You are on page 1of 14

137

zegiy ihewl

mihtyn

`weec e`l card z` mikn xy`k "deeda aezkd xaic" .`


weqtae ,7 xg` edyna `l` ,haya
epzyxta mipey zenewn drax`a
iptn wx ,"haya" dlnd driten
aezkd xaic" :llkd z` i"yx xne`
."deeda aezkd xaic"y
oiivn `ed dpey`xd mrta .1 "deeda
:xzei mcew weqta mi`ven ep` jk :2 "xey gbi ike" weqtd iabl df llk
z` yi` dkde miyp` oeaixi ike" ,sere dige dnda lk cg`e ,xey cg`"
wx o`k aeyg i`cea ± 8 "...edrx okn xg`l ."deeda aezkd xaicy `l`
lke ,"edrx z` yi` dkde" ly oiprd miweqt dyelya df llk i"yx `ian
wx daezk "miyp` oeaixi ike" dncwdd .'b sirqa oldlck mitqep
."deeda aezkd xaic"y meyn gbi ike" weqtd iptl s` :oiadl yi
miweqt yi ,dyxt 3 dze`ae ,"xey
i"yx akrn recn :oaen oi` ,jk m` mda z`aeny ,dxe`kl ,gipdl jixvy
cr "deeda aezkd xaic" eyexit z` xaic"y iptn ,zniieqnd `nbecd
z`f xne` epi`e ,"xey gbi ike" weqtd oicdy iptn `le ,"deeda aezkd
± zegtle) ,dpey`xd mrta cin ote`a `weec `ed df weqta xkfend
?(ef dyxta .hxetnd

eze` i"yx dpey recn oiadl yi ok z` yi` dki ike" weqta ,lynl
df mikenq zenewna minrt rax` llk ly oicdy oaen ,4 "...haya ...ecar
?oldl hxetiy itk ,dfl miinei e` mei m` j` ,mwpi mewp"
mb ,6 zehyta lg 5 "...mwei `l cenri

,bk `vz .hi ,eh .f ,bi d`x i"yxta d"ke (1


.c ,dk .`i
.gk ,`k (2
"dgivx z`kd"c dlilyd ixdy ,"deda aezkd :exzia `nbecle df iptly zexcqa f"cre (3
."a"eike drevxe lwn"a mb `ed ,(my m"anxay) .'eke .bk ,fh glyaa .bi ,hi
,"deda aezkd xac" mrhd `lel` :daxc`e (7 .k ,`k (4
ik ,zxg` `nbec `wec (hytd c"r) xn`p l"v 'id .`kÎk ,my (5
zindl ick ea oi`y hay mb zllek "hay" zaiz xn`p jkl :c"id a"t gvex 'ld m"anxa (6
,(fh ,dl zehn i"yxt d`x ± "lfxa ilk" k"`yn) `l` ezekdl zeyx dxez dpzp `ly ,haya
xaca edkdyk `wec `ed aezka xn`py oicde g"de` d`xe .oda `veike drevxe lwne haya
.(t"dr i"yx d`x) zindl ick ea yiy mb (a) .llk df xkfp `l i"yxta (`) :la` .o`k
.gi ,`k (8 xac" zngn `ed "haya" oeyldy l"v f"tl
138
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

z` oiivn i"yx mixg`d miweqta mb i"yx ± xeal dlitp iabl .a


.12 dgked mey `ll llkd e` xey" recn giken
"xeng
miweqt xtqn :xzei lecb s` iyewd
dny ltpe" weqtd lr ,13 xzei xge`n :9 dpyndn ,dxe`kl ,gewl df llk
i"yx yxtn jk lr s`y ,"xeng e` xey dig oke ...dnda lk cg`e xey cg`"
ok` `ed ,"dige dnda lkl oicd `ed" xn`p dnl ok m` ,mda `veik sere
xn`py mewn lkay" jkl dgked `ian aezkd xaicy `l` ,xeng e` xey
xey xey eze` oicnl ep` xenge xey ."deeda
."...zayn
zyxtny miweqtd lk iabl j`
xeng e` xeyy xzei ievn :dxe`kle "xey") weqta ritend hxtdy ,dpynd
,"dige dnda lk" xy`n xeal elti aezkd xaic"y iptn wx `ed (dnecke
jkl daiqdy ,my dpyna xn`pk zegked 10 `xnbd d`ian ,"deeda
iabl "xeng e` xey" `wec mixkfeny mixen` mpi` el` mipicy ze`xnd
aezkd xaic" meyn `id "xead zlitp" .weqta xkfend hxtd iabl `weec
(deed) "ze`ivn" iabl ixde ,"deeda
,llkk z`f raew i"yx ,z`f znerl
jxc oial hytd jxc oia licadl oi`
`ian eppi`e ,"deeda aezkd xaic"y
z` raew i"yxy oeik ,jk m`e .dkldd
iabl mb oicd `ed jky dgked mey
,llkk "deeda aezkd xaic" ly oiprd
ike" iabl ,`nbecl .mixg` mihxt
xey xey" dgkedl wewf `ed dn myl
oicy dgked mey `ian i"yx oi` "gbi
?"zayn
jke .11 "xey" iabl `weec e`l lg df
xeal dlitp iably ,xnel dvxp m`
`wec "mlyi xead lra"y aeygl ozip
,"xeng e` xey dny ltpe" xy`k
,dvetp xeal mzlitpy iptny meyn ,a`fd d"c ` ,a 'dpq i"yxtae .a ,cp w"a (9
mieedn ezgizt e` xead ziixk ixd oiire ."xey gbi ike" oiprl ef dpyn d`aed
jixv jkitle .14 mdiabl `wec driyt n"eg xehn xirdle) .c"n `"t 'dpq h"ieza
.n"k`e .(my dyixcae h"tyqx
,ik ,"zayn xey xey" gikedl i"yx d"c ` ,fk zekxa i"yxae .my w"a (10
"deeda aezkd xaic" llkd ,oaenk oiprl zayn xey xey y"fba opixnbc ,lwqpy
.lwqi xeyd
.zlz `l` zayn xnbnl `kilc ,my h"ieza
.n"k`e .my n"ega g"a .o`k `zlikn d`x la`
.22 ,17 zexrd onwl d`x (12 :(o`k `"ebe m"`x mb d`xe) o`k g"ya (11
.bl ,`k (13 weqt lr i"yxty 'ek zayn xey xey opitli"
xey oiprl) driyt `id xead ziixky s`e (14 ,zehyta k"d`la la` ."xeng e` xey (bl ,`k)
zlitp lr xeht 'idiy xnel xyt` n"n ,(xenge y"n lr r"` jenqi i"yxy xnel mewn oi`
.jli`e `"rq ,ap w"an xirdle .zxg` dnda .df ixg`l
139
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

,17 zeawp cg`e mixkf cg`" :i"yx zipeibd daiq oi` xy`k wx miiw
miypdy ,deeda aezkd xaicy `l` oial weqtd ly hxtd oia licadl
xne` ztqep mrt .18 "zetykn zeievn ,15 mixg` mihxt
i"yxy xg`l recn ,oaen oi` ixd -
lkl oicd `ed"y dgked `ian xak
ae` iab `dc" :` ,fq 'dpql i"yxta (17
dy`l yi` oia wlg `l md mityknc ipercie xn`p `le" miiqn `ed ,"dige dnda
z"dr eyexitay dfn ,la` ."dy` e` yi` aizkc xeng ,mc` `le xey `l` xenge xey
cnl `l cinlzdy hxtae] ef dgked `ian epi` xiaqdl yi ,dxe`kl ,ixde ."milk `le
gken ,[ipercie ae` iab xn`py weqtd oiicr
jxc t"r "zeawp cg`e mixkf cg`"l ezii`xy
i"yx ly ekxc idefy ,hytd jxca
.(o`k g"yak `lce) envr df weqtn `id hytd xey xn`p `le"y ,dxezd lr eyexita
"'igz `l" oicdy xnel `xaq oi`y oeikn ik aezkd xaicy iptn `l` ± xeng e`
dtykna wx `ed [*"c"aa znez" `ed eyexity] el` milny i"yx cnel oipn ."deeda
itl `ed dtykn xn`py dfy l"v ,sykna `le
.15 dxrde a"q l"pk ,deda aezkd xacy
?milke mc` hrnl ze`a
xac" `zil myy `l` .my 'dpqa mb d"k (18
.34 dxrd onwl d`xe ."deda aezkd llkd z` `ian i"yx .b
:my `xnbd oeyl iabl i"yxta iepiy cer
zaiz hinyn i"yxe "'ek miyp aexy" my 'dpqa
zetqep minrt
oirl d`xpd ze`ivnde hytd c"r ik ± "aex"
"deeda aezkd xaic" llkd z`
minrt yely ,xen`k ,i"yx oiivn
:epzyxta zetqep
ly i"yxa jyndd mb x`al xyt` f"tr (*
ipyy ,"c"aa znez `l`"l "'ek mixkf cg`" yxtn 16 "digz `l dtykn" lr
cg`e" azeky cre ,'` xeaica mazk mipiprd
:siqend e"`ea ± "'ek mixkf
xzei xeng mypery xnel `xaq yi miyp`a
lkl yi`l dy` zeeydl aezkd jxved okly] :dfa mipipr ipye (15
.(p"ye .(y"iir) ` ,dl oiyeciw) dxezay 'eke oiyper `nbecd oia wlgl `xaq yiy oeikn (`
:da xn`pe (k ,a ziy`xa) ecbpk xfr d"d dy`de ycgl `"` ,zexg` ze`nbecl aezka dxn`py
lirl i"yx mb d`xe .(fh ,b my) ja lyni `ede mb `ed aezka xn`py oicdy (dgked mey ila)
m`a okle .[oipn .. dy` .. yi` `l` il oi` :fh ,`k wx aezka d`a `nbecdye zexg` ze`nbeca
`l epiid] dzeigdl `ly (wx) 'id "'igz `l" 'it oi`yk k"`yn) deda aezkd xacy df zngn
,` zeny) lirl i"yx d`x ± oefne min dl wtql .(k"dfb edfy xnel wgec ,wlgl `xaq
dn cinlzdl dyw 'id `l [oiigze yexita (fi mb 'id aezkay oicd m`a (:efn dxizi) (a
ile` xne` 'id ik ,(dawp 'l) "dtykn" xn`py `nbec aezka xn`p 'id `l ,zexg` ze`nbeca
± xzei lecb eypry sykna weqt f"g`l `eai df cvn wx ± `weca d`ay `xaq da yiy efk
`l`" yxtn i"yxy ixg`l la` .c"aa dzin mewn yi f"iry oeikn ± xzei dlibx `idy
wx recn :zehyta cinlzd dywn ,"c"aa znez `l ik :hi ,hi miyecw g"de` d`xe) zerhl
:daxc` ixde ± sykn `le dzin zaiiegn dtykn envr df ixd k"`e .(zerhl yi mewn deda xaci
jiynn okle ± ?xzei xeng myper l"v miyp` .ef `nbeca `wec `ed oicdy giken
."'ek mixkf cg`e" i"yx .fi ,ak (16
140
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

ozip "digz `l dtykn" iabl mezie dpnl` lk" weqtd lr i"yx z`f
epi` "(`xwnl) yng oa"y ,aiydl ,mc` lkl oicd `ed" :19 "oeprz `l
rcei epi`e ,24 seyikd `yepl rcen mdy itl ,deeda aezkd xaicy `l`
xy`n miyp lv` xzei ievn seyikdy ."mzeprl 20 ievn xace gk iyeyz
zerhl lelr `ed jkitle ,miyp` lv` dcya xyae" weqtd lr ,okn xg`l
`ed "digz `l" ly oicdy aeygle ziaa s`" :aey xne` `ed 21 "dtixh
.sykn iabl `le ,dtykn iabl `weec mewn ,deeda aezkd xaicy `l` ,ok
weqtay ,ycgl i"yx jixv okl .22 "sxhil zenda jxcy
meyn wx "dtykn" dlnd zxn`p
i"yx jixv recn :oaen oi` jka
miypdy ,deeda aezkd xaic"y
.minrt rax` llk eze` xnel
.25 "zetykn zeievn
xak xyt` mixg`d miweqtd zyelya
`l mezie dpnl` lk" iabl j` ly eyexitn ,dxe`kl ,z`f zrcl
"dtixh dcya xyae" iable "oeprz ?23 "xey gbi ike" lr i"yx
ze`nbecdy ,dxe`kl ,cinlz lk rcei
,recne ,xzei zevetp weqta ze`aend
`l" xeqi`dy aeygie drhi `ed ,`et` xacn aezkdy hxtae .'ek miyp aex oi` ± xya
.lreta dtykna
,"mezie dpnl`" iabl `wec `ed "oeprz 'iyrn mrpni yperdy t"li q"yae ±
iabl `wec `ed "elk`z `l" xeqi`de i"yxta xe`iad c"r `edy l"p xzei .lreta
jixv i"yxy jk ,"dcya" sxhpd xya zerc 'a `iady (dk .bk ,ai d`x) mcl rbepa
y"iir ."dvw" "mitehy" ze`ivna zeketd
.(jli`e 47 'r c"ig y"ewl d`x)
.`k ,ak (19
zenewn 'ba mbe .*"ded" `ed aezkay `nbecdy d`xe .(r"x ixaca) o`k `zlikn mb d`x (20
"dtykn"n dpyn "mezie dpnl` lk"a ± `teb el` .o`k i"yxtl `"eb
(a) ."itl" siqen (`) :"dtxh dcya xyae"ne .l ,ak (21
± "mzeprl ievn xac"y dfl mrhd mb x`an d"d"y opitli mye .t"dr `zlikn (22
."gk iyeyz" `ian epi` i"yxy dnn la` .ywidn "ziaa
.h ,gi mihtey i"yxtn xirdle (24 cvn `ed ok hytd jxcay gken ,ywidd
aezkiy witqn 'id f"tl ik .wgec ± la` (25 .a"q lirl d`x ± `xaqd
.(my 'dpqak) "zetykn zeievn miypdy" wx el` miweqt lkay mrhd edn :dfn dxzi (23
df yxity s`) "deda aezkd xacy" siqeny dfne :exiagl cg` mewnn i"yx dpyn
`l] `ed o`k yecigdy rnyn ,(gk ,`k lirl xak cg`e 'ek cg`" ± mipey`xd miweqt 'aa (`
mvr [mb `l` ,"ded" `ed miypa seyikdy wx ± "dlil dxwna"e) "mezie dpnl` lk"a ;"'ek
.34 dxrd onwlck ,"deda aezkd xac" ly oiprd ;"'ek oicd `ed" ± ('eb xyae t"dr i"yxtay
."'ek [ziaa] s`" ± "dtxh dcya xyae"a
± "dlil dxwn"n f"r ezi`xa i"nez dpyne)
itl edfy ,dxe`kl l"i ± "dtykn"l rbepa (* .(l"pk ,"oicd `ed"
.mipta onwlck ,seyik ipipra rcei epi` cinlzdy aezkd xac"y wx azek "xey gbi ike"a (a
azek i"yxy dn witqn df liaya ik ,wgec la` ,(a"eike "gbpl xeyd jxc"y siqen epi`e) "deda
."deda aezkd xacy" ji` x`an f"g`ly zenewnd 'ba eli`e
141
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

dfy ± 26 "d`vn dcya ik" (`) :`vz s`"ye "xac lkl oicd `ed"y ycgl
riyen oi`" eay mewn lka oicd ?"ok ziaa
ik "dcya" oiivn weqtd j` ,27 "dl
`l xy`" (a) ;"deeda aezkd xaic"
oicd `ed" ± 28 "dlil dxwn xedh didi zegked ± "dcya" .c
aezkd xaicy `l` ,mei dxwnl ipy yexite
."deeda xy`k :xzei dyw s` ddinzd
jixv i"yxy ,xnel igxkd zehyta lr ,ziriaxd mrta ,i"yx yxtn
miritend miweqtn zegked `iadl ,"dtixh dcya xyae" weqtd
`ian epi`e ,`vz zyxta xzei xge`n iptn z`aen "dcya" `nbecdy
exkfedy ,mincew miweqtn zegked aigxn `ed ,"deeda aezkd xaic"y
miweqtn `l oke ,dnvr epzyxtn ,lirl mpyiy ± "...oke ...oke" xne`e
ik" iptl ,okn xg`l miaezkd miax aezkd xaic" mday mitqep zenewn
xaic" yexitdy iptn ,29 "d`vn dcya gikedl ick ,'d sirqa oldlck ,"deeda
dywe dpey df weqta "deeda aezkd el iz`vn `l" xy` oipr df oi`y
zenewna xy`n idylk daiqn xzei yexit `ian `ed okn xg`le ."xag
jixv okle ,c sirqa lirlck ,mixg` dlnay ,"...mbxz qelwpe`e" :ipy
dcya ik" miweqtd z` hhvl i"yx `le ,dcyl `weec `id dpeekd "dcya"
dxwn xedh didi `l xy`"e "d`vn ."deeda aezkd xaic"y
xzei dyw recn :llk oaen oi`e
"deeda aezkd xaic" llkd z` lawl
"dtixh dcya xyae" weqtd iabl
.fk ,ak (26
cr ,mincewd miweqtd lka xy`n
.my ixtqae o`k `zliknake (27
lk" :a"d `"t dleza dxrp 'ld m"anxa o`k jixv i"yx (` :jk meyn xy`
lke .. dqep` zwfga ef ixd dcya zlrapd miweqtay zexnl .jkl zegked `iadl
'id f"tle ."dzetn zwfga ef ixd xira zlrapd yexitk z`f lawn `ed mincewd
`ed "d`vn dcya ik" y"ny ,yxtl xyt`
m` wx `ed weligd xwir ,zehyta la` .`weca
s` (a ,zegked oerh epi`y ,heyt
dl oi`y mewna e` riyen dl yiy mewna df 'id yexita jxev yi oiicr ,zegkedd xg`l
"xir"e "dcy" mby d`xpe) .my ixtqake ,riyen ?ipy
,aex t"ry itl ,`nbecl wx `ed my m"anxay
xir k"`yn ,miriyen dl oi`y mewn `ed dcy
d`xe .(`nrh xza lifc (`xwc 'ipyil hwpe)
.my `vz z"dr o"anx
`vz zyxtn zegked .d
.`i ,bk (28
weqtd lr i"yx `iany zegkedd
zlgzay "`vni dcya m`e"n `l elit`e (29
onwl d`xe .(dk ,ak `vz) dnvr ef dyxt xaic" eyexitl "dtixh dcya xyae"
.44 dxrd zyxta miweqt ipyn od "deeda aezkd
142
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

± milnd zg` z` oiivl dkixv dxezd xaic" yexitd mda xy` ,"dlil
z` zxgea `ide ± dtykn e` sykn .epweqta df llkl dnec "deeda aezkd
ik ,dawp oeyla ,"dtykn" dlnd
:oaen oi` j`
."zetykn zeievn miypd"
aezkd xaic" yexitdy oeik (`
`l mezie dpnl` lk" iabl mb jke
zyxtay el` miweqt ipya "deeda
"mezie dpnl`" `nbecd ici lr ."oeprz
xyae" weqta df llkl dnec `vz
ik ,weqta mixzein mixeac mitqep oi`
i"yx jixv recn ± "dtixh dcya
jynda edylk `yep oiivl igxkd
epi`e ,elld miweqtd ipy z` hhvl
."oeprz `l"l
?mdn cg`a wtzqn
dcya xyae" weqta z`f znerl
aezkd xaic" llkl yi m` (a
aezkd xaic" llkd `lel ixd ,"dtixh
dcya xyae" z` yxtnd "deeda
xyae" wx zxne` dxezd dzid ,"deeda
,mitqep zenewn ipya "xag" "dtixh
xnel dywe ,"elk`z `l dtixh
ly yexitl mb i"yx wwfp recn
iptn wx zxzein dln dtiqen dxezdy
?"mbxz qelwpe`e"
dcydy ,"deeda aezkd xaic" llkd
okl ."sxhil zenda jxcy mewn" `ed
zegkedd lr zel`yd .e
xaic" llkd iptny dgkedl i"yx wewf
ze`aend
dln dtiqen s` dxezd "deeda aezkd
.zxzein zi`xpy z` xiaqdl did ozip ,dxe`kl
weqta "deeda aezkd xaic" ly iyewd
ik"n zegked i"yx oiivn okle
eze` iabl ,"dtixh dcya xyae"
xedh didi `l xy`"e "d`vn dcya
:mincewd miweqtd zyelya yexit
zeriten my s` xy` ,"dlil dxwn
"dlil dxwn"e "dcya" ly ze`nbecd ici lr ixd ,"xey gbi ike" weqta
oldl d`xe) weqta miln ztqed ici lr oi` ± xey ± dvetpd `nbecd zxkfd
.(b"ie a"i mitirqa ixd :zxzein dln mey ztqeezn
"gbi ike" xnel dleki dpi` dxezd
,dl`yd xzei dyw df xaqd itl j`
`id ,jk m`e ,30 gbepd oeiv ila ,cala
zxxerznd ,'` sirqa lirl dxkfedy
dvetp elv` ik ,"xey"d z` dxikfn
"...haya ...dki ike" miweqtd lr
.dgibpd xzei
dlnd s` ."... miyp` oeaixi ike"e
i`ceae ,31 dxe`kl ,zxzein "haya" :"digz `l dtykn" weqta mb jk
.zexzein "miyp` oeaixi ike" milnd

,gbepd lr `ed "lwqi lewq" oicdy hxtae (30


.6 dxrd lirl d`x (31 .'f sirq onwl d`xe
143
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

hxt zpiivn dxezd xy`k j` i"yx lawn myy ,`et` ,okzii cvike
dpeek yiy ,xnel yi ,oica miieqn xack "deeda aezkd xaic" llkd z`
.df hxta `weec eli`e .ex`al jxev llk oi`y heyt
`ed "dtixh dcya xyae" weqta
oeaixi ike" weqtd lr :jkitle
,elawl dywy yexitl z`f aiygn
yibcdl jixv i"yx oi` "...miyp`
xg`l s` xy`e ,zegkeda gxkd yiye
mb lg "...wx ...dwpe ...dkde" oicdy
?ipy yexita jxev yi zegkedd
ike" hxtd ik ,"oeaixi ike" `ll
,oaene ,xetiqdn wlgk `aen "oeaixi oeaixi ike" milndy ,xn`p m` s`
wx `aen `edy ,i"yx yexit `ll mb daiqn zeriten "haya"e "miyp`
ote`a rxe`nd z` yigndl ick aezkd xaic" llkd iptn `le ,zxg`
.ievnd miweqtd x`y lka s`e ,"deeda
,"haya ...dki ike" weqta mb oke iptn zetqep miln mda yiy d`xpy
lg oicd eze`y oiivl jixv epi` i"yx ± ozrtedl zxg` daiq `vnp df llk
`l` ,haya dpi` d`kdd xy`k mb xzqa ...jziqi ik" weqta ixd
`ed "haya" hxtd ik ,xg` edyna ± xzqa" :envr i"yx xne` ,32 "xn`l
.cala rex`d xe`izn wlg `lely ,oaene ."...deeda aezkd xaic
dzid `l "deeda aezkd xaic" llkd
xy`k ,"xey gbi ike" weqta j` jixv ,jk m`e .zxg` dln my driten
`l` ,xeyd lra iabl wx eppi` oicd dcya xyae" iabl ,`iadl i"yx did
lewq" ± envr xeyd iabl xwirae mb 'eb jziqi ik" weqtdn dgked ,"dtixh
hxtdy ,`vei ixd ± "...xeyd lwqi dcya ik" weqtd iptl ritend "xzqa
,'xetiq' ly oepbqa `edy s` lr ,"xey" ?"d`vn
did eli`k ,envr oica mb hxt `ed ixd
`ed gbepy xey ly epicy weqta xn`p ± `nbecd hexit .f
zraew dxezdy aeygl ozipe ± dliwq oica e` xetiqa
iabl `le ,gbep xey iabl `wec df oic
xidadl i"yx jixv okle ,xg` miig lra :`ed lirl xen`d lkl xaqdd
,sere dige dnda lk cg`e xey cg`" miieqn oic zpiivn dxezd xy`k
."deeda aezkd xaicy `l` m`y ,"`adl mixac xetiq" ly ote`a
yi f` ,jke jk oicd didi ,jk dxwi
± "digz `l dtykn" .g dxezd zpiivny mihxtdy ,gipdl
cala oic zriaw z` yigndl ick mi`aen df xetiqa
weqta recn oaei lirl xen`d it lr ."deeda" ,xzeia uetpd ote`a rex`d
z` aey i"yx xne` "digz `l dtykn"
epi`e ,"deeda aezkd xaic" llkd .f ,bi d`x (32
144
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

dxdf`d ;mlekl ± oicd .h :33 "xey gbi ike" weqta


dpnl`" iabl cgeina ±
llkd z` `ian i"yx did eli`
"mezie
gbi ike" lr wx "deeda aezkd xaic"
dpnl` lk" weqtay jkl daiqd meyn z`fy ,aeygl did ozip ,"xey
yibcdl i"yx jixv "oeprz `l mezie ,zegtl ,mixacd mi`aen df weqtay
xaicy `l` ,mc` lkl oicd `ed" aey hxtdy zexnl ,xetiq ly oepbqa
:35 `id ,"deeda aezkd .envr oicdn mb wlg `ed "xey"
"digz `l dtykn" weqta ,z`f znerl
xaic" llkd mi`zn ,hytd jxca
wx `l` ,rex` ly xetiq llk oi`
dxezd xy`k wx "deeda aezkd
,"digz `l dtykn"y ,oic zriaw
yi xy`k j` ,zg` `nbec zpiivn
`weec `ed df oicy aeygl did ozipe
xnel xyt` i` ,ze`nbec izy weqta
,dtykn iabl
dzid f` ik ,"deeda" xacn weqtdy
dievnd ,cala zg` `nbec driten cg`e mixkf cg`" i"yx xne` okl
ze`nbec izyy 36 c`n xicp ik ,xzei ,34 deeda aezkd xacy `l` ,zeawp
."zetykn zeievn miypdy

zeievn miypdy" yibcne siqen okle ,(zncewd


.rxe`nda `le oecpda oipr edfy epiid ,"zetykn
:(mipta onwl y"nl sqep) xnel yi mb (35
exn`l jiiy "deda aezkd xac" llkd (`) mewn lka miaezkd jxc :l"i mb (33
`le) rxe`nda `ed "ded"d xy`k ,dxe`kl aezkl [ea mieey dawpe xkfy oipra mixacnyk]
.(oaenk ,xzeia weica l"vy oicde ieeivda xac" zngny ,xnel `xaq 'id okle .xkf oeyla
`ed "ded"dy ,"('igz `l) dtykn" :enke miaezkd jxcn dpyn weqtd 'id `l "deda aezkd
zetykn zeievn miypdy ± "dtykn"c oiprda ,"xey gbi ike"n c"ecp cenll oi` okle ,n"ka
aezky dn oaen f`y ,("'igz `l" ieeivda `le) ekxcn dpyn aezkd oi` "xey" oeylda ixdy
ieeivdy s` ± "dtykn" (seyikd dyerl rbepa) .n"ka
s`c ,c"ecpa k"`yn .syknl rbepa mb `ed xac"y azek i"yxy dn mb oaen f"tre (34
ixd ,mzeprl `ed ievn xac mezie dpnl`y zeievn miypdy"a wtzqn epi`e] "deda aezkd
"ded"d "oeprz `l mezie dpnl`" aezkda azky s` ± [25 dxrd lirl d`x ± "zetykn
rbepa `ed ieeivde ,ieeivd oipra `ed (oeprz) mby ycgn o`k ik ± (gk ,`k) lirl xak df
xnel `xaq oi`y c"qw okle .mc` lkc iepirl .deda aezkd xac `c oebka
`l ± ezpeek "oeprz `l mezie dpnl`" ieeivdy siqedl i"yx wwfedy dn mb oaei f"tre
.mc` lkl oeprz dxrd lirl d`x) "zetykn zeievn miypdy"
,mc` lkl `id aezkd zxdf` zpeek m`a (a) "zetykn zeievn miypdy" y"n mbe ± (23
"mezie dpnl` lk" zaizl dxe`kl yexit oi` ik ± "miypa ievn seyikdy" `le (q"ya f"cre)
oeikn ,(mezi xrcri oe` dpnl` xrcri) oicdn wlg `id o`k "dtykn" zaizy oeikn
.mc` lkl `id dpeekdy zetykn zeievn eid `l miypd m`a ,l"pk
mvnvl xyt`d `zbeltdn xirdl (36 ievn seyikd rxe`ny 'id "dtykn"c "ded"de
zn` zxez ixd ± c"ecpa la` .(` ,fi zexeka) (± dawp oeyla) xn`p 'id `l ,xzei miypa
(wgeca t"kr) l"iy `l` .mvnvl dleki i`cea dxrda x`eand t"r hxtae) "dtykn"
145
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

xaic"y iptn ,"mezie dpnl` lk" .dcn dze`a weica zevetp eidi
gek iyeyz mdy itl ,deeda aezkd dxezdy ,xnel yi dfk dxwnae
jxev yi jkitl ,"mzeprl ievn xace ,37 cala el` mihxtl `weec zpeekzn
.epri `l mze`y cgeina xidfdl ."deeda aezkd xaic" llkd iptn `le
lk" weqtl miribn xy`k ,okle
± "xeng e` xey" .i
oa" l`ey "oeprz `l mezie dpnl`
ick ,zevetp ze`nbec
zexkfen weqtay jkn :"`xwnl yng
hrnl
opi` ze`nbecdy ,oaen ,ze`nbec izy
wewf recn oaei lirl xen`d lk itl `l` ,"deeda aezkd xaic" llkd iptn
"xeng e` xey dny ltpe" weqta i"yx ,el` mixwnl `weec `id dpeekd
dnda lkl oicd `ed"y cgein cenill miyp` zeprl xzen m`d :denze
"xeng e` xey"y yxtl jixve ,"dige dxezd zxne` jk meyny ,mixg`
oeik :milke mc` hrnl ick mixkfen ?"oeprz `l mezie dpnl` lk" `weec
± ze`nbec izy zexkfen df weqtay
`ed" ,xg` geqipa ,i"yx xne` jk lr
cenild `ll ixd ± "xeng"e "xey"
,`ed oicdy ,i`ce .38 "mc` lkl oicd
,aeygl did ozip ,"zayn xey xey"
dxezd j` ,mc` mey zeprl xeq` ok`y
`ed "...mlyi xead lra" oicdy
,"mezie dpnl`" iabl cgeina dxidfn
itl wxe ,xenge xey ly dxwna `weec
:mnvr mdiable ,mze` 39 wx dxikfne
oicd `ed"y mircei ,cgeind "cenil"d
,el` ze`nbec izye ."dige dnda lkl
ipy hrnl ze`a ,weqta ze`aend
`le xeng ,mc` `le xey" :mixac ote`a l"t``y miaezka okle onfl onfn dpzyny
."milk .'ek iepiyd iptn ze`nbec 'a hwpc l"vkr ± xg`
epi` i"yxy dn zehyta mb oaen f"tre (37
df weqta mby ,xnel yi df itl `ed oire oy xn`py dfy (ek weqt lirl) yxtn
.(my r"a`xak) deda aezkd xacy itl
."deeda aezkd xaic" ly oiprd miiw
"'ek oy m`e" aezkd oepbqn :dfl sqepe
xyt` ,mixac ipy hrnl ick wx ,ik weqta ± dlecb zekix`ae ,ycg oic zlgzd)
"dig e` dnda dny dltpe" xnel did "deda aezkd xac" zngn f"i`y gken ,(r"ta
cenll did ozip f` mbe ,dnecke ze`nbec 'aa mby mixne` epiid m`a elit`)
.(df llk jiiy
.40 "milk `le dig ,mc` `le dnda"y rbepa `ed "oeprz `l"c oicd wxy epiide (38
.mezie dpnl`a wx xacn aezkd la` ,mc` lkl
.. zepnl` .. eide" miiqny dnn mb gkencke
mrhd [mb `l` ,(l ,ak onwl .fi ,ak lirlck) dcn cbpk dcn oirk `ed zehytay ,"minezi
.miptak ,"'ek aezkd xac" lr .(ipewfgd y"nke)
miyxtnd ziiyew zvxezn f"tre (40 dxrd lirl d`x) "itl" i"yx siqen okle (39
xyt` ji` :(o`k `"ebe m"`x ,z"dra epizeax) `ed "'ek gk iyeyz mdy"a ezpeek ik ± (23
dpi` "xey" zaiz ixde ,"xey"n mc` hrnl "ded" `id aezka `nbecdy ji` wx `l] x`al
146
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

mb lg df llk .`i ,"xeng e` xey" `weec xn`p ,mpn`e


oica `id `nbecdyk lirlck ,xzei dvetp xeal mzlitp ik
envr .41 'a sirqa
,"deeda aezkd xaic" llkd ,mpn`
,mincewd miweqta i"yx yxity itk
z`aen `nbecd xy`k wx lg epi`
xy`k mb `l` ,"xetiq" ly jxca ik ± zayn xey xey slinl jixhv` ik zxzein
,envr oicdn wlg `id `nbecd weicdn `l] `ed "milk `le .. mc` `le" cenild
'a aezka yiy dfn [`"k ,"xeng"e "xey"
,"digz `l dtykn" weqta ,lynl epiid "'ig e` dnda" xn`p 'id m` mbe ,ze`nbec
.miptak ,milke mc` mihrnn
,envr oicdn wlg `id "dtykn" dlnd oicd `ed" gikedl i"yx wwfedy dne (41
oeyla `nbecd zxkfen z`f zexnl j` ,"zayn xey xey" cenildn "'ek dnda lkl
,"zetykn zeievn miypd" ik ,dawp 'al jxevdy s` ± "deda aezkd xac" yxit `le
:l"i ± dfl mrh yi ze`nbec
`id `nbecd xy`ky ,xnel yi j` xead lra" oicdy xnel `xaq yiy itl (`
.'a sirq l"pk ,xenge xeya `wec `ed "mlyi
iabl zeniieqn zelabd yi ,oicdn wlg
oia wlgl `xaq oi`y xn`p m`a elit` (a
:"deeda aezkd xaic" llkd 'itdl mrhd ixd ± 'ige dnda lkl xenge xey
oia wlgl `xaq oi`yk) "deda aezkd xac"
rxe`n xetiqa zwqer dxezd xy`k icka ,`ed (ze`nbec x`yl aezkay `nbecd
rxe`nd z` zx`zn `id ,ygxziy .(15 dxrd lirlck) k"dfb `edy xn`p `ly
yi xy`k s` ,xzeia ievnd ote`a "'ige dnda lkl d"d" 'itdl mby ,c"ecpa la`
mc`l 'ige dnda oia weligd ± k"dfb o`k yi
oebk ,miln jk myl siqedl jxev did `l ,mdipia wlgl `xaq 'id m`a ik] milke
yi` dkde miyp` oeaixi ike" weqta ,[oa d"c ` ,ap w"a i"yx d`xe .herinl jixv
z` mb zx`zn dxezdy ,"...edrx z` (zayn xey xey cenild ilel) l"t` 'id k"`e
oeaixi ike" ± zeygxzdd ly ote`d .k"dfba ,`weca md aezkay xenge xeyy
'a opyiyk ,zenewnd aexay oeikn (b
mix`ezn mixacdy oeik ± "miyp` ,"deda aezkd xac" zngn `l) md ,ze`nbec
siqedl jxev yiy zexnl ,xetiqk xey cenild ilel) giken envr f"d ± `weca (wx
.miln jk myl xenge xeyc ze`nbecd mby (zayn xey
ze`nbec 'a yiy n"kak ,`weca md aezkay
z` wx zpiivn dxezd xy`k j` `l ,'ige dnda lka 'id aezkay oicd m`a ik]
`l` ± "sxhi ik xyae" `l) oicd yi f"iry oeikn ± "xeng e` xey" xn`p 'id
dxrd seq y"n c"re) dpeekda zerhl mewn
dcya") `nbecde ,("dtixh xyae" xey xey" cenildl i"yx wwfed okle ,[(l"pd
,envr oicd zriawn wlg `id ("dtixh ."zayn
ly mihxtd s`y ,xnel xazqn mewn lkay" wiicn i"yxy dn wznei f"tre
,x`al icka ± n"wtp i`nl ,dxe`klc ± "'ek
mb xy`k s`) oicdn wlg md `nbecd
oda oi` aezkay "xeng e` xey" zeaizdy
`nbece ,jk `ed oicd mixg` mixwna xn`py mewn lkay oeikn ,zerhl mewn zpizp
.("deeda aezkd xaic" iptn z`aen ef .zayn oicnl ep` xeng e` xey
147
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

giken "d`vn dcya ik" weqtd on x`zl icky ,ipeibd df oi` ,okle
ievnd ote`d z` x`zl icky ,i"yx miln dxezd siqez ,dievn `nbec
.oica mb miln siqedl dxezd dleki mvrl zexeyw opi` xy` zexzein
dxwn xedh didi `l xy`" weqtd one wx ritei weqtay ,xnel yi oke .oicd
xaic" llkdy ,i"yx giken "dlil ote`d `l j` ,xaecn eilry oiprd
mb lg ,oic iabl s` "deeda aezkd aeyg xacd oi` m` ,ygxzn `ed eay
,oicd lg eay ,oiprd ote` iabl xacd oi` xy`k s`) envr oicd jxevl
.oldlck .(miln ztqeda jexk
weqta yxtl did jixv dfÎitÎlre
zegkedd lka jxev yi .bi
ztqepd dlndy ,"dtixh dcya xyae"
ipy 'itae
("dtxh xyae" milind enk) "dcya"
eppi` "d`vn dcya ik" weqtd xeqi`dy ,xnelk ,oicd mvrl daeyg
daiq ± "ik" `l` ,"mixac xetiq" .dcya sxhpy xya iabl `weec `ed
`l dxrple" oicdn wlg edfe ,oicl ,42 ok ziaa s`"y ,i"yx ycgn jkitle
ribn `ly jkl daiqd ."xac dyrz jxcy mewn ,deeda aezkd xaicy `l`
iptn ,"d`vn dcya ik" `id yper dl aezkd xaic" llkdy ,"sxhil zenda
oi`"y mewna ,"dcya" d`vnpy siqedl jxev yi xy`k mb lg "deeda
."dl riyen dlnd xy`k s`e ,dln jk myl
`l` ,oiprd mvra hxt dpi` ztqepd
miiw oic eze` :dl`yd zxxerzne
."sxhil zenda jxcy mewn" iabl wx
oi`" m` "d`vn xira" xy`k mb
zpiivn ,`et` ,recn ."dl riyen
ipy ± zegked izy .ai
?"d`vn dcya ik" mrhk dxezd
mipipr
oi`" "dcya"y ievn xzei ,mpn`
jixv recn mb oaei lirl xen`d itl
ik" xnel witqn j` ,"dl riyen
gikedl ick miweqt ipy `iadl i"yx
recn ."dl riyen oi`e ...dwrv
xaic" llkd lg eply dxwna mby
jkn ?"d`vn dcya" dxezd dtiqen
on cg` lk ik ± "deeda aezkd
"deeda aezkd xaic" jxevly ,oaen
:43 xg` haid giken miweqtd
.44 oica s` miln dxezd dtiqen

dn (23 dxrd lirl d`x) oaen f"tre (42


253 'r d"g [mbxeznd] y"ewl d`xe .xg` oiprl ± xzei yecig ly oepbqa ,"ok ziaa s`" azeky
.20 dxrd ,`k lirl y"n c"r) "dcya cg`e ziaa cg`" `le
mb wizrn i"yxy dn (`) wznei f"tre (44 .(fi ,ak .gk
ybcen ef daiz i"ry itl ± "ik" zaiz azek ipyd weqt iaby dn oaen f"tre (43
dn (a) .xetiq ly oipr epi` "d`vn dcya"y `id df weqtn dgkedd ik ± "oke" t"der i"yx
148
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

,"dxwn ...didi ik" xn`p ,"rnyz `l dgkeda wtzqdl leki epi` i"yx j`
okle ,xacd okzii cvik ,oaen oi`e daiqdy oeik ,ixdy .cala ef
itk ,"dlil" dlnd z` dxezd dtiqen mewnd `id "xac dyrz `l dxrple"l
,"mei dxwnl oicd `ed" i"yx wiicny `nbecdy `vei ,"dl riyen oi`" xy`
,dlil lr wx xaecn envr weqta j` eay uetpd dxwnd `idy ,"dcya"
.mezie dpnl` iabl lirl xen`k oiprl xywa dppi` "dl riyen oi`"
.envr oicl xywa `l` ,iccv
dlnl dgked ef oi` jk meyn
zxzein `idy ,epweqtay "dcya" dcya ik" milndy zexnl ,jkitle
dxexa dicrla mbe ,oihelgl df oi` ,dxe`kl ,zexzein "d`vn
,"dtixh xyae" ly zernynd ,epweqtay "dcya" dlnl ynn "xag"
`ed dndad dtxhp eay mewnd eay
ik" weqtd z` mb i"yx `ian jkitl
oicl xeyw epi`y ,oihelgl iley oipr
xac xqgi `l ea s`y ,"d`vn dcya
."elk`z `l dtixh xyae"
riyen oi`e ...dwrv ik" xn`p eli`
wx ze`a "d`vn dcya" milnde ,"dl didi `l xy` oke" i"yx siqen okl
."deeda aezkd xaic" jxevl `nbecd eay ,"dlil dxwn xedh
ly oicd iable ,iccv oipr `id "dlil"
jixv recn oaei lirl xen`d itl
eay onfl zeaiyg llk oi` "dxwn"
xg`l s` ,ipy yexit `iadl i"yx
.xacd rx`
ik ± `vz zyxtn miweqtd ipy hehiv
ze`xn opi` oiicr el` zegked izy .wtzqn i"yx oi` df weqta mb j`
dln dtiqen dxezdy ,xexa ote`a ik ,45 zxzein dpi` "dlil" dlnd ,ixdy
iccv oipr iabl oicd mvra zxzein "rx xac lkn zxnype" xn`p ok iptl
.oihelgl m` dide" dncwd `ll ,okn xg`l cine

'd xacn `ed rahd mb .ci


zlgzay "`vni dcya m`e"n giken epi`y
"dxez ly dpii" ly mipiprdn ± (bk weqtay "xira yi` d`vne"n oke) dyxtd
:df i"yx yexitay .xetiq ly oipr `ed my ik
dwrv `l xy` xac lr"n giken epi`y dne
lw ,otec `vei rxe`n ygxznyk oicdl mrh `ed my mby s` ± (ck ,my) "xira
`a df rxe`ny lawl mc`l xzei driazdc dxaqdd `id "xira" ik ± "mzlwqe"
`ed "xir"y zeidlc] "dwrv `l xy` xac lr"
zelibx zeieygxzda j` ,dlrnln
dl ied ,miriyen dl yiy mewn (aex t"r)
± ebdpnk mler" rxd xvid dztn ixdy ,xzein "d`vn dcya" k"`yn .[wervl
.46 "bdep ± envr ely rahae bdpna ."dl riyen oi`e ('eb dwrv)" xn`p
ztqed ila) "dxwn" (mb) `xwp dfy (45
wlan mb xirdle .ek ,k `"y ± ("dlil" zaiz
.a ,cp f"r (46 .my i"yxte c ,bk
149
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

xg`l `weec ± yecigd .eh 47 mdxa` ly dlecbd ezdinz lre


dxez ozn ± "!?bidpn `la dfd mlerdy xn`z"
"ezrca hheyl" eilry ,oreh `ed
zehyta dlbne yxtn i"yx df oipr
jkl xy`e ,'eke 48 dlilae meia aeygle
ozn iptl ik ,mihtyn zyxta wx
`ly el` iable ,zn`d dzlbzd xaky
mb) "dxifb"d dzid xy`k ,dxez
mdilr xab" xak dligzkln jka eced
"mipeilr" oia (jezig oeyln 49 "liqke owf"d ixd - ,48 "eizei`xa
ze`xl did ozip `l ,55 "mipezgz"l
liqk ala 50 zehy gex qipkn
- "aezkd xaic"y ynn ielba
lk llk el oi` `linne ± 51 el`nyl
,"deed" ly mipipra ± "mipeilr"
.zxcrp zn`de ,dl`ye ddinz
xzei yi mday ,ixnbl "mipezgz"
ila ebdpnk mler"y zerhl mewn xaic" llkd z` i"yx `ian jk lr
,dxez ozn xg`l wx ."bdep bidpn xacd ,"deed"d s`y ,"deeda aezkd
,dhnl `a (dxezd) "aezk"d xy`k ,e"g rahd cvn epi` ,xzeia uetpd
f` ± "mipezgze mipeilr xeaig" xvepe iptn ,52 "aezkd xaic" iptn `l`
,mipezgza ,"deed"a mb ze`xl xyt` miign xy` ,aezkay zexn`n dxyr
."aezkd xaic"y ielba lk z` (deedn oeyln "deed") mieedne
llkd z` oiivn i"yx oi` z`f lka .53 rbxe rbx lka mi`xapd ihxt
,exzi zyxta "deeda aezkd xaic"
zyxt xg`ly mihtyn zyxta `l` oal elit` df llk yibcn i"yxe
ly ixwird yecigd ik ,dxez ozn el` oia `ed s` ik ,`xwnl yngd
ycgzdy "mipezgze mipeilr xeaig" xga" 54 m"anxd oeyla xn`p mdilry
ozn xg`l s`y ,`ed dxez ozna `apzp" xy`k ,"dlgpl l`xyi 'd
,57 "laeid jeyna" xg`l ,56 dxez ± dxez ozna ,xnelk ± "epiax dyn
."ezcear jxc mricede"

.h `x`e `negpz .b ,a"it x"eny (55


epi` ± `teb z"n zryac xeaigd k"`yn (56
"mipezgz"d f` eid `ly oeikn ,k"k yecig
zil" ixdy ,df xg`lc e` df iptlc ze`ivna
`aed ± f"ewz) "oednr 'ipin liln `lc xz` .jl jl t"x x"a (47
z"dra epizeax mb d`xe .y"iir .e"lt `ipza .b"d `"t f"r 'ld m"anx (48
x"eny) "'eke geev `l xetv" ;(`"d ikp` t"dr .my x"dwe .bi ,c zldw (49
.cere .(h"ktq .` ,b dheq d`x (50
,jli`e 9 'r c"g [mbxeznd] y"ewl mb d`xe .a ,i zldw (51
,z"n ixg`ly oey`xd r"lrnc zeaiagd mrha .` ,et mixac z"ewl d`x (52
.dceard oipr lgzed f` ik .ezlgza `"deidry d`x (53
oniq `ed :my i"yxtae .bi ,hi exzi (57 .`"tq my m"anx (54
150
zegiy ` mihtyn ihewl

`le ,envr oiprd lr wx `id dpeilrd xagl mzcear zervn`a l`xyi elkei
jk lr .xacd ygxzi eay ote`d lr zelbl ± mipezgzl mipeilr oia
dcya xyae" weqta i"yx xne` ."aezkd xaic" z` "deed"a
,"deeda aezkd xaic" llkdy ,"dtixh
xaic" llkd z` i"yx xne` okl
s` `l` ,envr oiprd iabl wx epi`
ik ,mihtyn zyxta "deeda aezkd
("dlil"e "dcy") onfde mewnd iabl
dpey`xd dyxtd idefy jkl sqepa
.zerxe`nd eygxzi mday
ly 58 dpkez ixd ,dxez ozn xg`l
mihxtd x`y lk iabl mb oaen jkn ,"mihtyn"d iabl mby ,`ed ef dyxt
Îlrad xn`nk ,rxe`nd ly zeaiqpde mdy zelbl yi ,zeilky zeevn mdy
mewnn xarnd wx `ly ,60 aehÎmy .59 "ipiqn"
dgbyda `ed ,yw ly elit` ,mewnl
`ed eay ote`d s` `l` ,zihxt lkd lr zihxt dgbyd .fh
lr e` dndae mc` ilbxa m` ,ygxzi
dgbyddy aeygl xyt` oiicr
hxt lk ,lkd ± dnecke dxrq gex ici
.zihxt dgbyda `ed ,jka ohw
,mihtyn t"y zegiyn) q"eq t"kdei 'ld f"dc` r"ey .dpiky weliq
(g"kyz t"wie ,`yz .b"kxz
zeaiagdl rbepa mb `ed f"cry ,xirdl (58
sqepc ,(56 dxrd lirl d`x) y"dbgc 'ad meic
oiprd mb ,z"n ixg`ly oey`xd mei `edy dfl
x`eank ,dceard oiprl dxen envr df mei ly
.my y"ewla
elqk hi zgiy) a ,bt `"g c"ewl d`x (60 y"ewl d`xe .mihtyn t"x i"yxt (59
.('b ze` c"vxz .h"q 130 'r g"g y"ewl .152 'r b"g [mbxeznd]

You might also like