD
TXHVHDQXQSRFRWULVWHVRXQSRFRWHUULEOHV/DVWULVWHVVH
TXHGDQ P¡V VRQ P¡V FDUL±RVDV b< ODV WHUULEOHV VRQ WDQ
HPRFLRQDQWHV
< MXVWR FXDQGR 9LROHWD HVWDED SRU HPSH]DU D GLVFXWLU OD
DWDM³GLFLHQGR
ߚ%XHQRWUDLJRODFDFHUROD"
ߚ'DOHWUDHOD
3HUR ORV TXH V HVWDEDQ VRUSUHQGLGRV HUDQ )HOLSH \
)XH HVH GD SUHFLVDPHQWH TXH GHVSX©V GH PXFKDV %XUUXFKD TXH GHVGH VX SXHVWR HQ HO UHLQR GH ORV
GLVFXVLRQHVHQYR]EDMDFRFLQDURQD0DULDQD/HSXVLHURQ PRQVWUXRV SUHVWDEDQ JUDQ DWHQFL³Q D OR TXH HVWDED
0DULDQDSRUTXHD9LROHWDOHKDFDDFRUGDUDVXWDTXHHUD VXFHGLHQGRHQHOSDVYHFLQR
LJXDOGHYRODGRUD\WDPEL©QWHQDHOSHORXQSRFRDOXQDGR
7DOYH]VHDGLIFLOGHFUHHUTXH©VWDIXHUDODSULPHUDYH]
$ P QR PH VRUSUHQGL³ GHPDVLDGR SRUTXH ODV KH YLVWR TXH )HOLSH YHD D VX KHUPDQD FRFLQDQGR KDGDV 3HUR OR
FRFLQDUXQPRQW³QGHKDGDVHQWRGRVHVWRVD±RV6LHPSUH FLHUWR HV TXH IXH OD SULPHUD YH] TXH SUHVW³ DWHQFL³Q D OR
HV P¡V R PHQRV LJXDO ODV FRFLQDQ OHV LQYHQWDQ DOJXQD TXHHVWDEDVXFHGLHQGRDOODGR6LPHSUHJXQWDQDPGLUD
KLVWRULD\GHVSX©VODVPDQGDQDYLYLUHQDOJXQDGHODVIORUHV TXH OR TXH VRUSUHQGL³ D )HOLSH \ WDPEL©Q D %XUUXFKD VX
GHO 5DP³Q )ORULGR VL VRQ GH WHPSHUDPHQWR IXHUWH D ODV DPLJR IXH TXH ODV FKLFDV ODV PXMHUHV GH DO ODGR IXHVHQ
URVDV SRU HMHPSOR VL VRQ WPLGDV D ODV PDUJDULWDV < DK FDSDFHV GH LQYHQWDU KDGDV GHO PLVPR PRGR HQ TXH HOORV
VHTXHGDQODVKDGDVLQYHQWDGDV'XUDQWHXQWLHPSRVLUYHQ LQYHQWDEDQ $VFRV \ 0RQVWUXRV &UHR TXH ORV SREUHV
SDUD MXJDU D GLYHUVRV MXHJRV 9LROHWD VH GLVIUD]D GH 2OJD HVWDEDQFRQYHQFLGRVGHTXHHQHOUHLQRGHDOODGRV³ORVH
SRU HMHPSOR TXH IXH XQ KDGD TXH QRV GXU³ EDVWDQWH \ MXJDEDDVHUDPDGHFDVD
11/34
< HVR SRUTXH )HOLSH VLHPSUH PRVWU³ VXV $VFRV \ VXV
5HFXHUGRV GHO 0RQVWUXR VLQ QLQJXQD YHUJ¼HQ]D SHUR
&HFLOLDHQFDPELRVLHPSUHHVFRQGL³VXVKDGDV
< VL PH YROYLHUDQ D SUHJXQWDU WDPEL©Q GLUD TXH IXH SRU
HVRTXHORVYDURQHVHPSH]DURQDEXUODUVH3RUTXHOHVGLR
UDELDTXHIXHUDWDQLQWHUHVDQWHORTXHVXFHGDGHORWURODGR £*8(55$
'LJDQTXHUDUDYH]QRVFRQVXOWDQDQRVRWURVORVSHUURVb\
HVR TXH SRFRV VDEHQ P¡V TXH QRVRWURV DFHUFD GH ORV
KXPDQRV(VORTXHFRPHQW¡EDPRVFRQORVDPLJRVHORWUR 0DULDQD \D HVWDED FDVL OLVWD FXDQGR HPSH]DURQ ODV
GDHQODSXHUWDGHODFDUQLFHUDODJXHUUDHQWUHORVYDURQHV KRVWLOLGDGHV &HFLOLD \ 9LROHWD FXFKLFKHDEDQ HQWUH HOODV VLQ
\ ODV PXMHUHV HV SRU HQYLGLD SRUTXH VH HQYLGLDQ ORV SUHVWDUPXFKDDWHQFL³QDORTXHHVWDEDVXFHGLHQGRGHORWUR
VHFUHWRV ODGR GH OD IURQWHUD QR WHUPLQDEDQ GH SRQHUVH GH DFXHUGR
FRQUHVSHFWRDTX©IORUGHO5DP³QOHSRGDFRUUHVSRQGHUD
XQ KDGD WDQ HVSHFLDO 2SLQDEDQ TXH 0DULDQD HUD OD PHMRU
2WUDGHODVDEVXUGDVSHOHDVHQWUHKXPDQRV 1GHO3 KDGD TXH KDEDQ FRFLQDGR HQ WRGD VX YLGD (UD PX\
&HFLOLD\9LROHWDOODPDQߡKDFKHVߢDODVKDGDVFXDQGRQRTXLHUHQTXH)HOLSH\ KHUPRVD&RQHVDMDXODHQFLPDGHODFDEH]DSDUDDWUDSDU
%XUUXFKDHQWLHQGDQGHTX©HVW¡QKDEODQGR$PLPHSDUHFHXQVHXG³QLPRDSURSLDGR ORV VXH±RV TXH VH OH HVFDSDEDQ DO GHVSHUWDU < HVH SHOR
SRUTXHODVKDGDVVRQLQYLVLEOHV\ODVKDFKHVVRQPXGDV 1GHO3
KHFKR WRGR GH OXQDV PHQJXDQWHV < HVRV RMRV QHJURV \
SHOLJURVRV GH ORV TXH VDODQ FKRUURV GH IXHJR GH YHUGDG
FXDQGR VH HQRMDED < HVD PDULSRVD QHJUD TXH VLHPSUH OD
DQGDEDURQGDQGR\HVDVDODVHQORVSLHVTXHODKDFDQVHU
WDQVLOHQFLRVD\OHSHUPLWDQYRODUWDQEDMLWR
12/34
7HQD XQD UDELD HQRUPH \ ORV RMRV OOHQRV GH O¡JULPDV
3HUR QR OORU³ VH SDU³ HQFLPD GH VX FDPD \ JULW³ HQ
GLUHFFL³QDOUHLQRGHVXKHUPDQR
ߚb7H RGLR )HOLSH 0XV b7H RGLR WH RGLR \ WH RGLR b< WH
GHFODURODJXHUUD
13/34
2&83$1'2(/7(55,725,2(1(0,*2
(QUHDOLGDGQLQJXQRGHQRVRWURVWHQDODPHQRULGHDGHD
TX©VHUHIHUD&HFLOLDFRQHVRGHTXHOHGHFODUDEDODJXHUUD
DVXKHUPDQR3RUPLSDUWHHVWDEDFRQYHQFLGRGHTXHWRGR
KDED WHUPLQDGR DK +XELHUD MXUDGR TXH PHGLD KRUD
GHVSX©V HVWDUDPRV ORV FLQFR VHQWDGRV WRPDQGR OD OHFKH
\RORP¡VFHUFDSRVLEOHGHO%XUUXFKDSRUTXHVLHPSUHGHMD 'HER FRQIHVDU TXH GXUDQWH OD PHULHQGD )HOLSH \
DEDQGRQDGRVMXQWRDODWD]DORVUHERUGHVFURFDQWLWRVGHODV %XUUXFKD VH ULHURQ EDVWDQWH \ TXH \R PRY OD FROD FDVL
WRVWDGDV TXH VRQ FDVXDOPHQWH PL PHULHQGD IDYRULWD LQLQWHUUXPSLGDPHQWH GDGRTXHSRUDXVHQFLDGHODVFKLFDV
+DEDSUHVHQFLDGRQRXQDVLQRPLOSHOHDVHQWUH)HOLSH0XV %XUUXFKDFRPL³FXDWURWRVWDGDVHQOXJDUGHGRV\PHGHM³
\&HFLOLD0XV\MDP¡VKDEDYLVWRTXHSDVDUDQDPD\RUHV SRU OR WDQWR GREOH UDFL³Q GH UHERUGHV FURFDQWHV 3HUR
3HURHVWDYH]IXHGLIHUHQWH PHQWLUDVLGLMHUDTXHQRVHVWXYLPRVULHQGRGHHOODVRGHVXV
&XDQGR VH R\³ OD YR] GH 6LOYLD 0XV OODP¡QGRQRV D OD KDGDVFRFLGDV1LVLTXLHUDHVWXYLPRVKDEODQGRGHPXMHUHV
FRFLQD&HFLOLDJULW³GHLQPHGLDWRTXHHOODQRWHQDKDPEUH 'HORTXHKDEODEDQ)HOLSH\%XUUXFKDHUDGHODJXLWDUUDTXH
< 9LROHWD VH VROLGDUL]³ SRU VXSXHVWR 6³OR IXLPRV )HOLSH KDEDQ YLVWR HQ XQD YLGULHUD GH OD DYHQLGD FHUFD GHO ORFDO
%XUUXFKD bSRU VXHUWH \ \R VRQUL©QGROH D %XUUXFKD SDUD GH ORV YLGHRMXHJRV < \R VHJºQ HV PL FRVWXPEUH QR
PLV DGHQWURV VH IXH HO SULPHU HUURU GH )HOLSH GHMDU HO KDEODED
FDPSRDEDQGRQDGR 'H PRGR TXH FXDQGR UHJUHVDPRV DO FXDUWR HVW¡EDPRV
GLVWUDGRV\FRQODFDEH]DHQRWUDFRVD
$SDUHQWHPHQWH QR VXFHGD QDGD &HFLOLD \ 9LROHWD
HVWDEDQHQKHEUDQGRORVFDUDFROLWRVTXHKDEDWUDGR9LROHWD
GHODSOD\DHOD±RDQWHULRUSDUDFRQYHUWLUORVHQFROODUHV<R
DQGDED FRQ JDQDV GH XQD EXHQD VLHVWD GHVSX©V GH XQD
PHULHQGD WDQ DEXQGDQWH GH PRGR TXH PH LQVWDO© HQ OD
14/34
]RQDGHODVKDGDVTXHHVHQJHQHUDOP¡VWUDQTXLODTXHOD
GHORVPRQVWUXRV\PHTXHG©GRUPLGRDOLQVWDQWH
0HGHVSHUW³XQJULWRIXULEXQGR(UD)HOLSH
ߚ4XL©QSHJ³HVWRHQPLSDUHG"
6LOHQFLR
1R WXYH P¡V UHPHGLR TXH LU D YHU SRU PL FXHQWD (UD
FLHUWR 'HVGH OD YHQWDQD \ HQ GLUHFFL³Q D OD SDUHG QHJUD
KDVWD HO PLVPVLPR FRUD]³Q GH ORV $VFRV KDED XQD
SULPRURVD JXLUQDOGD GH IORUHV 1R PH FRVW³ UHFRQRFHU ODV
TXH &HFLOLD KDED HVWDGR UHFRUWDQGR FRQ WRGR HVPHUR HO
GRPLQJR \ JXDUGDGR DGHQWUR GH XQ FXDGHUQR 1R SXGH
PHQRV TXH HFKDUOH XQD RMHDGD GH DGPLUDFL³Q GH PRGR
TXHODGXOFHODVLOHQFLRVD&HFLOLDHUDFDSD]GHJDVWDUVHHQ
XQD VROD YHQJDQ]D ODV IORUHV TXH OOHYDED VHPDQDV
DWHVRUDQGR SDUD HQULTXHFHU VX 5DP³Q )ORULGR" 3RU HVR OH
GHFDD&LULORHORWURGDTXHMDP¡VWHUPLQDU©GHHQWHQGHUD &HFLOLDORPLU³\VHVRQUL³ bHVWDFKLFDPHGHVFRQFLHUWD
ODVPXMHUHV \PXFKRPHWHPRTXHWDPSRFRDODVSHUULWDV ߚ64XHGDOLQGRQRHVFLHUWR"
1XHYDLQYHVWLJDFL³QGH)HOLSH )XH XQD VXHUWH TXH GHMDUD GH OORYHU \ TXH WRGRV
ߚ&HFLOLDYRVSHJDVWHHVWRHQPLSDUHG" SXGL©UDPRV VDOLU SRU ILQ GH HVH FXDUWR GRQGH IORWDED \
VHJXLUDIORWDQGR XQHVSDQWRVRRORUDJXHUUD
15/34
JRPRVLWRVSHJDMRVRV\XQSRFRWUDQVSDUHQWHVTXHUHVXOWDQ
YHUGDGHUDPHQWH LQPXQGRV HV XQ JUDQ DUWLVWD 3HUR )HOLSH
VH HVPHU³ HQ ORV RMRV ODJD±RVRV \ ODV OHQJXDV EDERVDV
TXH VRQ VX HVSHFLDOLGDG \ HQ FRQMXQWR UHVXOW³ XQ $VFR
HVWXSHQGRXQRGHORVPHMRUHVDPLMXLFLR
&2175$$7$48(12&78512 (VWDEDVHQWDGR\WHQDGRVFDEH]DVXQDP¡VRPHQRVD
ODDOWXUDGHORVKRPEURV\RWUDTXHOHFUHFDHQXQDURGLOOD
/DGHORVKRPEURVHQOXJDUGHSHORWHQDVHUSLHQWHV\ODGH
<R HVSHUDED SRU VXSXHVWR XQD UHVSXHVWD GH )HOLSH ODURGLOODbUDYLROHV&UHRTXH)HOLSHVHGLRFXHQWDGHTXHD
SHURQRLPDJLQ©TXHVHUDWDQIHUR]WDQFRQWXQGHQWH P ORV UDYLROHV QR PH SDUHFDQ ELFKRV GHPDVLDGR
&RPRFXDOTXLHUDSXHGHVXSRQHUHQXQDFDVDWDQPQLPD DVTXHURVRV bDGRUR ORV UDYLROHV TXH KDFH 6LOYLD 0XV
FRPR OD QXHVWUD HV GLIFLO \ KDVWD LPSRVLEOH HQFRQWUDU XQ SRUTXHPHGLMR
VLWLR GRQGH WUDEDMDU PLHQWUDV ORV GHP¡V GXHUPHQ 3HUR ߚ/RVUDYLROHVHQHOSHORVRQPX\DVTXHURVRVVDEDV"
)HOLSH FRQVLJXL³ DWUDYHVDU HO GRUPLWRULRFRPHGRUVDOD
HVFULWRULRGHVSHQ VD HQ SXQWDV GH SLH VLQ GHVSHUWDU D ORV
SDGUHV(QFDPELRPHGHVSHUW³DP WHQJRXQVXH±RPX\
OLYLDQR \QRW©TXHOOHYDEDKRMDVGHSDSHO\XQSXO³YHUHQOD
PDQR/RGHOSXO³YHUPHH[WUD±³SRUTXHHUDXQDQRFKHFLWD
SDUD MDGHDU HQ FXDQWR XQR VH DOHMDED PHGLR PHWUR GHO
YHQWLODGRU 'H PRGR TXH GHFLG LQYHVWLJDU \ PH OH HVFXUU
HQWUH ODV SLHUQDV DQWHV GH TXH FHUUDUD OD SXHUWD GH OD
FRFLQD
ߚ4X©KDF©VDF¡1HSR"ߚPHGLMR 3HURFUHRTXHHQ
HOIRQGRHVWDEDFRQWHQWRGHODFRPSD±D
(OSXO³YHUHUDSDUDWDSDUODUHQGLMDGHOX]TXHVHILOWUDED
KDFLD HO FRPHGRU SRU HO XPEUDO GH OD SXHUWD ©UDPRV
FODQGHVWLQRV\WHQDPRVTXHWUDEDMDUHQVHFUHWR
)HOLSHHVWDEDSRUGLEXMDUXQ$VFRSRUVXSXHVWR
ߚb4X©O¡VWLPDTXHQRHVW©%XUUXFKD1HSRb&RQORELHQ
TXHOHVDOHQORVJXVDQRV
'R\ IH GH TXH HV DV %XUUXFKD GLEXMD XQRV JXVDQRV
16/34
$GHP¡VGHUDYLROHVKDEDGHWRGRRMRVHQODSXQWDGHOD
OHQJXD XQD OHQJXD HQ OXJDU GH FRUEDWD UHQDFXDMRV TXH
YLYDQHQODERFDODJDUWLMDVTXHVDODQGHODVRUHMDVRUHMDV
TXH FUHFDQ HQ ODV SLHUQDV (Q ILQ VHUD LPSRVLEOH DJRWDU
OD GHVFULSFL³Q GH XQ $VFR WDQ FRPSOHWR FRPR ©VH (UD /26(-e5&,7266(35(3$5$1
UHDOPHQWHGHVDJUDGDEOHLQFOXVRSDUDPTXHVR\XQSHUUR
GHHVW³PDJRUHVLVWHQWH
'HVSX©V)HOLSHDSDJ³ODOX]GHODFRFLQDTXLW³HOSXO³YHU +DFLHQGR XQ EDODQFH GHO DWDTXH GH &HFLOLD \ GHO
GHO XPEUDO DEUL³ OD SXHUWD \ VDOL³ HQ SXQWDV GH SLH FRPR UHVSHFWLYR FRQWUDDWDTXH GH )HOLSH FRQVLGHU© TXH OR MXVWR
KDEDHQWUDGR0HRUGHQ³LUDPLFXFKDMXQWRDODGHVSHQVD HUD GHFUHWDU XQ HPSDWH \ FRPHQF© D DEULJDU HVSHUDQ]DV
\ROHKLFHFDVRSRUTXHVHPHGLRODJDQD \©OVHYROYL³D GH TXH UHWRUQDUD OD SD] D FDVD GH ORV 0XV 3HUR YROY D
VX FXDUWR $O GD VLJXLHQWH OH WRF³ JULWDU D &HFLOLD (VWDED HTXLYRFDUPH (UD HYLGHQWH TXH ©VH KDED VLGR V³OR HO
IXULRVD \ D SXQWR GH OORUDU )HOLSH KDED VHQWDGR VX $VFR FRPLHQ]R )XH GHVSX©V GH OD WUHJXD GH 1DYLGDG TXH VH
HQFLPD GHO 5DP³Q )ORULGR QDGD PHQRV 3DUD VHU P¡V GHVDW³HQWRGDVXIXULDHOFRQIOLFWR
SUHFLVRV HQFLPD GHO QDUFLVR HQ HO TXH SRU ILQ KDEDQ (QWUHHOGHGLFLHPEUH\HOGHHQHURQRVXFHGL³QDGD
GHFLGLGRGHFRPºQDFXHUGRFRQ9LROHWDTXHWHQDTXHYLYLU TXH PHUH]FD VHU QDUUDGR 3HUR QR IXHURQ VHPDQDV
0DULDQDHOKDGDUHFL©QFRFLGD(OWXFRTXHVHHVFXUUDGH SHUGLGDV VHJºQ SXGH HQWHUDUPH OXHJR VLUYLHURQ SDUD
ORV SHORVUDYLROHV JRWHDED HQFLPD GH XQD KHUPRVD UHFOXWDU YROXQWDULRV DUPDU HM©UFLWRV \ DOPDFHQDU
PDUJDULWD\XQDHVSHFLHGHJXVDQRFRQFDUDGHHVFXHU]RVH PXQLFLRQHV
HQURVFDEDHQHOWDOORGHOQDUFLVR /RVSHUURVGHOEDUULRWHQHPRVODFRVWXPEUHGHUHXQLUQRV
HQHOEDOGRHOGDGH)LQGH$±R4XLHQP¡VTXLHQPHQRV
WUDHVXPRUFLOOLWDVXWURFLWRGHIDOGDVXKXHVLWRGHRVREXFR
R LQFOXVRDOJXQDVF¡VFDUDVGHTXHVRTXHYLHQHQPX\ELHQ
SDUD OD SLFDGLWD VLQ FRQWDU ODV JHQHURVDV GRQDFLRQHV GH
&LULORTXHSRUSURYHQLUGHXQSHUURTXHYLYHHQFDVDGHXQ
FDUQLFHURPHUHFHUDQXQFDSWXORDSDUWH )XHDKTXHOD/LOL
QRV FRPHQW³ FRPR DO SDVDU TXH ODV PXMHUHV VH HVWDEDQ
UHXQLHQGRWRGDVODVWDUGHVHQFDVDGH-XOLD
ߚ3DUHFH TXH OD PDGUH GH -XOLD OHV GRQ³ ODV SLODV GH
UHYLVWDVYLHMDVߚGLMR
17/34
$VRPEURJHQHUDOL]DGR
/DV UHYLVWDV YLHMDV GH +LOGD OD PDGUH GH -XOLD VRQ FDVL
XQDOH\HQGDHQHOEDUULR&RPRHVPX\DKRUUDWLYDVHQLHJD
D WLUDUODV (V P¡V ODV UHWLUD GH OD EDVXUD GH RWUDV FDVDV \
ODV JXDUGD HQ HO SDWLHFLWR GHO IRQGR +DFH D±RV TXH YLHQH
KDFLHQGR HVR \ \D OOHYD DFXPXODGDV XQDV YHLQWH R WUHLQWD
SLODV GH QR PHQRV GH WUHV PHWURV GH DOWR (Q UHDOLGDG \
DXQTXH +LOGD QR OR TXLHUD UHFRQRFHU JUDQ SDUWH GH HVDV
UHYLVWDV\DUHVXOWDQLQVHUYLEOHVSRUTXHVHKDQLGRPRMDQGR
\ VHFDQGR \ DUUXJDQGR KDVWD FRQYHUWLUVH HQ XQD PDVD /R PLU© FRQ FLHUWD FRPSDVL³Q $ YHFHV SLHQVR TXH
SDVWRVD 3HUR WDPEL©Q VRQ PXFKDV ODV TXH HVW¡Q WRGDYD 2WRQRU KD GH VHU XQ SHUUR H[WUDWHUUHVWUH SRUTXH DQGD
HQEXHQDVFRQGLFLRQHV VLHPSUHHQRWUDJDOD[LD\VHFRQHFWDFRQOD7LHUUDV³ORPX\
ߚ&HFLOLD 9LROHWD MXLOD \ TXL©Q P¡V" ߚVH LQWHUHV³ HO GHWDQWRHQWDQWR
&ROLWDTXHHVDPLJRGHODVSUHFLVLRQHV ߚbb<TX©YDQDKDFHU2WRQRU"ߚOHODGU©ߚb5HFRUWDQ
ߚ&DPLOD 3LUXFKD OD 3HWL )ORUHQFLD 5LJDQWL OD RWUD IORUHV SRU VXSXHVWR b1R KDFH IDOWD VHU XQ SHUUR GH FLUFR
)ORUHQFLDHVDUXELHFLWDTXHVHPXG³KDFHSRFR\TXHQRV© SDUDGDUVHFXHQWDGHHVR
F³PRVHOODPD 6HQWDPDUHRVGHV³ORSUHQVDUHQODHQRUPHFDQWLGDGGH
ߚ,Q©V ILJXULWDVTXHWHQGUDQ\DUHFRUWDGDV\PHSUHJXQWDEDVLORV
ߚ(VR,Q©V6RQXQPRQW³Q YDURQHV HVWDUDQ HQ EDELD FRPR HUD VX FRVWXPEUH R
<DKHVW¡EDPRVFRPHQWDQGRODVQRWLFLDV\UDVSDQGRHO WDPEL©Q HOORV KDEUDQ DSURYHFKDGR OD WUHJXD SDUD
ILQDOGHQXHVWURVKXHVRVFXDQGR2WRQRUPLYHFLQRTXHVH DOPDFHQDUPXQLFLRQHV
KDED SDVDGR OD ILHVWD GXUPLHQGR SULPHUR DEUL³ ORV RMRV \ 1RWDUG©HQGDUPHFXHQWDGHTXHODKDEDQDSURYHFKDGR
OXHJRVXERFD]DGHSHUUR6DQ%HUQDUGR\PHSUHJXQW³WDQ \PX\ELHQSRUFLHUWR-DPDVORJU©DYHULJXDUF³PRQLG³QGH
FHUFDGHODRUHMDTXHFUHTXHLEDDWUDJDUPHODFDEH]D KDEDQ WUDEDMDGR SHUR OD FXHVWL³Q HV TXH KDEDQ ORJUDGR
ߚ<TX©KDFHQFRQODVUHYLVWDVFKH" DOPDFHQDUVLHWHFDMDVGH]DSDWRVUHSOHWDVGH$VFRV\VLHWH
FDMDV P¡V FRQ 5HFXHUGRV GHO 0RQVWUXR (VWDEDQ WRGDV
GHEDMRGHODFDPDGH)HOLSH<RPLVPRGHVFXEUHOSROYRUQ
FLHUWDWDUGHFLWDGHFRPLHQ]RVGHHQHUR
/DV FDMDV HUDQ HQ WRWDO FDWRUFH GH PRGR TXH SRGD
LPDJLQDUFDWRUFHFRPEDWLHQWHVRELHQVLHWHVLHVTXHFDGD
XQR VH KDED HQFDUJDGR GH XQD FDMD GH $VFRV \ XQD FDMD
18/34
GH 5HFXHUGRV GHO 0RQVWUXR )HOLSH \ %XUUXFKD SRU
VXSXHVWR \ VLQ GXGD WDPEL©Q +XJR *XVWL HO 1HJUR 7DO
YH]:LOVRQ5DPUH]DSHVDUGHODWHUULEOHSHOHDTXHKDED
WHQLGRFRQ)HOLSHKDFDPHQRVGHXQPHV KHQRWDGRTXHD
PHQXGR EDVWD TXH HVWDOOH XQD JXHUUD QXHYD SDUD TXH VH
ROYLGH XQD JXHUUD YLHMD < SUREDEOHPHQWH HO *RUGR TXH 81$*8(55$08<$35(7$'$
VLHPSUH VH HQWHUDED GH WRGR \ VHJXUDPHQWH WDPEL©Q VH
KDEDHQWHUDGRGHHVWR
< DK HVWDED \R SUHJXQW¡QGRPH FX¡QGR HVWDOODUD OD &U©DVH R QR HVWD JXHUUD WXYR OXJDU HQ HO &XDUWR GH ORV
JXHUUDFXDQGRWXYROXJDUODSULPHUDEDWDOOD 'RV5HLQRVGHPRGRTXHHVSHURTXHVHPHSHUPLWDGHFLU
TXHIXHXQDJXHUUDPX\DSUHWDGD
6LFLQFR©UDPRVPXFKRVHOGDGHODSULPHUDHVFDUDPX]D
(QYHUDQROD/LOVHSDVDODYLGDHQHOWDOOHUPHF¡QLFRSRUTXHGLFHTXHORVPRWRUHV HV I¡FLO LPDJLQDUVH OR PXFKRV TXH VHUDPRV FXDQGR HQ
GHVDUPDGRVVRQGHORP¡VIUHVTXLWR\FRPRORVIRQGRVGHOWDOOHUGDQFRQORVIRQGRVGH FDGD XQR GH ORV GRV UHLQRV VH DOLQHDURQ ORV FRPEDWLHQWHV
ODFDVDGH-XOLDVHSXGRHQWHUDUGHORTXHQDGLHP¡VVDED 1GHO3
(QOD©SRFDHQTXH6LOYLD0XVYXHOYHDFDVDFDUJDGDGHJDOHUDVHVP¡VI¡FLOTXHDQGH UHVSHFWLYRV FRQ VXV FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHV PXQLFLRQHV
\RGHEDMRGHODVFDPDVEXVFDQGRODIUHVFDTXHQRHO_HVFRELOO³QEDUULHQGRHOSROYR< SUHSDUDGRVSDUDDWDFDU\JDQDUHVSDFLRV
HQHVRVGDVSUHFLVDPHQWHQXHVWURHVFRELOO³QHVWDEDGHYDFDFLRQHV 1GHO3
(VSDFLRSUHFLVDPHQWHHUDORP¡VGLIFLOGHJDQDUHQHVH
VLWLRFRPRELHQSXHGHDWHVWLJXDUXQSREUHSHUURTXHQRHV
WDQMRYHQSDUDDQGDUKDFLHQGRSLUXHWDV\TXHVLQHPEDUJR
WXYRTXHSDVDUVHXQDWDUGHHQWHUDWUHSDGRDODFDMRQHUDGH
XQSODFDUG+DEU¡DOJXQRDKDTXLHQVHOHRFXUUDSUHJXQWDU
SRUTX©QRPHPDQGDEDDPXGDUGHHVHVLWLRWDQFRQFXUULGR
\ PH LQVWDODED PHMRU HQ QXHVWUR FRPHGRUGRUPLWRULR
HWF©WHUDRHQODFRFLQDRHQHOSDWLHFLWR VLHPSUHLEDDVHU
P¡V F³PRGR FRQYLYLU FRQ WUHV PDFHWDV TXH FRQ GLHFLRFKR
FKLFRV OD PHQRU GH QXHYH UHFL©Q FXPSOLGRV HO PD\RU GH
GRFH DFDEDGRV GH FXPSOLU (VWLPDGRV OHFWRUHV GH KDEHU
KHFKR HVR QR KDEUD SRGLGR VHU WHVWLJR GH ORV
DFRQWHFLPLHQWRV QL WHQGUD WRGR FRQ TXH FRQWDU HVWD
KLVWRULD 'LJDPRV TXH PH VDFULILTX© SRU HO ELHQ GH OD
FU³QLFD b$VGHKHU³LFRVVRPRVORVQRYHOLVWDV
19/34
WHQHEURVR \ VH FRQYLUWL³ HQ XQ SHTXH±R MDUGQ HQIXUHFLGR
6H UHVHUYDURQ WUHV FODYHOHV SDUD SHJDUORV HQ IRUPD GH
UDPLWR VREUH OD FDEHFHUD GH OD FDPD OXHJR )ORUHQFLD
5LJDQWH TXH HV JHQLDO GLEXMDQGR FRQ W©PSHUD EODQFD OH
KL]RXQPR±LWRDOUDPR<&HFLOLDDQRW³GHEDMRFRQVXOLQGD
OHWUD3DUDHO0RQVWUXRFRQFDUL±R+DGD0DULDQD
2WUD HVFHQD )HOLSH \ :LOVRQ 5DPUH] VH FRQILUP³ OD
UHFRQFLOLDFL³Q SUHVW¡QGROH ODV PDQRV DO *XVWL \ HO *XVWL
WUHSDGRHQFLPDGHHOODVSDUDSHJDUHQHOFLHORUUDVRXQJUDQ
WUR]R GH SDSHO DILFKH GH FRORU DPDULOOR 'HVSX©V FRQ XQ
PDUFDGRU OH GLEXM³ XQ PRQW³Q GH JRWLWDV \ VDOSLFDGXUDV DO
'HVGH PL HVFRQGLWH WUHSDGR D OD FDMRQHUD \ DJUDGHFLGR UHGHGRU \ HVFULEL³ D ODV DSXUDGDV 3LV <R HVSHUDED DOJR
TXH QL )HOLSH QL &HFLOLD WXYLHUDQ SRU FRVWXPEUH GHMDU ELHQ P¡VLQJHQLRVRSHURVXSRQJRTXHQRHVI¡FLOHVFULELUFRVDV
FHUUDGDV ODV SXHUWDV GH QLQJºQ SODFDUG SXGH SUHVHQFLDU LQJHQLRVDV HQ HO WHFKR PLHQWUDV XQR HVW¡ SDUDGR HQ XQDV
DOJXQDVVHFXHQFLDVLQWHUHVDQWHVGHOFRQIOLFWR PDQRVTXHQLVLTXLHUDVRQODVSURSLDV
20/34
)HOLSH \ %XUUXFKD VH QRWDED D OD OHJXD VX DPSOLD 1RSD1DGD1RSDV³QDGD
H[SHULHQFLD HQ PDWHULD GH $VFRV \ GH 0RQVWUXRV +DEDQ 6HEDVWL¡Q0XVHFK³XQDRMHDGDDODVSDUHGHVGHOFXDUWR
GLEXMDGRXQDERWHOOD\XQDFRSD GHGX]FRTXHGHFRORUURMR GHVXVKLMRV\OXHJRVHGLULJL³DODFRFLQD<RORDFRPSD±©
LQWHQVR \ ODV SHJDURQ MXQWR DO YHODGRU GH &HFLOLD 'HEDMR PRYLHQGRODFROD\UHFODPDQGRODFXRWDGHVDOXGRVTXHPH
DQRWDURQ FRQ OHWUDV FKRUUHDQWHV ߡ%ULQGR FRQ OD VDQJUH GH FRUUHVSRQGD GH PRGR TXH SXGH RU PX\ ELHQ FXDQGR OH
PLV YFWLPDV D OD VDLXG GH OD EHOOD 0DULDQD (O &RORI³Q GLMRD6LOYLDGHVSX©VGHGDUOHXQEHVR
'HILQLWLYRߢ ߚ9RV YLVWH OR TXH HV FXDUWR GH ORV FKLFRV 6LOYLD" $
$SHQDV KDEDQ WHUPLQDGR FXDQGR VH GLHURQ FXHQWD GH YHFHVPHSDUHFHTXHQROHVWHQGUDPRVTXHGHMDUGHFRUDU
TXH SRU HO VXHOR DYDQ]DED XQD KRUULEOH ILOD GH PDUJDULWDV WDQWRODVSDUHGHV
KDFLDHOUHLQRGH)HOLSH\WHUPLQDEDIRUPDQGRXQDDOIRPEUD
IORULGD MXQWR D OD FDPD +DED XQ SDSHO IHVWRQHDGR \ PX\
SRVLEOHPHQWH SHUIXPDGR VREUH HOODV 'HFD ߡ7XV SLHV
PHUHFHQSLVDUV³ORIORUHV0RQVWUXRPR+DGD0DULDQDߢ
)XH XQD WDUGH IHEULO GHVHVSHUDGD ORV GLHFLRFKR
FRPEDWLHQWHV VH PRYDQ GH XQ ODGR DO RWUR HQ HVH FXDUWR
GLPLQXWR RFXSDQGR WRGRV ORV HVSDFLRV OLEUHV GH ODV
SDUHGHVD\XG¡QGRVHRHQWRUSHFL©QGRVH VHJºQIXHVHQGHO
PLVPR EDQGR R GH EDQGRV FRQWUDULRV KDVWD FRQYHUWLU HO
&XDUWR GH ORV 'RV 5HLQRV HQ XQ GHVHQIUHQDGR EDWLGR GH
URVDV FRQ WULSDV GH PR±RV FRQ EDERVDV GH GDOLDV FRQ
FROPLOORVHQXQJUDQUHYROWLMRGHPRQVWUXRV\GHKDGDV
3UHFLVDPHQWH HVH GD UHJUHV³ 6HEDVWL¡Q 0XV GH VX
UHFRUULGDGXOFHUDSRUORVDOPDFHQHVGH(QWUH5RV&XDQGR
VHDVRP³DOFXDUWRGHVXVKLMRV\DORVGHP¡VFRQWHQGLHQWHV
VH KDEDQ UHWLUDGR \ WRGR SDUHFD HVWDU HQ FDOPD )HOLSH
HVWDEDWLUDGRERFDDUULEDHQODFDPDOH\HQGRXQDKLVWRULHWD
\&HFLOLDWLUDGDERFDDEDMROHDXQDQRYHOD
ߚb+RODSDߚJULWDURQORVGRVDOPLVPRWLHPSRHQFXDQWR
ORYLHURQ\FRUULHURQDDEUD]DUOR
ߚ+ROD&HFL+ROD)OSHUߚMDP¡VHQWHQGSRUTX©OHGLFH
)OSHUD)HOLSHߚ$OJXQDQRYHGDG"
21/34
PLHO HQ OD FDUWXFKHUD GH 0DWDV \ 0DWDV OH KDED WLUDGR
XQD ]DSDWLOOD SRU OD YHQWDQD 3HUR SDUHFH VHU TXH DKRUD
FXDQGR HUD FXHVWL³Q GH GDU EDWDOOD D ODV GHO RWUR UHLQR
WRGRVVHVHQWDQP¡VMXQWRVTXHQXQFD
<ORTXHUHVXOWDEDDºQP¡VFXULRVRHUDHOKHFKRGHTXH
6($*8',=$(/&21)/,&72 PXFKRV FRPEDWLHQWHV GH XQR \ RWUR EDQGR PLUDEDQ FRQ
JUDQ LQWHU©V D FLHUWRV FRPEDWLHQWHV GHO EDQGR FRQWUDULR
&HFLOLDSRUHMHPSORVXVSLUDEDSRUHO1HJURGHVGHHOGDHQ
&RQ HO FRUUHU GH ORV GDV OD JXHUUD VH YROYL³ UHDOPHQWH TXHORYLRHQFDEULWDUODELFLFOHWD\REOLJDUODDDQGDUHQXQD
SRSXODUHQHOEDUULR(QSDUWHVHJºQPLRSLQL³QSRUTXHORV VROD UXHGD < D %XUUXFKD OH FRVWDED VDFDU ORV RMRV GH
FKLFRV HVWDEDQ GH YDFDFLRQHV \ GLVSRQDQ SRU OR WDQWR GH HQFLPDGH&DPLODSRUTXHORVKDEDWHQLGRSRVDGRVHQHOOD
PXFKRWLHPSRSDUDVXVEDWDOODV<HQSDUWHWDPEL©QSRUTXH GHVGHTXHHVWDEDQHQSULPHUJUDGR
HO QXHVWUR HV XQ EDUULR P¡V ELHQ WUDQTXLOR GRQGH HV UDUR 3DUD QR KDEODU GH )HOLSH \ 9LROHWD TXH HQ FXDQWR VH
TXHVXFHGDQFRVDVHPRFLRQDQWHVGHPRGRTXHORVSRFRV YHDQVHSRQDQFRORUDGRV
DVXQWRV HPRFLRQDQWHV TXH KD\ VH DSURYHFKDQ DO P¡[LPR (Q ILQ TXH KDED PXFKRV JXHUUHURV \ XQD PH]FOD
/D FXHVWL³Q HV TXH ORV SDUWLFLSDQWHV WHUPLQDURQ VLHQGR XQ UDUVLPD GH RGLRV \ GH DPRUHV < WRGRV HVRV RGLRV \ HVRV
PRQW³Q DPRUHVߚHVRHVORLQV³OLWRߚHQXQºQLFRFDPSRGHEDWDOOD
/R FXULRVR HV TXH PXFKRV GH ORV FRPEDWLHQWHV GH XQ HO&XDUWRGHORV'RV5HLQRV
PLVPREDQGRKDEDQVLGRHQHPLJRVGHFODUDGRVKDVWDSRFR <D V© TXH ©VWD HV XQD DILUPDFL³Q TXH SXHGH
WLHPSRDWU¡V3RUHMHPSOR,Q©VKDEDFRUWDGRDPXHUWHFRQ GHVFRQFHUWDU D FXDOTXLHUD F³PR SXHGH VHU TXH TXHSDQ
)ORUHQFLD 'LQRVN\ HO ºOWLPR GD GH FODVHV SHUR DKRUD OD WDQWRV JXHUUHURV HQ XQ FXDUWR HQ HO TXH DSHQDV VL FDEDQ
D\XGDEDDUHFRUWDUORVS©WDORVGHXQJLUDVROJLJDQWH9LROHWD GRV FDPDV" 1R OR V© \ OHV UXHJR TXH QR LQVLVWDQ FRQ HVH
RSLQDEDTXH3LUXFKDHUDXQDFDQFKHULWDLQVRSRUWDEOHߋ WLSRGHSUHJXQWDV UHFXHUGHQGHWDQWRHQWDQWRTXHVR\XQ
SHUR DFHSW³ FXDQGR VH RIUHFL³ SDUD VRVWHQHUOH OD SHUUR \ TXH SRU HVD UD]³Q PLV FRQRFLPLHQWRV GH
JXLUQDOGDTXHHVWDEDSHJDQGRDOUHGHGRUGHODSXHUWD PDWHP¡WLFDV \ GH JHRPHWUD VRQ DOJR UXGLPHQWDULRV /R
< OR PLVPR VXFHGD FRQ ORV YDURQHV (O GH :LOVRQ TXH SXHGR GHFLUOHV HV TXH KXER PXFKR P¡V GH YHLQWH
5DPUH] FRQ )HOLSH 0XV QR KDED VLGR HO ºQLFR FDVR GH FKLFRVGHHQWUHQXHYH\GRFHD±RVPHWLGRVHQHOFRQIOLFWR
UHFRQFLOLDFL³QSRUIXHU]DPD\RU8QSDUGHPHVHVDWU¡VVLQ (V SRVLEOH TXH QR KD\DQ HVWDGR QXQFD WRGRV MXQWRV HQ HO
LU P¡V OHMRV FXDQGR \D HVWDEDQ SRU WHUPLQDU ODV FODVHV HO FXDUWR 3HUR WRGRV HOORV VLQ IDOWDU XQR UHFRUWDURQ
*RUGROHKDEDSXHVWRHOSLHD+XJRHQHOUHFUHR\+XJROH GLEXMDURQ SHJDURQ LQYHQWDURQ FRQVLJQDV PHQVDMHV
KDED GHYXHOWR OD DWHQFL³Q HQ IRUPD GH WURPSDGD D OD UHVSXHVWDV FRSODV DWDTXHV \ FRQWUDDWDTXHV HQ HVD
VDOLGD HO *XVWL KDED GHUUDPDGR XQ IUDVFR FDVL HQWHUR GH EºVTXHGD GHVHVSHUDGD SRU DGXH±DUVH GH XQ HVSDFLR WDQ
22/34
FKLTXLWR
+XER GDV HQ ORV TXH SXHGR DVHJXUDUOHV TXH QL VLTXLHUD
LQWHQW© HQWUDU DO &XDUWR GH ORV 'RV 5HLQRV /RV SHUURV
VRPRV LQGLYLGXRV PRGHVWRV \ QRV DGDSWDPRV D ODV
FRPRGLGDGHV GH TXH GLVSRQJDQ ORV KXPDQRV SRU
LQVXILFLHQWHV TXH ©VWDV VHDQ SHUR QR HVW¡ HQ QXHVWURV ¢(1/$*8(55$72'29$/("
SODQHVPRULUDSODVWDGRVHQWUHFRGRV\]DSDWLOODV
(O GD HQ TXH &HFLOLD FRQ DLUH WULXQIDO SHJ³ OD ºOWLPD
DPDSROD HQ HO ºOWLPR OXJDU TXH TXHGDED OLEUH HQ OD SDUHG
GHODYHQWDQDFHUFDGHO]³FDOR ODVFKLFDVFUH\HURQTXHOD
YLFWRULD HUD GH HOODV 6H HTXLYRFDEDQ ORV YDURQHV QR
WDUGDURQHQHPSH]DUDFXEULUOHVODVIORUHVFRQHVSDQWRV
ߚb(VRQRYDOHߚJULW³&DPLOD
ߚ(Q OD JXHUUD YDOH HVR \ FXDOTXLHU FRVD ߚVHQWHQFL³
+XJR
ߚ3HURHVRHVWUDLFL³Q\ODWUDLFL³QQRYDOH1LVLTXLHUDHQ
OD JXHUUD YDOH VHU WUDLFLRQHUR ߚGLMR 9LROHWD FRQ OD FDUD
HQFHQGLGDFRPRXQDOLQWHUQD
)HOLSHQRSXGRPHQRVTXHHFKDUOHXQDRMHDGDSRUTXHOH
HQFDQWDEDODFDUDTXHSRQDFXDQGRVHHQRMDED
ߚ%XHQR ߚGLMR &DPLOD HPSX±DQGR HO IUDVFR PLV JUDQGH
GHSHJRWHߚSHURHQWRQFHVWUDLFLRQDPRVWRGRV
23/34
72'$*8(55$1(&(6,7$815(*/$0(172
24/34
&XDQGRFRPHQ]³HOFRQIOLFWRSDUHFDTXHYDODFXDOTXLHU
FRVD VLQLUP¡VOHMRVKXERXQDFRQWHQGLHQWHFX\RQRPEUH
SUHILHURROYLGDUTXHWXYRODGHVGLFKDGDLGHDGHSHJDUPHXQ
UDPRGHJODGLRORVHQODFROD <HUDPX\FRPºQRUORVJULWDU
DFDGDUDWRߡb(VRQRYDOHߢRߡb7UDLFL³QߢRߡb0XOHUD3HUR
FRQ HO WLHPSR IXHURQ SRQL©QGRVH GH DFXHUGR DFHUFD GH
DOJXQDVUHJODVHOHPHQWDOHV
ߚ/RTXHQRVKDFHIDOWDHVXQ5HJODPHQWRߚGLMR&HFLOLD
XQDWDUGHHQODTXHKDEDKDELGRWDQWDVSHOHDVTXHVHOHV
KDEDDWUDVDGRPXFKRODJXHUUD
/RVHQFDUJDGRVGHUHGDFWDUHO5HJODPHQWRIXHURQ)HOLSH
\9LROHWD FDVXDOPHQWH 7HQDV³ORFXDWURSXQWRV
1R YDOH HPSH]DU QLQJXQD EDWDOOD VL QR KD\ LJXDO
QºPHURGHVROGDGRVSRUEDQGR
1R YDOH VHJXLU SHJDQGR ILJXULWDV GHVSX©V GH TXH < DV VLJXL³ FDSD WUDV FDSD GXUDQWH GRV VHPDQDV
WHUPLQ³ODEDWDOOD (VRTXHUDGHFLUTXH)HOLSH\&HFLOLDQR P¡VFDOFXOR
SRGDQDGHODQWDUWUDEDMRGXUDQWHODVKRUDVGHGHVFDQVR &DGD YH] TXH 6LOYLD 0XV HQWUDED HQ HO FXDUWR SDUD
/DYHQWDQDODSXHUWD\HOSODFDUGVHGHFODUDQ]RQDV JXDUGDU XQD UHPHUD HQ HO SODFDUG R SDUD FDPELDU ODV
QHXWUDOHV (Q UHDOLGDG WDPEL©Q HO VXHOR TXHG³ IXHUD GHO V¡EDQDV GH OD FDPD PLUDED ODV SDUHGHV \ VXVSLUDED /D
FRQIOLFWRSHURHVRQRIXHQXQFDSDUWHGHO5HJODPHQWR)XH SREUHHVWDEDWDQDJRWDGDºOWLPDPHQWHTXHQLIXHU]DVWHQD
XQD FRQFHVL³Q TXH WXYLHURQ TXH KDFHU GHVSX©V GH TXH SDUD SRQHU HO JULWR HQ HO FLHOR FRPR HUD VX FRVWXPEUH \
6LOYLD0XVVHODVLQJHQLDUDSDUDSRQHUHOJULWRHQHOFLHORVLQ PHQRV VLQ OD D\XGD GH XQD EXHQD HVFDOHUD 'HVSX©V VH
UHFXUULUDQLQJXQDHVFDOHUD YROYDKDFLDVXJUDQSLODGHJDOHUDVPXUPXUDQGR
< GHMR SDUD HO ILQDO HO ºOWLPR SXQWR HO P¡V VDELR \ ߚ(Q FXDQWR WHUPLQH FRQ HVWR bOLPSLH]D JHQHUDO b(VWRV
WDPEL©QHOP¡VPLVHULFRUGLRVR FKLFRVH[DJHUDQ
1RYDOHSHJDUILJXULWDVHQHOSHUUR 3HURFRPRSDUDHVD©SRFDODVJDOHUDVQRQRVJDUXDEDQ
(O 5HJODPHQWR KL]R TXH OD JXHUUD VH FRQYLUWLHUD HQ DOJR VLQR TXH QRV OORYDQ D PDUHV OD OLPSLH]D JHQHUDO QXQFD
EDVWDQWHP¡VDPDEOH OOHJDED<GLJRP¡VKXERQXHYHGDVIDWDOHVߚORVºOWLPRV
ORV P¡V WHUULEOHVߚ HQ ORV TXH 6LOYLD 0XV QL VLTXLHUD SXGR
HQWUDUDHFKDUXQDRMHDGDGHWDQHQJDOHUDGDTXHHVWDED
6H SRGUD GHFLU TXH IXH HQWRQFHV FXDQGR OD JXHUUD VH
25/34
YROYL³ YHUGDGHUDPHQWH ORFD \ HO &XDUWR GH ORV 'RV 5HLQRV
HQWU³HQHVWDGRVDOYDMH
26/34
$YHFHVODVGHGLFDWRULDVHUDQP¡VFRPSOHWDV\YHQDQHQ
YHUVRFRPRSRUHMHPSORODVFRSODVTXHOHGHGLF³HO+DGD
DO&RORI³QHQHOS©WDORGHXQDD]XFHQD
(O&RORI³QVHSHLQDED
GHEDMRGHXQWDPDULVFR
FRQXQSHLQHGHUHWDPDV
\XQFHSLOORGHMDFLQWRV
<XQSRFRP¡VDEDMR
(VOLQGRYHUDODOOXYLD
TXHYDEDMDQGRGHOFLHOR
P¡VOLQGRHVYHUDOPRQVWUXLWR
SRQL©QGRVHORVUXOHURV 2ODVUHVSXHVWDVGHO&RORI³QTXHHVWDEDQHVFULWDVHQWUH
ODV X±DV GH XQD JDUUD SHOXGD R HQ HO PDQJR GH XQ KDFKD
TXHFKRUUHDEDVDQJUH
&XDQGRSDVRSRUWXFDVD
WHVDOXGRFRQHOKDFKD
\DYHFHVWHGHFDSLWR
SHURHVVLQTXHUHUPXFKDFKD
$QWHDQRFKHVR±©XQVXH±R
\DQRFKHYROYDVR±DU
6R±©TXHWHGHVWULSDED
\QRTXLVHGHVSHUWDU ߋ
27/34
0H SDVDED HO UDWR PLUDQGR ORV GLEXMRV \ OH\HQGR ODV )XHWDOHOVXVWRTXHQRSXGHHYLWDUSHJDUXQDODULGR
SDODEUDV (VD JXHUUD VH HVWDED YROYLHQGR YHUGDGHUDPHQWH
'HVSX©V ORV PLUDED D )HOLSH \ D &HFLOLD \ ORV YHD DK SHOLJURVDVLVHJXDQLQYDGLHQGRORVHVSDFLRVSRFRDSRFR
GRUPLGLWRV WDQ VHUHQRV WDQ GLIHUHQWHV \ WDQ SDUHFLGRV ORV UHSWLO D D]XFHQD QDUFLVR D YDPSLUR WULSD D FULVDQWHPR
GRV DO PLVPR WLHPSR \ QR ORJUDED HQWHQGHU GH G³QGH EDPRV D WHUPLQDU SHUGLHQGR HO SRFR TXH WHQDPRV \ HVR
VDFDEDQODHQHUJDSDUDVHJXLUHPSDSHODQGRDPXHUWHHVD SRGD UHVXOWDU IDWDO SDUD JHQWH TXH YLYH FRPR YLYLPRV
SLHFLWD 3HUR HQ ILQ DV VRQ ORV KXPDQRV VLHPSUH QRVRWURVHQXQDFDVDGLPLQXWD
LQVDWLVIHFKRV VLHPSUH FRQYHQFLGRV GH TXH WLHQHQ SRFR $WHUUDGR HPSHF© D LPDJLQDU OR TXH VXFHGHUD HO GD HQ
VLHPSUH EXVFDQGR P¡V HVSDFLR 1R HQWLHQGR KDFH D±RV TXH \D QR HQWUDVHQ QL VLTXLHUD ODV GRV FDPDV MXQWDV HQ HO
TXH YLYHQ FRQ QRVRWURV ORV SHUURV \ WRGDYD QR ORJUDURQ &XDUWR GH ORV 'RV 5HLQRV 6HJXUDPHQWH &HFLOLD \ )HOLSH
DSUHQGHUQDGDORVSREUHV1LVLTXLHUDVHHQWHUDURQGHTXH SDVDUDQ D GRUPLU HQ HO FRPHGRU FRQ ORV SDGUHV \ PL
SDUDVHUIHOL]HQODYLGDQRKDFHQIDOWDGHPDVLDGDVFRVDV GRUPLWRULRVHYHUDGHVSOD]DGRDODFRFLQD2SHRUDºQߚ
XQKXHVRXQULQF³QXQWUDSLWRXQ¡UEROFXDQGRKDFHIDOWD QRTXHUDQLLPDJLQDUORbDOSDWLR &RQR]FRPXFKRVSHUURV
4XHDXQRORGHMHQROHUHOPXQGRWUDQTXLORTXHYLYDDOJXQD TXH YLYHQ HQ HO SDWLR FRPR HO SREUH &DQXWR DO TXH ORV
SHUULWD FHUFD < TXH FDGD WDQWR YHQJD XQ DPLJR D GXH±RV GH FDVD GHVWHUUDURQ D XQD FDVLOOD KHFKD GH WDEODV
SDOPHDUOHDXQRHOORPR\DUDVFDUOHODVRUHMDV PDOHQVDPEODGDVSRUGRQGHVLHPSUHVHFXHODHOYLHQWR
)XH GHVSX©V GH XQD GH HVDV FRQWHPSODFLRQHV 6HQWTXHHOFLHORVHPHGHVSORPDEDHQODFDEH]D<OHV
PD±DQHUDVTXHFRPHQF©DDODUPDUPH1RW©GHSURQWRTXH DVHJXURTXHQRHVWDEDH[DJHUDQGRSDVDUGHXQDFDVLWDGH
OD YHQWDQD SDUHFD P¡V FKLFD P¡V RVFXUD P¡V OHMDQD (Q GRVDPELHQWHVDXQDFDVLWDGHXQDPELHQWHHVFRUWDUVHSRU
FLHUWR PRGR SDUHFD OD YHQWDQD GH RWUR FXDUWR \ QR GHO ODPLWDGQLP¡VQLPHQRV
QXHVWUR SRUTXH HVWDED DO ILQDO GH XQD HVSHFLH GH WºQHO \
HUDPX\SRFDODOX]TXHQRVOOHJDED7DPEL©QHOSODFDUG\OD
SXHUWD HVWDEDQ KXQGLGRV GHWU¡V GH XQDV SDUHGHV
$OILQDOGHOOLEURSRGU¡QHQFRQWUDUXVWHGHVXQDEUHYHUHFRSLODFL³QGHDOJXQDVGHODV
PXOWLFRORUHVTXHKDEDQFUHFLGRGHSURQWRMXQWRDODVRWUDV FRSODVTXHIXHURQDSDUHFLHQGR \GHVDSDUHFLHQGRDPHGLGDTXHTXHGDEDQVHSXOWDGDV
3DUHFLWDVEDVWDQWHJUXHVDVGHODQFKRGHGRVODGULOORV EDMRQXHYDVFDSDVGHILJXULWDV 1GHO3
(QWRQFHV YROY D PLUDU KDFLD GRQGH GRUPDQ )HOLSH \
&HFLOLD \ PH GL FXHQWD GH TXH ODV FDPDV HVWDEDQ PX\
MXQWDVFDVLSHJDGDVDWDOSXQWRTXH\DFDVLQRKDEDVLWLR
SRUGRQGHWUD]DUODIURQWHUDHQWUHORVGRVUHLQRV
(O FLHORUUDVR KDED GHVFHQGLGR WDQWR TXH VHJXUDPHQWH
)HOLSH HUD FDSD] GH WRFDUOR FRQ OD PDQR VLQ VXELUVH D
QLQJºQEDQTXLWR
28/34
H[WUDRUGLQDULDPHQWH WHVWDUXGRV \ VH QLHJDQ D OOHQDU VXV
HVWDQWHUDVFRQGXOFHGHURVDPRVTXHWDb(VLQFUHEOHb&RQ
ORGHOLFLRVDTXHUHVXOWDXQDXQWDGLWDVREUHODVWRVWDGDV /D
FXHVWL³Q HV TXH YROYL³ GH 6DQWD )H PX\ FDQVDGR \ SDUWL³
SDUD/D3DPSDHQHOPLVPRGD$SHQDVVLWXYRWLHPSRGH
/$&8(9$'(/26'265(,126 HFKDUXQDRMHDGDDO&XDUWRGHORV'RV5HLQRV
3HUR VXSRQJR TXH DOJR UDUR QRW³ SRUTXH R FXDQGR OH
GHFD D 6LOYLD PLHQWUDV DOLQHDED ORV IUDVFRV HQ VX YDOLMD
$ SDUWLU GH HVH GD PH GHGLTX© D LQYHVWLJDU ODV GXOFHUD
FDUDFWHUVWLFDV GH HVH HQYROWRULR TXH VHJºQ \R ߚb/R TXH HV HVWR GH DQGDU YLDMDQGR SRU OD OODQXUD
VRVSHFKDEDLEDDWHUPLQDUSRUDVIL[LDUQRV 6DEHV TXH HVWD PD±DQD FXDQGR OOHJX© PH SDUHFL³ P¡V
1RW©TXHHVDVSDUHGHVTXHQRVKDEDQFUHFLGRGHSURQWR FKLFDODFDVD"b&RPRVLVHKXELHUDDFKLFDGRPLHQWUDV\RQR
QR HUDQ WDQ FRQVLVWHQWHV FRPR ODV YHUGDGHUDV VLQR PXFKR HVWDED
P¡V EODQGDV \ DOJR IOH[LEOHV 6L XQR VH FKRFDED FRQWUD < 6LOYLD 0XV OH FRQWHVWR VLQ OHYDQWDU ORV RMRV GH VXV
HOODVHQOXJDUGHUHFLELUXQJROSHVHQWDTXHVHKXQGDHQ EHQGLWDVJDOHUDV
XQD HVSHFLH GH FROFKRQHWD (UD HYLGHQWH TXH VH LEDQ ߚ(V SRU OR VXFLD TXH HVW¡ 3RU HVR SDUHFH P¡V FKLFD
DFXPXODQGR ORV EROVRQFLWRV GH DLUH HQWUH FDSD \ FDSD GH 3HUR \D OHV GLMH D ORV FKLFRV HQ FXDQWR WHUPLQH FRQ HVWR
ILJXULWDV(ORORUHUDXQSRFRGXO]³QEDVWDQWHGHVDJUDGDEOH bOLPSLH]DJHQHUDO
\HOJXVWR ¡VSHUR\SRFRLQWHUHVDQWH $O FRPHQ]DU IHEUHUR FXDQGR \D OOHY¡EDPRV XQ PHV GH
$OJXQRV VH SUHJXQWDU¡Q TX© RSLQDEDQ 6LOYLD 0XV \ JXHUUD)HOLSHWHQDTXHDJDFKDUODFDEH]DSDUDHQWUDUDVX
6HEDVWL¡Q0XVGHWRGRHVWR0XFKRPHWHPRTXHHVWDEDQ FXDUWR < ODV GRV FDPDV QR V³OR HVWDEDQ XQD SHJDGD D OD
GHPDVLDGR DWDUHDGRV GHPDVLDGR GLVWUDGRV GHPDVLDGR RWUD VLQR TXH HVWDEDQ D VX YH] WDQ DSUHWDGDV FRQWUD ODV
OHMRVSDUDQRWDUORTXHHVWDEDVXFHGLHQGR SDUHGHV GH ILJXULWDV TXH ODV KXQGDQ FRQ OD SUHVL³Q < ODV
<DGLMHTXH6LOYLD0XVVHKDEDSDVDGRHOPHVGHHQHUR REOLJDEDQ D DUTXHDUVH IRUPDQGR JUDQGHV SDQ]DV SRU
FRUULJLHQGR JDOHUDV < OD VHPDQD HQ TXH ODV SDUHGHV \ HO HQFLPDGHODVFROFKDV
WHFKR DYDQ]DURQ FDVL PHGLR PHWUR DPHQD]DQGR FRQ 3RU RWUD SDUWH ORV FDEH]D]RV TXH FDGD WDQWR VH GDEDQ
DVIL[LDUQRV WDPEL©Q HOOD SDUHFD DVIL[LDGD \ SHUGLGD GHWU¡V )HOLSH SULPHUR \ GHVSX©V WDPEL©Q &HFLOLD FRQWUD HO WHFKR
GHVXVJUDQGHVSLODVGHSDSHOHV KLFLHURQ TXH HO FLHORUUDVR VH DEROODUD HQ FLHQ OXJDUHV 'H
7DPSRFR6HEDVWL¡Q0XVHVWDEDHQFRQGLFLRQHVGHGDUVH PRGRTXHHOFXDUWR\DGHM³GHSDUHFHUXQFXDUWR\HPSH]³
FXHQWDGHQDGD$QGDEDGHYLDMHHQYLDMHHOSREUH 3DUHFH DSDUHFHUP¡VELHQXQDFXHYD<XQDFXHYDDOJRWHQHEURVD
VHU TXH DOJXQRV DOPDFHQHURV \ VXSHUPHUFDGHURV VRQ $ OD WDUGH FXDQGR VH SRQD HO VRO \ GHVDSDUHFD OD
29/34
HVFDVDOX]TXHHQWUDEDSRUHOIRQGRGHOWºQHOGHODYHQWDQD
HOFXDUWRSDUHFDLQYDGLGRSRUVRPEUDVH[WUD±DV(OEULOORGH
ORV YHODGRUHV OD O¡PSDUD GHO WHFKR KDED TXHGDGR
LQXWLOL]DGDKDFDUDWR QRKDFDP¡VTXHDXPHQWDUHOHIHFWR
GH OXFHV \ VRPEUDV $JUDGHF XQD \ PLO YHFHV WHQHU PL
GRUPLWRULRLQVWDODGRMXQWRDODGHVSHQVD\SRFRDSRFRGHM© (/$50,67,&,202-$'2</$635(1'$6'(3$=
GHIUHFXHQWDUHO&XDUWRGHORV'RV5HLQRV\DQRUHVXOWDED
XQ OXJDU DSURSLDGR GRQGH GRUPLU PLV VLHVWDV 1R HQWHQGD
F³PRSRGDQVHJXLUGXUPLHQGRDOO)HOLSH\&HFLOLDSRUPX\ <D OOHY¡EDPRV FXDUHQWD GDV GH JXHUUD FXDQGR SRU ILQ
PRQVWUXRVRPX\KDGDVTXHVHVLQWLHUDQ VHILUP³HODUPLVWLFLR
7DPEL©Q ORV FRPEDWLHQWHV HPSH]DURQ D IDOWDU D ODV FLWDV 8QDWDUGHPLHQWUDVVHDUUDVWUDEDIXHUDGHVXKDELWDFL³Q
GH JXHUUD 3RQDQ H[FXVDV 6H LEDQ WHPSUDQR < HVR GHVSX©V GH KDEHU SHJDGR XQ ºOWLPR UDPLWR GH YLROHWDV
SRUTXHODGLYHUVL³QKDEDHPSH]DGRDHVWURSHDUVH$SHQDV &HFLOLDORPLU³D)HOLSH\GLMR
VLFDEDQGRVSHUVRQDVHQXQOXJDUWDQHVWUHFKRGHPRGR
ߚ)HOLSH 0XV PH SDUHFH TXH \D YD VLHQGR KRUD GH TXH
TXH KDED TXH WXUQDUVH SDUD HQWUDU D SHJDU ODV ILJXULWDV
KDJDPRVODVSDFHV
&RPR ODV SDUHGHV VH KDEDQ DFKLFDGR WDQWR WHUPLQDEDQ
HQVHJXLGD b\ YXHOWD D HVSHUDU HO WXUQR (Q XQD SDODEUD <)HOLSHOHGLRXQSHOOL]F³QHQHOFDFKHWHTXHHVORTXH
TXHWRGRVHLEDSRQLHQGREDVWDQWHDEXUULGR KDFH FXDQGR HVW¡ VDWLVIHFKR FRQ VX KHUPDQD &HFLOLD
UHVSRQGL³FRQXQDWURPSDGLWDHQHOSHFKR
3RU RWUD SDUWH HVWDED OD RVFXULGDG \ HVH RORU
GHVDJUDGDEOH TXH HPSHRUDED GD D GD 1R HUD I¡FLO 'H LQPHGLDWR FRQVXOWDURQ FRQ VXV UHVSHFWLYRV HM©UFLWRV
YHQWLODUODKDELWDFL³QFDGDYH]TXHXQRTXHUDXQSRFRGH &RPR HVH GD HVWDEDQ SUHVHQWHV V³OR 9LROHWD ,Q©V \ -XOLD
DLUHWHQDTXHWUHSDUVHDOWºQHO\JDWHDUKDVWDGRQGHHVWDED GHO EDQGR GH ODV KDGDV \ HQ HO EDQGR GH ORV PRQVWUXRV
ODYHQWDQDSDUDDEULUOD %XUUXFKD HO 1HJUR \ :LOVRQ 5DPUH] TXH UHVXOW³ PXFKR
P¡V OHDO GH OR TXH )HOLSH KDED LPDJLQDGR QR IXH GLIFLO
2SLQR TXH OD FXHVWL³Q GH &DUQDYDO IXH XQD YHUGDGHUD
SRQHUVH GH DFXHUGR 7RGRV FRLQFLGLHURQ HQ TXH OD JXHUUD
EHQGLFL³Q
KDEDHVWDGRPX\GLYHUWLGD\VHGHFUHW³XQHPSDWH
6HDSXUDURQDILUPDUHODUPLVWLFLRSRUTXHDOGDVLJXLHQWH
HPSH]DED HO &DUQDYDO +DED TXH OOHQDU GH DJXD ODV
6GHERUHFRQRFHUTXHDUUDQTX©XQWDUDVFRQFLWRGHODSDUHGTXHKDEDFUHFLGRMXQWRD ERPELWDV FRQVHJXLU EDOGHV \ SDODQJDQDV SDUD JXDUGDU ODV
ODSXHUWDSHURIXHDGHVJDQR\SRUSXURDI¡QFLHQWILFRSXHGHQFUHHUPH 1GHO3
PXQLFLRQHV \ SUHSDUDUVH SDUD OD EDWDOOD GHO DJXD HQ OD
YHUHGD /D UHXQL³Q VH GLR SRU WHUPLQDGD FXDQGR HO 1HJUR
DQXQFL³TXHHODEXHOROHVLEDDSUHVWDUODPDQJXHUD
30/34
ߚ/DODUJDRODFRUWD"ߚTXLVRVDEHU%XUUXFKD
ߚ/DODUJD0HSURPHWL³
ߚb4X©EXHQDTXHYDDHVWDUHVDJXHUUDߚGLMR:LOVRQ\
OHSDOPH³HOKRPEURD)HOLSH
(VD PLVPD WDUGH )HOLSH \ &HFLOLD HPSH]DURQ D
GHVHPSDSHODUVXVSDUHGHV<DWHQDQSHQVDGRF³PRLEDQD
GHFRUDU VXV UHVSHFWLYRV UHLQRV HQ FXDQWR UHFXSHUDUDQ HO
HVSDFLRTXHKDEDQSHUGLGR
(VD QRFKH HVWXYLPRV WRGRV FRQWHQWRV (Q SULPHU OXJDU
SRUTXH XQR HVW¡ P¡V FRQWHQWR FXDQGR YLYH HQ SD] TXH
FXDQGRYLYHHQJXHUUD(QVHJXQGROXJDUSRUTXH6HEDVWL¡Q
0XV YROYL³ GH VRSHW³Q GRV GDV DQWHV GH FXDQGR OR
HVSHU¡EDPRV ORV DOPDFHQHURV GH /D 3DPSD UHVXOWDURQ
JHQWHVHQVDWD (QWHUFHUOXJDUSRUTXH6LOYLD0XVDFDEDED
GHFRUUHJLU VX ºOWLPD JDOHUD < HQ FXDUWR OXJDU SRUTXH VH 'HVSX©VGHWUDEDMDUWRGDODPD±DQDDUUDQFDQGRIORUHV\
UHVROYL³TXHHUDXQDQRFKHSDUDIHVWHMDUFRPLHQGRSL]]D HVSDQWRVKDVWDOOHQDUGLH]EROVDVGHEDVXUDGHODVJUDQGHV
'H PRGR TXH QRV IXLPRV ORV FLQFR D OD SL]]HUD GH OD )HOLSH VDF³ GHO IRQGR GHO FDM³Q OD PHGLD TXH OH VLUYH GH
HVWDFL³Q<RLEDPRYLHQGRODFROD\VRQUL©QGROHD6HEDVWL¡Q DOFDQFD \ PH LQYLW³ D LU FRQ ©O KDVWD OD DYHQLGD 1R PH
0XV SDUD PLV DGHQWURV 6HEDVWL¡Q 0XV QXQFD FRPH HO QHJX©SRUVXSXHVWR PHHQFDQWDDVHJXUDUPHGHTXHWRGRV
UHERUGHGHODSL]]D\ORVUHERUGHVGHSL]]DGHPX]DUHOD\ ORV DUEROLWRV GHO EDUULR VLJXHQ VLHPSUH HQ HO PLVPR VLWLR
MDP³QVRQSUHFLVDPHQWHPLFHQDIDYRULWD +DED PXFKR SDUD HOHJLU SHUR ©O HOLJL³ XQ UDPLWR GH
SHQVDPLHQWRV (UDQ HQRUPHV \ VHJºQ GLFHQ PRUDGRV \
7DOYH]RWURGDUDSRUWHUPLQDGDDTXODKLVWRULDSHUR\R
DPDULOORV
FUHR TXH OD KLVWRULD WHUPLQ³ HQ UHDOLGDG DO GD VLJXLHQWH
FXDQGR &HFLOLD \ )HOLSH FRPHQ]DURQ D FDYDU SDUD UHVFDWDU /HV FROJ³ XQD WDUMHWD ߡ3DUD HO +DGD 0DULDQD 'H SDUWH
VXVYLHMDVSDUHGHVHLQWHUFDPELDURQSUHQGDVGHSD] GHO &RORI³Q 'HILQLWLYRߢ GHFD \ VH ORV GLR D &HFLOLD TXH
HVWDED PX\ DWDUHDGD GHVHPSDSHODQGR ORV DOUHGHGRUHV GH
OD YHQWDQD <R PH VHQW© D DVSLUDU FRQ ORV RMRV
HQWUHFHUUDGRVODVQXHYDVU¡IDJDVGHDLUHTXHYHQWLODEDQSRU
ILQHOFXDUWR
ߚb*UDFLDV)HߚGLMR&HFLOLD\OHGLRDOKHUPDQRXQEHVR
\ XQ DEUD]R TXH D )HOLSH OH SDUHFLHURQ FUHR XQ SRFR
31/34
H[DJHUDGRV 7DPEL©Q OH HQWUHJ³ VX SUHQGD GH SD] XQD
KRMD GH SDSHO HQUROODGD FRPR XQ SHUJDPLQR \ DWDGD FRQ
XQD FLQWD GRQGH GHFD ߡ'HO +DGD 0DULDQD DO &RORI³Q
'HILQLWLYR&RQPXFKRFDUL±Rߢ
&UHR TXH )HOLSH HVSHUDED RWUD FRVD SRUTXH HQ FXDQWR
WHUPLQ³ GH GHVHQUROODU HO SDSHO SHJ³ XQ VLOELGLWR GH (3Ì/2*2'(813(552
VRUSUHVD < PH SDUHFH TXH KL]R ELHQ HQ VRUSUHQGHUVH
SRUTXH OR TXH &HFLOLD OH KDED UHJDODGR HUD XQ $VFR
HVSO©QGLGR GH OD PHMRU FDOLGDG XQ $VFR YHUGDGHUDUPHQWH /D KLVWRULD OOHJD D VX ILQ QR KD\ YXHOWD TXH GDUOH < \D
SHJDMRVR EDERVR H LQPXQGR 'H XQD RUHMD EURWDED XQ PLUR FRQ QRVWDOJLD HO WHFODGR V© TXH YD D GHMDU GH
QDUFLVRHVWXSHQGRPX\SDUHFLGRDOQDUFLVRHQHOTXHKDED UHSLTXHWHDUHQFXDOTXLHUPRPHQWR
YLYLGR 0DULDQD HQ YVSHUDV GH OD JXHUUD 0H SDUHFL³ XQ 0H TXHGD V³OR FRQWDUOHV GRV R WUHV FRVDV DQWHV GH
GHWDOOHLQWHOLJHQWH GHVSHGLUPH
ߚ(VSDUDWXQXHYDFROHFFL³QߚGLMR&HFLOLD (O &XDUWR GH ORV 'RV 5HLQRV YROYL³ D VHU OR TXH HUD
(QWRQFHV )HOLSH OH GLR GRV SHOOL]FRQHV D &HFLOLD XQR HQ DXQTXH QR H[DFWDPHQWH )HOLSH \ &HFLOLD UHFREUDURQ VXV
FDGDFDFKHWH \OHGLMR HVSDFLRV\YROYLHURQDGHFRUDUVXVSDUHGHV(QPLRSLQL³Q
ߚ*UDFLDV&HFLb(VW¡EXHQR6LTXHU©VSRGHVMXQWDUFRQ HO QXHYR 5DP³Q )ORULGR HV DºQ P¡V HVSO©QGLGR TXH HO
%XUUXFKD\FRQPLJR DQWHULRU &HFLOLD KD WUDEDMDGR PXFKR HQ ©O )HOLSH FRODERU³
ߚ<YRVVLTXHU©VߚGLMR&HFLOLDPLHQWUDVSRQDHQDJXD FRQ GRV PDUJDULWRQHV LQPHQVRV SLQWDGRV D PDQR TXH D
ORV SHQVDPLHQWRVߚ SRG©V YHQLU FXDQGR TXLHUDV D FRFLQDU &HFLOLDOHJXVWDURQPXFKR
KDGDV /D SDUHG GH ORV $VFRV VLJXH VLHQGR QHJUD \ OD QXHYD
<GHVSX©VDJUHJ³FRQXQDULVLWD FROHFFL³Q HV H[FHOHQWH %XUUXFKD KD SHUIHFFLRQDGR PXFKR
ߚ1RFUHRTXHD9LROHWDOHPROHVWH VX W©FQLFD SDUD GLEXMDU JXVDQRV 'D OD VHQVDFL³Q GH TXH
HVW¡QYLYRVGHYHUGDG\TXHHQFXDOTXLHUPRPHQWRSXHGHQ
GHVSUHQGHUVHGHODVSDUHGHV\HPSH]DUDFDPLQDUOHDXQR
SRUHOFXHUSR&HFLOLDKDHQWUHJDGRXQSDUGHFRQWULEXFLRQHV
TXHORVFROHFFLRQLVWDVMX]JDURQH[WUDRUGLQDULDV
(QODIURQWHUDHQWUHORVGRVUHLQRVMXVWRGRQGHFRPLHQ]D
HO PDUFR GH OD SXHUWD VH KD FUHDGR XQD ]RQD GH
LQWHUFDPELR$OOVHSLQFKDQ\VHSHJDQODV0RQKDGDV TXH
VRQ ORV 5HFXHUGRV GHO 0RQVWUXR \ GHO +DGD )HOLSH \
32/34
9LROHWDVRQORVTXHP¡VVHHPSH±DQHQDGRUQDUHVD]RQD
6HSRGUDGHFLUTXHORVGRVUHLQRVYLYHQHQSD]DXQTXHD 'HO&RORI³Q'HILQLWLYRDO+DGD0DULDQD
YHFHVVHURPSHODDUPRQD+DKDELGRGLVFXVLRQHVSHOHDV
\ HQ P¡V GH XQD RFDVL³Q VH GHVHQFDGHQDURQ IHURFHV
$\HUSDV©SRUWXFDVD
EDWDOODV GH DOPRKDGDV 3HUR GHER UHFRQRFHU TXH
ºOWLPDPHQWH VH UHVSHWDQ PXFKR ODV IURQWHUDV \ HVR HV WHYLFRPLHQGRFHUH]DV
VH±DOGHTXHVHTXLHUHHYLWDUODJXHUUD \GLXQVXVSLURWDQKRQGR
(O UHVWR GH OD IDPLOLD VLJXH P¡V R PHQRV LJXDO XQRV TXHWHDUUDQTX©ODFDEH]D
FRUULJHQ JDOHUDV \ RWURV YHQGHQ PHUPHODGDV 6LJXHQ
VR±DQGRFRQXQDFDVDXQSRTXLWRP¡VJUDQGH 6H±RUD+DGD0DULDQD
<R PH PDQWHQJR ILHO D PLV FRVWXPEUHV 1R PH SULYR GH EODQFDHVSXPDGHODPDU
PLV VLHVWDV FRQ HO KDGD QL GH PLV UHYROFDGDV FRQ HO DOO¡YDPLYDPSLULWR
PRQVWUXRQLGHURHUFDGDWDQWR
XQEHVLWROHYDDGDU
XQEXHQKXHVRQLGHVH±DODUSUROLMDPHQWHORV¡UEROHVGH
PL FXDGUD $QGR PHGLR HQDPRUDGR GH OD /LO &KDUOR
VLHPSUH FRQ &LULOR 6LJR HQ JXHUUD FRQ ODV SXOJDV < HVWR\ (QPLºOWLPDPDVDFUH
SHQVDQGR VHULDPHQWH HQ GHGLFDUPH D HVFULWRU VLHPSUH \ QRTXHG³XQDPRVFDYLYD
FXDQGR FRQVLJD TXH PH SXEOLTXHQ HVWD KLVWRULD (VR HV OR $YRVWHGHYRURJUDWLV
TXH OH SUHJXQWDED HVWD WDUGH D OD /LO PLHQWUDV SRUVHUXQKDGDWDQOLQGD
KXVPH¡EDPRV XQ FKDUFR HQ OD YHUHGD VHU¡Q PX\
TXLVTXLOORVRV ORV HGLWRUHV R HVWDU¡Q GLVSXHVWRV D SXEOLFDUOH
0XFKRVKD\TXHWHGLFHQ
DXQSHUUR"
ߡ7HQHFHVLWRߢ
<RQRWHGLJRQDGD
\RWHPDVWLFR
33/34
'HO+DGD0DULDQDDO&RORI³Q
(QHOFLHORODVHVWUHOODV
HQHOPDUORVFDUDFROHV
\HQHOFDPSRPLPRQVWUXLWR *5$&,(/$0217(6
GHVKRMDQGRJLUDVROHV
4X©VHU¡ORTXHUHOXPEUD
GHEDMRGHORVPHPEULOORV"(V
PLPRQVWUXRTXHVHDILODFRQ
D]ºFDUORVFROPLOORV
1RPHWLUHVFRQSXQ]RQHVTXH
PHYDVDODVWLPDU7UDPHFRQ
PDUJDULWDV
TXHPHTXLHURHQDPRUDU
&RORI³Q'HILQLWLYR
1DFL³ HQ )ORULGD %XHQRV $LUHV \ HV XQD VREUHVDOLHQWH
EHOORPRQVWUXRWDQIORULGR HVFULWRUDGHOLEURVSDUDQL±RV\M³YHQHV+DSXEOLFDGRP¡V
UHJ¡ODPHGRVJODGLRORV GHVHWHQWDWWXORVHQWUHORVTXHVHHQFXHQWUDQ2WURVR\/DV
\XQDGRFHQDGHOLULRV YHODVPDOGLWDVWDPEL©QHGLWDGRVSRU$OIDJXDUD(QWUHRWUDV
GLVWLQFLRQHVREWXYRHOSUHPLR/D]DULOORHQ
'HVGHTXHHUDFKLTXLWLWD
PLPDPLWDPHHQVH±³
DSHOHDUPH\DPLJDUPH
con monstruitos como vos.
34/34