Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ASHLEY BROWN
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the
University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing
worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and
certain other countries.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval
system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in
writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, by license, or under
terms agreed with the appropriate reproduction rights organization. Inquiries concerning
reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department,
Oxford University Press, at the address above.
You must not circulate this work in any other form and you must impose this same
condition on any acquirer.
DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780197551752.001.0001
For Ruby
Contents
Acknowledgments
Introduction
1. Coming Up the Hard Way
2. A Queer Cosmopolitan
3. The Making of a Strong Black (Woman) Contender in the South
4. From Florida A&M to Forest Hills
5. Dis/Integration
6. Resurfacing
7. Press(ing) Matters
8. Changeover
9. Finding Fault with a Winner
10. Game Over
11. New Frontiers
12. A Winner Who Hasn’t Won Yet
13. The Harvest
14. Two Deaths
Notes
Bibliography
Index
Acknowledgments
THE CLICHÉ IStrue: it isn’t how you start that’s important, it’s how you
finish. Serving Herself: The Life and Times of Althea Gibson began
as my doctoral dissertation and represents more than a decade of
research and writing. In that time, many people and institutions
contributed to the completion of this book. I offer my heartfelt
thanks to them here.
I could not have asked for a better editor for my first book than
Susan Ferber. Susan saw the strengths and possibilities of this
biography at the right time and consistently gave me the time,
space, support, and trust that I needed. She is everything—scout,
coach, analyst, cheerleader, teammate, talent manager, problem
solver, and visionary. She is also a very fine person. Susan has been
a dream to work with, and publishing with Oxford University Press
has been a dream come true. Assembling the final product would
not have happened without the careful diligence of copy editor Sue
Warga, indexer Colleen Dunham, proofreader Bob Land, and
production editor Amy Whitmer.
The University of Wisconsin–Madison has been my ideal
professional home since 2017. The History Department is an all-star
team. Whether an assistant, associate, or full professor, every
member of the faculty has contributed to my growth here. My
Madison story begins with the dedicated members of the search
committee that brought me to campus in February 2017: Sue
Lederer, Tony Michels, Karl Shoemaker, and co-chairs Susan Lee
Johnson and David McDonald, both of whom became my mentors.
Susan (now of the University of Nevada–Las Vegas) opens doors and
creatively paves paths. David is an astute reader and a terrific
conversationalist, especially about the world and history of golf. In
subsequent years, other colleagues stepped forward to further
support my work. Brenda Gayle Plummer is a trailblazer whose
encouragement has meant a great deal to me. Lee Palmer Wandel is
a keen listener whose clear-sightedness has positively impacted my
approach to pedagogy. Leonora Neville stands out as an advocate
and a creative leader. As I entered the final stages of this project,
Mary Louise Roberts became my mentor and friend. Lou’s attention
to detail, wit, wisdom, and commitment to excellence have
enhanced my work.
Allan H. (Bud) Selig plays an important role in my work. In 2010,
Commissioner Selig, a UW-Madison alumnus, made a major gift to
the History Department to create the Allan H. Selig Chair in the
History of Sport and Society, the position that I have held since
January 2020. The chair, a rarity at an American university, enables
me to do what I love: encourage my students to think about the
people, places, productions, institutions, and reach of American
sports in new and expansive ways. My students teach me, and they
apply their knowledge and skills to innovate their chosen fields. I
draw much energy and inspiration from their examples. Teaching the
course Biography in U.S. Sport History in the fall of 2021 was
especially helpful as I completed the final chapters of the
manuscript. The Selig Faculty Fellowship in Sport History, awarded
during the 2017–2018 academic year, gave me the time and
resources required to write, among other things, “ ‘Uncomplimentary
Things’: Tennis Player Althea Gibson, Sexism, Homophobia, and Anti-
Queerness in the Black Media,” which the Journal of African
American History published in 2021. The research support of the
Selig Chair has been invaluable to bringing Serving Herself to fruition
and thus familiarizing historians, students, and others with Althea
Gibson’s preeminent place in the history of sports. Commissioner
Selig’s generosity and leadership are signal reminders of the need
for and vast impact of philanthropy in higher education.
Institutional support has been essential to Serving Herself. George
Washington University backed my studies and research through its
Presidential Merit Fellowship, the Jeffrey C. Kasch/GWU Horton-Vlach
Fund for American Studies Research Fellowship, and multiple
American Studies Academic Excellence Awards for Summer
Research. The North American Society for Sport History’s 2015
Graduate Student Essay Prize, which led to the publication of my
first article, “Swinging for the State Department: American Women
Tennis Players in Diplomatic Goodwill Tours, 1941–1959,” in the
Journal of Sport History, helped establish my reputation as a scholar.
Giving the graduate student keynote address at the 2015 NASSH
conference in Miami was an experience that I will savor for the rest
of my career. The opportunity gave me a view of what the future
might bring. The Alumnae Association of Mount Holyoke College’s
1905 Fellowship funded an important research trip to Tallahassee,
Florida, in 2017. An associateship at the Five College Women’s
Studies Research Center, led by Banu Subramanium, was a pivotal
launchpad for my transition from graduate school to the
professoriate. That same year, Lucas Wilson, Preston Smith, Lynda J.
Morgan, and the Africana Studies Department at Mount Holyoke
gave me a bridge that added to my appreciation for my alma mater.
In 2017–2018, a postdoctoral fellowship at Emory University’s James
Weldon Johnson Institute for the Study of Race and Difference, led
by Andra Gillespie, became an essential landmark on my professional
journey. The University of Wisconsin–Madison has buttressed my
endeavors through the Selig Chair, support from the Office of the
Vice Chancellor for Research and Graduate Education, and, in 2020–
2021, an invaluable Nellie McKay Research Fellowship. Accessing
resources at UW-Madison would not have been possible without the
diligent efforts and knowledge of Todd Anderson, Sophie Olson, and
Jana Valeo. Leslie Abadie, Scott Burkhardt, Mike Burmeister, Lisa
Normand, John Persike, and Jenny Schumacher make everything
better. The support of the organizations and people named here
supplied much-needed time to work, access to the many sources
required to write this book, and additional authorial motivation.
Along these lines, I extend my thanks to the many colleagues who
have shared encouraging words, insights, and, in some cases,
invitations to share my work with their campus communities.
Leaders in this respect are the late Craig Lanier Allen, Amy Bass,
Madeleine Blais, Andy Bruno, Aram Goudsouzian, Pamela Grundy,
Eric Allen Hall, Felipe Hinojosa, Tera W. Hunter, Jane Kamensky, Rita
Liberti, Mary G. McDonald, Michele Mitchell, Elizabeth Odders-White,
Martin Polley, Randy Roberts, Jaime Schultz, Johnny Smith, Susan
Ware, Brandon Winford, Darius Young, and Oxford University Press’s
anonymous reviewers. The author of groundbreaking works, Susan
K. Cahn is a major reason this book exists. I have been influenced
by Susan’s scholarship, encouraged and enriched by her interest in
my research, and strengthened by her reminder that we must care
for ourselves as people rather than exclusively as producers of
scholarship.
My first intellectual homes were in Massachusetts and Washington,
D.C. When I was an undergraduate at Mount Holyoke College, David
Sanford, Preston Smith, Paul Staiti, and Elizabeth Young sparked my
dream of becoming a professor. At George Washington University,
Kip Kosek, Erin Chapman, Suleiman Osman, Melani McAlister,
Jennifer Nash, and Tom Guglielmo helped make that dream come
true. During a chance meeting at GW’s Gelman Library in 2014, the
late Jim Miller said the right thing at the right time.
Sources are the lifeblood of scholarship. I appreciate the efforts of
the staff at each of the institutions whose archives I accessed. I give
special praise to Meredith Miller Richards, Nicole Markham, Ymelda
Rivera Laxton, Troy Gowen, and Doug Stark of the International
Tennis Hall of Fame and Museum; Rebecca Baugnon and Gerald
Parnell at the University of North Carolina–Wilmington; Gloria Woody
at Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University’s Coleman Library;
E. Murrell Dawson of the Meek-Eaton Black Archives Research Center
and Museum; Beatrice Hunt and the archives of the West Side
Tennis Club; Toni Wiley and Sportsmen’s Tennis and Enrichment
Center; and the employees of the Library of Congress and the
National Archives and Records Administration in College Park,
Maryland. This project would have suffered immeasurably without
the consistent support of Carolyn Eaton, the youngest daughter of
Dr. Hubert A. and Celeste Eaton. Not only did Carolyn grant me
permission to access her father’s papers in 2013, but she also
offered terrific and timely advice that Althea Gibson would have
liked: “Just do you.” Like her parents, Carolyn is a champion of
integrity and African American history. The Eaton family has my
respect and my gratitude. Michelle Curry, executor of the Gibson
estate, is an important figure in sharing Gibson’s legacy. Don Felder,
Gibson’s second cousin, came through in a big way by sharing
original sources to which I had sought access for years. Don and
Michelle’s joint efforts in many forums are teaching people across
the country and around the world about Gibson.
In any life and career, time, interests, geography, and fate intervene
in such a way that we get to know some colleagues better than
others. The COVID-19 pandemic brought welcome opportunities to
forge new bonds and strengthen old ones. I could fill a book with
memories of Jennifer Ratner-Rosenhagen’s many gestures of
goodwill before and during the pandemic. Jennifer is a friend, muse,
guide, and sounding board with a generous spirit. My experience of
this unprecedented time in history would have been very different
without the kindnesses of Jennifer and her family, especially Ulrich,
Miriam, and Mabel. Nan Enstad has been equally munificent. Time
with Nan allowed me to laugh and relax. Nan and her partner, Finn,
embody living and working with honesty. Emily Callaci, my running
buddy in the pre-Prefontaine sense of the word, is a model of
benevolence and persistence. Sharing in the childhoods of Emily’s
sons, Theo and Otis, has delighted me beyond words. .
The past dozen years brought opportunities to reflect on the
meaning of friendship. Friends are there for you with positivity and
generosity when things go well, not just when things go wrong.
Friends enhance the afterglow of your victories, great and small, and
the things that give you joy. Lila Webb’s frankness, wit, confidence,
and laughter have enriched my life for more than twenty years. Her
children, Rowan and Juna, have grown up alongside this book.
Catherine Connor’s optimism is contagious. Cathy and my
grandfather have convinced me that cheerfulness is essential to
becoming a nonagenarian. Sally Sheaffer Lehman’s company and her
belief in me have never wavered. Discussions with Doc Pye led me
to make the leap to graduate school. Doc was the first to believe in
this project. My journey would have been much more difficult
without her. Whenever I shared good news about some
breakthrough or honor, Doc always said, “I am happy for you, and I
am not surprised.” Mickey Goldmill has been a consistent source of
fun, clarity, challenge, patience, and strength. Wherever I have
been, Mickey has been there, too. Wherever I go, she will be there,
too.
My family is ever-present in my life. I thank my grandfather Willie
James for telling me when I was four years old that I should go to
college. My brother, Dudley, influenced my early interest in sports.
My aunt and uncle, Michelle and Craig, showed me that tennis and
golf are magical games. I thank my parents, Richard and Iva, for
accepting my wish to pursue my dreams wherever they lead me.
More than anyone else, Mom and Dad remind me of the importance
of being ambitious and true to myself, maintaining discipline and
focus, persevering, having faith, and deriving pleasure from work.
Ruby, my dear niece and daughter of Dudley and Rochelle, my
very kind sister-in-law, is the pride and joy of our family. I sincerely
hope Ruby and her generation will read works of history and learn—
by thinking deeply about the successes, shortcomings, failures, and
unrealized ambitions of our predecessors—how to make lives of
happiness, purpose, productivity, and fulfillment. May they also find
the ingredients for making a compassionate country and a peaceful
world.
Serving Herself
Introduction
ALTHEA GIBSON SHOULD have been on top of the world in the summer of
1957. Instead, she found herself at odds with it yet again. In July,
Gibson won the women’s singles title at Wimbledon, six years after
becoming its first Black American competitor. Queen Elizabeth II
presented her with the victor’s plate, marking the first time a Black
person, male or female, had claimed the top prize in tennis. Gibson
was the belle of the Wimbledon Ball that night, dancing the
traditional first dance with Lew Hoad, the men’s singles champion
from Australia. Blond and White, Hoad guided her around the dance
floor. Some attendees watched in admiration; others stared with
displeasure.1
Days later, Gibson was back in her hometown, New York, riding up
Broadway in an open convertible and waving at the thousands of
people who lined the streets during the ticker-tape parade held in
her honor. The mayor gave her the key to the city, and a series of
speakers lavished her with praise during a banquet at the Waldorf-
Astoria Hotel. Gibson was a “wonderful ambassador and saleswoman
for America,” said one, a reference to the dozens of tournaments she
had won around the world. She “came up the hard way and now
stands at the top of her class,” remarked another.2
The mood changed in Chicago, where Gibson went to compete in
the U.S. Clay Court Championship the following week. Because she
was Black, none of the hotels in River Forest, the leafy suburb that
hosted the tournament, would give her a room, forcing her to find
lodging miles away. Intent on maintaining her form through the end
of the season, she prioritized practice and rest over media
obligations before the tournament began. Reports emerged that
Gibson gave “brush-offs” to the mostly male press corps, refusing
requests for interviews and photographs. Some journalists got close
enough to ask Gibson questions. With the civil rights movement
under way, they wanted to talk about race. Did she think that her
accomplishments in tennis “helped” other African Americans? Did
she “cherish” being compared with Jackie Robinson, who ten years
earlier had become the first Black man to play in baseball’s major
leagues in the twentieth century?3 “No, I don’t consider myself to be
a representative of my people. I am thinking of me and nobody
else,” she reportedly answered.4 “I’m trying to help myself.”5 Gibson
won the tournament decisively, but her image was tarnished as
writers called her “arrogant,” “non-cooperative,” and “as ungracious
as a stubborn jackass.”6
Apologies and appeals for understanding were not Gibson’s style;
doubling down and going on the offensive were. Speaking outside
Pittsburgh in early August, she gave her version of what had
happened in Chicago: “They said I was hostile and wouldn’t
cooperate. I say I wasn’t given a fair opportunity to be helpful.” She
had no plans to be helpful going forward. “Frankly, I’m tired of being
pushed around by people who don’t seem to have any concern for
my feelings,” she told the press pool, living up to the derisive labels
—“Jackie Robinson without charm” and “Ted Williams without his
skills”—that some sportswriters had given her.7 “I’m ready to start
speaking out and saying what I think is right. I might lose some
friends, but there are those who will understand my viewpoint. . . .
[F]rom now on I’m going to do what I think is right and not worry
about what some people who don’t mean anything to me say. Then
when I get mad, I’m going out on the tennis court and [will] take it
out on whoever’s across the net.”8
Gibson soon made good on her promises. The subject of Time’s
cover story for the last week of August, she spoke candidly about
her fraught relationship with the notion that she carried a special
duty to be a racial representative or spokesperson as the only
African American in elite amateur tennis. “I tried to feel
responsibilities to Negroes, but that was a burden on my shoulders,”
she admitted. “If I did this or that, would they like it? Perhaps it
contributed to my troubles in tennis. Now I’m playing tennis to
please me, not them.”9
Two weeks later in September, Gibson won the United States
National Lawn Tennis Championship at Forest Hills (now the U.S.
Open), where she had been the first Black player allowed to enter in
1950. Vice President Richard Nixon presented her with the trophy.
When asked which victory that summer was more meaningful, she
replied, “Winning Wimbledon was wonderful, and it meant a lot to
me. But there is nothing quite like winning the championship of your
own country. That’s what counts the most with anybody.”10
The victory meant that Gibson had achieved another historic racial
first. She would accomplish still more. She successfully defended
both her Wimbledon and U.S. Nationals titles in 1958, giving her,
with her capture of the French Championship in 1956, a career total
of five Grand Slam singles titles, joining her six others in doubles and
mixed doubles. In 1963, she was the first African American to
compete on the Ladies Professional Golf Association (LPGA) Tour. In
1971, she was the first African American inducted into the
International Tennis Hall of Fame. Between 1975 and 1977, she was
the athletic commissioner for the state of New Jersey, the first
woman and the first African American to hold that position. Every
opportunity, every setback, every accolade, and every criticism that
Gibson received was linked to her identity as an African American
woman who dared to defy social norms and expectations of what
tennis players, golfers, race leaders and pioneers, and even Black
women said and did and how they looked. She persevered in the
face of it all as her audacity and achievements challenged the
progressiveness of the communities and institutions that she entered
and occupied.
ABYSSINIA